HISTORIC DISTRICT COUNCIL STAFF REPORT HDC June 16, Subject Property: c. Accessory structure is on the 1926 Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps

Transcription

1 HSTORC DSTRCT COUNCL STAFF REPORT HDC June 16, 2016 Subject Property: 14 S. 2 nd Street c. Accessory structure is on the 1926 Sanborn Fire nsurance Maps Owner/Applicant: Mac & Gi LLC / Donna Lynne VanPuymbrouck Requested Action: Certificate of Approval (COA) for the demolition of a noncontributing accessory structure Historic Resource Survey: This parcel is listed as noncontributing in the 1985 and 2007 surveys. Zoning/FLUM: C-3 / Central Business District Existing Use: Storage for Joe s Bistro Adjacent Properties: North c Commercial Office C-3/CBD South c. Parking Lot C-3/CBD East c Restaurant C-3/CBD West c Commercial Office C-3/CBD

2 HDC Page 2 of 2 14 S. 2 nd Street June 16, 2016 All required application materials have been received. All fees have been paid. All required notices have been made. SUMMARY OF REQUEST AND BACKGROUND NFORMATON: The applicant requests the demolition of a 192 square foot commercial storage structure. This particular parcel is listed as noncontributing on both the 1985 and 2007 Historical Surveys. The storage structure the applicant is requesting to demolish is on the 1926 Sanborn Fire nsurance Maps. Professional Engineer Asa Gillette inspected the structure and provided a letter with his findings. The structure has a wood wall system with a brick veneer that appears to supporting some of the roof load. The brick veneer has suffered settlement damage and the mortar is crumbling. According to Mr. Gillette the wall does not appear to have any lateral ties and it is starting to bow outwards. Please see Mr. Gillette s evaluation that is attached. At this point the owner has installed temporary shoring to stabilize the wall as you can see in the attached pictures. Past COA: None for the storage building. APPLCABLE GUDELNES: Land Development Code (LDC) Section (A) and Section (A) (1) of the Code states that the review of the proposed development shall be based on the Secretary of the nterior s Standards for Rehabilitation. Secretary of the nterior Standards 2 and 3 apply to this project. LDC Section (A) states that the review of demolition shall be based on the following criteria, which are described in this section: 1. Secretary of the nterior s Standards for Rehabilitation 2. Applicable Design Guidelines, which in this case are the Historic Preservation Guidelines for the Downtown Historic District 3. City Comprehensive Plan 4. City Land Development Code Section (B) and Section (A)(2) of the LDC states that the review of proposed development within the Historic District Overlay shall also be based upon compliance with the Downtown Historic District Guidelines. The applicable 2013 Guidelines: Demolition (p.109). Section (D) States that the HDC may request written evidence is submitted as part of an application for a Certificate of Approval for Demolitions. Asa Gillette, P.E. submitted an letter with his evaluation of the structure. ANALYSS AND STAFF RECOMMENDATON: This applicant decided to demolish the structure only after have a Professional Engineer determine that the structure was not practical to save. This demolish will also ensure the safety for Joe s Bistro Patrons. Staff concludes the requested action is substantially consistent with the Comprehensive Plan, Land Development Code, the Downtown Historic District Guidelines and the Secretary of the nterior s Standards to warrant approval at this time.

3 HDC Page 3 of 2 14 S. 2 nd Street June 16, 2016 Recommendation: Approval MOTON TO CONSDER: move to approve or deny HDC case number ; AND move that the HDC make the following findings of fact and conclusions of law part of the record: That HDC case , as presented, is or is not substantially compliant with the Land Development Code, the Downtown Historic District Guidelines, and the Secretary of the nterior s Standards to warrant approval at this time. Jacob M. Platt Planner

4 OFFCE USE ONLY REC D: C b BY: PAYMENT: TYPE: jt17... APPLCATON #: - 3oo, CASE#: WJ 20fl, BOARD MEETNG DATE: ( APPLCATON FOR HSTORC DSTRCT COUNCL COA APPLCANT NFORMATON Owner Name: l 14c - &, L L C OtJa/ M Mailing Address: / La/4i // / Telephone: 1 fs (.ct 1 9 Fax: Ø1 /q 1 CC. MCc Je-4 Agent Name: Mailing Address: Telephone: Fax: PROPERTY NFORMATON Street Address: /9 5Ccc,/ he 6c4 Parcel dentification Number(s): Lot Number: PROJECT NFORMATON Block Number: L STAFF APPROVAL L BOARD APPROVAL: CONCEPTUAL OR FNAL L New Construction L Additions/Alterations Demolition L Other: Brief descripti of work proposed: fo d H /1 d He k d A- j,,t j City of Ferncindina Beach Community Development Department. 204 Ash Street Fernandina Beach, FL P: F: i,.,. 9r 7 A

5 List proposed materials and colors, as applicable: Prolect Scope Type and Material Color Exterior Fabric Doors Windows Roofing Fascia/Trim Foundation Shuffers Porch/Deck Fencing Driveways/Sidewalks Signoge Other Other Other SGNATURE/NOTARY The undersigned states the above Date c/lt/ /( Signature of Applicant STATE OF RORDA COUNTY OFN&S Subscrib d and sworn to before me this t/day of N tcn4 Public: Sigfre Personally Known A k2( C. Printed Name OR Produced dentification 2OL My Commission Expires D Produced: fl \J u L. /o255 City of Fernandina Beach Community Deveiopment Department. 204 Ash Street Fernandina Beach, FL P: F: rnA

6 0 OWNER S AUTHORZATON FOR AGENT REPRESENTATON /WE Mc &, LL, - (rint name of property owner(s)) hereby authorize:.. / (print name of agent) to represent me/us in processing an application for: 0 4-?144i (type of application) on our behalf. n authorizing the agent to represent me/us, /we, as owner/owners, attest that the application is made in good faith and that any information contained in the application is accurate and complete. (Signature of owner) -iowa d (Print name of owner) (Signature of owner) (Print name of owner) STATE OF iz -4, SS COUNTY OFNSSAU cj 3 before me this day of 2O. Notary Public: Signature Sycxi C. MftYik Printed Name My Commission Expires Personally Known OR Produced dentification D Produced:Thl)t_1O3q 2p-- 5) City of Fernandina Beach Community Development Department. 204 Ash Street Fernandina Beach, FL P: F: fl 7 A

7 . NON-AD ALT KEY REAL ESTATE ESCROW MAC&GLLC 14S2ND 4361 CHCKERNG LN NASHVLLE, TN BLOCK 269 LOTS 2 & 3 N OR 1800/65 CTY OF FDNA BEACH -- TAXNG AUTHORTY MLLAGE RATE ASSESSED VALUE EXEMPTON AMOUNT TAXABLE VALUE TAXES LEVED BOARD OF COUNTY COMMSSONERS GENERAL FUND ,815 (1 346,815 2, TRANSPORTATON , , SCHOOL BOARD BASC DSCRETONARY , , CAPTAL OUTLAY , , SCHOOL BOARD LOCAL EFFORT , ,815 1, ST JOHNS RVER MGMT DST , , FL NLAND NAVGATON DST , , MOSQUTO CONTROL DSTRCT , , CTY OF FERNANDNA BEACH FERNANDNABEACH , ,815 2,11630 VOTER APPROVED DEBT , , TOTALMLLAGE ADVALOREMTAXES $7, NON-AD VA ORFM ASSFSSMFNTS LEVYNG AUTHORTY RATE AMOUNT VALOREM ASSESSMENTS $0.00 (COMBNEDTAXESANDASSESSMENTS $7, ) [iaidby Feb 29, 2016 Please Pay $0.00 JOHN M. DREW, CFC NOTCE OF AD VALOREM TAXES AND NON-AD VALOREM ASSESSMENTS NASSAU COUNTY TAX COLLECTOR p O REAL ESTATE MAC&GLLC 14S2ND 4361 CHCKERNG LN z NASHVLLE, TN BLOCK 269 LOTS 2 & 3 N OR 1800/65 CTY OF FDNA BEACH PLEASE PAY TN U.S. FUNDS TO JOHN M. DREW, CFC TAX COLLECTOR LCENSE ROAD, FERNANDNA BEACH FL 32034, OR ONLTNE AT [ f Paid By Feb 29, 2016 Please Pay $0.00 L

8

9

10 . MAP SHOWNG BOUNDARY SURVEY OF LEGAL DESCRPTON: ALL OF THAT CERTAN PECE OR PARCEL OF LAND STUATE. LYNG AND BENG N THE CTY OF FERNANDNA BEACH (FORMERLY NAMED FERNANDNA) N TFE:COUNTY OF NASSAU AM) STATE OF FLORDA AND KNOWN AND DESCR3ED UPON AND ACCORDNG TO THE OFFCAL PLAT OF SAD CTY (AS LTHOGRAPHED AM) SSUED BY THE FLORDA RALROAD COMPANY N 1857 ANDENLARGED, REVSED AND RESSUED BY THE FLORDA TOWN 1MPROVEMEN COMPANY N 1887 AND 1901) KNOWN AS: LOTS.2 & 3 N BLOCK 269 W7A 7? 7 ( 3To / r ,.,. 1 ii :1 :: :1 l / SAY çfr 7. 2: A. /. 7, 2: f. /. T AA. T,/.j P3.2..,S,\... \ c r 2 : _.% _,s._.. _ 4c : &,e-A e.( CzAXY4 /25_. ao ç r7p 4c7 Y %.e 15 2> SURVEY NOTES: 1) The Legal Description hereon is in accord with the the description provided by the client. 2> Underground improvements were not located or shown. 3) Lands shown hereon were not abstracted by this office for easements, rights of--way, ownership or other instruments of record. 4) Bearings and/or angles shown hereon ore rslotv to those hpwn on tha plot r.f.r.ns*d in the legol desoriptien. The bearing reference tine is indicated as thus (BR>. S CERTFED TO: G. DAWN ROBERTS-ROBUCC FRST UNON NATONAL BANK OF FLORDA OLDE TOWNE TTLE NSURANCE CO. FDELTY NATONAL TTLE NSURANCE CO. 5) Fence ownershp, if oplicoble, hos not been determined by this office. Fences ore drown out of scale in order to occentuote their relationship to property lines. Fences ore not deemed to be encroachments unless ownership s opporeni. 6) Unless it bears the signature and the original raised seal of o Florido licensed surveyor and mopper, this mop/report is for inforrrsatiorial purposes only and is not Valid, 7) The property shown hereon li within flood zone as per F.E.M.A. Flood nsurance Rote Mop, Panel / O/7OY6 Doted 8) This firms Certificate of Authorization Number is LB S _ S A./: f,),- PA T 7 C*LC. CALCU.AED CBS. - CCNCRB1E ELOO( STRUCTuRE CENTERLNE G.M. CONCRETE honuuej4t CONG. CC.4CRETE SE. * DRANAGE EASEMENT 0/F DRAN clew E EASE. EASEMENT AERAl. UTLTY WRES Et.EY, ELEVATON Fl. FNSHED ftocr 10, round P. RON PPE.E RON RS) lw. A C. - RON RCS) W/ PLASRC C.P. LENGTh BAS. M ASURED N A TT NAl. & TiN TAB s HAS. A N G.V,D. NATTONA. GEODETC PER1CAT. OATTJU ER. SCATTNG REFERENCE ORE. OFFCAl. RECORD 5004 P.O. PLAT BOON PC. * POiNT OF CURVAT L.RE P.C.C. PONT OP COMPOUND CJRVATRE p P. PVRAANENT CONTRA PONT POE. * POST OP EEGUANNG P.O.C. PONT OF CONENCD4ENT P.R.C. - PONT OF RLAERSE CURVATURE R.P.M. PERMANENT REFERENCE ACNUUENT PT PONT OF *ERSECVON P RAOJS R/W - RGHT-OP-SAT PN. - PARCEL DENTFCATON NUMBER SEPTC TUNC UT. UTLTY EASE4EN CENTRAl. ANGLE. - 04*1W 111*1 FENCE - WOOl) FENCE El CONCRETE rlatpcnc PQ51(R POLE t. L. HEREBY CERTFY THE NFORMATON SHOWN HEREON MEETS THE MNMUM TEC4NCAL STANDARDS SET FORTH BY THE FLORDA BOARD OF PROFESSONAL SURVEYORS AND MAPPERS N CHAPTER 61G17 6, FLORDA ADMNSTRATVE CODE. PURSUANT TO SECTON , FLORDA STATUTES. BY: MCHAEL A MANZE, P.LS. FLORDA CERTlflA1Ec.No OLDE SLE SURVET NG & EAAPPtN eccpan,y South Eghth Street Fernc FL. (904) ee FA) SCALE: DAlE: /i 22?? ORN 8Y:.47 n.m. Cl<D BY. JO NO: 7J? BNo

11 ;E_ i %! \ *1i

12 4 p (Jr At r 2t a -

13 j J vj

14 U,, *, : 1,c V

15 0 L t [1 T. 1 _._L -. 1 iij

16 - -7 :.,-. - i!!! jiklji[.l1 [ lt.ii A - -..,-.-: -

17 .,.

18 r 4! 4 f% V.. w 4.

19 j J vj

20 U,, *, : 1,c V

21 s / / / 1 p a:

22

23 _J