Trinity Plaza. 450 South Rose Avenue. Tom Davies Canyon Cardiff Oxnard, LLC for New Trinity Community Church

Transcription

1 Trinity Plaza 450 South Rose Avenue Tom Davies Canyon Cardiff Oxnard, LLC for New Trinity Community Church April 28, 2015

2 Appeal of Planning Commission Denial - On March 19, 2015, the Planning Commission took action to deny special use permits and a tentative parcel map to subdivide a 2.52-acre vacant site into three separate parcels for development of: - a 3,000 sf fast food restaurant (Carl s Jr.) with drive-thru facility; - a 7,400 square foot (sf) church (New Trinity Community Church) with seating for 250 members; - a 6,100 sf building including off-site sale of beer and wine (ABC-Type 20) within the for a 2,500 sf 7-Eleven, 24-hour convenience store. 2

3 Appeal of Planning Commission Denial - On March 23, 2015, the applicant met with the City staff regarding concerns raised at Planning Commission Hearing. - Appealed filed on March 23, Application for appeal does not include Special Use Permit No to permit a 7-Eleven, 24 hour convenience store with off-site sale of beer and wine (ABC-Type 20). 3

4 PZ (TENTATIVE PARCEL MAP) Subdivide the existing vacant 2.52-acre parcel into three separate parcels Parcel A 0.73-ac (31,767.8 sf) Parcel B 0.60-ac (26,094 sf) Parcel C 1.04-ac (45, sf) 4

5 PZ (SPECIAL USE PERMIT) Development entitlements: Parcel A: 3,000 square foot fast food restaurant (Carl s Jr) w/ drivethrough Parcel B: 6,100 square foot multi-tenant commercial building. Parcel A 0.73-ac (31,767.8 sf) Parcel B 0.60-ac (26,094 sf) Parcel C 1.04-ac (45, sf) 5

6 PZ (SPECIAL USE PERMIT) Parcel C: 7,400 square foot church with seating for 250 persons (New Trinity Community Church). Parcel A 0.73-ac (31,767.8 sf) Parcel B 0.60-ac (26,094 sf) Parcel C 1.04-ac (45, sf) 6

7 Site Information ac, previously part of 6.52 acres - Rose Park Neighborhood; abuts 3 different neighborhoods (East Village to the North; La Colonia to the west; and West Village to the northwest) & 2007 entitlements expired for approved 18,800 sf church Surrounding Uses - Commercial Ag Land/NECSP - Camino del Sol Senior Apts - Holiday Manor Apts - Del Sol Park Site 7

8 Pictures Camino Del Sol Senior Apartments Holiday Manor Apartments 8

9 Pictures Southeast 9

10 Site Plan Design - Separate ownership lots - Site design provides for shared access, parking, circulation, pedestrian path of travel, lighting, and signage. Parking Provided: 134 Parking Required: Standard Stalls - 7 ADA Stalls - 3 Motorcycle Stalls - 7 Stacking drive-thru - 1 Loading Zone Carls Jr. Restaurant New Trinity Community Church 10

11 Floor Plan Southwes t Northeast Sanctuary Northwest 11

12 Northwest Eas t North Floor Plan Southwes t Dining Prep/Storage CAMINO DEL SOL Restrooms 12

13 West View Tenant Tenant Tenant East View Floor Plan South View North View 13

14 Traffic Study - Traffic Impact Study prepared by Alliance JB, a traffic and transportation planning engineering firm. - Site specific - Evaluated 6 intersections to consider traffic concerns with and without the Project. - Cumulative traffic conditions when considering approved/pending approvals, would operate at acceptable levels (A-C). - Traffic Study recommends striping for east bound lane along Rose Avenue. 14

15 Public Hearing Concerns - Compatibility with Del Sol Park and adjacent apartment/senior housing - Alcohol (7-Eleven no longer proposed) - Loading and Unloading - 24-Hour Fast Food Restaurant - Pedestrian access across Rose Ave - Traffic Impacts (current and future) - Crime activity at a nearby convenience store 15

16 Project Changes - Applicant met with Traffic Engineering and Planning to address concerns raised at the Planning Commission hearing: - Relocated loading zone; - Removed request for alcohol sales; - Allowance for up to 5 tenants (4 previously) 16

17 Site Plan Delivery Truck Turn Radius 17

18 Alternative, Due to Changes in The Project: Council may wish to overturn the Planning Commission s decision of March 19, 2015 and adopt resolutions: - Approving PZ (Special Use Permit), subject to certain findings and conditions; - Approving PZ (Special Use Permit), subject to certain findings and conditions; and - Approving PZ (Tentative Parcel Map), subject to certain findings and conditions. 18

19 Staff Recommendation That the City Council adopt a resolution: - Upholding the decision of the Planning Commission and denying PZ (Special Use Permit); - Upholding the decision of the Planning Commission and denying PZ (Special Use Permit); - Upholding the decision of the Planning Commission and denying PZ (Tentative Parcel Map). 19