Cole's of Columbus Building no answer 6 State Fairgrounds 4500 block of North High Street in Columbus

Transcription

1 APPENDIX H

2 Question Survey Section 2. Buildings, Please list by name any building or buildings in your city, county, or region that were constructed between 1945 and 1970 and that you think are good examples of design, engineering, or use of modern materials for this period. Question Please enter the approximate street address or location, including city or county, for the buildings you listed above. Response Response Building 1 Building 2 Building 3 Building 1 Building 2 Building 3 1 Saint Ladislas Catholic Church Reeb Ave. Columbus, Ohio Erieview Tower Winton Place 2 East 12th Street between St Lake Avenue, Clair and Lakeside, Lakewood, Ohio Cleveland, Ohio 3 Lazarus building Drexel Theater 3 Downtown N High St E Main St Bexley 4 Various Wright-style houses in 4 Walhalla Rd, Columbus, Ohio Walhalla Ravine 5 Our Lady of Peace Church in 5 Clintonville: corner of N. High Clintonville Street and E. Dominion 6 Ohio Historical Society Museum Cole's of Columbus Building 6 State Fairgrounds 4500 block of North High Street in Columbus 7 Legal Arts Center Market Street, Youngstown, OH Macy's Kingsdale (previously Kingsdale Center, Lazarus) Columbus, OH The Boulter House, FLW 1956 Woodie Garber Residence Ray Rouch Residence 9 1 Rawson Woods Circle, Glendale, OH Eight Mile Rd., Anderson, Cincinnati, OH OH 10 Fairborn Theatre Fifth Third Bank/Dollar Savings Building 11 Round Bank Building Houses on Sharon View Drive Middletown City Hall 10 Downtown Fairborn, Montgomery County Jim Ridd building el & Associates 11 Corner of 30th St. and Route 79 Heath, Ohio, Licking Co. SE Corner of High & Third Streets, Hamilton, Butler County Sharon View Drive Newark, Ohio, Licking Co. 1 Donham Plaza, Middletown, Butler County Sharon Valley Road Newark, Ohio, Licking Co. 12 Wade Ellis Residence Bank Building MacDonald residence Shipherd Circle, Oberlin 40? South Main Street, Oberlin 13 L-O-F (Libbey-Owens-Ford) Building (now Hylant Group) National Exchange Club Maumee Indoor Theater Madison between Headquarters Ontario and Michigan Sts., Toledo 14 Math and Science Building Education Building Saddlemire Student Service 14 Bowling Green State Building University campus 15 St. Philip Christian Church Ameritrust Tower ( ) Pepper Ridge houses ( East 30th Street, (1968) Frederick Toguchi Marcel Breuer 66) Robert Little Cleveland, OH 16 Congregation B'nai Israel Charter One Bank buildings Days Inn Hotel Kenwood Boulevard, Toledo Overbrook Rd, Elyria 3050 Central Ave., Toledo 601 Conant, Maumee Bowling Green State University campus 900 Euclid Avenue, Cleveland, OH 5072 Monroe Street (just one example), Toledo Bowling Green State University campus 1-18 Pepper Ridge Road, Pepper Pike, OH 1800 Miami Street, Toledo

3 Question Please list by name any building or buildings in your city, county, or region that were Question Response Response 17 Cleveland Trust Tower Park Synagogue Carl B. Stokes Building Euclid Avenue, Cleveland Please enter the approximate street address or location, including city or county, 3300 Mayfield Road, Cleveland Heights 1201 Lakeside Avenue, Cleveland 18 Cleveland Trust Tower Jewish Community Center Cleveland Electric Illuminating 18 East 9th and Euclid East 18th and Euclid 55 Public Square 19 Tower East Building Chagrin Boulevard, Shaker Heights 20 South Elementary School 20 intersection of Providence Ave. and South Broadway 21 Weltzheimer-Johnson House Hall Auditorium Oberlin Conservatory of Music 21 Morgan Street, Oberlin OH North Main Street, Oberlin OH West College Street, Oberlin OH

4 Question Approximate date of construction Question Original primary use (if known) Response Response Building 1 Building 2 Building 3 Building 1 Building 2 Building Religious Commercial Residential 3 3 Commercial Other Residential Religious Educational Office Commercial Residential Residential Residential Commercial Commercial Other Commercial Residential Residential Residential Commercial Residential Office Other Commercial Educational Educational Educational Religious Office Residential Religious Commercial Other Office Religious Office Office Office Office / Office Educational Residential Educational Educational

5 Question Current primary use (if known) Question What do you think makes this building significant? (check all that apply) Response Response Building 1 Building 2 Building 3 Building 1 Building 2 Building 3 1 Religious 1 Design/Style; Engineering 2 Commercial Residential 2 Design/Style; Engineering; Design/Style; Engineering; Use of modern materials; Architect(s); Landscaping Use of modern materials; Architect(s) 3 3 Design/Style Design/Style; Architect(s) 4 Residential 4 Design/Style; Ravine setting 5 Religious 5 Design/Style; Engineering; Architect(s); Architect Earnest Gaal influenced by architect Eero Saarinan...AIA Guide to Columbus 2008 p. 214; diamond Shaped 6 Educational 6 Design/Style; Engineering Design/Style 7 Other 7 Design/Style; Use of modern materials 8 Commercial 8 Design/Style; Use of modern materials; Designer Raymond Fernand Loewy 9 Residential Residential Residential 9 Design/Style; Engineering; Design/Style; Use of modern Design/Style; Engineering; Use of modern materials; materials; Architect(s); Use of modern materials; Architect(s) Landscaping Architect(s); Landscaping 10 Other Commercial Other 10 Design/Style; Use of modern Design/Style; Engineering; Design/Style/ Architect(s) materials Use of modern materials 11 Commercial Residential Commercial 11 Design/Style Design/Style; Use of modern Design/Style; Engineering; materials; Architect(s); Use of modern materials; Developer Architect(s); Developer; Builder(s)

6 Question Current primary use (if known) Question What do you think makes this building significant? (check all that apply) Response Response 12 Residential Commercial Residential 12 Design/Style; Engineering; Use of modern materials; Developer; Part of Oberlin's first "suburban" community, many owner designer and built, owners co-op to buy materials. Owner/builder was Oberlin College's first African American professor. Design/Style; Engineering; Use of modern materials; Only mid century commercial building in downtown district Design/Style; Engineering; Use of modern materials; Architect(s); Architect John Terrence Kelly, still in original family 13 Office Other Commercial 13 Design/Style; Use of modern Design/Style; Use of modern materials; Architect(s); Landscaping materials; Architect(s); Landscaping Design/Style; Use of modern materials; Architect(s); Already on National Register 14 Educational Educational Educational 14 Design/Style; Use of modern Design/Style; Use of modern materials materials Design/Style; Use of modern materials; Landscaping 15 Religious Other Residential 15 Design/Style; Use of modern Design/Stylel; Use of modern materials; Architect(s) materials; Architect(s) Design/Stylel; Use of modern materials; Architect(s); Developer; Landscaping 16 Religious Commercial Other 16 Design/Style Design/Style Design/Style 17 Other Religious Office 17 Design/Style; Architect(s) Design/Style; Architect(s); Design/Style Landscaping 18 Other Office Office 18 Design/Style; Architect(s) Design/Style; Architect(s) Design/Style 19 Office 19 Design/Style; Architect(s) 20 Educational 20 Design/Style; Use of modern materials; Architect(s) 21 Educational Educational Educational 21 Design/Style; Use of modern Design/Style; Use of modern materials; Architect(s) materials Design/Style; Use of modern materials; Architect(s)

7 Survey Section 3. Planned Residential Neighborhoods and Subdivisions, Question Please list by name any major planned residential neighborhoods or subdivisions Question Response Response Planned Neighborhood/ Subdivision 1 Planned Neighborhood/ Subdivision 2 Planned Neighborhood/ Subdivision 3 Please enter the approximate location, including county or city, of the planned Planned Neighborhood/ Subdivision 1 Planned Neighborhood/ Subdivision Walhalla Ravine 4 Walhalla Rd, Columbus, OH 5 don't remember what it was called but in Clintonville between E. North Broadway and Blenheim(N-S) and (E-W) between Granden and Indianola pretty sure being told was built in 1950's after Korean Conflict 5 Franklin County, Columbus, Clintonville, don't know name as was called then but N-S between E. North Broadway and Blenheim and E-W between Granden and Indianola Upper Arlington 8 North of Lane Avenue (area of Macy's) - Five Points South of Lane Avenue Arlington Avenue Planned Neighborhood/ Subdivision 3 9 Greenhills, OH Rush Creek, Columbus, OH 9 Greenhills, OH Rush Creek, Columbus, OH (near Delaware) Southgate development near Morgan Manor, Newark, Presidential Estates, north of 11 21st. Route 79, south of west of Country Club Drive, North of Moull St. West of Moundbuilders, Heath across from OSU Newark Moull St. west of 21st St. Circle Mound site, Heath north of Granville Road, 21st St. Campus Newark 12 College Park aka Shipherd 12 Shipherd Circle off of East Circle College St in Oberlin, OH 13 Lincolnshire Neighborhood Country Place Neighborhood Sleppy Hollow 13 along Central Avenue, west of Secor Rd., Toledo all of Country Place, Sylvania Entered off Monroe St., just east of its intersection with Erie St., Sylvania Pepper Ridge Dalebrook Estates Sandalwood Estates Pepper Ridge Road, Pepper Pike OH. Dalebrook Road, Independence OH. Sandalwood Drive, Bay Village OH. 16 do not know do not know do not know 16 do not know do not know do not know 17 Mills Creek 17 Center Ridge Road & Mills Creek Lane, North Ridgeville 18 18

8 Survey Section 3. Planned Residential Neighborhoods and Subdivisions, Question Please list by name any major planned residential neighborhoods or subdivisions Question Response Response Please enter the approximate location, including county or city, of the planned Oldtown Colonial Estates Holderbaum Edition 20 SE New Philadelphia SW New Philadelphia 21 Shipherd Circle 21 Shipherd Circle, Oberlin OH

9 Question Approximate date of construction Question What do you think makes this neighborhood significant? (check all that apply) Response Response Planned Neighborhood/ Subdivision 1 Planned Neighborhood/ Subdivision 2 Planned Neighborhood/ Subdivision 3 Planned Neighborhood/ Planned Neighborhood/ Subdivision 1 Subdivision Ravine setting my understanding from friend is that was built about time of Korean Conflict to house families of men returning from military duty Planned Neighborhood/ Subdivision Design/Style; Landscaping methods and/or materials; Although best known for its early 20th c residential architecture, the vast majority of UA's growth occured Design/Style; Engineering; Use of modern materials; Architect(s); Developer; Builder(s); Landscaping methods and/or materials; spatial relationships Design/Style; Engineering; Use of modern materials; Developer; Builder(s); Landscaping methods and/or materials; Spatial relationships Expansion of Heath and Newark area in 1950's Design/Style; Use of modern materials; Architect(s); Developer; Builder(s); Landscaping methods and/or materials; Spatial relationships; Mid-century affluent neighborhood Planned neighborhood with bi-level, split level, and ranches. Streets named after presidents

10 Question Approximate date of construction Question What do you think makes this neighborhood significant? (check all that apply) Response Response Design/Style; Use of modern materials; Developer; Builder(s); Spatial relationships; owner/builder co-operatives, covenant, no sidewalks Design/Style; Engineering; Use of modern materials; Architect(s); Developer; Builder(s); Landscaping methods and/or materials; spatial relationships Design/Style; Developer; Landscaping methods and/or materials; Spatial relationships; entire street is post-war housing Design/Style; Engineering; Use of modern materials; Architect(s); Developer; Builder(s); Landscaping methods and/or materials; Spatial relationships Design/Style; Use of modern Design/Style; Developer; Design/Style; Developer; materials; Architect(s); Landscaping methods and/or Spatial relationships; Developer; Landscaping methods and/or materials; Spatial relationships; first modernist (i.e. Miesian style) planned housing community in Cleveland. materials; Spatial relationships; entire street is post-war housing; Intact sprawling ranch community on large oval/wooded roadway Planned neighborhood consisting of 3-4 plans including ranches, split levels. 16 do not know Landscaping methods and/or materials; Spatial relationships Spatial relationships Spatial relationships Design/Style

11 Survey Section 4. Planned Communities, Question Please list by name any major planned communities (with residential, Question Response Response Please enter the approximate location, including county or city, of the planned Planned Community 1 Planned Community 2 Planned Community 3 Planned Community 1 Planned Community 2 Planned Community Upper Arlington 8 Five Points Newark High School Campus 11 Granville Road Newark do not know do not know do not know 16 do not know do not know do not know 17 Reserve Square Apartments E. 12th Street

12 Question Approximate date of construction Question Original primary use (if known) Response Response Planned Community 1 Planned Community 2 Planned Community 3 Planned Community 1 Planned Community 2 Planned Community Residential Educational Residential

13 Question Current primary use (if known) Question What do you think makes this community significant? (check all that apply) Response Response Planned Community 1 Planned Community 2 Planned Community 3 Planned Community 1 Planned Community 2 Planned Community Residential 8 Design/Style Educational 11 Design/Style; Engineering; Use of modern materials; Architect(s); Developer; Builder(s); Landscaping methods and/or materials; Spatial relationships; May be rare example of campus style (in scale) high-school for this region Residential 17 Design/Style; Use of modern materials

14 Survey Section 5. Landscape Designs, Question Please list by name any major modern landscape designs that you know of in your Question Please enter the approximate location, including county or city, of the landscape Response Response Landscape Design 1 Landscape Design 2 Landscape Design 3 Landscape Design 1 Landscape Design 2 Landscape Design Park of Roses at Whetstone Park in Clintonville/Columbus 5 N. High Street and Acton Road to east, Columbus road going into park (west of High Street)has different name do not know do not know do not know 16 do not know do not know do not know

15 Question Approximate date of construction Question Original primary use (if known) Response Response Landscape Design 1 Landscape Design 2 Landscape Design 3 Landscape Design 1 Landscape Design 2 Landscape Design Recreational

16 Question Current primary use (if known) Question What do you think makes this landscape design significant? (check all that apply) Response Response Landscape Design 1 Landscape Design 2 Landscape Design 3 Landscape Design 1 Landscape Design 2 Landscape Design Recreational 5 I don't know...not my area of expertise, just know it was built during this time

17 Survey Section 6. Urban Renewal Projects, Question Please list by name any major urban renewal projects that you know of in your city, Question Response Response Please enter the approximate location, including county or city, of the urban Urban Renewal Project 1 Urban Renewal Project 2 Urban Renewal Project 3 Urban Renewal Project 1 Urban Renewal Project 2 Urban Renewal Project redevelopment of Flytown into 6 Thurber Village in Columbus -- Thurber Village Neil/Buttles scattered site public housing 12 W. Lorain St., S. Park St., S. Main ST., Oberlin, OH Cleveland State University Erieview Plaza 15 Euclid Ave, between East 1801 East 9th Street, 18th St & Innerbelt Highway hway, Cleveland, OH Cleveland. 16 do not know do not know do not know 16 do not know do not know do not know 17 Erieview 17 E. 9th & St. Clair Avenue, Cleveland

18 Question Approximate date of construction Question Original primary use (if known) Response Response Urban Renewal Project 1 Urban Renewal Project 2 Urban Renewal Project 3 Urban Renewal Project 1 Urban Renewal Project 2 Urban Renewal Project Residential Educational Office Office

19 Question Current primary use (if known) Question What do you think makes this project significant? (check all that apply) Response Response Urban Renewal Project 1 Urban Renewal Project 2 Urban Renewal Project 3 Urban Renewal Project 1 Urban Renewal Project 2 Urban Renewal Project Residential 12 Design/Style; Use of modern materials; Developer; Landscaping and/or materials; Spatial relationships Educational Office 15 Design/Style; Use of modern Design/Style; Use of modern materials; Architect(s); materials; Architect(s); Landscaping and/or Landscaping methods and/or materials; Spatial materials; Spatial relationships relationships Office 17 Design/Style; Use of modern materials; Architect(s); Spatial relationships

20 Survey Section 7. Architects Working in Ohio, Question Please list any architects who you think made a significant contribution to architecture Question Response Response Please list the name of the architectural firm (if known) for the architect(s) you listed Architect 1 Architect 2 Architect 3 Architect 1 Architect 2 Architect Thomas Volt Ben Dombar Woodie Garber Ray Rousch 9 Ben Dombar Woodie Garber Strauss & Rousch John Noble Richards and Skidmore, Owings, & Merrill Harrison & Abramovitz 13 Richards, Bauer & same as above same as above Charles Stark Moorehead Marcel Breuer Don Hisaka I.M. Pei do not know do not know do not know 16 do not know do not know do not know Minoru Yamasaki Wallace Harrison Warner, Burns, Toan & Lundy 21

21 Question Please provide the location (city and state) of the architectural firm (if known) for the Question Please provide an example of the architect's work, such as a building name or a Response Response Architect 1 Architect 2 Architect 3 Architect 1 Architect 2 Architect Columbus, OH 4 Various homes in Walhalla Ravine Cincinnati, OH Cincinnati, OH Cincinnati, OH 9 Runtel Residence Hamilton County Library Weston Residence Toledo, Ohio New York New York 13 Columbia Gas of Ohio Building Libbey-Owens-Ford World Headquarters Fiberglass Tower Ameritrust Tower; Cleveland Art Museum addition ( ) Giddings Elementary School (1970) Erieview Plaza plan ( ) 16 do not know do not know do not know 16 do not know do not know do not know Oberlin Conservatory of Music, Oberlin College Hall Auditorium, Oberlin College Mudd Library, Oberlin College

22 Question Please provide the location of the architects' project examples you listed above. If Question Response Response Survey Section 8. Landscape Architects Working in Ohio, Please list any landscape architects who you think made a significant contribution Architect 1 Architect 2 Architect 3 Landscape Architect 1 Landscape Architect 2 Landscape Architect Walhalla Rd Anderson Downtown, Cincinnati East Walnut Hills, Cin., OH Jefferson Ave., Toledo 811 Madison Ave., Toledo 200 N. St. Clair St., Toledo Euclid Avenue, Cleveland 2250 East 71st St. Cleveland 1801 East 9th St, Cleveland 15 OH OH OH 16 do not know do not know do not know West College Street, North Main Street, downtown Oberlin College campus, 21 downtown Oberlin OH Oberlin OH Oberlin OH

23 Question Please list the name of the design firm (if known) for the landscape architect(s) you Question Response Response Please provide the location (city and state) of the design firm (if known) for the Landscape Architect 1 Landscape Architect 2 Landscape Architect 3 Landscape Architect 1 Landscape Architect 2 Landscape Architect

24 Question Please provide an example of the landscape architect's work, such as a plaza, park, or Question Please provide the location of the landscape architects' project examples you listed Response Response Landscape Architect 1 Landscape Architect 2 Landscape Architect 3 Landscape Architect 1 Landscape Architect 2 Landscape Architect

25 Survey Section 9. Land Developers and Builders Working in Ohio, Question Please list any land developers and/or builders who you think made a significant Question Response Response Please list the name of the firm (if known) for the land developers and/or builders Land Developer/ Builder 1 Land Developer/ Builder 2 Land Developer/ Builder 3 Land Developer/ Builder 1 Land Developer/ Builder 2 Land Developer/ Builder

26 Question Please provide the location (city and state) of the firm (if known) for the land Question Response Response Please provide an example of the land developers and/or builders work, such as a Land Developer/Builder 1 Land Developer/Builder 2 Land Developer/Builder 3 Land Developer/Builder 1 Land Developer/Builder 2 Land Developer/Builder New Philadelphia 20 residential neighborhood 21 21

27 Question Please provide the location of the land developers and/or builders' project examples Question Response Response Survey Section 10. Ohio's Outstanding Architecture from 1945 to 1970 What buildings, planned neighborhoods/subdivisions, planned communities, Land Developer/Builder 1 Land Developer/Builder 2 Land Developer/Builder 3 Property 1 Property 2 Property Legal Arts Center Sleepy Hollow subdivision Community Services Building/United Way Building Libbey-Owens-Ford World Headquarters/Hylant Group Robert Little Houses - Pepper The Illuminating Building East Ohio Building Ridge se New Philadelphia Oberlin Conservatory of Hall Auditorium Mudd Library Music

28 Question Property Name Question Street address or approximate location Response Response Property 1 Property 2 Property 3 Property 1 Property 2 Property Legal Arts Center Market Street Sleepy Hollow subdivision Community Services Libbey-Owens-Ford World 13 Off Monroe St. east of Erie 1 Stranahan Square 811 Madison Ave., Toledo Building/United Way Building Headquarters/Hylant Group St., Sylvania Pepper Ridge development The Illuminating Building East Ohio Building Pepper Ridge, Pepper Pike OH 55 Public Square, Cleveland OH 1717 East 9th Street, Cleveland OH Oberlin Conservatory of Music Hall Auditorium Mudd Library 21 West College Street, downtown Oberlin OH North Main Street, downtown Oberlin OH Oberlin College campus, Oberlin OH

29 Question Name of architect (if known) Question Name of developer and/or builder (if known) Response Response Property 1 Property 2 Property 3 Property 1 Property 2 Property Samborn, Steketee, Otis & Skidmore, Owings, & Merrill 13 Browning Evans Robert Little Carson & Lundin Emery Roth & Sons Minoru Yamasaki Wallace Harrison Warner, Burns, Toan & Lundy 21

30 Question Name of landscape architect (if known) Question Name of general contractor (if known) Response Response Property 1 Property 2 Property 3 Property 1 Property 2 Property

31 Question Date of construction (estimated) Question Why do you think this property is significant? Response Response Property 1 Property 2 Property 3 Property 1 Property 2 Property started in early 1960s Planned subdivisioon with high architectural intregrity and a covered bridge Architecture Architecture and history Early modernist planned residential community First modernist office tower in Cleveland (and first construction project in the core since 1929) Second modernist office tower in Cleveland architect distinctive design Brutalist style - broad patterns of history

32 Question Response Survey Section 11. Optional Comments Please share any additional comments you have about this project. 7 This is a great modern building located in the center city. It makes great use of the site and 8 dd th i d f th d ( ki td ) Its a great idea, but it takes way longer than minutes to complete if you take it 14 Saddlemire i l I Student t 45 Servie i t Building it (Building i d it3) was bit demolished f h in F2007. l ill h thi 15 Please keep me updated on the results of the survey. Thanks! Also, in downtown Oberlin, is the modest midcentury modern Peoples Bank building, currently undergoing restoration to its 1958 appearance. Good example of "Main Street" adoption of midcentury modern. Many modest examples of midcentury modern residential

33 OPTIONAL - Please provide the following contact information if you have specific questions about this project or would like to share additional information. Name address Question or Comment James Varga vargastone04@aol.com Marilyn Veracka mveracka@wowway.com no questions at this time and nothing else to share Paul Hagman paulhagman@gmail.com Chuck Lohre, owner The Boulter House chuck@lohre.com, 1 Rawson Woods Cir., Cin., OH I'm more familiar with local residences. OK to contact me. Tom Barrett tombarrett89@yahoo.com Kerry Fan sfan@bgsu.edu I wish I could provide more information. Kerry Adams, Senior Historic Preservation Specialist, Cleveland Restoration Society KAdams@clevelandrestorati on.org Greg Tisher director@oberlin.org