CORONADO HISTORIC RESOURCE COMMISSION AGENDA REGULAR MEETING 3 P.M.

Transcription

1 CORONADO HSTORC RESOURCE COMMSSON AGENDA REGULAR MEETNG 3 P.M. WEDNESDAY, DECEMBER 6, 217

2 THS PAGE NTENTONALLY LEFT BLANK

3 HSTORC RESOURCE COMMSSON AGENDA REGULAR MEETNG WEDNESDAY, DECEMBER 6, 217, 3 PM CORONADO CTY HALL COUNCL CHAMBERS 1825 STRAND WAY, CORONADO, CALFORNA PRELMNARES Roll Call Pg 1 Approval of the Minute of the Regular Meeting of November 1, 217 DRECTORS REPORT ORAL COMMUNCATONS AND OTHER MATTERS Each peron wihing to peak before the Hitoric Reource Commiion on any matter hall approach the Commiion, give name, and limit addre to three (3) minute. State law generally preclude the Hitoric Reource Commiion from dicuing or acting upon any topic initially preented during oral communication. Your information may be received, placed on the next agenda, or referred to the appropriate City taff. PUBLC HEARNGS Pg 9 NO GLORETTA BOULEVARD: Requet for a Notice of ntent to Demolih (Determination of Hitoric Significance) Review for the property addreed a 1132 Glorietta Boulevard and located in the R-1A(CC-1) (Single Family Reidential) Zone (continued from the meeting of November 1, 217) Pg 93 HR MARNA AVENUE: Nomination for Hitoric Deignation (Determination of Hitoric Significance) for the property addreed a 548 Marina Avenue and located in the R-1A (Single Family Reidential) Zone. Pg 169 HAP F AVENUE: Conideration of a Requet for a Hitoric Alteration Permit for a remodel and addition, including zoning exception requet related to etback, for the property located at 1127 F Avenue in the R-1A (Single Family Reidential) Zone. Pg 239 HP CTY OF CORONADO: Hitoric Reource Commiion review of Hitoric Preervation Mill Act application ubmitted in 217 for prioritization and placement on the Hitoric Preervation Mill Act Waiting Lit: 1144 abella Avenue; 116 Fourth Street Unit 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7; 55 A Avenue, 455 A Avenue, 46 E Avenue, and 111 Loma Avenue. ADJOURNMENT AS A COURTESY TO OTHERS, PLEASE SLENCE CELL PHONES

4 APPLCANTS OR THER AGENT(S) ARE REQUESTED TO ATTEND THE HSTORC RESOURCE COMMSSON MEETNG TO ANSWER QUESTONS THAT MAY BE POSED BY THE COMMSSON. TRADTONALLY, THE COMMSSON HAS NOT ACTED ON APPLCATONS WHEN THE APPLCANT OR AN AGENT S NOT PRESENT. F YOU HAVE ANY QUESTONS, PLEASE CALL (619) n compliance with the American with Diabilitie Act (ADA), if you need pecial aitance to participate in a City meeting or other ervice offered by thi City, pleae contact the City Clerk office, (619) Aited litening device are available at thi meeting. Ak the City Clerk if you deire to ue thi device. Upon requet, the agenda and document in the agenda packet can be made available in appropriate alternative format to peron with a diability. Notification of at leat 48 hour prior to the meeting or time when ervice are needed will ait the City taff in auring that reaonable arrangement can be made to provide acceibility to the meeting or ervice. Material related to an item on thi Agenda ubmitted to the Commiion after ditribution of the agenda packet are available for public inpection in the Department of Community Development at 1825 Strand Way during normal buine hour. AS A COURTESY TO OTHERS, PLEASE SLENCE CELL PHONES

5 HSTORC RESOURCE COMMSSON MEETNG MNUTES Regular Meeting November 1, 217 The regular meeting of the Coronado Hitoric Reource Commiion wa called to order at 3 p.m., Wedneday, November 1, 217, at the Coronado City Hall Council Chamber, 1825 Strand Way, Coronado, California, by Acting Chairperon Talbert. MEMBERS PRESENT: MEMBERS ABSENT: STAFF PRESENT: CTY ATTORNEY: Goot, Keith, Pator, Talbert Gillingham Tricia Olen, Aociate Planner Laura Ramo, Recording Secretary, Minute Preparer Lauren Hendrickon APPROVAL OF MNUTES The minute of the regular meeting of October 18, 217, were approved a ubmitted. DRECTOR S REPORT M. Olen reported that the HRC meeting of November 15, 217, and January 3, 218, will be cancelled. The HRC will meet on December 6 and, depending on member availability, may meet on December 2. PUBLC ORAL COMMUNCATONS There were no member of the public wihing to peak at thi time. PUBLC HEARNG HAP C AVENUE Conideration of a Requet for Hitoric Alteration Permit for an addition to an acceory building, including a zoning exception requet related to floor area ratio, for the property located at 731 C Avenue in the R-1B ( (Single Family Reidential) Zone. Acting Chairperon Talbert aked member to dicloe ex parte communication. Commiioner Goot recued herelf from participating in dicuion and left the Council Chamber a he own property within 5 ft. of the ubject project. All member dicloed they had driven or walked by the ite. 1

6 Hitoric Reource Minute November 1, 217 Page 2 M. Olen introduced the taff report a outlined in the agenda and anwered quetion of the Commiion. The applicant, Chri and Barbara Harmer, provided a brief overview of the project and anwered quetion of the Commiion. The applicant repreentative, Donna Croman, anwered quetion of the Commiion. PUBLC COMMENT There were no member of the public wihing to peak at thi time. COMMSSON DSCUSSON Commiioner Pator and Keith indicated they had no objection to the requet. COMMSSON ACTON COMMSSONER KETH MADE A MOTON TO RECOMMEND TO CTY COUNCL APPROVAL OF A REQUEST FOR A HSTORC ALTERATON PERMT FOR AN ADDTON TO AN ACCESSORY BULDNG, NCLUDNG A ZONNG EXCEPTON REQUEST RELATED TO FLOOR AREA RATO, FOR THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 731 C AVENUE N THE R-1B (SNGLE FAMLY RESDENTAL) ZONE, AS SUBMTTED. THE FOLLOWNG FNDNGS WERE MADE: A. THE PROPOSED ALTERATON S CONSSTENT WTH THE PURPOSE AND NTENT OF THS CHAPTER, THE HSTORC PRESERVATON ELEMENT AND THE GENERAL PLAN AS THE PROJECT S CONSSTENT WTH OBJECTVE D OF THE HSTORC PRESERVATON ELEMENT OF THE GENERAL PLAN, AS THE PROJECT S CONSSTENT WTH THE SECRETARY OF THE NTEROR S STANDARDS FOR REHABLTATON. B. THE PROPOSED ALTERATON WLL NOT ADVERSELY AFFECT THE HSTORCAL, ARCHTECTURAL OR AESTHETC VALUE OF THE HSTORC RESOURCE AS THE PROJECT AS PROPOSED S CONSSTENT WTH THE SECRETARY OF THE NTEROR S STANDARDS FOR REHABLTATON. C. THE PROPOSED ALTERATON WLL RETAN THE ESSENTAL ELEMENTS THAT MAKE THE HSTORC RESOURCE SGNFCANT AS THE PROJECT DOES NOT NCLUDE ANY EXTEROR MODFCATON OF THE HSTORC DWELLNG, AND THE ADDTON TO THE ACCESSORY BULDNG DOES NOT ADVERSELY MPACT THE HSTORC DWELLNG. D. THE PROPOSED ALTERATON WLL NOT ADVERSELY AFFECT THE HSTORC RESOURCE S RELATONSHP TO TS SURROUNDNGS AND NEGHBORNG HSTORC RESOURCES AS THE PROJECT DOES NOT MPACT SURROUNDNG BULDNGS OR HSTORC RESOURCES, AND THE 2

7 Hitoric Reource Minute November 1, 217 Page 3 RELATONSHP OF THE BULDNG TO TS SURROUNDNGS WLL REMAN UNCHANGED. E. THE PROPOSED ALTERATON COMPLES WTH THE SECRETARY OF NTEROR S STANDARDS AS SET FORTH N SECTON 16 OF THE NATONAL HSTORC PRESERVATON ACT OF 1966 AS THE PROJECT MEETS THE STANDARDS AND GUDELNES FOR NEW ADDTONS, AS THE SMALL ADDTON TO THE NON-HSTORC ACCESSORY BULDNG, S SUBORDNATE TO THE ORGNAL DWELLNG, AND S DFFERENTATED YET COMPATBLE THROUGH THE USE OF STUCCO EXTEROR FNSH. THE FOLLOWNG CONDTONS WERE ADDED: 1. CHANGES TO THE APPROVED PLANS MAY REQURE THE REVEW AND APPROVAL OF THE HSTORC RESOURCE COMMSSON. 2. ANY MECHANCAL EQUPMENT NSTALLED N ASSOCATON WTH THE PROJECT WLL BE SCREENED FROM VEW FROM THE PUBLC RGHT OF WAY. 3. THS HSTORC ALTERATON PERMT SHALL EXPRE THREE YEARS FROM THE DATE OF APPROVAL BY THE HSTORC RESOURCE COMMSSON. COMMSSONER PASTOR SECONDED THE MOTON. AYES: NAYS: ABSENT: ABSTAN: DSQUALFED: Keith, Pator, Talbert. None. Gillingham. None. Goot. The motion paed with a vote of 3-. Commiioner Goot returned to the dai at 3:18 p.m. All member were preent except Chairperon Gillingham. HAP AVENUE Conideration of a Requet for a Hitoric Alteration Permit for a new carriage houe at 266 Avenue in the R-1A(E) (Single Family Reidential) Zone. Acting Chairperon Talbert aked member to dicloe any ex parte communication prior to conidering the item. All member dicloed they had walked or driven by the property. M. Olen introduced the taff report a outlined in the agenda. The applicant repreentative, Kevin Rugee, project architect, provided an overview of the requet. 3

8 Hitoric Reource Minute November 1, 217 Page 4 PUBLC COMMENT There were no member of the public wihing to peak at thi time. COMMSSON DSCUSSON Commiioner Keith aked taff if thi project wa conidered a new acceory dwelling unit (ADU). M. Olen reponded that the applicant i propoing a carriage houe, which ha it own requirement under the CMC. She confirmed that thi project i not an ADU. COMMSSON ACTON COMMSSONER GOOT MADE A MOTON TO APPROVE A REQUEST FOR A HSTORC ALTERATON PERMT FOR A NEW CARRAGE HOUSE AT 266 AVENUE N THE R- 1A(E) (SNGLE FAMLY RESDENTAL) ZONE, AS SUBMTTED. THE FOLLOWNG FNDNGS WERE MADE: A. THE PROPOSED ALTERATON S CONSSTENT WTH THE PURPOSE AND NTENT OF THS CHAPTER, THE HSTORC PRESERVATON ELEMENT AND THE GENERAL PLAN AS THE PROJECT S CONSSTENT WTH OBJECTVE D OF THE HSTORC PRESERVATON ELEMENT OF THE GENERAL PLAN, AS THE PROJECT S CONSSTENT WTH THE SECRETARY OF THE NTEROR S STANDARDS FOR REHABLTATON. B. THE PROPOSED ALTERATON WLL NOT ADVERSELY AFFECT THE HSTORCAL, ARCHTECTURAL OR AESTHETC VALUE OF THE HSTORC RESOURCE AS THE PROJECT AS PROPOSED S CONSSTENT WTH THE SECRETARY OF THE NTEROR S STANDARDS FOR REHABLTATON. C. THE PROPOSED ALTERATON WLL RETAN THE ESSENTAL ELEMENTS THAT MAKE THE HSTORC RESOURCE SGNFCANT AS THE PROJECT DOES NOT NCLUDE ANY EXTEROR MODFCATON OF THE HSTORC DWELLNG, AND THE CARRAGE HOUSE DOES NOT ADVERSELY MPACT THE HSTORC DWELLNG. D. THE PROPOSED ALTERATON WLL NOT ADVERSELY AFFECT THE HSTORC RESOURCE S RELATONSHP TO TS SURROUNDNGS AND NEGHBORNG HSTORC RESOURCES AS THE PROJECT DOES NOT MPACT SURROUNDNG BULDNGS OR HSTORC RESOURCES, AND THE RELATONSHP OF THE BULDNG TO TS SURROUNDNGS WLL REMAN UNCHANGED. E. THE PROPOSED ALTERATON COMPLES WTH THE SECRETARY OF NTEROR S STANDARDS AS SET FORTH N SECTON 16 OF THE NATONAL HSTORC PRESERVATON ACT OF 1966 AS THE PROJECT MEETS THE STANDARDS AND GUDELNES FOR NEW ADDTONS, AS THE 4

9 Hitoric Reource Minute November 1, 217 Page 5 CARRAGE HOUSE S LOCATED AT THE REAR OF THE PROPERTY, DOES NOT ADVERSELY MPACT THE HSTORC DWELLNG, AND S DFFERENTATED YET COMPATBLE THROUGH THE USE OF SNGLE LGHT DUAL GLAZE WNDOWS N THE AREA OF THE NEW CARRAGE HOUSE. THE FOLLOWNG CONDTONS WERE ADDED: 1. WNDOWS AT THE CARRAGE HOUSE SHALL HAVE NO DVDED LGHTS, N ORDER TO LEND TO DFFERENTATON OF THE NEW CARRAGE HOUSE FROM THE HSTORC DWELLNG. 2. CHANGES TO THE APPROVED PLANS MAY REQURE THE REVEW AND APPROVAL OF THE HSTORC RESOURCE COMMSSON 3. ANY MECHANCAL EQUPMENT NSTALLED N ASSOCATON WTH THE PROJECT WLL BE SCREENED FROM VEW FROM THE PUBLC RGHT OF WAY. 4. THS HSTORC ALTERATON PERMT SHALL EXPRE THREE YEARS FROM THE DATE OF APPROVAL BY THE HSTORC RESOURCE COMMSSON. COMMSSONER PASTOR SECONDED THE MOTON. AYES: NAYS: ABSENT: ABSTAN: Goot, Keith, Pator, Talbert. None. Gillingham. None. The motion paed with a vote of 4-. NO GLORETTA BOULEVARD Requet for a Notice of ntent to Demolih (Determination of Hitoric Significance) Review for the property addreed a 1132 Glorietta Boulevard and located in the R-1A(CC-1) (Single Family Reidential) Zone. Acting Chairperon Talbert aked that member dicloe any ex parte communication prior to conidering the item. All member dicloed they had walked or driven by the property. M. Olen introduced the taff report a outlined in the agenda and anwered quetion of the Commiion. The applicant repreentative, Chritian Rice, provided a brief overview of the requet and anwered quetion of the Commiion. PUBLC COMMENT There were no member of the public wihing to peak at thi time. 5

10 Hitoric Reource Minute November 1, 217 DSCUSSON Page 6 Commiioner Goot aid he did not ee anything that would allow the property to be conidered hitoric. Commiioner Pator agreed there wa nothing about the property that had hitoric ignificance. COMMSSON ACTON COMMSSONER KETH MADE A MOTON TO APPROVE A REQUEST FOR A NOTCE OF NTENT TO DEMOLSH (DETERMNATON OF HSTORC SGNFCANCE) REVEW FOR THE PROPERTY ADDRESSED AS 1132 GLORETTA BOULEVARD AND LOCATED N THE R-1A(CC-1) (SNGLE FAMLY RESDENTAL) ZONE, WTH THE FOLLOWNG CHANGE TO THE RESOLUTON: THE NO MEETS CRTERA B N THAT DONALD DLL AND WALTER GREATSNGER FARROW ARE DENTFED AS SGNFCANT N LOCAL AND NATONAL HSTORY. M. Olen aked Commiioner Keith to point to the documentation in the application that upport the propoed change to the Reolution. Commiioner Keith aid the information i found online. Commiioner Goot aid that, unfortunately, the information i not included in the application. Commiioner Keith aid he doe not conider the application to be complete. M. Olen tated that every taff report ak Commiioner to requet any additional information he or he feel i needed to make a determination. She uggeted the Commiion may requet the applicant to provide additional information o the Reolution i defenible and upportable by the evidence in the record. COMMSSONER KETH WTHDREW HER MOTON. Deputy City Attorney Hendrickon explained that the documentation, a ubmitted, of the publicly-noticed hearing include information the applicant provided in the application. n order to change the Reolution to include additional information, it mut be included with the original application to be conidered a part of the public document, and thu, part of the record. She noted information cannot be included if it ha not been provided to the public. M. Hendrickon uggeted the Commiion may move forward with the public hearing, or continue the public hearing and ak that the applicant return with more information. Commiioner Keith aked if oral reporting can be conidered. M. Olen aid oral reporting can be conidered if documentation i provided in upport of the oral report. The documentation i then made available to the Commiion and the public and become part of the public record. To change the Reolution, reearch hould be done and evidence hould be ubmitted in upport of the change. 6

11 Hitoric Reource Minute November 1, 217 Page 7 COMMSSONER KETH MADE A MOTON THAT THE TEM BE CONTNUED TO THE HRC MEETNG OF DECEMBER 6, 217, TO PROVDE THE APPLCANT SUFFCENT TME TO RESEARCH AND MAKE AVALABLE ADDTONAL NFORMATON UNDER CRTERA B, AS REQUESTED BY THE COMMSSON. COMMSSONER GOOT SECONDED THE MOTON. AYES: NAYS: ABSENT: ABSTAN: Goot, Keith, Pator, Talbert. None. Gillingham. None. The motion paed with a vote of 4-. ADJOURNMENT There being no further buine, the meeting wa adjourned at 3:4 p.m. Tricia Olen, Aociate Planner 7

12 THS PAGE NTENTONALLY LEFT BLANK 8

13 CORONADO HSTORC RESOURCE COMMSSON Regular Meeting AGENDA TEM Public Hearing December 6, 217 N GLORETTA BOULEVARD: REQUEST FOR A NOTCE OF NTENT TO DEMOLSH (DETERMNATON OF HSTOMC SGNFCANCE) REVEW FOR THE PROPERTY ADDRESSED AS 1132 GLORETTA BOULEVARD AND LOCATED N THE R-lA(CC-l) (SNGLE FAMLY RESDENTAL) ZONE fcontnued FROM THE MEETNG OF NOVEMBER 1, 217) RECOMMENDATON: Determine that the property doe not meet the criteria to be deignated a a Hitoric Reource in accordance with Chapter 84.1 and 84.2 of the Municipal Code, by adopting the attached reolution (Attachment 1). PUBLC NOTCE: A public notice wa publihed in the Coronado Eagle & Journal and mailed to all property owner within 3 feet of the boundarie of the property. BACKGROUND: n accordance with Chapter 84.2 of the Municipal Code, a "Notice of ntent to Demolih" Pennit application i required to be filed with the City for the propoed demolition of a tructure that i 75 year of age or older. The applicant' requet for thi review doe not necearily mean that the ubject tructure will be demolihed; rather the applicant ha requeted thi determination of hitoric ignificance in order to gain certainty regarding option for future preervation, modification, or demolition of the dwelling. A determination that the property meet two or more of the deignation criteria will reult in hitoric deignation of the dwelling, and regulation of the property a a Hitoric Reource. A determination that the property doe not meet two or more of the deignation criteria will reult in the property being determined to be non-hitoric, no further regulation under the hitoric reource code will be required, and the property owner may preerve, demolih, alter, or otherwie develop the property conitent with applicable zoning and building code. The applicant ubmitted a Notice of ntent to Demolih (N1) review application for the property on October 5, 217, which i included a Attachment 2. On November 1, 217, the Hitoric Reource Commiion opened the public hearing on thi item, heard the taff report, aked quetion of the applicant, and engaged in dicuion. Commiioner Keith requeted additional infomiation from the applicant regarding two occupant of the property, General W. G. Farrell, and Donald M. Dili, and the Commiion voted to continue the item until today' hearing in order to allow the applicant to conduct additional reearch, which i included a Attachment 4. ANALYSS: The ubject property i located at 1132 Glorietta Boulevard and conit of a twotory dwelling contructed in 193. The building contruction hitory for the property i included in Attachment 2. 9

14 The Hitoric Reource nventory completed in the 198' by Source Point did not provide an evaluation of thi property. The Coronado Property Review (CPR) Lit completed in 28 did not identify the property a potentially hitorically ignificant. t hould be noted that the Source Point rating and Coronado Property Review tatu are provided for informational purpoe only. The Source Point urvey wa not officially adopted for ue a a urvey document and i known to have ome factual error; however, it doe indicate what the hitoric condition of the dwelling wa conidered to be in The Coronado Property Review urvey wa, alo, not adopted by City Council and i ued a an informational reource only. n accordance with Chapter 84.2 of the Municipal Code, in order for the tructure to be deignated a Hitoric Reource by the Hitoric Reource Commiion it mut meet two or more of Coronado' adopted deignation criteria. Following i a brief analyi of the property under each criterion. CRTERON A - t exemplifie or reflect pecial element of the City' military, cultural, ocial, economic, political, aethetic, engineering, or architectural hitory. The applicant ha indicated that reearch did not reveal any information that indicate that the property i hitorically ignificant under Criterion A. Baed upon the information that wa preented with the application, taff did not find any evidence that indicated that the property i hitorically ignificant under Criterion A. n order to deignate the ubject property under Criterion A, the Commiion would need to determine that the property poee aethetic, engineering or architectural propertie urpaing other of it kind; or ignificant military, cultural, economic, or political aociation uch that it exemplifie or reflect pecial element of the City' hitory, and evidence would be needed to upport that determination. CRTERON B - t i identified with a peron() or an event() ignificant in local, State, or national hitory. The application include infonnation on all known property owner and applicant, a well a relevant newpaper article that were found. Reearch indicate that property owner include Earl Brix, a retired aviator; Captain Mile Browning, who wa awarded a Navy Silver Star medal for ervice work during WW; Captain Walter Coleman, who wa Commander of the Pacific Fleet' Amphibiou Squadron Five; Donald Dill, a doctor and Chief of Staff at Coronado Hopital; and Gerald Schwartz, a WW Navy Veteran. Reearch ubmitted with the application ugget that Captain Mile Browning owned the ubject property during the time he completed the ervice for which he wa awarded the Navy Silver Star, a the Browning owned the property from 194 through 1944, and he wa awarded the Silver Star in The article note that Captain Browning participated in variou 1

15 operation in the Central Pacific during WW, including the Battle of Midway which occurred in June of The record of owner and occupant ubmitted in the application indicate that the Browning owned the ubject property from , but that it wa occupied by Albert and Billie Heckey between 1938 and Reearch by taff into the reidency of Captain Mile Browning and hi wife Charlie indicate that during their ownerhip of the ubject property they reided at the neighboring property, 1138 Glorietta Boulevard (attachment 3), and therefore it would not be appropriate to aociate the ubject property with Captain Mile Browning during the time of hi ervice for which he wa awarded the Silver Star. Supplemental reearch ubmitted per the requet of the Hitoric Reource Commiion i included a Attachment 4. The applicant indicate that, baed upon thi reearch, the property i hitorically ignificant under Criterion B for it aociation with General W. G. Farrell, and Donald M. Dill. The applicant note that during hi ownerhip General Farrell wa deputy commander of the 11( Naval Ditrict air bae (1945), wa awarded a Bronze Star medal (1945), and commanded all of the Marine Corp air bae on the wet coat at the time of hi retirement (1946). Regarding Donald M. Dill, the applicant note that during hi occupancy of the ubject property, Donald M. Dili erved a Chairman for the annual Chritma Seal Campaign (1964), erved a econd Vice Preident of the Coronado Chamber of Commerce (1967), wa awarded the Boy Scout Silver Beaver award (1971), and wa appointed Vice Preident of Coronado Hopital (1978) and Medical Chief of Staff (1979). f the Commiion determine that thee contribution to hitory during the occupancie of General W. G. Farrell and Donald M. Dill are hitorically ignificant, then the property can be conidered hitorically ignificant under Criterion B. n order to be hitorically ignificant under Criterion B, the Commiion would need to determine that the property i aociated with a peron or event who made hitorically ignificant contribution to local, tate, or national hitory, and evidence would be needed to upport that determination. Generally, the property that would be deignated for it aociation with an important individual would be the exiting property that i mot cloely identified and aociated with the peron' productive life, whether that i their home, office, laboratory, etc. CRTERON C - t poee ditinctive characteritic of an architectural tyle, and i valuable for the tudy of a type, period, or method of contruction and ha not been ubtantially altered. The applicant indicate that the property i not hitorically ignificant under Criterion C becaue the dwelling ha been ubtantially modified. Staff agree a follow: While it i likely that the dwelling wa originally contructed in a Spanih tyle, a the builder, Chri Cogrove, wa known for Spanih tyle deign in Coronado, the current appearance of the dwelling due to a major remodel in 1983 ha completely modified what would originally have been preent. When taff i conidering whether modification to a tructure are ubtantial for the purpoe of evaluation under Criterion C, the nature, extent, and viibility of the modification are examined within the context of the Secretary of the nterior' Standard. Modification aociated with 11

16 maintenance and repair, uch a re-roofing in kind, or replacement in kind of deteriorated architectural detail are not conidered ubtantial. Likewie, addition to the rear of a tructure that are not viible from the public right of way, and addition or modification that are conitent with the Secretary of the nterior' Standard, are not conidered ubtantial. However; change to the front of a tmcture, addition that overwhelm the original tructure, or cumulative modification that reult in change to more than half of the original hitoric tructure are generally conidered ubtantial and the property will not be conidered hitorically ignificant under Criterion C. The contruction hitory of the property outline modification that have taken place over time. From the time ofcontmction until 1967, only minor repair, electrical, and plumbing work are noted. However, in 1967, a permit wa iued for a new front entrance, patio lab, and front walkway, which would have ignificantly changed the hitoric appearance of the dwelling. n 1976, a family room wa added, and mot ignificantly, in 1983 a permit wa iued for a complete remodel of the home which further modified the hitoric appearance of the dwelling. Elevation and floor plan for that remodel i included in Attachment 3. Due to ubtantial modification to the dwelling, the property i not hitorically ignificant under Criterion C. n order to deignate the property under Criterion C, the Commiion would need to determine that the ubject dwelling poee ditinctive characteritic of an architectural tyle, i valuable for the tudy of a type, period, or method of contruction, and ha not been ubtantially altered, and evidence would be needed to upport that determination. CRTERON D - t i an example of the notable work of a builder, deigner, architect, artian or landcape profeional. The applicant indicate that the property i not hitorically ignificant under Criterion D a an example of the notable work of the builder, Chri Cogrove, a it ha been ubtantially modified. Staff agree that becaue of the ubtantial modification in 1967 and 1983, the dwelling no longer retain architectural or material hitoric integrity, and no longer reflect the deign or workmanhip of the builder, Chri Cogrove and i not hitorically ignificant under Criterion D. n order to be ignificant under Criterion D, the Commiion would need to determine that the property i a notable work of a builder, deigner, architect, artian, or landcape profeional, and evidence would be needed to upport that determination. CRTERON E - t ha been lited or formally determined eligible for the California Regiter a et forth in Section of the California Public Reource Code (a amended from time to time). The ubject property i not lited or determined eligible for the California Regiter, and therefore doe not appear to be hitorically ignificant under Criterion E. CONCLUSON: Staff recommend that the property not be hitorically deignated, a it doe not meet two or more of the hitoric deignation criteria, a outlined in the criteria analyi 12

17 above. f additional information regarding hitoric ignificance under any of the deignation criteria i required in order for the Commiion to make a determination, additional information and analyi hould be requeted from the applicant. f the Commiion determine through the public hearing proce that the property meet, or doe not meet, the criteria to be deignated a a Hitoric Reource, the Commiion hould adopt or modify the attached reolution making the appropriate finding, upported by fact, for aid detemiination, and addre each of the adopted deignation criteria. The deciion of the Commiion hall become final 1 day after the adoption of the reolution unle a notice of appeal to the City Council i filed with the City Clerk. A deignated Hitoric Reource i entitled to all the benefit and retriction of hitoric deignation a outlined in Chapter 84.1 and in Chapter 84.2 of the Municipal Code and mut comply with the requirement of the California Environmental Quality Act. f the property i deignated a a Hitoric Reource, thi action i final unle appealed within 1 day of the Commiion' action and overturned by the City Council. Any modification to the Hitoric Reource would require conitency with the Secretary of the nterior' Standard, and approval by the Hitoric Reource Commiion. The applicant mut file a Hitoric Alteration Permit and undertake environmental review under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) in order to proceed with the demolition of the property. Benefit of deignation, including but not limited to zoning exception, parking exception, and Special Ue Permit, are ubject to approval at noticed public hearing and are not a guarantee of deignation. Pleae ee the attached reolution, with the taff recommendation incorporated, for conideration. f the Commiion wihe to make a determination other than the taff recommendation, the attached reolution hould be modified accordingly. The application, photograph and micellaneou dociunent ubmitted with the application are attached for additional information. Attachment: 1. Reolution with taff recommendation 2. Notice of ntent to Demolih application 3. Staff Reearch 13

18 Attachment 1 RESOLUTON NO. HR A RESOLUTON OF THE HSTORC RESOURCE COMMSSON OF THE CTY OF CORONADO DETERMNNG THAT THE PROPERTY ADDRESSED AS 1132 GLORETTA BOULEVARD LOCATED N THE R-lA(CC-l) (SNGLE FAMLY RESDENTAL) ZONE DOES NOT MEET THE CRTERA TO BE DESGNATED AS A CORONADO HSTORC RESOURCE WHEREAS on October 5, 217, the property owner ubmitted a Notice of ntent to Demolih (Determination of Hitoric Significance) application in aociation with potential future demolition or partial demolition of a building on the property that i 75 or more year old, in accordance with Chapter 84.2 of the Coronado Municipal Code; and WHEREAS, on November, 217 the Hitoric Reource Commiion of the City of Coronado held a public hearing on N at which time the Commiion continued the public hearing to December 6, 217, and requeted additional reearch and analyi from the applicant; and WHEREAS, on December 6, 217 the Hitoric Reource Commiion of the City of Coronado held a public hearing on N at which time all peron deiring to be heard were heard, and WHEREAS, evidence wa ubmitted and conidered to include without limitation: 1. Notice of ntent to Demolih Permit Application N ; 2. Oral tetimony; 3. Hitoric Reource Commiion taff report dated December 6, 217; 4. Additional written information and photograph provided by the applicant; NOW, THEREFORE, BE T RESOLVED that the Hitoric Reource Commiion of the City of Coronado find the property addreed a 1132 Glorietta Boulevard hall not be deignated a a Hitoric Reource becaue it meet only one of the following criteria: a) No evidence wa preented in the application that indicate the property exemplifie or reflect pecial element of the City' military, cultural, ocial, economic, political, aethetic, engineering, or architectural hitory; b) The property i hitorically ignificant for it aociation with General W. G. Farrell who wa deputy commander of the 11th Naval Ditrict air bae (1945), wa awarded a Bronze Star medal (1945), and commanded all of the Marine Corp air bae on the wet coat at the time of hi retirement (1946); and for it aociation with Donald M. Dili, the who erved a Chainnan for the annual Chritma Seal Campaign (1964), erved a econd Vice Preident of the Coronado Chamber of Commerce (1967), wa 14

19 awarded the Boy Scout Silver Beaver award (1971), and wa appointed Vice Preident ofcoronado Hopital (1978) and Medical chiefof8taff(1979); c) The building on the property doe not poee ditinctive characteritic of it original architectural tyle, and i not valuable for the tudy of a type, period, or method of contruction and ha been ubtantially altered; d) The dwelling on the property i not an example of the notable work of the builder, Chri Cogrove, a it no longer retain architectural or material integrity and doe not reflect the original deign or workmanhip of the builder due to ubtantial modification in 1967 and 1983; e) The property ha not been lited or formally determined eligible for the California Regiter a et forth in Section of the California Public Reource Code. NOW, THEREFORE, BE T FURTHER RESOLVED that the Hitoric Reource Commiion of the City ofcoronado hereby determine the property addreed a 1132 Glorietta Boulevard doe not meet the required criteria to be deignated a a Coronado Hitoric Reource. PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Hitoric Reource Commiion of the City of Coronado, California, thi 6th day of December, 217, by the following vote, to wit: AYES: NAYS: ABSENT: DSQUALFED: Attet: David Gillingham, Chair Rachel A. Hurt Director of Community Development 15

20 r fc'cefved CT5W COMM%EvnE u%%" CTYOFCORONADO Attachment 2 DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNTY DEVELOPMENT PLANNNG DVSON 1825 STRAND WAY, CORONADO, CA (619) (619) (FAX) COMMDEV@CORONADO.CA.US HANDOUT 8 January 216 DETERMNATON OF HSTORC SGNFCANCE (For Nomination for Hitoric Deignation and Notice of ntent to Demolih Review) PURPOSE: To determine whether a building, tructure, object, or ite i a Hitoric Reource in aociation with a nomination by a property owner or an application for demolition or partial demolition of a tructure 75 or more year old. AUTHORTY: Coronado Municipal Code Title 84, Hitoric Preervation, Chapter 84.1 and 84.2 NOTES: 1. All quetion on the application hould be anwered a completely and accurately a poible. A complete analyi of the property per each of the Hitoric Deignation Criteria i required. Attach additional page a neceary. 2. Pleae ee the following Hitoric Deignation Criteria Guideline, available from the Community Development Department and on the City' webite for aitance in completing the application. 3. While not required, the aitance of a profeional hitoric conultant i highly recommended, and may be helpful in the reearch and preparation of your application. 4. Application package hould be ubmitted to the City of Coronado Community Development Department. Original document are required, copie, can, or faxe will not be accepted. 5. Application package mut be complete incluive of all attachment and complete Hitoric Deignation Criteria analyi. ncomplete application will not be docketed and will be returned to the applicant for additional reearch and analyi. 6. Complete application will be docketed for the earliet available hearing, unle a pecific date i requeted by the applicant. Hitoric Reource Commiion hearing are held the firt and third Wedneday of each month at 3: p.m., in the Council Chamber of City Hall. 7. Fee - Refer to current Planning Fee Schedule at APPLCANT DATA: Addre of Property:1132 'oritta Blvd. Coronado, Ca Owner: Evelyne Shaffer Mailing Addre: 163 El cajon Place Coronado, CA Phone #: evelhaf163@centurylink.net Signature: Aeor Parcel No.: Applicant: Chritian Rice Mailing Addre: 1127 LomaAve. Coronado, CA Phone #: cr@chritianrice. Signature: REQURED ATTACHMENTS: Site plan depicting general location of building() and improvement on ite. 53 Copy of Reidential Building Record (available from the County Aeor' Office at 16 Pacific Highway, San Diego) Current color photograph of the treet view of the property, and each exterior elevation of all tructure on the property. nclude thee photograph digitally a jpg file on a CD, or to tolen@coronado.ca.u Q Hitoric photograph of the property, if available. Copy of Grant Deed. f the property i held in a Trut, Corporation or LLC, documentation identifying the trutee and executor trutee, and or manager authorized to act on behalf of the Corporation or LLC. Other documentation, including but not limited to hitoric newpaper article, hitoric drawing, plan or rendering, chain of title, notice of completion, or other hitoric information relevant to the application. CTY STAFF USE: Cae#:Ol'WV1-l(& Date Received loffh Date Application Complete l 5'n Hearing Date: ( 11 16

21 PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1132 Glorietta Blvd. Coronado, CA ARCHTECTURAL DETALS Architectural Style: Unknown Provide an architectural decription of the reource under review (tyle, feature, building type, condition, exterior material, window type, etc), attach additional page a needed: See attached report. CONSTRUCTON DETALS Original Contruction Date Original Architect Unknown Prior location (if relocated): NA original Builder chri A. Cogrove _Date of Relocation:. NA Provide a complete contruction hitory of property (addition, alteration, modification, repair, etc.) attach additional page a needed: See attached report OWNERSHPOCCUPANCY DETALS original Owner Earl & Martha Brix original Occupant Earl & Martha Brix Provide a complete hitory of ownerhip and occupant (name, occupation, known detail, etc.) attach additional page a needed: See attached report 17

22 PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1132GloriettaBlvd, Coronado, CA92118 CRTERA EVALUATON: For each Criterion, provide a complete analyi of the reource under tudy, indicate whether the reource meet or doe not meet each deignation criteria, indicate what reearch wa conducted, and provide evidence and documentation upporting the analyi. t i recommended that the criterion analyi be provided in the form of a detailed Hitoric Reearch Report. Criterion A t exemplifie or reflect pecial element of the City' military, cultural, ocial, economic, political, aethetic, engineering, or architectural hitory. D Property i hitorically ignificant per Criterion A a a pecial element of the City' (D military D cultural D ocial D economic D political D aethetic D engineering D architectural) hitory. D Property i not hitorically ignificant per Criterion A Whether you are indicating the property meet or doe not meet Criterion A, a complete analyi mut be attached, Criterion B t i identified with a peron() or an event() ignificant in local. State or national hitory. D Property i hitorically ignificant per Criterion B for it aociation with: D Property i not hitorically ignificant per Criterion B Whether you are indicating the property meet or doe not meet Criterion B, a complete analyi mut be attached. Criterion C t poee ditinctive characteritic of an architectural tyle, and i valuable for the tudy of a type, period, or method of contruction and ha not been ubtantially altered. D Property i hitorically ignificant per Criterion C becaue it poee ditinctive characteritic of the. tyle, and i valuable for the tudy of a (D type D period D method of contruction), and ([]ha D ha not) been ubtantially altered. D Property i not hitorically ignificant per Criterion C Whether you are indicating the property meet or doe not meet Criterion C, a complete analyi mut be attached. Criterion D t i repreentative of the notable work of a builder, deigner, architect, artian or landcape profeional. D Property i hitorically ignificant per Criterion D becaue it i repreentative of the notable work of_ a (D builder D deigner D architect D artian D landcape deigner) D Property i not hitorically ignificant per Criterion D Whether you are indicating the property meet or doe not meet Criterion D, a complete analyi mut be attached. Criterion E t ha been lited or formally determined eligible for the California Regiter a et forth in Section of the California Public Reource Code (a amended from time to time), (Qye Ulno). ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS: 3 By igning thi application acknowledge that undertand that a Hitoric Reource Deignation doe not reult in an automatic Mill Act entitlement. A Mill Act Agreement i a eparate application proce after deignation, which alo require approval by City Council. alo grant permiion to the City of Coronado to ue photo and a decription of the property on the City' Hitoric Preervation webite, brochure, andtfift manal. Signature of property owner r2 QL - c f the property i hitorically deignated, will you be ubmitting a Mill Act application following deignation? Yd ND f the property i hitorically deignated, do you intend to apply for a Hitoric Alteration Permit in the future? Y D ND (.'it Coiincii. lio;»il..iiid l oinini-.kin'.ilr'.l ii]'i]t,\apiilii.-;]ioii',l R!';u;i(;igc 1 111< );."~i"n;il[i)n\h:]]iti()iii tlt;ini;i[iotl.!;inii.ir\.'iilii i; 18

23 Attachment A - Building Development nformation Pleae provide the following item a Attachment A: Architectural Decription Site Plan Complete contruction hitory of property Reidential Building Record nformation on Architect or Builder How do prepare thi Attachment? Architectural Decription-Thi i a phyical decription of the reource and it character defining feature (tyle, feature, building type, condition, exterior material, window and door type, etc). The book A Field Guide to American Houe by Virginia and Lee McAleter i a helpful reource for identifying the architectural tyle of a reource and character defining feature. Thi book i available at the Coronado Public Library. Site Plan - Thi can be a imple hand drawing or a profeionally drawn ite plan howing property line, footprint of each tructure on the ite, and identify area of non-hitoric addition. Aerial photograph may be ued, if tructure on the property are not obcured by foliage. Contruction Hitory - Thi i a tabular lit of all permitted and unpermitted modification to the reource from contruction to the preent. There i no need to provide copie of building permit, a relevant information hould be provided on the tabular lit. Example: Date: Permitted Work: Permit ued to: C.J. Wincheter Two duplex apartment and garage Sewer connection C.J. Wincheter Unknown Replace window (no permit found) Builder: Thoma C. Cooke Unknown Thi information can be reearched by looking at building permit for the property a well a phyically examining the property and identifying modification. Building permit can be found at: Coronado City Hall, 1825 Strand Way, Coronado (Digital record of all permit) Hour M-F Sam to 5pm. Coronado Hitorical Aociation, 11 Orange Avenue, Coronado (pre-198 permit only) Call for appointment (619) Reidential Building Record - Thi document i available at: San Diego County AeorRecorder Office, 16 Pacific Highway, San Diego Note that you mut be the property owner or have written authorization from the property owner to obtain thi document. There may be a fee for copying the document. nformation on Architect or Builder - Thi i a tatement of any known information about the architect or builder, including biography, known work, and work that have been deignated a Hitoric Reource. The architect or builder of the reource may be identified on the original building permit or the Notice of Completion. You can alo ak taff for any available information on an architect or builder that you hould ue a a tarting point for your reearch and analyi. Relevant newpaper article or other document related to your analyi of the building profeional hould alo be included here. 19

24 n 1132GloriettaBlvd. Coronado, CA APN# Lot: 13'Block: 78 Map: 376 * \ \ Hitoric Report Glorietta Boulevard EXSTNG CONDTONS The property aeed i located at 1132 Glorietta Blvd. The property i located in a reidential zone. The property generally conit of one irregularly haped parcel of land. The dwelling wa contructed during 193 in an unknown architectural tyle. The exiting dwelling itting on the property exhibit ign of an extenive additionalteration to the front facade, ide and rear. Thi can be verified by looking at the building record and record drawing provided. The tructure of the dwelling conit of conventional wood framing with wood and aluminum framed window. Window type throughout the dwelling conit of caement, lider, fixed and bay window. Window and door throughout the houe appeared to be replaced with the 1983 remodel project. The exterior finih i made up of tucco. The roof i mid-loped at perimeter of tructure with a flat center. t conit of aphalt hingle at flat area and clay roof tile at loped area. ARCHTECTURAL DESCRPTON No image of the original home could be found, and due to the extenive renovation to the original home that occurred over the year, there i no longer any evidence of the architectural tyle of the original home. Additionally, no decription of the architectural tyle of the original home wa dicovered in the reearch. CONSTRUCTON DETALS The original builder for the dwelling wa Chri A. Cogrove. During reearch Cogrove' name came back with ome hitorical ignificance in San Diego County (See Criterion D). According to building record the houe ha gone different type of alteration throughout the year ince it original contruction. n 1983 the home went through a major additionremodel that completely changed the layout and ize of the houe. 2

25 r- r Exiting Pool 1.ine of exiting 2nd floor Area of alteration to original tructure r -i\yl Area of alteration to original tructure Exiting 2 Story Reidence J 1 Line of exiting 2nd floor r L J L Exiting Site Plan Glorietta BJvcL 1132GloriettaBlvd. CoronadoCA,92118 Chritian rice architect, inc. 21

26 n 1132GloriettaBlvd. Coronado, CA APN# Lot: 13 Block: 78 Map: 376 Hitoric Report Glorietta Boulevard CONSTRUCTON HSTORY A building permit wa iued for the original contruction of the dwelling on the parcel. (See attached building permit # 3868) A building permit for the contruction of a retaining wall wa iued. (See attached building permit #4414) A building permit for the reroofing of a deck wa iued. (See attached building permit # 574) Building permit for repair of the dwelling. (See attached building permit #7865) Electrical permit for wiring of two outlet. (See attached electrical permit #7521) Building permit for remodel of exiting bathroom. (See attached building permit #1492) Plumbing permit. (See attached plumbing permit #4891) Electrical permit for 12 outlet and 6 ocket. (See attached electrical permit #8573) Building permit for removal of partition in dining area. (See building permit #15837) Electrical Permit for 5 outlet. (See electrical permit #9394) Building permit for contruction of tile roof over ide entry. (See attached building permit #1591) Building permit for contruction of new front entrance, patio lab, front walk and terrace. (See attached building permit #15891) Plumbing permit. (See attached plumbing permit #695) Building permit for remodel of kitchen, laundry and bathroom. (See attached building permit #17762) Plumbing permit. (See attached plumbing permit #7588) Electrical permit. (See attached electrical permit #183) Electrical permit. (See attached electrical permit #1886) Building permit for chain link fence in rear ide yard. (See attached building permit #19529) Building permit for addition of new family room. (See attached building permit #2171) Plumbing permit. (See attached plumbing-mechanical permit #975) Electrical permit. (See attached electrical permit #12124) Building permit for new pool and pa. 2 liding gla door. (See attached building permit #22519) Plumbing-Mechanical permit. (See attached plumbing-mechanical permit #11477) Electrical permit. (See attached electrical permit #13247) Building permit for a fence. (See attached building permit #22491) Building permit for additionremodel. (See attached building permit #8127). 22

27 n Electrical permit. (See attached electrical permit #E638) A mechanical permit wa iued for the remodel and addition. (See attached mechanical permit # M262) Plumbing permit. (See attached permit #P927) Building permit for remodeladdition. (See building permit #B124). 23

28 ..' (1 1 t M -1 1 <n h. bj <ft * '. V. A 1 S 1 i i P L Lu vi : y> Q i =? (Q 3 F: 1*J Q co < z a: a- P <n 11. Si <n u " < u? 2. ul, o S' u- 7. :vl S'<-1 '. a: (Cl-ti tt u> y lul.5 5? F. [ H u c <?' ltl w k-: a a: \ $ M < S te t :5 8 ri )<d 5 a u> % ]2 <t 3 - lu! 1 Cl ol??l5lb «u <Q ; Q >1 2: 3 g vlk t~ < te>.l!j=>l -)<* a: <? \A< v,'" Cii tt 2 h. lu u. >.lll Q -1\. \ 9 t.?; Q? 5 ~1\ 3 1; & < $ i! \ u» u. (u a <B w ST. c 5 f li <, J te u» 5 i tt» <a J >H «! J 8 1 "? V (\ ir a: ' ni 1 (C n- t <y1 > to r t ft; a U) & 4i- ] << (t.- c ft (M x ti. <» ; -> <j S?lk< S Tn ft ~ -J 1< a 5 u. y (31 fit - co % >; o 'f llil 5 '- -ttl <Q < 3» <1 1 % :r F 1 3: 1 ;i! N :g tl c: 1 Y < d 8 1 Q ni -< Q u SB?1.<.-ti '. ' rd ' = g t>,. <& t K»; <, "d 'K ST: ti ; tt. w 5» E g 5 r- 5 to ft SJ 14: % \ 5 c» :-; 515 <y 5e 4 1 u Q 1- >< 1. lu =; V;! K. i» b6 a i u; a u 1 1 J ( <3 i y.? M a o a < a w> *. 5 y> g? - < 1 11 l %? \ y 1» c % t c: X. < < > «\ >< n? a <( t: :1>< ' c y >? il <t < 3 \1 1 F: ac ai 1 u. $ N: ti M a. rt 1 9 S3 -a-t < ~> t) tk u 1?x> a. c» d u S>-11 > ol n <31 - r 1 d <?>9 a u».? -\ y<> Q <T( N ly 1 Nt t. > < \a \J \.6 tpti? Q 5 J! :J"M Ji J - 6 r ; a: ol d < f i < : ll 5 u; < 15 t1 u Sl U) ' 1 c u <J A oyv bd - h <d- -? 3d S<] nc b?;.' < 5 T- o 1 rt w.3 n<] n n \ > ft w > 5 d \a a Q: B 5 m d-1 Q; u 13 >u -# <!i lu ij Q?1 % rr> a 5 < <rl <J - J : <? : x -ii! "> V? 5 < < c ft 1*1 <»;<»:».»-1. X. rx A.<( --d '»!. S 41 1.O.h* CM «< <t>- 11 M 3 -t -5 \ < «ff < :$ a: - K <j <5 te 1 y <\ -SJ => \ M 1 <; L<: U) (Ml r< A. -i- j fc?1 to c? (. fl v\ 5 a la \r < \a -?LJ Q V tx> K.t < lu <rl<t! & -1 -u)lt - ; t. >. <n -t- g 5 >? t< 5 «a 5 i i lu r~< - J l u te *a!; { K@1 i:.? OJ.5 <3 51 Qr nt )k>. o «j «Q t k N <li N3 <r> fi th P<1 ),; '? a 5 -? 'C>1 J S P» Q SL ft!"i h S -»?? Q: g 3 1 cl c 1~ (1 8 \LS T) u 8 u rf do?» g < J" <1 <( n. Uj 'll < {; \ t) te Q d a - : a M inll'ot r"i. > '? a»».-??'2; 3.5 Uo fl t<p» <n <. 1 3 N y <a Q c \ a ' % <~fl t *-i <? c-g a:» \ 'a <.1 < u B3 --J A JSfQ?1 u. 9. u (a X. c Yll< u -A4 t<8 Q hi \; < hi c u -1 - a? ft, 5 n a; 1.5 = il ] >A?t.5 tt :?i (.l{' N y <l d4 u> 5 ' Sit w ojb a: K d <t j 5 r\ u u> u hi 6 ca " te t < Cr uld. 5:1-: S \r t ->, a. <3 fl GJ a ft: : OK >. a <n \J 5 i 5 f< fc \-\ ru-t??il d fj» c» n \\ U) L5 & Q. J. rt L4 u <M N <i M < ij u K Q <». j?a fl (. 3 Q' M51 $ 1- pl )c c. Q N K n 1 o 4fr aj*- u \ o* '. \. c «M uo24 KS =>u 5

29 v> tu a: ( => t t~ (ft (ft l*i % <2 l'l *K? l»s c r-!1 *; i.3 w 3 11? 15 5 v». '1 <3-1.1,N 1-3j <N.l i-1 <L r\ f\\ \! i<,l i t \ 4 4 C>< -! 11-1»l \S t y-i ' ;1 'i 3L-(- F i -»..? 1 \ '-t- < <>Sfl FS»' '. <a r< *- (S L i rt f ) (\ -»D r ri. > >.(t :) "Ac (n 1* & \Lf*C!,1 <1 n Kt <;J] '1 r- 3- M r * X" j Q "li». r*» : t t n r'\ < X N <i \ t-.,-< 'rkt' i 'Ull \»! -ri a <c g V < 1 ; <( S) Q.! >i,-.j S) r "1 - '&<».J <- " i'3 ~J! '»!'> <-( \i f< o». ;t t. 1~ --t ~~ { <.,1 <a.-,'.1; y»..' 1 - "1 >>. '-'- 3 * '"!\. 1 y u > H.? K t w t. > -+' 1~? -» T.-1 ', < roi»> < > \. H: <t \ - ( - << \ 5 u *. )) tl 1 d tl y <3 V} 1 fl t" '~ N. >.; 'll <: 1 <?1 " 1-1 <a h< -<* 1 ; -j -1 '"J ll <1 "?1 1 ~<! it-.l 4 i ~M v \ \J \J 1 t 1 -J ',. y\ <1.j -1 Of -?1 1 T t K. c'» \ * f. -H<?:,..,-4-.' ( ' <--.(... (.,.44.U4-f! ' "'"t~t't"t T t '"*"t" Lrriii t't +. Lt'il.. 1 t..-*- "" ;" r, 4 t 1~ -; a t -) L-?f - ~ T ->.--d? "l '.J ~* \ % J \kt* ' ', t;. - ~< S a* * > JT -j,, f,-(...»....,,. 1. r f i irn:tt;:?:; t-r-t ; ' < -?u t: V,»-. ' ; a! " il,.+-{.. 44f-f-,-.}.4.H-ru-4-1 mtf-h-t. "i-t-r" r1-f-}..4 r. *. i4- '»->-t-i ; f-t-'"~tt *+-' <-'l [:"t? '»--w-.-,.*-y4-. t..t-t- < i-i.-.L...-t.1-,., 4 1-; "! > t-h 1-" -»-i t"tr-t ; T < ' 44"(1. * :"".J:]-<Tt:.;n,±..L-L prq.4- iffh t-*-'; t-tit-'-r-f i, tllit' tlll.l;.: 1 r {, +- (? ṛ.< rtt-h-- E! T u -. i i f- t,».- -i.., <r '; ''TT t h"' t " -..J. rt» ' :*;. J 1 J i- -t*"-"ih*w{ r;n.. t- t-'-*" < -T*-*W1 :;,..tti i..:.tbr! -4 jlfi 144-j,'ffi it' i -r

30 a: <te >u.s } n RFlFl 2 g1 aei'<. (. a < «: <5 p* S u» 5 ec v 2 % [SS Q: &u kj 5 ' t 1 h. g < <d 12 <t m 'QW'o lu a:. c», % Ul te ' Q G Rlt- t. 5 Q 5> < wn : << a J 3 te> <t li y-. <» \k a: v\ u K fc 6)t«< 2 tc. t~ 1*1 *. > \ ll <5 h. t ' u --1\ q \ ;a u <» <l u. U -3 lr ST a. & c rl <J - ri. a: 3 i '.?].lu> Q lu» Y n> '& ir < u 15 J i <? 'A <io ~t1 5 F 6! t: Nj ( c! tli ( e>. <yi n: v > to a <2 til 3. a: < 1 «% <: K.- C. t; ~ll -*< ft (t >~ <M -X. So );» S<» ~ ft fc% Ut 8 '<. u: So Ki! ft <a.i? CT- lu u DO a; u. flw --) -l? -.t- K> (ft & tl> Q - tt : a -? f»a a %..n;r. tl ii - n r, ;; iil.'g '; 5 a e: c-<i v <a; 5 d < ' 1 t; d SL >< y l» a u ' -tx.-d Bi < H t 2 >< -,. <5-1 - oi vrt 9 t =e f u t 'K ul if»:.*: :5 $ t a. ; [ S» r v> 5 n.?t3 ou -r 1C 1 t % g <Q & 1 :5 tu -q Ci a Sl'5 y u; 4 D1K '<ww > ->1 \. Q p d < <lv ( rl X. h> 6 l-. iy Ci w [ u 1 hi 1 y Sl <d h- a; Q -51il? 5 r\ <n u. a <S!"> St1 g Ol? y\ 5 l % <y )?M; r $111 c 5 c <a % a» Xl 1. < c x?xi n ' a X i 5 Q <l k; ei; a. 5'te Ul l-l 'l 5fi1. 5 iii (t l\ \ Kl-4 ai '< < G D< p. ti 4 Q. i 4 <J X Uj c u \J '4. <; u c fl So a ta!. ; (t ri <»> :.- a ~ 6o ' n Q. a <.1\1 Q o n Q U)?>41 3 Ua.? ~- N Un y> 1 N? Q <\ lu h.» \?1 X r\ 1? 6 Q 5 J ti <n h< i 6. *.' g.r < <a o Q : «<a.. < 6? o < < li < <S1B ni Q k. a: 1-; K > &; - h? Qv g5] i rx b <l =).- < w- ( (Q " 1 mi nt fc V.3 '1 r< \.'< tl> k; w Q \ 1 9» (t ~> -»~1 u <c gtkl- -t- 5?l i >a<j 3t- - iy 5.r ' ni.- $ $ n (rl f\ -a. g o x 5 < c a: 31 lu ") 5 V ' < u:n: :.8' ~< lu a '~i( S a.iu w j5» Ul Q <ti <<l»- 15»».: U) te k<. < < tt.1 u t u' i. < te 1 i- - a ->; L<; lu w >9 1 t«uj.n,?.5 c. <8 tt M»» -ff - Tl E } «? D 1 <"r «u 1 2 <rt t>9 A t. < 3 1 (t u (i». <r ] \3 A. - n? 3? 1*1 il-i f T-, "7 yj a; e «ff -g!; { <Q <3 f~ r» y r< "r\\-'[j.5 < *. Ki t lt. N '> Al M *'( w (Vt } < j; 1 ><- xt><~k -u M <;? < -iiavr a -l > '3 z» Q?M ~M S -5 1 ec :-» > Q: S3 c? 1 t~>) i< <J fri M\LS g ~B tf) tl. 3 -D r- do <1 <l >d u \w: < <n a; B \ a 'n!: 1< 1 inllv>4.-i ri- 9 tn Si " -' tt: )u a»-? ;; y ) '4 J <» > Sil:i- < u «l ni «T<< <n?1' 5 Q l<l'.l -1 a % r\\ Tl 5 <. 1 1 < "<< < ac ' <»?1 < 8!». 5C c Si. -J < u hf 11 ; SJJ i <J fl.l \( -) -J K a? tt.l.j n: 7= < ft «l, t 5 Q: llifl.3 CJ rf k: J >J»» r\ 1 U>1 4L (U N?l u te a L 31 a u Q. -.t: A \ U) a,. : 1-. \r. i :1 -!u < p a:. > i % a ( 5 r< (S ro KMS- -u i:!-; l.iil? v d w u g SJ, : c w r< % u <M r!&-1' < Stlii t< Ul 1 <( u: n: Q '< {!>.?" <! r 1!<liQ'f1: <6 ' t\ \ < r~ -)- r-, *K M ' ;) - L.'<?- ~8l. uo 26 j

31 T»? Hitoric Deignation, Legacy 16 r r Home Deiqnation Qualification ] Company Profile Newletter Link Archaeology ac Hitorlc Preervatlon Hjrjc Dj:-:j2jiJn Leggcy 16,. P.O. Box San Diego, CA PhoneFax(619) Leaacvl 6inc@aol.com J. ;;Aaj. Hitoric Landmark No. 588 Cogrove Ratner Houe Unknown, Architect Chri A. Cogrove, Builder 1949 Kenington Community Hitorical Landmark No Deignated Nlay 23 c HSTOHCAl. NOMNATON <)1; Tilt COStiROVK V RA Nt:K 111 SE.i thrift r"<n>kt~t MWr WoAn ffoh* JNOf trf? * AX..Wfa,p* c *- 1< L?j.)-y iv,. :-.'3~;,;- c to thi Mater Builder..3! * ft?; ;: ±L; % CHRS COSGROVE HOUSE c'o New Connection Learned between Chri Cogrove and Loui R. Dilley! Exciting new information about Chri Cogrove' early career in the City ofcoronado ha come to light with the November 26 deignation of the houe at 127 Adella Avenue and the October 24 deignation of 115 Adella Avenue. Thee two houe can now be added to the lit of hitoric home credited See our commentary on the Loui R. and Muriel Dilley Monroe E. and Olga J. Wallace Houe in Miion Hill for the new!

32 15217.r" Hitoric Deignation, Legacy 16,< A 1949 CHRS A. r COSGROVE MD- <N- ''" 1" 1\ CENTURY MODERN RANCH HOUSE Thi San Diego Mid-Century Modern houe i one of only a few home from thi important and intereting era that have been deignated a San Diego Hitorical Landmark. Lat year. Legacy 16, nc. preented a paper on midcentury modern commercial building at the Save Our Heritage Organiation' <<«r -ik., ' Swimming pool and recreation area in the rear of the houe. (SOHO) Modernim Weekend. Ronald V. May talked about the pychology behind the zany architectural deign often found with thi tyle. We trongly upport SOHO' enthuiam to promote a heightened undertanding and appreciation of San Diego' midcentury modern architecture and architect. The Chri Cogrove Houe i aociated with peron ignificant to the pot World War San Diego real etate and clothing indutrie. Chri A. Cogrove and David G. Fleet were leader in the emerging pot-war real etate indutry throughout the City of San Diego. The Ratner family wa a leader in the electrical contracting and clothing indutrie and they helped hape San Diego' ocial and economic hitory during the ame period. Chri A. Cogrove wa a ignificant land developer in San Diego County during the pot World War 194 and 195 eatern expanion of the City of San Diego. n hi 65-year career, he wa a pioneer builder of over 3, home and commercial propertie in Point Loma, College Height, Talmadge, Rolando, Cogrove Height, Kenington, Coronado, La Mea, Alpine, Rancho Santa Fe, Lo Angele, and Palm Spring. He wa a recognized cutom-home deigner, who eized upon the fahionable architectural theme of pot-war California modernim and favored hi own verion of ranch tyle houe that phyically embraced backyard outdoor recreation. Many of hi building exhibit hi ditinctive flagtone maonry facade. Later owner Nathaniel and Sally Ratner old the houe to David G. and Louarn Fleet in David G. Fleet wa the on ofrueben H. Fleet, who with hi family ha made ignificant contribution to San Diego' houing development and ocial hitory. A early a 1932, Rueben H. Fleet and on David G. Fleet relocated Conolidated Aircraft from Buffalo, New York to San Diego. Cogrove' brand offha-influenced non-spanih tyle home mark the final tage of primary real etate development in Kenington. The Great Depreion and a Congreional building moratorium during World War terminated the Kenington Architectural Board, which alo uffered the untimely death of mater architect Richard Requa in Cogrove, along with other builder in Kenington, took advantage of the regulatory vacuum of the late 194 to develop high-end cutom home along in thi area. Thi houe i an excellent example of thi recognized pot war building tyle. f.i. Permiion to ue thi material i granted provided it i attributed a follow: Copyright 21 Ronald V. May and Dale Ballou May, Legacy 16, nc., Home Deianation ] Qualification Company Profile New Link

33 Attachment B - Ownerhip and Occupant nformation Pleae provide the following item a Attachment B: Timeline of ownerhip andor occupant ince contruction California Digital Newpaper Collection earch for all owner and occupant Copy of Current Grant Deed. Micellaneou document related to property owner and occupant How do prepare thi Attachment? Timeline of Ownerhip and Occupancy - Provide a complete hitory of ownerhip and occupant (name, occupation, known detail, etc.) in a tabular lit. Copie of hitoric deed do not need to be provided, a relevant information hould be included in your tabular lit. Example: Year Owner Occupant Occupant Note Jane Smith Same Nure 1941 Jane Smith No liting Jane Smith Sally Jone Rocket Scientit You can reearch ownerhip hitory in the following way: Order a hitoric Chain of Title earch from a company uch a California Lot Book nc., or reearch the title hitory at: San Diego County AeorRecorder Office, 16 Pacific Highway, San Diego Occupant hitory can be reearched uing the Polk and Frye City Directorie. Note that Coronado may be included in the Suburban San Diego Directorie rather than the San Diego City Directorie for ome year, and houeholder (treet index) directorie for Coronado are not available for all year. Thee directorie are available at: San Diego Hitory Center Archive El Prado, in Balboa Park (baement level) Call archive for hour (619) San Diego Central Library, 33 Park Boulevard, San Diego, 9th Floor room 93, Special Collection Occupant hitory can alo be reearched uing Acce Ancetry.com free of charge at the Coronado Public Library. The following record are epecially helpful: US Cenu Record City Directory Liting Voter Regitrie California Digital Newpaper Collection Search -Coronado' hitoric newpaper include: Thee newpaper are available online at and are earchable by name, or other earch term. You can narrow your earch by City to reduce the reult to include only Coronado or San Diego newpaper. Pleae include copie of all relevant article found for owner and occupant, and notate each article with the relevant name or topic. Searching other local newpaper archive may be helpful, uch a the San Diego Union, which i available at: San Diego Central Library, 33 Park Boulevard, San Diego Copy of Current Grant Deed - Thi mut be provided by the property owner. f the property i held in a Trut, Corporation or LLC, the documentation identifying the trutee and executor trutee, and or manager authorized to act on behalf of the Corporation or LLC i required. 29

34 n 1132GloriettaBlvd. Coronado, CA APN# Lot: 13 Block: 78 Map: 376 \ \ \ \ Hitoric Report Glorietta Boulevard OWNERSHPOCCUPANCY TMELNE The lit of name provided below were found during our reearch. After extenive reearch in the record provided by the city library and the Coronado hitorical aociation, none came back with any hitorical ignificance. Chain of Title Lit: 1. Earl Brix & Martha Brix - Original Owner ( ) 2. Albert Heckey & Billie Heckey - Tenant ( ) 3. Mile R. Browning - Owner ( ) 4. Charlie G. Browning - Owner ( ) 5. Mary B. Farrell - Owner ( ) 6. Walter D. Coleman & Jean N. Coleman - Owner ( ) 7. Donald M. Dill & Janet Ann Dill - Owner ( ) 8. Burton Gilbert Sherwood & Sandra Joy Sherwood - Owner ( ) 9. Gerald M. Schwartz & Eleanor J. Schwartz - Owner ( ) 1. Nicki P. Troutman - Owner ( ) 11. Oren G Shaffer & Evelyne Shaffer - Owner (217- Preent) 3

35 r.r- r r EL- >y fe. \f[ c t {» L Well Known Aviator Retire From Service At V«own Kqttrt, wid, wiok tl»» pprovl of ib» i»ri4»t»l, S«aior UtQtfimiiit,. " «WM pl<rf on tiaii niird Htrt <yf tt» navy, «p<m AOQiiry 11 Lt ikrwwl for tw»nty y<fr» in Vr navy; twle y<ar» of whirh tiw w in the aviation «>rpt. White M duty»t th«rrvat»ty tatic tt» r (wilt t 118 Ad<iU».»v<'»w4yaCcironiM&o.» irill»ali<e fcto hcin&flbert* " " u 31

36 r» THUKSDAY, AniL 27, 1939 COKONABO JOUtNAL PACE "BULLDOG'ARR" WlMS.TWO B1.UC RlftBONS'lN 1>6 SHOW 4 * 1.1 ; 'y:'- t.. Dale Brix. Dane Wibon and Earl Brix, left to right, wit'i do([ f.arri. <*Tri won two blu< ribbona in the dog ahow lay h* wa judged Uw bent dog of i* low w vvtt» the dog with the bet co»tum». SECOND ANNUAL DOG Feet Enter Canal; SHOW SCORES HT Amve Next Week Coronado' Canine Again Have Their Dav in Colorful Dog Show; Ribbon A»urd«l Once uirai'i Coronado'n ycunireat act howed their eldere how to put on a do how. Saturday afternoun on the t i» lar bciicvad Urt the Bix-inch crutaera of the Honolulu and Sa-; UK will come to San Dieiroi irt of Mra. 'aul Weireforth, a* aoon aa the European aituation per-1 dren. with a board cf c [mita. tora cunaiatinit of Marjoric M»c' Several warahipa now at Mare. Rccd MacNally, Earl Brix, Nancy land, 'carl Harbor and Bremerton.' Wrenn and Peter Scott, pre«entod a!ii re alo due to arrive n the wal hardoj? nhon' that for color and genuine h(-r n»xt month, they include the airinteret far urpabbti many thnt have 'raft carrier Saratof{», the cruiorfi been plftnnwl by experta in the boin<*88, ntun nntj Oetruit iind a core pf FdllowinR are tlie winnera in Coronado' BrcciMl annual (OK &how: DO(T in beat cohtumc :Date Brix, with "an Enalih bull named eecond, Ann Montftumfi-y with ac) anil thin); Tomniy Willinmon with (Continued from Paffe One) dpatroye nnd tender. Alno arrivinir next month arr thn't1 naval tranport brintring a nr inibfr of navv peronnpl and tl B tranafen-i'd from fatt-rn flition. The trio of veael and their date of arrival are the Vefra, Mai HenderRni, Moy ff and Siriua. May with long-eat hair; Catherine inon with a collie; aecond, Barbara lack with Prince. Harry L. Perkin to Uoy in the bet conditicn wit) mofit pep compared to affe: Head Rotarian Hertz with Mouaie. Doff with nioat triclta: Mre. Walter (Continued from Pa»e One) Vwr with Chummy; wcond, Virfrinia Brown with Anna; third, Tonuny on committee and hall been a memher of the board of director everal Hamilton with Boot*. Dojnnanahip; Craiy Conutoclt wltli ttmw. Durtny the current year he h»» Kiltie; econd. Tommy Williamaon been a member uf the board of directon and alao aerved on the achool ccn- with Tony; third, Mary B»BS with MUe. tact committee. He w» chairman of Cutet doft: Pat Crcwley with the decoration committee durine lat Honey; oin Spreckela with ft Chihuai; and third. Sue Morchouge with n all the yeare that Harry ha been wwk'a ditrict convention. iv Tim. a mrmber o{ Rotary he haa never been Doff with loudeat haa: Gene Faw- Uiffftcd with a nickname, but a few. JJ!. Two Boy to Be Honored at Graduation Exercie For the firat time in the hiatury of Coronado HiRh achoul two bcya haw attached to the Atlantic fleet only been chown from higrh honor atudente i f. Y w OM*C r.3 v.<«* 5DEO» a. CM'T co\s1?.'ot oltg of x ROOtO,;io". of the enior claw for B»lut»tori»n and fedictorian. n pwvioua yeara the : nor haa gone to a boy and ir\ or two frirla. Graduation cxwciea will take placp ht, June 2 at y o'clocli in mado hiffh theatre. -, Hitoric Bell Ring in "Stagecoach" The mellow, liquid note that heard (furinir one of the dnuni ttcenea in "Staffecoach" come from «church bell that ha liwked down u] much of America'a fcrmativc wetei hiatory. t wa borrowed by the Walter Wanirer atudio froi CaliforniariB who have «p<n lcctinf valued hiatorical object. Stranyely enoufth, the bell waa caat cai in the foundrf- four of Sltka, Al ki when heti Baranff wan the "Little Czar ;( the Pacific." Thee.fouDdrin wei the BOurce of mont of the btlla itaed in the firt California mibaiona. Wanffcr' production. "Staffecoach." come to the Coronado theatre on ; Saturday. Sunday and Monday through United Artiat rcle e. t i«a tenaily f4mu Me e Bo»«' Sport Show. White or Mo oiu) whit* witk tathei loin. $2.95 Children' Sho«t in whim, btock or brown. $1.39 to $3.95 dnwn >wn rtory of the part the at. couh ch pl«ye<l played in the formative Uvee it* pawei pamenen while the wet ih«bailt John Ford directed thi frontier drama, with Claire Trevor and John Wayne, who cu-fitar with the ; of Andy Devine, John C»rr»- lomaa Mitchell. Louiae Hatt. Bancroft. Tim Holt and Berton ill. Subcribe hi Hit Connodo Jounwl WANTED Hwif. 3 or 4 btdrwm*. tt2(w to <KW cuh. Nil» «ll. Writ* itncription, price, and your addrun to Andia Woon. nrc Curunado Journal. WE HAVE JUST RECEVED OUK SPORT SHOES N ALL WHTE AND TWO-TONE N LEATHER AND CREPE SOLES- $2.98 $3.95 f 5. Growing Girl' gny wdt, cmp< ol«$1.99 Ton and Wkih R«bb«r Solct. $2.95 Mn'i Wo.k Sho- in Mack. Hijh oc low $2.95 WE GVE S6H GKEEN OR G1.D STANDARD TRADNG STAMPS Super Shoe Repairing Dyeing Renewng Findingt Coroaado Univeral Boot Shop Phon. CtTOKidil 415 J 945 Oronga Aw. SAFEVAV PRCES FOR THURSDAY-FRDAY-SATURDAY, APRL 27th, 28th, 29th SAFEWAY OFFERS ALL TH«EE LOW PMCES-CONVENENCE-QUAUTY UY THE EST FOB LESS BEVERAGES FOR HOME REFRES1MENT Grapeirnit Jtdce 4o.».25c Town PBUU-NO. 2 C*n Tomato Juice 4».r23c Sunny Dawn. No..1 Can No. Z can, 3 for 2e Snowy Peak Beverage Bottle «for t5c Baltic E»ch Cc QUAUTY MEATS Hen Tarkey ib221c Fancy Local. Fr«ah DreMed 9 to ]2.1b». Bacon t-llc Gold Coin-.Ccllo Pk. Lamb Roat.-Uic Shoulder. Fancy California lmh Pork Roat ib 15c Center Cut Shoulder Wiener Coney ulsc All You Want at Thin Price Smoked Picnic ibl7ic Cudahy'K Gold fo in or Mofrell'a Pride Tendered, Shanklw vory Soap Mri. C.ke LTtc. 2 fkn lie PCG Soap White Naptha R<t. Bar 5c 3e Super Sud KK Box Blue Boi 9t Brown Derby BEER 12-<. Cuia FNE COFFEES Airway iruic 3.1b. bag 37e Mild and Mdlow Edward ib224c 2-1h. c.n 44t Vacuum P«tk«<l Mayonnaie»3c <lt. Piedmont Pint 19c Peanut Butter l-25c Beverly -ib, lar Sc Canterbury Tea Finr Favor F-onomicaly Prkcd..i-b. loc 11.1b. St Snowdrift 1 b. f*i> lie Del Mont» No. ;No2y, 2 C.n...17c -b » $»b;51c «.16c Kitchen Craft Flour No. 1 Bag 35c ii-bbl 79c Keen Shortening 4-lb. Can 4c 8-1b. Can 78c 8c NiUet Del Mail ,o,29c FRUTS 8 VEGETABLES Avocado 5..rlc Banana C*)av<w. 6-ox. a to 1.oe each 5c Fancy. Golden Rip* Pea b.loc Artichoke Freah Grwn Fnll Poda, Fancy No. 1 Quality Jumbo Su«, Selnlul QiulilT Potatoe fto.ltc Cdory N«-w White Row No. Grade Eiln Lu-ac, Utah Typ* li'.'i.l'jfi VJJX....xitwftwr-wyw.-wr" celt mth Toby; 8MOlld_ CJenninin month afro he acquired one "Ferdinand" (he lovca to amd] the flowera). with Micky; third. MM. Earl Brix with Harry i one of the city'8 leadintf floritb, which may explain th? c-of?noinen- ivoritc puppie: Pat Crowley with Honey; econd. Mm. B. L. Rutt with Butch; third, Sue Monhouw with Tiny Subcribe to the Coronodo Journal Tim. Doy meet difficult to clanaify: Jean Fawcett with Toby; econd Paul Everything tn Heincman with Bitten; third, Lionel Kowe with ChipB. FURNTURE Do? with lonffet tail: Poppv Clark with Friti; econd, Ann Mon with Schnitiel; third, LOWEST PRCES wi Lena. Fatteet do: Bill Harper wit Ceronado ran; econd, Mn. George Nflw) with Milty, third. P«t Wilmn with Furniture Store Racket. Doy with tail that waga -fateat- olid June M. Brcwn with Scotty, aecond, Sue Morehouw with Tiny Tim; Coronado Tranfer Mn. Walter 'oor with Chumny. NEW.nd USED FUKNTURE Larffeflt doff: Prince, owned by B»rin Bluk. Z Daily Trip to San Diego iiiahua, owned by 21 Ynn in Corwailo Mr. H, S. Duc)< 19 Oraiijt A»«nue Cor. 547 >at do: Garri, owned by Mr. Earl lb- Ctn. -1c Pot Toatie Kp"" 3<.rl7c Box 8c 5,.25c 3..4C,.iklOC 32 <r y 5 i 1

37 c Bulldog Win Many Honor at Show < Bnniriny hot&e 2 cup* and 7 i '"Donatciia Gari." two-ycr old Knii U»k bttlldotf owwd by Un. ftf tols Adetla, weft imporuurt honw t tfe«silver Bay K<nn»! club h<nr!&rtunlay and Swulay. Wlnntnr ti»* Miwrv tn>phy, which M»rard«tfce aco»»d xwrt dof of tfx ritow, aad Ur fl»t pri in th«mrvice claiui, tb» bulldog' to<4t ftnta too in th* limit od locxl dainf. Tkfel?fai *'Dun»toaia Uwi'*" fint ppuu»n«ta A <lo» ahow, Nr».»Ut»d today. Tt»* honera ni t the mow nporalj b<*au the SHvdr Bay Kmnel club «j ffiliafd with th«i Amtncan Kannct dob. Anoth»r C-oronado dog rwiv*d a fint prlm wbw» tb» bltr ribbon WM wnt»d to Mr». R. F. Ma<N»ny'» ] trtckw»pani*l. T»»» finrt WM n the, Aiwrtnn br<rf iip»nt<l clww. R«d M*cN»»y. «m of Mr.»d Mn. MaeNalty. w awanl flnt pria«in tl»e e»iil4nn'» handuiik <l*w. and D«-..-, w awunitd foortii pnae in Uf clan. Ahwh \\ WA<<y \c\ c Ohtl uarw Mn.EarfBrh Former _ lonk-ttoc Coronudto reident Mn. ;, 7». dnd n SeuAfa, Cal.. on Wovtmbcr e. Daughter c< Major Wflliun X* Kjieedler, USA (nt.). oncj_of Coronador» founder tfie hl i?vd in the City T M rty 48 ye»r» before mortng to <<ffn«we jh»'1985 She w the widow of U. -. USN. She ia aunrived by Mra. R. E. Cummin of Pacific Grwc; and two on, f;«-! of Shn Trneice mid Dale of San Dfe»». f (ArAt V\y, owe. \ 33

38 r r r.r Copt. Mile Browning 1; Aworded Navy Medal Valorou action on Pacific warfront lia won the Silver Star medal for Capt. Mile R. Browning, U.S.N., of Coronado. the navy department an- nounced today. Capt. Browning en-ed a chief of taff to a tak force commander during a erie of highly ucceful oftenive miion, including- attack on the Marhall and Gilbert land, raid on Wake and Marcu laland, te Battle nt Midway and imilar ope'ration in the Central Pacific. Depite the contant threat of airi and ubmarine attack, the citation! aid, the tak force uffered only] minor damage due to Capt. Brown-] inp' kill and determination under] fire. n addition, he contributed mate-] rially to the marked ucce of other' action, through which the tak force, came uncathed after inflicting ex-] tremely heavy damage on Japanee hi-] tallation and hipping. < \'CvM(M6 v \f\w c Bridge Luncheon Mr. entertained wive of offieera of aqiudrmi VP-3, of which Licut. Conidr, i in ch»rre, at a tlvirming'lj ppointftd bn4ic<*-3uncl*n Thuraday, in her home. toos K Avenue. Cowra were laid for Medanaeg. Atden H, ran»> Charlea L* Wwthofcn, WUluim iot!i,nk»worth., JameB J. McRofcwrta, Geor( C. Montgomery, John P, Wliilney, Edward P. lor.re. Karl E. Jung-, Sytviu& G&«2-fr, John RuhBcnberger. Kugiene Tatom, Seytftour Johruion, WtHiara Gtiancll Tonilinon, Raymond -. W»n r and Henry,* H.H»lc. ".: '"W-J1 1 &AM.\A VSjMyJ(? t < o<?n\e> WS'? -( t f t 1 34

39 cr' r Dinner Party Honor Copt. and Mr. E. C. Ewen Mr. entertai(hlt recently with a ciinnor party at Hotel del Cort'Kadu ill honor of Cai>t. Edward C. Ewen, U.S.N., and Mr. Eweii. The honorec arrived nl<-entlv from Wahington and are ue.t. of the hotel for an indefinite tav. Gueti numb<*red 2<L t2u% ZovttAKS ric { \ c c EttSy?(BB.w.%»Af..-,V Service Familie Enferhiifiing With cnore nftrvlcn ftmsued on tjio move thia month, their comjnff nd KOatfig had l.hwq the lnc<lltive fo.r aun! }»rti<f.o than ill no.rmil in» cit.y wrhkh tokrt it* WAt reilpuafllbilltlcfli M H*riowriy v» C'oTOTkftrio. Conidr. <kii4 Mr*' Hwtht D. Dotigiaa who an now occupana w Pie'tenon horn? on (k-biin b(vd.< ftntftrt.alncd a larff*1' tpnup of friffnda at th» WK-kUat tour xat l-'rlday ft<-rtiocin. The party h.nond Mra. K.uwli A» ASr of Dtffcroit, anothfrr of Mt». DoiafEM. Mr». i-...i'- '. -; r-".*"'ic< 'inl.brt*jn<d about forty ffa<wt<»t cflclctwla in bar htwnft on tjorietta on Friday, uad Colonel and fn. RildCT Jac.iclln ifttlt*4 ftfvenu yuwf to dtbfi with them»t Hotel d«i CarftaNlfl. BAT Ailffi. aud Mra, Orin -. Sturfiii»tKo cniprtdinbd 1«1 wftek» nvltiftf frienda at th* roclrtail h<wr on Thura- ikii»! t \u\ Qv ODip-vAr3 35

40 r' r' r r c Detroit Viitor Mr. Jamca P. Welh, of Detroil, Mich-, arrived hut Monday ba Cari liudo to b<! the houib ufeat of Mr«> 1,:,:., ".. L»?t Wftdneaday aftenowi a<r»- " ' [L invited a group of frtpnda ta at tb< cockl&il hour to meet Mrt. W*lah, Mn, B ; ;;' turt buck rrum two weelia i» San Jadinfco, when? rii*;»penl two wwkk. recimtly rfwtved a letter from Mm Thomaa D, Gu(E, which contained new fit Caplaan Gulnn» wbfch wlu be of tntkrttt to their numflrou purcinado frlff&dt. CaptAto Gulnn, L'SN, who la now n Norfolk, Va-. n coinmand of 9 tr&mtnxwnit, ha» rccrttuy been nwut-ddiy the navy a Bronze Star a cltatkir fat meritorio'uflt ae ilu BC! tor ff'fffii-nt at NouiTMf? and tlic filanda- The Army hd» preh tin with nwdal and ribbon»hittpplne camewtga o of X>DC. TMl, wb»n Captain Guljua comma&d<k<3 Cavtt*?. Captain Gulan ia alao to reci*w» ttmi Pridcntifll Cttatj<m awardwl to Patr&t Wln< 1 for kt* worlt a( the beginning of the war. * m W6 5XLol p\. \.\ c Ch< -\A. S2.\l <AT)b VOT Charlie G. Browning ( h.iiltc G, Bro\\ni!'r a former Coroniido reident, died Oct. 7 a( El Oijoii Valtcy Hopital of hcan failiire. She wa 82. Mr. iio'i who wa born in Wahington, D.C., had lived in the San Diepo area until her death. She i iirvivecl by her couin, Maybcllc Pettit of Lapuna Beach. No memorial ervice are planned.! S 36

41 r' r' r r c SANDERSON'S SHOP NCREASES N SZE?iMUvu The ncwly-cxpandcd Sander- ro on' hop at C Avc., in the Crown Shop, will be open for the firt time an Wedneday, it wa announceif thi week by M : manager. The hop, \ffhich wa opened here jut 15 month ago, ha been enlarged to include the pace formerly occupied by the Coronado Chamber of Commerce office. The new facilitie have been remodeled to include paciou fitting room, a millinery corner and large tockroom aftd office pace, Mr. ;.>,; i tated. Wall of waxed natural birch and walnut are complemented with a new platic material reemblnig corrugated gla, in a oft yellow tone. for the decor. (alfech Honor (oronado Boy Frederick M. Trapnell Jr., on j of Mr EGlorietla Blvd.. ha been electod! to receive a tudent body honor certificate at the California ntitute of Technology, Paadena. He i one of 19 tudent recciving honor certificate for particiion in variou campu activitie. He erved a a ergeant in the U. S. Marine Corpa, K (cu. \ Young Trapnell 'Geh CalTech Key Paadena Frederic M. Trapnell Jr. of Coronado, a tudent at the California ntitute of Technology here, ha been choen to receive an honor key at the pring award aembly next month* Honor key are awarded to undergraduate who have made major contribution to campu life. Trapnell i the on of Mr. ly ] 1132 Gonetta Blvd., and i a ophomore majoring in phyic. U. LTT 37

42 r' r...,.lalfmmtto VSfrrvAW- touenl Swcvflin u j 1 CAPTAN...,....!- f m«4 BKNT CadamctiAl'f $# * PacWc Ft'k Awptirilwii Sqvadroo Fn». tswwi",-.:" ' :f.' Chaplain, lay leader B CD) meet to dicu goal Oezwe w\ u Chaplain and lay leaden cd Amphibiou Squadron Five and Landing Ship Squadron Five met at the Amphibiou Bae in Coronado in November to dicu goala of the Force Lay Leader Program. Called by Captain of 25 Sixth treet, th conference wa conducted by Lt Cmdr. E. R. Mcrtineatt. chaplaia for Squadi'on Five, 38

43 r.r, c c c l'mt (aplltn ir kipper Sfluadron Five vk. CAptaln SW Stxih 4UB»(, t''ii.irona4 >ii rti. ll»v<wi CaplN'n AlfxiUKler C. V<«aey. U< Mtttao(4 Ji'ywtw, M Ciamn-iindfi' : ( thf?actf<- F3«*l'G Ampftibiioua Sc}vudn?o Five Sfiptarnbe-r 4 T»H- <TiU;rig» trf KM-nyiyiFtd i<n-i'iti"rie»i wfre beed labcwrd the Bqua"lrtiD ruitathip. liw! iittrrli piin.flpurt U2$S Cah'art. <;:*psain Vn»M?y lua b n r»&m<>d CbM-'f of be Navai Sect on nt the MiliUkry AaUftc** Ad v l aery <.;tt:-up to Japa H» wdl \»KVV l.'fitnadoi Bho?ll3f for hla iww *t Ln (hr FBiF B*->t t!ttptflln?fl>orla to hu n«w cotiiniuiod from bi fumfff Ktwtt a» Cwnfypdicr ti? xndin. jdijvuibft &i. a poet w MB held ibce Octrbcir taurt yau" PrioT U* that CltjnAiR iiwvwt * Cummwting f>j(ucm: tit ihie ttaeii traaappn US lien rto. The ew Ai»ipM&,lcnfet Sq-jArtran nv» eun'iwndtt tf> * Ktl <?»dmhte of the Navrl Ai:»d<ci*ir *B4 }i4» bw»a i»w.»nd**dl U t iun of ftt»rit 1U[»dal an4 Mui Nav-y Cwn mculatio-n il.hbiwi wltii C"ml«!ilt VV't. Du.rlni WratW War», h«rved n th* df-aitfycr USS MgEffn and a CirririBEK.-* id, Gunnary OffkT? 'w th<- Kta(f *rf th<» t'&inirtiuiaci" Uetroycr Fare V. S. Pwdic Fleet. VlEC CoiW prenvvn r t * --.4 San Joe mayor flueri OT (ajvert ftobert C >aen-, mayar of San J<trt, C&furtila, c«itly W thf iurich-c&ct luct of Cppt. Comffiiandcr AwiphjbiOut 9qu»itfi<?r» Plvff. on fe-oard th* attack trttraipurt USS CNJveTt AOn- lutnch, Tbi hff»w flfti tditfrn on * hip'a taur by CApt W S. Midtfox, ramtnumllnt otftc»r (if the Cfll'rt Stayar DQCTT, who pfrpreicnted Sut Ji<- a; th? Piielfk' Awa C<m. Spycwt of Mayora n S»n Dwa. lftiaa bwn Aciti'» n ruit'iiwfiis ttnd Wtemati.iNnat munlcjpat wwk. n, the t?«(it»-«kr l)» liilffl<l»rf Eh» tnlcruitkmtfll l'd(iffm» o( Miiyor n'llo-isiand *ra waa ow rif ('f' 8»-}frct»d to tfwt C<?rm»ny u cuwl of the; Wiurt GerfaKft j u.t<rttiniil'r(, H» wu im ATtny C'&udtor-iitc]. lig-iw* ajnt duruyt WtirWt W(tt U lind 'WRa <dtv*ty wia»ffed ih th apprebeojutifn at Nad wuj' cru'nlnlilii. & PU. hw wid» aervicf: expct-iiwwe. Uug auiyor Mtid b» ks wfw t*< n on bewd an amphjb]* cu hip and w linpn-«n»«<3 wijth th< pompksnmy.nd op<mibalu'bb, of le llaghip. \hvq oic-har At4 \ ' i -»»' 1 < ( 39

44 r,- r. r c dpi. Colemtft telfew FrMk Wiairf Cl»il ' 1'-'"- 11K j Cloflttf bou)<r»»»d, Coroifiiu. tftitvfs C»p>. Frank Wluaiit, 1» AUa'-tilu btl3»r*rtl. t» cfal»( t! *Ufl t<i Vie* Adinirt John Sylviftcr, i*omraa(id»t <?T thtf!» ciltr. Dwt AivipttlhKitu Fore*. «( CvwvMta, MoBitay. Jui'a t Captain Wlrunt, t>o h.u wn-ml M (;l,l*( Sta?f lt<-v Jum. ;»«, will *»!.-j;i»«du»>«* M thr nrw <'t.imnift-idirt» fltllcer ; d-x Sau>! Am-r.uc-tion >»p<t. Concwrf, C-«Ufatnf H< u> wffu knowti in the Cw&nadr..rt* tw?>li nctiv* pttrt.ii*iptiiwft in tfcf Coroc;N<t<> UWJy!fl<u? in which h«r*;mlly fervfd ii» prnl.j*nt C*p<«tn n-ptirtad Ui *»taft th le&ruary ot Uila yew awiirtiinl chif orf ktuk for <?pcra< t>h< lie luu becu c*>mrniift*l!iig oft* CT?* af l N<vd; Amfnunitior Qc. pol. l>*hu, T H. fplttn <il tha»tu<li (rxkjkirt Hcn»-f>, n»n nrtadnr Tmtyort &i,vi»*wti SK and Anipht1?K>u» S<t<A»rfroti Vvv C*pt»<n VM iinirfu l fra* th* Swt Ar«d«m», clai itf la.)* «*A iitn"i-> t* llutlbl y<-i :n th*1 Navy amurd U*» baultnhttxi Niwi riwnr*.. Uunn» Wcr:ii Ww tl. :-.»rvm ui w»i>l< «iln>)>»n Mr (init <*<irtnn;x*tk1»*t? tfc<-iftiuttruyr H.rt Ctifrfrft wrffttf A lt:f* O-jn of?.*».>*»«. unu JT.U <ry, 1141 «Kl wft -inttalollt ftwt- Tt-rt ofui iai br ti»<r < ( (,'am »(!«"iuinc* l''cr(». Ptlflc n«l 1.1 w» H» Niw»»»< tv fttrvpi-t PtCV Squadron T)»r»- *«'.'.hhf >tf<( OifA<*r. * Cfrtmbw. H1 wi (<«r <>N fwkt ht-vt yr* he.wt Wftkii( tfc» ffiiivr' A?TA<M W.6. M boob filveft library bonorliiff Jame MeNabofi PTWO-. a< -A* Uf Mnn t. UfUmtr-v, huv» K-an't'ifU* taij [(n-n» tn.t.ki» tlx CututUiSft t*[iuf l-'wiff :ft M» >t.?ah»y, JBar.f,-t at<p t'.t- (hkt B»B»(('«*' ivetr n kt»-'*<i)!' ot nr»'»<:a*i.', tt'wu"'.-i'ft.nr.uy»j{ i ftiiwlwn (.l-ti'a-.na' d«l-cj.:(niict;t fti>t*, [ A4 tm-lud- fxnf t:t*«yid, «<»<fd lut 4u«y Ww»«wl»lii<;»'waf.'ioK wdil t-unl. frwiiit»f» Oriiu Kavl AB»-t J.&l*'cU.»a at t'it i.a«awfete t1 \pttl Cove c V\y r Flower Show conimihee guet at brunch meeting Mr. Gregory Panaw<k, chairman of the Table An-angement ection of the Coronado Flower Sfaftw ntftrtaintd hfr oo-cluiurman and committee women at a brunch, February 17. at 1 a.m.. in her new home at 731 Country Club Lane. The ladie took thi opportunity to formulate plan for their ection in the forthcoming Flower Show to be held April 12 and 13. Mr. Mark E. Dennett will a- urt a co-chairman. The committee member include Mme. -i- ;-; 1 Royal L. Rutter, Charle W. Amo. Edwin Schadewald, Elliot Andrew. Oliver Coanpton, Edward Hearn, frank Lowe, Paul Cogrove, Frank M1ler. Joeph Pac, Harry Vice. Robert Merrick, Fred Snyder, Prank Gooding, Leonard Smith and Theodore Balea. \ e- Cfl\N gely \f 4

45 r r' r' TB drive ucce The 1964 Chritma Seal cam» paign cloed exactly $5,33.22 aliead of the previoiu campaign. Dr. Coronado area chairman, reported. Receipt were only $ behind i959, the mot productive year to date. The campaign cloed March 31, t)otlar \U, Mv iif Chamber of Commerce 1968 Officer Ooo t. McttV(1 c < "?<!»* OfWCCt nilud* chwf h. f pnlf (< ««nih«>» *>»>««iui Vin«B«Vt<ii )h»»*dw<. Mn Mary K<y fwff, ; wh* (wttiatlt <ftd Aftrrr will bo V.NH*» ud«nl, M. i<d Vlw. )M»*< l>t ><» nu-t o< J»» Mwitlon Nl»nu*nr. Un»»«ll*U«far pitlur. J»h>i Huf- g hit Ntk Vi«<»»*. to<. nn iiihniu. rtt. HMmw.»»H«> )«, ini-t. hf g ll ult 4aM3t* ; llatiw» l>mn wh b» M rtf CCC Hfff S '-' " " 119- Ptu'B fc c K.-;*.,;.A.. ''mfcib.ak,-',',.. r C>\> (>\L fflrer Beam :.S1 1 wi " SUvur BVW, A njitioawl Vayl, WM jcoaferrtd on 14 County &oy Seouta of Anierlfta tender at their SUver Beaver Dinner. A capacity crowd of 3.- leader and their wive witneaaed the preaentation at the Comniunity Concoure. Recipient! of the high honor ncluded Dr. of Coronado. 41

46 r' r ( Or Dili named hopital chief of taff it.l.: rm. < * tan?»,* talb*fcl - fhife* 2 t&d»»* n.»i «*Hr,.:»«U.J.*., ( n.ih.m-lnlttu!» ).-- nittf» 1: '.'" -f '. ' " l". l*»!* +X rlty d 1<1C«J M(1UU< U 'S*'.'.. f-lifiw *»"'*v*-» ':»*»»»»<»)" * <ii>a a t-hif»ia.,',fn,,a k «*n»*- bt ii*,,, x-uit«a toftr hmii i.. > «.r.l-':'<'' tld :.l in Wlliuu. urt > mt rf...-!!am* iiu>cjt.:r\ l*uam«u*fsll «M«flM«iMu ±«tv.: "'*1 - ;»1( Uo-ai'i'iK!' 'lllimum't. &K? i **lr'r:wat>«>: i*t?jit tv 'A*»ai»A& :i X DUE tl at "- TH-'"W ~,,.,< au»»:ri a* twi Mbu -» *1 UJ k-.*ilr3*l 1. A«',,;:-';,;< wh'»'":«u» i'"r XJ*..y. " >Tm-,.» "- -*. Vr*tl! WE*r! M: '"tr.:fi * t'-~1t-.i.."w..*li: S'd. ic>l<l»at** :"r»*«?»»:; m b> «*'*" 'T<r»*f * " ":*lt x Hu «* i*-v ivf5;..' _?. <_? _ *t-»r!i!» 'H«"*'.'<" " "» rt»":<''': l"wrm"-r '*'-r w< v <-j-v» '. Crown City Mariner hot An E'-'ening with Rev. Wactaty',«:,«'- '' CSw"'.-'- «*WiKt *"t SiraU*:»»:*- -tfa* k.a'3 -fc'kt - " M iwrry.l A* wi<{»...»i,.' K ' fc.j.l.»>.» a t.t.fci lla ffii '-V. nwa- "l *< "»AM». i. a r <nt wry iu>ti<<)i iiin tt.--u.bn :': «*i»>v:» r-:tlkhcs3> :tk»- )»< :" W* l <,". iin*.:! fc.x iwr*i»fe?uiu*«h..<-;k:nrjca«mn j '." r<<nu t; m dii» 'frnii iu ikarji ' ' tf xri. r»lw. ':' nfmwm < :T'"tUi litt(d*-, * ' -ii vvw bonix a Tflit tmmxl tat?».irl >l>l,-, ijii,!»utlli if, «-i»" l»'ut-.3a*a > ) l-evf i <*ud t? ; > Kf t? T<fcid «n.i U-..11 jfiti, - «n.rff W.TV- U< i. «('«r>l».<t U --T.r.-taar.TKjE.i, ; ;* ll»r -!iv»f..1 >» Alt-m wwfen-l M vla-at rait. <jid 4,{i nr--j -?."i '- g >:l.jw " gj@31. lll n-'fi &,,. ;» «* '>'!«S'Nt.-f...a.7 tt FAt.fc *- ). Fl»«lh» <n.'! t -»'* 1W *W»-! *»»<l "* ttaii'l»< *~ it? *<» <a < <> ii-ij- a vuw-f, v t.. fr.-rii ittaati :iwt <* * fliif )' ifc»»»*a»»»**..h-n1e<l Or, Samb$ to peak to Sabred Heart PTQ P';Jtei8.***-W *'!- W'*> an'ur u,!--l""ll'>«;<»».»-»<» t ii»iijr»»«tv»» -,11)1 taant <)fr4 Utrr.wna-y* *lt! '»rnta tvff E iiatnii-»rnm( *.ittuiu«;(»ym»n» 3'S -, 'S,,W.i«iNi»;.awfS«i». T*.*l, - il«fa«ud *( -,»rt x < u4 lto»»«<ptl» l»,'ii»n l-i 'fadlk h» :;.'ac 'ith.nt*i»i y<ir. -t-to-.r» i f<<».-:«> i» «.»t,w»: :-](*n*'lbnt <(<fca_>li.fct r.tf.i i. 1C 1. <. «aii«c.».!' <4"<.»»Ut f»ftn»-*» fviit*f OFrt*»*m < imiuti lit &-»-» -u> (uiu'». '«r Bai»u!-««hf t.vsffimf <int..'?nk"» wiaf tm it.--<*-«m -W-Wtt* -t» r Sf' ii %-< iiwiin air*>ai»aj-f crpuif* Ol< \\L \ov-v Dr. DoTiaSd Dili elected 5 medical chief <rf taff Dr. ha been mlnllnt a» rrxxairfll chkfof rtaff.< Vl ;* rt.-; i fr Dr.,k ' 1. il.l -.. AiLi. t toroniuilo Hopital, niccwdtng Dr. Jo-Kph Ewing, Thi u th< third time Di. -i.. ha been clw,1«t to head actmtie»,''' the medical naif. >r. ~ " h» aiw tcn'cd a* chief of family pra;iii:t at Coronado lliwpial, lie ftr»t vamc in 'oronado a a Na'y flithi ii.igcon. aftd hu tem m pm<tticc here for the paia t»o d<c*<le'». H< *u (radinlcd f'am Jeffcrwn Medic*! C<»tlcgc in Phil*<l<lphii. :y;;' -.ff... + ll THF? Y>otrvp t>vl \\} \f[( 42

47 _r r Porhzo Oti-L hffl} W3 Coronado Hopital announce new board of director,t n w h,». a aactan» * ' TM *i 1 <4 *( **w laaim W»<»>*! <fvf (.>*" Fr*»l w p-n i»*nw( '*»(» * <l;<*vwt» r kurwl > p(f >»i.ulk.<» f»»»h*t tl»» «tn.f. >ir.»<yntfo <'uht.u*nn3»» y» k T*w< * n»< i><«*f< t. Tie.Ubut<»'*«M<«U Afn * * < <«i : Jllltt.»<» *r-r-* t- «*t lh*i»inn- ik M* wri a* ht*f<» w* *» rin to a f 'BTrfNA' Bptri hlu Bf *. < inil+i Wl»»r«<* wx»«w-. i*»nk»wn»u* pirt*- NK <»> >-».** irwrnf >**h>n :V»;.*i <"Di» t-witnin an. <dn >* *» kt»< f fw ti.lm»*i*o. *. t»»»n-<l» (>a«r>*»rf k*t» *»m>»»* K» U*i<. *- '<-i N» *»»*»*». *ti«t * HtU (»*»» W- kit** tb< N*. Ll. -l * >n«.th»»?» ht KrtBnti.Nl l.* <tfcl»». y«a* 1 W MW. L C ***» l<*w* t** r--uh ' *< :'-'>.l.)3«*ltut>, Ut.tutU* *N*u. (wa» Ai *»<wab M!. >*u PNM r«r - t#t lit.»t.;rtnj ihqn1»<»r 'O)»WN» ff Uw«l»»«n<liifKntf*.oN fu*»*.<ca w *r»a *<» *»ifa"w Ma K*. i wk >tl to»*» a» nn»-kj h* > n<wc«!kww NN. ttici *' uon»»», V t. KltN f. hlji.-nrt.r.'l. rttoi r*t *v-t "M N «>.,r..!u'» -(.h»-.nt.o. n;». nuw»«(«n» *N *< i~- "-* «w;»»' «!»~?*, -'i Kiiin»i-f*#i» >»i.t,'l*wn» ****»* WNW<»»* 'iwwwf 'S-. hd -htnu» -*' -»»* WWt-.U*.Wt,» >» <» urf nm U 11.. ('. NN'rftefc;" -rf **WUWArtnamnN TfW <*if» W»N»» K U.w'M -<*-t.u»»«a, ** ff ;ft.' mfv*'-, <»«<*( mil *»» >fc»«nnrt *u *»,» M x.--**» *» j* tdwifcnr.tm- -i<r<,,.»a- M-»».G Hfri*)»W;,N( tww. *r *b»., *«< *d *»N, i * twt>w»<.- :lnwt.«r»«<.thm.mt»no»;< M»» n)l«?(ll N,:,,,.,.-,.,:, :l»'t»»unu'"~"'.' tlw.nn><'*n>p*wtmlli**ff ;to<#<>«uw.»rf*p(w* i»,n»«~-~ >.«u, >.»,<-- >»; 3l>UllKfOr»t».;-?'"T "":-.-., *i.i>».i»*».»<n>».-::"*t<.t»«>ib«* MW rua'»«,-«., ( «i;'i«'-s>t>>< *Kit*> --.;' Wxmn * (i. r «t «>n.y*n n;;.lluii.i'n ' a Pb*4At t>i.l- Aoy- -2 >T c <»>Ufat.VWM*t.<< tnlnwwrt 'k R 1 *ar - (* =3 i < L- t»r MhtjjBCBbiidthcltotaniCtOodliniAwafdlaotnltoiarv PKM.tdent Dari Gciuler. Subnutle4 photo ;-e=.. :.:-. :--_. _tf 43

48 . r G 6 1 <SCAJ p»<lt-l PeZt>' o \-? Gerald Sch wart:, f limy tifnc Cornnado n-tiient. C>i)iti>mi.i n.ilive..iiit) Wi>ri(< W-ir Tr S N;V\ VctCtJ. p.lsm'it p<...l-llltl\ in hi>.»lffp i>n X-i cnihcr "th He <*;i-. ninety t'lvc yc.tr-' i>iif.init hi*. xpini u ;t' a'ily» ii)<>\c rn lie ) > -iirvim-il h'> hi--»t(i: tsec CorcmaJJeweC )'i>ur Jewelry Ciintillant Kcpitj. AppraiaJ, Retringlnji. Walch Rtpiiln.. Cutom D<ie"«!d.lf*»clQ (;rcs Talker M9-SOT.7.U P.O. lhi\ funuk. (»nmad«> V.!17S ('.fjnor. hi<. d.iufhlcr Nii.ki. <ni htt\. tcp-min ' t'hriliiphur.ind RKhiinl. h> nuinct"u'.,.tyiult.'hitttreii, yrrai i;t.inti>.hiftlri."ii. yrc.il i:ri;4t L'r.iiukhilitien..inil hv ciiunt lr>' riciid- iinil rel.itim.' Ovct thr oiuic iil hl nine plu iti.v.iilf on canh hi.m.\»d pli\)iiih.'nt<.inil fpcrifiii.t.-'. *viv myii.iil und rcwidini; Ht 4.in ;)Mil tr;i\rlcr iind ptiri'.kiiin..1 f'twctitagaibavaaaimw + «American Heart A>aa!iun T-y-~i i" i.-::". y-i <-'l~.*.t piiiiid Niiv. m.iii i.tmnu tn thi South r'li-iti*..it.1 tiiitr f.ttrn \nirrk.i lrul> iliil full i>n it'> j.'rf.ilrl rtfiicr.iiiiin. >iiid he u.i.1 <uc i.i x.dil hi!-.iih'>timil * ith ittlfir'.l thf-'u'hrui C.ilttrrni.1 lit' kt.i a tin mf hilhynil.intl i. unti:; p.uciit uith 11 quiet \ciif "i huinur uix).1 *iinitt'rtiill\ ubinlivi; iiultinik rn lllc '. Ki"thlllti>;'> Ki; h»iu.in jhiltt) to put ; diik' <m vour t.x.f or biiiil' ir;u<tii Miur L'vc lit- will hr iilim.d.tful lovctl l>\ ihiim; whrktii.* hni hi.l. nil in.iut lik.-iin', itnu niiiu hf. pirit kill M- oil,-\ inciikio.tl -.cnkc u.u-- hekt -it Mtr.ini.il \.t»iim.il(.'i;ii><-lcr> fft 'fck.riiht'r :?>lt> licie ti >i» lah! '.ii n">t ( 44

49 Branch :4,Uer :DATU r r Comment; r'r Station d :DBA9 r " -\ RECORDNG REQUESTED BY: Ffdeiity National Title 5f D reqo AND WHEN RECORDED MAL. TO; Oren Shaffer and Evelyne Shaffer 1633 Galleon Drive Naple, FL 3412 i DOC# iitiflijiiiiniiiiiiiiiijiimifflflumiiikimimmihii May 1, 217 9;2&AM OFFCAL RECORDS Ernet J. Dronenburg, Jr,, SAN DEGO COUNTY RECORDER FEES; $2,578.5 PCOR: YES PAGES: 3 Title Order No.: AP#: THS SPACE FOR RECORDER'S USE ONLY: Ecrow No.: GRANT DEED THE UNDERSGNED GRANTOR(S) DECLARE(S5 DOCUMENTARY TRANSFER TAX i $2,557.5 [X] computed on full value of property conveyed, or [ j eomputed on fuli value le value of lien or encumbrance remaining at time of ale, ( ] Unincorporated area [X] CityofCoronadoAND FOR A VALUABLE CONSDERATON, receipt of which hereby acknowledged, Nick! P. Troutman, Trutee of The Schwartz Family Trut datd October 14, 213,Suwivor' TrutTrut A, a to an undivided % interet and Nicki P. Troutman, Trutee of The Schwartz Family Trut dated October 14,213, Bypa TrutTrut B, a to an undivided % interet, a tenant in common hereby GRANT() to: Oren Q. Shaffer and Evelyne Shaffer, Trutee of The Oren G. Shaffer 212 Spoual Etate Reduction Trut dated December 26, 212 a to an undivided 5% nteret and Evelyne Shaffer and Oren G. Shaffer, Trutee of The Evelyne Shatter 212 Etate Reduction Trut dated December 26,212 a toan yndlvlded 5% nteret the real property in the City ofcoronado, County of San Diego, State ofcalifomia, decribed a: Ail of Lot 13 and that portion of Lot 12 in Block 78 of Coronado Beach South land, according to Map thereof No (ee attached legal; Exhibit A) Alo Known a: 1132 Glorietta Bivd, Coronado, CA DATED: April 24, 217 Signature Page attached hereto and made a part hereof MAL TAX STATEMENTS TO PARTi' SHOWN BELOW; F NO PARPi' SHOWN, MAL AS SHOWN ABOVE: u SAN DEGO,CA Docuinent: DD Page 1 of 3 Printed on :24:18 PM 45

50 Branch :4,Uer ;DATU r' n Comment: Station d ;DBA9 \ Title Order No.: Ecrow No,: AP#: SGNATURE PAGE Title of Document: GRANT DEED Date of Document: April 24, 217 The Schwarfcz Family Trut Dated October 14, 213, Bypa TrutTrut B And The Schwartz Family Trut dated October 14, 213, Survivor' Trutf Trut A By: Nicki P. Troutmari, Trutee :am> in ACKNOWLEDGMENT A notary public or other officer completing thi certificate verifie only the dentity of the ndividual who igned the document to which thi certificatb i attached, and not the truthfulne, accuracy, or validity of that document. STATE OF CALFORNA COUNPOF on.i-1-r before me, :< Lrel A Notary Public peronally appeared kjki''cp.trn(atmal' who proved to-me on the bai of atifactory evidence to be the eeian(} whoe pame() jgare uberibed to the within intrument and acknowledged to me that hegtethey executed the ame n hihertheir authorized Hy(ie), and that by hitiejytheir gnaty("e() on the intrument the eon(), or the entity upon behalf of which thej!.ei;,sqn() acted, executed the ntrument. certify under PENALTY OF PERJURY under the law of the State of California that the foregoing paragraph i true and correct. WTNESS my hand and official eal. Signature (Sea!) % NCHOLAS WARD Commiion iis( Notary Public - California Butte County My Gomm. Expire Mar 4, 22 SAN DBOO,CA Document; DD Page 2 of 3 Printed oil :24:19 PM 46

51 Branch :4,Uer :DATU r p Coinment: r r- Station d ;DBA9 r ] FRBUMrNARY REPORT YOURREFERBNCE: Fidelity National Title Company ORDER NO,; 91S43-S&2-SD1.DS EXHBT A LEGAL DESCRPTON THE LAND REFERRED TO HBREN BBLOW S STUATED W THE CTY OP CORONADO, COUNTY OP SAN DEGO, STATE OF CALFORNA. AND S DESCRBED AS FOLLOWS: ALL OP LOT 13 AND THAT PORTON OF LOT 12, N BLOCK 78 OF CORONA.DO BEACH SOUTH!SLAND, N THE ary OF CQRONADO, COUNTY QF SAN DEOO, STATE OF CALORNA, ACCORDNG TO MAP THEREOF NO, 376, PLED N THE OFFCE OF THE COUNn REC.ORDER OF SAN DEGO COUNTY, NOVEMBER 12,1886, BOUNDED AND DESCRBED AS FOLLOWS: BEQNN-NO AT THE MOST SOUTHERLY CORNER OP SAD LOT 12; T1ENCE NORTH 65 39' EAST ALONG THE SOUTHEASTERLY LNE OP SAD LOT 12, A DSTANCE OF FEET; THENCE NORTH 24 21' WEST A DSTANCE OP 1.82 FEET; THENCE SOUTH 65 46' 3" WEST A DSTANCE OF FEET TO A PONT N THE SOUTOWESTER.Y LNE OP SAD LOT 12; THENCE 8UTO 24 21' FAST ALONG SAD SOUTHWESTERLY LNE OF LOT 12 A DSTANCE OF 2.2 FEET TO THE PQNT OF BEQNNNO. APN: c u CLTA PrctimiDaiy Report'Form - Modified (11176) Page 3 SAN D]EGG,CA Document: DD Page 3 of 3 Printed on :24:19 PM 47

52 Attachment C - Photograph Pleae provide the following item a Attachment C: Hitorical photograph (if available) Current color photograph r., How do prepare thi Attachment? Hitorical photograph- Provide copie of any hitorical photograph of the property and notate each photograph with a date and addre. Hitorical photograph hould be provided in print at full ize, and canned ajpg document and provided to taff on a cd, flah drive, or ed to tolen@coronado.ca.u Note that mut be le than 1 mb. The following reource hould be earched for hitorical photograph: Coronado Hitorical Aociation, 11 Orange Avenue, Coronado. (Archived print record of hitoric permit) Call for appointment (619) San Diego Hitory Center Archive El Prado, in Balboa Park (baement level) Call archive for hour (619) Previou property owner - f reachable, previou property owner can be great reource for photograph and hitory of a property. California Digital Newpaper Collection -Coronado' hitoric newpaper include: Coronado Citizen ( ) Coronado Compa ( ) Coronado Eagle and Journal ( ) Coronado Eagle ( ) Coronado Mercury ( ) Coronado Saturday Night (1922) Coronado Tent City Daily Program (193) El Patio ( ) Thee newpaper are available online at and are earchable by name or other earch term. Pleae include copie of all relevant hitorical photograph of the property if any are found. Current color photograph - Provide current color photograph of the treet view of the property, and each exterior elevation of all tructure on the property. nclude thee photograph in print a well a digitally a jpg file on a CD, flah drive, or ed to tolen@coronado.ca.u Note that mut be le than 1 mb. 48

53 r.-., -r Sii -; " A, >»..» tf. m w * ; a -,. 1 a "-': i f» r. r' A" -? y?.» - * -..: :is r K View 1 ;»\ < K?: : ft u i SSSSaSW i 7. m F: "32!! ii View 2 \iai r.",>.w-r*i 49

54 r r' -mm.; t. t ::.' i :$ i JP *"< t.,;? ;? 1.' i. ;?'ft > <!>< m fi i- '. K a%. h: X t >'..( 'rv At & Pi 1; i u.i-1..._ View 3 r.1. li. t & ffi V." :i!'i-a \.ff ' 1 pi ;r-.%l! ;.'l G'ir'l %,i. A 1- -:i li:!ll M. r 1R!?S't%';i Jl i'.- fc a fr y.,;"m! e.vi.'i!''m. Sil» P%1 < ". :' y 'm r \: AS! i? " i-i <a,< m % -,< ". ~,' 'M 3 ; ;'!» m u View 4 5

55 r r 1a ~;,ff....f.f-.- YV» r < > '' y''.*..'t' i;?-! <y at *' «f: m f *: 2. % -'' t»p v. %;;;. f w '., f. <t & <1'? %~ Mfy ;«ip -'» & a ViewS K» ;. 'w «.e iw ti i-ma ac rka p m " t », :? - «m «*..< "- - ' -< - - -"' gu t»-" - ;'5. WSK % L- View6 51

56 r r' r? \ a. -:-<5 <. -.<;'" "< r.? m». \ tl i» 'H c <.' View 7 v!, "' - ; Tr M a. i ::-1!-,,;; "%i,t,'? ' fc.».*. <; r ). c ViewS ',' Vii *; i :?»r 52

57 r- r" < J- k? *»- 7 : a W;?' W»l r-?» -a; fc y;?n?;1-i N. w. C-- -~~ P-.». fe U! r TW *3 B i«. M i;t? w '- <' View 9 t < <i! y -T-i r > - 8 -" '.12 f <. <& "1<" '\;.,.' w<?*i*. ". "> t3.%;... w "K ". :- r. u View 1 53

58 Attachment D - Deignation Criteria Analyi Pleae provide the following item a Attachment D: Deignation criteria analyi How do prepare thi Attachment? Deignation criteria analyi - Provide a complete analyi of the reource under tudy per each of the Hitoric Deignation Criteria. ndicate whether the reource meet or doe not meet each of the deignation criteria, and reference upporting documentation dicovered through reearch conducted in aociation with Attachment A, B, and C. Pleae conult the City' adopted Hitoric Deignation Criteria Guideline, available at City Hall and on our webite at for aitance in applying the deignation criteria. Criterion A - t exemplifie or reflect Special Element of the City' military, cultural, ocial, economic, political, aethetic, engineering, or architectural hitory Reearch that i helpful in determining whether a reource i hitorically ignificant under Criterion A include, but i not limited to: Contruction Hitory Ownerhip and Occupant Hitory Newpaper Reearch Hitoric Photograph Criterion B t i identified with a peron() or an event() ignificant in local. State or national hitory Reearch that i helpful in determining whether a reource i hitorically ignificant under Criterion B include, but i not limited to: Notice of Completion Ownerhip and Occupant Hitory Newpaper Reearch Criterion C t poee ditinctive characteritic of an architectural tyle, and i valuable for the tudy of a type, period, or method of contruction and ha not been ubtantially altered Reearch that i helpful in determining whether a reource i hitorically ignificant under Criterion C include, but i not limited to: Architectural Decription Site Plan Contruction Hitory Reidential Building Record Hitoric and Current Photograph Criterion D t i repreentative of the notable work of a builder, deigner, architect, artian or landcape profeional. Reearch that i helpful in determining whether a reource i hitorically ignificant under Criterion D include, but i not limited to: Architectural Decription Contruction Hitory Reidential Building Record Hitoric and Current Photograph nformation on architect, builder, or other aociated profeional 54

59 n n 1132GloriettaBlvd. Coronado, CA APN# Lot: 13 Block: 78 Map: 376 Hitoric Report Glorietta Boulevard CRTERA EVALUATON Criterion A: Through our reearch on the property, we were unable to any ignificant evidence that the home erved a a pecial element of the City' pat, including apect relating to military, cultural, ocial, political, aethetic, or engineering. The home went through an extenive additionremodel in 1983 that completely changed the original layout, aethetic and volume of the original dwelling. A a reult of the lack of information, it i our concluion that the property doe not meet Criterion A. Criterion B: The name lited above in the chain of title have been reearched through the following ource: California Hitorical Reource nventory Data Bae Journal of San Diego Hitory Biography & Genealogy Mater ndex City of Coronado Newpaper archive Name that came back with reult: Earl Brix: o Coronado Eagle and Journal, No.6, Feb Well known Aviator Retire (See Newpaper article attached) o Coronado Eagle and Journal, No. 17, 27 April Second Annual Dog Show Score hi it (See Newpaper article attached) Martha Brix: Coronado Eagle and Journal, No. 36, 7 September Bulldog Win Many Honor at Show (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, No. 46, 15 November Obituary (See Newpaper article attached) Mile R. Browning: o Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 17, 29 April Captain Mile Browning Awarded Navy Medal. (See Newpaper article attached) 55

60 n n Charlie G. Browning: Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 46, 14 November 1935-Bridge Luncheon. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 22, June Dinner Party Honor Capt. And Mr. E.C. Ewen. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 42, 21 October 1943-Service Familie Entertaining. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 17, 26 April Detroit Viitor. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 41, 13 October Obituary. (See Newpaper article attached) Mary B. Farrell: Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 2, 25 May Sanderon' Shop ncreae in Size. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 19, 7 May CALTEChl Honor Coronado Boy. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 16, 22 April 1954-Young Trapnell Get CALTEChl Key. (See Newpaper article attached) Walter_D, Coleman: Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 37, 12 September Captain Walter D Coleman Named new commander of the Pacific Fleet' Amphibiou Squad Five. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 51, 119 December 1957-Chaplain, lay leader meet to dicu goal. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 37, 12 September Captain Coleman kipper Amphib Squadron Five. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 48, 28 November San Joe Mayor guet on Calvert. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 25, 19 June 1958-Capt. Coleman relieve Frank Winant. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 8, 2 February Flower Show committee guet at brunch meeting. (See Newpaper article attached) Donald M. Dill: Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 15,15 April TB drive ucce. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 47, 23 November Chamber of Commerce 1968 Officer (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 6, 11 February Dr. Dill i A Silver Beaver (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 11, 15 March Dr. Dili named hopital chief of taff. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 5, 3 January Dr. Donald Dill elected medical chief of taff. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 16, 22 April Coronado Hopital announce new board of director. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 12, 21 March 27 - Dr. Donald M. Dill received the Rotary Good Egg Award from Rotary Preident Dan Genler. (See Newpaper article attached) 56

61 n n Gerald M. Schwartz: o Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 51, 18 December Obituary. (See Newpaper article attached) The information available pertaining to the lit of owneroccu pant of the dwelling doe not how a valid connection to a ignificant peron or event of local, State or National hlitory. Therefore, we have concluded that the property i not hitorically ignificant per Criterion B. Criterion C: Reearch how that the exiting dwelling on the property ha been ignificantly altered from it original deign. Alteration include an extenive additionremodel in 1983 that changed the front, ide and rear elevation. All the window and door have been replaced. The altered deign doe not poe ditinctive characteritic of any ignificant architectural tyle and it doe not hold any tudy value. For thee reaon, it i our concluion that the home doe not atify Criterion C. Criterion D: Reearch ource: Coronado Hitorical Aociation, San Diego Hitory Center The original builder Chri A. Cogrove wa conidered a mater builder and ignificant land developer in San Diego County during the pot-world War 194' and 195' eatern expanion of the City of San Diego. n hi 65-year career, he wa a builder of over 3, home and commercial propertie in Point Loma, College Height, Talmadge, Rolando, Cogrove Height, Kenington, Coronado, La Mea, Alpine, Rancho Santa Fe, Lo Angele, and Palm Spring. Cogrove ha three home with hitoric deignation in the city of San Diego and Coronado. There aren't any ignificant characteritic remaining from the original home built by Cogrove at 1132 Glorietta Blvd. due to the extenive alteration to the original tructure during the major remodeladdition in Alo, no record of a project architect, deigner, artian, or landcape architect wa uncovered with our reearch. Furthermore, the property wa not lited on the Source Point Coronado Hitoric Reource nventory. There weren't any image or record of any ignificance related to the property. For thee reaon, it i our concluion that the property i not hitorically ignificant under Criterion D. 57

62 SANBORN MAPS Glorietta Boulevard n Attachment 3 \ \ G»» : "4 y \ { 1132 Glorietta Boulevard >. 78 Ny N?v \ (» 7 \ 1132 Glorietta Boulevard -1988» N <. \.,»'<» 11 «S 1132 Glorietta Boulevard

63 Captain Mile and Charlie Browning, reidence r California, Voter Regitration, for Charlie G Browning San Diego County > 194 > Roll 27 'trouniiik, Mr. Charlie (;., t:tk (.lot iftta lllvd., Hxv. No. r' -1{ w~"r \ U.S. City Directorie, Califbnua > San Diego > 1941 > San Diego, California, City Directory, 194J Wanda maid 575 A a'v Browning Mile (Charle) USN hll38 Glorietta ; 1. California, Voter Regitration, for Charlie G Browning San Diego County > 1942 > Roll 3 Browning. Mr. Charlie G., 113«Glorlcttn Blvd., Hw. No. U.S. City Directorie, for Charlie G Browning California > Coronado > 1944 > Coronado, California, City Directory, 1944 Browning Charlie G Mr lwn hll38 Glorletta blvd ' 59

64 fvs -> f» i 3 i»-:s is S*',,<:j.\ ( y,t«ay Kr-d cca L»» ->* M er W;*c. >.'<«ro*aiod» -t'.h'ai.'iy Oti- 'oiacu; <c? k.'.-"~:'' Tliffi. \w i. - S. tll y?»i ; "P 3 J p ~ t 3 S88?'.'.' < -. Q~ ; ~. 3 «a 2. S hi B El t » U li!tt t it ; T T- n [ J '.b-l.j '! fct? i ta in* t " \ 8 3k y i v i: rp- -i -<r Ul i--vi ); t- d 1-1 r i S =11»1» i a w 3 k» < < t _.L S2.B ' rf & K ( -- f3 ":,\ 3 f t? '»...,.. u,- + tt+,'; "* r \ u is g 1 r. - ~-.,,-..<,.-. w v L.. E.; n R ;i»< -c > " < ' V- 1L t LU ,-an M u 4? T.... a 21!( a 4.U. c- _J KUU a ' v= i t?»t ri <1 r< t <v <i -- >«t ;»- t-:- 4 t-., ' 4- L~. <- 1 lt(? f\\ { 1 1\. L-J i» n! H v-1r"-1 "? T". i L.. J u. "~"~J\: u St'? \ < illii ' «6 a li»

65 \ «: r ; t» t \» -» S*'.f':! 9(»ry icffu Ka*ff f»w * -:: ;*.'» -~.»» k»» r-k r< VWi-"3W.-*«S»ye---r-'r,.-, 5.:<- - w v.-4 j. - ' -r -.f--'.d i lift Stii V».i«, m',<.? < '..":. -.-a.-.t..a. -:-"'E""'""-;..':i'5] 'a.wttw.iiu'-.l. 'SlflWS'WSift «nj.-<r_ -a*. r'ka.i.racw.--twuu <».. -i;y - - -< ~ ;,., - +-,.;«- + ; t w i ' -±-?-..-. i.-. J-_.-<"'' ' ".«.>-- ".r"-' f' t--y-+ -i i lfcl!s '-;-'-f2'-»l.-t.. il --ti"lgla": T ii i} i! 'Ei'Sr i»-» -LL FHT- yt F. _- f< v* Tff»..F.il:'<r'<.] i. "'i't-j-;' >- S' 4 *'!L_.l)t " '».' 7 & 'L. 3 v 3 i S - S '" 1. g. :.<-'.,»--.-.i ',T--«'.< -«3. <.5'.' ox o3l j,l S 5, Ui : SM! 13; ; --a- -JT- * ;1 - J _. '.-.'. li 'U.? -'r ] - i. : t Ji 1 S_1_. 'w ' t"''""f~:vr'' al'o UJ-- ~- J* «-. «i.,.:? fl i.«r.».!tk: -"-'!,' -'<?,... ; - ', d.--.f. <- '-.» i,. >. ;. '... ',-.'.>.. ' -, '- - ra-"> l-l >.,<-, * <-,.. ii. - S' r-,:c. Klff i _ H% t" Lit] '"fd~ : li i.. t ija.'l & ; il-:. > ;1 il u ' --S-t-'- T ;1 1 i.!!!"9 i » -.p. SSS -\ W ill -fr-l -' ; -»: ii TSC7v~ScKw36.? m. f ft - c E e > *.! A y.-.- -?.,-? -4-, -fv,»-w" t -.:. -.«"i,r-n-.s ' '-'' ffr«-.»".s-»*,»;'. ; -..: ?K 61

66 Attachment GloriettaBlvd. Coronado, CA APN# Lot: 13 Block: 78 Map: 376 Hitoric Report Glorietta Boulevard CRTERA EVALUATON Criterion A: Through our reearch on the property, we were unable to find any ignificant evidence that the home erved a a pecial element of the City' pat, including apect relating to military, cultural, ocial, political, aethetic, or engineering. The home went through an extenive additionremodel in 1983 that completely changed the original layout, aethetic and volume of the original dwelling. A a reult of the lack of information, it i our concluion that the property doe not meet Criterion A. Criterion The name lited in the chain of title have been reearched through the following ource: California Hitorical Reource nventory Data Bae Journal of San Diego hlitory Biography & Genealogy Mater ndex City of Coronado Newpaper archive Name that came back with reult: Earl Brix: o Coronado Eagle and Journal, No. 6, Feb Well known Aviator Retire (See Newpaper article attached) o Coronado Eagle and Journal, No. 17, 27 April Second Annual Dog Show Score hi it (See Newpaper article attached) Martha Brix: o Coronado Eagle and Journal, No. 36, 7 September Bulldog Win Many Honor at Show (See Newpaper article attached) o Coronado Eagle and Journal, No. 46, 15 November Obituary (See Newpaper article attached) Mile R. Browning: o Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 17, 29 April Captain Mile Browning Awarded Navy Medal. (See Newpaper article attached) 62

67 Charlie G. Browning: Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 46, 14 November Bridge Luncheon. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 22, June Dinner Party hlonor Capt. And Mr. E.G. Ewen. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 42, 21 October Service Familie Entertaining. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 17, 26 April Detroit Viitor. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 41, 13 October Obituary. (See Newpaper article attached) Mary B. Farrell: Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 2, 9 January Cocktail Party. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 26, 26 June th Annual Coronado National Hore Show Open Sale of Boxe. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 2, 25 May Sanderon' Shop ncreae in Size. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 19, 7 May CALTECH Honor Coronado Boy. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 16, 22 April Young Trapnell Get CALTECH Key. (See Newpaper article attached) Walter G. Farrell: Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 48, 29 November Capt. Farrell and Family Arrive from the Eat. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 2, 16 May Noted Soldier Viiting Coronado Relative. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 27, 8 July Mary Belcher Trapnell Bride of Major Farrell; Ceremony Today Noon in New York City. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 1, 7 January Gen. and Mr. Farrell Complimented. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 9, 3 March Pictureque Veteran Still Like Fight. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 36, 25 September Farrell Return to Coronado. (See Newpaper article attached). Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 36, 9 September Birth of Baby Announced. (See Newpaper article attached). Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 5, 14 December Gen. Farrell hlome on Leave. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 14, 6 April Will Move to Glorietta Blvd. (See Newpaper article attached). Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 11,16 March Col. Farrell Promoted to Brigadier General. (See Newpaper article attached). Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 21, 24 May Mr. Farrell Expected in Coronado. (See Newpaper article attached). Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 18, 3 May Decorated for mproving Survival Method. (See Newpaper article attached). Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 2, 9 January Maj. Gen. Walter G. Farrell Return. (See Newpaper article attached) 63

68 Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 12, 18 March Mr. Farrell Here. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 45, 8 November Coronadan in $1, lawuit. (See Newpaper article attached). Walter D. Coleman: Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 37, 12 September Captain Walter D Coleman Named new commander of the Pacific Fleet' Amphibiou Squad Five. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 51, 119 December Chaplain, lay leader meet to dicu goal. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 37, 12 September Captain Coleman kipper Amphib Squadron Five. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 48, 28 November San Joe Mayor guet on Calvert. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 25, 19 June Capt. Coleman relieve Frank Winant. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 8, 2 February Flower Show committee guet at brunch meeting. (See Newpaper article attached) Donald M. Dill: Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 4, 26 January Explorer medical pot name late. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 51, 17 December Chritma Seal drive halfway. (See Newpaper article attached). Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 51,2 Augut Hopital Aux meet today. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 21, 21 May 1964-Scouting Memberhip goe over top. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 15, 15 April 1965-TB drive ucce. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 1, 7 January White Plague No More. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 42, 21 October Fahion how benefit Hopital Building Fund. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 5, 14 December Everything i Coming Up Roe. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 47, 23 November Chamber of Commerce 1968 Officer (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 5, 14 December CCC intall at aala dinner (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 22, 3 May Spread the Cot, Vote the Bond (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 6, 11 February Dr. Dili i A Silver Beaver (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 5, 2 February Medical taff appointment (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 11,16 March Real etate brief. (See Newpaper article attached) Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 11, 15 March Dr. Dili named hopital chief of taff. (See Newpaper article attached) 64

69 o Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 5, 3 January Dr. Donald Dill elected medical chief of taff. (See Newpaper article attached) o Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 16, 22 April Coronado hlopital announce new board of director. (See Newpaper article attached) o Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 12, 21 March 27 - Dr. Donald M. Dill received the Rotary Good Egg Award from Rotary Preident Dan Genler. (See Newpaper article attached) Gerald M. Schwartz: o Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 51, 18 December Obituary. (See Newpaper article attached) Below i a biography of the two mot ignificant owneroccupant of the property: General W.G. Farrell: Maj. Gen. Walter Greatinger Farrell wa a pioneer naval aviator who erved in World War and. He wa the oldet living naval aviator in the world and held two of the very few licene igned by Orville Wright. Born in San Francico on Oct. 4, 1897, the on of Gen. and Mr. P.J.H. Farrell, he joined the Army in 1916,but oon witched to the Marine. The young Marine lieutenant erved in France during World War, leading replacement companie through combat training. n 1921, he won hi wing a a Navy pilot. Between the world war, he erved in Haiti and Nicaragua, and briefly a aitant naval attache at the American Embay in London. After reorganizing and training a wing group in San Diego at the outet of World War, Farrell went to Guadalcanal and the Ruell land, earning a Silver Star for "exceptional heroim" in action againt the Japanee. Promoted to brigadier general, he commanded the 3rd Marine Air Wing, and later erved in China. Early in 1945, Farrell reported for duty at El Toro Marine Air Station in Orange County a deputy commander of the 11th Naval Ditrict Air Bae. He retired in 1946 a a major general, after 3 year of ervice. At that time, he wa commanding all Marine Corp air bae on the Wet Coat. He paed away on Thurday October 11, 199 at the age of 93 at San Diego Naval Hopital. During Occupancy: Mary B. Farrell wa the legal owner of the reidence from 1944 to After Maj. Gen. Farrell' retirement, they traveled for everal week at a time while hi parent upervied the reidence. General W.G. Farrell' ignificant contribution to hitory during the time of occupancy were: Donald M. Dill: Reported for duty at El Tore Marine Air Station in orange County a deputy commander of the 11th Naval Ditrict Air Bae Awarded the Bronze Star Medal for improving the urvival method ued by Navy and Marine airmen downed at ea hie retired a Major General, after 3 year of ervice. At that time, he wa commanding all Marine Corp air bae on the Wet Coat. Dr. Donald M Dill grew up in Ohio. hie graduated with honor from Jefferon Medical College Of Thoma Jefferon Univerity in After doing hi internhip at the hopital of the ame name, he joined the Navy in an officer program where he erved a a Lieutenant Flight Surgeon. After completing a tour of duty in South America, he wa commiioned to the Naval Air Station on North land Coronado. n 196, 65

70 Dr. Dill joined Dr. Jame Muhovic in a mall family practice on the corner of 8th Street and Orange Avenue. n the pat, people paid what they could afford for conultation. Dr. Dill and Dr. Muhovic knew all their patient on a firt name bai, and their family member, having delivered mot of them. Dr. Dill went on to be a community leader and prominent member of the Coronado community, hie erved in the Chamber of Commerce and Chief of Staff of the Coronado hlopital. On June 3th 216, there wa a Proclamation from the City of Coronado naming it Dr. Dill Day. (See City of Coronado proclamation on next page). During Occupancy: Donald M. Dill wa the legal owner of the reidence from 1962 to n 1978 he purchaed a new home at 767 B Ave. During the time of reidence at 1132 Glorietta Blvd. Dr. Dili' ignificant contribution to Coronado hitory were: Served a Chairman for the Annual Chritma Seal Campaign for the Coronado area. The campaign focued on raiing money to fight Tuberculoi and other repiratory dieae in San Diego County ntalled a econd Vice Preident of Coronado Chamber of Commerce Awarded the Boy Scout Silver Beaver Award Appointed Vice Preident of Coronado hlopital Appointed Coronado hlopital Medical Chief of Staff Criterion B Summary: The information pertaining to the pat owneroccupant of the dwelling how a valid connection between two ignificant people and Coronado hitory: General W.G. Farrell and Dr. Donald M. Dili (See biography above). Therefore, we have concluded that the property atifie Criterion B. Criterion C: Reearch how that the exiting dwelling on the property ha been ignificantly altered from it original deign. Alteration include an extenive additionremodel in 1983 that changed the front, ide and rear elevation. All the window and door have been replaced. The altered deign doe not poe ditinctive characteritic of any ignificant architectural tyle and it doe not hold any tudy value. For thee reaon, it i our concluion that the home doe not atify Criterion C. Criterion D: Reearch ource: Coronado hlitorical Aociation, San Diego Hitory Center The original builder Chri A. Cogrove wa conidered a mater builder and ignificant land developer in San Diego County during the pot-world War 194' and 195' eatern expanion of the City of San Diego. n hi 65-year career, he wa a builder of over 3, home and commercial propertie in Point Loma, College Height, Talmadge, Rolando, Cogrove hleight, Kenington, Coronado, La Mea, Alpine, Rancho Santa Fe, Lo Angele, and Palm Spring. Cogrove ha three home with hitoric deignation in the city of San Diego and Coronado. There aren't any ignificant characteritic remaining from the original home built by Cogrove at 1132 Glorietta Blvd. due to the extenive alteration to the original tructure during the major remodeladdition in Alo, no record of a project architect, deigner, artian, or landcape architect wa uncovered with our reearch. Furthermore, the property wa not lited on the Source Point Coronado Hitoric Reource nventory. There weren't any image or record of any ignificance related to the property. For thee reaon, it i our concluion that the property i not hitorically ignificant under Criterion D. 66

71 WHEREAS, Dr. Donald Dill, known a a "doctor' doctor," ha erved the people of Coronado ince 1961 a their general practitioner, diagnotician and urgeon, until retiring on December 31, 215; and WHEREAS, a one of Coronado' mot recognizable phyician, he brought thouand of babie into thi world and helped thouand of other cope with their final day, meeting their end with dignity and grace; and WHEREAS, a typical day would often include the eeing of 5 patient; performing a urgery or two; delivering a baby; and till having to cover hift in the emergency room. Alo, it wa not uncommon for him to leep all night in a hopital room, the ER or CU to keep an eye on hi patient; and WHEREAS, Dr. Dili helped hi patient and their familie time and time again to deal with their medical need and ometime with their grief; wa known to treat four generation of the ame family; and gave unelfihly and untiringly to the hopital, the foundation, to hi patient, and to the community; and WHEREAS, Dr. Dili tarted the Alcohol and Drug Rehabilitation Center in Coronado; wa Chief of Staff at Coronado Hopital for five year; brought a cutting edge attitude to medical practice that i now commonly ued by other phyician; and remained a tudent of hi field until he retired, managing to change with the time and to hi patient need; and WHEREAS, the City of Coronado owe Dr. Donald Dili it deepet gratitude and appreciation. Now, Therefore,, Caey Tanaka, by the power veted in me a the Fiftieth Mayor of the City of Coronado, together with the full City Council of the City of Coronado, do hereby call upon the people of Coronado to honor Dr. Donald Dill for hi year of ervice a Coronado' premier mall town doctor, and do hereby proclaim June 3, 216: and July 216 a: in the City ofcoronado. ft 'DR. DONALD DLL DA Y" "DR. DONALD DLL MONTH" n Witne Thereof, Have Hereunto Set My Hand and caued the Seal of the City ofcoronado, California, to be affixed thereto thi 3th day of June 216. Caey Tanaka, Mayor Attet: Mary L. Clifford, CMC, City Clerk 67

72 Earl &Martha Brix 1. Well Known Aviator Retire From Service At hr own riaaat, an<t, wtth ttf ppr<»v»l of tht? prrldint, Siitor UeyteMint, * < 8. ~ wa pt»«4 on Uio niinml U»t of the n»vy. vpon jbovary S!»t L&.»<yv«fur twrnty y<ir» in th» imvy: twflvt year* of whkh ttwi<i WBJ in l via< tion trpai. Wlul oa duty At th«n»vt air tation i.t? buill 11 M Ad U».»»»<» CorcuMM&o. Ht will mke fei< iktthc'hcrc. o" 68

73 f THUKSOAY, AML n, 193» CO»ONA»B JOU»NAL fact» "BULLlXXi "SAftRl" WNS. TWO BUJE MBtONS N 6fi SHOW t V: f. &:x A.i;,. Dale Bda, D»nc Wilwn and Earl Brlx, Wt to riht, wit') ting f««rrl. G«rri wan twn btu< nbbona in the <to t how wt Satarday tk w»a ludk«d Uic fawt doa of a>itw" well u th» doa witk ttie bet codtume. SECOND ANNUAL DOG [Fleet Enter Canal; SHOW SCORES HT larrive Next Week Coronado' Canin Again How Their Ooy in Cotorhil Dog Show; Ribbom Awanbd Once apaiii Coronado' yc-ung«it et t! [ c btllend tk«t the ix-mch] ahowod their cider how to put on tffun cruiaen of the Honolulu dog how. Saturday afternoon on vannh cl will come to Sai tennia court of Mr. Paul Weceforth, ;aa aoon a th» European ituation per- the children, with a boiird cf directy»:3s'&;' SWSrS'CS, Coronado hiffh thwtn. mit. Fridoy myht, June 2 at 8 o'clock in lveral warhtpa now at Mare x. lanfl. Paart Harbor and Bremerton.' Wrenn and t*et4t Scott, piwxented are alno due to arrive in the local k»rher next month, they include the air- dog how that for color and genuirk interet f&r urpac-d many that have craft carrier S&ratop», the cruier i been planned by experta in the buine. dptroyc and tender. Trenton and Detroit and a ewre of i FoliowiniT are the winner in Coronado' ercnri annual doff how: Alo arrivhiff next month arc thrw naval t.ran8port8 brinffing a DOT in beat coatume :Dae Bri] of navy peronnel and with "an Eiialhh bill] n«l>i< tranferred from eatern at,-*-1 Ann Montfpfmery with 'ommy Williamfton wi wn. The trio of yeahea and th(r daten of arrival are the Vtfg*, May 7; Ton; with longwit hair; Catherinft iruon with a collie; mcond, Barbara Hack with Prince. Dog- in the bet conditicn with the mot pep compared to ag»: Klaine! Head Rotarian Hen» with Mouaie. Dot»lth_mnit tritk.: Mn._W.lter (Continued from Pare One) Poor with Chummy; econd, Virffinia Brown nrith Anna; third. Tommy on cummittw and h»a baen a m< Hamilton with Boota. the board of dincton aeveral Dognrnlup; Cniff Comatock with imea. During the current year he ha econd. Tommy Williamon ; been a member of the board of dirwly; third, Mary Baaa with! tun and al»o acrrcd on the ftchwl ccni tact committee. He waa chairman of Mlt»i«. 1,cut?" Ctrteat isoit: Pat Crcwley with Hoiwy: iiwy: x>i» Spreckela with a Chihuahua; and third. Sue Morehouae with Tiny Tim. Do» with loudert bark: Gene Fawcett with Toby; aecond, C. Jennin ith Micky; third, Mn. E«ri Bril itk Garri. Favorite pupptea: Pat Crowley with Hofity; econd, Mr. B. L. Rutt with atch'; Ulird, Su«Monhoue with Tiny DO)T moat difficult to clabify: Jean Vawcett with Toby; aecon<i Paul Heineman with Bitten; third. Uonel Row with Chipg. Do? with lonreat tail: Poppy dark with Fritx; aecond, Ann Mont with Schnitzel; third, Harrii with Leni Fittet <iofr; Bill Harper with Su-»an; econd, Mn. r»eoree Newhall»ith Miaty; third, Pat Wilton with Racket. Dog with toil that wag fateat: June M. Brown with Scotty; econd. Sue Morehoue with Tiny Tim; third, Mr. Walter Poor with Chummy. irfteat doff; >rince, owned by B*rbar Black. Smallet do: Chihuahua, owned by Mr.. S. Duel it do»; Garri, owned by Mr. Earl Brix. JC f Henderncn, May 8 and Siriua, May 13. Two Boy to Be Honored at Graduation Exercie Continued from Pagt One) For th firnt time in the hwtory <rf Coronado Hitfh achoo) two bcyb hv attached to the Atlantic flwt only temporarily. bwn choaen from high honor atudi of the aenter d a for»lut»totian and wtedtctoriwft. n pnvioua want the :oor h»a iifotrt U>» boy and riri or yiri. Graduation xwciaea wilt take place Harry L. Perkin to the decoration committee during imtj week' (titrjct convention. 1 n» the ycara that Harry faaa bwn a member of Rotary he h&a never wen.tnred with a nickname, bat. a fev montha luro he acquired one "F<trdi [ nd" (he love to amcll the fluwern). irry i one of the city'a leadine florit, which may explnin the co)[ptnm<?ti. Eterything FURNTURE LOWEST rrces Caronade Furniture Store a«d Coronado Tranfer NEW and USED FUKNTURE 2 Daily Trip to San KO 21 Ye«n hi Corooado j 1» Ornng* Avenue Cw. 547 Jj CiM! Ki Ta'o < :'". isss",il ind'r,9 A4- coux1'' 'cb.u.'"ll' Hiteric Bell Ring in "Stagecoach" The mellov. liquid iiotea that heard durinir one of the dnimtt< i in "Stagwoach" conn from» [church a boll bill that th»t hrb looked down upoi much of Americ»'a formative wertern i hitory. t waa borrowed by the W»liter Wanger atudiob (rom» ffroup of icalifomiana who have p«nt yeara colitectinc valued hitorical objectfc iou)?h, the bell w»» <ai»t idrica of Sitka. wn_bani>cn the; "LltUe itlw P.clfic." Thee ThfM toundrlw were im of moat of the bella uaed iret, California mia»ion». WiuiRpr' pmductton, "Stairecoach," i cornea to the Coron»<io theatre on!s»turd«r. Sunday and Monday through tita nle t. t ia a tenaeiy i~ <«Me Wt Boy' Spift Slion. Whir w tan and kit*»im> tootlrr»!«. $2,95 CMdrm' Sko«m wliic. block or browit. $1.39 to $3.95 drn rt»rr of Uw put tk«1*coach pl»ywt tn the (omattv» Una o< ita pamcnaw whtl* th* wwrt wu ln» built, <»hn Fort ilimtnl frontier drwna, with Cl»lr» Tnvor Fohn Wayne» who c<kt*r with th«ipport of Andy Dwlne, John Caw- >, Thonuu Mtch»tl, LoutM Phttt, lcorac Bwncreft, Tim Bolt and Berton mblll. Sakicrit* n HN Conm* rt«nl WANTED Bo««c.» or < b«*»r>.»»» t» tm uuk No»»M» Writ* *. criptlon, priuy w>< ynir d<rw to Amelia Moon. can C»nui*> Jnnul. WE HAVE JUST»ECEVED OU SFO»T SHOES N ALL WHTE AND TWO.TONE N LEATHER AND CKEPE SOLESf2.98 $3.95 f 5. Gnwing Girta* gny»wd», cnpt ut«* $1.9» Toil and Wliit* Ktbkw Solu. $2.95 M-' W«A Sl«m i Hith K lo»- $2.95 Mack. WE GVE S&H GREEN 1 GOLD STANDARD TKAONG STAMK S»pw Sho«Repairinfl Dyhta R«**nnng Fmdingi Coronado Univeral Boot Shop MOM Coninndo 415. J 945 Onf An. SAFEWAV PRCES FOR THURSDAY - FRDAY - SATURDAY, APRL 27th, 28th, 29th SAFEWAY OFFERS ALL THREE LOW PMCES-CONVENENCE-QUAUTY 8UY THE EST FOR LESS BEVERAGES FOR HOME REFRESHMENT Grapetruit Jaice 4c5c Town flihim No. 2 On Tomato Juice 4<"r23c Sunny Dawn. No. t Can Nn. 2 can, $ for 2c Snowy Peak Beverage 12-o«. Bottlt 6 (or»»< S2-oit. Bottle... Each loc QUAUTY MEATS Hen Turkey ibmlc l-'amr L«c«l, Frnh Drnnd t to 12-]]». Bacon iibllc (.old Coin Cello Pk]t. Lanib Roat ibltic Shoulder. Fancy Caltfornia Lamb Pork Roat nlsc Center Cut Shoulitr Wicncr Coney ih.l5c All Y<)U Want at Thir *rice Smoked Picnic»nie Gold Coin or.motrdl'. Prld< inklttw vory Soap 5C Mnl. C«ki L«r te, 2 ctkn. lie P8G Soap White N.ptht Rn. B«r 3C Super Sud Rtd Box Blue Box th FNE COFFEES Airway ii-.ulc.1.1b. b 37C MU H) Mtllow Edward,22ic a.1b. un 44«Tuu«n Pukrf Mayonnaie Piednunt finl 19c Peanut Butter BeTwly t.lb. l»r 5«Brown Derby 4.o,2<C BEER C*na Me Qt. l-25c Canterbary Tea Fine N»vor Bconttmic»lly Priced Crwn..... r<.b. l9e -b..,,.,... -He «*ck,..,..'i-lb. l&c 'i.tb c Snowdrift Ub. ( 'n 19c i»b,,51c C-ttC lk-1 Manti No. 2(.i Can Kitchen Craft Flour No. 1 B«( SSe %-BbL 79t Keen Shortening. <c l-1fa. C»n 4c 8Jt>. Caii 78c 8c «1c WUet Dd Mui llo. PotToatie 1..47C Regular Box LargW Box 8c FRUTS 8 VEGETABLES Avocado 3f«rlc C«l<». 6-<u. <! lo.oi «uk St Pea»».1c Fmh Gm» Fy l Po*h Faiicy N«. 1 quill? Potatoe ft.-ltc New WMt«R«««No. 1 Gnik Banana Fancy, G<rfd<n Ripe Artichoke Jnnho Sn«. Stlntnl Qulily Cdery Eilni Lu»t. Ufh Tn«'i',i..rti vj-l. 5»»15c i»..1c loc 69 f.tift

74 J BulldogWin Many Honor at Show BrinKinf hon»«2 CUJK a»ni 7 rikkon*. "Dunat&nta Gari." two-yew old Rn r- U»h bulldf ownad by Mn of 118 Adfflta, won mportant hooon at ttx Silver Bay Kcnnol elub l»ow Salurttoy»n4< Sunday. < Wlnoinjr th* r«wrv trophy, wtiiea iu v»rd««t the t«-&n<t bil do» of the riiow. and tl»» flnrt prt»# in th* novice chw, th* butldok tovk flntji»t» in Uxi tinit and local cs»we«. ThUi t» "Dunatoola G»ri'»" f(r»t pp«*nua<>* n A dof hcnw, Nn.»t»tod today. 1 The honon M (!» mor» mportaalj b<k«i»e the Stiver Bay K»na»l club» affihatl with th«am»rifn Kenmri ctob. AlMiiixr Coronado doir r<h<-«iv»!d tint prii* wh»n the bla* rihtxin wa» waniwl to Nr». R F. Ma<Nal»y'» c»tcli»r apuiitl. Th«tint wa» b» th«f American br*<l ( ntet elaa t Rwd NacNatly. on of Kr. luod Uf. 1 MAcNally, w awarded fint prix* in UM> <hitdnm'» h»n<llint flaw.»"<! >»i» < L.. w» awrded fourth pn» in th» etm*. t ObU uarie i" Mr. Eart Brix Former lobg-tlmt Coronado reident Mr. 79 <j i<d in Seaide. Cat., on Novenber <k Daughter of Major WiHaun L. Kneedler, USA (r»t.), onu_<rf Coronado'a focndera, h< had l?vd in the City for nearly 4 ynn before nnoving to Seuiefe m'1955. She wa the wi«knr of U. Bn:<. USN. She ia aurvlved by a ader, W;, R. E. Cummin of Pacific Cro\; and two on, K;u? of San rrancico and Dale of San Dffr»B. 7

75 Mile & Charlie Browning Sr Capfr. Mile Browning Awarded Navy Medal Valorou action on Pacific warfront ha won the Silver Star medal for Capt. Mile R. Browning. U.S.N., of Coronado, the navy department announced today. Capt. Browning erved a chief of taff to a tak force commander during a erie of highly ucceful oftenive miion, including? attack on the Marhall and Gilbert land, raid on Wake and Marcu laland, tte Battle of Midway and imilar operation in the Central Pacific. Depite the contant threat of air and ubmarine attack, the citation «aid, the tak force uffered onty minor damape due to Capt. BrowninR' kill and determination under fire. n addition, he contributed materiatly to the marked ucce of other action, through which the taak force came uncathed after inflicting extremely heavy damage on Japanee in- tallationa and hipping. Bridge Luncheon Mre. entertained wivea of <rffi<kert of aquadron VF-3. of which Lwul. Comdr. _ l» in clyirffe, at charminfly ppoiat<d hhdare-ltmnchfrqn Thunwlay, in her ho<n, 18 E AvcnuB. Cowra were laid for Medame Atden H. lron», Charle Lu Ww.lhofen, William H(»(ltntr»wortM, J»me» J. McRobcrta, G«<tr»< C. Moiitgomery, 1 John P, Whitny, Edward P, Moon. Kwl E. Jun, Sytvm G»KM, John. Rttbwnberger, Cuifenft Tatom. Sey- moor jlohrwon. Willrm Goenel] Tomlineon, Raymond... Waller and Hcnry 1. H»lc. f h!-1 ll ' u. ' ll L< 71

76 \ Dinner Party Honor Copt. and Mr. E. C. Ewen Mr. ' eritertaitietl rec<>ntty with a dinner party at ott;! ({1 Corn na< n in hon or of ('apt. Kdward C. twn, U.S.N.. and Mr. Eweii. The tioiioree arriveit recentlv from Withinton and are quet of the hotel for an in(ktfiiutc tay. Guet iiuinbered 2. ims. Service Familie Enferfroining WiUi cnoni iwrvlc< fwniuedl Dft tlic movo hw tboatii, tjm'ir cojnjaw»d ffvia h*& xwn the incezitivc for EttD.m pkrt«?fl thntn i» nrtoftl in n ri(,y whhch lakeft UB. war re«wjiubili,ll 8- Ul Bcrirunly M Cnronftdo, Comdr.»n4 Un. Pwiffht D. Ekttigita who are now fliccupipia hf Pe.nion hoffift on (1c n blvd., tfntftrtaitrtd A ltff«n KTr'up "'' ffiend* a.l th<i e*(n?kt*il haur but l'"ri{lay ajti-tioon- Th* party honond Mn, luiieli A, AK-cr of Detroit. Buudef of Mrt. DoufftM- Mr», '.'..' '. f ;ir " " fnlcrtalned about f<i-rty iroffrtr lit cwktwl» in h»r honid on (orictla en Fnda.y,»nd C<t1oiie1 and Mn, Kildcr JacJc" Ann invited frfv?tnl gufrtfl to dine w*,h thf?n lit Hote-1 rifll ("arftnadn. Sent Adm. aiid Mra, Onn -. Kurfin aliura pntr'rtainwl wl Wfrfrk, ntiunc fnenda at the roeleuul hflvr no Thuni- 4»y» 1 < l' 72

77 \ \ \ \ Detroit Viitor Mra. Jamu r. Wclab. of Detroit, \ Mich., arrived wt Munday in *Cwocado to b< the hou«? u.ml of Mn. 1c.:.. L<i»l Wednndaiy aftemxxm Mn- :_ invited a group of fripndt n at thr cocklai! hour to meet Mn. WuLah, Mjra, ;."iii Juat back fram two wwkt i» San Jaduafco, whfrre hr pent two wwlui, recent]y rfcrlved a ] tk?r trotu Mra. Thonua D Gulnn, which contained new» <ai( Captain CSutnn, whkh will be of intr.reat to their uuraibro-u Fud-inada (rlcndg. Captain Ouinn, URN, who h now in Norfolk, Va-, in coinmiuul of a truu'itnaitnii.. ha* rrcrntly been j avtaidliy thy n.a'y a BmnAe Star inctidp a citation foic meritqriou» acjlk''(.'!u-flt at Naumpa and the RuQfcl land- The Army ha pre- BcriK-htm. with medal and ribbfla for WKPTilll.ppuae camp-dlign &a of Qvc. 1'.M}, whfrn Captflin GuLnn commaci-jeit CavKc. Captain, GuJiui ifl alwti to receiivc the Pre-ickntiat Citation <iwikrdcd to Patrol Wing 1 far kta work At hfc beginning (it the war. K w *i Charlie G- Browning C'harltc Ci. Hrovviiitif, a tormer Coronado reident, died Oct. 7 at El Cajon Valley Hopital of heart failure. She wa 82. Mr. tlii «i! who wa born in Wahington. D.C.. had lived in the Sun Diego area until her death. She h iirvivcu by her couin. Maybcllc Pettit of aguna Beach. No memorial ervice are planned. 73

78 Mary B. Farrell Lieut. and Mr. John H. Griffin, 466 H avenue, entertained at the cocktail hour, Saturday afternoon in their home. Among the invited quet were Lieut. Comdr. and Mr. T, H. Robbin, Lieut (jg) and Mr* John K. Well, Maj. G. Farrell, Mr. and Mr» Frank Godfrey, Mr. Frank Donovan Ower, Mr. Mary B. Trapnell, Lieut (jg.) M. P. Evenon. Calfech Honor (oronadoboy Frederick M. Trapnell Jr., on of Mr Glorietta Blvd.. ha been electod to receive a tudent body honor certificate at th California ntitute of Technology, Paadena* He i one of 19 tudent recciving honor certificate for participat ion in variou campu activi" tie. He erved a a ergeant in the U. S. Marine Corp, VoungTrapnell igef CalTech Key Paadena Frederic M. Trapnell Jr. of Coronado, a tudent at the California ntitute of Technology here. ha been choen to receive an honor key at the pring award aembly next month* Hcnor key are awarded to undergraduate who have made major contribution to campu life. Trapnell i the on of Mr. B 1132 Glorietta Blvd.. and i a ophomore majoring in phyic. 74

79 t :;.:- aaa SANDERSON'S SHOP NCREASES N SZE The ncwly-expandod Sandcron' hop at C Ave., in the Crown Shop, will be open for the firt time' an Wedneday, it wa announce th i week by M manager. The hop, ffhich wa opened hrre jut 15 month ago, ha been enlarged to include the.pace formerly occupied by the Coronado Chamber of Commerc«? office. The new facilitie have been rpmodcled to include paciou fitting room, a millinery corner and large tockroom ahd office pace, Mr, tated. Wall of waxed natural birch and walnut arc complemented with a new platic material rcemblnig corrugated gla, in a oft yellow tone, for the decor. Sale of boxe for the l4th annuall Coronado National Hore how ha tarted, with Mra. Frank A. Frye, jr., directini; an afirgreiv-e campaign. She i bein? aited by Mr. Jame Forward, Mr. W. Murray Smith, Mn. Luther Kennett, Mr. Willia Allen and Mr. Philip Gildred. Mn. Frank G. Belcher, general chairman announce that a large number o{ ring%id< boxe h»ve been added thi year, aa the hore how manapement anticipate the demand will exceed the aupply. Alo, the price will be coniderably below lat year' nmgt. Aa all committee have had an earlier atart thi year, the nunaerou detail* connected with ahow of thi maynitude an well in h»nd. The opening performance will be on the evening of July 17, with the pro(rnnr continuing through the following Sanday iiight. M»tinw are cheduled for Saturday and Stinday. Mn. Walter G. F»rrell u rcaiining a chairman of the profrnbb committee for the n*tion»i ahow, uid will leave Boon for WMhinyton. D. C. to be with her haaband, Lt. CoL Famll. U. Col. FTWill, U.S.M.C.. who h»8 been "an ObMrver n England, haa been ord»wd to duty in W hington, b7c. Mn. John Btackett will take over the chairaunahip of the profr»m conunittee. 75

80 Walter G. Farrell Lieut.-Commander John Fndfrti'E.jj Bate and wife arc here from Bremerton aiid lucatrd t 7(i Orange avenue. Mr. and Mr. C. M. Fleck from ndiana, urc here for the winter and have taken the houae at 467 Alameda avenue. ' Lieut. Volney C. Finch and wife] have arrived from Boton and have taken the houxe at 663 J avenue. They were here five yrar aeu and are glad to be back in Coronado apiin. Lieut. Finch ha bwn takini? a courae t the Maachuett natitute of Technolofcy at Cambridtfe, and ia now ttached to the naval air tation at North iiland.» Aviation Mechanic H. Butler, and Mn. Butler and their young' dauehttr Mary Lou, aicfd ix month, have arrived from Treniontun, Boxclder rounty, Utah, and arc domiciled at 869 D avrnuf. Mr. B'ltler K now - ticnwi to the Army aviation Field, North ilanil. Mr. Butlcr'8 home t\ty wa San Francico and hia home wa at Black Pinr, daho, * John A. Mauck, proprietor of the Olive Grocery. 864 F avenue, wa viited during- la-t week by hia brother, H. A. Maurk, recently proprittor of a hat atore in Portland, Oregon, but now retired from that buaineu nd making; hia headquartera in Loa AnKelc. He expreed much admiralion for Coronado and ita urroundin. Thi wa the fint meeting of the brother in aevcn yeara. Eniim Peter K. Wella and wife an here from Long Beach, and are rctiding at 59 Seventh atreet. He w» formerly with the U. S. S, Tenneee nd i» now attached to the torpedo, tation at North land. He i» a nalive of Wa-thinetoii, D. C., and Mn. Well i (rom Warrenton, Virginia,; near Wahinifton. Th»y were located at Long Beach before comini? to Coronado. Opt. Farrelf and Family Arrlv» From the Eat Cnpt Walter G. Farrell, recently from'the Air Service TacUcal School, Langley Field, Virginia, and Mra. FarirelL and their young aon ThomM, who celebrated hifl gecond birthday November 2, and Mia Sadie Fife, geil 19, companion, have mve<< (rom Tray, New York, and have taken the houe at 725 Tolita avenue for the winter. ter Capt. Fartcll expecta to be ent to China. Eniim De Witt C. E. Hamberger of the U. S S. Stoat and wife are locatwl at 617 Tenth treet afttr thort ojourn n San Dief(o. Jn September they tu-rived from Panama on the S. S. Manchuria. Mr». Hamberger i» a daughter of Mr. andmra. Henry Albera of Waahinfrton, D. C. Her iter, Mig -ouic Altwr, u- rived two week ago and will be viitor here until next»i>rin». En- Vfcn Hambyrger'a family 4 *t r' folk, Virginia; i t t 1 { ( 76

81 Noted Soldier Viiting Coronado Relative Prominent figrure in the wan of many land, yet hale, hearty ana-active at the age of 72, General Patrick J. H. Farrell i thi week viiting at the home of hi on. Captain Walter G. Farrell, U.S.M.C., M4 Adella Avenue. The general i a pat commander-inchief of the Veteran of Foreign War and tcok occaion to viit the local veterana' pot at ita meeting lat Friday evening where he delivered mot inpiring addre. The Boy Scout movement in America wa launched by General Farre hortly after he returned from a viit to England whpre he wa impreaed with the idea whi(:h had recently been tarted by Sir Robert Baden-Powell. With] characteritic nthuiaam, the general devoted hi entire energy to the work and ha been conaitently active in Boy Scout work ever ince. General Farrell ha a remarkablewar record, having erved aa a aoldier on five continenta and in the Philippinea. He wa born in Calcutta in 1863 and a a very young man erved a captain of cavalry in tl'.e Britih army in a hot campaign againt the Eyfendi rebela. n one of thee fighta he received hi firt bullet wound an ugly one in the right leg. He alo erved in the Egyptian and Sudan wan, riding over the deert and through the junglea on camel or hore. n 1889 he waa hi the Chilean army, fighting to uppre a rebellion, during which he diatinguihed himelf and wa made tint a colonel, then brigadier general. After thia war the general returned to the United Statea and took up the tudy of medicine, graduatinf from the Kentucky School of Medicine of the Univerity of Louiaville, i achieving ditinction in thi profeaaioo little hort of hi war record. At the outbreak of the Spaniah- American w»r he went to the Philippine where he aerved»a captain and urgeon in the Fint California infantry. When the»reat earthquake and fire viaited San Fr»nci»co in 198 the general ruhed there from llinoi and did yeoman aervic in emergency hoapital work. When the World war broke out General FamU helped muter in troopa in Texa and later aw aenrice in France in command of the advance ector of the hopital ervice. He wa wounded five timea and wa decorated by France and coiweaa "for Gallantry in Action." 1, 77

82 Mary Belcher Trapnell Bride of Major Forrell; Ceremony Today Noon in New York City The marriage of Mr. Mary Belcher Trapne, daurhter of Frank J. Belcher of Coronado, and Major Walter G. ' Farrell, U. S. Marine Corp, on of Genenl and Mr. P. J. H. Farrell. will be olemniied today at high noon, in the reidence of Mr. and Mr. Edar G. Croman, 1148 Fifth Avenue, New York. Mr. Croman (Helen Farrell) ia Major Farrell' iater. The bride and groom will ail on the lie de France following the wedding, to pend their honeymoon abroad. Up- ( \ l- < \ PCTURESQUE VETERAN] STLL LKES FGHT General and Mr. Farrell Return to Coronado For Brief Viit After an abence of about a year, General and Mr. P. J. H. Farrell came down from Lo Angele Friday tor brief viit with frienda, returning the tint of the week. Whfle here they alo enjoyed a hort viit with their Bon, Major Walter G. Farrell, U.S.M.C., who ferried a plane here from Qu»n- Uco- Virginia, where he haa been atationed for gome time. Major Farrell only remained a couple of day before returning to hi dutie on the eat coat. General and Mn. Farrell, who have been 'living- in Loa Angele aince November, left Coronado about a year ago and have pent the intervenin< time at variou pointa on the eat coat, viiting at intervab with their on at Quantico and with a daughter in Connecticut. Wtiile viiting on hi daughter' Connacticnt (arm lat nunmer General Farre, veteran of practically evcry war fought in any part of the world in the pat 4 or BO year, received a long ditance crfl one day inviting him to make a trip to the Wet ndiea on a teamer ailing from New York the following night. "And a there appeared to be quite a revolution Koingr on down there, with ome bitter fighting between the Haitian and the Dominican republic, t went down to watch the proceeding," aaid the Gen- ral. While the Haitian outnumber the Dominican two to one and are better armed and equipped to take care of themelve. General Farrell aya he think the buine men of the iland would like to ee the fighting continue until Uncle Sam might find- it nece- ry affain to atep in and keep the peace, puinea, they aay, han't been BO good ince the withdrawal of American marine and their American money aome four year ago. Gen. and Mr. Farrell Complimented Maj. Gen. Patrick J. H. Famll, u. S. A. retired, and Mr Farrell were quet of honor at a amart cocktail party Saturday afternoon from 5 to 7, (riven by their on, Maj. Walter G. Farrell. U.S.M.C., at hi home, 1 Gl-rietta Boulevard. Gen. and Mr. Farrell, who have been viiting' their on for the pa«t ten day, have been the incentive for» number of charming courteie while here. They returned to Lo Angele early in the week for an indefinite ojoiim. 78

83 Farrell Return To Coronado Lt Col. Walter G. Famll. U.S.M. C., and Mr. Farre, who were formerly popular ervice»et memben in Coronado and San Diego, have returned to Coronado and are at preaent guet at the El Cordov They plan to take a houe here for an indefinite period. [ Birth of Baby Announced r'..!»»,.l M».y Wyl»o». (: i'iirrr'lt n Col. and Mr. Walter (>. Farrell of -.H Jollp, fonnerly if t'oroiiado, have aiii)i>iiiic(><l the birth of ;i (iaukhter lat VV»>tl(u'<iav at Srrijip Memorial hopital. Tie baby who ha been naine'i Mary VirKinia, h.i two brothpr. Frilz anti 'atrick. Mr. Farr<--ll i the daughter of Frank J. Kelchor, Jr., and the lat<1 Mr. Bclrher, and iter of ia. Frank (larreton Belcher. now viitinj? iii C<>n>na<lo. General Farrell Home On Leave Brig. Gen. Walter G. Farrell wa welcomed lat weekend by Mr. Farrd 1 and their children, when he returned on leave from overea duty. The Farrell expect to have General Farrell' parent, Brig. Gen. Patrick Farrell, USA ret., and Mr. Farrell of Lo Angele, with them over Chritma. Will Move to Glorietta Boulevard Mr. Walter G. Farrell, wife of Brig. Gen. Farrell, USMC,who with her children ha been making her home at Hotel del Coron ado ~ ince Gen. Farrell ha been overea. ha recently purchaed a home on Glorietta boulevard, where ahe will move in the near future. 79

84 Col. Farrell Promoted To Brigadier General Col. Walter G. Farrell, U.S.M.C otf La Jolla and Coronado who ha been tationed at the San Diego Mar- Sne Baw at interval duriny hia career and who i» now tationed in Hawaii, ha been nominated by Preaident Rooevelt for temporary promotion to brig-adier g-eneraf, it waa announced thi week in Wahingrton. Gen. Farrell'a wife, the former Mary Belcher Trapnell, and two children, Patrick, 6, and Mary Virginia, 6 month, are making their home at Hotel del Coronado while the officer i away on duty.! t \ { Decorated for mproving Survival Method Brig. Gen. Walter G. FarreU, USMC, of Coronado, deputy commander of Marine aviation activi- 1 1 tie in the Eleventh Naval Ditrict, ha jut been awarded the Bronze Star Medal and citation from Fleet Adm. Cheter W. Nimitz, USN, for < improving the urvival method ued by Navy and Marine airmen downed at ea. Gen. Farrell, who reide at 1132 Gorietta blvd., received the decoration from Rear Adm. Alva D. Bemhard, USN, Commander of Eleventh Naval Ditrict air bae, in a formal ceremony at El Toro Marine Corp Air Station, Santa Ana, headquarter of the Marine general. ( n the citation. Gen. Farrell wa praied for laying the foundation of 1 a flight peronnel urvival training coure while commanding general of a Marine Aircraft Wing in the Hawaiian area from December, ] to November, Stating that General Farrell contributed materially to the aving of live of night peronnel through the training coure, the citation aid in } part: "He upervied the arrangement that reulted in the ucce and afety of long over-water flight by ingle engine aircraft. By hi initiative, pereverance and peronal attention to detail, he contributed much to the future afety of flight peronnel." ]» 1 1 < 1 < Mr. Walter G. Farrell. wife of Brigadier General Farrell, USMC, commandmg general at El Toro, i expected in Coronado Friday for the weekend. Mr. Farrell ha been in Santa Ana with her huband. t 8

85 Maj. Gen. Walter G. Farrell. USA, nnd Mr. Farrcll have returned from Corte Madera, where they pent the holiday with the Belcher family. \ Coronadan in $1,8 lawuit A lawuit (or $1, damage ha been filed by Maj. Gen. Walter G. Farrell, USMC, ret., of 1132 Glunetta boulevard, againt Capt. Theodore J. Shultz, USN. ret.. and Mr. Shultz, of 1417 Tenth treet. General Farrell' pleading in the uit, which were filed in Superior Court lat Saturday, BS- Mr. Walter G. Farrell, wife of Maj. Gen. Farrell. USMC, pent lat week-end in Coronado viiting her children and General Farrell' parent, Brig. Gen. Patrick Farrcll, USA, ret., and Mr. Farrell, who are taying in the Walter G. FarreU hwnc while they arc away. Mr. Farrell left by plane Monday to rejoin General Farrell in San Francico. The Farre. who plan to remain everal week in San Fran- Cico, have jut returned from an extended trip to the Orient. ert that a dog belonging to Capt. nd Mr. Shultz bit him one year ago, November 8, The complaint continue that General Farrell uffered permanent groin injurie. Leland C. Nielen. attorney for General Farrell. aid the injurie are auch that General Farrell ha been told to tay within hour' ditance of medical aid. The uit for damage i baed on the (act that General Farrell i a management engineer, Nielen aid. adding that the profeaion require extenive travel, which i prohibited by the doctor' order. Captain Shultz declined to comment un the notice of uit, which wa erved on him Saturday. He ftid the matter wa too new (or him to be able to comment. t i undertood that the rae will not cume up for court action for at leat nine month, becaue the court calendar i overcrowded. 81

86 Walter D. Coleman a att m *!»! v t m, m., m K! te; "m. CAPTAW.». E-i naiul affw* Cftrtimufldkw»» th* Pacific Fkari ACTp-hAicui Squadren Fht, Chaplain, lay leader meet to dicu goal Chaplain and lay leader of Amphibiou Squadron Five and Landing Ship Squadron Five met at the Amphibiou Bae in Coronado in November to dicu goal of the Force Lay Leader Program. Called by Captain L of 25 Sixth (trect, the conference waa 'conducted by Lt Ondr. E: R Mcrttn<?»d, chaplaia for Squadron Five. 82

87 \ (aptaln (oteman kipper AmpWk Squadron Five C*pt«iii i38 Sixth lukt, Coronadak n' ll»v«*d Captuin A.kaMMlcr C. Vwiaey. UK Mn'gini* <iv»nv. 11 'C<i«nn.*nd<-r 'i 1h<- y*ftfu- P\c*t' jajripiiihboua Stiuadr'n rive Sfp- (nmbct 4. Tho <-li.an(» ul rtmninyind f'rritrcniea w<>re held JBbewrt the aquadton rtiitkjiiy. <Sl<c iutlach 8r»iM;?i.irt 'SS Calvrt. CAptAin Vnat*»v luu b n ruun»d Chxif r.t tbr Navi Swtan Qf tb«" SNtiltUiry AwtAUintr Adv t a ry?l.;i-»'up to Japan. Mi watt tffiit* t-'tre'nado hc?',jy!or hla iww wt 'n hr Phf B4i»t. faptiln rcflortjt lo hu 'new c'ainmaieid trvm. hta fyrro<fr,<t:ut»(» u Co*vii»uipid*» of timton.1 ; vuiot, Ai, pin hie hu held ;aiac< Octcbcr but yct PrhMr U> that CaiVlalR ivint v. ;ron>i»i.uid.ing nttiaei at iha t!tark trannpnr* USS Hcni-wo. The n-ur AinipAWtn ' iqawirai Fivii ciimm.andrr 111 lluil ff*d»- At* at the NaviiJ AcaAcmy kiaxt ]hma bwn wtd Ut* t iia» or :Mr-rlt h(«al and Uhw Kavy Cnn imcadatic-n Rthttf>n with Cr'nitrt ""V". Durlna Wotlid War 11. he.atf-i-k-m n. 1 hr di--<'!rr'ycr U&3 ;Mc;Euucn and SA Ordnnnci? 4»n<J!Ganr»«ry Offl«:rr r-n lh» iifca<f o< llbp ConiK-itu'.A'f UFAtmycr Farcv?U. S. ParEtM- nn-t. * : San Joe mayor ;aued on Calveri ktobcrl C t>o«-rr, CT-.B.vor of San Jont, Ca.Kartiia, rwrilly th" UPClll< M (UM-t of f'apt., Con'miinder Ajmphjbinia 3qu»iti<i'n 1!?lw. on board tiip allae-li tranaponrti L"SS Calvcrt. Afer limrh, ftu.qt nra»i t»si,<tii on * ahiy'a laur by Capl W S. Madrfox, ctiimmandin< effh i t of thf <;Nlv<irt SAayor kierr, w ha rrpnacnk-dt" Sun. Ji-f N; lh* Pafirk Ac*a C"»n-'] i (F?enr«of SAayan in S*n O'Mfa, FtiHu b»wn art i r<k n njitftnai andi 1 i.flfmdtumui munkjpal wwlc. < n hff phyt >«kiar h» dfhtfit th<f- 1 li<<krn»ilionfll l"anfftb» o( Myycr!. t n 'Hol'and and waa uno ffl fi'k'pirl-td t<» vwt\ (Snnar-y u eunt t cf (h W<»t German tuv<nlii»i»rit Kff <«U tfl. ""y C'Dunter-lTit<;]> U»f?i<"* agent durlnjl Wor&rt War ( ;H and rr lldlv*! r'naa(t«l Ji th<? aipprchenmoa al Ha-d vur crimniijk. l>mpilr [ wide Hcrvkc e-xpcrueticc. the mayor»8mt h»<k llad never wme-r. en boiird an arr.pliiba' oua ahip and w ijmprrwm T*-«h ht cwnpklii.iy»»<* afgani.u.ikiei [Of tix flagahlti. '» \ 83

88 . i li it Qlpfc ( hinaii wuew Frank Wtfiiflt Cipt,. ; " ' 1 "» Uarlttf biwlrvni. Cnrnuiiu. r»ti»vw) Capt. rnnk t Wlu.nt, 11» Atiin;nl» b<)ul»v*rd. u at *t«h tn Vtw Aiiminii Jnhn S)i»uter. romn>li id*i <>t thr P» tulc Dnt AmphlbKxu Fnm Cutunadu, Monitty, Jum B Oiptiiin Wlnant, who ku «*n-ikl M Chwl nt SUW lrit >uw. Wt. will Manx dulin u th» MW itwnnrndint tlicrr»( th» Nair! Amn-.undon D*pot. Concori, CiUfomu'H* u well linuwti n th» Coronadr tna tut hit ncliie (Hinirip»llvrt >n»h Coroirdo -lu» t.»»<"'. 1" rh.rh *w rfc-on'ly ervwi na pmm»nl Captun r<<x)rt«d to Ul» Ktxff n Vtbrvuy ol UU» yu uutant chirf irf rtatf (ar opcrat tow Ur hu bin cumwnrtait oth- CTT irf th- N»v] AmroUBitWB fc fat, >u, T H. ciptrtn «t thr rttack (riktliart Hen»k-«, coinmmntot Tnaipcrt Divuiim M nd AmpbtbtttUB S<iit*<t»<)<i fvw >pt*i«i. iru (ndu t tnn Uw Nw< Aw4wy, e( a( Wt d tpfft lif yan n thr N«Tr tbiml4 Ur katuiltr 4 draw* tnn Wld Wn ll h*»)v?rt w or iui <*»tn>y»n Ha linl Cfl'niftTiid <ira<i tlw A«aE«l Hari C»»rm *«r*»i<l in u'r lunn»r onln**. untit Jinu ny. W ri on rtrtoirt > ncrr otfw.t <»» ttatl n( Cam umtw 'tonnw Fapc«. Pflfk tint. til 1M» N» t>2» «< U Swvtf Vvrr* Sqvdrmi Thr*» N <»»( WaU OBb-ti C piwmtin, tt»t mt f«r Or iwt Kin* yinn h* w»< ww. *t wm.wwtfl "t «h> Nivr'i <»(?*'"''* *o*«<t«tvejk?pnwr,t ftwt<, Kii hut 4u<ir j<(nri rwl»ln< FlNirtt CA»TA<M W.O M boob fthw library bonortng Jame McNakoii ynnxt* trf <)» trt» mnia K MtWihwi l.av t-mintni M d.11 itn-.n< hi»l» lu UK CotTtWdel Pafcllr LlfrtT m '1*> itixuwjl, Bonlia "tiwn fr.r Mt miudortll iu»(i *n af-nntt nt p>»»:b*o) tmau<h rsymttrt.uy f* d>iwn atbd hicludr Naitf nlmbtia. u iwfll M Xiow nion RSCC tttt telrrtiot at (tut '** 1»pfc Mhtt Klrfill #Alh* Flower Show comniinee guet at brunch meeting Mr. Gregory Panawek, chairman of the Table Arrangement ection of the Coronado Flower Show ntwtaiawd her co-chair. man and committee women at a brunch, February 17. at 1 am., in her new home at 731 Country Club Lane. The ladie took thi opportunity to formulate plan for their ection in the forthcoming Flower Show to be held April 12 and 13. Mr. Mark E. E)«*nnett will a- it a co-chairman. The committec member include Mme. Royal L. Rutter, Charle W. Amo. Edwin Schadewald. Elliot Andrew. Oliver Coumpton. Edward Hearn, Frank Lowe, Paul Cogrove. Frank Miller, Joeph Pac, Harry Vice. Robert Merrick, Fred Snyder, Frank Gooding. Leonard Smith and Theodore Balea. 84

89 Donald V- Dill Explorer medical pot name late Coronado' new Explorer Scout unit. Medical Spe<ialty Pot 88, ha grown to 16 member, who! are beginnng their invetigation [ < of th» medical-dental proff'iion.i. Officer for the new pot, the firt pecialty group to be formed in San Diego County, ponaored by the Coronado Hopital taff, have been elected. They art: David Hancn. preident: Richard B Forward, vice preident: Philllp Sullivan, ecrct&ry: Jame R, Wlllema. treaiiurer: Robert Buxton, quartermater; Kent Crawford and Norman Aim, cabinet repreentative: Advior i Dr. Donald Dili. Quarter S. North land; aaitant advior are Curti Yeager and Marvin Nottingham. On the iponor' i.'ommittee are Levcrett Britol, chairman: Dr Jame Muihovic, inatitutional repreentative: G. W. Sfhtiert. George Buxton. Dr P. H. Morton and Dr Charle Eaton, commit- (pe member. Other member of the pot are: Rnbert L Bothwell. Gregg Mt- DonouKh. Gary Sfhlierf. Theodore M Srhultz, Robert M. Taylor, Jim Ward. Chuck Fowler, Bill M..dden and Mike Bunker..i other Scout new it hax been announced that a new potaje tiirnp. wd. y'dlow and green, ha been iued to comnwmorate the Third National Jamboree of Pakitan Boy Scout The deign how* Kirn' gun and the Boy Soout emblem. ; < 1 ',. <»l nfnia Seal drive halfway The 58th Annual Oirirtmaa Seal Campaign to rum nwney to fight Tuberculom* m other reapiratory di»ea»e» in Sit DtfO County ha paaaed the haltway point. Dr. Donald M. Dili. Coronado area chairman, reportkl recently. Thu far 38.2 contributt>r» haw givca $ ; The TuberculoME and Hwdth Aaociation of Sut Diego Couaty la ponoring the driw. While the auoclatinn dow npt Bx a goal, ita rehabilltaunn. m<dical re»earch. health cducatton, and caae-finding progrun* (tw next year will require the Ppart of a $15, budget,»11 id, adding "Rapffatory dtwca w» tourth on the lit of killeni hi the United State, Worac. d<nyntrend in the number of new tuberculoi caw diagnoeed rwry year wa revened between 1M2 nd 19S3 in many ple* (aeluding San Diego County." «t Hopital aux. meet today Memben of the?oronad6 Hoipital Auxiliary will gather for their quarterly meeting at 1:3 p m. today in the olarium of the Convalecent Wing. Gueata will be welcome to hear Dr. Paul Shoa of Mercy Hoxpital. Of particular interet, will be a report (rom waya and mean rhairman, Mr. Eugene Horton, regarding the annual Village Fair, cheduled for October 8, 9. nnd 1. Mr Amo Schaefer, of the inemberahip committee, will intniducc the following new memben: Mr. Nick Dano, Mr, Dyer De- Winter, Mr. Robert S. Kraham, Mr. Bednck P. Popelka. Mr. William A. Ward. Mra. Donald M Dili, Mr. Charlea G. Jamea, Mr Harwood H. rawrett, MiM Harriet K. Neal, Mr. Samuel H. Arthur, Mr. Louia B. Vo«t, Mn. Barry Stevena, and Mn. Fnnk Shippey. memberhip goe over top The Coronado Ditrict of the me (joronaao uuinci ot ine; Boy Scoutta o( America held it','. nnual Recognition Dinner and annual meeting. May 12, in the ' uditolium u( Central Elfinentary School. Dr Jama M. Cahill. Diatrict Chiunnan tor Coronado, wclcom- d Uu Scoutan and thanltal them for their aupport which nnwdc Coronadu a 1 per cent Scouting Community. Dr. Cahill tcporttd a record number o{ boy (wrtictpalmg and told o( the "over th* top" mord in the au»-1 fining membcrthip effort, tn hi npurt M dwtrict rhainnan. he id four Cub Scout park* and [ ix tnxhi and (our Explorer! pot* are in operation in the Coronado diatrict. i Capt. D. R. Dodaon. maiter; of ceremonie, introduced the keynote peaker. VAdm, J. B Cotwell. Comniander Amptitbiou Forccii Pacific, who addreed the Scoiiten on American Hentage. VAdm Coiwell paid pfcial tribute to the Navy peronnel and their wive who pnrtlopate n the (ifoutinfi movement in Cnronado. Many of the aim of couting parallel thoe of the Navy and j othrr annwi xrrvirc. The Boy' Sk'uut Handbook in many repect ; cituld pu for the Navy training; nianuaf for piomotiun to th*1 pet" ty officer grndu, he aid, ' AwurdK wrw Riven to Cub- ' niuter Franklin Forick-i. Ralph J. Bauni, Terry L. Lone and Jay Chrrtlnc. Al»o recognized wen Scoutnrnter San Woodhoue. Robert Boyd, Gordon Wyatt, Riuell ScAaefer, Benjamin B and Robert Logdon. Further honored were the Explorer Pot Advior John D. Moore, John Elwell, John J. Schultz and Donald M Dill. A pecial thank wa given to the Den Mother in the program for their effort in making Coronado Cub Scouter ome of the mot active in the county. RAdm. Clarence Coffin, ditrict commimiuncr, preented the Unit Award to Cubmater Jay Chritine of Cub Pack 84. The Rfv. Ken Canon gave the invociition and Henry Boney, Council Preident, intalled the incoming oficera. Miuic for th«dinner waa provided by Chief Mu'iician Tanguay and hi Com- PhibPac Band. Chairman of the dinner committee wa Ron Eve* A pecial mention wa given to RAdm. Marhall White and R- Adm. Joeph Callahan tor their uccerful cftorta mide n the Sutaining Metnberhjp Dtly 85

90 TB drive ucce The 1964 Chritma Seal campaign cloed exactly $5,33.22 ahead of the previou campaign. Dr. Coronado area chairman, reported. Receipta were only $2.579,6 behind the mot productive year to date. The campaign cloed March 31. Fahion how benefit Hopital Building Fund fi* ik<»»*l<4 f%t Mar- i Thr wondei-ful world <>( Mauru.-e Rentner... Sophie... Adele-Sinipiiuii... Purci... Mollic Parni... Yvunne... brought gaapt of ucl4[ht from an en- U-amed audwnce at the S«ka Fifth Aveniu;»lx>w taged laat. weelt at Hotel del Curunado for the bertafit of th«curonado Huapilal Building Fund. Emerging before himtnering jeweled background at gold. the lovely model exhibited a (urtune in fun and iiise of the moat triking enaamblw aver -wen un the fahion StUfff. ie froiiting on the eke prdved to t>e the penunal appt-atance uf famed California deik'n'r "Yvonne" who fominentat d her own colorful fall colle<aion of aport* and at-home apfearol that would create a plaah in any fahion pond. fr. Charlea Granzor. preridel of the poaaonng Soropttmi{ Club of Coronadu introdu»ed member of the hoapital taff and board in attendance at the how a* well a extending a.'fpeciiil welcoine to nwmben of thu-coronado Hoapital Auxiluu-y who aiiutfd on many of the coauruttee. niron and donor* to the ho»- pit* benefit included Dr. and Mrt. Jame Muhovic, WT. and MnL Event Herter, Dr. and Mr*. Donald M. Dili, Dr. and Mr». ChSrleM Eatun. Mr. and Mr*. Michfl W. ftwnd, Dr. and Mn. G<!<grge 1 ganger, Mr. and Mn. Joaaph Todaro, Dr Jeie T. Rutt an* RAdm. and Mr». Robert S. Dayi*. Al»o, Mr*. W. J. C. A<new, Met. Eugene T. Burkett, Mr. and M». Ben Cohen, Mr. and Mn. WMOTUCM ttwook dnnhk... l».,<<h»».», :fvh» MKM:» ate fflninitfl W a e iwtott t h Pti<ttN nk» itttina'* wunl ww rto krtowft cuow far it. Th* erwrtmmt w»» b»l MM, iwhtton of»«tontl, <! ww followed by the <(»i of t*te NmUorin, whw paautfi W wcvwm v> cold, dry mou»khiin air. Wwn ft wu dineowriii that *ur»wy eoxtm 1» <»*<Uhw.! Meantmw, the dwth n w»!»n«win» «ateady ttoulftf. h Ae wrty W». t»h» dnth n(» bwa fo 1U dranuithmflsr. ffltw "mincto" dhtiga ik>ni*ut(m pw-amtnonrilcylte cht (?A», Ukrf rtnfcnnycin www fcuntfl tof be extraonttnarlty tiiui. NM Ml hop w<r» rriwd thrtl whhin a r«hrtiv»ly»bort ttnaafl (Uftetwriona would be «Mritete<t] ia thi* country. Thtg waa not to be, (tor tasbwfculoi germa tend to develop naiatance to the three druga. n CaBfornia alone 7.3 per cent at the new tuberculoii patient* an nwtant to the "iniracle" drug* and phyician muat try other and ometime difficult dru to treat them. n many area including San Bte» County the down. trend in dfttr wa nww»d be» tween 1963 and The battle continue and ow fcwt for ftutda la g»at We am now in UK fotlow-up phae of Ac <8th' Annual CftriatrruM Se Campaltrt and hope the people of W\a community will rwpond generouty to our rtmindera., t i never too ta» to tight (Oj- Berculoaw antf other rfvr»ary d««u«nk hi the United S«w> Owy MM towttk on th» trt el killer. Sincerely your, Donald M. DiU, M.D. Coronado Area ChaUnr 86

91 '"*r; -, -.»> 1. \ *.- ' itnf<, H*mft«, hrwurw; DoiwM M. Dili, 2nd vk» pfwldrt; Nl» rt Fe»»yt*t, prldtont; and Charl Fr, ** wte» pniddmtt.l? a; Chamber of Commerce 1968 Officer i <,. Si th SaeNi»*nC«W l~l»4«ctfcfm h*.. X pwff»n OfmbT» *t Maiiuin Vilt»B» fvln Pmirfnrt, Nn- f»«rr K«r.»««r«>,»hTii t*drt<«*n itiiwr will b» )*i»ud*nt. M,, 2nd Vlc» txn'wil by rfw mutir't nt Jw M»wdr»»<w MNl l>nu*nt Un«ltoW«f«- pltkn Jakn Hut- hi*»!»<»«vwhx»w n<w«ltu< llitt MH, f to; PNtN «<i«, Mn<t», h g 1(1 Ul» 43*-3»M. >(«««W*ii» *t»ic««k* M Or CCC N<». Fnrtk Jinlnk pcc*issbrf- af aala dinneii lnkbe,»ew!>k«sk*iani,( f.]siiqtkl!y runiy5i w to-; «tauwt prerident at tha CorotxrioS Chamber of ConnnBrce Saturd; [night at a fla party dinner t! M»xic«n VUl«g»'» Attec Room.l when a capty crowd heud J<W) Mondngoa and hl» Ma<ic Vlolina in a procnm <rf nctalcttl miuic. t WM cahtd COC S9Wf-\ ng," and Mn. ronyth prpmi»ds m«ny mon uf th»m n bur tcnnl of offtce. natalled wen: Charlw Free a* drat vice pwri-i jdent Dr. Donald Dili M Mcond viuii brnwent,, { Joh Rartiwtt M tremurer. M. Phtton tvit u»cntm7» 87

92 'SPR AD THE COSTS, VOTE THE BONW n«, - nr«mt ««Dear Mr. WUUanu: am writing to tdl»w» <*rt am in favor of tb» band t»ue that bwig ubn»jltte4 J*me <1 tor tb«tchool. t»eem» evident to nr that Conno < la (or tlr dpu] du» t» the btmt f ha»e now people haf in Caroaado, we «n gotng to fve more»chool childrun and we need clamrooma and faciuuea for them. Our chool ytem h long enjoyed a reputation of on» of the beat, and for one want to our fine educatioari program continued. iindentand tjut tfw pppo-i nitt* of th» bcwd lacttaa»rp- ( PON tfw* tk» dlrtrict u K» it) r*»rv««to buud tu* buudiag Tlito down't nakt (ood NBW to] me for am couvinwd that the ditrict may a d rewv for potgible future emergwuae*. < There arc a few who propoae a Ugh tut nt» (or 6 to t? n totwd of th«bond luir. A U<h tm mte for a l»ort tvm cnuu <l uc» tbi* cboel bi«t (<, ti» Bay Nafair bn«u» it lcrct ttaancial woblbuily upon a few who will ue the gcbool in the imin«<uate tutur* nlhtrl Uun apnaikffir th«i»»oi»<mu(y ] to the prwent and future yeaqfc t ia my undentaadtng th*t ttw d4«t t»x» far *cto9<i b»- c»u»c of Uu bond wue woud wiwwt to tow 4<Un ywr pnmmy (8 to (W tor inert of tu here tn Coronado. from vhlt have *«n <rf the plan and know of the cot, think it ii a xcellent bargain, and houm be utilized» an aaurance ff our continued excellent educ»- tiawd program. Sincerely your. Ounrid DU4 M. D: i, $tw 8ea er SUw tlfilvr. A natfonal.inyd,. WM jcootond on M County Boy Scout» of Amcri<;a le<id«r«at their SUver Beavr Dinner. A capacity crowd of 3,- leader and their wive witimnued the pmentation at the Community Concoure. Recipienti of the h4(h honor [included Dr. o< Ccronado. T»- Medical taff appointment Dr George M. Sanger, newly elected preident of the Coronado Hopital Medical taff, ha announced appointment for the new year. Serving with Dr. Sanger on the medical taff i Dr. Donald M. Dill, vice-preident and preident elect for 1979; and Dr. John A. Kerley, ecretary and treaurer. Appointment a chief of ervice are: Dr. Bloom A. Sanger, chief or aneuieiology; i Dr. Martin E. Wicariu, chief of dental taff; Dr. j Donald A Vance, chief! of emergency taff; Dr. Jame Muhovic, chief of family practice. Dr. Robert H. Rexrode, chief of internal medicine; Dr. Jame P. Moran, chief of obtetric and gynecology; and Dr. John V. Banta, chief of orthopedic. Alo Dr. Jame R. Nickel, chief of pathology; Dr. Ethel M. Water, chief of pediatric; Dr. Joeph Cornfeld, chief of radiology; Dr. Victor C. Stratton, chief of aurgery; and Dr. Robert T. Plumb, chief ot urology. n addition to erving a medical taff preident. Dr. Sanger will f (u> t irrtifl "f 1 if a i committee; tiie profeional activitie review committee; and a chairman of the medical education, library, reearch and diater committee. Other committee chairmen are Dr. John A Kerley, utilization review committee; Dr. Ramon E. Moncada, medical care evaluation committee; Dr. Bloom A. Sanger, credential committee; Dr. Jame P. Moran, patient care, pharmacy and medical record committee; and Dr. John C. Schmidt. technical ervice committee. Dr Jame R. Nickel wa appointed chairman of the tiue and tranfuion committee: the infection control committee; and mortality and morbidity committee 88

93 Real etate brief (or a tranfer tax value of M5. The buyer were Richard M. and Phylli M. Pittenger of Calabaa. Stewart S. and Mary Jane Etdridge have purchaed the condominium at 177 Avenida del Mundo from Elwood G. and Bertha M. Childer. Donald M. Dll! ha» purchaed the home at 767 B Ave., from Jame and William Richardon Jr., and Betti M. Richardon. Tax value or $12,. Coronado Development Co, old a eventh floor unit in the latet tower at the Coronado Shore to Edward G. and Ruth M. Hale of Salt Lake City for a tranfer tax value of»185,. A 14th floor unit wa old to Dr. Albert and Helen Sherhow for a tranfer tax value of tl 55,. The condominium in Coronado Cay at 75 Antigua Court wa old for a tranfer tax value of (13, by David S. Lane. Buyer were Jame R. and Ellen L. Stem berg. John E. and Florence E. Whitely have purchaed the condominium at 821 E Ave.. from Verne E. and Barbara A. Geiinger and Raymon M. and Lynne A. Perei for a tranfer tax value of $15.. Coronado Development Co. old five unit in the newet of the Shore condominium tower (or a total tranfertax value of (85,. Three of the unit were acquired by Panama corporation. A 12th floor unit wa bought by California Beach Corp. for a tax value of $17.. The ame firm bought an llth floor unit (or a tranfer tax value of?18.. Glorietta Bay Corp. acquired a 1th floor unit for a tranfer tax value of $165.. An llth floor unit wa old for a tranfer tax value of $15, to Arthur R. and Ethel Krame of Chargin, Ohio. Abdulamir and Emat Smoghi bought a fifth floor unit for a tranfer lax value of tko.ooo. Dr. Diil named hopital chief of taff» - j1"11 ir<d,.,.<i.1 *?'".!w:»»< - ;.: n»» - ***<».. d 1*,< «t *-:% tir.t'a;. i.- f'..'* -ff <tfr*<i*» h'»*»-t» iw"'lt ;:,,:,.. -riw )) inlm E»~»KJW -.i An T:.r ;<!:.. "M it rvt x»*<>_»:»; < <hn M»3 :y fc*fi>. 1.<» '.-.. u 'K > to trf 'w-t ir l«ia..<t't»...«>>r 'r< irilf t< gpaettfrn fctwe. Atrf» r«<nw<<-* tk!i»<n.t *» k «*«lt*' < kl l.r<'i»'*. *l4d-:»( *b»oc<t-)in t t.tmw -**!»< NKO.T.r **4 *< Stfc.-! **<<' -..i<t( U+d-Rlit--K- O*?. i tuiitu "At llii.4ttrjl" *? 'A* <!MJ rt*' iiri K &'<tc<< ni n rniii?«uta litim 111,J» ;<t» iui uii l»- M r fur«tf «-*r»ir i<»- r»< c«t:*t<*m,rt Vl i.1 TWM > Cro C'y Mariner hot WiEvaingwFtev.Waddy & -»thnt(*h*.ni fc.< M4»i4 t *'>»r» m«3 JP 'j«- <!.i.,...rin.<t>.<. <*»*1 dl.,<u - ~@ o-*»< "tmk» «ir K J!'..'" gl i.sy i?1 Si'SS... ;:' '" ;1 A-..*< JT ftal»)1!-). :111»*«t»««' auiuui.in t xt -i tr«?».* k«?4u< NnUt nn. hrlliu 1 S«nrr tu»»<, f*: V»Vf *».»«n. M- t;t»»-yi rv.tnffcut it. 1»!-< :- ' " M } NttKt»«r fwff St.lHKM.1 b 3*3 :Tre.»f B. M» it r'luw d ai ti, tinnl" *<ii «' - y :..; win r-t ni ".-<MU> ktm. M» f-ii tv.ac b*t»yi no- tnxai k lih'-fl * -< '.-. tf >* :.!<.»» *i..t»«nb.;u;«1'xi ( -»»ci>ktu.an tf «!<'» «ts» n <l u<wi a -MKf lu.1»ni >.<> U»» W..M JM A Vw -MUtot t Kilt Atftn. pjba'i -< ' > ' *. 4 ff».n»"\a,» i»»-r*f :"n in *fua*» ft«ni»»l»»1 "-..<''." -" - W MttU.UN t*..u-» «< *%? 4.<*i!t*<1; iuuui --rt- - *. mh i*. -..it, fwllt g a-<*«,-i>. a <*»< it- im. t: n»..< lrw>»<i tir k-<» tini.- t. laut.;*uwllm»«** *n* *«flfptifod U»*«l."-«t.ntiln gr.,,'«i? AyMrt'a nfc**nm»id >»«anrf to H ar»< tomf.r * )»» r«ut rltui t nt ll-'l t.1 1» Dr. Sar"b to peak ai'<» lfc i.+wif 11 itw»t<-n:«a tit TN»». * Mr <-.:r-.aat--» hv to Sacred Mean PTG»Hf»«a >*-.«1*» Jyv.i MU M *1 t* *;fc'» MN "t * -»-», n«r-i( <» ' KJ. :»t+< M»dC*r liaitrt,.i«'fd!..»tiua<.l-'mi 't» t.»i,rti l iji»;' la.ni i«>--» l-uuiu!>» <" * *««ru-.ki ),> mic< N1,Tnrn Bfr* );.A t». Dr. DonciSd Dili elected medical chtet oi taff Dr. hu been iiutatlcd a* mwlical chwf of aaft >N 1 r <.1S n4 A»..t, y.fy ' 4 V..! Ur, r'yluua Lu>»< Coroniulu HoipKal,»uccwding Dr. JoiKph Ewinj. Thn a the third time Dr..1,1. h&i been clcckd to head actiitin j :1»f the mtdical itaft pr ~ ha< as.w ttmd»* cwdt of ramiiy prauit at CorotUuto HiMpiial, Hr fini aimc '11 <>'oronado M Na'.y flitht wigeon. and hw bwn in practicr hwc for the put luo <t<c<kte He WM ydtflcd from Jcffcrwn Mtdjad CoU<»e in Philadctplua TUF ;<1 89

94 Coronado Hopital announce new board of director r.<3*.a* f tl* )»»<»* dut ' tilk. imka>u.'v X.w*n».'t <K >-wv».. * <in w hwf. t an«ur*» '** >wl M '* NNN» WW hb t*m*l o*aw'».*(>ny»-mn<i A»»fl>t«Ac»w»t ncawit '<*»» ht<ft A*** tn itukyto'n* fmtrf U kt.» >» *>? * < i bt.'uk OBNr*ar» tf * >»«. ir ""'.'1. n»< A* nnttoar * teii r< lfc-**ftft?a Wh Dhl»1)f<M' *t t rfxi»» ; *» -xratn. *f<*» '<ft;-«* <;..<». \fv **»<(! tw T*. Mfc (*N(Ui ht rfwi -t.wn.cn N1 t» i *.» >*. p«t»fw». ha,m.w..-unh. «N-N <»J tirfu» <.* N»kH»ft, U- tilb. )b* >N J tn v*l 4»*.» (a WldlM ll toil l. f**. *»»» to»to.mm fa f SUU l;; MN f. -rwitt «*»»»4<i,«,uuw ' h - Al... l*< Kuki M t., MNk. pt<m» to *» *tort*i MA. lihit Prtn M i N»T * t f;.:lr<?*(nt tlwo* Kit* <««n>*»uwt ttouifia.«> «*i tw **»T tw*w«y; Ma.» ia. *B.M UM» *nma»*v.»wt nunkv v»n at )M»* <.Jkn»t K tw* <», u i. 1 (»»<;1» <N»*B.»»ttWN*t*fa«t.t»Wnt N»«N t»tl NT'i».1 -nf Ywn toii.tintnonh-i»*?» NU.t»r.-»(«** \t>a»lt»fc«"'»-t,'r'< i t. in*. lt<l(; Nk»*UKt*"n ' h*w»w»rfn <Mh-* CT«a»*A-»A«t*»»T xw t-» N tucb<elntt>»»wntt <«;u*ta». Mwawt fi.j(n»»n»n»»*«wm»** -.. >h *>-. W» *n *** < <b 3*.»»>i ti»»t1l. W<h»»» >~>n.«ni nii, t. l»w l.lirllll... i-...; '~ ' -f iua.f u»f t«. «l«in tf»t wi *t Ttt < fa*j, Hi. A».*». *LN< irtin» **. <»** ' ~" *»»*<»»»)».(UtflM»<.t *.ll»itaiw>'l» Tte hwcmto rf ** ftoua ciantwi ;<»W*N!. M»r» tmi ln k*"><«l»t«**»»»«*n ub>»((»nm>»(i**. *,< i»w <»»*<<n* r»». Lk.i. "*Tr.i niu..d,.nb» «XAV.u.gi;» R P p A r Dt i;(q{ht modrtd (he flotary Good tw ANtd twm ROUUT ntudeot Dan Gtauler. Suteutltfdphaia 9

95 Gerald M. Schwartz \Gerald Schwart:. < '.i.i'.-i,.t:' ntllitimc j Corxn.itld rckjrnt. Calitiirnia nalive.,ind Worltl \V4r wii S i\yv\ Vclcrll. pam'tl pr.kl-lull\ in hi --lccp oil kvrmhcr "th He vy. ninety tivc year <il<t.imf hi>. pirit <*;i-< rt.t» i> lo OM; rn Hr i iir\i\t:it h\ hi> ifc e( CormwJJewef )uur Jewelry ConuSant Repair,.appraial, Rctringlng. Watch Repair.. Cutom Deigned Jewelry igreti Walker <»iq-»w-(r7.w P.U.BOK l(tu*(w.tunin.m»n»217«k'nnr. hi*, tl.iuyhu'r NK>.. rn JTT\. '.tcp-m>n\ (.'hrintophcr nd Rii. hard. h\ iiiiiiifrou'. r.iiutthil ilrcn. i;rr.it i.indchildrfii. ffv.tf yiv.it yriintli.hililrcn. jnit h<> >.iuinl- ]l. ' nvrd-- ynil rfl.itnc OMT ihc t.ixirm- iil hi ninv plu itci.iulf'. on cjtih hi pllhh)l nl.inil i.-pcrifik-i.-'. '.Mri.- ni)nit uiid ri.'m.ifitini; tli: Au un 4 id tr,i»ctt.'i kind.pttri'.mun. d + American Heart AMtciutiun F.arng Wi'' C SciSi S"3 3'WSi. S B@MirtnttiA'H>liteiltoe«;»N»«i»B 9 pniiiil N.iv iti.iii MTML' D thr Stltllh '.K.ltlt C 'Aht-'ll \nirr»..i inily itul t..ill on tt< iir-.it rt ycilfl.ilkitl.iixl >»< w,i>>.1 MK i-rtiit htimtif-mti.in \»tlh iiitcrr'.t ihtoiirhnil C.ilitrmt.i «C \».1>..1 t"\ lllf tni'.hrxl anii t.iniij; p.irrnt Aith.1 quiet '.i.'nc.i hiiiiior.iiiil,1 itiinili.tliill'k 'uh fl-m.' l>ultl"lk»11 tllc\ K>N~lhlll iic< tie h.iil.m jhitil\ tii put.1 <m(lr oil fiur t.icc or hnne tear'. lii your CM'S Kf 'A ill bt.' lllls'.ttl.l()lj lovvil h\ lh«<.r Alu> li.ncw hiin.l.uh) in i>ii» hr.tlt ami )lllui! pitll Aill live un A im-niofil 'crmci. w.f hi.'l»i.it Mir.ini.u Ndiion.il Ccniclciyiw Uctx-tnbei ;<'(h *lh:rt: tv >A4 laitl to ret. 91

96 THS PAGE NTENTONALLY LEFT BLANK 92

97 CORONADO HSTORC RESOURCE COMMSSON AGENDA TEM Public Hearing Regular Meetin December 6,217 HR MARNA AVENUE: NOMNATON FOR HSTORC DESGNATON (DETERMNATON OF HSTORC SGNFCANCE) FOR THE PROPERTY ADDRESSED AS48 MARNA AVENUEND LOCATED N THE R-1A (SNGLE FAMLY RESDENTAL) ZONE RECOMMENDATON: Determine that the tructure meet the criteria to be deignated a a Hitoric Reource in accordance with Chapter 84.1 of the Municipal Code, by adopting the attached reolution (Attachment 1). PUBLC NOTCE: A public notice wa publihed in the Coronado Eagle & Journal and mailed to all property owner within 3 feet of the boundarie of the project. BACKGROUND: The applicant ha requeted thi review in aociation with a nomination of the property a a Hitoric Reource. A determination that the property meet two or more of the deignation criteria will reult in hitoric deignation of the dwelling, and regulation of the property a a Hitoric Reource. A determination that the property doe not meet two or more of the deignation criteria will reult in the property being determined to be non-hitoric, no further regulation under the hitoric reource code will be required, and the property owner may preerve, demolih, alter, or otherwie develop the property conitent with applicable zoning and building code. On October 27, 217, the applicant ubmitted a Nomination for Hitoric Deignation (Determination of Hitoric Significance) application for the property, which i included a Attachment 2. The ubject property i located at 548 Marina Avenue and conit of a two-tory dwelling contructed in The building permit hitory for the property i included in Attachment 2 and 3. The unadopted Hitoric Reource nventory completed in the 198' by Source Point gave the building a hitorical value rating of 3. A rating of 3 indicated the tructure wa built before 1942; i in good phyical condition; ha had minor modification to it original exterior appearance; i repreentative of a recognized tyle or local vernacular tyle; would qualify a a contributing tmcture to a potential hitoric ditrict. The Source Point DPR form for thi property i included in Attachment 3. The unadopted Coronado Property Review (CPR) Lit compiled in 28 identified the property a potentially hitorically ignificant. t hould be noted that the Source Point rating and Coronado Property Review tatu are provided for informational purpoe only. The Source Point urvey wa not officially adopted for ue a a urvey document and i known to have ome factual error; however, it doe indicate 93

98 what the hitoric condition of the dwelling wa conidered to be in The Coronado Property Review urvey wa, alo, not adopted by City Council and i ued a an informational reource only. ANALYSS: n accordance with Chapter 84.1 of the Municipal Code, in order for the tructure to be deignated a Hitoric Reoiirce by the Hitoric Reource Commiion, it mut meet two or more of the adopted deignation criteria. Following i a brief analyi of the property under each criterion. CRTERON A - t exemplifie or reflect pecial element of the City' military, cultural, ocial, economic, political, aethetic, engineering, or architectural hitory. The applicant indicate that the property i hitorically ignificant under Criterion A a a Special Element of the City' cultural and ocial hitory becaue the owner of the property at the time of contmction, John Jerauld ngle, later built a mirror image of the ubject home at 133 Adella Avenue; becaue the home wa included on home tour in 1965 and 1974; and becaue meeting for local community organization were held at the home in 1948, 1965, and The ubject property wa owned by John Jerauld ngle, a local real etate profeional, when it wa contructed in According to the original building permit, ngle contracted with a contractor by the name ofmerrick to contruct the home. Nine year later, in 1924, ngle i lited a ownerbuilder of the dwelling at 133 Adella Avenue, which i a mirror image of the ubject dwelling. Coronado' adopted hitoric deignation criteria guideline tate that ignificance aociated with a builder i appropriately conidered under Criterion D, therefore thi aociation i dicued under Criterion D. The nomination include newpaper article that document the incluion of the home on the Coronado Home Tour in 1965 and the Coronado Woman' Club Home Tour in 1974, and article that note that the County YMCA held one of their weekly meeting there in 1948, the Newcomer Club coffee wa held there in 1965, and that the Coronado Woman' Club held a new member' coffee there in Coronado' adopted hitoric deignation criteria guideline tate that in order to be hitorically ignificant under Criterion A, a property mut be ditinct among other of it kind or urpa the uual in ignificance. The nomination doe not provide information on how thi property urpae in ignificance the many other home included on annual home tour, or location of regular meeting of ocial organization in Coronado. Baed upon the infomiation preented in the nomination, it doe not appear that the property i hitorically ignificant under Criterion A a a Special Element of the City' hitory. Baed on the reearch conducted and information preented in the application, taff doe not agree that the property i hitorically ignificant under Criterion A. n order to deignate the ubject property under Criterion A, the Commiion would need to determine that the property poee aethetic, engineering or architectural propertie urpaing other of it kind; or ignificant military, cultural, economic, or political aociation uch that it exemplifie or reflect pecial element of the City' hitory, and evidence would be needed to upport that determination. 94

99 CRTERON B - t i identified with a peron() or an event() ignificant in local, State, or national hitory. The application ubmitted by the property owner indicate that the property i hitorically ignificant under Criterion B for it aociation with property owner Captain John Horace Everon, who received the Navy Cro for ditinguihed ervice a Commanding Officer of the US S Fanning during World War. The nomination alo note that Everon wa reactivated to military ervice after hi retirement, during World War. n an article publihed in the Coronado Eagle and Journal in 25, Captain Everon' on, Landi, tate that hi father wa in charge of the coat of Panama and Southern California during World War. Captain Everon' obituary note that during World War he erved a peronnel officer of the 11th Naval Ditrict in San Diego and a ditrict intelligence officer of the 12 Naval Ditrict in San Francico. Staff conducted additional reearch into Captain Everon' military ervice during the time he owned and occupied the ubject property, tarting in 1924, which i included in Attachment 3. During thi time, military record document that Captain Everon wa the Commander of the 11th Naval Ditrict, Commander in charge of the U. S. Navy Educational Office, and Commander at the Naval War College in Newport, Rhode land. He retired on June 3, t appear that Captain Everon erved again a Commander of the 11th Naval Ditrict at variou time during , for a total of 8 month and 16 day, returning to retirement in While it i clear that Captain John Everon wa a ditinguihed military officer, baed on the information preented in the application, it doe not appear that the property i hitorically ignificant under Criterion B for thi aociation a Captain Everon did not reide at the ubject property during hi ervice during World War, for which he received hi ditinguihed ervice award. No information wa provided in the application or dicovered by taff regarding ignificant contribution to hitory that Captain Everon may have made during hi military ervice a Commander of the 1 1th Naval Ditrict or the U. S. Navy Educational Office. n order to be hitorically ignificant under Criterion B, the Commiion would need to determine that the property i aociated with a peron or event who made hitorically ignificant contribution to local, tate, or national hitory, and evidence would be needed to upport that determination. Generally, the property that would be deignated for it aociation with an important individual would be the exiting property that i mot cloely identified and aociated with the peron' productive life, whether that i their home, office, laboratory, etc. CRTERON C - t poee ditinctive characteritic of an architectural tyle, and i valuable for the tudy of a type, period, or method of contruction and ha not been ubtantially altered. The application tate that the property i hitorically ignificant a an example of the Prairie tyle. Staff agree a follow: The Prairie tyle wa developed in the late 19th century by Midwetern architect, mot notably Frank Lloyd Wright. The tyle wa intended to be a truly original North American tyle, free from the influence of earlier Claical architectural tyle. Character defining feature of the Prairie Style include emphai on horizontal line; two tory maing with one tory porche or 95

100 wing, flat or low-pitch hipped roof; broad, boxed, overhanging eave; window grouped in horizontal band; emphai on olid contruction and craftmanhip; and lack of ornate ornamentation. Like the Art and Craft movement of John Rukin and William Morri in England and Gutav Stickley in America during the mid and late 18'; the Prairie Style promoted importance of organic deign through emphai on implicity in form; the importance of quality hand-craftmanhip; and "truth in material", that i, allowing a material to diplay it natural qualitie rather than covering it up with ornate detail. The Prairie Style enjoyed popularity nationwide during the early 2 century. Locally, the Prairie Style wa epecially popular in San Diego' Miion Hill neighborhood, and example of the tyle are alo frequently found in North Park, South Park, Golden Hill, and Point Loma. Additional information on the Prairie tyle i included in Attachment 3. The ubject dwelling exhibit character defining feature of Prairie tyle. The maing i two tory with a very hallow pitch hipped roof; the fa9ade i aymmetrical, with a front porch upported by maive quare pillar; window are double hung with multi light ahe, arranged in grouping of two or three in many location; ingle tory projection are preent on both ide elevation; exterior finih i tucco, with no ornamentation other than a belt coure preent below the window. When taff i conidering whether modification to a tructure are ubtantial for the purpoe of evaluation under Criterion C, the nature, extent, and viibility of the modification are examined within the context of the Secretary of the nterior' Standard. Modification aociated with maintenance and repair, uch a re-roofing in kind, or replacement in kind of deteriorated architectural detail are not conidered ubtantial. Likewie, addition to the rear of a tructure that are not viible from the public right of way, and addition or modification that are conitent with the Secretary of the nterior' Standard, are not conidered ubtantial. However; change to the front of a tructure, addition that overwhelm the original tructure, modification that are not conitent with the Secretary of the nterior' Standard, or cumulative modification that reult in change to more than half of the original hitoric tmcture are generally conidered ubtantial and the property will not be conidered hitorically ignificant under Criterion C. Until 22, exterior modification to the dwelling were minimal. Variou interior repair and remodel took place and a rear family room wa contructed and a un room wa demolihed in n 22, modification took place which altered the hitoric appearance of the dwelling. The original wood window were replaced with clad window; the tucco belt coure wa modified to only be preent below the window, rather than running acro the length of the building facade; and the center column wa removed from the front porch. While thee modification impact the hitoric integrity of the dwelling, the replacement window were kept within the original opening and the opening frame were left intact; and the modification of the belt coure and removal of the center column do not adverely impact the dwelling uch that it doe not exhibit ufficient character defining feature of the Prairie tyle. Staff doe recommend that if the property owner hould chooe to apply for a Mill Act Agreement in the future, a requirement of the agreement will be to retore the dwelling baed upon hitoric photograph, including retoration of the center porch column, belt coure, and replacement of all clad window viible from the public right of way with hitorically appropriate true wood true divided 96

101 light window. However, in it current condition, the dwelling exhibit character defining feature of the Prairie tyle, i valuable for the tudy of reidential contruction dating from 1915, and ha not been ubtantially altered. n order to deignate the property under Criterion C, the Commiion would need to determine that the ubject dwelling poee ditinctive characteritic of an architectural tyle, i valuable for the tudy of a type, period, or method of contruction, and ha not been ubtantially altered, and evidence would be needed to upport that determination. CRTERON D - t i an example of the notable work of a builder, deigner, architect, artian or landcape profeional. The applicant tate that the property i ignificant under Criterion D a an example of the notable work of John Jerauld ngle, who the applicant identifie a the builder of the dwelling. The nomination note that ngle came to San Diego with hi family in 1913, worked a deputy City Attorney in San Diego for three year before moving to Coronado and tranitioning to a career in real etate. The nomination note that two known work by ngle remain intact, the ubject property and the dwelling at 133 Adella Avenue. No documentation wa provided in the nomination regarding John Jerauld ngle, or hi body of work a a builder. The original building permit for the property identifie a builder by the name of Merrick a the contractor, and identifie John Jerauld ngle a the property owner. ngle i imilarly lited a the property owner for the two other known propertie aociated with him that have been previouly reviewed by the Hitoric Reource Commiion. The dwelling at 1125 Alameda wa contmcted in 1912, and ngle wa lited a the property owner, with no contractor lited on the permit. The property wa reviewed by the Commiion and determined to be non-hitoric. The dwelling at 133 Adella Avenue wa contmcted in 1924, and i the property that the applicant refer to a the mirror image of the ubject property at 548 Marina Avenue. ngle wa lited a the property owner and contractor on the permit for thi property, and it wa deignated by the Hitoric Reource Commiion under both Criterion B and Criterion D for it aociation with John Jerauld ngle. Note that the deignation of 133 Adella Avenue took place in 25, prior to the adoption of Coronado' deignation criteria guideline, which etablihed guidance for determining ignificance under the deignation criteria and prohibited the ue of one piece of evidence to meet two of the deignation criteria. Staff reearch on John Jerauld ngle indicate that he wa bom in ndiana in By 1894, he wa living in San Diego at Seventh and Ah Street, and lited hi occupation a "tudent" on the Voting Regiter. n 1895, he received hi licene to practice law in California. No infonnation wa found by taff regarding hi law career. The 191 federal cenu lit ngle reiding at 2524 Second Street in San Diego and working in real etate. All ubequent information found by taff indicate hi career wa a in real etate, and no information wa found indicating he wa known a a contractor or builder, other than hi liting of himelf a owner and contractor for the building permit for 133 Adella Avenue. ngle i not lited on the building pemiit a the builder of the ubject property at 548 Marina Avenue. t appear, baed on the known information, that he had the property contructed by another builder a a peculative invetment, renting out the 97

102 property for everal year before elling the property to the firt owner and occupant. Captain Everon. See attachment 3 for additional information on John Jerauld ngle. Baed upon thi information, it doe not appear that the ubject property at 548 Marina Avenue i hitorically ignificant under Criterion B a an example of the notable work of John Jerauld ngle, a the builder identified on the permit i Merrick. Staff conducted curory reearch into the builder identified a Merrick (attachment 3), and found that during thi time period, a contractor by the name of Archibald Merrick wa reiding in Coronado at 81 Glorietta Boulevard. Archibald Merrick wa bom in ndiana in 1872, and i identified a a carpenter a early a 191, when he wa reiding at 182 Burton Avenue in Eat St. Loui, llinoi, according to the federal cenu. By 199, Merrick wa living in Oakland and working a a builder, followed by a move to Lo Angele 191, where he i identified a a building contractor in City Directory and cenu record. City Directorie from 1914 through 1916 place Merrick and hi family in Coronado, where he worked a a building contractor and carpenter. By 1917, Merrick had relocated back to Oakland and wa working a an architect. Thi information indicate that Merrick lived and worked in the San Diego area for only a hort period, and wa tranitioning from a career a a building contractor to a career a an architect. t i alo clear that John Jerauld ngle replicated Merrick' work when he contructed a property at 133 Adella Avenue in 1924, indicating that Merrick' deign and workmanhip for 548 Marina Avenue wa till conidered ucceful enough to be replicated nine year after contruction. While other work that may have been contructed by Merrick during hi hort reidency in Coronado are unknown, baed upon known information, the ubject property can be conidered an example of the notable work of the builder, Archibald Merrick, and i hitorically ignificant under Criterion D. n order to be ignificant under Criterion D, the Commiion would need to determine that the property i a notable work of a builder, deigner, architect, artian, or landcape profeional, and evidence would be needed to upport that determination. CRTERON E - t ha been lited or formally determined eligible for the California Regiter a et forth in Section of the California Public Reource Code (a amended from time to time). The ubject property i not lited or determined eligible for the California Regiter, and therefore doe not appear to be hitorically ignificant under Criterion E. CONCLUSON: Staff recommend that the property be hitorically deignated, a the property meet two of the Coronado hitoric deignation criteria, a outlined in the criteria analyi above. f additional infomiation regarding hitoric ignificance under any of the deignation criteria i required in order for the Commiion to make a determination, additional information and analyi hould be requeted from the applicant. f the Commiion detennine through the public hearing proce that the property meet, or doe not meet, the criteria to be deignated a a Hitoric Reource, the Commiion hould adopt or modify the attached reolution making the appropriate finding, upported by fact, for aid 98

103 determination, and addre each of the adopted deignation criteria. The deciion of the Commiion hall become final 1 day after the adoption of the reolution unle a notice of appeal to the City Council i filed with the City Clerk. A deignated Hitoric Reource i entitled to all of the benefit and retriction of hitoric deignation a outlined in Chapter 84.1 and in Chapter 84.2 of the Municipal Code and mut comply with the requirement of the California Environmental Quality Act. f the property i deignated a a Hitoric Reource, thi action i final unle appealed within 1 day of the Commiion' action and overturned by the City Council. Any modification to the Hitoric Reource would require conitency with the Secretary of the nterior' Standard, and approval by the Hitoric Reource Commiion. The applicant mut file a Hitoric Alteration Permit and undertake environmental review under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) in order to proceed with the demolition of the property. Benefit of deignation, including but not limited to zoning exception, parking exception, and Special Ue Permit, are ubject to approval at noticed public hearing and are not a guarantee of deignation. Pleae ee the attached reolution, with the taff recommendation incorporated, for conideration. f the Commiion wihe to make a determination other than the taff recommendation, the attached reolution hould be modified accordingly. The application, photograph and micellaneou document ubmitted with the application are attached for additional information. Attachment: 1. Reolution with taff recommendation 2. Nomination for Hitoric Deignation 3. Staff Reearch 99

104 Attachment 1 RESOLUTON NO. HR A RESOLUTON OF THE HSTORC RESOURCE COMMSSON OF THE CTY OF CORONADO DETERMNNG THAT THE DWELLNG ADDRESSED AS 548 MARNA AVENUE LOCATED N THE R-1A (SNGLE FAMLY RESDENTAL) ZONE MEETS THE CRTERA TO BE DESGNATED AS A CORONADO HSTORC RESOURCE WHEREAS on October 27, 217, the property owner ubmitted a Nomination for Hitoric Deignation (Determination of Hitoric Significance) application in accordance with Chapter 84.1 of the City ofcoronado Municipal Code; and WHEREAS, on December 6, 217 the Hitoric Reource Commiion of the City of Coronado held a public hearing on HR at which time all peron deiring to be heard were heard, and WHEREAS, evidence wa ubmitted and conidered to include without limitation: 1. Nomination for Hitoric Deignation Application HR ; 2. Oral tetimony; 3. Hitoric Reource Commiion taff report dated December 6, 217; 4. Additional written information and photograph provided by the applicant; NOW, THEFEFORE, BE T RESOLVED that the Hitoric Reource Commiion of the City of Coronado find the property at 548 Marina Avenue hall be deignated a a Hitoric Reource becaue it meet two of the following criteria: a) No evidence wa preented in the application that indicate that the property exemplifie or reflect a pecial element of the City' military, cultural, ocial, economic, political, aethetic engineering, or architectural hitory; b) No evidence wa preented in the application that indicate that the property i hitorically ignificant for aociation with an individual or event ignificant in local, tate, or national hitory; c) The property i hitorically ignificant under Criterion C a the dwelling exhibit character defining feature of the Prairie tyle, i valuable for the tudy of reidential architecture dating from 1915, and ha not been ubtantially modified; d) The property i hitorically ignificant under Criterion D a an example of the notable work of the builder, Archibald Merrick, a the property owner, John Jerauld ngle, replicated Merrick' work when he contmcted a property at 133 Adella Avenue in 1924, indicating that Merrick' deign and workmanhip for 548 Marina Avenue wa till conidered ucceful enough to be replicated nine year after contruction; e) The building ha not been lited or formally determined eligible for the California Regiter a et forth in Section of the California Public Reource Code. 1

105 NOW, THEREFORE, BE T FURTHER RESOLVED that the Hitoric Reource Commiion of the City of Coronado hereby approve the deignation of the property addreed a 548 Marina Avenue a a Coronado Hitoric Reource with all the benefit and retriction of hitoric deignation, a outlined in Chapter 84.1 and Chapter 84.2 of the Coronado Municipal Code, including compliance with the requirement of the California Environmental Quality Act. PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Hitoric Reource Commiion of the City of Coronado, California, thi 6 day of December 217, by the following vote, to wit: AYES: NAYS: ABSENT: DSQUALFED: Attet: David Gillingham, Chair Rachel A. Hurt Director of Community Development 11

106 Attachment 2 CTY OF CORONADO DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNTY DEVELOPMENT PLANNNG DVSON 1825 STRAND WAY, CORONADO, CA (619) (619) (FAX) COMMDEV@CORONADO.CA.US HANDOUT 8 January 217 DETERMNATON OF HSTORC SGNFCANCE (For Nomination for Hitoric Oeignation and Notice of ntent to Demolih Review) PURPOSE: To determine whether a building, tructure, object, or ite i a Hitoric Reource in aociation with a nomination by a property owner, or an application for demolition or partial demolition of a tructure 75 or more year old. AUTHORTY: Coronado Municipal Code Title 84, Hitoric Preervation, Chapter 84.1 and 84.2 NOTES: 1. Application package mut include a Hitoric Reearch Report that include all attachment lited on the following page, including a complete Hitoric Deignation Criteria analyi. 2. The following page provide a lit of required document for each ection of the Hitoric Reearch Report and guidance on where to perform reearch and find the required document. 3. Pleae review the Hitoric Deignation Criteria Guideline, available from the Community Development Department and on the City' Hitoric Preervation webite for aitance in preparing a deignation criteria analyi for Attachment D of the Hitoric Reearch Report. 4. While not required, the aitance of a profe;,ional hitoric conultant i highly recommended, and may be helpful in the reearch and preparation of your Hitoric Reearch Report. 5. Submittal mut include one (1) print copy (unbound, ingle ided) of the application and Hitoric Reearch Report, a well a one pdf copy, to be provided on a cd, flah drive, or ed to tolen@coronado.ca.u. Note that mut be le than 1 mb. 6. Note that for any non-tandard ized (larger than letter-ized) material that you wih to include with your application, mut alo be provided reduced to letter ize, and even (7) copie of the fuil-ized material mut be provided a well. 7. Application package hould be ubmitted to the City of Coronado Community Development Department. Original document with property owner' ignature an? required. Copie, can, or faxe will not be accepted. 8. Complete application will be docketed for the earliet available hearing, unle a pecific date i requeted by the applicant. ncomplete application will not be docketed and will be returned to the applicant for additional reearch and analyi. 9. Hitoric Reource Commiion hearing are held the firt and third Wedneday of each month at 3: p.m., in the Council Chamber of City Hall. 1. Fee mut be paid at the time of ubmittal- Refer to current Planning Fee Schedule at w.ww.coronado.ca.u 11. Refer to the City' Hitoric Preervation webite at for additional reource. APPLCANT DATA: Addre of Property: 548 Marina Avenue, Coronado, CA aeor Parcel No.; Owner: Ken and Jan MacLeod Living Trut Kenneth & Janice MacLeod Mailing Addre:548 Marina Ave, Coronado, CA Mailing Addre: ame Phone #: Phone #: kenmacleod.mac@gmail.com janjmacleod@gmail.com,.' Signature:,; -. < *-.:';"<,y Signature: M.( C [ A.-t ' c" v " -- ' (_,- Pleae indicate if thi i a: QNomination for Hitoric Deignation or QNotice of ntent to Demolih Review B By igning thi application acknowledge that undertand that deignation a a Hitoric Reource doe not reult in an automatic Mill Act Agreement. CTY STAFF USE: Cae #: tw ? Date Received 'V'll Date Application Complete o 11\1 Hearing Date: 1 <»

107 PROPERTY ADDRESS: 548 Marina Ave, Coronado, California Architectural Style: prairie tyle Original Contruction Date Orieinal Architect unknown Prior location (if relocated): none original OwnerJohn Jerauld ngle.original Builder John Jerauld ngle _Date of Relocation:. NA John Durand Kennett, Mabel Kennett, and Dorothy Elli Dunn.Original Occupant DESGNATON CRTERA: ndicate which of Coronado' adopted hitoric deignation criteria the reource meet or doe not meet, and provide a complete analyi of the reource per each criterion. (See Attachment D to thi application.) Criterion A t exemplifie or reflect Special Element of the City' military, cultural, ocial, economic, political, aethetic, engineering, or architectural hitory. a Property i hitorically ignificant per Criterion A a a Special Element of the City' (Q military B cultural B ocial Q economic Q political 1-1 aethetic Q engineering Q architectural) hitory. a Property i not hitorically ignificant per Criterion A Whether you are indicating the property meet or doe not meet Criterion A, a complete analyi mut be attached. Criterion B t i identified with a peron() or an event() ignificant in local. State or national hitory. B Property i hitorically ignificant per Criterion B for it aociation with: Captain John H. Everon a (H peron D event) ignificant in (D local D tate national) hitory. Q Property i not hitorically ignificant per Criterion B Whether you are indicating the property meet or doe not meet Criterion B, a complete analyi mut be attached. Criterion C t poee ditinctive characteritic of an architectural tyle, and i valuable for the tudy of a type, period, or method of contruction and ha not been ubtantially altered. B Property i hitorically ignificant per Criterion C becaue it poee ditinctive characteritic of the Prairie _ tyle, and i valuable for the tudy of a (H type D period D method of contruction), and (Dha B ha not) been ubtantially altered. Q Property i not hitorically ignificant per Criterion C Whether you are indicating the property meet or doe not meet Criterion C, a complete analyi mut be attached. Criterion D t i repreentative of the notable work of a builder, deigner, architect, artian or landcape profeional. B Property i hitorically ignificant per Criterion D becaue it i repreentative of the notable work of John Jerauld ngle a (B builder Q deigner 1-1 architect Q artian Q landcape deigner) a Property i not hitorically ignificant per Criterion D Whether you are indicating the property meet or doe not meet Criterion D, a complete analyi mut be attached. Criterion E t ha been lited or formally determined eligible for the California Regiter a et forth in Section of the California Public Reource Code (a amended from time to time), (Oye S no). 13

108 ATTACHMENT A - Building Development nformation Architectural Decription The architectural tyle of the home i Prairie. Thi imple, but elegant home wa built in 1915,and ha been well maintained ince it wa built. The houe i a taupe colored tucco with trim of white window and black window frame. The roof i alo black. There i a chimney on the wet ide of the building. The property conit of two building that are imilar in tyle, material, and color. The main houe i a two-tory building with a low-pitched, hipped roof and broad overhanging eve. Mot window are double-hung and conit of a multi pained top ah paired with either a ingle pained or a multi paned bottom ah. The window of the main room are in cluter of three to five, with the five widow cluter "wrapping" around the corner of the houe giving one ide of the room three window and the other ide two window. The double thick window are clad on the exterior and wood on the interior. There i a taupe colored tucco ill coure below mot of the window grouping. The front porch i located on the northeat corner of the main building and i defined by three large quare tucco pier covered by it own low-pitched, hipped roof. Two pier are in the front and one i on the ide of the houe. The porch wrap around the front corner of the houe. The front door (48" x 8") i tained in a medium brown and ha four column coniting of five window each and a decorative middle wooden panel at the center of the door. The econd building conit of a two tory, two-car garage with a one tory, two-bedroom, one bath unit attached. The window are imilar to the main houe in tyle, but are not in grouping and do not have a belt coure deign feature. The light colored roof i primarily low-pitched and hipped and there i one mall ection above the one tory unit where the roof i a gable tyle. Site Plan See attached. Contruction Hitory Date: Permitted Work: Permit ued to: & Room Dwelling Jerauld ngle (owner) MerrickDavi Brother (Builder) & Servant' Quarter Gla Porch EL Everon (owner) W Dorman (contractor) Stucco & Enlarge Garage Ether Everon (owner) W Dorman (contractor) General mprovement: Porch, window, tile bath reroof J hi Everon (owner) A Laing (contractor) Reroof J hi Everon (owner) Benton Roy & Paint (contractor) Termite Repair J H Everon (owner) D W Wallace (contractor) Kitchen Remodel Simmon (ownercontractor) 14

109 Plumbing CTSimmon (owner) V L Kracht (contractor) Electrical Work Paul Ramey (owner) T R Froio (contractor) Enlarge Garage Paul Ramey (owner) Solon Powell (contractor) Demolih exiting un room & add Family Room Paul Ramey (owner) Walter Vetal (contractor) Electrical Work Ramey (owner) Alcaraz Electric (contractor) Furnace Work Ramey (owner) Coronado Sheetmetal (contractor) Plumbing Ramey (owner) Vie Kracht (contractor) Work in Kitchen: cabinet & ceiling Ramey (owner) C E Cox (contractor) Full Retoration of electrical, plumbing, & roof and an addition of Uptair Mater bath, cloet & office and downtair kitchen enlargement. Family Room wa upgraded to match the ret of the houe in roof tyle and window. All pulley window were matched with identical, in appearance, clad exterior and wood interior, double thick window S' maonry wall built on the back portion of the eat boarder of the property. (Thi replaced a failing wall of imilar type). Ken MacLeod (owner) R B Taylor (contractor) Donna Croman (Deigner) Janice MacLeod (owner) Minitry Concrete, Romeo Martinez (contractor) Reidential BuildingRecord See attached. Notice of Completion None wa found. nformation of Architect or Builder We believe that the builder of thi property wa John Jerauld ngle. We located two permit that were pulled during the contruction of 548 Marina Avenue in One permit lited Merrick a the contractor and ngle a the owner. We found a Coronado telephone directory liting for Archibald Merrick, carpenter, living at 81 Glorietta Blvd. in Coronado for the year 1914 to No buine liting or advertiing in San Diego or Coronado newpaper or directorie where dicovered for Mr. 15

110 Merrick. According to the Coronado Strand Newpaper, Mr. Merrick left Coronado in The econd permit lited ngle a the owner and the contractor a The Davi Brother. The Davi Brother were a local plumbing company with their buine addre decribed a being on Orange Avenue near 4 St. in Coronado. The brother were Sidney Jame Davi living on Glorietta Blvd and hlenry Ward Davi living at 8 2nd St. in Coronado. n addition, in 1925, ten year after the contruction of 548 Marina Ave, a building permit wa pulled for the contruction of 133 Adella Avenue in Coronado in which John Jerauld ngle wa lited a both owner and contractor. That home wa built a a mirror image to the Marina property, except for the placement of the garage, it very cloely reembled the home on Marina Avenue. Becaue Mr. ngle wa lited a the ownercontractor on the Adella property and becaue the contractor lited on the two permit were not known to be general contractor, but ubcontractor, we believe that Mr. ngle wa, in fact, the general contractor of 548 Marina Avenue in Coronado. John Jerauld ngle (b: , d: ) made hi living in real etate in San Diego and Coronado during the early part of the 2th century. He wa the on of Heber ngle, one of the four original developer of Coronado. hie wa alo related, through marriage, to Eliha S. Babcock, the founder of the Hotel Del Coronado. Mr. ngle, originally from ndiana, moved hi family to Coronado in He pent hi early year in Evanville, ndiana, then obtained hi law degree from Univerity of Michigan. Later, he moved to San Diego where he erved a deputy city attorney. After three year a the deputy city attorney of San Diego, he decided to give up hi law practice to become a real etate developer. hie purchaed many propertie in Coronado and San Diego. Two of the home he built are at 548 Marina Avenue and 133 Adella Avenue in Coronado. 133 Adella Avenue ha received hitoric deignation Alameda Boulevard in Coronado, the old Cahill houe, which wa recently been detroyed, wa alo one of the example ofjerauld ngle' work. 16

111 @, ll <"!»'!!iii#i*aaiaiinhi m m 3 Si < : lll!hbilkjlllljl!l '-Kii fq (:>'. ;i::skjil!ijlmlliiil!81! J "BBftdSBBSiB a ff 'SSjSS a il \j.l : ~t:<smi d: - <h. m m 'KSSS'USSS'SSSS'SSSSSSStiSS l: M V- J ::wia. a llll ie a ll - jl va B na :aa 17

112 te - ~~ c 3 g TS. ~1?; a A1.it. A- <u L c t OB, <: id a; li ** : -\ < 1 < r S 1-7l u c ' c: -5 SA fcu te? f< GL 5 Sf.?c 2 ' ec \ \ i <«V.+ N 4* > i <f» -. fat a - *» a- «3 < 6? <? f «'' : \ \ \ll \. \ \ 'K \ ' f 18

113 T- ' Ofl.». m 3! 818 S S 3 F> in? $. Offi 6 K AVE. c< *»; a a &' n * 2. A v» ' ft 1 ft (.-;» t - u.< A \ - ) c t-' f' <<l* g -!< 3 2? ; \ 3 m S< 1U? 1 g9 85! ' i 1 Sg 11 SK >!.1 v, 1-- 1>n * ; :?. a ' j: a ;H ft: Ul z All, w 5 >> < a? ji E R Si << ig ll? al:!3! y i 5 igai ils C OOS-2.CC 19

114 k: lu h* a: < <n \ <: h. \») «u lu tt hi a: 2» 1 { u-.' 1' J 9..! ir i y> Q = " 3 -J.51 p : ( < gl <fl U: <" 1-tl 5 li 64a.z - t U1 t >u ril tl hi Q B lill ll tt) i a. 1 <fl 1 Ul i w,n:!o CM V,<a a: ffl :'l B S llu Q ll ] ll i-?-] 111 " ll Sf jt \ 11 Yl, \ \ \ fl *?j ji rlt? '5 6 4 tjj ii x 1 to 31"!1 11 ii -:S fl il $ < 3 5 a:.l 11 j ll 1~<1 ll li let <» v <o ll ll K a. ' N ii - t : l ' llll.' 1 i 11 t <3 <c K *'< 5: $ <j K?131 1 t il.fi ll w <» jni i ff ai n i il 51 ll li ll "xl ' } <a - V t l r ll 11!! - S lit " < toiku! Cl 1!@ S -1 < w Jrfl 11 \1-? cm 5> 1~: xl ll - ll \ v v i? u *" 'i i a: <3 ll ll ill l lli ll i. Pl tel Jjl } yj -lwl<o 1 2 M\ K fill Ki a =4 j> &4 : >J 1 1-1\ '! X \ ',. \ u: G <o ut h* < St -\, 3 (\ 1 f\ rt \1 ll ll ll?> 1*1 tfi 2; \ 3 & lll 11 ll Wl "13 "Ml l'»«-l "1:E1 <? tel :r u 5' <] 3 a ll Q <,-St '».i!&i i; 1M - '" Sf M <:y +i " i 1 e?l ;.St'CT 1\A -1 SS: hi >:! y \1 r'i : 1 M ol 11 i 11 11!S l oi u 1-!<3 1-!» i\v\u- k- a! Si i i vl f! -) N 3 5 S =>u n 5 S8 3 8 u 5S 5 * '. Jrfl Oa CX> 6o >a &> -1 -A Col K1 S] <)1 r4 fd < <-(1 1 5 r< r~ l>d r< \ Oa ft Ol A ; t> 1 < c rt! SJ y- ~1 Q Qi 3. o S ift tw f(\ (* r-i \ n Q.D r 5 <y Vl SM NN ( < ;7) u n -<1 c. 1 <l h«v Q M <y r- a 1 KS 1 S~S Pl d. ou M u t v c» <o \, «\ } r ~t~ > <<\ '1 SJ» SJ A ) yo 5 rn 5 > > t«-i <3 t 1 ~- 135 d \ r <» n <» al-o So -1 c f SJ? ''a tk '&]f» ~ <A o<al < -1 (< (v?<1 \ <~: '-< n "< («\ BM a.. > w - ) «S ) ->r ou r< - -r Q t> < CT va k] ' c y "n <SJ. \» < rj n 1 - & r R1S <N \i S VS - <t4 SJ ct\ ' <! f <N?< ' L 1 ") 65 <3 <a q R. <» <a?1 N SJ *\ vi 1. o \< <y y t\. <; e vf '1 > <t <a i»<-\ <» 1 '< Q.1 <!> CB <a d fi 3; in V?t ; a h- J y.2 3 u- C3 \ t» a <; 1 3 Q: fct - Q. 3 > ' Q. < \ i a: < i <3 < M A ;l 11

115 Ql c. t* & >u.!" z U) t u l 'l 3 11 < -J.11\l 2 w ec l < 1 11 '.l ;ll 3Z"* 1 < > om -i J d. z N l w\ z u. UJ w z V. x\ i n «t < g ull.?l u? u.1 ll - < 5 <e.x u.!l.r] 1111 S i?? - 11 ] 5?\MS\\ ai ilo.l Sl? f! al 21 llililllll { x t ll <a ll ll x 3: ] il 1 Sl? 3 \. 5 ll «* "2 du) ~& u? <a <n ṛ 1» <3 i\ < 11 ql ll ill Q! 1 a-.\ 51? 1ll F nl i ca u OT 8 " \ tl w\ a 4iu. : Q" D ll Jl " il u 4~t 5> -1= M ili tc w ES 11.1 z w z S S u j\ 5\? \ 51 E ] UQ ' H 1 ujl"l u> z[ a! i=l R if 11 i _5 * H1 15 jn P'5 >- 8 Rl A, i 3 i! t. w < -J? {S - < uj 1 (3 <c? UJ.11 ll i t a. 8 ; 13 5 S 11 <1»1 :'1,- 'S1 "<i a a <a a <y <a '3 a cd 1 }. u- ' i '») - A N t >1 <5 1'j >< " 5»1 ( Pl j.hl j y\ - 1 EC < 111 Q J " BC U T

116 ATTACHMENT B - Ownerhip and Occupant nformation OwnerhipOccupancy Detail Date OwnerOccupant Detail Owner: John Jerauld & Leda ngle Mr. ngle wa an early developerbuilder in Coronado and the on of Heber ngle, one of the four original developer of Coronado. He wa alo the 1t couin of Eliha S. Babcock (Mother were iter). Mr. ngle wa the daughter of Mr. & Mr. Charle von Gerichton, a pioneer family of San Diego. Both played a prominent role in Coronado community civic and ocial life. For the firt 1 year of the home, Mr. ngle rented the 548 Marina property to ocialite from around the world. The contruction permit for the home tructure wa iued on through 1918 Occupant: Dorothy Elli Dunn (age 18-2) Mabel Pomeroy Dunn & John Durand Kennett through 192 Occupant: Mr. Altadena G. Neutadt, M.W. E. Greene,& Alida Otenon Later: Mr. Robert G. Neutadt M. Dorothy Elli Dunn lived with her mother Mabel Kennett and tepfather: Naval Officer, John Durand Kennett. n 1929 Dorothy married Herbert Van Btarcom Acker a world-renowned artit. He tudied in Pari and ha art work in the LA Athletic Club. They made their home in San Marino, California. Mr. Neutadtcameto Coronado while her huband Robert G. Neutadt left for the Eat Coat to join the Army. Mr. Neutadt wa alo a famou international polo player. Mr. W. E. Greene, Mr. Neutadt' mother came to tay for everal month. n 192 Mr. Neutadt alo reided at 548 Marina Ave. 112

117 1921 Occupant: unknown 1922 Occupant: Mr. Walter Fitch Jr., Mr. Franke C. Fitch, and 4 or 5 children 1923 Occupant: Mr. & Mr. William B. Kellyor, more likely, it wa William V. Keltey and hi wife 1924 Occupant: Mr. Dorothy K. Whitley (widow of Charle W. Whittey) and her four children, Charle age 14, Mary E.age 12, Helen M. age 1, and Robert K age [ OwnerOccupant: Capt.John H Everon Family: John Horace Everon, Ether Landi Everon, and three on: J.L, Stanley, & Landi M. Otenon wa employed a a maid. Mr. Fitch, a mining engineer, wa a charter member of the Hotel Del Beach & Tenni Club. They had 5 children. The Fitche moved to Coronado in 192 and lived there until their death in 1965 &1971 Chicago ocialite who pent the Summer of 1923 at 548 Marina Ave. William V.Kelley wa a member of a one of Darke County' pioneer familie. CW Whittey wa a mining engineer and worked for American Smelting & Refinery Co. &Garfield Smelting Co. n 1927 Mr. Whitley lot and then found a roe-tinted peart necklace valued at $6,.. Mr. Whitley traveled often. However, he made her home in Coronado and died at the El Cordova in US Naval OfficerServed in World War & 11Received the Navy Cro for action during WW. n 1954 Ether and John preented trophy to the Coronado Floral Aociation called the Sally Greham Perpetual Trophy in honor of their friend. The trophy wa given to the exhibitor with the 6 bet roe of any variety and held for one year. Their on, Landi, wa born at 548 Marina Ave. Landi wa a college profeor a well a a noted poet. n 25, he wa awarded the Emily Dickenon Firt Book Award for hi collection of poem. Capt. Everon died in 1958 at the age of 71. Mr. 113

118 OwnerOccupant: Cdr. & Mr. C.T. Simmon (Charle Thoma & Virginia L.) OwnerOccupant: Dr. & Mr. L.B. Vogt (Loui BennettSi Dolore rene) OwnerOccupant: VAdm. & Mr. Ramey (Paul Hubert & abella Turton) Everon old the houe hortly after hi death. The Simmon family moved from Honolulu, Hi to Coronado in Cdr. Simmonwaan ndutrial Relation Officer at North land Dr. Vogt wa a family phyician who practiced in Coronado. Mr. Vogt wa involved in many civic organization including: Newcomer' Club, Children' Home Society, and AAUW. n 1965, 548 Marina wa on the 12th annual Coronado Home Tour ponored by the Coronado ection of the American Aociation of Univerity Women. Proceed went to fund a two year cholarhip to San Diego State College for a Coronado girl. Dr. Vogt offered phyical exam for participant of the annual rough water wim and alo led the cout memberhip drive of the Silver Strand Boy Scout which had over 1,86 boy enrolled. VAdm. Ramey wa active in the US Navy from 192 to He wa awarded the Navy Cro for hi action in the Battle of the Coral Sea during WW. At the end of hi Naval career, he erved a deputy chief of Naval Operation (Air). He pent hi pot military career reiding at 548 Marina Ave where he erved on multiple civic and military group a well a recreation commiioner from He died at Coronado Hopital in Mr. Ramey wa alo active in local civic organization including: Coronado Women' Club (CWC) where he erved a preident. Navy Relief Society, 114

119 OwnerOccupant: Mr. & Mr. S.W. Gott (Stanley W. & Darby Y.) and on Ryan & Philip Gott preent OwnerOccupant: Mr. Kenneth D. MacLeod Family: Kenneth Drury MacLeod,JaniceJohannen MacLeod, and three children: Kyle, Kritin, & Kathryn American Red Cro, Coronado Garden Club, and Coronado Women' Golf Club. n 1974, 548 Marina wa on a home tour repreenting home built in the early 19' that wa ponored by the CWC. Stanley Gott wa a partner with Deloitte & Touche, which took him to Saudi Arabia. Darby Gott wa employed by Coronado School Sytem and worked a the middle chool librarian a well a an intructional aide and reading guide. Darby and Stanley were active in everal civic organization uch a Coronado Hitorical Society, Coronado Hopital Foundation, and Coronado School Foundation. Both boy were tudent in the Coronado public chool during the time they reided at 548 Marina. Ryan ha ince become an attorney. He i a partner at WKW&R Law Firm in Boton, and practice family law and probate litigation. He ha a wife and two children. Philip ha become a ballroom dance champion and i currently a dance intructor at Mary Murphy' Champion Ballroom Academy in San Diego. He wa once married to Mary Murphy. Ken MacLeod i a Home Mortgage Conultant and ha worked with variou lending companie. He i currently working with Well Fargo. Ken ha been active with Coronado Rotary where he erved a preident, Coronado Mater Swim where he erve on the board, and Coronado Hitorical Aociation where he erved on the board. He ha alo erved 115

120 on the Chrit Church Day School board. Janice MacLeod i an RN with experience in critical care, chool nuring, and health creening. Janice ha alo been an active volunteer at the Chrit Church Day School erving on the parent' aociation board and etting up a parent taught art program that till exit today. She alo acted a the treaurer at Chrit Church. Janice alo taught CPR to the 9th grade cla and worked in the nure' office at The Bihop' School in LaJolla. Kyle ha married and live in Autin, TX and i a Manufacturing Engineer workingformoog, nc. Kritin live in Claremont, CA and work a a Chemical Engineer for Niagara Bottling. Kathryn live in San Francico and work for Muhtayzik Hoffer Advertiing Agency. n 22, the MacLeod' remodeledretored 548 Marina Avenue. Copy of Current Grant Deed: See Attached. 116

121 viany Keal etate ale Keponed KecenUy ' -l","' r l Much Activity... of 2 'c tty' >; powered by A Freely Acceible Repoitory of Digitized California Newpaper from 1846 to the Preent.' 1( '.-.'n ftl nitf, = AJ. to Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 3, 24 May 1924 Many Real Etate Sale Reported Recently' -1",'" r 1 Much Activity Reported n Real Etate Circle. ndication Point To Big Year [ARTCLE] Many Real Etate Sale Reported Recently» Much Activity Reported n Real E»- tale ttrclea. ndicalionr Point To Big Year N. Gardner and Conipany report that the outlook for the ummer eaon look mot lavurable, judging from the inquirie received and by the tfcent ale made by thi firm. The following ia a lit of the ale made (luring the lat ix week, which total»75, Marino Avenue. Thi i one ox the more attractive home, owned by Mr. Jerauld ngle, and now occupietl by MFM. Whitley. t ha been purch- SL»et[ by Commander and M re. Eve r- yon who will make it their home. Corner 1th and A Avenue, from Mr. Gulick to Mr. T. H. Linahan of New Haven, Conn. Oraiiipe Court Apartment, from Mr. Ayne C. Moore of Chicago, linoi, to Mr. Httim.ohn, of the Corona<lo Grocery. Mr. Haimohn ib «lelikhted with hia new purchae, having great faith in invetment in Coronado real etate. G Avenue, near 9th, being the very altructive tucco bungalow owtie«l and jut being completed by Mr. Alfred Laing. Thi ha been purchaed by Captain and Mr. Robinon, who plan on making it their home. 8R4 Orange Avenue, from Mr. Geo. Uentzer to Madame Gilliard. Thi i t- <»<«*»w»!n<l n t!a»t»tan<uint, r 7_ r..r:. '!" ~ fwi - lad ' )JOJ , 3:27 PM

122 auici i urunauu cagie ana journal zy epiemoer lyzj (aii... nttp:cdnc.ucr.educgi-bincdnc'.a=d&d=cj &rpo=3&. c A *- "A. < «t' v- A Freely Acceible Repoitory of Digitized California Newpaper from 1846 to the Preent Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 21, 29 September 1923 SOCETf [ARTCLE] SOCETY powered by J<1 - <;, "" nk iuwr a m- %!B» -* '. r lof4 A benefit bridge and mah joiwg afternoon wa gwen in aid of tl»e Southern California Bide-a-Wec home for cat and dog, in the Palm court of the U. S. Gnnt hotel at 2 o'clock yeterday afternoon. Mr. Charle S. Holawaaer w»«in zharge of» home-niade cake and pie table. Thoe inlertk.teti in getting up the affair were Mr. Clau Spreckele, Mr. Charle Longctreth, Mr. rvinr Snyfter and Mr. E«t(irar Saltu. The Southern California Bide-a- Wcc home wa taitcd with an initial donation of $1. given by Mr. SatUw in memory of her dog, Toto. t opened ita door to ave the animal. lairt July 14. An acre of land wa ecure*! with a five-room bungalow on it, and kennel, ninway and a firt aij <lepartment followerf. The opening uay everal unwanted and lot animalt* were brought in and went out to good home. The purpoe of the organixation i to ave friendtea animal and the bet dog from the neighborinr poutida, to treat them if necciiary, an< can for them till they can be placed in good home. t ii* mo<tele«l yfter the famou Cide-a-Wee home of New York. 41 Eat Thirty-eignth ] t.treel> of which Mr. Saltu i one of <Ae director. The home ia now located in Altodena, Calif., near the arroyo, where the animal interfere with no on, be- Ailmint «n<l Nt*. SnMt K. W. l.iu»ll» nitorfuml «Mmb*r of t ( hnnil» ill chwnin* lliimr p»ny ohrnl tk* fliu>*t» NtWtl* l*>t Tiwtay «wnin». Ttw Kipino huntt t<mytil dvrl ilinner i><t ftwnfa! fw tt»»cinff. «Or rial almilar hr th*»«r] fatuni ia wriu of Unrtir* inirto to W i»mi laanl ttw N*W< im * MHxminn of TiWMfay nnhif»» AdiBind uil Mn. luttelle. nu«l )ti>lh«rin»i> will b* nfunnal bufhttl n»*n,. >u ba (uttamfl ky dntbi«, nil it i«pl md tu wtertaia o«t ( gtint* wi <i oemiftn. Nn. W. B. Krily, nil lorn 1 th-ty ininn B( Chmw, Btwtaimd with nmrt kri-lit» lunchni jferttly 1 the 8*a M*w Cwauiy dab K arta. Vitte. Mr.»nd Nn. Wy hw >»ul th* imn m tk«t tliri*. C«n>«o hmn*. M«Nwiu wt UNCT phu to nturn f Clifca] wly hl* fell. («M«t«at Un lanchmn Nm.uniii OuriN LNfrtnth, rrl*r T. Bnydtr, Wd* C. H«y«, Hwtnt] wi*. E. B. Nlaon. BmnU T. H«N- w, Kchud H Bwrtk, Cdri* U. Cotk.; Hniy a O'llftt. NTXU W»mn, 1.1 X McNlr d Nu>» faln Wum>. Vititiiit inn) Biimltar.w lie ca 1 t» &M Ui*r!»ttnd tt» uniwui i»r»it at th* iwwl air fwim Sna-1 day. ww ft«rwurd» irnwte t a li idimn* luncbnxi Mty finn t UN bom» of Cfft. and Nn. nomu T.] Cnnn *t Nnrth >J*n<l AAnita Buhrt B. Cmrt com- naritr la riii»f -r th* L'nttod atul (l«t,»u th» guwt at honor at thi«d.rtdiffiu l BUim, it* fouwr-1 bting iniiif> lu NNt AAniil C-anU; Adnlml B. S. Rohtam, Bur Adniml ixl Nr». S. E. W. Uttelh.' Krw AAninl w»t Nn, Add*y H. Kulitrtwn. Bri». Gn. N Nn. J- ph H. P«ndt*ton, Cft. fc. A. Bort-j kk. Capt. a»d Mn. W. *. Nnritt,] 'lpt. iwi Un. W. G. Ra»«r, Cum. nil Mr*. J. V. ffovud, Ctuplala & fi. Nunlock, Con. UN Nn. Bwn«U K»uffm»nn, Cap'- W. 1. Littell. Niu N«ry lutulla nd Jnt. Coin.. B.] Whi»», jr. E» )tri«ac»d mm urf flnit d niulpinnit W< lk» Jinnnl to hinifl* ynur prlbtinc iinii* n y«u unplrt» ti.iiftfction. S'6 MCJL Ar - -c W' , 3:16 P

123 lome lour et Dy group oronaao iiagle and journal b May lybi... Mttp:cdnc.ucr.educgi-bincdnc'!'a=d&d=CJ iy6su5u6.2.s &rpo=2&... c y " ; ';" powered by A Freely Acceible Repoitory of Digitized California Newpaper from 1846 to the Preent ( n '\ Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 18, 6 May 1965 Home Tour et by group [ARTCLE] Home Tour et by group 12th n» iaih taiw Tour, WNWW by th* Coaunadn SNtton, Ainwtean A»' ocuttiflb ol Univewity WoniMit luui bvm nt lor SuaAiy. May K* Hi»w o»ea tor the tour wiu be thow of Capt and Mr. Wwf c» R. QtM. 91 Alwa Blvd.; toh Geory Wiling»(» luart ut; RAdn. ana Mn. W. T. McGarry, 1&32 Glorrtta Blvd., and Mr. Charle H. Quinn, 59 Potaona avenue. Othw are the home of RAdm. Mid Mn. Aohn Kaufman, 758 ttuptbritoi aa<k Dr. and Mra. Louia Vt, 548 Marina avenue. oceedb wu provide a tw chnlmnlitl to San Dleao tor CanuNlo High Schotrt tfl p»du».. Ttclcet fw tl» nd an avaaable tl th honw on tour and ftwn»»mb at th AAUW. ''. r, of 1 C , 1:13PM

124 ijlli JLUUC luul LCai.UCS t ceuiy tuiuiiuuu cagic auu juuiuai it ii(. iuip.t;uni;.uu.euui;gi-uin(;uu(;'a-uo<,u-ji--'tiiit.z.t+.>c>rpo-z<x,. c '"x,_-?.. <...> powered by A Freely Acceible Repoitory of Digitized California Newpaper from 1846 to the Preent 5St? "1-1 f -SL'tk»» Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 46,14 November th Home Tour feature 4 early [ARTCLE] 15th Home Tour feature 4 early 19 houe Four Coronado home, built in the early l9". will be the local point of the Coronado Woman Club l5lh aonwl Hoit Tour and Bazaar on [ednedav afternoon Nov 2 from 1 ttft!a tv o( Architectural tyle have provided a for the Woman the year. Proceed lour will be ued tudent in the field muic and cholardiip a well a to oer civic and philanthropic -" project in Coronack) and the urfounding rommunitv Example of careful retoration and remodeling may be wn in thi year' tour home The home are thoe of Dr and Mr Henry Gaylor. 138 E Ave. Mr and Mr Greg McPartlin. 822 Firt St. Capt. Burt Davi. USN i ret i and Mr. Davi, 633 B Ave and Vice Adm Paul H. Ramey. USN < ret > and Mr. Ramey. 548 Marina Ave Ticket are $3 (or the bazaar and tour and may be purchaed at the Woman Clubhoue, 1735 Strand Way, the day of the event or at the variou home. The bazaar at the clubhoue will feature a wide variety of hand-made item created by the clubwomen during the year. Tea will alo be erved at the clubhoue during the afternoon for a mall donation of 2 \-or TO (-~ [n For further information on ticket contact Mr C.C Harri at ,1:21P1V

125 t. m.. A. i.eaaerivieet ionanacuvme~oronaaoi.agieanaj... nttp:canc.ucr.eaucgi-dmcancya=a&a=jiy4sz3.2.y< rpo=&a... c *T A_"r[ Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 13, 25 March 1948 [ARTCLE] " , Y. M. C. A. Leader Meet To Plan Activitie»» *- < r<.,u»* nt th o r'niint The local Committee of the County Y. M. C. A. met at the home of Capt. John Everon, 548 Marina Avenue, lat week. Plan for the remaining part of the year were dicued and organized for action. At the preent time, the County Y. M. C.. ha loclub group working through the Corontodo School. More than 2 boy and girl participate in the club' wc'ckly meeting. The aim of the club are baed on ervice and high ethical tandard of peronal conduct. ';! ;.; powered by A Freely Acceible Repoitory of Digitized California Newpaper from 1846 to the Preent 1,- m )' w 1. C. A. Leader Meet To Plan Activitie -7 r r- YMA L Mh> of , 3:39PM

126 Newcomer oronaao,agie ana journal feomary iyo3 aiiro... nttp:canc.ucr.eaucgi-dincancya=a<ka=l;jiyb3u2u4..t)l<krpo:=l&;... 'c.,,t; i'-.-.' i...;..y.. A>i'"-T' X>. powered by A Freely Acceible Repoitory of Digitized California Newpaper from 1846 to the Preent $J ''"f'.-.'n % SSK.'_ r! rru' Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 5, 4 February 1965 Newcomer [ARTCLE] Newcomer The Newcomer' Club coffee will be held Thunday, February 11. in the home of Mr. LouiB Vogt, 548 Marina avenue. ;. All newcomer in the area are inviled. Mn. Elmer Muhl. h(»- pitality ohairman. i in charge of reervation. Mr. Frank Van Buren, tranportation chairman, may be contacted fur a ride to the coffee Mr Van Buren'a addre i 431 Pomona. \VO3> G of , 3:55 PM

127 uiuiiauu wuiuaii <iuo LU iiear UT. ivianna lurpin iviarcn i L-oron. nnp:canc.ucr.eaucgi-dincancya=a&a=uiy72u4.z.zt>&rpo=.i... c *; A>i"V:r ;r y :.;?" ' powered by A Freely Acceible Repoitory of Digitized California Newpaper from 1846 to the Preent -:' [-1 % lfi» Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 8, 24 February 1972 Coronado Woman' Club to hear Dr. Martha Turpin March 1 [ARTCLE] Coronado Woman' Club to hear Dr. Martha Turpln March l..«l The Conmado Woman'a CTub will meet on Wednwday. March 1. at the clubhouac on the Strand. Guert apeaker wiu be former Coronadan Dr. fertha Turpin.co-founder. with her huaband Dr. Jamea Turpln, of Project Concern. She ia curr»ntly chairman of "Walk for Mankind." Dr. Turpin will apeak on hw experienc«i of the paat ten yeart ince leaving Coronado. Thw include living for a time on a fkf ting clinic in Hong Kong harbor, then returning to th» State* to attend medical achool and wceiv her degree. The program will be open to the public on the conduaion <rf the 1:3 p.m. buaineu meetin(. Tea will be rved following OMB proff-in. "Hie program committee and the philanthropy committee are cooperating in a Joint project to collect imn»d clean linena (towela. pillow cama, aheeu) for u» in the nrny projecta pon- ored by Project Concern. Tliw may be brought to the meeting. New mcmben and acction chairnrn we fmlnded that a new mwmbera' coff will be held on Monday, Ftbruary 28, at 1 a.m. at the h<mr of Mn. Paul Ramaey, 548 Marina avenue. r r- of 1 cro ' c' , 3:47 PM

128 Awara winning roei waxe un oronaao AS A Youin t.ronaao,... nnp:canc.ucr.eaucgi-oincanc.''a=a<ka=l,juu31 i-u.z.3&:rpo=»&a ifc t{.. 1 < \'f "A.," i powered by A Freely Acceible Repoitory of Digitized California Newpaper from 1846 to the Preent '' m %K ci-.'- d Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 48, 3 November 25 Award Winning Poet Waxe On Coronado A A Youth [ARTCLE+LLUSTRATON] Award Winning Poet Waxe On Coronado A A Youth by Rebecca Motlagh A Coronado ha a way of taying with one; that' what Landi Everon found. A native of Coronado feveron, 79, wa recently (awarded the Emily Dickenon Firt Book Award for hi collect ion of poem. The prize ineluded a $1, award and the publihing cot for hi poem. At the acceptance ceremony in Chicago, he read hi poem 'Coronado Poet," which he wrote about a year ago, even though he han't lived here incc graduating from high chtx)!. n it. he write of foghorn, wave?». untan and andcatle. v'eon rte? ' He even mention an old clamate who paed away. "1 wa born in niy own houe," aid Everon. The on of a Naval officer, a Navy doctor attended hi mother on Ml a- rina Ave. He attended l(x;al chim)l and graduated from Coronado High'School in He didn't participate in ponjut *>wimming on the beach, everyone did7 He wa a member ofthe Hi-Y, a ocial club. Coronado wa where he found hi original mue. 'People ak me how got taned, who wa my bigget influence," aideveron. " tell»'» -.-»>» , 2:4 P1

129 \ thciii kiiiil of tongue in check," it vvu (\iiiiphcll t\s(nipy<t Armor. iveroii rcl.itcd (he following tory. One d.ty "Soiipy" carik* over and aiil he wanted to hou 1<-\ er(»ii a pocin he had written for a contet. "He w<t i*()ii)l* to win firt pnc," he aid. lvcron read the p(klni unit " uid. *1 tliink it\ iiwtul.ind il c<nildn't write any thing better than that j\t (juit Soiipy yid. 'Well. iiiarty pant, \hy don't you jut try.' So aiit. will. lacron won firt place. AlthtHih he doen't rcnicinhcr that tirl pociii. it hitd "vaguely rcliiini overtone " lli1 thiiik it ituijht huve hren piihlihcd in the vearhook. hilt he' SHKC lot ii '-M'SO) ha toiul iiicinonc i»t (it childliod. "'Acrvone knew cvervoiic. ll wu u verv in<ill hih clum)!. We ati L'iCW Up together nit)t purciit VMTC Navy, t wa like un extciidcd tamily." aid lvcrdd "vnvonc w.i interc<ti*tl in \Kho \\a dttlint* wlio. When (iiiic<»iic fell ick. we tclt ick ttur -cryonc \u iinprtant to c\cr\onc ele." Atthoiiuli he' lived (»ii hot h ttktt aiul even in Japan tor (iiiic he aiil. "There no other place like that (( orod.itlo) "t wa p.iiadim'. coulil go all <Hfr on iny hike. my parvnt never hiut ti> wi»ny omeone might kidnap or hoot me." he.uitl. "Hytf the iland vacant. hornytoad and red ant." The i)nly way to get itut wa iin the terry and he rciiiember neaking off with a clymutc to "look tor gold in the hill behintl San Ditfpi: il wa titol' gtiltl. All the canyon were empty then." He alii recall Tent City next to the Htitel Del. fc\'erm)n' father, who had re- Hired, wa reactivated in WW. \ "He wa in charge of both coat j fl'panainu anil outhern p;ui of the ciia.l <>t'cali(omia."uid liver'ion.--' lj"b(ith iny brother and jrincd Army tt> get hack at him and it worked.' Everon wa ent to Leyte in the Philippine. After (he war. he came back to Con>nadt» and wa "having a pretty gihul time." He knew he wanted to go to college but "at that time all the vet returned: we had the Gl Bill and CA hill. we Cttuld ue cither one for college. The college were HtKuled. couldn't get in." hu l6< A t 'c 125

130 Award Winning Poet Waxe Un Coronado A A Youth Coronado E... http;cdnc.ucr.educgi-bincdnc?a=d&d=cj251l3.2.5&rpo=8&d 4 of 8 aid. ('Acron' brother did get into the hiivcrity of Kedland. but he wa fluitkiitji* l.nghh. o l:vcron would write hi conipoition und he wa gcttiiig traiiit A'. ut when he hdd to wittc onicthing in cltt. the tcachtt riked him what ina'ainc lie vvtt c<ipyin the coiiipoition from. 11 i brother confeed that it u vcron who w.i wrtting them und "he uid, ' want to meet your brother.'" livcron' parent dnnc hini <»\ cr u nd he got hiiii ill. "Aftcr that it wa no trick at all to truntcr iip to k'rkrlt'y" in 194S. lie tartcii writing poetry a.iui ill Rcdlund. n k'rkclcv " toiinii all thee poet, they bccaiiic iiiy tumilv: they \vci\* very iiiijhtant to tiic poetically anil u friend." he aid. hvcroti then went t«colutii hia Univcrttv it nd yot hi Mater' dcurcc in lnglih. Attcuurd he rctiinicd to Berkeley to yet ll Ptil). nil dinppcii otit in (cni).hi cl.i. " re.difd vv.i not tciiipcniiiil'iitally uiteil to he a chtdar." he aid. But he did cnjoy tcitchinr. o he ttiughl "coltcgc here *ind there ' intludini* l?c Davi. Cal.Stutc S*in JOM\ «in(l the College ot San Matco. Kc taiiyht in Japan and at an experimental chttiil call Bi(h»p Dft'p Spring. "Aiitl then t«p icit." l.)urttii; that tinie he didn't write much poetry. " wrote nxtlly tor my poet friend." >.aid Hveroii. anil o when he wan't with them. he didn't write. n fact the lat time he wrote p<x:try wa in the W). " topped writing tor 43 year; 've bn»ken ome kind (if record," aid Evertfn. explaining that it wa held previouly by a poet who hadn't written in 23 year. " beat ihc pant oft him." Ever-on rnly reiunied to writing pi>ciry when a BoMon poet l<><»kc<j hint up white wrjlini,! iu» ut.iy i>n the Berkeley Rcnaix* ance. pan of the poetry gniup [:veron belonged (o. fiir a p<.»cto' magazine. He aked Everon if he had aiiy unpublihed poetry and Kver.on ent him ome. lie then ent it to variiw journal. The New Republic publihed "Curunado Piiet." in their online magayine. Aked if hi poetry i omething he ha tu work on or if it eonw. fully-fomiea Even>on aid both. "t can o cither way. 'Coron.ido P(»ct carnc out full blown. didn't evrn kiiov\, wa y<»in to rite about (hi claniatc)' he SUKJ. jfowevcr. he alway knew he c<nild fnid hini at the beach. t*l wa hi friend. there' no intent t<» be! it (1c him: it' iivt n»t.t'«li»i'» tv»r mr ch«l<th<uul '* J& >) P , 2:4 PJ

131 ' jut notalgia t<*r my childh(xxl.'< ;vrr(m aid h.tnying out at the hc.tch. "wa the thing to do. We btklviirtct: urttu»;»rd (hen were longer than <»n yuti>m<»bilc ;tntl hcyvy." He.tiil thut a a child the vvtivc crahfil <»nt<» the reck ;ind tlunny tonii wcnl over them. "At i»nc point the llolcl X' ua m eriou triuihlc: ihc heuch h;id ht.'en e.itcn <» tar back it ua thre.iteniny the tcniii club und p<n>l.' At thai tiinc. (he Spynih Hiyht. "u kinil «t wampy b;iy.' wa till thrrc. 'he only u ay t<» get t<i (onin.ttlo tn»m North land wa by bridge (»r ylony the hcych, t \\u tillcii when the N*ivy drctlycit Suit )CL'» H;i\ lo he able (o briny in ihc.iirci.ik c.irncr. "'hey'u never 'ct.ivvay with that totjav.".iid '-M'rnn. he pl.icc had "cruh that lived in ilirt hitlc iinil tunny little fih. N<m;i(.hiy. they'd he cndyngcreti peck' " Kc yid fill might have chaiiyctl (lie currciit. "And all the and bcyan to.ippcur. t blow my niinu when C(»HC by now and ec that enormou tretch ot and. He aid that he could only walk along Central Beach area dunnp low tide. When he and other youth went td the beach it wa at North land, or in tnwt of the Del. "t w;i a lot prcttier." We lived acro from the g<ilf coure. that went all the way down to the bay and we ued td ride hop»e. there wa a table there: we all rode hore.' Evert)n. who moved to San Lui Obipo everal year ago. becaue he liked it when travelling hctvecn Coronado and Berkeley u a tudent, aid Coronudo had already become t<w) croutlcd und too expenive for him buck then. Although he' only been back a tcw time ince he graduuted from high chooj he till keep in touch \Mth cluinutc who arc till here. incjuding Torn Beuttie ynd Charlotto Mcduire. Hi father lived here until hi death and then hi niothcr Jivcil a few vear near him in Stinon Bciich and then inovcd near hi hrother and hi children. Both F:ver()n' parent yrc buried at ;t. Roccutn Nutional Cemctcrv A for hi poetic future. he han't been able to writf too much Jtttelv. He' been too buy truvelliiig to attend ccrcinonic and reading. Hut he plan to continue. Sul)niit((><! Plioto. \' a" 1 t «(;(T Koh M;K<K) left. and -andi Ewron indoronadoin <)5(). t-.. -.;» *<>«.. 127

132 rtamey c-veron L-ompieie i raining at v on (aey L-oronaao tiagie... nttp:canc.ucr.educgi-dinccinc7a=a< a=cj iy4jujii.z. iu4&rpo=... c.ci>'':] _> powered by A Freely Acceible Repoitory of Digitized California Newpaper from 1846 to the Preent m f. n a TK Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 1,11 March 1943 Stanley Everon Complete Training at Fort Caey [ARTCLE] Stanley Everon Complete! Training at Fort Caey l>«-;fi«u i<f'»tlln<' Fvfron nn of i'rivate Stanley Kveron, on of ('apt'in and Mr. J. H. Ev-ron of 548 Marina avenue. ha. fompletcd hi. baif training at Fort Caey. Wah - ington.and ha be<*n temporarily tationed there with the ( oat arti!?ery. Th" Everon family have been rci- <1cnt_of Corona<Joi:enT9TT-ah(nay wellbil at(:<t native (»f thi city. M r. Ev'eron attpn(t<'(]contnad" chool and (rra'luat«*fl frnin the Coronado hi(rh chool lat year b»'fore atterdtiifr the Univerail of Rea'and, from which he went into the aen'ice. '-; - t of 1 TSQt\ , 1;51PM

133 .api. r.verun uie in j. oronauo cagie ana journal u January i... ntip:canc.ucr.eaucgi-dincanci'a=a<ka=l;jiy3»ui.>u.2.t)<:rpo=i<;... WUC powered by A Freely Acceible Repoitory of Digitized California Newpaper from 1846 to the Preent -t nifti a= * la r -r~- Coronado Eagle and Journal, Number 5, 3 January 1958 Capt. Everon die in SJ. [ARTCLE] (apl.iwnon dte h SJ.. Cwtain J<An H. Btcnon, USN» ret., died Januny t3, h» Lattarroan General Rorftal, San Tnnctoco. Sevcnty-onc yean dt agie, C>* tote Bvenon had reided in Con>nado at 5<a Marina avenue tor th< put St yct. He to nurvtved by hia widow, Ether LaruUB axid Uuee OM» Joton of Midland, Texa and Statt. ley and Landu ot San FranciMO. Cremtion followed the tunerl ervicc ia San Faranciaco. Gravadde aervice were held in Fart Raaecnn Naltonal Cemetery. n lieu of flower donationa wdf made to the National Foundation (or Arthmatit Childm in Tucadn. Ariwa. Then t» too much nimal courage in aociety and net ufficient drfrtil cafe. Mury rttr Eddy. of 1 Jk ti- <l > n , 129 1:17 AM

134 '1C SAN DEBO ONro Rat.. Jan. S. lom»; SAW OlBttO. CAtlFONA a 15 J. H. Everon Die; Retired (» Navy Officer<! Capt. John JLEveron, 71. j USN. ret, of :>131arina Ave.4 Coronario, dk*d Thurday in j San F"ranci<*o. During World War nc **en'pd a? peron r.elx»jftcpr of' the llth Naval Ditrict in an Diego and a ditrict intellt.j gcncc offtwr of the 12th Na.! vat Ditrict in San Francico. Prior to hi entrancp into! the \S. Naval Academy. h(*1 attended th<* Ut»tveryny ofj Pari. in Fraru>e. He wa. grad-1 (,uated from the academy ns June. 19S. Survivor nclude hit widow, j lether. and three n, J. L. in Texa. Stanley of San Fran.l clco and Landi of Burlln.l game. Cat if. Th f time and) place of ervice are pending.! The f amity requp?*t contribu-j tion tw made to t hp Founda-1 tion for A<?;hinatic Children,! Tucon. Ariz. > ( J,h 13

135 John Horace Everon Date of death: January 23,1958 John Everon graduated from the U.S. Naval Academy at Annapoli, Cla of 198. He retired a a U.S. Nayy Captain. AWARDS AND CTATONS See more recipient of thi award Awarded for action during the World War The Preident of the United State of America take pleaure in preenting the Navy Cro to Lieutenant Commander John Horace Everon, United State Navy, for ditinguihed ervice in the line of hi profeion a Commanding Officer of the U.S.S. FANNBMG, engaged in the important, exacting and hazardou duty of patrolling the water infeted with enemy ubmarine and mine, in ecorting and protecting vitally important convoy of troop and upplie through thee water, and in offenive and defenive action, vigorouly and unremittingly proecuted againt all form of enemy naval activity during World War. Action Date: World War Service: Nav Company: Commanding Officer Diviion: U.S. S. Fanning +.,-e -' 1\'1 vvvv, milt, nu; 11 4 V koo-y Jo i<\ 131

136 RECORDNG REQUESTED BY: Advantage Title, nc. (U T S't-Wtf-S'P When Recorded Mail Document To: Kenneth MacLeod and Janice MacLeod 548 Marina Ave Coronado.CA Ecrow No.: JC Title No.: fe if- D OCtt iilbftniliiiiii JUN 25, 21 8:C AM OFFCAL RECORDS SAN DEGO COUNTY RECORDER'S OFFCE DAVD L. BUTLER. COUNTY RECORDER FEES: 3. oc: oc PAGES: 1 APN: GRANT DEED The underigned grantor() declare() Documentary tranfer tax i $. SPACE ABOVE THS LNE FOR RECORDER'S USE D computed on full value of property conveyed, computed on full value le value of lien or encumbrance remaining at time of ale, D Unincorporated area: FOR A VALUABLE CONSDERATON, receipt of which i hereby acknowledged, Kenneth D. MacLeod and Janice J. MacLeod, huband and wife a joint tenant hereby GRANT(S) to Kenneth D. MacLeod and Janice J. MacLeod, Trutee, or their ucceor in trut, of the Ken and Jan MacLeod Living trut dated Augut 8, 1997 the following decribed real property: LOT 1 N BLOCK 2B, CORONADO BEACH SOUTH SLAND N THE CTf OF CORONADO, STATE OF CALFORNA, ACCORDNG TO MAP THEREOF NO. 376, FLED N THE OFFCE OF THE COUNTY RECORDER OF SAN DEGO COUNTS ON NOVEMBER 11, 1886 Dated: June 18, 21 M K neth D. Mact-eod State of California County ofs=c2.-t~ >\eetq C J A>(6LCc On ( i o- <e>- c» before me, 3anice J. Ma6Leod tsa-~. v e- A' ("L&rotf?, Notary Public, peronally appeared Vik.-i'c-c- J. ry><nc-<-eot - ~t>. prictc, _L ocl who proved to me on the bai of atifactory evidence to be the peron() whoe name() iare ubcribed to the within intrument and acknowledged to me that hehethey executed the ame in hihertheir authorized capacity(ie), and that by hihertheir ignature() on the intrument the peron(), or the entity upon behalf of which the peron() acted, executed the intrument. certify under PENALTY OF PERJURY under the law of the Slate of California that the foregoing paragraph i true and correct. Witne my hand and official eal. Signal }[8&l \C _< t ~»w cou55' ConwfUttton i» labiaa Notay'>"c-CaUomia So" Dtogo County Mycomm. Exptow U ] 6,2tol Non-Order Search Doc: SD: Page 1 of 1 Requeted By: kevinfarrell, Printed: :12 AM 132

137 \ ATTACHMENT C - Photograph See attached. 133

138 \ tttulc viroro VZ aek!j'x': <, ',- -ywainnbn, -a tt.a jt <r t",,. \ WM1'.1 «*<<» "f *>Ci *» RB:i*.,:,,: -. {.ttiwypy?1->, u.l m.-.?.fti«w,'i L\ '' *'....- m.uade '-?.< : if - i-.. 4 j -,>- ; a?. < t.. <? V M Jf { i.j; rtmffi«tff':am" ywv '*w r~* J '>» awft.t- fe; <p iw 1 * '»-:.v- A&x;-.. V:.!< >-; " : -r:::: SF-i; " BaFiii»''«1" %.,' '«'»;! r v *? t 134

139 \ \STO<- PV»rW) - l<3ll<»i 1- f.- < k- \ - :Jt - 4- B 1 l '??'>. <\. if! K" ft $v '".:<. E-f '- w...:.-""-: -MSWSft, 135

140 r W?ST1M.<- VVVtTU - VL r'y,yw' w a r rf ;;1 r. il!d a te fiajte ;, «* m. f -5 < >w M Mf 1L- =9 < f \ r' tt*.-j1 ( <.,y?..,<7, ) <. t.. "t,n :>. '.- -.,; t ": "? V;' «> -» * < 1 J& $ to; '?- " 1K. *< im t»fc?. }.'» Aatt-i-BBX n u y ~fk \ A>\ '""T.f, n - ".-. -.<?'"'.... ' '.':..-..' \ t -jvwlk vf.\,- ',»<W x.»wbt.-» :""-r' :- y '.1»- J rr o-uw-lut- *": nir-h'.l.vi.bk?. f w 136 fsss.

141 ( \ \ { T?> UOTV eotj L. BT \?M '-' yv 'F " :f -" w:. k 'Mra Pl', M 1%1. M'. < ::iill m f :1.1'S # 'iiti'i'(, 'WS-i k w i!,.- >' % K % % (

142 S3SSKViy?WKnS ts '. t.'-w-'.?i ',?!» 6:.. ;( N»l*fe f.k ' \ >- ';. t ii*' 4 f: m r ii? issi m» m a-i S& t -f m "» <8z v "r Y'v&tl rf t y<. -T "S!»?ai :e 4 %.'ti : f ;M \;i 3 m K 138

143 VH' f*. k -y f. f i 4 m J a, E E-1 r t < <8M- ov SoVTt TlOhJ f. - y ' < t.1 l»g: 139

144 m. m f m ifts 1 m i f. K& - K'f m m- ii 1» S* N; %% i m- L_ d %8 i;; 3 4r S m f. a p 1 >f f MSf ;. 'y'»» 1 w k- K» V Ov \$T 'S\VO\S \ -f? -?i- K?1 f7; «%. K % 'F'...1* ;t >< J f- '>f.. r %.,->':'. :;yf 14

145 .i n4c nuvk,- i\uic- AVj*fie(4...'- \*'-y'. f. ; f -v -; 3 V»!, ' a -.» fe i w <» "r. ij..' &? VS3 w' <' V. fl?k K K» "w? <,,*T» " ; m - J!-t' - & w A * <. ff:!v& 'ii < <> -? SF?,y <ofr, -. m fif! K 5 r «* &?*.' 'K.-n > p,»i m 1. «i-- w,..h.-» '-* A.. li is

146 ot \r S -' kt VTiOtJ B ES. K v ;. S?'',. t- A:.. '? ' - i». <( ( K '..ffl &?; *, j. U =Ui ft. a» St?»,i4 JT i % ff- "f. KS. >. w w ;-" M \~T-; i i Mfc 'i iivs <t fc\ v n K b "?! 6 *<*4. 1? * fl >! fc< B -...f K fe» r. m i r f" lisiit. * ES?.»'S.»-;A '("kc; t«e»> tt«142

147 r 1, \ \ \ K m Jj >T \\T)- SQ- VONf 1 M? t» r? 4.. a 4.-- «t f %. A-. r..*ibc-a» \ 't nil SB (1 '-S?iSiS2» UUlMit!. <i 1, *. ' 9 t) g A\ t 1 \ *. f» r f; r 3 1\ S-a -!-«; " a» ~* :t w r j j '.'KSS < "y ;,\.. ' '< - E-«. :; 143

148 . \ ( \ \ otr ~ vr?mot>l Ff - -»\ ~"1» ikss <wa.< i a.,?, [V. V. TT-il 4 rv?-» fs t. :-ai fiml N < J HF», ni- *: ir :} «> ; - '<» Kl" Wl t -4 r r 144

149 ATTACHMENT D - Deignation Criteria Analyi Criterion A - t exemplifie or reflect Special Element of the City' military, cultural, ocial, economic, political, aethetic, engineering, or architectural hitory Over the pat 1 year, the home located at 548 Marina Avenue in Coronado ha had multiple mention in Coronado newpaper article, and in the early 2 century, wa often referred to a "The ngle Home." t i apparent that Mr. ngle valued the home at 548 Marina Ave by the fact that hortly after he old the home to the Everon' in 1924, he built a mirror image of 548 Marina at 133 Adella Avenue. 548 Marina Avenue wa alo ued in community event. n 1965 the home wa opened for a home tour to raie the fund to develop a cholarhip exprely for a Coronado girl to attend San Diego State College. n 1974 the Coronado Women' Club ued 548 Marina a part of a home tour that repreented home built in the early 19'. Several of the occupant of 548 Marina Ave were active in community organization. They would often hold meeting at the houe. n 1948, Capt. & Mr. Everon held a meeting for the local YMCA Leader to meet to plan activitie. Mr. Vogt held everal Newcomer meeting at 548 Marina in 1965 & n 1972 Mr. Ramey held meeting at the houe for the Coronado Women' Club. There are more example of thee type of gathering held at the home. Criterion B - t i identified with a peron() or an event() ignificant in local. State, or national hitory The Everon family had reided in Coronado ince 1919 and were decribed in one article a "native" of thi city. Captain John H. Everon (a ditinguihed military officer) and family reided at 548 Marina Ave. from May 1924 until hi death in Captain John Horace Everon (b: , d: ) attended the U.S. Naval Academy, graduating in the cla of 198. He received the Navy Cro for ditinguihed ervice a Commanding Officer of the U.S.S. Fanning during World War. The Fanning, a Paulding-cla detroyer, ecorted and protected convoy of troop and upplie through water infeted with mine and enemy ubmarine. Captain Everon retired ometime after WW. During World War Captain Everon wa reactivated to military ervice. He wa placed in charge of the coat of Panama and the outhern part of California. n the later part of hi career, he erved a Peronnel Officer of the 11th Naval Ditrict in San Diego and a ntelligence Officer of the 12th Naval Ditrict in San Francico. Criterion C - t poee ditinctive characteritic of an architectural tyle, and i valuable for the tudy of a type, period, or method of contruction and ha not been ubtantially altered Thi home i built in 1915 in a Prairie tyle which i one of the few architectural tyle originating in America. Frank Lloyd Wright deigned and built the firt Prairie tyle home in 1893, called the Winlow Houe in River Foret, llinoi. Mr. Wright wanted to create a completely new tyle of home that did not build upon European nor previou deign. The "broad expane" of the Midwet i reflected in the Prairie Style. t ha been written that "the Prairie houe carried within it two characteritic national trait: the retle American pirit-the kind that abandoned the Old World to come and turn the prairie 145

150 into farmland, and a ene of rootedne, hearth, and home." Thi tyle wa primarily built in the Midwet from 195 through A uch. Prairie tyle home are le commonly found on the Wet Coat. The home at 548 Marina Avenue in Coronado demontrate the defining characteritic for Prairie tyle. The neutral colored, two tory tucco houe ha a low-pitched hipped roof with wide overhanging eve. The houe i characterized by an aymmetrical front entrance covered by a maller low-pitched, hipped roof, one of the four principal ubtype of the Prairie tyle home. The open porch on the northeat corner ha maive quare tucco pier that are alo characteritic of thi tyle. Note that the original houe had three pier acro the front porch, but during the 22 remodel, the center pier wa removed. There i alo a pier that upport the roof of the porch on the eatern ide of the houe. The remaining three pier are in concert with the prairie tyle defining characteritic. The front door i original. t i overized (48" wide by 8" tail) and deigned with 2 gla pane and a decorative olid center panel. The home alo how an emphai on the horizontal. Thi i accomplihed by a horizontal ill coure deign detail located under each grouping of window. The window are placed in group of two or three in cloe proximity. The uptair window appear to wrap around the wall with three on one ide and two on the other. The window are double hung. Some are multi paned and other are ingle paned. The original weight and pulley window where replaced during the 22 remodel by exact replica. The new window are inulated, clad exterior and wood on the interior. They were made to order and were deigned to pop into the original wooden window frame, which are till in place today. n 1925, an exiting back porch wa encloed to make a family room. The room wa diimilar to the tyle of the ret of the houe in that it had modern aluminum framed window and a lanted, beamed roof. n 22, the room wa remodeled to be in concert with the ret of the houe. The ceiling wa made level and the aluminum window were replaced with clad and wood window to match the ret of the houe. Bae board, crown molding, wood floor, and the window frame detail in the family room were alo matched to the ret of the houe. A mentioned in Attachment A of the architectural decription there exit a econd building on the property. t i a two-tory garage with an attached one tory two bedroom and one bath dwelling. The one-tory dwelling wa added to the property in 1925 and wa called "ervant' quarter." The building tyle i imilar to the Prairie tyle with the low-pitched hipped roof, but without the wide overhang. t i covered with the ame tucco and trim color a the front houe. The window are double hung clad exterior with wood interior and were replaced in a imilar manner a wa done with the main houe in 22. Window are not grouped in horizontal line and do not have multiple pane. n 1924 John Jerauld ngle developed another houe that wa decribed a an identical mirror image to the 548 Marina Avenue property. That houe till exit and i located at 133 Adella Avenue in Coronado. t ha already received Coronado' hitoric deignation. The Site Plan, Contruction Hitory, Reidential Building Record were ubmitted under Attachment A. The Hitoric and Current Photograph were ubmitted under Attachment C. Source: Morgan, W. (24). The Abram Guide to American Houe Style. New York, NY. Harry N. Abram, nc. 146

151 McAleter, Virginia and Lee. (2). A Field Guide to American Houe. New York, NY. Alfred A. Knopf. Criterion D - t i repreentative of the notable work of a builder, deigner, architect, artian or landcape profeional. A wa explained in Attachment A under "nformation of Architect or Builder" although we could not find written proof of hi role in the contruction of the home, we believe that John Jerauld ngle wa the builder of 548 Marina Avenue. Ten year after the contruction of the Marina property, he wa lited a the contractor and owner on the building permit for 133 Adella Avenue property. The Adella and Marina home appeared identical in the interior and exterior in material and tyle. The contractor that wa lited on the building permit for 548 Marina Ave., Merrick, wa lited a a carpenter in the telephone directory under reidential liting. There wa not a buine liting for Merrick, who left Coronado for Berkeley in The econd permit for the property lited Mr. ngle a owner and Davi Brother a the contractor. The Davi Brother were a local plumbing company. No notice of completion wa dicovered. Unfortunately, outide of 548 Marina Ave and 133 Adella Ave all other propertie known to be aociated with Mr. ngle have been torn down or remodeled. John Jerauld ngle wa born in ndiana and attended univerity in Wiconin and Michigan. He became an attorney and moved to San Diego to erve a deputy city attorney of San Diego. He moved to Coronado in 1913 and dropped hi law practice to enter the real etate buine. He continued to live in Coronado and invet in real etate until hi death in Mr. ngle wa a leader in the community of Coronado. n 1914, Mr. ngle wa being conidered a one of 5 City Trutee. The article decribing him mentioned that he wa good for the job becaue he wa a lawyer, independently wealthy, and wa a real etate man by occupation. He alo owned a coniderable amount of real etate. He wa an elected member of the Coronado Citizen' League which wa "organized to upport candidate pledged to give, if elected, a quare deal to all citizen buine interet in the city." 147

152 548 Marina Avenue Permit Hitory [Date: Permitted Work: Permit ued to: Dwelling with 8 room Sewer connection permit Sewer connection permit (rear) Addition to garage - ervant' room Gla Porch Enlarge preent garage and tucco Repair to dwelling - tile bath, change bar, change porch, cut window, reroof Reroof Correct termite and dry rot damage Remodel kitchen Plumbing - ga line, ga outlet Electrical - 5 outlet, 1 range Enlarge garage Contruct family room Demolih Sun Room Electrical -12 outlet, 3 ocket, 1 ervice entrance Plumbing Jerauld ngle Contractor: Merrick J. ngle Contractor: Davi Bro. A. N. Everon Contractor: J. R. Alien E. L. Everon Contractor:. W. Dorman John H. Everon Contractor: O.W. Dorman Ether Everon Contractor:. W. Dorman J. H. Everon Contractor: A. Laing J. H. Everon Contractor: Benton Roy & Paint John H. Everon Contractor: D. W. Wallace Simmon Contractor: Self (Gadcke) Ctr. C. T. Simmon Contractor: V. L Kracht Ramey Contractor: T. R. Froio Paul Ramey Contractor: Solon Powell Paul Ramey Contractor: Walter Vetal Paul Ramey Contractor: Walter Vetal Ramey Contractor: Alcaraz Electric Ramey Coronado Sheetmetal Plumbing Ramey Contractor: Vie Kracht ntall 4x6 heater in utility room. tall drop ceiling in kitchen, direct P. Ramey replacemet of four cabinet. Contractor C. E. Cox Reroof StandelyCott Contractor: T.D. Baker Roofing t and 2nd floor addition to garge, deck & SFD MacLeod Ken & Jan Living Trut Contractor: Ralph B. Taylor Deigner: Donna Croman New 371q ft deck wtrelli at rear of reidence Ken & Jan McLeod Contractor: Ralph B. Taylor Attachment 3 148

153 548 Marina Avenue Permit Hitory Attachment 3 Date: Permitted Work: Permit ued to: Demolih portion of exiting CMU wall along property line and contruct new CMU wall per approved ite plan and footing detail PV Sytem 7.54 kw New HVAC Unit with Electrical MacLeod Ken & Jan Living Trut MacLeod Ken & Jan Living Trut Contractor: Natural Energy MacLeod Ken & Jan Living Trut Contractor: M N Mauzy Mechanical 149

154 SANBORN MAPS Marina Avenue E :T\ 548 Marina Avenue \ \ a h >. L b 1 J'<! M L..'. 548 Marina Avenue »\ (M l«i<» 1 Eift -\, 3i\ L>-.ti 548 Marina Avenue t» & **-* <i a? : - * { =»"7 r fe 548 Marina Avenue

155 %; w DENTFCATON 1. COMMON NAME: Ramey Home 2. HSTORC NAME: Jerald ngle Home 3. ADDRESS: 548 Marina Avenue CTY: Coronado Zn': COUNTY: San Diego 4. PARCEL *: PRESENT OWNER: abelle T. Ramey ADDRESS: 548 Marina Avenue CTY: Coronado ZP: OWNERSHP S: PUBLC: PRWATE: X 6. PRESENT USE: Reidence OMGNAL USE: Reidence DESCRPTON 7A. ARCfflTECTURAL STYLE: Prairie 7B. BMEFLY DESCRBE THE PRESENT PHYSCAL DESCRPTON OF STRUCTURE AND DESCRBE ANY MAJOR ALTERATONS FROM TS OmGNAL CONDTON. Legal Decription: Coronado Beach South land, Block 28, Lot 1. Thi attractive home i two torie and ha a tucco exterior and a low hipped roof with a wide overhzmg. There i an open porch on the northeat corner with a imilar roof upported by maive tuccoed column. A one tory wing extend to the wet. The facade ha double hung window with multipaned ahe in et of three. There i a chimney on the wet and a belt coure between torie. t \W (» f 8. CONST. DATE: EST: FACT: ARCHTECT: unknown 1. BULDER:. W. D arm an 11. APPROX. PROP. SZE (FT): FRONT. 4 DEPTH. 18 OR APPROX. ACREAGE 12. DATE OF PHOTO: 1985 a< fi Kfi

156 13. CONDTON: Excell Good X Fair Deteriorated No longer in exitence 14. ALTERATONS: 15. SURROUNDNGS: Open Land Scattered Bldg Denely built-up? X Reid X ndut Com'l Other 16. THREATS TO STE: None known X Pvt devel Zoning Vzuidalim Public Work project Other 17. S STRUCTURE: On it orig ite? X Moved? Unknown? 18. RELATED FEATURES: SGNFCANCE 19. BMEFLY STATE mstorcal ANDOR ARCHTECTURAL MPORTANCE Thi home wa built in A econd unit wa later built in the back of the lot. 2. MAN THEME OF THE HSTORC RESOURCE: (N ORDER OF MPORTANCE). Architecture X Art & Leiure Economicndutrial ExplorationSettlement Govt Military Religion SocialEduc ation 21. SOURCES (BOOKS, DOCUMENTS, PERSONAL NTERVEWS, AND THER DATES). County Aeor and Recorder Office City of Coronado Building Permit 22. DATE FORM PREPARED: March 1986 BY: Dr. Ray Brande ORGANZATON: SourcePoint ADDRESS: 12 Third Ave., Suite 524 CTY: San Diego ZP: 9211 PHONE: (619) \ LOCATONAL SKETCH MAP t. 3 ff WE CT» rs A.y. tft SEVENTH ST EGl TENTH 5Ty ST e"c V. \\ AVE H i a '? ocew

157 Hill CO -. G b.j. (D B a, co 8 p 3 G CD ' &. S Hiili 8 & g g 3 }-1 i's till a,.3 8 y e.2 -»? 3 (S y -.a 5 z c- it! ". cn ] rt M 2 -c ;-. g- w.2.! g CL< Q -a u 11 1 S ±--.6 a, lt 3 S i -D 3 i3 3 rt g. w i ill E i -3 6 b 11 -a. -3 ti ii 3 g -3? t - -i rt 3 5 D» - g E z S3 1 ii S1il i. rt h 6 5 z 8 K. : H -S.2-3 J3 J3 S f. y SP a-i & ~3 ' c a d e e 2 h "! -a d. c. '.y g _Q -g &. i 2-6 c.5-2 e -? ff 2 g' & e? < CL '-< 8 -g.a << b <! K "-S < S! 2-3 fr. y d, u & u g d, w : 3 - & 3 8 M u ' e; n - B ' 5 -a 5 y 8 -Q : g e. 5) u -a i ' g a - -c g J3 1! g ' 111.y CM CL -? rt ' 1.5 & g 8 3 CL, 1*7 1 & i'h-l2.-5e 6 g a _c?. h a 8 ' g g g 3 - ll - S rt 3 &., &. u - Bi -Q - l- ' g <u a e; q ill ' e 3 - " 5 c-i g -2 a.s S" rt rt h. g w '-a-- 3 '2? & g -5 rt t31 a. w ~ h -5 3 g. & iu S S S 5i g Jj _Q "rt B -3 -a -a SJi ri.& a fi (D 2 u..is.,;a BAiA; SSSaSStS..? i- gi -- i J 3 g a D Sb D f gg D % fa g B a,, u 8 J a V g- E 5 S Sg & 3S a a. 9 e!? n y? g >< m V) 1-1 ff! g? ? Jl 11 & 5 a S. g a. & 5S 153

158 i 2 a. i g1 1 3' - 1.r-1 i a, ij ilij i.r i ll i " S-? g. rg c e 3 : B p.r a 'bfl g 1 i "e - r u g. n n a.n 1.11 S. 1 1 :5? 1 i p 1 1 ill.8 g i "wm ;M:ifi~.;ffl!ii»aSgSB %re -. i rt.ft 1 'Nilt -&- i Pl ". ittii.- rt u o ii.1-11'i-' it i &. 3 jjil- it f!1 ' - - e -lilli &-'3?> ~3 'S iiilii Cfl ititit & 'ir J3 illij 11jjlJ > j-j ll-'j i lltll liilil u (D 1 ji]idniiii lllll N ' 1 K - -c gi!j?jl 'i > 1i ' - 3 i.e1111 llilj 2 '?- S 8 ri.i 111 r lilt till illti -?iiiii rt S-S-2.r T'i i!.eil i lli !' ji'c'."~ l=j-1j 'S!!1 53 g i e! 5 '!l]ii g' i. 1 i!ij.sp11ilil?1lilj 12 Mil! till Jli. -' g fi Nl? i3--i K 5 llllfiltu liltiililllll S.N -l iim jtiiltliilll rt g-ii g.t-i i g 8 yxf9 il illti rt S E S fj 2 '-g -a -g.a-'3-1 ' -(3 &--S 1 i1 1!3: lt-li rt 11f. it ' ' l! i ll- 1. '- -e~1 t.is S r - : b'.11.b- 2 t]q tiill til fe; 111 ill &TG4 -»i r2 5'J :8 -wyyywaak;'«'a??k'!1 t<?- ' _ JiJ 1.y e.!!i( 11 >-. ll11= il lilt}} 11 G.i H! a.3? ill llll -4 " 11 2 iit Nll : ill! tl!l 1.1?i ill? -SS K till ll! illrt ~ -' rt 8-S.3 i y <1??1 ' g J3 S -3 S ti -a w -5 -d i.y <43 -S 3-1-i 3 &4'i ll 11 J3 ill ff- X i 11 1, 14-, T3 ~u -Q

159 i? i 1.1 S e 1 li im it 2 Jiiiffl liill Ml a 1! - z rt < > - g 11 rt Q z u a B B a a i E 3! i 5 5 i? i 1.11 g 3 11 a.g El E " 5, ii ri 3 <; 3 h< z w Q J a - i : M t 1 B! u w Q tl [D g- -5? ill i lit i 2 'S 3 155

160 f!».? 1 m r? m r" &%; 1f 4 i? m. m ri»3 -'' m i i -m: m. «* ea NE i -; il K m L.-,11 ffssstiifwtsww, i!h E ua» K fe Q i i t ij. tl l ll ilf y & '. ' i 1 m 8. «t'! i '< J» ll " i'iakifciii m TT-!, 3... m\\ '3 fim i f & itlll ill 11 'ioll it! H th g-s g - 11ll '. 'j llll '?i. t ji S31.S.!!}! 111,ii± litil ~ " ~g. 3 3-i Sill! ll ts w t»t till ] {! u 3 m e ij J & Ul Stri 1].1311ll illllill ill -5 S' S': llil -13-? JiJ P 1111Hljitil ii li 2 ;- K? Hill ijlll.. : llfllilfjl ll!? filljillllilili }-&..Q lillll lit! -liijl'i -jn-gllil!lltl!11 liiiiiiiifi lliii 'll imjtllilill S illllifl tilllliilllllll 1:111.5 a '! S"! i 1111llllillllili "ll llf!t U-3 S vo S d il- t t; t- 3 F u K \5 '" 156

161 to y w» ~ ''.* <>7 E»= 5 2 l*ti llij z 2 H- d& a & S d!! t i's gi z lltl S3 till fftil «-.< < 1 :!k R*.:- ih lliidlilii i:11-331j ( 'i {; x f - i 1.- x Mi a e a> Bi.2 llffli fflllllii fflll ijil iffltllit imli ( -.D.1.i ri! 'ii g- l titill lllll llillll 111 lit! 111: 3(3 :- Mi i r jn %;'.&.' r.i'ffi 'MV.A;:..'.N'idtoHa!.rfAi.' ' SVSSrWWiSy'Si'f!. f'??l)w?g SS(W.U%S'.?' *.* '; '"' '< -f Etl i»f*': t! y-f. 3 & g m» i * 3 <> 1 m m :,1 SK 3 V,-? a c (a.2 f n tl '' r- m -V m,:.;,; A 31 a :m m m '. t tl,1 y t, A 157

162 g R- '*, (? w o-l c* r il ll K ;3! c 11 i. m i *i.-!4 a ' Kii t' r;,11m'' t? 6 " ;< y x t- a, *» --4 ft K fiirt ;Sy r- t. m' % vy. K-? m?c- ' <(., w.1.a '.f. f 'h! '. 1-. M a.l 111 Hi u - -!' crt1,3-i.- 5 i 3 [5i-i ri ill! itlli ri m f" x~* S 11li Oil9 5 ifli i i}l.11.1 wi{i lllli ' Jilll iff -J '111 j.if l-l n~i dt 'llll ll'jtitill? ll ": ll 91 \ lllillii1'i g-5 i1till lltl <!ii Jg Jll.! H&'l11 ll -,'i i-j '- tin&i! jl Ki ll liitllijill 'Hj 1 < S, 1< i ll S-g g S'"-! g -" t iliilll! 11 - r?) :..l 1 E r? t 9& - n; *vf:s..," 158

163 . - m ' v m i i a i j f r. {- w a i:»,?',". ' < jj w?, :-i F' r 'Siijifflliij!a i<" ', K R J llll W3i i i & Q -'. ll ll N M ll g 1 ill " Jl i '-2 U.S i L ' i'ijll 1.1i lft 'M 3 1 g-. f--3:k -a S..u Wl.11Jil Hill" ffltil -., ili.11 Mil S N illiiill 11!ll,1 ll till i-i 111 Uiltiltii! -Jiililltil!-e.5 fifli'ill!h lill u ". S ji31i liilj -1 'lltitlililliii illijll! llil-3: Xl 3 g'g'3 S i.1 y m ffi Siil g g S r< 4. llfillijj \ K 3 i a 2 g E?.S B ""9 1 11»; y L 2 fi le w & 1 t u 1 i -\ { c;\ 159 i

164 l:ss%e'il:%%sl! tsjsgs SSiS; :?i iii l.l3j;i ::<lii iti :in aj 'F. U3 & a a 1-38 g 6?: U e S3 y- <t2 H 3.lilt ll '11 -lisj 111 '' Q d u6 ' S i3.3 "11 11 ll?i {ftffil lliliil '2 g 5'y 6 ttilll Jtill! jiill jj i 1-!i lllliil a Sii t 11 i.i illh u S-< Gy3 1-1 E.i'J J 2 i,'.',,- co llliijlt 1J» llllj1 u jfijje w? ii! 1N111 lltillll 4'- il 'S il S lild

165 John Horace Everon U.S. City Directorie, for John H Everon California > San Diego > 1921 > San Diego, California, City Directory, 1921 TCfc. 952 Everon John H (Eether), Leut Cornmander U S N, h 348 A av Fitzgerald Steepler mandlng officer, if U.S. City Directorie, for John H Everon California > San Diego > 1925 > San Diego, California, City Directory, 1925 otel del Co- Everaon Joha H (Ether) U S N ha48 Marino av w-»--*.-««- n«i-'a<» nt -*-<,*- Fo; Pol U.S. City Directorie, for John H Everon :aufomia > San Diego > 1926 > San Diego, California, City Directory, 1926 Kver»*on Alice M Mr r 54S Marina av John < Ether) U S N h 54& Marina av Evert R W r \'aval Air Station Oranfte Feurta Lupe ndy w Flood Th i' J < Mary y.,navy and Marine Corp Regitrie, for John H Everon S ;.>,.SMww U. Navy and Marine Coqi Directory > 1927 '.'...'. lta. pt,(f) NRy naval di?t Everon;_"Johcom, llbayj t U.S. City Directorie, for John H Everon California > San Diego > 1927 > San Diego, California, City Directory, 1927 Everon Jno H (Ether) USN h 548 Marina av l.'ntltn Tkla u.'aitor T-Tnt«*1 H<* fnrnnadn h U.S. City Directorie, for John H Everon California > San Diego > 1928 > San Diego, California, City Directory, 1928 Everon Archy <i (Clara)?ilmn ndependent til- Gro Co h 835 S 38th Clara M Mr with Marton Co r 835 S 38lh ian- " John H comdr in chg U S Navy Eklucation.-.l Office r Coronado K'rnrt 17'mor R hknr Rank eif talv r S629 28th California, Voter Regitration, for John H Everon San Diego County > 1928 > Roll 12 Everoon, John H. 548 Marina Ave., U. 8. N. No. 161

166 John Horace Everon U.S. City Directorie, for John H Everon California > San Diego > 1929 > San Diego, California, City Directory, 1929 on rt av Everon Archy G (Clara) lamn h 835 S 38th -a Clara M with Mareton Co r 835 S 38th " Grace r 835 S 38th " John ~H comdr in chff U S Navy EMucationa Office r Corunado ( California, Voter Regitration, for John H Everon San Diego County > 193 > Rotl14 Evcron, Joliii H. 548 Muriiiu, Box 683, U. S. N. Kcp. U.S., Navy and Marine Corp Regitrie, for John H Everon «.» U.S. Navy and Marine Corp Directory > 1932 v y»» a y A.fc y fc.v«*r»(in. John T, cnmdr, intm. naval war col- exewport. R U.S. City Directorie, for John H Everon California > San Diego > 1934 >_ San Diego, California, City Directory, Sj '&5ife»'15S&. SSSS'1: "'"" '~'-' '"'""" " ~'@ EvenoJohj} H'(EtheUSNh548 Marina av[ U.S., Navy and Marine Corp Regitrie, for John H Everon U.S. Navy and Marine Corp Directory > 1934 Everon, John H, c'omdr, * llth naval dit, San Di(ro. Calif U.S. City Directorie, for John H Everon California > SanDio > 1935 > San Diego, California, City Directory, 1935 rm ~ Everon John H (Ether) h548 Marina av l?nhnr Ttoannro 1K' y2ak r* av 162

167 John Horace Everon U.S., Navy and Marine Corp Regitrie, for John H Everon Navy Directory: Offirer of the U.S. Navy 1936 (v.3) BETREMENTS (142) To Alien, Burrell C., capt--. June 3,1936 1W6 Arey, Garrion K., t. (CC).... July 1, Babcock, John V., capt June 3, Badgett, Stephen H.. t May 1, B.illenger. Thoma P., capt. (SC)...-. T-' -T-... Juue 1, r' 415 Barne, Guy C., comdr June 3, Bate, John F., jr.,lt. comdr Do Beecher, Charle F., t. July 1, Behrand, Heury J., t. (jg). Do. 82-S Biery, Carl L.. t. (SC). June 3,193fi 442 Blankenhip, Ernet J., comdr-.-.. May 1, Branham, Hugh M., comdr- July 1, Bright, Thoma J.. comdr..-. June S Broadbent, John H., t. Og)-- May 1, " Brown, Harold.,lt. ar)"(mc) July 1, Burhen, Raymond, t. comdr. Do Butler, Harry St, J., t... Do. 912 Campman, John H.. t..-. June 3, Chadwick, Joeph H., t. comdr.--. Do. 3SS Chew, Franci T., comdr.... July 1, Confer, Fran'din P., comdr June 3, Connor, Edward H., comdr July 1, S2 Coaover, John S., t Do. 73 Cook, Harold E., capt June S261 Crane, Loui y.; }t.(sc)... Do. 37S Cuaainham, John C., comdr. Do. 93S9 Daiiey. Claude H. N.. chf. elec..... Jury l,1936 S61 Dalton, Donald M., t. comdr June 3, Davi, Charle H., comdr--.. "bo7 418 Davi, Lelie C., conidr- Do. 722 Durrett, Joeph H., t. comdr..-. May 1, Eldredge, Hugh., t. comdr July 1,1936 S713 England, Walter B., chf. mach.,.. June 1, Ete, Eddie J., comdr June Everon, John H., comdr Do. California, Voter Regitration, for John H Everon Kego County.j Everon, John H. S4H nrinu, R<*t<1 F8N. R<*p. U.S., Navy and Marine Corp Regitrie, for John H Everon UA Navy and Marine Corp Directory > 1937 EvBrdJ,g'S a<-o.u">-. 5<8 M"l- a«. 8» Dieu. Calif.. -..vfi'vm'giv U.S., Navy and Marine Corp Regitrie, for John H Everon Navy Cirectory: Officer of the U.S. Navy > 1938 (v.l) UK.? XUg \i.k3? Everon, John H, comdr, 548 Marina ave, Sau Diego, Calif (11 ND) U.S., Navy and Marine Corp Regitrie, for John H Everon Navy Directory: Officer of the U.S. Navy > 1939 (v.l) Everoii, Joiui' H. corner, o48 Mariiia avc, Coronado. Calif (11 JS'D) 163

168 John Horace Everon U.S., Navy and Marine Corp Regitrie, for John H Everon U.S. Navy and Marine Corp Directory > 194 D<*catur. Ga <?< Everon, Joha li. o'mdr Marina ave. Coro- Lalu. C&llf ( M)} ;U».i Name U.S., Select Military Regiter, Navy and Marine Corp Officer» 1941 Date of rank Retired Law governing retirement Sea ervice Active ervice ince retirement Charle Henry Davl... Frank Robert Berg (E).-... Stuart Omond Qreig ().. Jame Coe Van de Carr (C) John Craig CunntDgham (E).. Jabez Stubb Lowell Karl Frederick Smith CE).. Dalla Charle Laiziu'e John FrankUDMcClaln.... Franci Thornton Chew-... John Columbu HlUard-... RufuKlDg Maurice Rum?ord Pierce (E).. Charle Lewi Be$t-.. Eddie Jame Ete... 'Winiam Henry Stile Edmund Weyman Strother. Marhall Collin Klnchen Leonard BUU... Charle Milford Jame (C). Selah Moatroe La Bounty.... Abner MoyerSteckel ().. - Lcland Jordan (C)--... John Horace Everon (C).. Jame Garfleld Steven. 4 June Aug Oct Oct Oct Nov do do May Nov June 36 1 Dec July Jan do Mar Mar 2fi 3 May 26 4 June 28..:-.do. 3 Juno 36 Aug. 34 July 36 3 June 36 3 June 36 1 June 36 3 June 36 1 Feb Aug June 36.-.do..-.. Tune 35 4 June 28 3 June 36.-.do-.. 1 Sept do... 1 July 36...:do... 3 June do-....do......do.....do-....do......do......do......do......do... ::..:do.-..- F c c c c F. c F c F c c c c Yr Mo Yr. Mo. Day p 1U c California, Voter Regitration, for John H t\ Evcron. John H., 548 M«rina, Retd. USN. Rep. California, Voter Regitration, San Dtego County > 1944 > Roll 33 Evenon, John H., MS Mnrlna, Rctd. FSX. Rep. U.S. City Directorie, for John H Everon CaBfcrnta > San Diego > 1948 > San Diego, California, City Directory, 1S47-1S48 feverqn John H (Btfier L)h548 "Marina av U.S. City Directorie, for John Everon California > San Diego > 195 > San Diego, California, City Directory, 195 Bveraon John [Ejither L) hk Marina av 164

169 JohnJerauld ngle 1894 California, Voter Regiter, San Diego > :SSS -- S! %"<- ite-'-'&l--- '..- - l---1.1; *-.!>**:;:;.:» i HouaVlite.fam;!' S No. No. No. Name 191 United State Federal CenuforJ Jerauld ngle California > SanOiego > SanOiegoWard2 > Ditrirt14S 111 Birthplace i r t.t.e-l.tee [-L'i.?»*«'( *7 fy ( M-»*»»?c<Ar3f»"**- r«<-> " ~- p<«rt<.] AA*-**. - < <'. 1-i 'l.. JJ.-ti,L- '.,.1.,. --..'.«>K. «44t-««-j l-i-rt...!.l-.lia. : y. f. " '-.»*'-lr '7»77n7~T ~i ft. -, -S- c - A- ~ ~1r t~t7r71 ' 71.' Rdatlpn «2 e -S i Birthplat Father' Birthplace Mother' > Speak Englih Occupation ipduuy Emplc Typ< y \l U.S. City Directorie, forjerauld ngle Caaiumla > SanDiegB > 1S13 > San Olegu, California, atydlrectniy, 1913 meolb'an"uu>.i'»< *<.»---»<-» < " "" " la22 R r Coronxi"- * J-. - tc«t UMxh U.S. City Directorie, forjerautd ngle California > San Diego > 1918 > San Diego, California, City Olrectory, 1918 njrle J»nul<l (l<a ). nil»t 4»«B. rctomuido. U.S. City Directorie, for Jerauld ngle California > San Diego > 132 > San Diego. California, Qty Directory, 192 \(;LE JERAJB <Leda G), Real Eatate, Loana. Rental* and nanrance. 426 B, Tel Main 574. h 525 Alameda av. Coronado, Tel Coronado United State Federal Cenu tor Cerauld ngle Catifomia > SanOteRO > Coronado > Djtrirt?39 Name Relation lf»l??1 S5 Birthplace ] ; 111~rtw~ '*''*. i'yw'v~3 i -it-,»";i i ':.?* '<ijnu» Z\ZrZS.,;. -t.-'-!jg!,._.. '-J-'G4 CT: j3d»ff»;? d'»+&..-- tlu;_-.4--k<< '-i-o:fct>l..1l-;a-j)'a. _... _ 4, A~<L. _: Tongue Birthplace of Father j ( f Occupation indutry a!<-' i.'d.a-i FT-T - ';«il'm A f'y\ Sift_ &. l&ffj-t.. vi U.S. City Directorie, for Jerauld ngle CaBfomia > SanDio > 1922 > San Diego, Crfifomia,Gty Directory, 1322 ngle Jerauld (Leda G) real et 426 B r Coroaaao T-Z- T nr-i>~-?»l>ol\ h tdlvi 3ft»h U.S. City Directorie, forjerauld ngle California > San Diego > 1924 > San Diego, California, City Directory, 1924 ngle Jerauld real et 426 B r Coronado nlea. California, Voter Regitration, 19 l%8 for John Jerald ngle nrle, John Jcr«d 12B Alaneda Drtve. Connado, Realtor. Rep. U.S. City Directorie, forjerauld ngle California > San Diego > 1926 > San Diego, California, Crty Directory, 1926 ' - - ~ r ingie Jerauld (Leda ) real eat 426 B r Alameda Coronado U.S. City Directorie, for Jerauld ngle California > San Diego >.1929 > San Diego. California, City DirectwlSi " Jeraul'd (Leda) real et 426 B r Coronado!Z~.f i r>~ v»r rh-iiintnnnd nrefl-. Hou Name >ta.1-' t *<r,'''1. 4 ' W*** - 4A.' 193 United State Federal Cenu for J Jerauld ngle T? Relation Home.gEg,-J Birthplace Father Birthplace Mother Birthplace Language S value SSSSS&SS& mrni; 1 Occupation indutry < «uve" S S { -U<ltt..rri_i,L :f:rirri'-t1?!?' 165

170 JohnJerauld ngle U.S. City Directorie, forjerauld ngle CaUfomia > San Diego > 1932 > San Oiego, California. City Directory, 1932 nkl<- J<T;iul< r«-:il - 42l! 1< r ("iirolijiilo U.S. City Directorie, for Jerauld ngle California > San Diego > 1933 > San Diego, California, City Directory, '5?}?l1?.-.'>-<!l!lt4. 'i*r <2f'!!???**l. U.S. City Directorie, for Jerauld ngle California > San Diego > 1935 > San Diego, California, City Directory, 1935 K6w J reateat 426 B rc'hula Vlrta " Jerauld real e»t_ 426 B rcoronado U.S. City Directorie, forjerauld ngle Caiitomia > San Diego» 1939 > San Diego, California, atydlrectoiy, 1939 Jerauld real et 521 B rm 56 'rcoronado U.S. City Directorie, forjerauld J ngle California > Coronado > 1939 > Coronado, California, City Directory, 1939 " Jerauld J hl25 Alameda blvd U.S. City Directorie, for Jerauld ngle California > San Diego > 1841 > San Dfego, California, City Directory, 1&41 " Jerauld real et 521 B rm 56 rcoronado U.S. City Directorie, for Jerauld ngle CSomta > SantKego > 1S45 > San rtocasfomia, City OtFectory,lfl44"«a'J " Jerauld real et 521 B rm 56 r Coronado tt rjs T _jna <«"\ t.., - *n<-.< U.S. City Directorie, forjerauld ngle SanOiego > 1948 > San Die&OtCaUfoinia,atyWrectory,t 9* rerauld real et 524 B rm 418 rcoronado t Ttn t- l.ffl T---l- U.S. City Directorie, forjerauld ngle )ia > SanDleffB * 195 > San Diego, CaBiwnta, City Dfrectory, 195 '- Jerautd real eat &M B rm 411 rjcoronado 166

171 Archibald Merrick 19 United State Federal Cenu for Archibald Merrick llinoi > StClair > Eat St Loui Ward 7 > Ditrict 15 Houe HoutFamil Numt><Numt No. t_._ 1. "Y w.-. U;.L...-.k.;A.;l4-.:i''.u.l -',;, i '1 ' :K,.-: Name Relation to Head Birth Birth 2.j Birthplace S " "»" «-' S' & S66 -<.A.. ili. '. i.k.a7'"?";'. " J-..tteA23.M -i j_l'fb_ Father' Birthplace Mother' Birthplace immig Natur Year Occupation.(_ ; - '."' ':'"< :... U.J..;..,.;.-.<..,.::r.. ii-',., l.,j' ;':',..-<-fyf.' \._.?...A.-< <;-..,.. < U.S. City Directorie, for Archibald Merrick California > Oakland > 199 > Oakland, California, City Directory, 199 U.S. City Directorie, for Archibald Merrick lifomia > Lo Angele > 191 > Lo Angele, California, City Directory, 191 Mfn-'ick'Albt!Flmn Coulter Dry G< Co h 1217 W 49th_ u Arcltihald con tr h 1323a W 12th t T rlnntlot 4">r> S R'WaV h T71 m " Lir " Ha 1. \ -lou-vitte Famil No. No. NO. Name AAL- K-i. 33 i.. '...tea.<-au;'.. itf-uj. ltx<5n. Relation 191 United State Federal Cenu for Archie Merrick California > Lo Angele > Lo Angete Aembly Ditrict 73 > Ditrict i 1 Hi t! Birthplace Father' Birthplace Mother' Birthplace '-' 'T -T-":-7-- i.l. \f r rr.: lie u.i.ctii..u.!j2<l»»i-.>t.t) 4-7?-.w 'j»'(3u r-u l-\f -yi.tcc** u.. 'Kwfww ltw.'"wi<> 2A-.;.iAtrf«-.ldu.ul- i;i>a<-e;y - (jun-lc.l Speak Englih Occupation indutry E '-vy- ;-<L- :.,l.i:-t. i,~:t.ijkl'.l{-:.\lltlutt»,ttf-. jl tju- v,?2fl- { U.S. City Directorie, for Archibald Merrick Caglbniia > San Diego > 1914 > San Dto, California, City Directory, 1914 Merrick Arrhibald < Effle). bldi? contr'imorl J w Glorletta blvd of VenaliB; nad< av... tmorillt U.S. City Directorie, for Archibald Merrick California > San Diego > 1914 > San Diego, California, City Directory, 1914 fl d.5 5t ( 3-gS x «-> u - -'5 <» 4 N <.HMn«KH tuil.llf (f.inltnunl) riki W A.» i lnk H J. 4 T R.-<>ri(l«...! *"""".'*» lalhrof M. 3» Cottnnwood T.!'"ll"k. KmH- 1. A K. «r.-.! Karir-y N Sail t>l»-k<> '" ". ' *._] lranik. ( M. A MPM. \'"K'f i3_'1'- t.«l» tlm. 3:,!< Park M»d.!'" '.' ''. '.". 1.1rhman ( J. Cornnado Cnirt Apf, l>ltr!tyj.".< iironailo. txihman Th«-o. 6t K rm 3nT. 1-iiwrlaon J K. 1»7 Oreitnn..ir-Mi W A. Xl'. l>w-y. M'Ch-llan A 8. t'.7 Kwv M<<-orkl«- A M. i9\l. lotli. M.Cranpy J W L. 4:>XS N York..f.<T»»ry K H. <2U..-,th. Cornnado. Mi-<;n»rn R C. L»mon Urorp. M.lntrr» G T. St:.. loih. 5'l;ini'"l'<"('ol<m">*1 " Kut K;1?:»HJ Marnubray (;m.. tx!4. :>th. Mnam-ll W K. lilt N. Miltby C.ur. 2il!'. Kl ( Jan *. Mark.-r t <-, La Miwi. Marttn K K. hrondldo Martin * Kp»<t>n. KTondldci. Miynanl AM. til F. Maynanl F <-. 14 X F Mrlhrrn M V. 13US ft Stot-kton dr.' RalT-rty XV H Rain* 1 F. Kt Ramb<i * Tre Harmond J U. Khoadmi W T. Kl<- ( V. lt Ri<- W K. ( Hl<h»r<t»on J< Rl'hter A A. H lev \V V. S: Klrlirr R L. < San U<-Kn. R ibrrtii John Rohlniin National <! RiihiniMin J A Rnbtniion L \ KiifT* Jnu». RuKer* K L. < Row H R. -3' M.-rrl.k Ar.hihald.» Olori.-ir blvd, N of VT Sail*. furonado. Hui 11. *. U.S. City Directorie, for Archibald Merrick California > SanOiego > 1915 > San Dte8,Caltfomia,Chy Directory, 1915 imerrick Archibald (Effle) carp w») ; Glorietta blvd 1 of Vlalla av. Me». a -».l 167

172 Archibald Merrick California, Voter Regitration, for Archie Merrick San Diego County > 1916 > Roll 4 Mcrrlck, Archie OMvcnter,»1 OlorleCto, OonNwdo. No. U.S. City Directorie, for Archibald Merrick California > Oakland > 1917 > Oakland, California, City Directory, 1917 Ala ] Merrick Arch arch t r'~;331"d'w1ght Bkl.v la Mprrick K<»lo T. 1."'>.' SVfamnfa M ( U.S. City Directorie, for Archibald Merrick CaUfomia > Oakland > 1918 > Oakland, California, City Directory, itncoln Merrick ee alo Alyrifk' " An-li archt r 2331 Dwight B " Ualln. > <»-»». C-ll '-;- z " y a ' 111 la; Nat Reiatioi." ll a " R 192 United State Federal Cenu forarchable Merrick California > Alameda > Berkeley > Ditrict 177 iijii i i ij in T t Birthplace Tongue Occupatiort -» y.iull'b'. t... Tt<-u», 9 1H'W t indutry tsi'l S- ya-.ilifa-*: '-'"-tul.l L&jt (UAfrt.r.: UlLA*llt( e*atf U &tf1a- ' CiL.uli.-lTUf VL..' J,. AL.i... A-<<?-'LtA<fT«+ Qtl 1-UJ f\w\ff\w WA-1-2&U. &! -)U)-». 2 to a«i«ai rlwlfrilfi -\ &A 2&:!. 21A 9 168

173 CORONADO HSTORC RESOURCE COMMSSON AGENDA TEM Public Hearing Regular Meeting December 6, 217 HAP F AVENUE: CONSDERATON OLJEQUEST FOR A HSTORC ALTERATON PERMT FOR A REMODEL AND ADDTON, NCLUDNG ZONNG EXCEPTON REQUESTS RELATED TO SETBACKS, FOR THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 1127 F AVENUE N THE R-1A (SNGLE FAMLY RESDENTAL ZONE) RECOMMENDATON: Recommend to City Council approval of the project, a outlined in the attached reolution (Attachment 1). PUBLC NOTCE; A public notice wa publihed in the Coronado Eagle & Journal and notice were mailed to all property owner within 3 feet of the boundarie of the project. CEQA ENVRONMENTAL QUALTY ACT (CEQA) DETERMNATON: Cla 31 CEQA Guideline Section provide for exemption to Hitoric Reource Retoration and Rehabilitation project that involve maintenance, repair, tabilization, rehabilitation, retoration, preervation, conervation or recontruction of hitoric reource in a manner conitent with the Secretary of the nterior' Standard for the Treatment of Hitoric Propertie and will not caue a ubtantial advere change in the ignificance of a reource. BACKGROUND: On October 6, 24, the Hitoric Reource Commiion adopted Reolution HR 32-4 (Attachment 4) deignating the property at 1127 F Avenue a a Hitoric Reource. The property wa noted a hitorically ignificant for it Spanih Eclectic architectural tyle and a a notable work of the architect, Richard Requa. n June of 29, a Hitoric Alteration Permit application (HAP 2-9) wa reviewed by the Hitoric Reource Commiion and denied. n October of 29, a econd Hitoric Alteration Permit (HAP 3-9) wa reviewed by the Hitoric Reource Commiion which wa again denied. The applicant appealed the deciion to the City Council and the project wa approved. On March 27, 217 the property owner ubmitted a Hitoric Alteration Permit application (HAP 217-4), for addition and modification to the hitoric dwelling and ite, and included a requet for exception to zoning tandard related to etback. Thi HAP wa approved by the City Council on May 16, 217 and upereded the approval for HAP 3-9. A building permit ha been iued in aociation with thi HAP, for interior work only (B 175-4). The plan and reolution for thi HAP are included a attachment 3. On September 25, 217, the property owner ubmitted a new Hitoric Alteration Permit (HAP ) for a reviion of the previouly approved HAP in order to addre project change reulting from a lot conolidation with the neighboring property. Thi project wa 169

174 recommended for approval by the Hitoric Reource Commiion on October 18, 217. Thi HAP ha not been cheduled for final review by City Council. On November 13, 217, the applicant ubmitted a new Hitoric Alteration Permit which i nearly identical to HAP , but include minor reviion which are highlighted in the ummary tatement included in Attachment 2. Thi HAP alo memorialize in the plan the change to the exiting garage wall on the alley which wa propoed by the applicant at the HRC meeting of October 18 and wa included in the recommendation of approval. Should the Commiion and City Council approve the currently propoed project, it would uperede the approval for HAP 217-4, a well a the recommendation for approval ofhap PROJECT ANALYSS: The project propoed by the applicant include change to the previou approval of HAP 217-4, including: addition of a 552 quare foot Family Room and Breakfat nook and 211 quare foot Terrace at the exiting Kitchen and a change to Kitchen acce at the rear; remodeling of the exiting garage to a Guet Houe and Pool Room, including filling in of a garage door facing the alley and intallation of a window in that location; redeign of the previouly approved Covered Terrace including the addition of a econd chimney; a new four car Garage; filling in of an exiting door next to the baement tair, which i only een from the back yard; addition of a pair of wood gate at the alley; and contruction of a tucco wall, within the back yard, encloing a utility area. A zoning exception requet related to etback i requeted in aociation with the contmction of the Family RoomBreakfat Nook addition. The propoed project include omiion of the following project element approved in aociation with HAP 217-4: Breakfat Nook addition of 52 quare feet; Guet Houe addition of 816 quare feet, and aociated zoning exception requet; omiion of replacement of rear living room door and window, they are propoed to be retored or replaced in kind a needed. All other work previouly approved by HAP not modified in aociation with thi project propoal i propoed to remain. The propoed revied project i fully outlined in the project ummary and plan provided in HAP , included a Attachment 2. The Hitoric Preervation Ordinance provide benefit for hitorically deignated propertie including exception to zoning code regulation. The ordinance granting zoning exception wa written to provide relief to hitorically deignated propertie where addition or modification to tructure on the ite would provide difficult, if not prohibitive, if current zoning tandard were to be applied. Granting an exception to zoning tandard i a policy deciion for the Commiion, and ultimately the City Council, and there are no pecific criteria required to be met in order to approve or deny a requet for zoning exception. However, the Commiion hould conider the impact of the exception requet on the neighborhood, a well a the impact of the exception requet on the Hitoric Reource. The project propoal include omiion of two requet for exception to zoning tandard approved in aociation with HAP 217-4, a well a a new requet for exception to zoning tandard, all related to etback. 17

175 The following exception to zoning tandard, approved in aociation with HAP 217-4, are omitted in aociation with the propoed revied project: Side Yard Required Side yard etback of approximately 4'-8" for contruction of a covered terrace, where a etback of 15% of the width of the lot would be required. Side yard etback on the alley ide of approximately '-O" for contruction of a ingle-tory guet houe, where a etback of 5'-" would be required. The following exiting non-conforming condition i propoed to remain in place: Front Yard Required Thi ection of require that there be a minimum front yard of 25'-O", with ome exception for lot that have a depth of 6'-" or le, are fronting on an alley, or have an average front yard etback of le than 25'-" on the block face. n thi cae, a portion of the exiting dwelling, the tower adjacent to the front entry, encroache lightly into the front yard etback. Thi condition i propoed to remain. The following exception to zoning tandard i requeted in aociation with the propoed project: Side Yard Required For a lot ize of 11,999 quare feet or greater, a ide yard etback of 15% of the lot width i required. The propoed Family RoomBreakfat Nook addition would be required to have a ide yard etback ranging from approximately 18'-1" to approximately 22'-3" under regular zoning tandard. The propoed location of thi addition require a etback of 5'-", for the approximate 21 '-2" length of the addition, if the project i to be approved a propoed. The City' Hitoric Preervation Ordinance outline pecific criteria that hould be ued when evaluating propoed alteration to a hitoric tructure, including conitency with the Secretary of the nterior' Standard. The Hitoric Reource Commiion and City Council found that the previouly approved project (HAP 217-4) wa conitent with the Secretary of the nterior' Standard and Alteration Guideline for Mill Act Propertie and met the finding for approval. The reviion to the project a propoed in HAP include all of the retoration and rehabilitation item included in the previou propoal, including retoration of the non-hitoric roof baed upon hitoric photograph and replacement of nonhitoric window with period appropriate window, which are conitent with the Secretary of the nterior' Standard; and encloure of the loggia at the rear of the dwelling which complie with the tandard through the ue of teel door that, if removed in the future, would not damage or adverely impact the hitoric tructure. The applicant indicate that the new addition are deigned to be conitent with the Standard a well. Staff agree that the project i conitent with the Secretary of the nterior' Standard for Rehabilitation a follow: 171

176 Guidance from the National Park Service regarding interpretation of the Secretary of the nterior' Standard related to rear addition, pecifically Standard 9 and 1, tate that rear addition, like all new addition, hould be ubordinate to the original building in term of ize, cale, maing, and deign; that addition hould be viually compatible yet differentiated from the old building; and that new addition hould be undertaken in a manner that allow for the poibility of future removal without compromiing the integrity of the hitoric reource. The project propoal include contruction of a Family RoomBreakfat Nook, which i et back from the front facade of the dwelling approximately 8'-7", and i ubordinate to the original dwelling. The new four car garage will be located at the rear of the property. Both of thee addition are propoed to be differentiated through the ue of a lightly moother tucco texture than the hitoric texture, and through the ue of a two-piece red clay tile roof that will be imilar but will not match the retored roof of the original dwelling. The remodeling of the exiting Garage to be a Pool and Guet Houe will include motly interior modification, and the appearance of the building from the alley will be lightly modified by the removal of one of the garage door. The outline of the exiting garage door will be retained by indentation of the tucco in that area, and a window will be inet in thi location. The Covered Terrace, which wa previouly approved by HAP 217-4, i propoed to be modified from the originally approved appearance to be a more open tructure, and will be differentiated through the ue of light colored tone rather than tucco. A econd chimney i propoed in order to accommodate relocation of a pizza oven. Taking into account the element of the project already determined to meet the Standard through the previou approval, and the new element of project a propoed, the propoal in it entirety appear to be conitent with the Secretary of the nterior' Standard. A Mill Act Agreement for the property wa recorded in 216. Therefore, the propoed project conitency with the City of Coronado' Alteration Guideline for Mill Act Propertie (Attachment 4) hould be conidered in addition to the Secretary of the nterior' Standard. The Guideline provide pecific direction regarding modification to Mill Act propertie. The project, a propoed, complie with the Guideline, a follow: Guideline -C provide direction on treatment of window. The replacement of non-hitoric window with period appropriate window baed on hitoric photograph wa already determined to be conitent with the Standard and thee Guideline through the approval of HAP Guideline -A provide direction quite imilar to the Secretary of the nterior' Standard, reiterating the importance of deigning appropriate addition to hitoric building. The propoed Family RoomBreakfat Nook i et back from the facade and ubordinate to the hitoric dwelling, and i differentiated through the ue of mooth tucco, yet i compatible in tyle, a i the propoed new four car garage and remodeled Covered Terrace. 172

177 The project appear to comply with the City of Coronado' Alteration Guideline for Mill Act Propertie. The improvement a propoed appear to be conitent with the Secretary of the nterior' Standard and meet the finding for approval a outlined in the attached draft reolution (Attachment 1). CONCLUSON: Staff recommend that the Commiion approve the project, finding that the project i conitent with the Secretary of the nterior' Standard, the City' Alteration Guideline for Mill Act Propertie, and meet the finding for approval a outlined in the attached reolution (Attachment 1), with the following condition of approval: 1. Change to the approved plan may require the review and approval of the Hitoric Reource Commiion 2. Any mechanical equipment intalled in aociation with the project will be creened from view from the public right of way. 3. Thi Hitoric Alteration Permit hall expire three year from the date of approval by the Hitoric Reource Commiion. 4. Thi Hitoric Alteration Permit hall uperede any previou Hitoric Alteration Permit approval for the property. Pleae ee the attached reolution, with the taff recommendation incorporated, for conideration. f the Commiion wihe to adopt a reolution reflecting a recommendation other than the taff recommendation, the attached reolution hould be modified accordingly. Pleae ee the application for additional information and complete project cope. Attachment: 1. Reolution for HAP , with taff recommendation 2. Hitoric Alteration Permit Application HAP Reolution CC 8861 and plan for HAP

178 RESOLUTON NO. HR 4-17 Attachment 1 A RESOLUTON OF THE HSTORC RESOURCE COMMSSON OF THE CTY OF CORONADO RECOMMENDNG TO CTY COUNCL APPROVAL OF A HSTORC RESOURCE ALTERATON PERMT, NCLUDNG AN EXCEPTON TO ZONNG STANDARDS RELATED TO SETBACKS, FOR THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 1127 F AVENUE N THE R-1A (SWGLE FAMLY RESDENTAL ZONE). WHEREAS, on November 13, 217, the property owner ubmitted a Hitoric Reource Alteration Permit, with a zoning exception requet related to etback, for the property addreed a 1127 F Avenue in accordance with Chapter 84.2 of the Coronado Municipal Code;and WHEREAS, on December 6, 217, the Hitoric Reource Commiion of the City of Coronado held a public hearing on HAP at which time all peron deiring to be heard were heard; and WHEREAS, evidence wa ubmitted and conidered to include without limitation: 1. Hitoric Reource Alteration Permit application ubmittal HAP ; 2. Oral tetimony; 3. Hitoric Reource Commiion taff report dated December 6, 217, including taff determination that the project i Categorically Exempt from California Environmental Quality Act Cla 31 of Section regarding Hitoric Reource becaue the project a propoed i conitent with the Secretary of the nterior' Standard; and 4. Additional written documentation, plan, and photograph provided by the applicant; NOW, THEREFORE, BE T RESOLVED that the Hitoric Reource Commiion of the City of Coronado recommend to City Council that the propoed project a decribed in HAP meet the Secretary of the nterior' Standard, complie with the City' Alteration Guideline for Mill Act Propertie, and hall be iued a Hitoric Reource Alteration Permit becaue the following finding have been made: A. The propoed alteration i conitent with the purpoe and intent of thi Chapter, the Hitoric Preervation Element and the General Plan a the project i conitent with Objective D of the Hitoric Preervation Element of the General Plan, becaue the project i conitent with the Secretary of the nterior' Standard for Rehabilitation. B. The propoed alteration will not adverely affect the hitorical, architectural or aethetic value of the Hitoric Reource a the project a propoed i conitent with the Secretary of the nterior' Standard for Rehabilitation. C. The propoed alteration will retain the eential element that make the Hitoric Reource ignificant a the project include retoration ofnon-hitoric element to period appropriate appearance, and the addition of the Family RoomBreakfat Nook will not adverely impact the hitoric appearance of the dwelling. D. The propoed alteration will not adverely affect the Hitoric Reource' relationhip to it urrounding and neighboring Hitoric Reource a the project doe not impact urrounding building or Hitoric Reource, and the relationhip of the building to it urrounding will remain unchanged. 174

179 E. The propoed alteration complie with the Secretary of nterior' Standard a et forth in Section 16 of the National Hitoric Preervation Act of 1966 a the project meet the Standard and Guideline for New Addition, a the Family RoomBreakfat Nook i et back from the facade, i ubordinate to the original dwelling, and i differentiated yet compatible; other modification uch a encloure of the rear loggia will not adverely impact the dwelling and are reverible, and new acceary tructure will not adverely impact the hitoric dwelling and are differentiated yet compatible. NOW, THEREFORE, BE T FURTHER RESOLVED that the Hitoric Reource Commiion of the City of Coronado hereby recommend the iuance of a Hitoric Reource Alteration Permit and the following aociated zoning exception requet 1. Side yard etback of 5'-" at the Family RoomBreakfat Nook, where a etback ranging from approximately 18'-1" to approximately 22'-3" would be required under regular zoning tandard (CMC ) for the hitorically deignated property addreed a 1127 F Avenue and located in the R-1A (Single Family Reidential) Zone, a ubmitted in the application and plan compriing HAP , in accordance with Chapter 84.2 of the City of Coronado Municipal Code; with the following condition: 1. Change to the approved plan may require the review and approval of the Hitoric Reource Commiion. 2. Any mechanical equipment intalled in aociation with the project will be creened from view from the public right of way. 3. Thi Hitoric Alteration Permit hall expire three year from the date of approval by the Hitoric Reource Commiion. 4. Thi Hitoric Alteration Permit hall uperede any previou Hitoric Alteration Permit approval for the property. PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Hitoric Reource Commiion of the City ofcoronado, California, thi 6th day of December, 217, by the following vote, to wit: AYES: NAYS: ABSENT: DSQUALFED: Attet: David Gillingham, Chair Rachel A. Hurt Director of Community Development, Redevelopment & Houing 175

180 r Attachment 2 ym CTY OF CORONADO DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNTY DEVELOPMENT PLANNNG DVSON 1825 STRAND WAY, CORONADO, CA (619) (619) (FAX) COMMDEV@CORONAOO.CA.US HANDOUT 81 January 216 HSTORC ALTERATON PERMT REQUEST (MAP) PURPOSE: To requet review of a propoed alteration to, or demolition of, a deignated Hitoric Reource. AUTHORTY: Coronado Municipal Code Title 84, Hitoric Preervation, Chapter 84.2 NOTES: 1. Application package hould be ubmitted to the City of Coronado Community Development Department. Faxed application will not be accepted. 2. n order to be docketed for a hearing of the Hitoric Reource Commiion, application mut be complete incluive of all required attachment. ncomplete application will not be docketed and will be returned to the property owner 3. Fee - Pleae ee the current Planning Fee Schedule at 4. For demolition of a Hitoric Reource, an environmental checklit form and fee per the Planning Department Fee Schedule, hall accompany the application, in accordance with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). REQURED ATTACHMENTS: Summary Statement. See page 2 of thi application. a For project that include addition viible from the public right of way: One full-color rendered perpective drawing depicting propoed alteration to the hitoric reource i required. Note: All perpective drawing mut be prepared from a viewing poition of five feet above idewalk grade. Drawing mut alo be provided digitally, on a cd or ed to -..L:_;..-;.''._..._:.1,; _..j., a pdf document. Q Current color photograph of the treet view of the property, and each exterior elevation of all tructure on the property. nclude thee photograph digitally a jpg file on a CD, or ed to i-iico'c-n.-oo.;...-;- Q Sample of propoed exterior material ample a relevant (i.e., wood, brick, or tucco texture ample). One pdf copy and Seven (7) folded print copie of architectural plan and elevation (rolled plan will not be accepted), drawn according to Building Department Plan Requirement (Handout 33), including: o Site plan o Demolition Plan o Dimenioned Floor Plan o Door and window chedule (coordinated with floor plan and elevation) o Exterior elevation APPLCANT DATA: Addre of Property: '.,..< r A'-'F' "' b>. i:-t. Aeor Parcel No.: 3'? ) ) -"j Owner: Pi rt<>j <; 't1,,j faalzi.tn AoDlicant. -i?wt, jr?? Mailing Addre: } j Q TvC N.V STtt<.. Mailing Addre:?Mi 2. t?<.v('?ifto ; Phone #: -- _' W\ Sl2. Phone ff: -7j -?>:> - br'i. ' 4-Li. iav-. cjfca, t<_; tt U-i't-Afyi. <:;W Signature: Signature:'i'.n,i Jc<o~(.tl CTY STAFF UET" Caeff.Wn'lS' Date ReceivedU t l-1 _Date Application Complete.\vlln.Hearing Date:_ izlun 176

181 1< r--- Y PROPERTY ADDRESS: ttz P AtfLl OUVJ. ( Current Mill Art Statu: Recorded Mill Act D Pending Council Approval D No Milt Act D ntend to apply Are exception to zoning regulation requeted a part of thi application? J8etback D Height D Parking D Floor Area Ratio (FAR) D Lot Coverage Summary Statement of Project: Written decription of propoed alteration (location, ize, height, project material, finihe, color, manufacturer' pecification, etc.) f zoning exception are requeted, provide jutification for thi requet. Addre the project a it relate to the Secretary of the nterior' Standard for Treatment of Hitoric Propertie and indicate whether the project doe or doe not meet the Standard. Attach additional page a neceary to provide a complete Summary Statement. -lyaa) ADDTONAL NFORMATON: Additional information about Hitoric Alteration Permit and requirement aociated with their approval can be found at: City of Coronado Hitoric Preervation Program Guidebook, available at City Hall and online at: City of Coronado Municipal Code Section 84.2, available at City Hall and online at: iwi>-.w"-'vvr.,.' :'.:il;'.""1 '.',"; >.::i-'t;,iri..i,-..int;t->; if! li,,','h'niicoronddo84coronado842.html»84.2 The Secretary of the nterior' Standard for Treatment of Hitoric Propertie: ' UiJ..;.'."- :1'

182 t Mariotti Reidence 1127 F Avenue, Coronado, California Summary Statement of Project: Amendment to HRC Permit Approved on and Propoed AdditionModification to Hitoric Home: Omit the previouly approved Addition of 52 quare feet to the rearnorth elevation to create a Breakfat Nook. Addition of 552.f. to the ide of the Kitchen to create a mall Family Room and Breakfat Nook area. Thi addition will be et back from the front plane of the exiting houe by 8' 7-34". There will alo be a Terrace between thi new area and the exiting Kitchen. The Terrace will be 211.f. The propoed addition will be a requet for an exception to the ide yard etback. We are requeting a 5' ide yard etback where a 3' 2-7l"to 22' 3-717" etback i required (15% of lot width). 498.f. wa previouly approved by HRC on 11817, thi a add 24" along the front of the propoed Family Room. Move the acce to the exterior on the back ide of the Kitchen wall. Thi acce will lead onto the new Terrace in the backyard. Thi wall ha had a number of alteration over the year. Therefore, it ha already been altered. GarageGuet building Remodeling to include: Tranforming the exiting Guet Bedroom Bath into a Pool Bath and Pool Equipment Room, and convert the Garage into the Guet Houe. Omit the previouly approved Addition of a 816.f. Guet Houe located in the backyard. Thi Guet Houe wa located in the alley ide etback which wa allowed a an exception ince the property i Hitorically Deignated. Retain the Previouly Approved Covered Terrace, altering it to be more open on both ide, and removing the exception for a reduced interior ide yard etback ince the added lot will create more pace and will keep the tructure out of the ide yard etback. Add: Add a 2nd chimney attached to the Covered Terrace for the repoitioned Pizza Oven, which i only een within the backyard. New 4-car Garage located at the rear of the newly added lot. The tyle will be compatible with the original building on the ite. See "Propoed Finihe" for decription of differentiation. Add: Fill in the exiting door next to the tair to the Baement, which i only een from within the backyard. 178

183 t r- Omit: Changing exiting living room door and window at rear of building. Original fenetration to remain or be retoredreplaced a needed. Rehabilitation to Hitoric Home: All work Previouly Approved by HRC Remain: Replace exiting non-original red day tile roof with two-piece red clay tile roof more reflective of the found hitoric photograph. The color will be more varied than current roof and the intallation will be more varied to match the photo. The hitoric photo are black and white, therefore, our roof tile election will be baed on tone variation on the hitoric photo and other Requa and Jackon building of thi period that retain their original roof tile. At the front of the houe, replace the exiting non-original crank out caementfixedcaement window in the Kitchen. The new window will be placed in the ame opening (but reduced in ize to match the ize of the window adjacent), and will be a puh out caement to match the detail of the original caement window on the houe. The hitoric photo how a maller window a we are propoing to replace uing a imilar ize. (Window C.l on the propoed plan). At the front of the houe, replace the non-original crank out caement window at the Kitchen within the ame opening and ame ize (Window B) At the ide of the houe, replace the non-original crank out caement window at the Kitchen within the ame opening and ame ize (Window A) At the 1995 Addition located on the Upper Level Bathroom, replace all three crank out caement window with puh out caement window of imilar ize. (Window TT, UU, and VV) At the upper rear of the houe, replace the exiting non-original crank out caement located in the arched opening with more appropriate wood puhout caement window. Thi grouping of three arche were originally a covered balcony that wa filled-in a part of a remodel in 1998 per the Reidential Building Record. (Window grouping LL) Retorereplace in kind Living Room doorwindow at rear of building Propoed Finihe: All work Previouly Approved by HRC Remain: Previouly Approved: Family RoomBreakfat Nook Addition: Stucco to be the ame color but lightly moother than the original finih to differentiate the addition from exiting. The two-piece red clay tile hip roof over thi new area will alo help differentiate thi addition from the exiting tructure, but imilar 179

184 material will create a compatible addition. Add: 24" along the treet ide to the Family Room. Previouly Approved: Covered Terrace: The roof will be a two-piece red clay tile roof of imilar color and intallation to the original roof of the houe. The wall finihe will be light colored tone which will differentiate the tructure from the original. Previouly Approved: New 4-car Garage: Stucco wall in the ame color a the main houe but with a lightly different finih to differentiate it. The roof will be two-piece red clay tile imilar to the original roof of the houe. Previouly Approved: New Roof at the Hitoric Home: To be replaced to be a better match to the hitoric photo of the houe. More variation in color, more variation on the lay-up, and a cloer match to ize to the hitoric photo. Propoed Baement Expanion: All work Previouly Approved by HRC Remain: A portion of the current baement floor will be lowered to allow acce to the propoed Baement Expanion floor level. The new Baement Expanion will be entirely ubterranean and uneen. The only hint that there i below grade area will be a few light well that will be for the purpoe of light, air, and egre from the baement level. All light well will have grate that are walkable. All light well will be located at the perimeter of the ite and will be viually minimized. n the center of the Baement will be an on-grade wimming pool and pa. For the Baement footprint, ee heet Al.Oa. Site Acce and Logitic: Previouly Approved: Due to the nature of the excavation to accommodate the Baement Expanion, we are propoing that a portion of the Alley ite wall be removed, and then replaced in kind a the ame height, location, thickne, and tucco finih. Thi wilt allow for equipment to acce the ite a well a allow for proper horing along the property line. Previouly Approved: nterior ide yard wall i propoed to be removed from the rear of the houe to the garage to accommodate the Baement Expanion. We are propoing that the new wall i rebuilt at the ame height, thickne, and tucco finih a the original wall. The current wall it 4'-9" from the interior property line, our propoed wall will be on the property line. Thi will allow for the horing to be properly intalled along the property line and will regain lot quare footage behind the current wall location. 18

185 \ Add: Add a pair of wood gate along the alley wall to acce a utility pace for the * Electrical Service. Acce need to be from the alley for SDG&E. Backyard Modification: (With the exception of the peak of the Aviary and the interior ideyard property line wall, all exiting item to be removed are uneen from outide the property. All work Previouly Approved by HRC Remain except a noted: Addition of a Swimming Pool and Spa Omit: Addition of a Guet Houe, Pool Bath and outdoor hower Addition of a larger Covered Terrace to replace the current maller roofed Pergola (Exiting Covered Terrace). The new Covered Terrace will have a Dining and Sitting Area and outdoor fireplace. There will be tep from the Covered Terrace level to the pool level. Addition of a new BBQ Area outide the exiting Kitchen. Addition of variou hardcape. Landcape planting and garden element. Remodelingmechanical repair of exiting Water Feature at the backide of the Garage. Removal of the following tructure: Non-functioning Aviary at the alley property line wall (original deign not verified, but footprint appear on original plot plan) and the roofed Pergola (Exiting Covered Terrace) located 4'-9" from the interior property line. (The propoed Covered Terrace i located 5'-" from the interior property line) Removal of the exiting non-original Gardener' Bath. (not hown on original plan) Removal of the exiting non-original Gardener' Storage Shed (not hown on original plan and hitoric photo do not how tile roof) Removal of the exiting ite wall in the center of the ite. Removal of the exiting trellied hade planting area. Removal of the exiting non-original brick work, path and planter Removal of walled utility area below the propoed Breakfat Nook addition (not hown on original plan) Add: Add a tucco wall within the backyard to create an Electrical ServiceUtility area acceed from the alley. Front Yard Modification: All work Previouly Approved by HRC Remain: Landcaping to be fineed a needed after contruction occur. Full Landcape Plan to follow. Prior to intallation, material to be reviewed by HRC Staff, or a recommended by the HRC. Exiting non-original Entry walk. Step and Entry Stoop to be replaced with period appropriate material. Prior to intallation, material to be reviewed and approved by HRC Staff, or a recommended by the HRC. 181

186 n Requeted Zoning Exception: nterior Sideyard Setback [86.8.6]: 5;-" etback rather than 15% o The required ide yard etback i 3'-2-716" at the narrowet point where the ide yard etback meet the rear yard etback, and 22'-3 716" at the widet point where it meet the front yard etback line. o The propoed Family RoomBreakfat Nook i 5'-" from the property line. The exiting etback in thi area, prior to combining the two lot wa only 3'-. The length of the propoed tructure in the etback i only 21' 2-34". o mportant to note i the exiting home i located 4'-8-916" from the previou property line, where the current etback requirement (a the original lot) i 19'--14". (15% rule). o We are omitting the need for the Previouly Approved Covered Terrace ideyard etback encroachmentexception which wa le than 5' and for a length of 45'-3". Omit: Alley Sideyard Setback [86.8.6(1)]: 1' etback rather than 5' (Alley width i 2', propoed tructure i behind a olid maonrytucco ite wall that i exiting at ll'-o" tall - rebuild wall a noted in ite work) FAR: 5% Allowable, propoed 35% - Complie Height: 14'-4" Acceory tructure height limit, propoed 14'-4" - Complie Lot Coverage: 5% Allowable, propoed 29% - Complie Previouly Approved or Permitted work that i till activecurrent: HRC and City Council approved plan. n contruction now. Previouly Approved Plan No Longer Valid: 29 - Two tory and one-tory addition along the interior property line connecting the Hitoric Houe to the rear of the original Garage building. Thi project approval i till valid according to the City of Coronado. Not yet built Swimming PoolSpa permit iued, interior ite wall, Gardener' Bath and Gardener' Storage Shed and trellied hade planting area were all to be removed a the footprint of the new work overlapped thoe area. Thi project approvalpermit i till valid according to the City of Coronado. Not yet built 182

187 811Z6 V3 'OaVNOt3 SHNHAV d LZU Bfi NH aonaaia OVN a< till H 7, "iviiiiaian crv'i-i M u w Q 1- ) w p < 11 ll i i < Si a1 ill. l "t j nlllll 1. ilji iilijl 5E jl. a' j "-! B 6 lllily ll ilii L l Jl }ll JWili!!! il,11! ii!lil!l H il il,!lj1 Jiiit,,11 i!i jiijli Jlllll "iil llilliii ft lili ill ill! i ill!! : liili iiliii SillliilJill!!l ill -S! hi!' lilseliill jllll!!! ihh 1111 Hihilii inililji j.jj {llli dll! ill!,! S Kffillill! 11 JJHii! fflljll ll JiJ! iili j iliiiii Ji 11 illlilllllu lliiiiiilllliiillilllillll i, i 3i ill 3a 3B6? i Sit E r \ li S 66 SSSSSiSlS!i S P"" e? J g 5 ll!li!l!iil gsaaeam ia a! J1 SSSS isssisssit i im p???835 a i U Jlgp2iS?? 5 ill!! i! '62 a JiJ! liiiijiijiyi i!i $1 SiSSSSSS!i i ill S! h h SE ,111 a«6b8a68e6 S illli i Rill,! ill 1 J! 11iii!i! 5 ll! mm! 11 in ; Si ll li its p wnl i. ll illilii jss3i3m«3 i8 if,.(;; 1 lii il!!? S"i$8?8h>:l.; B?See8S28lB P' Jijj SBB«5 1 l >nl Sl 111 <1 l t i ii i 11 c S,! m libll? i m wa JJli iishilhi, Sl Nllj!! i) iwi'ui jiiiyiiiiiviihii."shssse j.>«i8se ii$l8.i3(sh.!ilijii!ii<5(({i!!i:»,sjse Ei iwuiu a iit&iuulitia.i.ii i Slh llhs :ll lil.l, ililjl S<JS«ii <. ihfti!?ie,i. j MSiiEiMlgEL'h.iaaugiSl MSSS nulm.iituh Miib i i,,.-lisi93i1<iehiii.ls3ssi5.iis5,i3sm 183

188 ill! d 5' S.i P 88 [, 81Z6 VD 'OQVNOH3 HFNHAV d LZll aonaaiai iiioivw i< \ EX; j S 8i lu] \ 1,1 3 lyl 1 ajl ol \ r \ -' \. r \ \ \ \ \.\ \ \ \ \ \ r- \-\ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ '\\ \ r Bl E 1118 w Q ll!: 'iviiian '<'VH \ \ \ \ J \ \ \ \\ \ \ Y\ \ \ \ \ \ L \ \ \ \ a? x fi > a r ~r i- [ JL==-==3 L==== [ J=4 nnnnn c ll! uuuub { iyl z il iu u "Jl? 1 t F! TH ~Q ' i:! rl ~M m i!t> 4n V,; 3 (LJ ll :::::] c u> c c Ml T c 3 :l 'c L ----E te J 9 h 8< _J 184

189 ! ș 3 \f. S U iliilllh,!lll,isii1 h jilj.lijl.iljljik1.! liiviiihjiiiiufnii 1111 <\ 81Z6 V3 'OQVNOX3 HHNHAV 3. Lll N1 adnaaiai OVN a<?? 5 - D < i *; i: y y in > in 'TV) ifiaian <rvh 5 {» -tf-' m & g ' 4 \ v \ \» < * X: x, a i.-i e.\ -< U &: \ f. 1&, S3 % \ z ;y U tfil.> < Q 1U LJ L y 1,,. (L isj ==1 i a r!a m n" ijt 1 ]B a", t{!q=. e giy y 12 r ~1? ]:.:.. 1 2KU-W+ :1 r 1 r _J! ' L;.Ci.{:9 N -li }!'f LT:l:ii 4A 8 i] [ a.-86 M.,2T.F9 A l'ft ll[; K ;' < 1»a:

190 !h ll i r { 8Z6 V3 'OQVNO3 il\t fi -L; T aonaiaykj'vri \ \ \ < \ \ \,\ - \ \ lliiili Mil! ll lill!! \ i \ i < 4 co f _1 i \ D (L \ \ " v iy \ \ \ '. \ \ 1L \ -1 \ 1U > \ 1U r - - in tf 1L - 1U rfl - tft =a i: ( ==J ==j fc== -a - ==1 F== ~- r-~ r---- _ J p a fj=l-l \a.lnan -d'v'i - nnnnn )1 : D 'S i uuuiju : %..1 L@ ] = \ l\ D K U J (S? T 1D \- li J! ( ) iffi &' ,!" \\-y J. H»V(W~ ~f l _J 3i l i m c 7 t a i L. W[- - wvr'fff.fcmc 186

191 f mm lli ' 81Z6 V3 'OQVNO3 annsav d LZ\\ admaaiai iiioivw a< il8ii8ji S! a 11 -i\'i.lian '<rv'h ( \ i D!w t 5 :.- - is D %3..-' i, 11 r -t S «.-'!t5;.- &J?T< ST U 33 (B.-' i '.'.T -.<.- r? \ X SS -- L_- 1 y!!l,.--1i c ll 11 i 51 u-1 iyl tl 1 isl Ql 9 3)S J r! 2S 2S Jp.y-w L -J 187

192 aa''i M admaaia rij53\vw \ < 8Z6 VD 'OaVNOU3 c S." a Ho -'\ v -\'lilnails 'd'v'h \ i.- \ \,' \ \ V- \ \\ t \..' " \ \ \ \ \ \ A.''» Si.' \ \ \\ \\ ' v\.- \ \ a- \ u \,- a 1 1L.'' ( )." <»K (D y \ 9 Y dd z t 1U in l l j(s ii Ml a u. Sl n:-i- -i " ;i 8 1: e c[ ; i! A ( a! ( \ S! ;! y. ll ± S 1 m WOHtM M gi;.; Sli 1 -frl - -Ff -J j L L

193 iii : 8Z6 V3 'OQVNOS3 (niaa A'.i1 adnaaia rir w \ \ i< -\ ' Y- \.- \ yo \ Dl«'. \ > t \ 1..' \ \r\ \ \ 'i \ \ a i5!! M!" i\'iiii'man '<rv'h m 11 1' il \ \ -(.. \ \ i \ \ y A:> \ \,' \\ -? \ \ \ \ z < i \ - (L.- (g) V n PE _J U-!5! - i iii U ;: j _1 : ' v ($ a c\ Qf t 3 a Sil a Sl~ ± i \.~. " ;!-l ll R-i -ill \ \ \ i. 2 l!ljl ll -1 h-j 1 li! L: liit h-1 \ \. mrj i-i S U--J -1 3 h a\y r", ll ± r -Ff _J K g V. L

194 [ \ 81Z6 V3 'OaVNO3 L> i \ ill i!l c-l " Fnt r adnaaiai 'i w \ <; t i Y- \ i.- \ a \ '. \ - \ 1.'' \ ~7 "TVllNtinS 'd'v'h \\ \ \ \\ \. - \ \ (>y \ \ y \ \ A;> \\ \\ y v\ '?». (L. - U-.-' > \ \ u. \.- U 1 rf) \ -\- v? r- - t \ u. - i< 4> < a il ±<! \ - n ± : lllli! ll!p!s -} y!1! i ill T - 'i.v, ll : - ti -r \ t -J L J- 19

195 !h in 8Z6 V3 'OaVNOH3 HONHAV d LZU adnaaia iiioi'avw p ir> 'T\'iiian <'V'H ( '.-.' y x '.".' r --" r-1 i 1.- L-.- r -7J 51 l 1? t ST 3 J r UJ J J < c.. - i 11 T L-: L 3 M <?ZT.F5 N 191

196 1 i 8Z6 V.3 'OOVNO3 annhavd.zii Nctiai OVN ill! t < riv.l.jjimani 'ii'v'h D D e a <b 3 11 <3 >nl U xl 1 <1 >1 S ln] <3Q in U z < > U 9 i U UJl t ii==ii r==iia 11 Q t $ 1 1 ml t >n xl U 1.fFHO l > 3; Ci => m Q UJ >n - K L lie 3o D 3 <9 S) S) ffl li <9.! -a- -!!J" S 8)? 192

197 til 8tZ6 V3 'OOVN3 annhav Z.Z r t < w ag adnaaia OVN 1V.1J.); "S -ct'vh 1 w- -»--»- ~ --»A- -S<B--». 3E E li FFffl]. " J 1 B3S!i! \ <3 hs- 1- ffil? t) c,? cj 9 (& < 1 - T oil 'ti D >B z - S > '" x U u- 3) ts) JU B Ct m d <n B- K B- n :-, ;% y A L 193

198 SZ6 V3 'OaVNOt3 annhav j.zii adnaaia OVN i< m vlll;arls 'd'v'u lit A 2; ( -S--S »--»« S- HE t ill l'! i t a t ill t g 31 i Q ncl <1 >1 U _ll lul > zl Ql li a 31 g S "\ 8) Ji > t xl 1-1 n'1 1 z zl 1-1 <1 >1 t z 1 E FFffl nl 1 inl xl U-ll Q r!s - &; nl Ql >n 1 n-1 u.} n-1 ll 194

199 ih 811Z6 V3 'OOVNO>[3 gnnaav 3. t.-zu admaaihi OVN io 8 S ' li 'Tviiiivan 'a'v'h c " \ \ \ \ -S--S » -»»--»- t t i a a i ill b n 5 -»--»- ---*- -S- -9- a? 19 fit) S) : >n z 1 <1 >1! D ) a $ \. c E 1 in zl <1 >1 lli ll D < <> 1 z 1 1 ( < 11 zl Ql lul fl < a ml Ml z >nl xl 11 fl D B =ii n D U in n- ft n- v v <3 195

200 15 13 T 811Z6 V3 'OOVNOUOD annhav j Z.Z adnaaia iiioiivw a< 11!! ll" t f "'iv.i.iihan 'ci'v'i-i ag 1 \ B Uffl in ' d 3 1 1? 88 z < > U UJ > z o m >n U > " e - ±- f 1? M v E 1 "Jl UJl 1: z a - < > U Cl [X SE' ;1 i nl UJ 11 <1 w.\ <1 11 l li; El n -- a d (Q in UJ (D 196

201 ll 81Z6 V3 "OaVNO)3 an-mhav J LZ\\ St 3DNaaia OVN i< TV.Liitvari 'd'v'h '? 11 <n Zl -»»- -»- - => in! <1 >1 t 11 zl < > U-t F J Ql - =1 U] l <1 fl <1 * 31 \y a >& z 88 1 in U tj y t a a >nl <1S oil h- <1 >1 lul - U t z 1 ml. >n < ii iu i H < S > i 1z Q '5 U 1 <1 11 <1 l 1 5 n S >n e? D i i t 6 -a» -e- e- JTr 197

202 8Z6 V3 'OaVNO>3 HflNSAV 3. AZll adnaaiai OVN i c~~~ 1 l\ ' iv.l.iiivan 'd'v'h -- -»- a -S- -9- i 5 >n i < > UJ S- < i 1U UJ < u. < 1 d 9 UJ -SHir'wiST 5 in -! S..L.._.._-._. a. 1 (f n- 1 U D > r <!i f li < i 1 i\ Cl '. in il n- l\ a B «- -<B- «- - ~55uB' Ti' i! «t in < UJ < > f» ' ; i; Si!i in -! o -»! UJ UJ 1 < w. < M) d UJ in n_ n: a S 1$. _L_ Oi > < f < S D U >n tt. u. - J_.-_ THrt-ZHEZau 198

203 81Z6 V3 'OaVNO>3 HONHAV S L-Zll adnaaia iiioiivw i lii ' 1!" g i t t in UJl z 1-1 <1 >1 U-l _ll u-l U 1 <1 1 f Ql UJl u.\ U >1 1 1 U-l in a-l 1 u.\ B-l? 11 ll \ ; 2»- -»--»- ;'\.-".-.1, 6 t E TV.LllMfln 'd'v'h lli in U z z 1 < > lul 1 <1 tfl Kl U 1-1 Q U nil UJ >1 1 1 &1 UJl in 1 B-l n'1 n-1 _L t &1J:.fe B St ik -$- [. le1: H'yyn S S "T -flj m :.(.; r-j.,:'-;--;-- LLi'.i'u:Li::a[;n: n --. fflilffl m u S} L[K1J1 l;!- ;-l;i; - n;l 1 <1 >1 tul U 1 <1 a'1 f lul 1-1 Q U-l n'1 U >1 1 nl UJ in 1 a-1 u.\ B-l E i 1» t i 8\. [ ktvurfllkh nufluuflm MiyAny rnr-i nupini u a'1 1 h-1 <1 >1 U - 1U U 1 <1 w.\ Kl 1 U n:l lul >1 vll Ql U tfll 1 n-i ir n-! 199

204 15 8Z6 V3 'OOVNOU3 SnN3AV 3. LZll 33Naaia~a OVM Nlli i >.\ lii!t 1 ill t\ wiiiiman 'ci'v'h -S--S- ( n 1 -,rr NmiHjm 11->-1 tviiuyiui in zl 1-1 <1 >1 U 9 m MLMim 'TfUiVrfUfr] in 1 $1 ll ( nuflnuflraj UJ < u. [f U t- U!- 1 <1 Oil u.\ ' vi ynya< run ran. c Cl UJ U' LU > vj Cl U in n- St D- ffi ' rrmrrm ll!llj iiit Ql l 1 >1 Q U in n-1 K\ n-l "." -9-- Slll 1 lli E : t lit u in :1 1 g a»: a t rv-1 f\ UJl U 1 tl ir 1 Ql U-l u'1 lul >1 Ol Ql U-l >n 1 n-1 u.\ B-l» J] 1-1 <1 ll UJl U-l w.\ 1 l d U >n n_ u. n- 2

205 !1 li i 8tlZ6 V3 'OQVNOOS gnna;vv d Z.Z admaaiai OVN io Pil i < iviiiian 'ti'v'h Jl ll 1 ll ( d 9 11 El il ll?1 jl Slllililll l M 1 l ai ilil El ll i l ] ililillil ll zlll w ll li u i i 6 =» D x <n illl l 11 li li t 1111,1.1,1.1, 11 1 il. :ll ;1 ;11 l.lll w ' { 2 S ;1»1' \ 2 Ji ill! ;! ill 81 i,1 El li.11. i i 2 : 2 2 lill lil!l i 1:11 li; 2. li l il a i i'l l i'l i'l al S 5 5 S a i E 3 i li; ilil ai a i a Sl l U -j =>1 1 U] l 1 in Sl nl zl Sl 11 i i 1 il l?l? i ll Jllll w l\m llllllilllll < <- => < e 3 & >i -: n 11 lit t \M l r"'" T aaodoad i! i \\ aodoad 21

206 n E <u QL fo <u - <u LO Q. Q Q- Q) ro c Q 1 U u» o 31 CO a.- \3 v1 \ fe : v p k '» 6 & - -yfi. t" M h, rf' K ( :SlA w9x u (D u < --' c ru L- (D rf. it<»? 22

207 \ - <--'; r ;; c? i. S( -<! \ Sl % T- cr 1. - \ft <?* m ',-wiw {,?,* '?. 23

208 n 1. W& 4..! ltj!.-?".«**".r 'K.. t'.-: h'?>? ':< --!%yr»a r>. t < > <* 9 3 -i 1?a- &... v { M K & R-; M. '.-3,< ; F A. «t. & * h < y'-lt.-< " ' r-'w 'tft'»i 24

209 fc. WK- WWWft NrKffN Htf., :t~ K Sa;S Ki ggsjlillpk.-.1 '" NK.gigjBge.SM...A '. ii%:se 25

210 VK K :-:& w f 4. "»! K'i it& V K ili T' <- :i'ks B :t";a f: -i. ':%, miw! ', ~~:- '»»»?;&? i%, R'? K: Sl..gii l:i 1, A ~S~li" ~»a. ttinra: "infniari. i-.!m. '- 2 t:.:53 K 'f-. ;m t "te... f,- i«g :*?. - * VKS'SSS -«-' te' m' w "-'» t»- - 5;- w abu»?»-'-.<<<, A. i.si E?:' 26

211 «,-> r. '' ] <»' - &*.». tt yw* e w, - 2 S '>-.:* f r V. 9 ff?f %,..' i-,. ( f,f\,? w. *i.' 1,. ( i-: 1 - v l!? { f :. i,; f M i ( ( i <- J r A ;t "56;3 '» - *#f t ) g fl r? at a f (» «B-!g w'wk e-''y-f?s SK V: m 'f..><-» isbs. v! f'. f fe -4 w- S! mt ff a» m r : f S f. "i i y its y fa?; 4 : i 1.? J? it &.t % '.«!; " vf & f m fsn»& S»i. 11 m SitS M -* m - fe: w.» tk.taa\ MA<* 27

212 A {' ti y.'-i.i Q- ; < i t t fe. v _.i,l J 1 is'js.'f ', i* ' Jr. '<1> w CL LU 4 >@ 7S;.A t. Bi!» Jfc >-)» Q CD i-. ':-\ " r, LU ifs f < LL m \f m * a.. 28 r'

213 -r < u > k m 29

214 ~\. GQ u > VQ <SB t±±l i 1 i 1 ; 21

215 r ' 1 ; ;; 1-3 BS ULJ > 211

216 r Q LU > a B a S y. A 212

217 m Lll LJ > 213

218 , u- : LU > f m. y 214

219 r Attachment 3 RESOLUTON NO A RESOLUTON OP THE CTY COUNCL OF THE CTY OF CORONADO APPROVNG THE REQUEST FOR HSTORC ALTERATON PERAT, NCLUDNG RELEF FROM ZONNG STANDARDS RELATED TO SETBACKS, FOR THE PROPERTY ADDRESSED AS 1127 F AVENUE AND LOCATED N THE R-1A (SNGLE FAMLY RESDENTAL) ZONE WHEREAS, on March 27, 217, the property owner ubmitted a Hitoric Reource Alteration Permit, witli zoning exception requet related to etback, for the property addreed a 1127 F Avenue in accordance with Chapter 84.2 of the Coronado Municipal Code; and WHEREAS, on April 19, 217, the Hitoric Reource Commiion of the City ofcoronado held a public hearing on HAP at which time all peron deiring to be heard were heard; and WHEREAS, the Hitoric Reource Commiion recommended approval of the application with aociated requet for relief from zoning tandard related to etback in aociation with HAP 217-4; and WHEREAS, on May 16, 217, the City Council of the City of Coronado conidered the Hitoric Reource Commiion recommendation to approve the iuance of the requet for a Hitoric Alteration Permit with aociated requet for relief from zoning tandard related to etback in aociation with HAP 217-4, at which time all peron deirmg to be heard were heard, and evidence wa ubmitted and conidered to include without limitation: 1. Hitoric Alteration Permit application ubmittal HAP 217-4; 2. Oral tetimony and correpondence received regarding the permit application; 3. City Council taff report dated May 16, 217, including taff determinatioh the project wa Categorically Exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act puruant to Cla 31 of Section regarding Hitoric Reource and Cla 1 of Section 1531(e) pertaining to mall addition; aiid 4. Additional written information, plan, photograph, and project material provided by the applicant. NOW, THEREFORE, BE T RESOLVED that the City Council of the City ofcoronado fmd, baed on the evidence decribed herein, that the zoning exception requet a decribed in Hitoric Alteration Permit application HAP 217-4, hall be approved becaue the following finding have been made; A. The propoed alteration i conitent with the purpoe and intent of tlii Chapter, the Hitoric Preervation Element and the General Plan a the project i conitent with Objective D of the Hitoric Preervation Element of the General Plan, a the project i conitent with the Secretary of the nterior' Standard for Rehabilitation. B. The propoed alteration will not adverely affect the hitorical, arclutectural or aethetic value of the Hitoric Reource a the project a propoed i conitent with the Secretary of the nterior' Standard for Rehabilitation. C. The propoed alteration will retain the eential element that make the Hitoric Reource ignificant a the project retain the original hitoric appearance from the public right-of-way, and retore non-hitoric element to period appropriate appearance. 215

220 D. The propoed alteration will not adverely affect the Hitoric Reource' relationhip to it urrounding and neigfaboring Hitoric Reource a the project doe not impact urrounding building or Hitoric Reource, and the relationhip of the building to it urrounding will reraaia unchanged. E. The propoed alteratioii complie with the Secretary of the nterior' Standard a et forth in Section 16 of the National Hitoric Preen'atioa Act of 1966 a the project meet the Standard and Guideline for New Addition, a the breakfat nook i located at the rear, i ubordinate to the original dwelling, and i differentiated yet compatible; other modificatioa uch a encloure of the rear loggia will not adverely impact the dwelling and are reverible, and new acceary tructure will not adverely impact the hitoric dwelling. NOW, THEREFORE, BE FT FURTHER RESOLVED that the City Council of the City of Coronado hereby approve the iuance of a Hitoric Alteration Permit for the hitorically deignated property addreed a 1127 F Avenue and located in tlie R-1A (Single Family Reidential) Zone, a ubmitted in the application and plan compriing HAP 217-4, in accordance with Chapter 84.2 of the City ofcoroaado Municipal Code and approve the following aociated zoning exception requet: 1. Side Yard Setback of approximately 4'-8" for contruction of a covered terrace, where a etback of 15% of the!ot width would be required (CMC ). 2. Side Yard Setback on the alley ide of approximately 1 '-" for contruction of a ingle-tory guet houe, where a etback of5'-" would be required. NOW, THEREFORE, BE T FURTHER RESOLVED that the City Council of the City of Coronado hereby approve the foliowing condition to HAP 217-4: 1. Change to the approved plan may require the review and approval of the Hitoric Reource Commiion. 2. Any mechanical equipment intalled m aociation with the project will be creened from view from the public right-of-way. 3. Thi Hitoric Alteration Pemut hall expire three year from the date of approval by the Hitoric Reource Commiion. 4. Thi Hitoric Alteration Pennit hall uperede any previou Hitoric Alteration Permit approval for the property. PASSED AND ADOPTED by the City Council of the City ofcoronado, California, thi 16th day of May 217, by the following vote, to wit: AYES: BENZAN, DONOVAN, DOWNEY, SANDKE, BAD.EY NAYS: NONE ABSTAN: NONE ABSENT; NONE ATTEST: Mary L. QJiiTord, C City Clerk RiAard Bailey,Mayoj CityofCoronado 216

221 l 8Z6 V3 'OaVNO)3 aniihav 3. LZ aonaaiai iiioiivw a H il ".'iljl (.i\.-s\.-w NO OUH A8 Q3AOaddV) M u M Q c w H < fc ll ll ll ill Ei 1&1 [S! l!! ih.jlli! iill!8!..»5 Ab, i!!l ill i! lil ll: Ht2 El; i liil N111 1 in K p? ll 36 ab y j SSiSS SSS!i!it SS!i i i«a i????" q5.1 i5ssi i t. S S SSi!.8»ES? R S 3 m Sl SiSSSSSSS S phfr? i H aiaaiilsg!l it li il!li ll!82 J f ll J Hil JJ jjl) 1 llllilj! S;!1111!il1!! ll 111)11 1?1 '? li ijjlifj t!l liii l.ili Ji l! iiilllini illlilll iliiiljli[!!ffl 11111!iiiiil lliltil iliililiii illiiiji lli ll i! 1111 lliil ill lllil] lil 11111,1 Jl! illllll Hi i liihllllllh tiijil 11 { iiiiliiiiiiijh j.. yiijjiij eeeeesbsb illlllt li lit JJJJ, lilllllj S ii.il li! 1,11 lilll! lid! ]i i!13in lli!i JJijJjJJ illllij jllllll JiSliJ 1 81 liltli ill 1 4 U?1 (: : < i i i l.p yy. l..h.? llillll!!26beae ly. i! i ll S l ll.l!! 3i!l! llil!!l li 1 ii n j!rie SSiS ill! BEBB 1 i li» p t E 5.6»S li (D js!11 ]M S lil!ii lilill ill!!! ill llljjil iig i! S i in < ull iiil ll ll1 ll ll! il!f lil ii! ill ill! 3 Ft 8 1<5 'f 3 3 U < U i3!!i! y!!!!j!jj!l.!ual!l illil llllll hsil i j iitiyj jjl i!i!j,yiiiiii.-'i.<!!! 'j..aaii!,! it ;l». M <" liiii.ti Aii'.iStiMii'.»u. l! 88,Ji J. jjj llllliliiill k llj iilijjiiilll h lattit it iititiittl&.s.i j, is; 11,_. lfl S JS < S -5»Si!fiifJil(,3 S issiii."ilj gtiii:-e!.lis3s iu& SSS8J lihi iiiiyiiii lj iiil i SiStStiliS -SildSiiSSS i ijjlil ililil...-u! ili iisisiis.iaisail 217

222 o z ul u 1»*tH, li CL 71; fc,'? u 1y (Al-6. OUH A9 aaouddv) " HB Z8' o 111 liillplillll ill llgii jglllj gs SiiSti5SS5ii 8 3 Si5l!S i:l liil ll t"-\ $SP ll if.,". y'i < N till q i Eillil u \ D ~ > - <1 u yl! ij li kl 6 S i li 113 Bi i - <-.<,;': V y i a g Y_J a p v y!% co < ) a n in os. S) <& N Y 3 kv f Oo> i< \ mg "-. yr A\, l HO"* rd" e UUL" c llll" -; A1d v 3 aiv ;\ ou «y\!1 3 7d» * v y 6- c PCC * o < e a a 8 F 218

223 !ii <i ; j; B i t t ; ~7 81Z6 V3 'OQVN3 annhav LZ\ adnaai-a OVN lilbwil 1 1.".' \ (L\--6\--W NO OUH AS a3aouddv) \ 1. \ \ \ \ i i % '' rt a % i» \ \ \ \ <11 31 ll 11 u-1 ll FT A A.,' < i! i \ a & 1 (-. x z- [ <1 1 1 ;".! t u' io 1 E -J 44Th Ti lilu!!! L f yii " li J! lli ±:: te L. fc"-l i; ihli v '-.,''\ \z; ~3 <p T n J -1 :!:! i!i@t - --{ S3 219

224 ', :' 1! 8Z6 V3 'OaVNOOD animhav d LZ. aonaaia OVN (1-61-W NO OUH AS Q3AOaddV) CN) ll M Q 1, \ lili J ;«u AS «y, r \ l\- \\4 (T- \>- ;u 1- fe\' J.11 "Jll ll LU _ll J 9 S ill r - y a <> < -T'l h a ( ]! ( --!- =! f u 22

225 1, ll l! Sli ll lill lil li!: l"ii!_ i! a 7 8Z6 V3 'OaVNO3 annaav 3. LZ t 3DNaaia'a OVN llffl! a< 118 Utl U:!iii!. S i llij ii! 3J hiiii ezbbii ill! li t ill! u in i < \ JlJ-6J-M NO OUH AS a3aoyddv)».. 1 1< E r 1 S 1. A- 1 \.( 1 \ " i ' i A U < -3,' v -z- r 1> ' Q' U3 m >!S < i 8S u- < 4[ - t Q U tfl a D- 5 :B c [ F &-1 -i 1 fc a - -r S?E <»E 1». : < f.oovoz' 3.zp'.er.-g U 11 1ll 221

226 ! \t ijlli li ill ll ; 11? llijillil1!; i! g ll lli.l 5 51h "ctf" 81Z6 V3 'OOVNOOD HONHAV d LZ ' 1 3 H \ t adnaaiai OVN a< l ill ill ' r: ill aaa ilh illl jjli i ea ill!! i. t: lit illj y >n i.!' i (il-61-m NO OUH AS a3aoaddv) i z >.. U 8 y \<! l\ ; \ \ r l i-ii'i'" g _ [...ji.j 2 '' 5 :8» ii ", 1. A --\ B r -< a U U v y > z ' i. a UA r 81 >.> Sfl < a - U-z U : t!?! M M_-J-- fc.oq-ooz 3.,f.f5 S i U E v in < [Q fe <11 d U in a- li, -1 -l 5 :i? K -4*- - i..,,e:.;-.i""<se : M ll 222

227 8Z6 V3 'OOVNOOD 3nN3AV d Z.Z ;u it HDMaaia'a OVN < a< {il-gl-w NO OUH AS a3aoaddv) \ > Sii ; » 6- % < Q.i ll < ll x S i, 1U lillli "i iri 3 11 lltl 5 > ill 1,11 i!lli in !1 U-. uiini D iillllllirij S til!» \ \ \ \ * & -< U < A 3 v -z- * \ i. a U r'.. > H 11 < ll L '<; r M i - r' iti h < 1U in M)! -. in x U il -f i Jl --??-lr -! r:x_.._.._-.-.._.&-r.._.._.._.._ t" T 3 -T =J ii!_ ~o5''55?"3~z{.'!e~ra~j~ _.J1_.._..-.S_.._ io. J': 223

228 81Z6 V3 'OQVNOOD HnNHAV d LL : i t c & adnaaia OVN < i B (U-61-W NO OaH A9 QSAOUddV) N Mi \ i \ \ ft ll t A w 5% t,: R * % z tl it <»i < it - B- w- 1, f, & \ \ -- \ U- % _J te & u- t, &> 1U - > 1U 1 \ U _1 & \- - tf) % - o? ai \ in " a L L c> (S) U ( 9 in? - t - % <» tf) <. < K, l % x ft < 1 a a u - i?»;l! is! m a li iss.i w. 1< w. m a lii :a i!s! 3S i i j!. ": aaa! ti Ll- t A y imle B 5 j- f( i itel'i S t S, & \it 'ri i nnnnn? ii! li S!i t JLi c: 3,i a ii r: -y : uuuuu :! ff li <K li; -j? iitj.! A ll }\ ; 1 B N % ll 5(i u\ 1 > liii S it [ S if a p te c f J al J UK ' r- i $ a( S:] B a( D= by S -'»i m, x i( lit _; 224

229 iii lij 8Z6 V3 'OaVNOOD gnimhav d Lc admaaiai iiioiivw i< (l\.-6\.-w NO OUH A8 a3aoyddv) ll lleili r!1 ijlih rr Sl \ <> p z < 1 - "i u. i ;» 1L U < u. K 1U?" >: y % y a * ka U A y => <>, y i te ' U a 1U." (S) % u. y. U -y- ir- t U.-'." <a> in ;',' iijt y < y < "?: : (L 3 a A r;? K n U.TM li S! < - in 5 i <* 3S U i < ( S(i < f t [ Q LfflSJ 1U rfl 9 K-! laj : F- ' U nnnn a a (f Q- fc J9 8 Sl< 3 HT-ei -<ST -1-3 UA -3 : [? 225

230 m. l!i 8Z6 V3 'OaVNOOD annhav d Li aonaaiai OVN a< y B 1 lilil co181!l \<!1 (Zt-6t-f NO OUH AS Q3AOaddV),'." \ ' a 5 g i $. i '.» i ' 3-> - % z \\ \\ \! < '. i. ft Q- % *i at y - y ai y d L?.1 <; U- '; - A? (i U ' U 'i > - 1U a z t 1U &\ \S) U - y it u',1 ko tf) :, V- t (L 1 x i U - *-i- (D. ( )«. 3 D Q(g) a is 11! 3 i a Sl i it «i *-T ill ( ( 11 t 'it li < :51 ( : 1? i. S ii.. B nn \ b 23 >1 23 >! S<Si n ll n aeb M?::3;! ;! as 33 ; > t3 Si ;3 ' BiiS G A z -1!!?r ii A y ts T j1 8< :5< a( ; :1U m 2 i J m»(.-w v.w «!.TO....pci \ti& i- [-D i r- 3 a 8i g? i 1--": r < 226 i

231 -l h lii t.' 8Z6 V3 'OQVNOOD annsav d Lc aomaaiai OVN i-a {il-61-w NO OUH AB Q3AOaddV).' \." ' \.' \ \." \ \. \ \ ---"»»t J-> ' m 1 \\ \ \\ < 6 t! 5 < - - \ ( u- \- '. \. 1L J \ 1L 1U - > 1U 1U >? U \ Ql. ', UJ '... :? > - SS 9 x i \!? U Kig]\ 3 E5 b li 111 a,!! %!S T 1(S!i? a: ii! S Si v. 1 i» 2l St $ 83 it 3) (i g fl-.u a 6ii L-M ill 11 l a i! 3 :.. ;:E11i e a i <- -L. ± J Hml M : 1 ± Ln!-4 ::te:] 227

232 GSll!i ' 8Z6 V3 'OQVNOOD SnNHAV d LL 1 a3n3qsa llovn i \." \ {il-6l-w NO OUH AB Q3AOaddV) \,' \.-' \ \ < &? \. - \\\ L \\ z? \- in x U. t. -,. > - t >? «1ll \ \ 1 ill? ll (. 1 k LJL F T T jlj a Sl. tj- - ±- l -. icol *- ;' u J '1 JEW t-t- 2 r 2 - c:fa 228

233 il i(i! ;. 8Z6 V3 'OaVNOOO animhav d A- adnaiai iiioiivw io S iiillb w [ 1!Bljl 6 l.ii-61-w NO OUH A8 a3aoaddv) \ \ < ;' '-.-' -,' t \ A v.--.' < _1 - L. \ \-' Q Y< U \5) 9. a. t»» <.. y \ \. f A f. \ \.<,' -A y L- < a- L w. 1U a < [~_] : M) 9 w. ;-,riy AifP i= tf) t x D \ 1U L-J r r'l-llh ---Ttn"' i:4i=a ll ::] [::::::::: [:::::- L 2 229

234 8Z6 V3 'OOVNOS3 3,nNHAV d -- A--A- --- H OJ! liiii f R Wii < m a 3 in a v ll?! o H Aa aaadadv) -. <g D D a a] in z in! <fa i < < > < > U a z > z z 1 m D > U z >n a. >n x u. L D 23

235 -»- -»- 111 y i 3 n i k- 811 Z6 V3 'OaVNOS3 SONHAV j a liaaia iitt)iivi< a ii>i i»i ii H t J io bhaaaaoald&lji M [ ] Si n J >n <1 UJl! >n <! 11 ul A 11 q U 11 C>1 11 l " xl tl ' Sll Ql nl ll inl n-l 1 B'1 n-1 \.?M >le \ -" y- y 231

236 , 8Z6 V3 'OOVMOOD gonhav d L-< aonaaia iiioiivw i a llltli (T} l g Ui-ei-w NO OUH AS aaaoaddv). i,,»,.,., [ \, S--S- -fb- -9- tl i ( { i k t t j S--S- -» t k 6 i a HE t L 11 ].u E l 1 tf>l <1 >1 1 z 11 d G> v E= xl >nl zl <1 >1 lul - U * zl 1! D ml >n xl ml Ql UJl in n-1 f n-1 v v 232

237 8Z6 V3 'oavnom3 ann3av d.zi aonaaish-a OVN i 1 (Al.-61-t'O NO OUH AS a3aoaddv) 1! \ 1, -S--S- -» -SS--S- -S--S- -S--S SS--St i t tie t ( ill 1k (fl ] 1? lli g h-1 u.\ 1 z z? <1 >] <1 >1 UJ -ll LU l z C>1 H 1 z &1 nl 1 z >nl Xl D E ml 1 UJl in n-1 Kl

238 81Z6 V3 'OaVNOtt3 gonhav S LZ] aonaaiai OVN i< (i\--6\.-w NO OUH A9 a3aoyddv> ll fil 1 11 li 51 -t i? i! t t.1 >nl D xl 1 <1 > E >n z < >! ( 1. UJl in»»»» u 1 >n U = >D 1 U-l in D-1 K n-1 S >nl =1 1 xl 1-1 >n U-l =1 MS 1 U-l >nl n-1 f n-1 "' --!!!»1 9 < t J m+h \ X Kl h-1 <1 >1 U? >n <1 z < > U E >nl =>1 1 lul >nl 1 xl 1-1 in in D d U >nl 1 n-1 1 tt!l n-1 "" a 1 * o U] in u.\ n-1 234

239 81Z6 V3 "OOVNOOD HONHAV LZ] aon3aia OVN i< (zi-i-t'o NO OUH AS aaaoaddv) H 1 l'l r: 1 l i 13 i -»--»- - - *! in <1 >1 U-l 1 E ll -«--»- v LL-ijiih wm\w in E ll g a -9--d i t i a 1 <1 u.\ nc Ql iu! 'i UJl >1 1 o >U >n n-l n; D. WllkNLm Ufll LLH11 WiyATbW nunmn b r \ 1 <1 >1 U -il lul U-l 1 <1 w.\ w.\ Ql Kl UJl >1 1 Q U; >ni 1 n-l n:l u-1 H Bill ::i BK W \"rf'.\ \ 1K UlS UN:11 fgil 1 A. J 3_ zl 1-1 <1 >1 U _ll UJl U 1 <1 u.\ n'1 lul 1-1 &1 U-l Kl UJ >1 <>1 Ql U in B-; 11 n-' 1 g -S--Sa. y "«"" -- T-i L 'nl <1 UJl z 1-1 <1 >1 U-l - U-l 1 <1 Oil u.\ 1 lul B'1 lul >' Cl U >n n- B' D- i 235

240 ;1!-1 ] 8Z6 V3 'OQVN3 gnnaav LZ adnaaiai OVN i< if E loo \< hi (1.-61-W NO OUH A9 aaaouddv) 1..1.) ;:\tt. ;,: V i ) 11 i\ 11 A w ll ll i AA ll M ll ll il i ill]?1 tl il AiAL \ ill u 1 i\ lit 1t?1 El31S!! u?1 11 ll LiL El l\ il il 1 ;'! il?1?1 lltl A Sl Pl El ill el M 1L ll 11!1 Ul El Pl it 1 N 11 d a ii ii l J!l!l ll! il ! Kil w lil l t> il 9 81 M1 1 ill ill S?1 81 iillllll.llljllll.l.lll.llllllllljlllllll 3 D»n n: D lli ll 1L jj ll! bl bll n w1 iltl *1 i! 'lal 81 2 li i i i a Sl Sl Sl Sl i i E a t\ 151 T 81 'l ' i\ f\?1?1 2 51?1 S 5 11; 81 i»1 : i 2 11 S S Sl Sl S'l 31 i\ S 81 i MXWWSW aovtw a i l t\ 1 l t> nl del!m b S S S S Sl Sl Sl t\ a ei a a i ii i lil ai nnr 236

241 tl 81Z6 V3 'OaVNOOD aniiaav d LZ cl 8 adnaaiai OVN io < lit! a?1?1 ill li fflj 51 jj! ll ill! u ll X 51 Sl?1 ill a a M u?1 El!1 Sil N 111 A11!li ill y a a i 1 Ji ffl S 111 El il lilw ill iilill!! j _ii i i i w! ilil?? ll S S S ill 8?1?1?1?1 ll ell (i\.-6\--w NO OUH A9 Q3AOaddV) 1 liilii l e ili ll ilililllilillli lll 1!1 ill ll ll ll ll ii! il ililillil ll?? l l l l l! ll ill 11 iii ll ilil ill a a a!1! ffl B 1111 iiil ll 1111 li 1 lit o,! Ji S<! Z : ii li i\'l Wi?; 1 lililil!l?l? lilil ill Sl Sill 11 l 111 jlll,llljlllllllllll llllllljl llljl. ll] SlilEl 3 3! elel h tf S E 6 S S S 2? 2 2 i l SlltllE 2 > i ; i i mw 8lel8lelelalel8lelBlelelelelel. el6lal8lel6lb 31 lil!l!l!l M ll ll li 1 ll m5l M lll M ws 2 l wf\?! S S ww\ww i\ t ilil lltl ill ww i 8 8 i 8 S i i 8 E ill S S i !1 Jllll ' S 2 8 l l j l l l l l l l j l j l l l l MS]il il illi i llttlll;l!llllill!l!lll!ll?l!l!lllll liillllliliiilllljllllillililllljlj a e 8 a 8 a 8 a 8 e a e B B B 8 8 B ate e S 2 S S S ; 8! < S '! ; ; 8 S <1«3 t iws t 8 i t t 3 $ awi (None H)!l!l!l!l!l!l!l lllilllll S S S S S S ww R a g?» i 237

242 THS PAGE NTENTONALLY LEFT BLANK 238

243 CORONADO HSTORC RESOURCE COMMSSON AGENDA TEM Public Hearing Regular Meetin December 6, 217 HP CTY OF CORONADO: HSTORC RESOURCE COMMSSON REVEW OF HSTORC PRESERVATON MLLS ACT APPLCATONS SUBMTTED N 217 FOR PmORTZATON AND PLACEMENT ON THE HSTORC PRESERVATON MLLS ACT WATNG LST: 1144 SABELLA AVENUE; 116 FOURTH STREET UNTS 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 AND 7; 55 A AVENUE, 455 A AVENUE, 46 E AVENUE, AND 111 LQMA AVENUE. BACKGROUND: On an annual bai, the Commiion prioritize new application for placement on the Mill Act waiting lit, baed upon a home' hitorical ignificance. The Commiion i given background information regarding each reidence that i obtained from the Hitoric Deignation and Mill Act application file. ANALYSS: Lited below are the 216 Mill Act application to be prioritized: 1. HRPA abella Avenue 2. HRPA through HRPA Fourth Street 3. HRPA A Avenue 4. HRPA A Avenue 5. HRPA E Avenue 6. HRPA Loma Avenue Background information for each property ha been provided a Attachment 1. f additional information i needed, Commiioner can review pat agenda and HRC meeting minute on the City webite, and project file for each property which are available for review at City Hall. Uing the rating heet Commiioner hould independently rate each property, in each category, with 1 repreenting a low value and 5 repreenting a high value. Therefore, there each property ha a poible total of 25 point from each Commiioner. f a Commiioner ha a conflict of interet and i diqualified from coring any of the propertie awaiting prioritization, that Commiioner hould leave the core blank and note "diqualified" on that rating heet. Staff will average the core given by other Commiioner in order to make up the core of the diqualified Commiioner. Commiioner hould return their completed rating heet to taff by January 25, 217. A numerical value baed upon the application date will be added to the core by taff and the propertie will be incorporated into the waiting lit. Once thi i complete, taff will preent the updated Mill Act waiting lit at the next regular meeting. Attachment: Background nformation and rating heet for 217 Mill Act Application :\City Council, Board, and Commiion\HR\HP Mic Preervation Report\217\HP Mill Prioritization\217 Mill Act App Prioritization.doc 239

244 Attachment 1 HRPA abella Avenue Deignation Date: Mill Act Application Date: HRC Mill Act Public Hearing Date:21217 Age: 13. Contructed in San Diego in 1887, relocated to Coronado in Deignation Criteria: A, C, D Architectural tyle (Criterion C): The property wa deignated under Criterion C a an example of the Queen \ Anne Victorian tyle. Hitoric mportance FamilyCommunity (Criterion A andor B): The property wa deignated under Criterion A, a a pecial element of the City' political, aethetic, and engineering hitory in aociation with the relocation of the dwelling from San Diego. The property wa not deignated under Criterion B. ArchitectBuilder (Criterion D): The property wa deignated under Criterion D a an example of the notable work of the architect, Edward Booker. Scarcity Value (Criterion C andor D): The dwelling on the property i one of 7 Queen Anne Victorian dwelling that are hitorically deignated. t i the only known deign of Edward Booker in Coronado. Architectural ntegrity: The property generally retain architectural integrity. A large addition wa completed at the rear of the dwelling in 1983, after it wa relocated to Coronado (Building Permit B1366). n 26, an unpermitted roof deck wa contructed and ubequently removed. The non-hitoric railing from thi roof deck remain, in place of the hitoric roof creting. Mill Act Hearing Comment: The Commiion recommended approval of the Mill Act application, recommended excluion of the 1983 addition, and recommended retoration of the hitoric roof creting baed on hitoric photograph a a condition of the Mill Act Agreement. t.5?», r-fi "(Ww }:. ihh * -, A" ;;'E ";% 24

245 RESOLUTON NO. HR A RESOLUTON OF THE HSTORC RESOURCE COMMSSON OF THE CTY OF CORONADO DETERMNNG THAT THE DWELLNG ADDRESSED AS 1144 SABELLA AVENUE LOCATED N THE R-1A (SNGLE FAMLY RESDENTAL) ZONE MEETS THE CRTERA TO BE DESGNATED AS A CORONADO HSTORC RESOURCE WHEREAS on September 11, 216, the property owner ubmitted a Nomination for Hitoric Deignation (Determination of Hitoric Significance) application in accordance with Chapter 84.1 of the City ofcoronado Municipal Code; and WHEREAS, on October 5, 216 the Hitoric Reom-ce Commiion of the City of Coronado held a public hearing on HR at which time all peron deiring to be heard were heard, and WHEREAS, evidence wa ubmitted and conidered to include without limitation: 1. Nomination for Hitoric Deignation Application dated September 11, 216; 2. Oral tetimony; 3. Hitoric Reource Commiion taff report dated October 5,216; 4. Additional written information and photograph provided by the applicant; NOW, THEREFORE, BE T RESOLVED that the Hitoric Reource Commiion of the City of Coronado find the property a decribed in the application ubmittal dated September 11, 216, hall be deignated a a Hitoric Reource becaue it meet three of the following criteria: a) The property exemplifie or reflect a pecial element of the City' political, aethetic, and engineering hitory, a the relocation of the large dwelling from the Shennan Height neighborhood of Sm Diego to it current location on abella Avenue in Coronado involved coordination of both juridiction a well a local utilitie and tranportation agencie; b) No evidence wa found that indicate the dwelling i identified with a peron() or an event() ignificant in local, State, or national hitory; c) The dwelling and carriage houe exhibit character defining feature of the Queen Anne Victorian tyle, are valuable for the tudy of reidential architectiire of the Victorian era, and have not been ubtantially modified; d) The ubject property i the only known reource contructed by deigner and contractor Edward Booker in Coronado, both the dwelling and carriage houe retain architectural integrity from time of contniction, depite a move from Shei-man Height to Coronado, and are example of hi notable work; e) The building ha not been lited or fonnally determined eligible for the California Regiter a et forth in Section of the California Public Reource Code. 241

246 NOW, THEREFORE, BE T FURTHER RESOLVED that the Hitoric Reource Commiion of the City of Coronado hereby approve the deignation of the property addreed a 1144 abella Avenue a a Coronado Hitoric Reource with all the benefit and retriction of hitoric deignation, a outlined in Chapter 84.1 and Chapter 84.2 of the Coronado Mimicipal Code, including compliance with the requirement of the California Environmental Quality Act. PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Hitoric Reource Commiion of the City of Coronado, California, thi 5th day of October, 216, by the following vote, to wit: AYES: Gillingham, Goot, Pator NAYS: ABSENT: Talbert DSQUALFED: Keith Attet: W i-r-" Rachel A. Hurt Director of Community Development AAL~ David Gillinghn, Chair ' 242

247 m City of Coronado Hitoric Preervation Program ' \ Mill Act Program Property Rating Form 1, Property Addre 1144 abella Avenue HRC Hearing Date Mill Act Application # HRPA Commiioner nitial Total Score Criteria Point Poible Point Awarded Ditinctive Architectural Style 5 Hitoric mportance (FamilyCommunity) 5 Prominent ArchitectBuilder 5 Scarcity Value e.g. few remaining example left in community 5 Architectural ntegrity (original tructure intact) 5 Total Point Awarded

248 HRPA Fourth Street Complex Deignation Date: Mill Act Application Date: HRC Mill Act Public Hearing Date:21217 Age: 119. Built 1898 at 138 Orange Ave, relocated in 1928 to 819 Pomona Ave, and again in 1943 to current location. Deignation Criteria: A, B, D Architectural tyle (Criterion C): The property wa not deignated under Criterion C. Hitoric mportance FamilyCommunity (Criterion A andor B): The property wa deignated under Criterion A, a a pecial element of the City' engineering hitory in aociation with the two-time relocation of the dwelling. The property wa deignated under Criterion B for it aociation with Mendel Chruchill and Bernard McKenzie at it firt location, and with Clau Spreckel at it econd location. t ArchitectBuilder (Criterion D): The property wa deignated a an example of the notable work of the architect, Frank L. Hope, who deigned the remodel of the building from a ingle-family home to a nine-unit apartment building a part of the Home Ue Program of the National Houing Agency. Scarcity Value (Criterion C andor D): Thi building on thi property i the only building deignated a an example of the notable work of the Frank L. Hope in Coronado. Architectural ntegrity: The property wa not deignated under Criterion C, for the architectural tyle of the building. The building retain a high level architectural integrity from the remodel to an apartment building in 1943, for which it i deignated a a notable work of Frank L. Hope. Mill Act Hearing Comment: The Commiion recommended approval of the Mill Act application and did not recommend any excluion or retoration item a condition of the Mill Act Agreement. a; 5f'-' w-.- ;f(... ' ' '.S'i.'W!,''"' -,. t i <. \ 'TiKC 1M -\.'; h- 3tl ' %».j ii-% 244

249 RESOLUTON NO. HR A RESOLUTON OF THE HSTORC RESOURCE COMMSSON OF THE CTY OF CORONADO APPROVNG THE HSTORC DESGNATON OF THE BULDNG ADDRESSED AS 116 FOURTH STREET LOCATED N THE R-4 (MULTPLE FAMLY RESDENTAL) ZONE AS A CORONADO HSTORC RESOURCE WHEREAS, John Murphy, Preident, and Ann Keyer, Vice-Preident, a maiiager of 116 Fourth Avenue LLC are the owner of the building addreed a 116 Fourth Street; WHEREAS, On May 29, 213, the property owner applied for the hitoric deignation of the building addreed a 116 Fourth Street in accordance with Chapter 84.1 of the City of Coronado Municipal Code; WHEREAS, on June 19, 213, the Hitoric Reource Coinmiion of the City of Coronado held a public hearing on HR at which time all peron deiring to be heard were heard; WHEREAS, evidence wa ubmitted and conidered to include without limitation: 1. Hitoric Reource Application ubmittal dated May 29,213; 2. Oral tetimony; 3. Hitoric Reource Commiion taff report dated June 19, 213; 4. Additional written information and photograph provided by the applicant; NOW, THEREFORE, BE T RESOLVED that the Hitoric Reource Commiion of the City of Coronado find the building a decribed in the application ubmittal dated May 29, 213, hall be deignated a a "Coronado Hitoric Reource" becaue it meet three of the following criteria: a) t doe exemplify or reflect pecial element of the City' engineering hitory, a a building that ha been moved twice ince it contruction in 1898; b) t i identified with peron() ignificant in local, tate, or national hitory, a the building, in it original location at 138 Orange Avenue, wa owned by Mendal Churchill and Bernard W. McKenzie, and in 1928 wa moved to land owned by Clau Spreckel at 819 Pomona Avenue; c) t doe not poe ditinctive characteritic of an architectural tyle, and i not valuable for the tudy of a type, period, or method of contruction and ha been ubtantially altered; d) t i repreentative of the notable work of an architect, Frank L. Hope, who remodeled the building to a nine unit apartment building a part of the Home Ue Program of the National Houing Agency; 245

250 e) t ha not been lited or formally determined eligible for the California Regiter a et forth in Section of the California Public Reource Code. NOW, THEREFORE, BE T FURTHER RESOLVED that the Hitoric Reource Commiion of the City ofcoronado hereby doe approve the deignation of the building addreed a 116 Fourth Street a a Coronado Hitoric Reource with the following condition: 1. That the exterior of the Hitoric Reource hall not be altered without approval from the Hitoric Reource Coi-rmiiion in accordance with Chapter 84.2 of the Municipal Code; 2. That the Hitoric Reource hall not be demolihed or removed from the ite without approval by the Hitoric Reource Commiion in accordance with Chapter 84.2 of the Municipal Code; 3. That the exterior of the Hitoric Reource hall be adequately maintained to avoid the lo of exterior building material, roofing material and paint; and 4. That the ite, landcaping, and micellaneou improvement urrounding the Hitoric Reource hall be adequately maintained to provide for the viibility of the tructure from public right-of-way. PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Hitoric Reource Commiion of the City of Coronado, California, thi 19th day of June, 213, by the following vote, to wit: AYES: Keith, McGowan, Ryan, Wilon NAYS: Gillinghani ABSENT: ABSTAN: Attet: pzu.r Courtepa'CMcGowe, Chap %<_ Rachel A. Hurt, Director of Community Development, Redevelopment & Houing Service 246

251 City of Coronado Hitoric Preervation Program Mill Act Program Property Rating Form [ Property Addre 116 Fourth Street HRC Hearing Date Mill Act Application # HRPA HRPA Commiioner nitial Total Score Criteria Point Poible Point Awarded Ditinctive Architectural Style Hitoric mportance (FamilyCommunity) 5 5 Prominent ArchitectBuilder 5 Scarcity Value e.g. few remaining example left in community Architectural ntegrity (original tructure intact) 5 5 Total Point Awarded

252 HRPA A Avenue Deignation Date: Mill Act Application Date: HRC Mill Act Public Hearing Date: Age: 14 (built 1913) Deignation Criteria: A, B, C, D Architectural tyle (Criterion C): The property wa deignated under Criterion C a an example of the Craftman Bungalow architectural tyle. Hitoric mportance FamilyCommunity (Criterion A andor B): The property wa deignated under Criterion A a a pecial element of the City' cultural, ocial, aethetic, and architectural hitory, however no additional information wa provided in the reolution, taff report, or nomination for the deignation regarding thi criterion. The property wa deignated under Criterion B for it aociation with Edgar Rice Burrough, an American novelit, the reolution and taff report note that Burrough rented the ubject property in 1913, one year after publihing Tarzan of the Ape. ArchitectBuilder (Criterion D): The property wa deignated under Criterion D a an example of the notable work of the builder, P. M. Holt, however no additional information wa provided in the reolution or taff report for the deignation regarding thi criterion. The original building permit for the dwelling identifie A. W. Wood, a builder known for contruction of many dwelling in Coronado and San Diego, a the property owner. No contractor wa identified, a wa typical of building permit iued to A. W. Wood, who bought property and built dwelling to ell a peculative venture. P.M. Holt i the contractor lited on the building permit for contruction of a garage and repair to the ubject dwelling in Scarcity Value (Criterion C andor D): Thi property i one of 38 Craftman Bungalow propertie that have been hitorically deignated, and i one of 4 propertie built by P.M. Holt that are deignated a Hitoric Reource, and one of 2 propertie deignated a example of the notable work of P. M. hlolt. Architectural ntegrity: The property retain architectural integrity. Mill Act Hearing Comment: The Commiion recommended approval of the Mill Act application and did not recommend any excluion or retoration item a condition of the Mill Act Agreement..( '.:w..!:9.r :."'u.-3t c 1,. " :.*"< L_-_i»,, )t y i.--?'-"»»-».: 't.;... au 248

253 . RESOLUTON NO. HR 11-7 A RESOLUTON OF THE HSTORC RESOURCE COMMSSON OF THE CRT OF CORONADO APPROVNG THE DESGNATON OF THE RESDENCE ADDRESSED AS 55 A AVENUE AND LOCATED N THE R-1A (SNGLE FAMLY RESDENTAL) ZONE AS A CORONADO mstorc RESOURCE ( WHEREAS, John C. and Patricia J. Kelleher applied for the hitoric deignation of the mgle family reidence addreed a 55 A Avenue in accordance with Chapter 7.2 of the City of Coronado Municipal Code; WHEREAS, on March 21, 27 the Hitoric Reource Coiiuniion of the City of Coronado held a public hearing on HR 2-7 at which time all peron deiring to be heard were heard; WHEREAS evidence wa ubmitted and conidered to include without limitation: 1. Hitoric Reource Application ubmittal dated February 16,27; 2. Oral tetimony; 3. Hitoric Reource Commiion taff report dated March 21,27; 4. Additional written information and photograph provided by the applicant; NOW THEREFORE, BE FT RESOLVED that the Hitoric Reource Commiion of the City of Coronado find the ingle family reidence a decribed in the application ubmittal dated February 16, 27, hall be deignated a a "Coronado Hitoric Reource" becaue being contructed in 1913 it i 94 year old and becaue it doe meet the following criteria: a) t doe exemplify or reflect pedal element of the City' cultural, ocial, aethetic and architectural Utory; b) t i identified with peron ignificant in national hitory in that Edgar Rice Burrough, the American novelit reponible for creating the character Tarzan and many Tarzan adventure book lived in the reidence in 1913 a year after hi firt book Tarzan of the Ape wa publihed; c) t i one of the few remaining example m the city poeing ditinctive characteritic of a Craftman Bungalow architectural tyle, and i valuable for the tudy of a type period, or method of contruction and ha not been ubtantially altered; d) t i repreentative of the notable work of a builder, P.M. Holt. 249

254 \ \ NOW, THEREFORE, BE FT RJRTHER RESOLVED that the Hitoric Reoiu-ce Commiion of the City of Coronado hereby approve the deignation of the reidence addreed a 55 A Avenue a a Coronado Hitoric Reource with the following condition: That the exterior of the Hitoric Reource hall not be altered without approval from the Hitoric Reource Commiion in accordance with Chapter 7.2 of the Mimicipal Code; That the Hitoric Reource hall not be demolihed or removed from the ite without approval by the Hitoric Reource Commiion in accordance with Chapter 7.2 of the Municipal Code; That the exterior of the Hitoric Reource hall be adequately maintained to avoid the lo of exterior building material, roofing material and paint; and That the ite, landcaping, and micellaneou improvement urrounding the Hitoric Reource hall be adequately maintained to provide for the viibility of the tructure from public right-of- wav. 1, PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Hitoric Reource Commiion of the City of Coronado, California, thi 21t.day of March 27, by the following vote, to wit: AYES: Crenhaw, Herron, MacCartee, O'Brien, Wilon NAYS: ABSENT: C- Attet: Ge _ff-5uuul MacGartee, ;ar Chair Jffw <7.' Tony A.Pfia, Director of Community Development 25

255 CityofCoronado Hitoric Preervation Program Mill Act Program Property Rating Form ( Property Addre 55 A Avenue HRC Hearing Date Mill Act Application # HRPA Commiioner nitial Total Score Criteria Point Poible Point Awarded Ditinctive Architectural Style 5 Hitoric mportance (FamilyCommunity) 5 Prominent ArchitectBuilder 5 Scarcity Value e.g. few remaining example left in community 5 Architectural ntegrity (original tructure intact) 5 Total Point Awarded

256 HRPA A Avenue Deignation Date: Mill Act Application Date: HRC Mill Act Public Hearing Date: Age: 13 (built 1914) Deignation Criteria: C, D Architectural tyle (Criterion C): The property wa deignated under Criterion C a an example of the Craftman architectural tyle. Hitoric mportance FamilyCommunity (Criterion A andor B): The property wa not deignated under Criterion A or Criterion B. ArchitectBuilder (Criterion D): The property wa deignated under Criterion D a an example of the notable work of the builder, C. J. Lihman, a one of hi few known reidential work and poibly hi only known work in Coronado. Scarcity Value (Criterion C andor D): Thi property i one of 4 Craftman propertie that have been hitorically deignated, and i the only dwelling built by C.J. Lihman that i deignated a a Hitoric Reource in Coronado. Architectural ntegrity: The property retain architectural integrity and wa recently retored baed upon hitoric photograph. Mill Act Hearing Comment: The Commiion recommended approval of the Mill Act application and did not recommend any excluion or retoration item a condition of the Mill Act Agreement. e. -r y m ",..} -"-!1; %: ' > a i?- t,f r. 1--" <«a E- g". av.i»>" *,!-&8; m '.». } A K -& SW&.',.':M "liv-: 252

257 RESOLUTON NO. HR A RESOLUTON OF THE HSTORC RESOURCE COMMSSON OF THE CTY OF CORONADO DETERMNNG THAT THE DWELLNG ADDRESSED AS 455 A AVENUE LOCATED N THE R-1B (SNGLE FAMLY RESDENTAL) ZONE MEETS THE CRTERA TO BE DESGNATED AS A CORONADO HSTORC RESOURCE WHEREAS on Septeniber 12, 216, the property owner ubmitted a Nomination for Hitoric Deignation (Determination of -itoric Significance) application in accordance with Chapter 84.1 of the City ofcoronado Municipal Code; and WHEREAS, on October 19, 216 the Hitoric Reource Cominiion of the City of Coronado held a public hearing on HR at which time all peron deiring to be heard were heard, and WHEREAS, evidence wa ubmitted and conidered to include without limitation: 1. Nomination for Hitoric Deignation Application dated September 1 2,216; 2. Oral tetimony; 3. Hitoric Reource Commiion taff report dated October 19,216; 4. Additional written information and photograph provided by the applicant; NOW, THEREFORE, BE T RESOLVED tliat the Hitoric Reource Conmiiion of tlie City of Coronado find the property a decribed in the application ubmittal dated September 12, 216, hall be deignated a a Hitoric Reource becaue it meet two of the following criteria; a) No evidence wa found tliat indicate the dwelling exemplifie or reflect pecial element of the City' military, cultural, ocial, economic, political, aethetic, engineering, or architectural hitory; b) No evidence wa found that indicate the dwelling i identified with a peron() or an event() ignificant in local, State, or national hitory; c) The dwelling poee ditinctive characteritic of the Craftman architectiiral tyle, vauiable for the tudy of reidential architecture dating from 1914, aiid ha not been ubtantially altered; d) The dwelling i an example of the notable work of the builder, Clifford J. Lihman, a one of few knowii example of hi reidential work, and poibly hi only known reidential work in Coronado; e) The building ha not been lited or formally determined eligible for the California Regiter a et forth in Section of the California Public Reource Code. NOW, THEREFORE, BE T FURTHER RESOLVED that the Hitoric Reource Commiion of the City ofcoronado hereby approve the deignation of the property addreed 253

258 a 455 A Avenue a a Coronado -itoric Reource with all the benefit and retriction of hitoric deignation, a outlined in Cliapter 84.1 and Chapter 84.2 of the Coronado Municipal Code, including compliance with the requirement of the California Environmental Quality Act PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Hitoric Reource Commiion of the City of Coronado, California, thi 19th day of October, 216, by the following vote, to wit: AYES: Gillingham, Goot, Keith, Pator, Talbert NAYS: ABSENT: DSQUALFED: -~1 Attet: David Giilingh6'm, Chair rr>r ~w. ';:. --'R'achel A. Hwi Director of Community Development 254

259 CityofCoronado Hitoric Preervation Program \ \ Mill Act Program Property Rating Form \ Property Addre 455 A Avenue HRC Hearing Date Mill Act Application # HRPA Commiioner nitial Total Score Criteria Point Poible Point Awarded Ditinctive Architectural Style 5 Hitoric mportance (FamilyCommunity) 5 Prominent ArchitectBuilder 5 Scarcity Value e.g. few remaining example left in community 5 Architectural ntegrity (original tructure intact) 5 Total Point Awarded

260 HRPA E Avenue Deignation Date: Mill Act Application Date: HRC Mill Act Public Hearing Date: Age: 88 (built 1929) Deignation Criteria: B, C, D Architectural tyle (Criterion C): The property wa deignated under Criterion C a an example of the Spanih Bungalow tyle. Hitoric mportance FamilyCommunity (Criterion A andor B): The property wa deignated under Criterion B for it aociation with Arthur Bratz, a Coronado Police Officer who wa recognized for hi work a an invetigator and topped an attempted uicide while reiding at the ubject property. The property wa not deignated under Criterion A. ArchitectBuilder (Criterion D): The property wa deignated under Criterion D a an example of the notable work of Chri Cogrove, a the lat remaining ingle tory dwelling contructed by Cogrove on thi block. Scarcity Value (Criterion C andor D): Thi property i one of 6 Spanih Bungalow propertie that have been hitorically deignated, and i one of 12 deignated propertie that were built by Chri Cogrove, and one of 1 propertie deignated a example of the notable work of Cogrove. Architectural ntegrity: The property retain a fair amount of architectural integrity. A remodel to the property wa completed in 216 which included replacement of non-hitoric vinyl window on the front facade with period appropriate, non-hitoric, wood window. t i not known if thee replacement window match what would have hitorically been preent. Mill Act Hearing Comment: The Commiion recommended approval of the Mill Act application and did not recommend any excluion or retoration item a condition of the Mill Act Agreement. a A g»y» asv -<» a? A.'A. Vt [A w- a- Si<- ;-.-"».- F* * R» g'. i e Kri -- -i -'' (! 256

261 RESOLUTON NO. HR A RESOLUTON OF THE HSTORC RESOURCE COMMSSON OF THE CTY OF CORONADO DETERMNNG THAT THE DWELLNG ADDRESSED AS 46 E AVENUE LOCATED N THE R-3 (MULTPLE FAMLY RESDENTAL) ZONE MEETS THE CRTERA TO BE DESGNATED AS A CORONADO HSTORC RESOURCE WHEREAS on July 6, 217, the property owner ubmitted a Nomination for Hitoric Deignation (Detennination of Hitoric Significance) application in accordance with Chapter 84.1 of the City ofcoronado Municipal Code; and WHEREAS, on Augut 2, 217 the Hitoric Reource Comniiion of the City of Coronado held a public hearing on HR at which time all peron deiring to be heard were heard, and WHEREAS, evidence wa ubmitted and conidered to include without limitation: 1. Nomination for Hitoric Deignation Application HR 217-1; 2. Orai tetimony; 3. Hitoric Reource Commiion taff report dated Augut 2,217; 4. Additional written information and photograph provided by the applicant; NOW, THEREFORE, BE T RESOLVED that the Hitoric Reource Commiion of the City of Coronado find the property at 46 E Avenue, hall be deignated a a Hitoric Reource becaue it nieet three of the following criteria: a) No evidence wa preented in the application that indicate that the property exemplifie or reflect pecial element of the City' military, cultural, ocial, economic, political, aethetic, engineering, or architectural hitory; b) The property i hitorically ignificant for it aociation with Arthur Bratz, a Coronado Police Officer who wa recognized for hi work a an invetigator and who topped an attempted uicide during hi occupancy of the ubject property; c) The dwelling exhibit character defining feature of the Spanih Bungalow tyle, i valuable for the tudy of reidential period revival tyle architecture dating fi'om 1929 during the period revival era, and ha not been ubtantially modified; d) The property i an example of the notable work of the builder, Cliri Cogrove, a the dwelling i the lat remaining ingle tory dwelling contructed by Chri Cogrove on thi block; e) The building ha not been lited or formally determined eligible for the California Regiter a et forth in Section of the California Public Reource Code. NOW, THEREFORE, BE T FURTHER RESOLVED that the Hitoric Reource Commiion of the City of Coronado hereby determine that the property addreed a 46 E 257

262 Avenue meet the criteria for deignation a a Coronado Hitoric Reource with all the benefit and retriction of hitoric deignation, a outlined in Chapter 84.1 and Chapter 84.2 of the Coronado Municipal Code, including compliance with the requirement of the California Environmental Quality Act. PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Hitoric Reource Commiion of the City of Coronado, California, thi 2nd day of Augut 217, by the following vote, to wit: AYES: Gillingham, Goot, Keith, Pator, Talbert NAYS: ABSENT: Attet; t.vr' 7 David Gillinghtn, Chair Rachel A. Hurt Director of Community Development 258

263 City of Coronado Hitoric Preervation Program [ (, Mill Act Program Property Rating Form Property Addre 46 E Avenue HRC Hearing Date Mill Act Application # HRPA Commiioner nitial Total Score Criteria Point Poible Point Awarded Ditinctive Architectural Style 5 Hitoric mportance (FamilyCommunity) 5 Prominent ArchitecVBuilder 5 Scarcity Value e.g. few remaining example left in community 5 Architectural ntegrity (original tructure intact) 5 Total Point Awarded

264 HRPA Loma Avenue Deignation Date: 9226 Mill Act Application Date: HRC Mill Act Public Hearing Date:92217 Age: 14 (built 1913) Deignation Criteria: A, B, C, D Architectural tyle (Criterion C): The property wa deignated under Criterion C a an example of the Victorian tyle. Hitoric mportance FamilyCommunity (Criterion A andor B): The property wa deignated under Criterion A a a pecial element of the City' military, cultural, ocial, aethetic, and architectural hitory, however no additional information wa provided in the reolution or taff report for the deignation regarding thi criterion. The property wa deignated under Criterion B for it aociation with Jame Lord Pierpont, author of Jingle Bell who i noted in the reolution a the great grandfather of the property owner who nominated the property for hitoric deignation; and Admiral McCain, who had a ditinguihed military career. No information wa provided in the reolution, taff report, or nomination for the property regarding Jame Lord Pierpont or Admiral McCain' occupancy of, or aociation with, the property. ArchitectBuilder (Criterion D): The property wa deignated under Criterion D a a notable work of M. Chapin, who the reolution note built over 2 home in Coronado' early hitory; however, no additional information wa provided in the taff report, or nomination for the property regarding M. Chapin a a builder. No builder or architect i noted on the permit for the contruction of the dwelling, however, M. Chapin i noted a the plumbing contractor on the ewer connection permit for the property, a he i on many ewer connection permit in Coronado during thi time. Scarcity Value (Criterion C andor D): Thi property i one of 3 Victorian propertie that have been hitorically deignated. t i the only property deignated a an example of the notable work of M. Chapin. Architectural ntegrity: The property retain architectural integrity; no major modification are known. Mill Act Hearing Comment: The Commiion recommended approval of the Mill Act application and did not recommend any excluion or retoration item a condition of the Mill Act Agreement. yf v,.- *-; - " >:..;< 9 J. v-- ra.ua i!!!ll!!!;iiji *«i< "Jilii'n **<(<,,t, G. ;- j a fl in jil'lll i <f- ;» i K. -V. f* nm m ll lll->a a a 26