With regard to this application, we would like to make the following points of clarification as part of our professional opinion:

Transcription

1 June 24, 2014 Project No /3000 Community Development Town of Gananoque 30 King Street ast P.O. Box 100 Gananoque, Ontario K7G 2T6 R: HRITAG IMPACT STUDY Dear Sir/Madam, This letter is written in support of the application for the Riviyra Condominium development with the intention of providing clarification to the Heritage Impact Study (HIS) prepared for the property located at 101 South Street, Gananoque, Ontario. The current details of this project are hereto attached as Appendix A. Golder Associates Ltd. was retained by the proponent to prepare an HIS as part of a complete application under the Town of Gananoque s Development Permit System. The HIS was developed by a team of heritage professionals whose expertise includes heritage planning, cultural heritage landscape analysis, architectural history, and heritage landscape architecture. The HIS and this letter are focused on heritage conservation matters and do not address broader issues of planning, architecture, and urban design. A site visit was completed on October 7, 2013, with supplementary site visits on September 3 and 11, October 23 and 29, 2013, and June 23, With regard to this application, we would like to make the following points of clarification as part of our professional opinion: The property was evaluated using Ontario Heritage Act Regulation 9/06, Criteria for Determining Cultural Heritage Value or Interest by a team of heritage professionals who visited the property several times and who examined both its interior and exterior. It does not demonstrate sufficient cultural heritage value or interest to warrant designation under the Ontario Heritage Act. Thus, the structure located thereon may be demolished without cultural heritage conservation concern; Salvage of building materials prior to demolition was recommended in the HIS. This process is currently underway. It was the intention of this recommendation to provide the opportunity for the adaptive reuse of these materials within the proposed development rather than to recreate false history ; There are no properties protected under the Ontario Heritage Act on, or adjacent to, the project property. The project is not located within a Heritage Conservation District designated under the Ontario Heritage Act; Golder Associates Ltd. 683 Innovation Drive, Unit 1, Kingston, Ontario, Canada K7K 76 Tel: +1 (613) Fax: +1 (613) Golder Associates: Operations in Africa, Asia, Australasia, urope, North America and South America Golder, Golder Associates and the GA globe design are trademarks of Golder Associates Corporation

2 Community Development /3000 Town of Gananoque June 24, 2014 While Benjamin Dillon may be a significant architect to eastern Ontario, this limited example in Gananoque does not articulate his architectural legacy. Other resources designed by Benjamin Dillon, particularly in Renfrew and Brockville, better articulate his contributions to architecture and design. For example, the Brockville Library (23 Buell Street, Brockville). For a list of his other projects, please see Appendix B; The Lowertown Study was initiated in March 2005 as an economic development initiative and strategy for future development of the area bound by Bay Street and King Street West to the waterfront on the west side of the Gananoque River and on the east side of Stone Street South and the area south of John Street and east of Charles Street South on the west side of the Gananoque River to the waterfront. This is an area in transition with numerous developments underway. Lowertown is not a coherent and sufficiently delineated cultural heritage landscape, as defined by the Provincial Policy Statement (2014); A viewpoint is identified in the Lowertown Study along the Stone Street South corridor to the waterfront. Apart from potential temporary obstruction during construction, the proposed development will maintain the viewpoint to the waterfront; A public waterfront trail will be created from Stone Street South to the Thousand Islands Playhouse (185 South Street, Gananoque); and, Gananoque s waterfront has been historically dominated by industrial, large scale warehouses and factories. While many of these structures have been demolished, there are several large existing and proposed waterfront developments. Large waterfront developments include the Gananoque Inn & Spa (550 Stone Street South) as well as residential developments including Pier One Condominiums (610 William Street) and Park Lane (235 South Street), which have a dominant waterfront presence. Image 1: Gananoque Inn & Spa (550 Stone Street South, Gananoque). View from Water Street. 2/4

3 Community Development /3000 Town of Gananoque June 24, 2014 Image 1: Pier One Condominiums (610 William Street, Gananoque). Image 3: Park Lane (235 South Street). 3/4

4 Community Development /3000 Town of Gananoque June 24, 2014 We trust that these points of clarification are of assistance, and if there are any further questions, please do not hesitate to contact the undersigned. Yours truly, GOLDR ASSOCIATS LTD. Marcus Létourneau, PhD, MCIP, RPP, CAHP Hugh Daechsel, MA David Waverman, OALA, CSLA, CAHP Senior Cultural Heritage Specialist Principal, Senior Archaeologist Senior Landscape Architect ML/HJD/lrb CC: Ken Dantzer, Proponent, CaraCo Development Corporation Attachments: Appendix A: Riviyra Development Inc. Architectural Plans. June 12, Appendix B: Work of Benjamin Dillon, architect. n:\active\2013\ contaminated lands\ cha 101 south st_caraco\letter\ gananoque letter_riviyra_24jun2014.docx 4/4

5 SIT DVLOPMNT AND ZONING INFORMATION SOUTH OUTLIN OF UNGROUNDD PARKING GARAG BLOW RAMP TO P1 LIN OF BUILDING ABOV THIS SIT PLAN DVLOPMNT AND ZONING INFORMATION IS BASD ON DVLOPMNT PRMIT BY-LAW BY TOWN OF GANANOQU, ONTARIO LIN OF GROUND FLOOR FOOTPRINT LIN OF RQUIRD 6M FRONT YARD STBACK LIN OF BALCONY ABOV RTAINING WALL WITH RAILING ABOV PROPRTY LGAL DSCRIPTION LOTS 671 TO 677 INCLUSIV PLAN 86(), TOWN OF GANANOQU, ONTARIO % 47.7% GROSS FLOOR ARA SM SF GROUND FLOOR 2,760 29,700 SCOND FLOOR 2,864 30,830 THIRD FLOOR FOURTH FLOOR FIFTH FLOOR 2,864 2,864 2,864 30,830 30,830 30,830 SIXTH FLOOR 2,864 30,830 TOTAL 17, ,850 BALCONY SM SF ,250 LIN OF PROPOSD 6M SID WA T RL YARD STBACK V L Steel & Concrete Retaining Wall (P2 & M) Steel & Concrete Retain ing Wall LIN OF RQUIRD 6M FLOOD HAZARD STBACK LIN OF 6.5M RAR YARD STBACK 3005 BALCONY ABOV 2 BDROOM+DN 88 TOTAL 100 CHAMBRLAIN ARCHITCT SRVICS LIMITD AND CHAMBRLAIN CONSTRUCTION SRVICS LIMITD HAV SIMILAR OWNRSHIP. 2.22% MAX. 20M AVRAG 18.9 M(FROM AVRAG GRAD TO ROOF DCK) WATRFRONT STBACK: CRCA XTRIOR SID YARD: NORTH (SOUTH STRT) RQUIRD 6.0M 6.0M 15.0M PROPOSD 4.0M 6.0M 0.5M RQUIRD PROPOSD 3459 LIN OF 6.5M RAR YARD STBACK OFF LASH MTAL FNC RFR TO LANDSCAP DWG PROPOSD 162 SPACS RQUIRD HANDICAP PARKING 8 SPACS (1 PR 20 PARKING SPACS) PROPOSD HANDICAP PARKING 8 SPACS PARKING DIMNSION 3.0M x 6.0M HANDICAP PARKING DIMNSION 3.0M x 6.0M PLUS 1.5M AISL DRIV WAY WIDTH 6.0M RQUIRD PROPOSD SPACS W AT R L V L Wate r's 14M x 3.5M 8.0M x 5.0M CRDIT NOTS dge THIS SIT PLAN IS BASD ON AND MUST B RAD IN CONJUNCTION WITH TH TOPOGRAPHICAL PLAN OF SURVY PRPARD BY HOPKINS, CORMIR AND CHITTY SURVYING CONSULTANTS INC, NORRIS COURT, KINGSTON, ON. FIL NO , DATD MAY 7, CHAMBRLAIN ARCHITCT SRVICS ACCPTS NO RSPONSIBILITY FOR TH ACCURACY OR COMPLTNSS OF TH DATA SPLID AND SUCH DATA IS NOT INCLUDD UNDR SALS OF CRTIFICATION, IF ANY PROPRTY LIN ( 28R ) PAR T 4 1 SPAC DIMNSIONS PA 20R.84T 6.5M SAL 1.0M 128 SPACS (1.25 SPAC PR SUIT) LOADING & M)) 2 DVLOPMNT INC. RAR YARD:AST (PLAYHOUS) 6.0M MIN 6.5M(SOUTH) PARKING RQUIRD 2 PART CLINT 160 SM, 1,722 SF MTAL FNC RFR TO LANDSCAP DWG A100 SIT DVLOPMNT AND ZONING INFO 1 : T R ST TOWN OF GANANOQU W NG KI AM LI IL T R ST S L AR CH S ON ST T R ST PART 5 T R ST S T R ST N R T WA T R T S HN JO T R ST H UT O S SIT LOCATION MAP CONSTRUCTION NORTH TRU NORTH PROJCT SOUTH STRT & STON STRT, GANANOQU, ON SHT NAM SIT PLAN START DAT JUN, 2013 CKD BY SCAL As indicated PROJCT NO. SUBJCT SIT ST. LAWRNC RIVR 1 : 250 SPT 20, 2013 OCT. 16, 2013 NOV 4, 2013 MARCH 26, 2014 APRIL 4, 2014 APRIL 25, 2014 MAY 23, % FRONT YARD: WST (STON STRT) YARDS CONCRT PATH PAR T PL1A N 28R A100 FOR DPA FOR COORDINATION FOR COORDINATION FOR PLANNING RVIW FOR DPA RVISD FOR DPA RVISD FOR DPA DO NOT SCAL S. US ONLY S MARKD "ISSUD FOR CONSTRUCTION". VRIFY CONFIGURATIONS AND DIMNSIONS ON SIT BFOR BGINNING WORK. NOTIFY ARCHITCT IMMDIATLY OF ANY RRORS, OMISSIONS OR DISCRPANCIS. 4,330 SM, 46,608 SF (INCLUDING SODDD PLANTING ARA, ROOF, UNIT PAVMNT) RQUIRD PROPOSD LIN OF RQUIRD 1.2M SID YARD STBACK Site Plan FLOOD HAZARD STBACKS OPTIONAL GROUND SOURC HAT PUMP BD 1 DAT BUILDING HIGHT LIN OF FLOOD HAZARD 93 7 LIN OF PARKING GARAG WALL BLOW AND MTAL RAILING ABOV (28R BDROOM ASPHALT PAVMNT ARA COVRAG LIN OF RQUIRD 6M FLOOD HAZARD STBACK LAWRNC ST. RIVR 5 COVRAG MTAL FNC RFR PART TO LANDSCAP DWG PLAN 1 28R BDROOM+DN LANDSCAP ARA ROOF LIN OF RQUIRD 6.5M RAR YARD STBACK ISSUD RSIDNTIAL UNIT BRAKDOWN (P2 & M) AMNITY ARA LOT PROPOSD 670 BALCONY N51 04'00" BALCONY ABOV GROUND FLOOR(SHOWN WITH ORANG TON): 2,757 SM (38.0% COVRAG) GROUND FLOOR PLUS OPN BRZWAY(128SM): 2,885SM (39.8% COVRAG) FULL FOOTPRINT INCL PARTIALLY BURID PARKING GARAG: 3,459SM (47.7% COVRAG) BALCONY NO. TR 0.3 C:\Users\hcui.CHAMBRLAIN-ONL\Documents\-Cananoque Condo\Gananoque Condo - Central-Option 3-Honglin.rvt 6508 RAMP TO P2 100 SUITS RSIDNTIAL BUILDING - 6 STORYS WITH 2 LVLS UNDRGROUND PARKING GARAG 5/26/ :46:25 AM COVRD OPN BRZWAY ON GROUND FLOOR TOWNHOUS SUITS ON GROUND AND SCOND FLOORS 6603 STON 4482 BUILDING COVRAG RQUIRD PROPOSD TR 0.3 3,459 SM, 37,232 SF (INCLUDING TH ARA OF BASMNT PARKING GARAGS THAT ABOV GRAD) BUILDING ARA P 6094 Cut Cross (613) 7,254.4 SM, 1.79 ACR SIT ARA N49 03'10" 5724 LOADING ARA LAY-BY ARA (P1 & M) LANDSCAPD ROOF LIN OF SCOND FLOOR ABOV MAIN NTRANC Architects ZONING CLASSIFICATION STRT PROPRTY LIN NW SIDWALK STRT A100

6 SOUTH STRT Architects RAMP TO P1 MAIN NTRANC LOADING ARA NO. ISSUD DAT 1 RVISION PR CLINT SPT 12, FOR DPA SPT 20, FOR DPA APRIL 4, 2014 SUIT 101 2BR+DN-T SF S1 SUIT BR-T2 939 SF SUIT BR+DN-T3 806 SF SUIT 104 2BR+DN-T4 903 SF SUIT 105 2BR+DN-T5 986 SF SUIT 106 2BR+DN-T6 985 SF SUIT 107 2BR+DN-T7 COVRD OPN ARA S2 SUIT 114 2BR+DN 1417 SF MAIL 214 SF OFFIC 231 SF VST. LOBBY 780 SF MOV. 438 SF GARB. 581 SF LC. 629 SF MCH. 582 SF SUIT 113 2BR+DN-J 1397 SF SUIT SF DO NOT SCAL S. US ONLY S MARKD "ISSUD FOR CONSTRUCTION". VRIFY CONFIGURATIONS AND DIMNSIONS ON SIT BFOR BGINNING WORK. NOTIFY ARCHITCT IMMDIATLY OF ANY RRORS, OMISSIONS OR DISCRPANCIS. CHAMBRLAIN ARCHITCT SRVICS LIMITD AND CHAMBRLAIN CONSTRUCTION SRVICS LIMITD HAV SIMILAR OWNRSHIP. FIRPLAC JAN CLINT CORRIDOR VST MN'S CHAN. RM SAUN. SAUN. WOMN'S CHAN. RM SHOWR SHOWR POOL POOL ROOM 1927 SF P. Q. BAR DINNING PARTY ROOM 1395 SF TRATR 558 SF LOCKRS SUIT SF DVLOPMNT INC. FITNSS 1112 SF BILLIARD SITTING SAL SUIT 108 2BR+DN-G 1556 SF SUIT BR-I SF S3 SUIT 109 2BR+DN-H 1709 SF CONSTRUCTION NORTH PROJCT TRU NORTH 4/4/2014 9:56:33 AM \\fnp2\projects\2013\\2.2 Design Development\Gananoque Condo - Central-Option 3.rvt SOUTH STRT & STON STRT, GANANOQU, ON SHT NAM GROUND FLOOR PLAN START DAT CKD BY SCAL PROJCT NO. JUN, 2013 A101

7 Architects VST. NO. ISSUD DAT 1 RVISION PR CLINT SPT 12, 2013 SUIT 114 2BR+DN 1417 SF MAIL 214 SF LOBBY 780 SF MOV. 438 SF GARB. 581 SF SUIT 113 2BR+DN-J 1397 SF LC. 629 SF MCH. 582 SF OFFIC 231 SF S2 FIRPLAC JAN CORRIDOR VST MN'S CHAN. RM SAUN. SHOWR P. Q. BAR TRATR 558 SF LOCKRS DO NOT SCAL S. US ONLY S MARKD "ISSUD FOR CONSTRUCTION". VRIFY CONFIGURATIONS AND DIMNSIONS ON SIT BFOR BGINNING WORK. NOTIFY ARCHITCT IMMDIATLY OF ANY RRORS, OMISSIONS OR DISCRPANCIS. CHAMBRLAIN ARCHITCT SRVICS LIMITD AND CHAMBRLAIN CONSTRUCTION SRVICS LIMITD HAV SIMILAR OWNRSHIP. SAUN. DINNING SAL WOMN'S CHAN. RM SHOWR POOL ROOM 1927 SF PARTY ROOM 1395 SF FITNSS 1112 SF BILLIARD SITTING CONSTRUCTION NORTH TRU NORTH SUIT 108 2BR+DN-G 1556 SF 4/4/2014 9:56:37 AM \\fnp2\projects\2013\\2.2 Design Development\Gananoque Condo - Central-Option 3.rvt SOUTH STRT & STON STRT, GANANOQU, ON SHT NAM NLARGD GROUND FLOOR PLAN START DAT CKD BY SCAL PROJCT NO. JUN, 2013 AM 1 : 100 A101.1

8 Architects NO. ISSUD DAT 2 FOR DPA SPT 20, FOR DPA APRIL 4, 2014 SUIT 201 2BR+DN-T1 982 SF SUIT 202 2BR-T2 918 SF SUIT 203 2BR+DN-T3 715 SF SUIT 204 2BR+DN-T4 802 SF SUIT 205 2BR+DN-T5 829 SF SUIT 206 2BR+DN-T6 829 SF SUIT B+D-T7 584 SF SUIT 208 2BR+DN-C SF 3% RAMP DOWN SUIT 221 2BR+DN-L 1390 SF SUIT SF SUIT BR+DN-K 1035 SF SUIT SF SUIT 217 2BR+DN-J 1427 SF SUIT SF DO NOT SCAL S. US ONLY S MARKD "ISSUD FOR CONSTRUCTION". VRIFY CONFIGURATIONS AND DIMNSIONS ON SIT BFOR BGINNING WORK. NOTIFY ARCHITCT IMMDIATLY OF ANY RRORS, OMISSIONS OR DISCRPANCIS. CHAMBRLAIN ARCHITCT SRVICS LIMITD AND CHAMBRLAIN CONSTRUCTION SRVICS LIMITD HAV SIMILAR OWNRSHIP. CORRIOR JAN. CLINT LOCKRS SUIT SF SUIT 209 2BR+DN-D 2226 SF SUIT 210 2BR+DN SF SUIT 211 2BR+DN-F 1792 SF DVLOPMNT INC. SAL SUIT 212 2BR+DN-G 1560 SF SUIT 214 2BR-I 1225 SF SUIT 213 2BR+DN-H 1710 SF CONSTRUCTION NORTH PROJCT TRU NORTH 4/4/2014 9:56:41 AM \\fnp2\projects\2013\\2.2 Design Development\Gananoque Condo - Central-Option 3.rvt SOUTH STRT & STON STRT, GANANOQU, ON SHT NAM SCOND FLOOR PLAN START DAT CKD BY SCAL PROJCT NO. JUN, 2013 A102

9 Architects NO. ISSUD DAT 7 FOR DPA APRIL 4, 2014 SUIT 301 2BR+DN-A 1795 SF SUIT SF SUIT SF SUIT SF SUIT BR+DN-C 1669 SF SUIT 318 2BR+DN-L 4467 SF SUIT SF SUIT 316 1BR+DN-K 1035 SF SUIT SF SUIT 314 2BR+DN-J 1427 SF SUIT SF DO NOT SCAL S. US ONLY S MARKD "ISSUD FOR CONSTRUCTION". VRIFY CONFIGURATIONS AND DIMNSIONS ON SIT BFOR BGINNING WORK. NOTIFY ARCHITCT IMMDIATLY OF ANY RRORS, OMISSIONS OR DISCRPANCIS. CHAMBRLAIN ARCHITCT SRVICS LIMITD AND CHAMBRLAIN CONSTRUCTION SRVICS LIMITD HAV SIMILAR OWNRSHIP. CLINT SUIT 306 2BR+DN-D 2226 SF SUIT 307 2BR+DN SF SUIT 308 2BR+DN-F 1792 SF LOCKRS SUIT SF DVLOPMNT INC. SUIT 309 2BR+DN-G 1560 SF SUIT 311 2BR+DN-I 1225 SF SAL SUIT 310 2BR+DN-H 1710 SF CONSTRUCTION NORTH TRU NORTH PROJCT 4/4/2014 9:56:47 AM \\fnp2\projects\2013\\2.2 Design Development\Gananoque Condo - Central-Option 3.rvt SOUTH STRT & STON STRT, GANANOQU, ON SHT NAM 3RD-6TH FLOOR PLAN START DAT CKD BY SCAL PROJCT NO. JUN, 2013 Author Checker A103

10 Architects XIT AT P1 PARKING CONTROL GAT NO. ISSUD DAT RAMP AIR IN. V1 V2 V3 V4 V5 V6 V7 V8 V10 17 AIR X. 1 RVISION PR CLINT SPT 12, FOR DPA SPT 20, FOR DPA APRIL 4, 2014 STOR. LV LOBBY VST 9 V11 V12 V13 V14 V15 V16 V17 V18 2 VST BIK STORAG STAIR #2 6 VST DO NOT SCAL S. US ONLY S MARKD "ISSUD FOR CONSTRUCTION". VRIFY CONFIGURATIONS AND DIMNSIONS ON SIT BFOR BGINNING WORK. NOTIFY ARCHITCT IMMDIATLY OF ANY RRORS, OMISSIONS OR DISCRPANCIS. CHAMBRLAIN ARCHITCT SRVICS LIMITD AND CHAMBRLAIN CONSTRUCTION SRVICS LIMITD HAV SIMILAR OWNRSHIP. CLINT LV LOBBY TANDM 1 VST POOL ABOV 6 4 DVLOPMNT INC. SAL 4 XIT FROM LOWR LVL 6 Room XIT XIT XIT FROM PR LVLS AT P1 CONSTRUCTION NORTH TRU NORTH PROJCT 5 3 AIR X. 4/4/2014 9:56:49 AM \\fnp2\projects\2013\\2.2 Design Development\Gananoque Condo - Central-Option 3.rvt SOUTH STRT & STON STRT, GANANOQU, ON SHT NAM UNDRGROUND PARKING LVL 1 START DAT CKD BY SCAL PROJCT NO. JUN, 2013 A104

11 Architects NO. ISSUD DAT AIR IN. 26 AIR X. 1 RVISION PR CLINT SPT 12, FOR DPA SPT 20, FOR DPA APRIL 4, 2014 STORAG LV. LOBBY 1 9 VST DO NOT SCAL S. US ONLY S MARKD "ISSUD FOR CONSTRUCTION". VRIFY CONFIGURATIONS AND DIMNSIONS ON SIT BFOR BGINNING WORK. NOTIFY ARCHITCT IMMDIATLY OF ANY RRORS, OMISSIONS OR DISCRPANCIS. RAMP 10 6 CHAMBRLAIN ARCHITCT SRVICS LIMITD AND CHAMBRLAIN CONSTRUCTION SRVICS LIMITD HAV SIMILAR OWNRSHIP. CLINT XIT 2 LV. LOBBY 6 4 DVLOPMNT INC. SAL 4 6 VST. VST 3 CONSTRUCTION NORTH TRU NORTH PROJCT 5 AIR X. 4/4/2014 9:56:52 AM \\fnp2\projects\2013\\2.2 Design Development\Gananoque Condo - Central-Option 3.rvt SOUTH STRT & STON STRT, GANANOQU, ON SHT NAM UNDRGROUND PARKING LVL 2 START DAT CKD BY SCAL PROJCT NO. JUN, 2013 A105

12 Architects TOP OF TH HIGHST LOAD BARING WALL TOP OF MAIN FLAT ROOF DCK +84 LVATION OF SOUTH STRT AVRAG BUILDING GRAD AVR. GRAD TO T/O MAIN FLAT ROOF AVR. GRAD TO T/O HIGHST LOAD BAR. WALL T/O PNTHOUS ROOF T/O ROOF DCK T/O SIXTH FLOOR T/O FIFTH FLOOR T/O FOURTH FLOOR T/O THIRD FLOOR T/O SCOND FLOOR T/O GROUND FLOOR T/O PARKING LVL NO. ISSUD DAT 7 FOR DPA APRIL 4, RVISD FOR DPA MAY 23 DO NOT SCAL S. US ONLY S MARKD "ISSUD FOR CONSTRUCTION". VRIFY CONFIGURATIONS AND DIMNSIONS ON SIT BFOR BGINNING WORK. NOTIFY ARCHITCT IMMDIATLY OF ANY RRORS, OMISSIONS OR DISCRPANCIS. CHAMBRLAIN ARCHITCT SRVICS LIMITD AND CHAMBRLAIN CONSTRUCTION SRVICS LIMITD HAV SIMILAR OWNRSHIP. CLINT T/O PARKING LVL HIGHT CALCULATION- WST LVATION A200 DVLOPMNT INC. SAL WILLIAM STRT SOUTH 3 3D Aerial View-North West A WILLIAM CHARLS STRT PROPOSD DVLOPMNT STON STRT 2 STRTSCAP- NORTH LVATION A200 1 : TOP OF HIGHST LOAD BARING WALL +84 LVATION OF SOUTH STRT 5/23/ :40:41 PM C:\Users\hcui.CHAMBRLAIN-ONL\Documents\-Cananoque Condo\Gananoque Condo - Central-Option 3-Honglin.rvt CONSTRUCTION NORTH PROJCT SHT NAM START DAT CKD BY SCAL PROJCT NO. TRU NORTH SOUTH STRT & STON STRT, GANANOQU, ON BUILDING HIGHT AND STRTSCAP ANALYSIS JUN, 2013 Checker As indicated A200

13 Architects MTAL SHINGL ROOF DOUBL GLAZD THRMALLY BROKN ALUM WINDOW WOOD BRACKT 9156 DCORATIV HALF TIMBRING MTAL SHINGL ROOF DCORATIV HALF TIMBRING CMNT BOARD SIDING 4678 T/O LV ROOF T/O ROOF DCK NO. ISSUD DAT 2 FOR DPA SPT 20, FOR DPA APRIL 4, 2014 PRCAST WALL BAND RD BRICK CLADDING MTAL RAILING T/O SIXTH FLOOR T/O FIFTH FLOOR T/O FOURTH FLOOR T/O THIRD FLOOR DO NOT SCAL S. US ONLY S MARKD "ISSUD FOR CONSTRUCTION". VRIFY CONFIGURATIONS AND DIMNSIONS ON SIT BFOR BGINNING WORK. NOTIFY ARCHITCT IMMDIATLY OF ANY RRORS, OMISSIONS OR DISCRPANCIS. PRCAST WALL BAND T/O SCOND FLOOR CHAMBRLAIN ARCHITCT SRVICS LIMITD AND CHAMBRLAIN CONSTRUCTION SRVICS LIMITD HAV SIMILAR OWNRSHIP. CLINT ARCHITCTURAL MASONRY CLADDING T/O GROUND FLOOR T/O PARKING LVL T/O PARKING LVL DVLOPMNT INC. 1 SOUTH LVATION A201 ALUMINIUM STORFRONT GLAZING SAL MTAL SHINGL ROOF DOUBL GLAZD THRMALLY BROKN ALUM WINDOW 7635 WOOD BRACKT TOP OF ROOF DCK T/O LV ROOF PROJCT CMNT BOARD SIDING RD BRICK CLADDING MTAL RAILING ARCHITCTURA L MASONRY CLADDING LOWST GRAD AST LVATION A HIGHST GRAD T/O ROOF DCK T/O SIXTH FLOOR T/O FIFTH FLOOR T/O FOURTH FLOOR T/O THIRD FLOOR T/O SCOND FLOOR T/O GROUND FLOOR T/O PARKING LVL T/O PARKING LVL /4/ :00:18 AM \\fnp2\projects\2013\\2.2 Design Development\Gananoque Condo - Central-Option 3.rvt SOUTH STRT & STON STRT, GANANOQU, ON SHT NAM BUILDING LVATIONS I START DAT CKD BY SCAL PROJCT NO. JUN, 2013 Checker A201

14 DOUBL GLAZD THRMALLY BROKN ALUM WINDOW MTAL SHINGL ROOF ARCHITCTURAL MASONRY CLADDING DCORATIV HALF TIMBRING WOOD BRACKT ALUMINIUM STORFRONT GLAZING ALUMINIUM CURTAIN WALL GLAZING WATR VIW OPNING ON GROUND FLOOR MTAL SHINGL ROOF Architects CMNT BOARD SIDING T/O LV ROOF T/O ROOF DCK T/O ROOF DCK PRCAST WALL BAND RD BRICK CLADDING MTAL RAILING PRCAST WALL BAND HIGHST GRAD AT SOUTH STRT T/O SIXTH FLOOR T/O FIFTH FLOOR T/O FOURTH FLOOR T/O THIRD FLOOR T/O SCOND FLOOR OVRHAD MTAL GARAG DOOR T/O GROUND FLOOR LOWST GRAD AT SOUTH STRT NO. ISSUD DAT 2 FOR DPA SPT 20, FOR DPA APRIL 4, 2014 DO NOT SCAL S. US ONLY S MARKD "ISSUD FOR CONSTRUCTION". VRIFY CONFIGURATIONS AND DIMNSIONS ON SIT BFOR BGINNING WORK. NOTIFY ARCHITCT IMMDIATLY OF ANY RRORS, OMISSIONS OR DISCRPANCIS. CHAMBRLAIN ARCHITCT SRVICS LIMITD AND CHAMBRLAIN CONSTRUCTION SRVICS LIMITD HAV SIMILAR OWNRSHIP. T/O PARKING LVL CLINT 1 NORTH LVATION A202 DVLOPMNT INC. SAL MTAL SHINGL ROOF DOUBL GLAZD THRMALLY BROKN ALUM WINDOW 6923 WOOD BRACKT CMNT BOARD SIDING RD BRICK CLADDING MTAL RAILING ARCHITXTURAL MASONRY CLADDING OVRHAD MTAL GARAG DOOR WST LVATION A202 T/O LV ROOF T/O ROOF DCK T/O SIXTH FLOOR T/O FIFTH FLOOR T/O FOURTH FLOOR T/O THIRD FLOOR T/O SCOND FLOOR T/O GROUND FLOOR T/O PARKING LVL T/O PARKING LVL /4/ :01:19 AM \\fnp2\projects\2013\\2.2 Design Development\Gananoque Condo - Central-Option 3.rvt PROJCT SOUTH STRT & STON STRT, GANANOQU, ON SHT NAM XTRIOR LVATIONS II START DAT CKD BY SCAL PROJCT NO. JUN, 2013 A202

15 APPNDIX B Work of Benjamin Dillon, Architect WORK OF BNJAMIN DILLON, ARCHITCT RNFRW MAIN STRT, residence for M. McKinnon, 1896 (Renfrew Mercury, 8 May 1896, 5, t.c.). MAIN STRT, new facade for Dr. Cleary's Block, 1896 (Renfrew Mercury, 15 May 1896, 5). unnamed street, residence for Mrs. R. Airth, 1896 (Renfrew Mercury, 3 July 1896, 5, t.c.). MAIN STRT, commercial block with Opera House, 1896 (C.R., vii, 23 July 1896, 2). unnamed street, residence for T.. Freedland 'near the CPR Station', 1896 (Renfrew Mercury, 23 Oct. 1896, 5). FIRMAN'S SKATING & CURLING RINK, 1896 (Renfrew Mercury, 27 Nov. 1896, 5, descrip.). MAIN STRT, commercial block for John Smith 'opposite the Dominion House', (Renfrew Mercury, 25 Dec. 1896, 7). unnamed street, residence for I.. Pedlow, 1897 (Renfrew Mercury, 26 Feb. 1897, 3, t.c.). ISOLATION HOSPITAL, 1897 (Renfrew Mercury, 23 April 1897, 1, descrip.; C.R., viii, 29 April 1897, 2). MTHODIST CHURCH, Main Street, 1897 (Renfrew Mercury, 30 April 1897, 5, descrip.; C.R., viii, 2 Sept. 1897, 2, t.c.). MURPHY BLOCK, Main Street, a commercial block of three stores for Dr. Murphy, 1897 (C.R., viii, 29 April 1897, 2). ST. PAUL'S ANGLICAN CHURCH, rectory for the church, 1897 (C.R., viii, 13 May 1897, 2, t.c.). NORTH WARD PUBLIC SCHOOL, 1897 (Renfrew Mercury, 21 May 1897, 1; C.R., viii, 24 June 1897, 2). unnamed street, residence for A. Barnet, (C.R., xiii, 10 Dec. 1902, 1, t.c.). BROCKVILL unnamed street, major addition and alterations to residence for George P. Graham, 1899 (C.R., x, 17 May 1899, 2, t.c.). LDS COUNTY RGISTRY OFFIC, addition and alterations, 1899 (C.R., x, 28 June 1899, 2). ONTARIO GLOV WORKS, Broad Street, major addition to factory, (Brockville Recorder, 22 June 1900, 6, illus. & descrip.). CANADIAN OAK BLTING CO., major addition to factory, 1901 (C.R., xi, 16 Jan. 1910, 2, t.c.). BOHMIAN AMATUR ATHLTIC ASSOCIATION, club house, 1901 (C.R., xii, 17 April 1901, 2). BROCKVILL WATR COMMISSION, pumping station, Water Street, 1901 (C.R., xii, 15 May 1910, 2, t.c.). GNRAL HOSPITAL, Pearl Street at Ormond Street, major addition, 1901; laundry building, 1907; addition to Nurse's Home, 1911 (C.R., xii, 19 June 1901, 2; xviii, 19 June 1907, 2, t.c.; xxv, 12 July 1911, 58, t.c.). PRTH STRT, residence for William Kyle, 1902 (C.R., xiii, 2 April 1902, 2, t.c.). unnamed street, residence for A. Barnet, 1902 (C.R., xiii, 27 Aug. 1902, 1). SKATING ARNA, Broad Street, for the Brockville Recreation Co., 1902 (C.R., xiii, 10 Sept. 1902, 2). VICTORIA HALL, King Street ast, major addition and alterations, 1903 (C.R., xiii, 11 Feb. 1903, 2, t.c.). DLTA PARK, pavilion for the Brockville & Westport Railway, 1903 (C.R., xiv, 29 April 1903, 3, t.c.). XHIBITION GROUNDS, major addition to the grandstand, 1903 (C.R., xiv, 6 May 1903, 2). SKATING ARNA, for Newton Cossitt and L.R. Cossitt, 1903 (C.R., xiv, 13 May 1903, 2, t.c.). CARNGI LIBRARY, George Street at Buell Street, 1903 (C.R., xiv, 5 Aug. 1903, 2; vening Recorder [Brockville], 29 Oct. 1903, 3, descrip.). ST. VINCNT D PAUL HOSPITAL, Pine Street, laundry building, 1903 (C.R., xiv, 23 Sept. 1903, 2, t.c.). COSSITT BROS LTD., foundry for Charles S. Cossitt and Fremont B. Cossitt, 1903 (C.R., xiv, 11 Nov. 1903, 2, t.c.). PIN STRT, residence for William. Braund, 1906 (C.R., xvii, 28 March 1906, 2, t.c.). BTHUN STRT, residence for Jospeh Deacon, 1906 (C.R., xvii, 2 May 1906, 2, t.c.). June 24, 2014 Project No /3000 1/3

16 APPNDIX B Work of Benjamin Dillon, Architect ST. PAUL'S ANGLICAN CHURCH, Pine Street at Victoria Street, chancel addition, 1906 (C.R., xvii, 6 June 1906, 2, t.c.). FIR HALL, Perth Street, 1910 (inf. Brockville Local Architectural Conservation Advisory Committee). KING STRT AST, major addition and alterations to residence for Hugh A. Stewart, 1911 (C.R., xxv, 1 Feb. 1911, 33, t.c.). KING STRT AST, carriage house and other works at residence for Mrs. Charles. Fulford, 1911 (C.R., xxv, 1 March 1911, 27). WLLINGTON STRT, at Ormond Street, pair of houses for John W. Ridgeway, 1912 (inf. Brockville Local Architectural Conservation Advisory Committee). ONTARIO MNTAL HOSPITAL, boat house facing the St. Lawrence River, 1919 (Ontario, Sessional Papers, 1920, No. 13, Report of the Chief Architect, 11). MACHINRY & FOUNDRIS LTD., Pearl Street ast at North Augusta Road, foundry, 1920 (C.R., xxxiv, 10 March 1920, 62, t.c.). (with Colin Drever).F. PHILLIPS LCTRICAL WORKS LTD., King Street West, major addition to offices and factory, 1936 (C.R., l, 26 Aug. 1936, 34, t.c.). LSWHR GANVILL, ONT., residence for Dr. Chananhouse, 1896 (C.R., vii, 20 Aug. 1896, 1). PAKNHAM, ONT., Presbyterian Church, (C.R., vii, 26 Nov. 1896, 2, t.c.). SLY'S BAY, ONT., Anglican Church, 1898 (C.R., ix, 30 March 1898, 2). CARDINAL, ONT., residence for Postmaster, 1898 (Renfrew Mercury, 3 June 1898, 5). PORTAG DU FORT, QU., large residence for G.. Reid, 1898 (C.R., ix, 15 June 1898, 3, t.c.). SLY'S BAY, ONT., store and residence for George R. Hawkins, 1898 (C.R., ix, 23 Nov. 1898, 2). ATHNS, ONT., Methodist Church, 1899 (C.R., x, 1 March 1899, 2, t.c.). PRTH, ONT., Skating Arena, 1899 (Perth Courier, 6 Oct. 1899, 4, descrip.; C.R., x, 18 Oct. 1899, 2, t.c.). CHAPLAU, ONT., parsonage for the Methodist Church, 1900 (C.R., xi, 2 May 1900, 2). FAIRFILD, ONT., Methodist Church, 1901 (C.R., xii, 4 Sept. 1901, 1, t.c.). LANSDOWN, ONT., residence near the town for W.A. McNeill, (C.R., xii, 18 Dec. 1901, 5). JONS FALLS, ONT., summer residence for A.L. Fennesy 'of New York City', 1901 (C.R., xii, 2 Oct. 1901, 2, t.c.). SMITHS FALLS, ONT., residence for W.W. Wiliams, 1902 (C.R., xiii, 23 April 1902, 3). LANSDOWN, ONT., manse for the Presbyterian Church, 1902 (C.R., xiii, 9 July 1902, 1). MALLORYTOWN, ONT. residence near the town for Mr. Foley, (C.R., xiii, 31 Dec. 1902, 1). NORTH AUGUSTA, ONT., Methodist Church, 1903 (C.R., xiv, 9 Dec. 1903, 1). ATHNS, ONT., Town Hall, Main Street, (Brockville Recorder, 20 Oct. 1905, 3, illus. & descrip.; M. MacRae & A. Adamson, Cornerstones of Order, 1983, 251-2, illus.). ATHNS, ONT., public school, 1905 (C.R., xvi, 31 May 1905, 2, t.c.). NWBORO, ONT., Union Bank, Drummond Street, 1905 (inf. Parks Canada, Canadian Inventory of Historic Buildings, Ottawa). NAPAN, ONT., astern Methodist Church, (C.R., xvi, 16 Aug. 1905, 1, t.c.). LYNDHURST, ONT., rectory for a church, 1906 (C.R., xvii, 7 March 1906, 2, t.c.). LYN, ONT., addition to rectory for the Anglican Church, 1906 (C.R., xvii, 18 July 1906, 2, t.c.). CHSTRVILL, ONT., Methodist Church, 1907 (C.R., xviii, 29 May 1907, 6, t.c.). HULBRT, ONT., Methodist Church, 1907; burned 1938 (Hulbert United Church ). NAPAN, ONT., Trinity Methodist Church, Bridge Street at John Street, (Canadian Cement & Concrete Review [Toronto], ii, March 1908, 54, illus. & descrip.). June 24, 2014 Project No /3000 2/3

17 APPNDIX B Work of Benjamin Dillon, Architect LANSDOWN, ONT., public school, 1912 (C.R., xxiv, 17 April 1912, 65, t.c.). HALLVILL, ONT., public school, 1922 (C.R., xxxvi, 26 April 1922, 50). Source: Biographical Dictionary of Architects in Canada \\golder.gds\gal\ottawa\active\2013\ contaminated lands\ cha 101 south st_caraco\letter\ gananoque letter_24jun2014-appendixb.docx June 24, 2014 Project No /3000 3/3