ILC: Political Status

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "ILC: Political Status"

Kory Wilkinson
5 years ago
Views:

1 ILC: Political Status Rey.Hori googlemap Updated on 25th March Satoru Yamashita (ICEPP, Univ. of Tokyo) ILC Ichinoseki Feb. 20, 2018

n n Domestic Topics n ILC250: Cost Reduction / Physics n Science Council of Japan / MEXT ILC Advisory Panel n Industry (AAA: Advanced Accelerator Association) (2008-) n Local area :Tohoku office

2 n n Domestic Topics n ILC250: Cost Reduction / Physics n Science Council of Japan / MEXT ILC Advisory Panel n Industry (AAA: Advanced Accelerator Association) (2008-) n Local area :Tohoku office (2016-), Private Finance Initiative (PFI), business sectors n National Parliament (Diet) / Government / Cabinet Office / Ministries n Diet / Federation of Diet Members (2006 LDP à 2008 expand) n MEXT ILC advisory panel, sub-panels (2014-) à by 2018 Spring n Cabinet Office (CAO), Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MOF), other Ministries n Prime Minister s office (Most essential) ß we have been communicating International n n n n European Strategy (ECFA/CERN) / US P5 Process (DOE) Chinese project (CECP), Chinese President Initiatives for Large S&T projects Schedule/Cost/Human Resources of other/existing projects ICFA/LCB/LCC n US-Japan ILC Discussion Group (2016-) cost reduction (2017-) n Europe-Japan (2018-) n France-Japan, Germany-Japan (Jan ) n Italy/UK/Spain to come in Spring 2018 n CERN, EC to come

3 ESSENTIAL n WONDERFUL PHYSICS - GUARANTEED & POTENTIAL n ENERGY EXTENDABILITY n STATE-OF-THE-ARTS ACCELERATOR & DETECTOR n WORLD-WIDE COOPERATION & SUPPORTS n CO-PROSPERITY WITH WORLD LABOLATORIES n SHARABLE INVESTMENT (COST&HUMAN) SCALE 3

4 ILC Promotion bodies in Japan Japan: Parliamentary cabinet system Government National Diet (Parliament) Representatives ~480 Councillors ~240 Political Federation of the Diet Members for ILC (2006, 2008~) Founded by LDP in 2006 à Multiparties in Now ~150 Members Industry & Academia Business sector AAA Advanced Accelerator Association (2008~) (2014~ incorporated company) Industry-Academia cooperation Led by Executives of Leading Companies and KEK DG Cabinet (Prime Minister s office) Ministries MEXT (Education,Culture,Sports,S&T) CAO (Cabinet office) S&T Council (CSTI) MOFA (Foreign Affairs) -- Embassy MLIT (Civil, Sightseeing, Transport) METI (Economy, Trade, Industry) + MOF (Ministry of Finance) Central activity in Researchers KEK ILC Promotion Office (led by KEK DG, 2014~) Technological leadership for Accelerator Cooperation with MEXT KEK, JAEA, QST, JAXA, RIKEN, SCJ Science Council of Japan Universities,, J-HEP Committee Japan HEP Community Local Area Candidate area ILC Tohoku Promotion Office (2016, June~) Led by Local Governments, Business Associations, Univ. Presidents. Cooperation of Civil engineering at candidate site area Geological surveys, preparation for campus

5 Jun : Ministerial Meeting at Prime Minister s Office Hon. S. Noda Hon. T. Nikai T. Kawamura Hon. H. Nakasone Hon. K. Yosano Hon. R. Shionoya Hon. K. Kaneko 7 Ministers ILC TDR Event (December 2012) Visit PM Abe (March 2013)

General Meeting of Diet Members for ILC: regularly held once per 1~2 months Hon. Shionoya reported on US visit, Mar. 2016 Attendance from Ministries/Agencies (ex.

Ministry of Culture, Education, Sports, Science and Technology (MEXT): Kazuo Todani Deputy Minister Futoshi Sano Director-General for Policy Coordination Yayoi Komatsu Director-General, Research

Director for Particle and Nuclear Physics Promotion Office, Basic Research Promotion Division, Research Promotion Bureau Cabinet Office (CAO) Takeo Nakagawa Deputy Director-General for Science,

6 General Meeting of Diet Members for ILC: regularly held once per 1~2 months Hon. Shionoya reported on US visit, Mar Attendance from Ministries/Agencies (ex. Mar 2016) Full with Diet members, Government Officers, Diet members staffs, Medias + industry, scientists. Ministry of Culture, Education, Sports, Science and Technology (MEXT): Kazuo Todani Deputy Minister Futoshi Sano Director-General for Policy Coordination Yayoi Komatsu Director-General, Research Promotion Bureau Hiroshi Ikukawa Deputy Director-General, Research Promotion Bureau Masami Watanabe Director for Basic Research Promotion Division, Research Promotion Bureau Sadahiro Hagiwara Director for Particle and Nuclear Physics Promotion Office, Basic Research Promotion Division, Research Promotion Bureau Cabinet Office (CAO) Takeo Nakagawa Deputy Director-General for Science, Technology and Innovation Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MOFA) Takahashi Noritsugu Director of International Science Cooperation Division, Disarmament, Non-proliferation and Science Department, Foreign Policy Bureau Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism (MLIT) Toshihiko Takahashi Engineering Affairs Division, Secretary division of Minister of MLIT Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry (METI) Kazuhiko Muto Director for International Affairs Office, Industrial Science and Technology Policy and Environment Bureau

7 September 25, 2017 General Meeting, Federation of Diet Members for ILC

8 Washington DC, May 1-3, 2017

9 International Meetings FALC ICFA International Conferences International Design Scientists Industry-Academia Local area Hon. Kawamura Keynote Speech Technical Design Report (2013) (includes staging scenarios) ILC promotion Schedule V-2017.June Apr. Aug. Dec. Mar. NOW Aug. CRITICAL Aug. Budget Request Budget Request n Budget Fiscal Budget RequestFiscal Budget RequestFiscal June 2017 Strategy Strategy Strategy 2013~2016 Request à International Government Federation àstart (Operational budget LCLS-II construction: use technology Cost reduction R&D tasks Agreement US Visit oku) US-Japan 2nd year US-Japan US-Japan 3rd year US-Japan 4th year (1st year R&D) Within US-Japan S&T Cooperation framework (conclusion) May: MEXT/DOE n With US: need start serious discussion on management and possibility of cost sharing Discussion Group Federation Federation: US-Europe-Japan cooperation US Visit End of October à Support Parliament/Government/Inter-government discuss Europe IEEE Cooperate with Federation n With Europe (EU countries & CERN): need start concrete discussion on new administration Europe Visit sharing of cost, technology, human resources Asia Germany-Japan& Congress Hon. Riesenhuber (by second half of 2018) MEXT ILC Advisory Panel Risk studies (commissioned) Input Advisory ESFRI (revised every 2 years; target 2019 spring) Gov. Panels Human resources Japan Organization, Panel & devlopment governance ConclusionSummer , Jan-Dec Studies on international organization (commissioned) European Strategy à Next 5-year plan Europen Strategy (2013) Europe Interim Report ICFA: staging endorsement Pre-discussionDiscussion à Proposal EC S&T minister, gov ts P5 report (2014) United States LHC results P5 report 2019 Aug Feb Aug Nov Feb Aug Feb Aug Feb Aug Feb IEEE LCWS2016 Staging Design (Cost Reduction) HEP community: consensus Future plans, ILC staging Cost reduction ALCW2017 LP2017 Staging, Cost, Physics International Effort Report Cost reduction Technology, cost reduction, local cost, distributed centers, private funds, logistics Report LCWS2017 KEK consensus ICHEP2018 LCWS2018 Domestic Outreach Report Toward domestic consensus ICFA critical decision Keep or stop ILC Activities LP2019 Phase-0 LCWS2019 ICHEP2020 Phase-1 Detailed design, automation (cost reduction, stability), reduce cost risk, detector engineeri Toward international consensus, technology applications, human development, managem Shown in 2017 June AWLC@SLAC

10 CRITICAL ISSUES in Year 2018 complete MEXT ILC Advisory Panel in Spring, receive opinion of Science Council of Japan in summer/autumn. Inform ILC scope (model of sharing, timeline, scheme) from Japan to partner nations. Establish Multilayer (political, ministerial, laboratory-agency, industry and liaison -researchers) bi-lateral body first with European Countries, and then with US (waiting for political appointment in DOE), and with Asian countries. Boost cooperation with Prime Minister s Office And Clear Signal from Japan (Governmental Intention to Host, Model for investment share,,) All must be done before European Strategy input

11 House of Representatives General Elections: October 22, 2017 Stable Political Situation = essential for ILC realization 11

12 n n n n à n n n n à n n n 12

13 January 8-11, 2018 The 1 st Japanese ILC delegation to Europe (France and Germany) was a big success. Sincere thanks to Hon. Olivier BECHT (French National Parliament) Hon. Stefan KAUFMANN (Bundestag) Dr. Alain BERETZ (MESRI/DGRI) Dr. Georg SCHUETTE (BMBF) and all others A big jump Next steps March-June: Spain, Italy, UK May: US (if high-level governmental officials are approved) Asia: start with India, Australia 13

14 Europe-Japan Processes in January EU-Japan Parliament Council à 1 st input to EU Parliament members from Japan (Hon. Kosaka -2016) 2. Spain-Japan (May-Jun. 2016): Symposium at Spanish Embassy in Tokyo, on mutually interesting area, Fusion and Accelerator related field. à MoU between INEUSTAR and Spanish Embassy in Tokyo, Japan in May Industry-Academia Spain-Japan Workshop at ECFA LC workshop at Santander in Spain in June Germany-Japan (Oct. 2016): parliamentary member interactions@tokyo Direct discussion for ILC between German Parliament Member and JP Diet members Strasbourg Two Diet members (Hon. Ito, Hon. Shina), AAA Nishioka /Oct/27 LCWS2017@Strasboug (Hon. Becht (France) Hon. Kaufmann Germany 3 Diet members (Japan, remote) Kawamura, Shionoya, Hirano /Nov/07 ICFA/LCB statements, hoping an international project led by Japanese initiative /Nov/29 Hon. Becht visited Japan, had a pre-meeting in Tokyo /December Preparation for the meetings in France and Germany Hon. Becht (FRA), Hon. Kaufmann (GER), ILC Federation of Diet Members, Alsace Japan Agency, French Embassy in Japan /Jan/9-11 Japanese Delegation visit to Paris and Berlin 14

15 EU-Japan federation meeting, France IPU Conference in Zambia Mar. 3-4, 2015 Mar. 19th-23rd, 2015 Japanese Diet members led by the late Hon. Kenji Kosaka Hon. Shun-ichi Suzuki Meeting with German Bundestag members, October 2016

Oct. 27, 2016 @ Tokyo Meeting with German Bundestag members for ILC Germany: Prof. Dr.

16 Oct. 27, Tokyo Meeting with German Bundestag members for ILC Germany: Prof. Dr. Heinz Riesenhuber (former Minister of Research), Herr Mark Hauptmann + German Embassy Japan: Hon. S. Suzuki, Hon. N. Tamura, Hon. T. Shina, Hon. Y. Takaki + Scientists (S.Yamada, S.Komamiya, Y.Okada, SY)

17 IEEE Oct & LCWS2017 Oct. Strasbourg Mrs. Catherine Trautmann Vice-présidente, Strasbourg Eurométropole Former French Minister of Culture Former EU Parliament member Former Mayor of Strasbourg

1 ) 1 (1 1 1,, 1 2 2 0 1. 0. 2018.1.08 and 1.

18 1 ) 1 (1 1 1,, and 1.12 visit CERN Germany/France side Leading Part: Hon. Becht (France) Hon. Kaufmann (Germany) Hon. Trautmann (EU/Strasbourg) True Heroes: Marc Winter Maxim Titov Supervision: Rolf Heuer Joachim Mnich 18

19 Window to EU and France IEEE: Strasbourg, Oct Catherine Trautmann, Former French Minister of Culture Former EU Parliament member Former Mayor of Strasbourg AAA Chairman T. NSS/MIC Plenary Hon. T. Shina Two Diet members participated and discussed on VIP meeting Hon. Ito

20 LCWS2016: Morioka, Japan, Dec. 5-9, 2016 participants from scientists, industry, local area, etc. Hon. Shun-ichi Suzuki, Hon. Hinako Takahashi, Hon. Takeshi Shina Members of Federation of Diet Members for ILC Keynote Speech by Hon. Takeo Kawamura Chair of Federation of Diet Members for ILC à Additional Material available: Speech at LCWS2017 (Dec. 2017) by Hon. Kawamura, the chair of the federation of Diet members for ILC

From Japan (ILC Federation of Diet Members,

21 The first step LCWS2017 in Strasbourg (October 27th) From Europe Hon. Olivier BECHT (National Assembly, France) Hon. Stefan KAUFMANN (Bundestag, Germany) From Japan (ILC Federation of Diet Members, remote) Hon. Takeo Kawamura Hon. Ryu Shionoya Hon. Tatsuo Hirano 21

The second step Japan: Hon. Kawamura, Hon.

22 The second step Japan: Hon. Kawamura, Hon. Shionoya, Hon. Hirano, Hon. Ito, Hon. Otsuka, Hon. Fujiwara MEXT: Mr. Itakura et al Members of AAA, Tohoku Economy Federation Researchers France: Hon. Olivier Becht Mr. Jean-Christophe AUFFRAY French Embassy) Mr. Aurelien ANTHONY Alsace Japan Agency) etc. 22

23 Japanese Delegation A big jump Date: January 9-11, 2018 Meetings@Paris: National Parliament, MESRI, Laboratories Meetings@Berlin: Bundestag, BMBF Federation of Diet Members: Hon. Shionoya, Hon. Ito, Hon. Otsuka Policy secretary of Hon. Kawamura Ministry: Mr. Itakura (MEXT) Deputy Director-General of Research Bureau, Officers of Japanese Embassy in Paris/Berlin (Ministry of Foreign Affairs) AAA T. Nishioka (former MHI President), J. Nishiyama, T. Sakamoto, M. Matsuoka Tohoku Economy Federation: H. Takahashi (former President of Tohoku Electric Power), O. Oe, G. Sato, E. Nishiyama Researchers A. Suzuki (Iwate-pref Univ/former KEK DG), H. Aihara (Tokyo), S. Yamashita (Tokyo), N. Niita (KEK, International Affairs Division)

- - 0 Meeting with French National Parliament Members Hon.

Pierre HENRIET,,, Meeting at Ministry of Higher Education,

Advisor of MESRI) Alain BERETZ (Director General of DGRI)

for research) Etc. M. Titov, M. Winter Hon. BECHT Hon.

IN2P3, TGIR) Meeting at CEA/Saclay (Directorate and international

24 - - 0 Meeting with French National Parliament Members Hon. Alain TOURRET, Hon. Olivier BECHT, Hon. Julien AUBERT, Hon. Pierre HENRIET,,, Meeting at Ministry of Higher Education, Research and Innovation (MESRI) Jean-Philippe Bourgoin (Research Advisor of MESRI) Alain BERETZ (Director General of DGRI) Christian CHARDONNET (Director, department of large infrastructure for research) Etc. M. Titov, M. Winter Hon. BECHT Hon. TOURRET LCWS2017 Meeting at CNRS Headquarter (Directorate of CNRS, IN2P3, TGIR) Meeting at CEA/Saclay (Directorate and international division and site visit), Industry sessions Alain BERETZ Christian CHARDONNET Visits to LAL/Orsay and THALES 24

25 Hon. TOURRET, Hon. BECHT Meetings at Palais Bourbon, Government building, and Laboratories Visit Lab/Industry 25

26 Meeting with Hon. Stefan Kaufmann, a member of Bundestag, together with Joachim Mnich and Marc Winter, Maxim Titov. Hon. Kaufmann LCWS2017 Meeting with Dr. Georg Schuette, state secretary at Education (BMBF), and other officers, together with Hon. Kaufmann. and Research Dr. Schuette Hon. Kaufmann 26

27 BMBF, Germany Hon. Kaufmann Dr. Schuette 27

28 Conditions for ILC realization from French/German Governmental point of views 1. ILC in the result of the next European Strategy of Particle Physics 2. Co-prosperity with CERN for long Also on Industrial Participation from each partner country Already Established / to be established Bi-lateral Counterpart in each of 5 layers 1. Parliament Level 2. Ministry Level 3. Funding Agency Laboratory Level 4. Working researchers (Liaisons) 5. Industry Level 28

29 NEXT to COME ITALY, SPAIN, UK Pre-Preparatory Meetings with Key Liaison Researchers in 3 countries Feb. 8 th - 13 th ITALY SPAIN UK INFN President Fernando Ferroni, Antonio Juan Fuster Phil Burrows + Brian Foster (net-connection) Mark Thomson to come à STFC DG Preparation started for Parliament-level, Ministry-level, funding-agency-level, industry interaction For the idea of coordination and task-share model in Europe With European Action & CERN Thomas, Hans, Marcel, and Steiner 29

30 CRITICAL ISSUES in Year 2018 complete MEXT ILC Advisory Panel in Spring, receive opinion of Science Council of Japan in summer/autumn. Inform ILC scope (model of sharing, timeline, scheme) from Japan to partner nations. Establish Multilayer (political, ministerial, laboratory-agency, industry and liaison -researchers) bi-lateral body first with European Countries, and then with US (waiting for political appointment in DOE à Undersecretary Confirmed), and with Asian countries. Boost cooperation with Prime Minister s Office ++ We understand need of Clear Signal from Japan (Governmental) All must be done before European Strategy input

31 CRITICAL ISSUES in Year 2018 complete MEXT ILC Advisory Panel in Spring, receive opinion of Science Council of Japan in summer/autumn. Inform ILC scope (model of sharing, timeline, scheme) from Japan to partner nations. Establish Multilayer (political, ministerial, laboratory-agency, industry and liaison -researchers) bi-lateral body first with European Countries, and then with US (waiting for political appointment in DOE à Undersecretary Confirmed), and with Asian countries. Issue On the track On the track Boost cooperation with Prime Minister s Office ++ We understand need of Clear Signal from Japan (Governmental) All must be done before European Strategy input On the track On the track On the track

Profile of Dr. Shigeru MORICHI

Profile of Dr. Shigeru MORICHI 1. Date and Place of Birth: Date of Birth: Sep. 29, 1943 Place of Birth: Kyoto City 2. Nationality: Japanese 3. Present Position: Senior Professor, National Graduate Institute