ROLL CALL APPROVAL OF THE DECEMBER 4TH, 2018 MINUTES PUBLIC HEARINGS

Transcription

1 AGENDA ST. TAMMANY PARISH BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT MEETING WEDNESDAY JANUARY 2, :00 P.M. ST. TAMMANY PARISH GOVERNMENT COMPLEX BUILDING A KOOP DRIVE, PARISH COUNCIL CHAMBERS MANDEVILLE, LOUISIANA CALL TO ORDER ROLL CALL APPROVAL OF THE DECEMBER 4TH, 2018 MINUTES PUBLIC HEARINGS BOA CASE NO BOA Request by applicant in an A4 Single Family Residential Zoning District for an after the fact variance to reduce the required side yard setback from 10 feet to 2.3 feet, to keep an attached carport to a single family residence. The property is located at 605 Grand Oaks, Madisonville, Louisiana. Applicant & Representative: Alfred F. & Christine L. Heine III BOA CASE NO BOA Request by applicant in a HC2 Highway Commercial Zoning District for an after the fact variance to reduce the required side yard setbacklgreenspace from 10 feet to 7.8 feet to allow for a portion of a commercial building to remain into side yard setback/greenspace. The property is located at Highway 21, Covington, Louisiana. Applicant & Representative: JSB HWY 21 LOTS, LLC John Bowers BOA CASE NO BOA Request by applicant in an A3 Suburban Zoning District to increase the maximum allowable combined length of an accessory structure from 50 feet to 90 feet to allow for the construction of an open carport and attached storage shed. The property is located at 128 Rue Holiday, Slidell, Louisiana. Applicant & Representative: Kevin S. Foltz OLD BUSINESS NEW BUSINESS ADJOURNMENT

2 MINUTES ST. TAMMANY PARISH BOAR]) OF ADJUSTMENT MEETING 3:00 PM TUESDAY DECEMBER 4TH, 2018 ST. TAMMANY PARISH GOVERNMENT COMPLEX BUILDING A KOOP DRIVE, PARISH COUNCIL CHAMBERS MANDEVILLE, LOUISIANA The December 4th, 2018 meeting of the St. Tammany Parish Board of Adjustment was called to order by the Chairman, Mr. Fandal. The roll was called as follows: PRESENT: Mr. Fandal, Mr. Ballantine, Mr. Schneider, Mr. Brookter, Mr. Gordon, Mr. Guidry and Mrs. Thomas. ABSENT: N/A STAFF PRESENT: Mrs. Riles, Mrs. Lambert APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES Moved by Mr. Brookter and seconded by Mr. Schneider to accept the November 7th, 2018 minutes. PUBLIC HEARINGS MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY BOA CASE NO BOA Request by applicant for a waiver a portion of the required 10 foot side yard greenspace area and to encroach 3.9 feet over the property line, within the adjacent required 10 foot side yard greenspace area, to allow for the construction of a 450 square foot outdoor seating area. The property is located at Highway 1085, Suite 105, Covington, Louisiana. Applicant & Representative: Copperstill Development LLC & CV Copperstill, LLC Mike Saucier (Mrs. Lambert read the staff report into the record...) Applicant Mr. Mike Saucier: identify himself as present for the request on behalf of WOW Café and Wingery, gave a description of the reasons for the request: to allow for a 450 square foot covered outdoor seating area to be placed within the required side yard/greenspace and to encroach over the abutting side yard greenspace area. Patio is part of the proposed restaurant business model, and will provide additional seating and an area to facilitate pick up orders. Marc Verges, Partner in Company: Described the importance of the patio for the restaurant and for the community. Patio is an integral part of the restaurant and allows for outdoor special events. It will have a large impact on the community. Steve Ballard, Owner of Company: Brand new restaurant model for WOW Café and Wingery. It is the first one in St. Tammany Parish. Patio is needed for the sports cormnunity and as a training space. 1

3 Mr. Fandal: Question the legality of approving v?rianc.qve,r the property line. Mrs. Lambert: Not prohibited but could create precedent. Mrs. Riles: Answered Mr. Fandal s question: Not prohibited but could create precedent. Mr. Schneider: Asked Mr. Saucier if he has a copy of the attachment referred in the letter submitted with the application form, in regards to the approval from Rouses. Mr. Saucier: We do have approval from Rouses. We can provide copy of the agreement. Mr. Schneider: Would it be possible to move the property line? Mrs. Lambert: Property line could be moved; however, moving the property line would not eliminate the need for a variance. Mr. Saucier: We could execute a servitude to allow to have the patio over the property line. Mrs. Riles: Servitude can be created and recorded; however it is a civil question between property owners. Moved by Mr. Gordon and seconded by Mr. Schneider to approve the requested variance. MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY OLD BUSINESS NEW BUSINESS ADJOURNMENT: Moved by Mr. Fandal MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY MR. TIM FANDAL, CHAIRMAN ST. TAMMANY PARISH BOARD OF ADJUSTMENTS Disclaimer: These minutes are intended to represent an overview of the meeting and general representation of the testimony given; and therefore, does not constitute verbatim testimony or a transcription of the proceedings. 2

4 ST. TAMMANY PARISH BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT STAFF ANALYSIS REPORT Case File Number: BOA Case No BOA Initial Hearing Date: 01/02/19 Date of Report: 12/18/2018 GENERAL INFORMATION Applicant(s) Name & Representative: Alfred F. & Christine L. Heine III Location of Property: 605 Grand Oaks, Madisonville, Louisiana. Zoning of Property: A4 Single Family Residential District Variance(s) Requested: After the fact variance to reduce the required side yard setback from 10 feet to 2.3 feet OVERVIEW The applicant is requesting an after the fact variance to reduce the required side yard setback from 10 feet to 2.3 feet, to keep an attached carport to a single family residence. STAFF COMMENTS The request is to allow for a 13 feet X 33 foot attached carport to remain within the required 10 foot side yard setback As shown on the attached picure, the purpose of the carport is to provide a cover for a boat. Staff is not in support of the request considering that no evidence of hardship or practical difficulty has been demonstrated to warrant support of the encroachment within the required setback. Moreover, the support or granting of such variance request may result in the establishment of a precedent in the parish.

5 @ BOA I :1:. Cl) 123 sy t17r1oe C 0

6 C ao Ic$r... r.,. 9 i1 tt... c. c ItT B.L 10 B.L q U, I General Notes: 1. The purpose of this plan is to show the purposed building footprint as defined by the metes and bounds of the recorded plot. 2. Dimensions setbacks, easements, plan selection, and any other information shown here in shall be verified at permitting and prior to construction for accuracy and compliance with all applicable codes and ordinances. 3. Builder is solely responsible for ensuring that the footprint is contained within the prepared building pad. The building pad shall be set high enough to allow for adequate drainage. 4. AJI calculations are approximate. They must be verified prior to permitting, purchasing, and/or construction. 11 o,, Set eave on 30 building line req. Ila pet Driveway a DR HortonLouisiana Lot Area SQ. FT. Grand Oaks Slab Area 3234 SQ. FT. Lot: 20 BIk: Coverage Ratio 24 Z Grand Oaks Lane 6221 Riverside Dr., f 116 Madisonvi le, LA IMng, Texas Plan No. Desoto ARB L S2E No Phone (972) Fax (972) DATE 4/29/13 DN A.X.A CHK D Scale: 1 = 20 PAGE 1 of 1

7 Photos for Project 2018 LO,,i.2 f;. Description Date Taken Date Upload Photo of Record 11/13/18 11/13/18. _ d:; r. 4.. I j.4:!, z 1llllW :4J Description Date Taken Date Upload Photo of Record 11/13/18 11/13/18

8 Photos for Project 2018.: I 071 U/200 Description Date Taken Date Upload 7/13/18 7/13/18 Photo of Record i: 7. 1Jlll I fll4j1iii I Description Date Taken Date Upload Photo of Record 7/13/18 7/13/18 C

9 Lr3_ Christian & Marci Griffiths 609 Grand Oaks Lane Madisonville, Louisiana September 24, 2018 Re: 605 Grand Oaks Lane, Madisonville, LA Carport To Whom It May Concern: We are neighbors of Al and Christine Heine. We have no objection of their rear carport structure adjoining our property. The structure does not negatively impact our property. We believe that the structure is aesthetically pleasing. Sincerely, Christian Ma rci Giths

10 ST. TAMMANY PARISH BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT STAFF ANALYSIS REPORT Case File Number: BOA Case No BOA Initial Hearing Date: 0 1/02/19 Date of Report: 12/18/2018 GENERAL INFQRMATION Applicant(s) Name & Representative: JSB HWY 21 LOTS, LLC John Bowers Location of Property: Highway 21, Covington, Louisiana. Zoning of Property: HC2 Highway Commercial District Variance(s) Requested: After the fact variance to reduce the required side yard setbacklgreenspace from 10 feet to 7.8 feet OVERVIEW The applicant is requesting an after the fact variance to reduce the required side yard setback/greenspace from 10 feet to 7.8 feet to allow for a portion of a commercial building to remain into side yard setback/greenspace. STAFF COMMENTS The request is to allow for a portion of an existing commercial building/covered area to remain within the required 10 side yard greenspace/setback, as shown on the attached survey and picture. The purpose of the covered area is to house some coolers for the new restaurant located inside the main building. Staff is not in favor of the request considering that no hardship or practical difficulty is being demonstrated to warrant support of the encrochment within the required greenspace area. Moreover, the support or granting of such varianc request may result in the establishment of a precedent in the parish

11 2O181322BOA LAURELLEAF S ThLER T t.? r DOGWOOD

12 I I I \ LOT 165AD /,.,,,., j \ri/ Il P5 DPBFt7 VIaNnYMAP A CERTAIN TRACT OF LAND BEING LOCATED IN FLOWER ESTATES SUBDIVISION. SECTION A, SECTION 47, TOWNSHIP 7 SOUTH, RANGE 11 EAST, ST. TAMMANY PARISH, LOUISIANA BEING MORE FULLY DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS COMMENCING AT A FOUND DOTD PIN MARKER BEING ON A CURVE TO THE RIGHT CLOCKWISE & NON TANGENT) AND RUN ALONG SAIG CARVE WITH A RADIUS OF FEET AN ARC LENGTH OF FEET. A CHORD BEARING OF SOUTH 82 DEGREES SD MINUTES 02 SECONDS WEST AND A CHORD LENGTH OF FEET TO A FOUND DOTD PIN MARKER BEING THE POINT OF BEGINNING: FROM THE POINT OF BEGINNING RUN SOUTH UK DEGREES Al MINUTES 24 SECONDS WEST FOR A DISTANCE OF SUU.U0 FEET TO A FOUND IS IRON ROD; THENCE RUN NORTH BR DEGREES 58 MINUTES ST SECONDS WEST FOR H DISTANCE OF FEET TO A FOUND Y, IRON HOD: THENCE RUN NORTH FOR A DISTANCE OF FEET TOG FOUND SC IRON ROD: THENCE RGN SOUTH 67 DEGREES 44 MINUTES Si SECONDS EAST FOR H DISTANCE OF FEET TOA FOUND DOTD PIN MARKER: THENCE RUN NORTH 77 DEGREES RN MINUTES 09 SECONDS EAST TONG DISTANCE OF FEET TOG FOUND DOTES PIN MARKER. ThENCE RUN SOUTH 09 DEGREES 57 MINUTES ST SECONDS EAST FOR A DISTANCE OF FEET TOA FOUND ROTO PIN MARKER: THENCE RUN SOUTH 82 DEGREES SE MINIUTES4S SECONDS EAST FOR A DISTANCE OF FEETTO A FOUND DOTD PIN MARKER AND SAID POINT BEING ON A CURVE TO THE LEFT COUNTERCLOCKWISE 6 NONTANGENT): THENCE RUN ALONG SAID CURVE WITH A RADIUS OP FEET AN ARC LENGTH OF 179.IU FEET A CHORD BEARING OF NORTH 87 DEGREES 23 MINUTES IS SECONDS EAST AND V CHORD LENGTH OP 179.G9 FEET BACK TO THE POINT OF BEGINNING SAID TRACT OF LAND CONTAINS ACRES OR 233, SQUARE FEET MORE OR LESS 16 La. Hwy #21 _1288, L A s89 5T55 E, S82;361vE io C = I I 15 II I LOT BlA Bu))diBg CIY Slab Lot 165A2 See Site CUrreTt)y W LOT 164 e al Under CDTSErUEEIOY H s too 9 C 0 Build)ng OTT I o S)ab zi L BuSetbocks \ J N W A 5/8 IRFI r99 T100 i L V LOT 180 L.a LOT 420Al LOT 421 LOT 422 LOT 177 LOT 178 LOT SEWER, DRAINAGE & UT)UTY EASEMENT (10 EACH SIDEI I I 1 inch = 130 feel LINE TABLE Graphic Scale NAMISDIeECXID5 DISTANCE LI )SGY aa ti t SD oc as BeOrlngs and d,4eoncca shnwn hereon ore based on Map File #SOIA SURVEO85NOT 1 THE LOCATION OF EUISTING UTILITIES ART SHOWN N AN APPROXIMATE WAY ONLY, THEY WERE NOT EGCAVATED TORE ACCURATE 9 LOCATED CAll LOUISIANA ONE 811 BEFORE DIGGING 2 SERVITUDES SHOWN HEREON ARE NOT NECESSARILY EDCLUSIGE. SERGITUDES OF RECORD AS SHOWN ON TITLE OPINION OR T TIE POLICY WILL BE ADDED HERETO UPON REQUEST AS SURVEYOR HAS NOT PERFORMED ANY TITLE SEARCH OR ABSTRACT 3 THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED WITHIN FLOOD ZONE C WITH ABASE OF N/A ACCORDING TO THE FEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY IFEMA) FLOOD NSURANCE RATE MAP FIRM) COMMUNITY PANEL NO O2EG C U D23OC DATED B9 4 SETBACK LINES SHALL REVERIFIED AT OWNER OR CONTRACTOR PRIOR TO ANY CONSTRUCTION. AS AN ARSTRACT HAS NOT BEER PERFORMED DY THE UNDERSIGNED. FRONT SG REAR SD SIDE SD HE PURPOSE OF THIS SURVEY IS TO SHOW AND DEPICT HE SLAB OF THE BUILDING UNDER CONSTRUCTION WITH RELATION TO THE PROPERTY BOUNDARY NO OTHER MPROVEMENTS HAVE BEEN LOCATED EXCEPT THOSE SHOWN HEREON Ill U, W IRON ROD FOUND UNLESS NOTED OTHERWISE A DOT D CAP POUND POC POINT OF COMMENCEMENT WOOD FENCE IRS IRON ROD SET 1FF IRON PIPE FOUND IRE IRON ROD FOUND P08 POINT OF BEGINNING PERFORMED AND PREPARED BY: PD Mod SONS II., LouisA,, crwo SLAB SURVEY e S S ER VIC ES LOT 165 A2 FLOWER ESTATES SUBDIVISION, SECTION A 985, b,r,50ain@ssurh.rng.amarlcs.com SECTON TOWNSHIP RANGE LANA OISTHICT $amvrmatwn PRDIECT NUMBER PARTY CHIEF DRAWN DY CAICS RE APPHOVED flflon To: HUG HWY 21 PROPERTIES L I.E I EerEIfX That this plot represents an aotual ground survey made byrne Dr under my direction, and It does Conform to the requirements for the minimum standards for property boundary surreys as found In LouisiaNa Administrative Code Title 46 LXI, Chapter 25 for a Class C survey 5o of LO(p kr, REG. No REGISTEREO PROFESSIONAL j 2DD Alfred) Resler Prvtesslonal Land Surveyor Date Stteet I of I N..

13 TIT N I 51,1511 CISC, C lssi 15 5 L( PHASE I LIMIT.Q,09 j uj (f)(fi cc 70 CC, z U] o J CD DoDIpIIon lire 0 I II, J J bj I Ll If) 701 S I. dthb J AC 0111$ CER DM40 oaog$t ]111. ROIl 001] AZALEA GARDENS AbPCkAM Fbap.fl.l_.,_. DRAINAGE PLAN (AS BUILT) PHASE 1 II18I,0. PHASE 1 DRAINAGE PLAN boo RNE T.DYER cool NOTED

14 49 1S$k. cj k?% ),x. 4;..t. J4..s r.1j( frt<. : t*% k 4.f, at k : t j, ;z 47. crt c I c V çr a.. * 4 ½.. 4., t._a.h % 4.. : cs4t.o :;;34ss. 4 t r n:. r r. A 4., a pçs. ir ;ç a C :. :7? 4 r N t $,; 4, r z::*l:$f z4r z: t. it a 4. C. %..4

15 ST. TAMMANY PARISH BOARD OF ADJuSTMENT STAFF ANALYSIS REPORT Case File Number: BOA Case No BOA Initial Hearing Date: 01/02/19 Date of Report: 12/18/2018 GENERAL INFORMATION Applicant(s) Name & Representative: Kevin S. Foltz Location of Property: 128 Rue Holiday, Slidell, Louisiana. Zoning of Property: A3 Suburban District Variance(s) Requested: Increase the maximum allowable combined length of an accessory structure from 50 feet to 90 feet OVERVIEW The applicant is requesting to increase the maximum allowable combined length of an accessory structure from 50 feet to 90 feet to allow for the construction of an open carport and an attached storage shed. STAFF COMMENTS The request is to allow for a 24 feet X 90 feet accessory building. The building is proposed to have a 60 foot long open carport and an attached 30 foot long enclosed storage shed (See attached drawings). The purpose of the carport is to provide a cover for personal vehicles and a motor home and the purpose of the attached shed is for a small workshop and personal storage area. Although the proposed structure does not violate the required setback nor exceed the maximum allowable size of an accessory buildings (7.5 percent of the area of the lot on which the main building), staff is not in favor of the request, considering that no hardship or practical difficulty is being demonstrated. Moreover, the support or granting of such variance request may result in the establishment of a precedent in the parish.

16 (iji;,o, ft a;x Ui / / / 193 ØRCHARI3 HILL / n 1, q 200 :,..., 1,.. 1)

17 Variance Request Letter Kevin Foltz 128 Rue Holiday Slidell, LA December 2, 2018 St. Tammany Parish Board of Adjustment P.O. Box 628 Covington, La Re: 128 Rue Holiday, French Branch Subdivision, Slidell, LA request for variance on accessory building. I am requesting a variance to be allowed to build one, ninety by twenty four foot building on my property. This building will have sixty feet of open carport with a thirty foot enclosed shed/storage building at its rear. See attached stamped plans of said purposed structure. The building will only be approximately 4.95% of the total square foot of my property. The property is just over one acre in area. The building will have the same/matching exterior material as was used on the house, which is and will be the only other building on the property. The carport will only be used for parking family vehicles and one 45ft. Motorhome, and all vehicles will be used strictly for personal and pleasure purposes The shed will be a small workshop and storage area, again to be used for personal use only. Under current rules I can build two separate buildings totaling the same square footage, but my request is to build one building which will make a more aesthetically pleasing landscape. I have letters of No Opposition from both adjoining neighbors, the neighbor across the street and from the French Branch Homeowner s Association. The property to the rear is 12.5 acres of wooded property with no signs of development in the 18 years that I have lived on the property. ResPecllY Submitted, Kevi n

18 ic cc A 0) Q It) (N c (N SITE PLA SCALE 1=20

19

20 I3o4 2 2 J4 15 OH. 15 OH. 4, il L ilz III. li FCNT ELEVATION SCALE = 1/4=10

21 IIo1II/I = NOIi A3 LS] 5D

22 c1 November 27, 2018 St. Tammany Parish Board of Adjustment P.O. Box 628 Covington, La Re: 128 Rue Holiday, French Branch Subdivision Lot 198, Slidell, LA request for variance on accessory building. Variance to be allowed to build one, ninety by twenty fourfoot accessory building on my property. Please accept this letter and the following signatures as proof of No Opposition to the variance request set before you. V S Paul and Molly Graham, 214 Rue Holiday, Slidell, LA (west side adjoining property)

23 ;e)1 j November 27, 2018 To Whom It May Concern: I, Deborah C. Foster, do not have an objection to Kevin Foltz requesting a variance for construction of a 90 ft. accessory building to house his motor home at 128 Rue Holiday, Slidell, LA 70461, as long as it meets all other parish codes and does not impact drainage on adjacent properties. Thank you, Deborah C. Foster 126 Rue Holiday Slidell, LA 70461

24 iç, November 27, 2018 St. Tammany Parish Board of Adjustment P.O. Box 628 Covington, La Re: 128 Rue Holiday, French Branch Subdivision Lot 198, SlicIell, LA request for variance on accessory building. Variance to be allowed to build one, ninety by twenty fourfoot accessory building on my property. Please accept this letter and the following signatures as proof of No Opposition to the variance request set before you. Johnny and Noel Venezia, 309 Rue Piper, Slidell, LA (across th treet)

25 I YT French 8raach Civic Association P. 0 8ox 1935 Slide!!. L.A 70 /59 December St. Taminany Parish Board of Zoning Adiusimen The French Branch Civic Association has been made aware that an accessory building is bemg proposed 128 Rue Holiday. It is our understandina that this building will require a zoning variance. The board of the FBCA is not opposed to the construction of this building. Smcere &Lfl4LQ 3. Lamulle President FBCA cc via FBCA officers