FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 08/09/2016 03:42 PM INDEX NO. 158315/2015 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 62 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 08/09/2016 S UPREME COURT OF THE S TATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF NEW YORK! TIMOTHY FOUCHER a nd KIMBER LY FOUCHER, I Inde xno: 158315/2015 P la intiffs, against THE P ORT AUTHORITY OF NEW YORK AND NEW J ERS EY a nd DELTA AIR LINES, INC., Bay Crane's Response to Piaintiffs' Notice for Discovery and Inspection to Third-Party Defendant De fe nda nts. THE P OR T AUTHOR ITY OF NEW YOR K AND NEW J ER S EY a n d DELTA AIR LINES, INC., against - Third~Pa rty De fe nda nts, BAY CR ANE S ERVICE OF LONG IS LAND, INC., Third-Pa rty De fe nda nt. Third-Pa rty De fe nda nt Ba y Cr8ne S e rvice of Long Is la nd, Inc. ("Ba y Cra ne '), by its a ttorne ys, Ma rsha ll, De nne he y, Wa rne r, Cole ma n & Goggin, he re by re s ponds to pla iiititts ' notice of dis cove ry a nd ins pe ction to third-pa rty de fe nda nt da te d Ma rch ll, 2916, a s follows : Ba y Cra ne ha s no informa tion conce rning the witne s s e s throug h whom "de fe nda nt" inte nds to a dduce evide nce. To the e xte nt tha t the re fe re nce to "de fe nda nt" is inte nde d to re fe r to Ba y Cra ne, Ba y Cra ne obje cts to the que stion a s pre ma ture give n tha t discove ry is in its e a rlie st s ta ge s, a nd imprope r, a s the que s tion ca lls for the dis closure of informa tion tha t is subje ct to the prote ctions of the a ttorne y/clie nt privile g e a nd the privile g e for work product/tria l pre pa ra tion intonna tion. More ove r, the que s tion is in the na ture of a n inte rroga tory a nd not a prope r subje ct of a notice for discove ry a nd inspe ction. Ba y Cra ne obje cts to this re que s t be ca us e it is in the na ture of a n inte rroga tory a nd not a prope r s ubje ct of a notice for dis cove ry a nd ins pe ction. W ithout wa iving this obje ction, s e e Ba y Cra ne `s response to 1lD1 of pla intiffs' combine d de ma nds to third~pa rty de fe nda nt da te d Ma rch i0, 2016.
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that these responses are ongoing and Bay Crane reserves the right to supplcment and amend them up to and including the time ofitriai if further informatinn becomes availabls. 1)zLtcd: Ne w York, Ne w York J uly 28, 2016 MARSHALL WARNER COLEMAN & GOGGIN Attorneysfor Third-party Defenclcznt Bay Crane ServiceofLong Island, Inc. B y : Q/..» -~* 1 3*.. f,,»~/"x1'j w.» S t ven H. Ka plan,sq / 4*.f 3* r a * u81 i _v M IWMWMMM l,r \... v9 J4. v9" " 88 Pine S tre e t, 21st Floor Ne w York, Ne w Ycwrk 10005 Tei.: (212) 376-6400 To: THE P ERFCMAN t 250 West 57th S treet, S uite 401 Ne w York, Ne w York 10107 Te l: (212) 977~7033 CONNELL FOLEY LLP Altorneysfbr Dqfendants/Third-Party Plaim'1j % The Port Az4 'horil;v ofnew York and New Jersey and Defra Air' Lines, Inc. 888 Sseventh Avenue, 9th Floor New York, New York 10106 Tel: (212)307-3700 LEGAL/I9572692-'Jf.v2 2
A13'FIpAv1T (JF s@2~y1ce_ Joan R. Beers, being duly sworn, deposes and says : I am nc>t a party to the within action, am over 18 years of age, am empkmyed by Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman 84 Goggin, 88 Pine Street, 21Si Floor, New York, New York; 10005 a nd re s ide in Ne w York, Ne w York, On July 28, 2016, I served a true copy of the within Bay Crane's Response to Plaintiffs' Notice for Discovery and Inspection. to Third~Party Defendant in the fbllowing manner: By mailing same in a sealed envelope, with postage pwpaid thereon, in a post office or official depository of the U.S. Postal service by first class mail, addwssed to the last known address of the addressee(s) indicated below: THE PERLCMAN FIRM P L L C Artorneysfor Plairztijjfv Timothy Foucher and Kimberly F?Jucher 250 West 5'7th Street, Suite 401 New York, New York 10107 Tel' (212) 977-7033 CONNELL FOLEY LLP Atrorrteysfar Defendanis'/Third-Party Plainhjiv We Port Auihority qfnew York and New Jersey and Delta Air Lines, Inc. 888 Seventh Avenue, 9th Flo<>r New York, New York 10106 Tel: (212)307-3700 Swom to iyefore me tiwis.tuly 2016 28"' F g.. 9 7.~,/ ;.i Joan R. Beers /,H" /A.93 `\ If 'ww \Irifary` "t4a1 DEBORAH Mc.NTOSH- CONTE Notaiy Public, State of New York No. 01MC5060400 Qualified in Kings County Commission Expires May 20, 2018
1 40458.00153 Ind@ x No. 158315/2015 SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF NEW YORK TIMOTHY FQUCHER a nd KUV1BERLY FQUCHER, -a ga inst- T11I8 PORT AUTHORITY OF NEW YORK AND NEW J ERS EY AND DELTA AIR LINES, INC., P la intiffs, De fe nda nts, AND A THIR D-P AR TY AC TION BAY C RANE'S R ES P ONS E TO P LAINTIFFS ' ` 4 NOTIC E FOR DIS C OVER Y AND INS P EC TION TO THIR D-P AR TY DEFENDANT MAR S HALL, DENNEHEY, W AR NER, C OLEMAN & GOGGIN Attorneys for Third-Parry Deferzdanr BAY C R ANE S ER VIC E OF LONG IS LAND, INC. Wa ll S tre e t Pla za, 88 Pine S tre e t, 21" Floor, Ne w York, NY 10005 (212) 376-6400
I EXHIBIT E