MS-2580 Alfred Carmichael Originals 1909-1936 36 cm Alfred Carmichael was born in Belfast, Northern Ireland in 1874, the son of a flour mill owner, and was educated at the Royal Academical Institution, Belfast, Lymn Grammar School, Cheshire and Manchester Technical School. At the age of 16, some time after his father s death, he came to Canada to make his fortune and then return to Britain. He reached Victoria in October, 1890 and found the city suffering a depression. His cousin, Herbert Carmichael, had preceded him to Victoria and his brother Norman followed later. He tried for a job in the machine shop of Albion Iron Works, but found that 40 had applied ahead of him. So he obtained a job in the boiler shop as a rivet heater at 10 cents an hour. The following year he began work at the Aberdeen Salmon Cannery on the Skeena River, supervising the filling of salmon cans. Then, in September 1892, he went to work for Robert Woods, the contractor for the building of the first paper mill in British Columbia, on the Somass River, Alberni. He worked for the paper mill company, which his cousin had organized. However, the mill had a serious fault. It lacked machinery to make paper from wood pulp. Such machinery was expensive and it was hard to raise capital, so the mill made paper from such materials as rags and old rope. Eventually the mill shut down as it was losing money. Alfred Carmichael began operating the sawmill attached to the paper mill. Logs and lumber were cheap and so he was able to run the mill at a profit. A self taught surveyor, Alfred Carmichael surveyed British Columbia coast water power sites for Scottish interests and reported favorably on the Powell River. Later he crossed in a skiff from Texada Island to Powell River and staked out the power site for a Victoria syndicate which later sold to Brooks/Scanlon interests. In the early 1890s he went with missionary Melvin Swartout on journeys along the west coast of Vancouver Island and to Barclay Sound and collected material for Indian Legends of Vancouver Island, published by Musson Book Company in 1922. Another collection of unpublished legends, illustrated by J. Semeyn, Frank Beebe and Judith Morgan, is held in MS-2305. Disappointed at the outcome of the paper mill affair, he decided to take a new direction, going to Atlin in 1899, where he prospected and placer mined for eight years. He spent the winter of 1907-1908 copper prospecting, timber cruising and locating timber on the Queen Charlotte Islands. With a partner, Alfred Woodcroft, he staked 22 square miles of timber, which he sold for a moderate profit. In the autumn of 1908 he took a contract from the Canadian Pacific Railway to clear the last eight miles of right-of-way for the extension of the Esquimalt and Nanaimo Railway into Port Alberni, taking Charles A. Moorhead (later Lieutenant-Colonel Moorhead) into partnership. He organized the firm of Carmichael and Moorhead Limited to handle real estate and insurance. This G:\RSD\@ORCS09\13050.20\MS-2580.DOC:2000/01/07 Page 1
company placed the city of Port Alberni on the market. He also organized the Port Alberni Contract Company, which cleared the townsite and rough-graded the roads, and was the Managing Director of the Port Alberni Syndicate Limited. Carmichael married Kathleen Frances Withers on 7 April 1909. In 1911 and 1912 he visited England, and made reservations to return on the Titanic, but luckily because of some business in London he cancelled his passage and returned on the Cedric instead. From 1914 to 1923 Carmichael was Victoria manager of the Franco-Canadian Trust Company, Vancouver Island Fruit Lands Limited and Uplands Limited. He and associates had acquired 30,000 acres of Vancouver Island land which they sold at a profit of $3.00 an acre to the Franco-Canadian Company, but they had to accept part payment in Uplands shares. Then the company that sponsored that housing development folded and had to be taken over by the Franco-Canadian Trust Company, which had lent it shares. The firm of Carmichael and Company Limited was incorporated in 1923. In 1926 Carmichael formed a partnership with David Leeming (who later became mayor of Victoria) in organizing Oak Bay Lands Limited, Victoria Properties Limited and Exchange Building Limited. The Oak Bay Lands Limited bought 400 Oak Bay tax sale lots for $63,000 in 1926. Carmichael and Leeming sold $22,000 worth in two days by auction from a tent at the foot of Oak Bay Avenue, and paid over the money as part of the purchase price. Then came the 1929 slump and the lots lost their value. Oak Bay Municipality was taking possession of hundreds more lots and selling them in competition at lower prices. The company had to let its holdings go for taxes and the balance owing. Carmichael was the president of Victoria Rotary Club in 1929 and president of Victoria Real Estate Board in 1927, 1931 and 1932. In 1952, Carmichael retired because of a heart condition, leaving the real estate business of Alfred Carmichael and Company in the hands of his only surviving son, David. His eldest son, Brian, was lost while flying anti-submarine patrols in the Mediterranean during World War II, and his daughter was drowned in a yachting accident off Orcas Island in 1952. Mrs. Carmichael died in April 1953. Carmichael died on 30 January 1963 in Victoria at the age of 88. Records include the business records of Alfred Carmichael. The bulk of the unit consists of the records of the Oak Bay Lands Limited, including minutes of shareholders, Board of Directors and Annual General Meetings 1925-1936; a ledger listing various financial transactions 1925-1933; a deposit book 1925; Bank of Montreal payments 1925-1930; Land Registry Office notification of registration of titles 1925-1931; and sundry miscellaneous material such as indentures, correspondence, conveyances, prospectus, balance sheets, reports, bills, accounts, shareholders list, land titles etc. This unit also contains minutes of meetings 1909-1928, lists of directors 1909-1921, lists of shareholders 1909-1919, register of transfers 1909-1919 and a G:\RSD\@ORCS09\13050.20\MS-2580.DOC:2000/01/07 Page 2
stock ledger 1909-1919 of the Port Alberni Syndicate Limited and deposit account books of the Investors Syndicate Limited 1933-1936. Related records in: MS-2305, which contains correspondence, manuscripts, articles, speeches, research notes, diaries, narratives, financial papers and newspaper clippings of Alfred Carmichael 1890-1961; MS-2306, which is the typed manuscript of Indian Legends of Vancouver Island ; and MS-2307, which contains business records of various of Carmichael s companies 1914-1957. Box File Contents Date 1 1 Port Alberni Syndicate minutes 17 Dec 1909-13 Oct 1928 1 1 Port Alberni Syndicate - Director s lists 1909-1921 1 1 Port Alberni Syndicate - shareholder s lists 1909-1919 1 1 Port Alberni Syndicate - register of transfers 1909-1919 1 1 Port Alberni Syndicate - stock ledger 1909-1919 1 2 Oak Bay Lands - minutes of shareholders, directors and annual general meetings 12 Mar 1925-21 Jan 1936 1 3 Oak Bay Lands - ledger [lists various business 1925-1933 transactions] 1 4 Oak Bay Lands - lists of shareholders, allotments, 1925 transfers and directors 1 5 Oak Bay Lands - deposit book 31 Mar 1925-11 Sep 1925 1 6 Oak Bay Lands - Bank of Montreal payments to various businesses and people, numbers 1-204 17 Apr 1925-23 May 1928 1 6 Oak Bay Lands - Bank of Montreal payments to 28 Jun 1928-25 various businesses and people, numbers 1-56 1 7 Oak Bay Lands - Land Registry Office notifications of registration of titles 2 1 Oak Bay Lands - commission books of Alfred Carmichael and David Leeming, real estate agents [3 books, small, with few entries] 2 2 Oak Bay Lands - Corporation of the District of Oak Bay, tax lots for sale 2 3 Oak Bay Lands - handwritten pencil notes regarding lots 2 4 Oak Bay Lands - various drafts of agreements and indentures between Oak Bay Lands and the Corporation of the District of Oak Bay 2 5 Oak Bay Lands - indentures and agreements between Leeming Brothers, R.P. Clark and Company and Alfred Carmichael and Company 2 6 Oak Bay Lands - letter from solicitors enclosing the Apr 1930 12 Aug 1925-1 Aug 1931 Jun 1923 G:\RSD\@ORCS09\13050.20\MS-2580.DOC:2000/01/07 Page 3
shares of H.E. Sims and asking that they be made over to his widow [good examples of the company s share certificates] 2 7 Oak Bay Lands - correspondence from the 1930 Corporation of the District of Oak Bay regarding lots and taxes 2 8 Oak Bay Lands - conveyance of land from Oak Bay 1933 Lands to Thomas George Marcham 2 9 Oak Bay Lands - taxes on lots, (Alexander) purchased by H.B. Thomson; Alexander lots take over from Carmichael and Leeming, lots held under option from Oak Bay Lands 2 10 Agreement between Oak Bay Lands and William J. 17 Jul 1925 Adler regarding sale of land 2 10 Agreement between Oak Bay Lands and Alfred G. 17 Jul 1925 Carter regarding sale of land 2 10 Agreement between Oak Bay Lands and Edith 17 Jul 1925 Florence Cathels regarding sale of land 2 10 Agreement between Oak Bay Lands and Walter Cecil 17 Jul 1925 Clubb regarding sale of land 2 10 Agreement between Oak Bay Lands and Margaret 25 Oct 1925 Isabel Clark regarding sale of land 2 10 Agreement between Oak Bay Lands and Helen 17 Mar 1926 Jeffrey regarding sale of land 2 10 Agreement between Oak Bay Lands and George 17 Sep 1928 Lovitt regarding sale of land 2 10 Agreement between Oak Bay Lands and George 15 Oct 1928 Smith and Fanny Webb Robertson regarding sale of land 2 10 Agreement between Oak Bay Lands and Barbara E. 21 May 1929 Barber-Starkey regarding sale of land 2 10 Agreement between Oak Bay Lands and Merle B. 22 Oct 1929 and Millie E. MacDonald regarding sale of land 2 10 Agreement between Oak Bay Lands and Ernest 12 Feb 1930 Verne and Louise Wilson regarding sale of land 2 11 Oak Bay Lands - correspondence, agreements etc. with H.N. Olsen relating to his mortgage 2 12 Oak Bay Lands - prospectus 2 13 Oak Bay Lands - indentures, agreements between Oak Bay Lands and the Charles S. Austin Company 2 14 Oak Bay Lands - balance sheets 1926-1931, 1933, 1936 3 1 Oak Bay Lands - shareholders lists [handwritten] no date 3 2 Oak Bay Lands - list of firms having Oak Bay Lands price list G:\RSD\@ORCS09\13050.20\MS-2580.DOC:2000/01/07 Page 4
3 3 Oak Bay Lands - statutory report 16 May 1925 3 4 Oak Bay Lands - letter from Henry B. Norman 1 Mar 1935 3 5 Oak Bay Lands - lots for sale at auction 17 Jun 1925 3 6 Oak Bay Lands - assessment of lots 1926 3 7 Oak Bay Lands - schedules of lots with release prices over $201, and less than $201 3 8 Oak Bay Lands - bills, accounts etc. 3 9 Investors Syndicate - deposit account books with the Canadian Bank of Commerce (8 books) 2 Jun 1933-Feb 1936 G:\RSD\@ORCS09\13050.20\MS-2580.DOC:2000/01/07 Page 5