Three-Question Matrix and Reference Checks. RFP Number: X P1 RFP Name: Low Profile Super Post Panamax Container Handling Gantry Cranes

Transcription

1 Page Exhibit 1 of 222 Page 1 of 24 Three-Question Matrix and Reference Checks RFP Number: X P1 RFP Name: Low Profile Super Post Panamax Container Handling Gantry Cranes Ranking (Not Alphabetical) 1 2 Firm Name Shanghai Zhenhua Heavy Industries Co., Ltd. (dba ZPMC) Bedeschi America, Inc. Questions 1. Have the vendors taken any exceptions to the County's Standard Terms and Conditions? NO EXCEPTIONS NO EXCEPTIONS 2.Dothevendorshavecomparable governmentexperience? Mississippi State Port Authority North Carolina Ports Authority Port of Miami, Miami Dade County Port of Houston Authority South Carolina State Ports Authorit Tampa Port Authority d/b/a/ Port Tampa Bay Port Authority of Trieste, Italy 3. Have the vendors references been checked? YES (Attached) YES (Attached)

2 ZPMC Reference Page of 222 Page 2 of 24

3 Page Exhibit 3 of 222 Page 3 of 24

4 Page Exhibit 4 of 222 Page 4 of 24

5 ZPMC Reference Page Exhibit 5 of 222 Page 6 of 24 Note: The duplication of check marks reflected on respective lines of this rating is due to ZPMC s submission to this RFP and Broward County s findings from its verification of ZPMC s reference. Ovals denote the results of Broward County's reference verification process.

6 Page Exhibit 6 of 222 Page 7 of 24 Cheerangie, Parum Kevin From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject: Follow Up Flag: Due By: Flag Status: Rubio, Carlos Friday, December 16, :22 PM Cheerangie, Parum Kevin; Delacruz, Arnold Williams, Marie; Byrd, Carla RE: References: X P1 - Low Profile Super Post Panamax Container Handling Gantry Cranes Follow up Tuesday, December 27, :30 AM Completed Kevin, Duringthereferenceverificationprocess,Mr.KevinHayesVPofLCBTwascontactedtoverifyhisexperiencewithZPMC asquestionedonthevendorreferenceverificationformforbidx p1.duringmyconversationkevindisagreed withtheanswersontheformasitwaspresentedbyzpmc.ithenproceededtoaskhimeachquestionasitappearedon theformandmadechangesdetailedinblueink.pleaseletmeknowiffurtherinformationisneeded. Thankyou, Carlos Rubio Project Manager II 1850 Eller Drive Fort Lauderdale, Florida Office: Cell: Fax: crubio@broward.org From:Cheerangie,ParumKevin Sent:Thursday,December15,20166:01PM To:Delacruz,Arnold<ADELACRUZ@broward.org>;Rubio,Carlos<CRUBIO@broward.org> Cc:Williams,Marie<MARIWILLIAMS@broward.org>;Byrd,Carla<CBYRD@broward.org> Subject:References:X P1LowProfileSuperPostPanamaxContainerHandlingGantryCranes Goodafternoon, Pleaseprovideanexplanationforapparentdiscrepanciesonpage5oftheattachedZPMCreference, Needs improvement and Excellent checkedoffforafewquestionsandforothersn/aandexcellentcheckedoff.your responseisduebynoon(est)on Thankyou 1

7 Page Exhibit 7 of 222 Page 8 of 24 ParumKevinCheerangie PortEverglades 1850EllerDrive,FtLauderdale,FL33316 Phone: Fax: (Environment of Trust, Empowerment, and Appreciation Motivating us to do Our Best and Nothing Less!) CustomerCareismypriority.HowamIdoing?PleasecontactmyManager,CarlaByrd,atcbyrd@broward.orgwith feedback. 2

8 ZPMC Reference Page Exhibit 8 of 222 Page 9 of 24

9 ZPMC Reference Page Exhibit 9 of 222 Page 10 of 24

10 ZPMC Reference Page Exhibit 10 of 222 Page 11 of 24

11 ZPMC Reference Page Exhibit 11 of 222 Page 12 of 24

12 Bedeschi Reference Page Exhibit 12 of 222 Page 13 of 24

13 Bedeschi Reference Page Exhibit 13 of 222 Page 14 of 24

14 Bedeschi Reference Page Exhibit 14 of 222 Page 15 of 24 New STS Cranes 23Row CONTSHIP ITALIA LSCT TERMINAL Paolo Mussi Technical Director LSCT STS 23Row LSCT OMG 0174/ October ,600,000 for n.2 STS

15 Bedeschi Reference Page Exhibit 15 of 222 Page 16 of 24 N2 STS Revamping CONTSHIP ITALIA LSCT TERMINAL Paolo Mussi Technical Director 2 V.KOCKS REVAMPING ,200,000 for n.2 STS

16 Bedeschi Reference Page Exhibit 16 of 222 Page 17 of 24

17 Bedeschi Reference Page Exhibit 17 of 222 Page 18 of 24

18 Bedeschi Reference Page Exhibit 18 of 222 Page 19 of 24

19 Bedeschi Reference Page Exhibit 19 of 222 Page 20 of 24

20 Bedeschi Reference Page 0 of 222 Page 21 of 24

21 Bedeschi Reference Page 1 of 222 Page 23 of 24

22 Bedeschi Reference Page 2 of 222 Page 24 of 24