The use of greenfield and brownfield land in Greenbelt housing & commercial projects

The use of greenfield and brownfield land in Greenbelt housing & commercial projects Including applications & approvals for full year 2017/18 PREPARED FOR: Campaign for the Protection of Rural England Date: May 2018

Contents Introducing Glenigan... 2 Background... 3 Main Findings... 5 Residential... 6 Applications... 6 Planning Decisions... 8 Completions... 12 Commercial & Industrial... 14 Applications... 14 Planning Decisions... 15 Completions... 16 Tables Table 1: Residential planning applications by type of site... 8 Table 2: Residential planning approvals by type of site... 8 Table 3: Residential planning applications by type of site and planning outcome... 9 Table 4: Proportion of residential applications approved, refused and withdrawn by type of site and year of application... 9 Table 5: Residential units on planning applications by type of site and planning outcome... 10 Table 6: Proportion of residential applications approved, refused and withdrawn by type of site and year of application... 11 Table 7: Residential units on approved planning applications by type of site... 11 Table 8: Residential Projects Completed by type of site... 12 Table 9: Residential units on completed projects by type of site... 13 Table 10: Commercial & Industrial planning approvals by type of site... 15 Table 11: Commercial & Industrial planning applications by type of site and planning outcome... 15 Table 12: Proportion of commercial & industrial applications approved, refused and withdrawn by type of site and year of application... 16 Table 13: Commercial & Industrial Projects Completed by type of site... 16 Charts Chart 1: English Greenbelt Areas... 3 Chart 2: Residential planning applications in the Greenbelt by type of site... 6 Chart 3: Number of residential units on Greenbelt applications by type of site... 7 Chart 4: Commercial and industrial planning applications in the Greenbelt by type of site... 14 1

Introducing Glenigan Established in 1973, Glenigan currently invests over 3million and makes over a million research telephone calls per year to provide details on every construction project in the UK. This enables us to provide the most up-to-date and comprehensive construction sales leads and analysis, to help companies win new business. We also have exclusive partnerships with key industry associations such as the Builders' Conference, Considerate Constructors Scheme and the Building Research Establishment (BRE), enabling us to offer project data that s not available elsewhere in the market. Glenigan s detailed insight is used across all levels of our customers businesses. Different departments have much to gain from using our industry knowledge and product features to deliver results for their specific job role. Further information For further information, visit glenigan.com or contact us on the details below. Phone +44 (0)1202 786700 info@glenigan.com 5th Floor, 80 Holdenhurst Road Bournemouth BH8 8AQ Subscription Sales Account Management Phone 0800 373 771 Phone 0870 443 5373 info@glenigan.com customer@glenigan.com Glenigan May 2018. This report is copyrighted. Information contained herein should not, in whole or part, be published, reproduced or referred to without prior approval. Users may download and print extracts of content from this report for their own personal and noncommercial use only. Brief excerpts may be used, provided full accreditation is given to Glenigan. Republication or redistribution of Glenigan content is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Glenigan. Disclaimer: This report is for general information purposes only. It should not be relied upon as a basis for entering into transactions without seeking specific, qualified, professional advice. While facts have been rigorously checked, Glenigan can take no responsibility for any damage or loss suffered as a result of any inadvertent inaccuracy within this report 2

Background This report provides data and analysis of the pattern of development in the English Greenbelt since 2009. The analysis covers planning applications for residential and large industrial & commercial new build projects in the Greenbelt and analyses the number and success rate of such applications over the nine financial years from 2009/10 to 2017/18. The analysis is based upon residential and non-residential planning applications and projects tracked and researched by Glenigan. In addition, Glenigan undertook primary research of all housing and large industrial and commercial projects sited in the Greenbelt. The primary research covered: Projects where detailed planning approval/ approval of reserved matters had been sought or secured between April 2009 and March 2018 Large commercial, industrial and residential projects (of 10 or more units) where construction had been completed between April 2009 and March 2018 Chart 1: English Greenbelt Areas The report provides an analysis of the number and proportion of the housing applications, together with the number of associated residential units to be submitted for detailed planning approval during each of the nine financial years from 2009/10 to 2017/18. The analysis also 3

covers the outcome of the application (approved, refused or withdrawn) and includes a breakdown of applications planning outcomes split by brownfield and greenfield sites. The report also examines the number of new housing projects and related units, together with the number of large industrial and commercial projects within the Greenbelt, which have been constructed during the period under examination and their distribution between greenfield and brownfield sites. 4

Main Findings The number of projects being built on the Greenbelt in England continues to increase. On average 206, residential, commercial & industrial projects were completed annually in the Greenbelt between 2014/15 and 2017/18 compared to 140 projects per annum during the preceding four years. The rise is largely due to an increase in residential projects. The number of new homes on projects completed annually has risen sharply over the period from just 70 units in 2009/10 to 8,143 units in 2017/18. Since 2015/16, the total number of residential units completed on the Greenbelt has more than doubled. Residential planning applications and planning approvals have also grown progressively for much of the period, pointing to further growth in the number of new homes being built in the Greenbelt over the next few years. Whilst brownfield sites continue to account for the majority of planning applications, there has been an increase in the number of greenfield sites being proposed for development. In addition, the average size of greenfield sites is larger than for brownfield applications. Between April 2009 and March 2018, 58% of the residential units to be approved in the English Greenbelt were on land identified as brownfield, while 37% of units approved were on greenfield land and the balance on sites that were a combination of greenfield and brownfield. Although across the nine years of the study, on average 58% of units approved were on land classified as brownfield, but there has been a substantial shift towards the proportion of units being approved for greenfield sites during this time. In the first year of the study, the proportion of residential units approved on greenfield land was 22%. In the last financial year covered by the study (2017/18), 53% of units approved were on land classified as greenfield and 47% as brownfield. The number of residential units reaching completion on the greenbelt in 2017/18 was the largest for the past nine years after rises in each of the last two years. There has, however, also been consistent rises in the number of units reaching completion on brownfield units in each of the last nine years. Just 22% of residential projects reaching completion in the Greenbelt over the period of the study were on greenfield sites compared to 77% of projects on brownfield land. The balance of projects were built on sites that were a combination of greenfield and brownfield. In 2017/18, 74% of completed projects were on land classified as brownfield. Over the period of the study, 80% of commercial projects approved within the Greenbelt were on brownfield land, while 19% of approved commercial schemes were on greenfield land. The balance were on land classified as a combination of greenfield and brownfield. The breakdown of commercial sites to reach completion during the period was similarly split with 80% of completions being on brownfield sites and 19% on greenfield locations. 5

Number of Applications Residential Applications The number of applications for residential developments in the Greenbelt has risen progressively over the last nine years. There were 1,961 residential planning applications submitted between April 2009 and March 2018. Of these, 1,382 projects (70%) were for developments on brownfield sites, 536 applications (27%) were on greenfield sites and 43 applications (3%) were identified as being for brownfield/greenfield sites. Chart 2: Residential planning applications in the Greenbelt by type of site 400 Residential Applications 350 300 250 200 150 100 50-2009/2010 2010/2011 2011/2012 2012/2013 2013/2014 2014/2015 2015/2016 2016/2017 2017/2018 There has been a sustained rise in the number of Greenbelt residential planning applications in England during the period, from 96 applications in 2009/2010 to 351 in 2017/18. During the period under review, the proportion of Greenbelt residential planning applications on greenfield and brownfield sites has remained relatively stable. The proportion of residential applications on brownfield sites rose from 71% in 2009/10 to 78% in 2010/11 and 2011/12, before gradually declining over the rest of the period to 67% in 2015/16 and 65% in 2016/17 then rising to a five year high of 73% in 2017/18. The number of residential units proposed in the Greenbelt applications during the period under review has been more volatile. Applications submitted in 2009/10 contained proposals for 16,050 residential units. The number of units in residential applications then fell to 7,219 in 2010/11, but began to rise sharply with a rise of more than 300% over the next three years. By 2013/14, plans to build 30,115 residential units on the greenbelt had been submitted. In 2013/14, the number of residential units in planning applications submitted was more than double the previous year. This would appear to be linked to the publication of the National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF). 6

Number of Units At the end of 2010, the government announced a review of planning policy and there was a significant drop-off of in units proposed in 2010 and only a 14% year-on-year increase in 2011/12. Even then, the total number of units included in applications was 515 smaller than the figure for the last full financial year before the planning review was announced. The final version of the NPPF was published in March 2012 in the 2012/13 financial year, the number of residential units proposed on the Greenbelt rose by 71% compared to the previous year and then more than doubled in 2013/14. After a lull in 2014/15 and 2015/16, when the number of units proposed fell back there was another sharp increase in 2016/17, when plans for 41,822 units were included in planning applications on the greenbelt. Units proposed on the greenbelt fell back by 9% in 2017/18 to 38,304, but this total is still more than double the level of homes proposed in the first year of the study in 2009/10. Over the full nine years, 206,3852 units have been included in planning applications on the greenbelt. Chart 3: Number of residential units on Greenbelt applications by type of site 45,000 Residential Unit Applications 40,000 35,000 30,000 25,000 20,000 15,000 10,000 5,000 0 2009/2010 2010/2011 2011/2012 2012/2013 2013/2014 2014/2015 2015/2016 2016/2017 2017/2018 The distribution of units across greenfield and brownfield site applications has similarly been volatile. Over the period as a whole 53% of units were on applications for brownfield site developments, with 39% for greenfield sites and 8% for mixed sites. Applications for greenfield sites accounted for a disproportionate number of units, indicating that the average size of greenfield applications is larger than for brownfield sites. Brownfield site applications accounted for a shrinking proportion of units over the period under analysis; falling from 78% in 2009/10 to 49% in 2012/13. Having risen during 2014/15 and 2015/16, the contribution of brownfield sites slipped back to 42% of residential units in 2016/17 before rebounding to 48% in 2017/18. 7

Table 1: Residential planning applications by type of site Year Applications Units Applications Units Applications Units 2009/2010 68 12,578 1 19 27 3,453 2010/2011 105 4,730 1 76 28 2,413 2011/2012 101 5,135 2 221 27 2,885 2012/2013 121 6,900 1 9 42 7,203 2013/2014 159 14,699 9 4,944 61 10,472 2014/2015 172 13,909 8 4,543 70 6,947 2015/2016 180 14,705 7 2,727 82 8,158 2016/2017 220 17,605 9 727 109 23,490 2017/2018 256 18,527 5 3,049 90 16,728 Planning Decisions Of the 1,961 residential applications submitted since April 2009, 603 (31%) are still awaiting a planning decision. The vast majority of these applications were submitted during the last two financial years. Indeed 235 out of the 351 applications submitted during 2017/18 are still undecided. The analysis below excludes those projects that are still awaiting a planning decision in order to analyse the relative success rate of planning applications on greenfield and brownfield sites within the Greenbelt. Projects where the planning application has been withdrawn are included. Table 2: Residential planning approvals by type of site Total Year Number Proportion Number Proportion Number Proportion Number 2009/2010 51 84% 0 0% 10 16% 61 2010/2011 70 81% 0 0% 16 19% 86 2011/2012 73 78% 2 2% 19 20% 94 2012/2013 88 79% 1 1% 22 20% 111 2013/2014 105 76% 0 0% 33 24% 138 2014/2015 109 78% 4 3% 26 19% 139 2015/2016 92 71% 5 4% 33 25% 130 2016/2017 41 73% 1 2% 14 25% 56 2017/2018 45 78% 0 0% 13 22% 58 Total: 674 77% 13 1% 186 21% 873 Of the 1,358 applications made since April 2009 that have either been subject to a planning decision or withdrawn, 985 were applications for residential projects on brownfield sites. There were 350 applications for greenfield sites and 23 applications were classified as brownfield/greenfield over the period of the study. At total of 873 residential planning applications were granted during the period, an overall approval rate of 64%. Of these 674 (77% of approvals) were granted for brownfield sites, 186 (21%) for greenfield sites and 13 (2%) on mixed greenfield/ brownfield sites. 8

Table 3: Residential planning applications by type of site and planning outcome Year Granted Refused Withdrawn Granted Refused Withdrawn Granted Refused Withdrawn 2009/2010 51 11 5 0 1 0 10 12 4 2010/2011 70 23 8 0 0 1 16 8 4 2011/2012 73 16 8 2 0 0 19 6 1 2012/2013 88 21 10 1 0 0 22 16 2 2013/2014 105 32 13 0 5 1 33 17 5 2014/2015 109 34 16 4 2 0 26 26 10 2015/2016 92 25 11 5 0 0 33 19 6 2016/2017 41 24 10 1 0 0 14 11 3 2017/2018 45 34 10 0 0 0 13 8 6 Total: 674 220 91 13 8 2 186 123 41 The high proportion of approvals granted for brownfield sites reflects the greater number of planning applications (73% of applications) for such sites and a higher success rate for such applications. Table 4: Proportion of residential applications approved, refused and withdrawn by type of site and year of application Year Granted Refused Withdrawn Granted Refused Withdrawn Granted Refused Withdrawn 2009/2010 76% 16% 7% 0% 100% 0% 38% 46% 15% 2010/2011 69% 23% 8% 0% 0% 100% 57% 29% 14% 2011/2012 75% 16% 8% 100% 0% 0% 73% 23% 4% 2012/2013 74% 18% 8% 100% 0% 0% 55% 40% 5% 2013/2014 70% 21% 9% 0% 83% 17% 60% 31% 9% 2014/2015 69% 21% 10% 67% 33% 0% 42% 42% 16% 2015/2016 72% 20% 9% 100% 0% 0% 57% 33% 10% 2016/2017 55% 32% 13% 100% 0% 0% 50% 39% 11% 2017/2018 51% 38% 11% 48% 30% 22% Total: 68% 22% 9% 57% 35% 9% 53% 35% 12% In the first half of the study, the approval rate of brownfield planning applications consistently ran at around 70% and was as high as 78% in 2010/11 and 2011/12. Between 2013/14 and 2016/17, this approval rate declined and dropped to 55% in 2016/17. The low success rate in 2016/17 appears to be due to the low proportion of applications made during the period that have yet to reach a planning outcome: 70% of residential applications on brownfield sites made in 2016/17 were undecided. Similarly, the success rate for applications made in 2017/18 was 51% as decisions, but in the final year of the study 67% of overall residential applications were undecided. It appears that decision to refuse or withdraw an application is typically made more quickly than an application s approval. 9

Of those projects refused over the course of the study, 22% of brownfield applications were rejected, while 35% of proposals for residential development on land classified solely as greenfield were rejected. Just 9% of applications for residential projects on brownfield land were withdrawn, but 12% of applications for residential projects on greenfield were withdrawn. The 1,358 planning applications made since April 2009 that were either subject to a planning decision or withdrawn included the potential creation of 102,111 residential units. Of these, 62,022 units (61%) were on brownfield sites, 36,518 units (36%) on greenfield sites and 3,571 residential units (3%) were on sites classified as brownfield/greenfield. Table 5: Residential units on planning applications by type of site and planning outcome Year Granted Refused Withdrawn Granted Refused Withdrawn Granted Refused Withdrawn 2009/2010 2,676 337 9,537 0 19 0 733 1,483 1,096 2010/2011 3,258 338 568 0 0 76 1,899 396 118 2011/2012 4,343 350 88 221 0 0 2,261 411 10 2012/2013 5,204 1,106 568 9 0 0 2,001 1,847 55 2013/2014 8,348 2,252 359 0 360 31 6,995 1,868 290 2014/2015 5,801 3,786 353 127 145 0 2,944 1,153 390 2015/2016 4,694 1,307 144 2,579 0 0 3,416 1,113 377 2016/2017 1,755 796 621 4 0 0 1,715 473 228 2017/2018 1,860 1,308 265 0 0 0 2,117 925 204 Total: 37,939 11,580 12,503 2,940 524 107 24,081 9,669 2,768 In percentage terms, 19% of units proposed on brownfield sites were rejected, but 26% of units on greenfield sites were rejected. On sites classified as brownfield/greenfield 15% of units in applications were rejected. However, the lower rejection rate for brownfield sites appears to relate to a higher propensity for applications to be withdrawn rather than a higher approval rate. Again in percentage terms, 20% of units in applications on brownfield sites were withdrawn, but only 8% of units in applications on greenfield land were withdrawn. On sites classified as brownfield/greenfield, just 3% of units were withdrawn. 10

Table 6: Proportion of residential units on applications approved, refused and withdrawn by type of site and year of application Year Granted Refused Withdrawn Granted Refused Withdrawn Granted Refused Withdrawn 2009/2010 21% 3% 76% 0% 100% 0% 22% 45% 33% 2010/2011 78% 8% 14% 0% 0% 100% 79% 16% 5% 2011/2012 91% 7% 2% 100% 0% 0% 84% 15% 0% 2012/2013 76% 16% 8% 100% 0% 0% 51% 47% 1% 2013/2014 76% 21% 3% 0% 92% 8% 76% 20% 3% 2014/2015 58% 38% 4% 47% 53% 0% 66% 26% 9% 2015/2016 76% 21% 2% 100% 0% 0% 70% 23% 8% 2016/2017 55% 25% 20% 100% 0% 0% 71% 20% 9% 2017/2018 54% 38% 8% - - - 65% 28% 6% Total: 61% 19% 20% 82% 15% 3% 66% 26% 8% Between April 2009 and March 2018, planning permission was granted for a total of 64,960 residential units. Of these 37,939 units (58%) were on brownfield sites, 24,081 units (37%) were on greenfield sites and 2,940 units (5%) were on mixed sites. The high proportion of units on approved projects that are for greenfield locations compared to the number of applications (37% of units against 21% of planning applications), indicates that average size of greenfield projects in the Greenbelt that secure planning approval is greater than for brownfield sites. The average size of greenfield residential projects securing planning approval during the period was 129 units, compared to 56 units on brownfield sites. The average size of mixed sites with both greenfield and brownfield land was 226 units. Table 7: Residential units on approved planning applications by type of site Total Year Number Proportion Number Proportion Number Proportion Number 2009/2010 2,676 78% - 0% 733 22% 3,409 2010/2011 3,258 63% - 0% 1,899 37% 5,157 2011/2012 4,343 64% 221 3% 2,261 33% 6,825 2012/2013 5,204 72% 9 0% 2,001 28% 7,214 2013/2014 8,348 54% - 0% 6,995 46% 15,343 2014/2015 5,801 65% 127 1% 2,944 33% 8,872 2015/2016 4,694 44% 2,579 24% 3,416 32% 10,689 2016/2017 1,755 51% 4 0% 1,715 49% 3,474 2017/2018 1,860 47% - 0% 2,117 53% 3,977 Total: 37,939 58% 2,940 5% 24,081 37% 64,960 11

Completions Over the course of the period under study, 22% of residential projects reaching completion in England were on greenfield sites compared to 77% of projects on brownfield land. The balance of projects that were completed were on sites classified as a combination of greenfield and brownfield. Table 8: Residential Projects Completed by type of site Brownfield Brownfield/ Greenfield Greenfield Total Year Number Proportion Number Proportion Number Proportion Number 2009/2010 2 100% - 0% - 0% 2 2010/2011 10 77% - 0% 3 23% 13 2011/2012 17 81% - 0% 4 19% 21 2012/2013 42 86% - 0% 7 14% 49 2013/2014 60 78% - 0% 17 22% 77 2014/2015 63 72% 3 3% 21 24% 84 2015/2016 55 85% - 0% 10 15% 65 2016/2017 58 74% 2 3% 18 23% 76 2017/2018 76 74% - 0% 27 26% 103 Total: 383 77% 5 1% 107 22% 490 The number of projects being built in the Greenbelt has increased progressively over the last nine years: More residential projects reached completion in 2017/18, than any of the preceding eight full years. The total number of projects completed in the most recent year was also greater than for the first four years of the study combined. The vast majority of projects completed continue to be on brownfield sites. During 2017/18, 76 brownfield sites were completed, this represents 77% of sites completed during the year and compares to 58 brownfield sites completed during the previous financial year. However, the number of greenfield sites being built has also been rising progressively, albeit from a lower base. At 27 sites, the number of residential projects completed on greenfield sites during 2017/18 was also the largest over the course of the study and was up by 50% on the total for the previous year. Again, this latest total was greater than that recorded in the first four years of the study. The residential projects completed in the Greenbelt since 2009/10 have created 24,154 new homes. Of these, 68% of were built on brownfield land and 31% on greenfield land. The balance of units were built on sites that were a combination of greenfield and brownfield. 12

Table 9: Residential units on completed projects by type of site Brownfield Brownfield/ Greenfield Greenfield Total Year Number Proportion Number Proportion Number Proportion Number 2009/2010 70 100% - 0% - 0% 70 2010/2011 203 45% - 0% 253 55% 457 2011/2012 302 85% - 0% 53 15% 355 2012/2013 886 60% - 0% 597 40% 1,483 2013/2014 1,323 63% - 0% 774 37% 2,097 2014/2015 2,238 61% 230 6% 1,183 32% 3,421 2015/2016 3,368 87% - 0% 518 13% 3,886 2016/2017 3,381 79% 23 1% 862 20% 4,243 2017/2018 4,756 58% - 0% 3,387 42% 8,143 Total: 16,527 68% 253 1% 7,627 31% 24,154 The number of residential units on completed Greenbelt projects has expanded sharply since 2009/10, from just 70 units in the first year to 8,143 in 2017/18. Indeed, the rising trend accelerated in the most recent year, with the number of completed units virtually doubled that seen in 2016/17. Until 2016/17, brownfield was the principal engine for growth. This growth continued into the most recent year, but was accompanied by a major upswing in homes completed on greenfield sites. The number of units on completed greenfield sites has also increased, with 2012/13 appearing to mark a step change, as it does for units on completed brownfield sites. In only two of the eight financial years of the study did any units reach completion on sites classified as a combination of brownfield and greenfield. 13

Number of Applications Commercial & Industrial Applications The number of applications for commercial & industrial developments in the Greenbelt has been on a rising trend for much of the last nine years, although the increase has not been as sharp as for residential planning applications and applications fell back during 2017/18. Chart 4: Commercial and industrial planning applications in the Greenbelt by type of site 300 250 200 150 100 50-2009/2010 2010/2011 2011/2012 2012/2013 2013/2014 2014/2015 2015/2016 2016/2017 There were 2,311 commercial & industrial planning applications submitted between April 2009 and March 2018. Of these, 1,806 projects (78%) were for developments on brownfield sites, 477 applications (21%) were on greenfield sites and 28 applications (1%) were identified as being for mixed brownfield and greenfield sites. There has been a gradual rise in the number of Greenbelt commercial & industrial planning applications during the period, from 195 applications in 2009/2010 to 288 in 2016/17. The number of commercial & industrial applications increased sharply during the last financial year (2017/18), rising by 26% to dropping to 363 projects. Whilst the overall number of applications has been increasing during the period under review, the proportion of Greenbelt commercial & industrial planning applications for greenfield and brownfield sites has remained relatively stable. The proportion of applications on brownfield sites has fluctuated between 76% (2012/14 and 2015/16) and 84% (2011/12). In the last financial year (2017/18) this ratio dropped back to 76%. The number of applications on greenfield sites has fluctuated between 16% (2011/12) and 23% (2015/16), but dropped back to 18% in 2016/17. In the last financial year, the proportion of commercial & industrial planning applications on greenfield sites rebounded to 23%. 14

Planning Decisions Of the 2,076 commercial & industrial applications submitted since April 2009, 235 (11%) are still awaiting a planning decision. The vast majority of these applications were submitted during 2016/17 and 2017/17. Indeed 151 out of the 212 applications submitted during 2017/18 were still undecided. The analysis below excludes those projects that are still awaiting a planning decision in order to analyse the relative success rate of planning applications on greenfield and brownfield sites within the Greenbelt. Projects where the planning application has been withdrawn are included. Table 10: Commercial & Industrial planning approvals by type of site Total Year Number Proportion Number Proportion Number Proportion Number 2009/2010 118 80% 3 2% 26 18% 147 2010/2011 138 79% 1 1% 35 20% 174 2011/2012 162 85% - 0% 29 15% 191 2012/2013 170 79% 2 1% 44 20% 216 2013/2014 165 82% 3 1% 33 16% 201 2014/2015 161 77% 3 1% 44 21% 208 2015/2016 158 76% 3 1% 47 23% 208 2016/2017 175 83% 5 2% 30 14% 210 2017/2018 151 79% - 0% 40 21% 191 Total: 1,398 80% 20 1% 328 19% 1,746 Over the course of the period under review, 1,398 (80%) of commercial & industrial projects approved were on brownfield land out of a total of 1,746 approvals, while just 328 projects (19%) were on greenfield land. Table 11: Commercial & Industrial planning applications by type of site and planning outcome Year Granted Refused Withdrawn Granted Refused Withdrawn Granted Refused Withdrawn 2009/2010 118 16 16 3 1 0 26 5 6 2010/2011 138 14 6 1 0 0 35 5 4 2011/2012 162 18 22 0 1 0 29 5 2 2012/2013 170 10 13 2 0 1 44 6 7 2013/2014 165 13 11 3 0 0 33 4 7 2014/2015 161 18 12 3 0 0 44 5 2 2015/2016 158 18 12 3 0 0 47 5 2 2016/2017 175 21 8 5 0 1 30 9 3 2017/2018 151 11 4 0 0 0 40 5 1 Total: 1,398 139 104 20 2 2 328 49 34 15

The proportion of commercial & industrial applications on brownfield sites securing planning consent has been higher than for greenfield applications over the period under review with 85% of brownfield applications approved during the period compared to 80% of applications for greenfield sites (excluding applications where a decision is still pending). The approval rate for mixed greenfield/brownfield sites was 83%. Table 12: Proportion of commercial & industrial applications approved, refused and withdrawn by type of site and year of application Year Granted Refused Withdrawn Granted Refused Withdrawn Granted Refused Withdrawn 2009/2010 79% 11% 11% 75% 25% 0% 70% 14% 16% 2010/2011 87% 9% 4% 100% 0% 0% 80% 11% 9% 2011/2012 80% 9% 11% 0% 100% 0% 81% 14% 6% 2012/2013 88% 5% 7% 67% 0% 33% 77% 11% 12% 2013/2014 87% 7% 6% 100% 0% 0% 75% 9% 16% 2014/2015 84% 9% 6% 100% 0% 0% 86% 10% 4% 2015/2016 84% 10% 6% 100% 0% 0% 87% 9% 4% 2016/2017 86% 10% 4% 83% 0% 17% 71% 21% 7% 2017/2018 91% 7% 2% - - - 87% 11% 2% Total: 85% 8% 6% 83% 8% 8% 80% 12% 8% Completions Over the course of the period under study, 19% of commercial & industrial projects reaching completion in England were on greenfield sites compared to 80% of projects on brownfield land. The balance of projects that were completed were on sites classified as a combination of greenfield and brownfield. Table 13: Commercial & Industrial Projects Completed by type of site Total Year Number Proportion Number Proportion Number Proportion Number 2009/2010 5 100% - 0% - 0% 5 2010/2011 37 79% 1 2% 9 19% 46 2011/2012 75 83% 1 1% 14 16% 89 2012/2013 105 86% - 0% 17 14% 122 2013/2014 112 79% 1 1% 28 20% 140 2014/2015 103 84% - 0% 20 16% 123 2015/2016 80 77% - 0% 24 23% 104 2016/2017 79 76% 3 3% 22 21% 101 2017/2018 125 78% 1 1% 34 21% 159 Total: 721 80% 7 1% 168 19% 889 16

The number of commercial schemes to reach completion on greenfield sites has fluctuated since 2013/14, but commercial projects reaching completion on brownfield were on a clear downward trend from 2013/14 to 2016/17, when there was a drop of 20%. However, the most recent year brought a resurgence and the highest number of commercial & industrial sites on both brownfield and greenfield land were completed in the entire duration of the study. Just seven commercial projects reached completion on sites with a mixture of brownfield and greenfield land. 17