Citizens Advisory Committee Meeting

Transcription

1 Citizens dvisory Committee Meeting for the NORTH EMBRCDERO PORT MSTER PLN MENDMENT and DRFT ENVIRONMENTL IMPCT REPORT March 16,

2 Revised Notice of Preparation - Scoping Session for the NORTH EMBRCDERO PORT MSTER PLN MENDMENT and DRFT ENVIRONMENTL IMPCT REPORT March 16,

3 Revised Notice of Preparation Scoping Session GEND Introduction California Environmental Quality ct (CEQ) Environmental Impact Report (EIR) Third Revised Notice of Preparation (NOP) Scoping Project Description Overview Scoping Comments Next Steps 3

4 Revised Notice of Preparation 4

5 Item I from Revised NOP 5-6 Story Mixed-Use Facility Commercial Recreation/ Parking/Youth Hostel Bay Front Shuttle Route ssign Commercial Recreation/Youth Hostel Use to 1220 Pacific Highway Parcel Lane Field Setback Park/Plaza Reconfigure Land Use Designations to Recognize Current Property Ownership and Permitting Jurisdictions (NEVP Phase 1 CDP) 205 setback Change Commercial Recreation Use to Marine Terminal Use Remove Crescent Pier and Consolidate 3 Existing Piers to 1-Public and 1-Excursion dd Broadway Pier Forecourt and Viewing rea dd to PMP Boundary and ssign Plaza/Commercial Recreation use Recognize G St. Mole Park as a Memorial Park dopted by BPC October 11, 2005 and authorized negotiating JP for implementation Resolution

6 Item II from Revised NOP 6

7 Citizens dvisory Committee Meeting for the NORTH EMBRCDERO PORT MSTER PLN MENDMENT and DRFT ENVIRONMENTL IMPCT REPORT March 16,

8 Introductions Port staff Jim Hirsch, Project Manager Irene McCormack, Vice President of External Relations Facilitator Lewis Michaelson Citizens dvisory Committee (CC) Members What organization do you represent? Briefly describe what you believe you bring to this process that will help the CC and Port move forward. 8

9 North Embarcadero Visionary Plan Schematic Design Illustrative Plan Boundary North Embarcadero Visionary Plan Boundary 9

10 Port Master Plan Precise Plan 10

11 Port s Objectives Revise the Port Master Plan to meet the direction of the California Coastal Commission scoping letter to clarify the status of the Visionary Plan and align it with the 2005 NEVP Schematic Plan as the standard of review. 11

12 Standard of Review., the NEVP is not the standard of review for the coastal development permit. the PMP itself, including the text of the PMP, the exhibits, the project list, and those portions of the NEVP specifically referenced in the PMP are the standard of review for coastal development permits issued by the Port District. 12

13 Mission Statement The mission of the North Embarcadero Port Master Plan mendment Citizens dvisory Committee is to assist Port of San Diego staff in aligning and enhancing the sustainability of the 2005 North Embarcadero Visionary Plan (NEVP) Schematic Design Plan through a Port Master Plan mendment by suggesting improvements and modifications that would increase its social, financial and environmental feasibility. It is presumed that implementation of the 2005 NEVP Schematic Design Plan will only be possible in the short and long term with the collaboration and support of key stakeholders and approval from relevant oversight bodies. To that end, the North Embarcadero Port Master Plan mendment Citizens dvisory Committee is charged with providing Port staff with recommendations, information, insights and suggestions that would support the ability to transform the 2005 NEVP Schematic Design Plan into reality. 13

14 Principles of Participation Role of Committee Members Representation Discussion Process Meeting ttendance lternates Support Meeting gendas Observers Media Communication Role and Responsibility for Public Outreach 14

15 Environmental California Environmental Quality ct (CEQ) Endangered Species ct (ES) California Department of Fish and Game (CDFG) US Fish & Wildlife Service (USFWS) rmy Corps of Engineers (COE) California Global Warming Solutions ct of 2006 (B 32) Construction costs Operations and Maintenance (O&M) costs Public Trust Doctrine Port ct California Coastal ct Taxes and grants Public ccess Revenue realization Construction phasing/timing of development Visitor serving services Local residents needs Future generations Existing leases State Lands Commission Financing Partnerships Jurisdictional authorities (Port, County of San Diego, Navy, City of San Diego) Financial Public Interest Sustainable Decision Making Framework 15

16 Questions & nswers 16

17 1998 North Embarcadero lliance Visionary Plan 17

18 dopted by BPC October 11, 2005 and authorized negotiating JP for implementation Resolution North Embarcadero Visionary Plan Schematic Design 18

19 NEVP OUTRECH TIMELINE Visionary Plan Feb, 97 Dec, 98 MEIR + PMP Dec, 98 Mar, 01 Pre-Schematic Jan, 02 ug, 02 Public Presentation of Foot of Broadway without Oval design ug 1, 2002 Schematic Design Sept, 03 Nov, 05 Public Meetings Validation of Schematic Design Oct, 07 pr, 08 Stakeholder Meetings Construction Documents pr, 08 Mar, 10 19

20 20

21 Revised Notice of Preparation 21

22 5-6 Story Mixed-Use Facility Commercial Recreation/ Parking/Youth Hostel Bay Front Shuttle Route ssign Commercial Recreation/Youth Hostel Use to 1220 Pacific Highway Parcel Lane Field Setback Park/Plaza Reconfigure Land Use Designations to Recognize Current Property Ownership and Permitting Jurisdictions (NEVP Phase 1 CDP) 205 setback Change Commercial Recreation Use to Marine Terminal Use Remove Crescent Pier and Consolidate 3 Existing Piers to 1-Public and 1-Excursion dd Broadway Pier Forecourt and Viewing rea dd to PMP Boundary and ssign Plaza/Commercial Recreation use Recognize G St. Mole Park as a Memorial Park 2011 North Embarcadero Port Master Plan mendment - Scoping Components dopted by BPC October 11, 2005 and authorized negotiating JP for implementation Resolution

23 Tentative Planning Workshop Schedule February -Finalize CC composition (staff) -Confirm CC members, schedules (staff) -Publish CC meeting Schedule (staff) -Prepare background material including California Coastal ct, B 32, SB 375, State Lands Commission, the Public Trust Doctrine, (staff) March Meeting #1 : 3/16/11 -Procedural Scoping Meeting -Planning rea Description -Introduction focc members, (staff) -Mission Statement Principles of Participation, Sustainable Decision-making (Lewis Michaelson) Scoping Components -Workshop schedule -Hand outs for next meeting, Port Master Plan, Public Trust Doctrine, Coastal ct, ;2005 NEVP Schematic Plan, Re-visioning Waterfront Workshop Meeting # 2: 3/30/11 -nalyze Goals and Policies; Compare Original NEVP and NEVP to California Coastal ct and State Lands Commission Policies (staff) -Background on NEVP, NEVP Pre-Schematic, and NEVP Schematic Design (including working waterfront and 10 Places), NEVP Phase 1 elements, and layout framework for aligning and updating NEVP Schematic Design (Elaine Nesbitt EEK) and Owen Lang -Potential Harbor Drive and Boradwayroad alignments (LLG, Nasland) pril Meeting # 1: 4/13/2011 -Open Space Setback Parks -Presentation by County of County dministration Center waterfront Park (County staff) May Meeting # 1: 5/11/11 -Project presentation / workshop on Navy Pier Veterans Park (Midway) -G Street Mole (staff) Meeting # 2: 5/18/11 -Potential Harbor Drive roadway alignments, Preliminary Modeling results (LLG, Nasland) -Parking management Plan and BayfrontShuttle (staff) June Meeting # 1: 6/1/11 -Public Space ctivation Update (staff) -The Wharf, Little Italy Plaza, North Lawn, The Cove, Tavern on the Bay (Elaine Nesbitt) Meeting # 2: 6/15/11 -Grape Street Mixed Use Parking Structure -Grape Street Piers and Plaza (Elaine Nesbitt). July Meeting # 1: 7/6/11 -Homeland Security Policy (staff) -Low-cost ccommodations Policy (staff) -Potential youth Hostel locations (staff) -"B" Street Pier use change (staff) Meeting # 2: 7/20/11 -Economic Feasibility nalysis (David Zehnder) -Wrap-up Presentation, Review (staff) ugust Meeting # 1: 8/3/11 -Select ligned NEVP Schematic Design, Select lternatives for EIR (staff) September -Begin Draft EIR (Dudek) 23

24 24 J N F E B P R M Y J U L U G EIR Phase: Begin Draft EIR Distribute Draft EIR (45 day public review) Board of Port Commissioners Certification of EIR and doption of PMP S E P O C T N O V D E C Coastal Commission PMP Certification Process Schedule subject to change DRFT Public Scoping Meetings for PMP and EIR Planning Phase: Begin Technical Studies Public Outreach Workshops and Citizens dvisory Committee Meetings Tentative Draft EIR and PMP Schedule F E B P R M R M Y J U N P R M Y J U N U G J U L S E P O C T N O V D E C M R J U N J U L U G O C T N O V D E C J N F E B M R J N S E P

25 Questions & nswers 25

26 Handouts Port Master Plan Port ct Section 87 Coastal ct Chapters 3 and NEVP Schematic Plan C3 Waterfront Revisioning Workshop Handout 26