Staff Report to the Municipal Planning Board June 16, 2015 ABN2015-00001 Item #1 O HIO ST., MICHIGAN AVE. & PART OF H ARMON AVE. R-O-W ABANDONMENTS Location Map S UMMARY Applicant/Owner Debbie Carey, Administrator Calvary Assembly of God Project Planner Jim Burnett, AICP Updated: June 4, 2015 Property Location: South side of Minnesota Ave. and west side of Clay St., all east of Interstate 4 and all owned by Calvary Assembly of God of Orlando (±1.6 acres, District 3) Applicant s Request: The applicant proposes to abandon Ohio St. (between Minnesota and Michigan Aves.), a portion of Michigan Ave. (between Ohio St. and Clay St.) and a portion of Harmon Ave. between the Calvary Assembly of God property and a vacant separately-owned lot, all within the North Orange neighborhood. Staff Recommendation: Approval of the Abandonment request, subject to conditions Abandonments in this staff report. Public Comment: Courtesy notices were mailed to property owners within 300 ft. of the subject property the week of June 1, 2015. As of the mail-out of the staff report, staff has received no comments from the public relative to the abandonment request.
Page 2 ABN2015-00001 Ohio, Michigan and Part of Harmon Abandonments FUTURE LAND USE MAP WINTER PARK Z ONING MAP UNINCORPORATED ORANGE COUNTY UNINCORPORATED ORANGE COUNTY UNINCORPORATED ORANGE COUNTY WINTER PARK SUBJECT ABANDONMENTS UNINCORPORATED ORANGE COUNTY SUBJECT ABANDONMENTS
Page 3 ABN2015-00001 Ohio, Michigan and Part of Harmon Abandonments P ROJECT ANALYSIS Project Description The applicant is requesting to abandon three (3) existing roadway segments, all located adjacent to Calvary Assembly of God and within the North Orange neighborhood. The street segments to be abandoned are as follows: A. Ohio St. (between Minnesota and Michigan Aves.); B. A portion of Michigan Ave. (between Ohio St. and Clay St.); and C. That part of Harmon Ave. (between the Calvary Assembly of God property and a separately owned lot, west of Clay St.). Previous Actions 1922: Southerly half of Harmon Ave., between Clay St. and Formosa Ave., platted as Fairbanks Ave. as part of The Pines Subdivision 1923: Ohio St., Michigan Ave. and the northerly half of Harmon Ave. platted as part of Lawndale Subdivision. 1952: Street name of southerly half of Fairbanks Ave. changed to Harmon Ave. 1953: Calvary Assembly of God established in two (2) former residential structures (demolished when I-4 constructed). 1984: Portion of Lawndale and The Pines Subdivisions, including subject portions of Ohio St., Michigan and Harmon Aves., vacated by Orange County Commission. 2002: Calvary Assembly of God properties annexed into City of Orlando (ANX2002-00019, City Doc. #020805910); Public- Recreation-Institutional future land use assigned (GMP2002-00073). 2012: Initial zoning of PD/T (Planned Development, Traditional City Overlay) assigned to property (ZON2009-00025, Doc. #1201091203). Adjacent uses, zoning and future land use designations are shown in Table 1 below. Direction Future Land Use Zoning Adjacent Uses North Public-Recreation-Institutional PD (Calvary Assembly of God Planned Church Parking Lots (PUB-REC-INST) Development) South PUB-REC-INST PD Church Parking, Church Buildings & Vacant Land East (across Clay St.) Orange County Low-Medium Density Residential T ABLE 1 - PROJECT CONTEXT County R-2 Context & Analysis The affected street segments are provided in Table 2 at right. Michigan Ave. continues east of Clay St., and Harmon Ave. continues east to provide access to a vacant non-church owned property. Post abandonment, the Ohio St. and Michigan Ave. R-O-Ws will likely be retained as access drives for the Church and a rear access to Calvary Towers (@ 1876 Minnesota Ave.). Single-Family Homes & Churches West PUB-REC-INST PD Church Parking Lots TABLE 2 - STREET SEGMENTS Street Ohio St. Michigan Ave. Area (dimensions) 0.32 ac. (50 ft. (w) x 280 ft. (lg.)) 0.75 ac. (50 ft. (w) x 660 ft. (lg.)) (includes a 0.52 ac. access easement) Adjacent & Proposed Development Harmon Ave. 0.23 ac. (50 ft. (w) x 200 ft. (lg.)) The subject R-O-Ws abut other Calvary Assembly of God properties that Total 1.3 acres are already developed with church-related uses and surface parking lots. Adjacent uses will not be impacted by the proposed abandonments. No known utility lines are located in the subject R-O-W segments but if any exist, it will be the responsibility of the applicant to work with the utility provider to ensure either relocation or recording of utility easements. Abandonment Process The abandonment process (Section 65.506 of the Land Development Code) requires the consent of all adjacent and abutting property owners. Calvary Assembly of God owns all of the properties adjacent to and abutting the proposed abandonments. Section 65.505 of the Land Development Code notes that two (2) factors must be considered in the review and approval of abandonment requests: A. Adequate Public Facilities: The abandonment cannot result in a higher demand on public facilities and services. In this case, three (3) street segments are being abandoned (see Table 2 above). The abandonment request in and of itself
Page 4 ABN2015-00001 Ohio, Michigan and Part of Harmon Abandonments will not create a higher demand on public facilities and services. B. Cost for Improvements: The cost for the abandonment of any right-of-way shall be paid by the applicant or developer of the proposed project, including cost of improvements to adjacent rights-of-way or relocation of utilities within existing easements. The applicant is covering all costs involved with the abandonment request, including costs to relocate existing utilities prior to future roadway removal. School Impacts - (Not applicable, since the existing and future uses will be non-residential and institutional in nature.) UNINCORPORATED ORANGE COUNTY WINTER PARK UN TY From Calvary Assembly property, looking east on Harmon Ave. towards Clay St. UN CO SITE PHOTO GE AN OR UNINCORPORATED ORANGE COUNTY ED AT OR RP CO IN SUBJECT ABANDONMENTS AERIAL PHOTO
Page 5 ABN2015-00001 Ohio, Michigan and Part of Harmon O VERALL SITE PLAN ( PER ZON2009-00025, 1/19/2010) S ITE PHOTOS OHIO ST. MINNESOTA AVE. MICHIGAN AVE. Ohio St., looking south from Minnesota Ave. ABANDONMENT REQUESTS CLAY ST. HARMON AVE. Michigan Ave., looking east towards Clay St. (church on the right). Harmon Ave., looking west from Clay St. Only a 200-ft. portion is requested for abandonment. PAR ST.
Page 6 ABN2015-00001 Ohio, Michigan and Part of Harmon 2015 SKETCHES OF DESCRIPTIONS (ALSO INCLUDES A 450-FT. LONG ACCESS EASEMENT WITHIN THE R-O-W) THIS LOT IS STILL IN PRIVATE OWNERSHIP (NOT CHURCH OWNED)
Page 7 ABN2015-00001 Ohio, Michigan and Part of Harmon F INDINGS Subject to the conditions contained herein, the Abandonment proposal is consistent with the requirements for approval of Abandonment applications contained in Section 65 Part 4E of the Land Development Code (LDC): 1. The proposed Abandonments are consistent with the purpose and intent of the City s Growth Management Plan. 2. The proposed Abandonments are consistent with the requirements of the Land Development Code. 3. The Abandonments will not result in incompatible land uses. 4. All future development will be in accordance with Chapter 59 of the LDC, the Concurrency Management Ordinance, which ensures that adequate public facilities are available to serve said development. Based on the information provided in the staff report and the findings noted above, staff recommends approval of the Ohio St., Michigan Ave. (west of Clay St.) and partial Harmon Ave. R-O-W Abandonments, subject to the conditions in this staff report. C ONDITIONS OF APPROVAL - REQUIRED Land Development 1. The abandonments as proposed in this report and subsequent ordinance shall take effect prior to the property being replatted and recorded. 2. Except as provided herein, the proposed Abandonment request is subject to all codes and ordinances of the State of Florida, City of Orlando, and all other applicable State and federal regulatory agencies. 3. Continued development/redevelopment of the site shall be consistent with the Calvary PD (ZON2009-00025, City Doc. #1201091203). Transportation Planning & Engineering 1. Easement Dedication - An ingress/egress easement within a portion of Michigan Ave. abutting the Calvary Towers parcel shall be fully executed and recorded within one (1) calendar year of City Council approval of the abandonment case. 2. Road Maintenance - All responsibility for maintenance of the roadway and sidewalks shall be assumed by the applicant/ owner. This requirement may be terminated if the property is redeveloped as something other than its current public benefit or residential use. 3. R-O-W Dedication - To ensure future access and higher functioning roadways, the applicant/owner shall provide an equivalent amount of R-O-W on both Minnesota Ave. and Clay St. adjacent to the Church properties, in exchange and in consideration for the R-O-Ws being requested for abandonment. This will ensure that sufficient R-O-W exists when the City deems it necessary to expand and/or improve both vehicle and pedestrian movements on Minnesota Ave. and Clay St. 4. Emergency Access to all buildings shall be maintained. At the time of permitting for new structures or as part of a potential redevelopment of the property, both the City's Solid Waste and Orlando Fire Departments must approve of all access areas for maneuverability. 5. Signage, et al - Additional measures shall be provided to alert drivers and pedestrians of the proposed abandonments. CONTACT INFORMATION Land Development Contact Jim Burnett at 407-246-3609 or at james.burnett@cityoforlando.net. Transportation Planning Contact John Rhoades at 407-246-2293 or at john.rhoades@cityoforlando.net. Transportation Engineering Contact Lauren Torres at 407-246-3220 or at lauren.torres@cityoforlando.net. R EVIEW/APPROVAL PROCESS-NEXT STEPS 1. Following the MPB meeting, the MPB minutes will be reviewed and approved by the City Council on July 27, 2015. 2. Following the MPB meeting, staff will provide the abandonment request information to the City Attorney s Office for preparation of an ordinance. The project planner will schedule said ordinance and exhibits for two (2) readings before the City Council. The 2nd reading will be a public hearing.