FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Regular Meeting Agenda Thursday, April 5, :30 PM

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Regular Meeting Agenda Thursday, April 5, 2018 12:30 PM Call to Order 18-0405-100 Approval of Agenda Invocation 18-0405-102 Approval of March 22, 2018 Minutes Citizen Time Section Reports 18-0405-200 Field Book Changes Page 4 18-0405-201 Homestead Exemption Changes Page 5 18-0405-202 Personal Property Administrative Changes Page 6 18-0405-203 Exemption Approvals Page 7 18-0405-204 Exemption Denials Page 22 18-0405-205 Conservation Use Approvals Page 25 18-0405-206 Residential Administrative Changes Page 28 18-0405-207 Commercial Administrative Changes Page 51 18-0405-208 Appeal Second Reviews (Personal Property) Page 68 18-0405-209 & 2018 Vehicle Appeal Withdrawals Page 76 Additional Items 18-0405-300 Adoption of 2018 CUVA Values 18-0405-301 Adoption of 2018 FLPA Values 18-0405-302 Authorization to Mail 2018 Personal Property Assessment Notices Discussion Items 18-0405-D001 Homestead Exemption Applications (Fitzgerald) 18-0405-D002 Deactivated Parcels (Fitzgerald) 18-0405-D003 Customer Service (Fitzgerald) 18-0405-D004 Sales Data Transfer (Fitzgerald) Chief Appraiser s Report

Fulton County Board of Assessors Regular Meeting Minutes March 22, 2018 Member Attendance: Brandi Hunter-Lewis, Chair; Salma Ahmed, Vice-Chair; Michael Fitzgerald; and Edward London. Royce Morris was not in attendance. Staff Attendance: DeWayne Pinkney, Secretary/Deputy Chief Appraiser; Dwight Robinson, Chief Appraiser; Curtis Broden and Tara Parker, Deputy Chief Appraisers; Vincent Clark, Gaetjens Coreus, Brian Gardner, and Corey McDaniel, Appraisal Managers; Henry Brigham, Information Systems Manager; Jacqueline Davis, Administrative Coordinator, Reginald Elder, Database Specialist. County Attorney s Office: Cheryl Ringer & Kimberly Alexander Communications Office: April Majors Accenture Consulting: Albert Kovacs, Courtney Koepke, Kelton Kosik Chair Brandi Hunter-Lewis called the meeting to order at 12:43 p.m. Approval of Agenda 18-0322-100 Motion to approve with add on items. Ahmed, Second: London. The motion passed unanimously. Invocation Brandi Hunter-Lewis gave the invocation. Approval of March 8, 2018 Minutes 18-0322-102 Motion to approve with corrections: Ahmed, Second: London. The motion passed unanimously. Citizen Time No citizens were present to speak at this meeting. Section Reports Motion Second Vote 18-0322-200 Field Book Changes Fitzgerald Ahmed Unanimous 18-0322-201 Homestead Exemption Changes Fitzgerald London Unanimous 18-0322-202 Personal Property Administrative Changes London Ahmed Unanimous 18-0322-203 Personal Property Releases Fitzgerald London Unanimous 18-0322-204 Special Properties Ahmed London Unanimous 18-0322-205 Residential Administrative Changes Ahmed London Unanimous 18-0322-206 Appeal No Changes Fitzgerald London Unanimous 18-0322-207 Appeal Second Reviews w/value Freeze London Fitzgerald Unanimous 18-0322-208 2018 Appeal Value Changes (Personal Property) Fitzgerald London Unanimous 18-0322-209 Appeal Withdrawals (Personal Property) Ahmed London Unanimous Adoption of 2018 FLPA Index 18-0322-300 Motion to approve: Ahmed, Second: London. The motion passed unanimously. Add On Items 18-0322-301 Motion to approve: Fitzgerald, Second: London. The motion passed unanimously. A copy of the Add On agenda is included with the minutes of this meeting. 1. 12-2704-0749-077-4 LIBERTY PARK VILLAGE LLC 2. 12-4825-1269-022-7 LOCKWOOD JOSEPH K 3. 12-2704-0749-076-6 PULTE HOME CORPORATION - 2018 Real Property Assessment Notices 18-0322-302 Salma Ahmed made a motion to set May 22, 2018 as the date to mail 2018 real property assessment notices. Edward London seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 2

Chief Appraiser Report A copy of the report outline and attachments are included with the minutes of this meeting. Discussion Items 18-0322-D001 Alpharetta Assessments (Fitzgerald) Dwight Robinson gave an overview of the status of assessment of the newly developed area and explained that research revealed that the $14 million dollar sale was determined as a non-arms-length transaction between related business entities. That property and any others that did not get assessed will be valued for according to the current land schedules. New improvements will be added to the digest for 2018. Executive Session Motion for executive session to discuss litigation: Ahmed; Second, London. The motion passed unanimously. Motion to end executive session and return to regular meeting: Ahmed, Second: Fitzgerald. The motion passed unanimously. Presentation 18-0322-301 Tax System Business Process Review This presentation was given by Accenture Consulting representatives in conjunction with Fulton County Manager, Dick Anderson. Copies of the presentation materials are included with the minutes of this meeting. Adjournment Motion to adjourn: Ahmed, Second: Fitzgerald. The meeting was adjourned at 3:40 p.m. Submitted By: S. DeWayne Pinkney, Secretary Board of Assessors Minutes March 22, 2018 Page 2 of 2 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 3

04/03/2018 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 05 April, 2018 HT536GAFUL FBC Field Book Changes RESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES PARCEL ID YEAR APPRAISER OWNER NAME REASON NOTES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE 1 17-0251- LL-089-4 2016 P15 TRIUMPH THE CHURCH & KINGDOM OF GOD IN Ownership correction CONVEYED TO FULTON COUNTY OCT 2015 138,200 138,200 0 2 17-0251- LL-089-4 P15 TRIUMPH THE CHURCH & KINGDOM OF GOD IN Ownership correction CONVEYED TO FULTON COUNTY OCT 2015 64,900 64,900 0 1 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 4

03/27/2018 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 05 April, 2018 HT536GAFUL HEC Homestead Exemption Changes HOMESTEAD DIVISION PARCEL ID YEAR APPRAISER OWNER NAME REASON NOTES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE 1 17-0071-0009-053-8 2015 EE PLUNKETT DOROTHY E Homestead removal OWNER DECEASED 95,300 95,300 0 2 17-0071-0009-053-8 2016 EE PLUNKETT DOROTHY E Homestead removal OWNER DECEASED 95,300 95,300 0 3 17-0071-0009-053-8 EE PLUNKETT DOROTHY E Homestead removal OWNER DECEASED 95,300 95,300 0 1 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 5

03/28/2018 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 05 April, 2018 HT536GAFUL AD2 Administrative Agenda-Personal Property PERSONAL PROPERTY PARCEL ID YEAR PROPERTY TYPE APPRAISER OWNER NAME REASON NOTES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE Personal Property Value Update 1 P20120001219 2013 KAI THE MEDICAL SPA Adjusting roll up value to return filed 7,572 6,972-600 1 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 6

03/28/2018 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF OS April, 18 HT536GAFUL ME Exemption Approvals EXEMPT PROPERTIES PARCEL ID YEAR APPRAISER OWNER NAME REASON NOTES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE 1 14-0115-0005-071-9 ATLANTA BELTLINE INC 2018 Make Exempt OWNED BY ATL BELTLINE INC 009 5,400 5,400 0 2 14-0115-0005-072-7 ATLANTA BELTLINE INC 2018 Make Exempt OWNED BY ATL BELTLINE INC 009 5,400 5,400 0 3 14-0115-0005-073 -5 ATLANTA BELTLINE INC 2018 Make Exempt OWNED BY ATL BELTLINE INC 009 5,400 5,400 0 4 14-0115-0005-074-3 ATLANTA BELTLINE INC 2018 Make Exempt OWNED BY ATL BELTLINE INC 009 5,400 5,400 0 5 14-0115-0005-075-0 ATLANTA BELTLINE INC 2018 Make Exempt OWNED BY ATL BELTLINE INC 009 5,400 5,400 0 6 14-0115-0005-076-8 ATLANTA BELTLINE INC 2018 Make Exempt OWNED BY ATL BELTLINE INC 009 5,400 5,400 0 7 14-0115-0005-077-6 2018 009 ATLANTA BELTLINE INC Make Exempt OWNED BY ATL BELTLINE INC 5,400 5,400 0 1 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 7

03/28/2018 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 05 April, 18 HT536GAFUL ME Exemption Approvals EXEMPT PROPERTIES PARCEL ID YEAR OWNER NAME REASON NOTES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE 8 14-0146-0012-044-0 VETERANS EMPOWERMENT ORGANIZATION OF 2018 Make Exempt 009 150, 000 150,000 0 9 14F-0065- LL-093-3 LIFE ENRICHMENT MINISTRIES INC 2018 Make Exempt RELIGIOUS ORGANIZATION 009 1,309,900 1,309, 300-600 1 0 17-0087-0005-051-8 GEORGIA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION 2008 Make Exempt GDOT PUBLIC PROPERTY 009 226,800 226,800 0 11 17-0087-0005-051-8 GEORGIA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION 2009 Make Exempt GDOT PUBLI C PROPERTY 009 226,800 226,800 0 12 17-0087-0005-051-8 GEORGIA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION 2010 Make Exempt GDOT PUBLIC PROPERTY 009 226,800 226, 800 0 13 17-0087-0005-051-8 GEORGIA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION 2011 Make Exempt GDOT PUBLIC PROPERTY 009 226,800 226,800 0 14 17-0087-0005-051 - 8 GEORGIA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION 2012 Make Exempt GDOT PUBLIC PROPERTY 009 226, 800 226,800 0 2 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 8

03/28/2018 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF OS April, 18 HT536GAFUL ME Exemption Approvals EXEMPT PROPERTIES PARCEL ID YEAR OWNER NAME REASON NOTES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE 15 17-0087-0005-051-8 GEORGIA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION 2013 GDOT PUBLIC PROPERTY 009 238,300 238, 300 0 16 17-0087-0005-051-8 GEORGIA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION Make Exempt GDOT PUBLIC PROPERTY 009 238,300 238,300 0 17 17-0087-0005-051-8 GEORGIA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION 2015 Make Exempt GDOT PUBLIC PROPERTY 009 256,800 70,400-186,400 18 17-0087-0005-051-8 GEORGIA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION 2016 Make Exempt GDOT PUBLIC PROPERTY 009 256,800 70,400-186,400 19 17-0087-0005-051-8 GEORGIA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION Make Exempt GDOT PUBLIC PROPERTY 009 256, 800 70,400-186,400 3 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 9

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form Appeal Correction Exempt ME Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Subdivision Name: 2018 Atlanta Beltline Inc 14-0115-0005-071-9 265 Washington Heights Ln 05 E1 1412 Agent I Tax Rep: Dwelling Characteristic Changes Exemptions & Special Assessments Year Built: Effective Age: Story Height: Square Feet Living Area: Basement (Finished Area): Basement (Unfin. Area): Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Garage: Attic: Condition & Desirability: Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: Percent Complete: X Public Prop. Conservation Use Religious Charitable Non-Profit Educational Notes & Recommendations Preferrential Asmt. Historic Rehabilitated Transitional Env. Sensitive This parcel was purchased by the Atlanta Beltline Inc. in March of from an environmental corporation. This parcel should be exempt as public property for the 2018 tax year. Recommendation: Grant exemption for tax year 2018 Land Information Square Feet: Acres: 0.1724 0.1724 Property Valuation Summary Special Asmt. Recommended Current Value Value Value Land 5,400 0 5,400 Building 0 0 0 Accessories 0 0 0 Field Review Date: Date Submitted: 03/26/18 Appraisal Staff: Kathryn Byrd ~ Appraisal Manager: Gaetjens Coreus ~ Dep. Chief Appraiser: Total 5,400 0 5,400 Chief Appraiser: Dwight Robinson Form SRF-RE (Rev. 09/06) Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 10

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form Appeal Correction Exempt ME Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: 2018 Atlanta Beltline Inc 14-0115-0005-072-7 261 Washington Heights Ln 05 E1 1412 Dwelling Characteristic Changes Exemptions & Special Assessments Year Built: Effective Age: Story Height: Square Feet Living Area: Basement (Finished Area): Basement (Unfin. Area): Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Garage: Attic: Condition & Desirability: Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: Percent Complete: X Public Prop. Conservation Use Religious Charitable Non-Profit Educational Notes & Recommendations Preferrential Asmt. Historic Rehabilitated Transitional Env. Sensitive This parcel was purchased by the Atlanta Beltline Inc. in March of from an environmental corporation. This parcel should be exempt as public property for the 2018 tax year. Recommendation: Grant exemption for tax year 2018 Land Information Square Feet: Acres: 0.1758 0.1758 Property Valuation Summary Special Asmt. Recommended Current Value Value Value Land 5,400 0 5,400 Building 0 0 0 Accessories 0 0 0 Field Review Date: Date Submitted: 03/26/18 Appraisal Staff: Kathryn Byrd fji Appraisal Manager: Gaetjens Coreus ~ Dep. Chief Appraiser: Total 5,400 0 5,400 Chief Appraiser: Dwight Robinson Form SRF-RE (Rev. 09/06) Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 11

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form Appeal Correction Exempt ME Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: 2018 Atlanta Beltline Inc 14-0115-0005-073-5 255 Washington Heights Ln 05 E1 1412 Dwelling Characteristic Changes Year Built: Effective Age: Story Height: Square Feet Living Area: Basement (Finished Area): Basement (Unfin. Area): Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Garage: Attic: Condition & Desirability: Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: Percent Complete: other: II Exemptions & Special Assessments X Public Prop. Conservation Use Religious Charitable Non-Profit Educational Notes & Recommendations Preferrential Asmt. Historic Rehabilitated Transitional Env. Sensitive This parcel was purchased by the Atlanta Beltline Inc. in March of from an environmental corporation. This parcel should be exempt as public property for the 2018 tax year. Recommendation: Grant exemption for tax year 2018 Land Information Square Feet: Acres: 0.1744 0.1744 Property Valuation Summary Special Asmt. Recommended Current Value Value Value Land 5,400 0 5,400 Building 0 0 0 Accessories 0 0 0 Total 5,400 0 5,400 Field Review Date: Date Submitted: 03/26/18 Appraisal Staff: Kathryn Byrd~ Appraisal Manager: Gaetjens Coreus Crt Dep. Chief Appraiser: 1/) I~ VY' l Chief Appraiser: Dwight Robinson ~ - Form SRF-RE (Rev. 09/06) Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 12

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form Appeal Correction Exempt ME Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: 2018 Atlanta Beltline Inc 14-0115-0005-074-3 251 Washington Heights Ln 05 E1 1412 Dwelling Characteristic Changes Exemptions & Special Assessments Year Built: Effective Age: Story Height: Square Feet Living Area: Basement (Finished Area): Basement (Unfin. Area): Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Garage: Attic: Condition & Desirability: Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: Percent Complete: X Public Prop. Conservation Use Religious Charitable Non-Profit Educational Notes & Recommendations Preferrential Asmt. Historic Rehabilitated Transitional Env. Sensitive This parcel was purchased by the Atlanta Beltline Inc. in March of from an environmental corporation. This parcel should be exempt as public property for the 2018 tax year. Recommendation: Grant exemption for tax year 2018 land Information Square Feet: Acres: 0.1726 0.1726 Property Valuation Summary Special Asmt. Recommended Current Value Value Value Field Review Date: Date Submitted: 03/26/18 land 5,400 0 5,400 Building 0 0 0 Accessories 0 0 0 Total 5,400 0 5,400 Appraisal Staff: Appraisal Manager: Dep. Chief Appraiser: Chief Appraiser: Kathryn Byrd{!) Gaetjens Coreus Dwight Robinson Form SRF-RE (Rev. 09/06) Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 13

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form Appeal Correction Exempt ME ----- Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: 2018 Atlanta Beltline Inc 14-0115-0005-075-0 245 Washington Heights Ln 05 E1 1412 Dwelling Characteristic Changes Year Built: Effective Age: Story Height: Square Feet Living Area: Basement (Finished Area): Basement (Unfin. Area): Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Garage: Attic: Condition & Desirability: Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: Percent Complete: X Public Prop. Conservation Use Religious Charitable Non-Profit Educational Notes & Recommendations Preferrential Asmt. Historic Rehabilitated Transitional Env. Sensitive This parcel was purchased by the Atlanta Beltline Inc. in March of from an environmental corporation. This parcel should be exempt as public property for the 2018 tax year. Recommendation: Grant exemption for tax year 2018 Land Information Square Feet: Acres: 0.1728 0.1728 Property Valuation Summary Special Asmt. Recommended Current Value Value Value Land 5,400 0 5,400 Field Review Date: Date Submitted: 03/26/18 Appraisal Staff: Kathryn Byrd (!) Building 0 0 0 Accessories 0 0 0 Total 5,400 0 5,400 Appraisal Manager: Dep. Chief Appraiser: Chief Appraiser: Gaetjens Cereus Dwight Robinson Fom1 SRF-RE (Rev. 09/06) Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 14

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form Appeal Correction Exempt ME ----- Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: 2018 Atlanta Beltline Inc 14-0115-0005-076-8 241 Washington Heights Ln 05 E1 1412 Dwelling Characteristic Changes Year Built: Effective Age: Story Height: Square Feet Living Area: Basement (Finished Area): Basement (Unfin. Area): Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Garage: Attic: Condition & Desirability: Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: Percent Complete: X Public Prop. Conservation Use Religious Charitable Non-Profit Educational Notes & Recommendations Preferrential Asmt. Historic Rehabilitated Transitional Env. Sensitive This parcel was purchased by the Atlanta Beltline Inc. in March of from an environmental corporation. This parcel should be exempt as public property for the 2018 tax year. Recommendation: Grant exemption for tax year 2018 Land Information Square Feet: Acres: 0.1728 0.1728 Property Valuation Summary Special Asmt. Recommended Current Value Value Value Land 5,400 0 5,400 Building 0 0 0 Accessories 0 0 0 Field Review Date: Date Submitted: 03/26/18 Appraisal Staff: Kathryn Byrd 0 Appraisal Manager: Gaetjens Coreus (k Dep. Chief Appraiser: Total 5,400 0 5,400 Chief Appraiser: Dwight Robinson Form SRF RE (Rev. 09/06) Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 15

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form Appeal Correction Exempt ME Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: 2018 Atlanta Beltline Inc 14-0115-0005-077-6 235 Washington Heights Ln 05 E1 1412 Dwelling Characteristic Changes Exemptions & Special Assessments Year Built: Effective Age: Story Height: Square Feet Living Area: Basement (Finished Area): Basement (Unfin. Area): Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Garage: Attic: Condition & Desirability: Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: Percent Complete: X Public Prop. Conservation Use Religious Charitable Non-Profit Educational Notes & Recommendations Preferrential Asmt. Historic Rehabilitated Transitional Env. Sensitive This parcel was purchased by the Atlanta Beltline Inc. in March of from an environmental corporation. This parcel should be exempt as public property for the 2018 tax year. Recommendation: Grant exemption for tax year 2018 Land Information Square Feet: Acres: 0.1725 0.1725 Property Valuation Summary Special Asmt. Recommended Current Value Value Value Land 5,400 0 5,400 Field Review Date: Date Submitted: 03/26/18 Appraisal Staff: ~ Kathryn Byrd Building 0 0 0 Accessories 0 0 0 Total 5,400 0 5,400 Appraisal Manager: Dep. Chief Appraiser: Chief Appraiser: Gaefens Coreus Dwight Robinson Form SRF-RE (Rev. 09/06) Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 16

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form Appeal Correction Exempt ME Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: 2018 Veterans Empowerment Organization of Georgia Inc 14-0146-0012-024-2 382 Lanier St 05 E3 C409 Dwelling Characteristic Changes II Exemptions & Special Assessments Public Prop. Conservation Use Year Built: Religious Preferential Asmt. Effective Age: X Charitable Historic Rehabilitated Story Height: Non-Profit Transitional Square Feet Living Area: Basement (Finished Area): Basement (Unfin. Area): Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Garage: Attic: Condition & Desirability: Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: Percent Complete: Educational Notes & Recommendations Env. Sensitive The property owner submitted an exempt questionnaire for tax year in which the property owner is described as a non - profit, 501 (c)3 entity. The property was acquired by the non-profit organization on December 28 of 2016. The organization's mission is to help the poor and the homeless achieve self sufficiency. The property is a 4 unit multi-family garden style apartment that is used as supporting housing for homeless veterans. This property is being used as purely public charity. Based on the information provided by the Veterans Empowerment Organization of Georgia Inc. and the field inspection of the property, it is our recommendation that the property be granted exemption for tax year 2018. Land Information Recommendation : Grant Exempt Status for tax year 2018 Square Feet: Acres: 0.3324 0.3324 Property Valuation Summary Special Sat. Recommended Current Value Value Value Land 114,200 0 114,200 Field Review Date: 03/02/18 Date Submitted: 03/26/18 Appraisal Staff: Kathryn Byrd t!j Building 35,800 0 35,800 Appraisal Manager: Gaetjens Coreus Accessories 0 0 0 Dep. Chief Appraiser: Total 150,000 0 150,000 Chief Appraiser: Form SRF-RE (Rev. 09/06) Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 17 Dwight Robinson } XJf' v '

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form Appeal Correction Exempt ME Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: 2018 Life Enrichment Ministries Inc. 14F-0065- LL-093-3 4644 Campbellton Rd cos E2 C505 Dwelling Characteristic Changes Exemptions & Special Assessments Public Prop. Conservation Use Year Built: X Religious Preferential Asmt. Effective Age: Charitable Historic Rehabilitated Story Height: Non-Profit Transitional Square Feet Living Area: Educational Env. Sensitive Basement (Finished Area): Basement (Unfin. Area): Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Garage: Attic: Condition & Desirability: Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: Notes & Recommendations Taxpayer submitted an Exempt Property Questionnaire for tax year 2018 requesting an exemption be made on this parcel because it is a religious organization. Life Enrichment Ministries Inc. obtained ownership of this property May 17,, making them eligible for exemption for tax year 2018. After performing a field inspection, it is evident that this parcel is a church and is used purely as a place of religious worship. Based on information provided and the field inspection, the recommendation to the Board is to grant the exemption for tax year 2018. Percent Complete: Recommendation: Recommend Exemption for Tax Year 2018 Land Information Square Feet: Acres: 6.06 6.06 Property Valuation Summary Special Asmt. Recommended Current Value Value Value Land 906,400 0 906,400 Building 403,500 0 403,500 Accessories 0 0 0 Field Review Date: 03/22/18 Date Submitted: 03/26/18 Appraisal Staff: Kathryn Byrd f:!j Appraisal Manager: Gaetjens Coreus ~ Dep. Chief Appraiser: Total 1,309,900 0 1,309,900 Chief Appraiser: Dwight Robinson Form SRF-RE (Rev. 09/06) Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 18

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form Appeal Correction Exempt ME Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: 2008-2012 Georgia Department of Transportation 17-0087-0005-051-8 115 Abernathy Rd 59 E1 17831 Dwelling Characteristic Changes Exemptions & Special Assessments Year Built: Effective Age: Story Height: Square Feet Living Area: Basement (Finished Area): Basement (Unfin. Area): Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Garage: Attic: Condition & Desirability: Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: Percent Complete: X Public Prop. Conservation Use Religious Charitable Non-Profit Educational Notes & Recommendations Preferential Asmt. Historic Rehabilitated Transitional Env. Sensitive The subject is public property owned by the Georgia Department of Transportation. It was acquired by the Georgia Department of Transportation in June of 2007 from an individual. The ownership status as of January 1, 2008 makes this property exempt for tax year 2008 forward. Recommendation : Grant exempt status for tax year 2008 through 2012 Land Information Square Feet: Acres:.4683.4683 Property Valuation Summary Special Sat. Recommended Current Value Value Value Land 65,300 0 65,300 Building 161,500 0 161,500 Accessories 0 0 0 Total 226,800 0 226,800 Form SRF-RE (Rev. 09/06) Field Review Date: Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 19 Date Submitted: 03/22/18 Appraisal Staff: Gaetjens Cereus c~ Appraisal Manager: Gaetjens Cereus &-- Dep. Chief Appraiser: A/J Chief Appraiser: Dwight Robinson ~ - I

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form Appeal Correction Exempt ME Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: 2013- Georgia Department of Transportation 17-0087-0005-051-8 115 Abernathy Rd 59 E1 17831 Dwelling Characteristic Changes Year Built: Effective Age: Story Height: Square Feet Living Area: Basement (Finished Area): Basement (Unfin. Area): Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Garage: Attic: Condition & Desirability: Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: Percent Complete: II Exemptions & Special Assessments X Public Prop. Conservation Use Religious Charitable Non-Profit Educational Notes & Recommendations Preferential Asmt. Historic Rehabilitated Transitional Env. Sensitive The subject is public property owned by the Georgia Department of Transportation. It was acquired by the Georgia Department of Transportation in June of 2007 from an individual. The ownership status as of January 1, 2008 makes this property exempt for tax year 2008 forward. Recommendation : Grant exempt status for tax year 2013 through Land Information Square Feet: Acres:.4683.4683 Property Valuation Summary Special Sat. Recommended Current Value Value Value Land 65,300 0 65,300 Building 173,000 0 173,000 Accessories 0 0 0 Field Review Date: Date Submitted: 03/22/18 Appraisal Staff: Gaetjens Coreus G- Appraisal Manager: Gaetjens Coreus Cr Dep. Chief Appraiser: /1. /} Total 238,300 0 238,300 Chief Appraiser: Form SRF RE (Rev. 09/06) Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 20 Dwight Robinsonf'xf)\. v \

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form Appeal Correction Exempt ME Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: 2015- Georgia Department of Transportation 17-0087-0005-051-8 0 Abernathy Rd 59 E1 17831 Dwelling Characteristic Changes Exemptions & Special Assessments Year Built: Effective Age: Story Height: Square Feet Living Area: Basement (Finished Area): Basement (Unfin. Area): Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Garage: Attic: Condition & Desirability: Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: Percent Complete: X Public Prop. Conservation Use Religious Charitable Non-Profit Educational Notes & Recommendations Preferential Asmt. Historic Rehabilitated Transitional Env. Sensitive The subject is public property owned by the Georgia Department of Transportation. It was acquired by the Georgia Department of Transportation in June of 2007 from an individual. The ownership status as of January 1, 2008 makes this property exempt for tax year 2008 forward. The improvement is deleted to reflect the parcel being vacant. Recommendation : Grant exempt status for tax year 2015 through Land Information Square Feet: Acres:.4683.4683 Property Valuation Summary Special Sat. Recommended Current Value Value Value Land 70,400 0 70,400 Building 0 0 0 Accessories 0 0 0 Total 70,400 0 70,400 Form SRF-RE (Rev. 09/06) Field Review Date: Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 21 Date Submitted: 03/22/18 Appraisal Staff: Gaetjens Coreus G: Appraisal Manager: Gaetjens Coreus (k_ Dep. Chief Appraiser: rxj/j Chief Appraiser: Dwight Robinson (~. v \

03/28/2018 PARCEL ID YEAR APPRAISER BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF OS April, 18 OWNER NAME REASON NOTES EXM Exemption Denials EXEMPT PROPERTIES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE HT536GAFUL Exemption Denial 1 14F-0066-0006-069-5 JESUS SET THE CAPTIVE FREE INC EXEMPTION DENIAL 009 49,900 49,900 0 2 14-0146-0012-044-0 VETERANS EMPOWERMENT ORGANIZATION OF NOT IN USE AS OF 1-1-17 009 150,000 150,000 0 1 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 22

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form Appeal Correction Exempt EXM Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Subdivision Name: Jesus Set the Captive Free Inc 14F-0066-0006-069-5 2290 Fairway Cir SW 05 R1 4618 Agent I Tax Rep: Dwelling Characteristic Changes Exemptions & Special Assessments Public Prop. Conservation Use Year Built: X Religious Preferential Asmt. Effective Age: Charitable Historic Rehabilitated Story Height: Non-Profit Transitional Square Feet Living Area: Educational Env. Sensitive Basement (Finished Area): Basement (Unfin. Area): Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Garage: Attic: Condition & Desirability: Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: Percent Complete: Notes & Recommendations Taxpayer submitted an Exempt Property Questionnaire for tax year requesting an exemption based on the property owner being a non-profit organization. Jesus Set the Captive Free Inc., owns this single family residence in which the owners state it is being used to conduct religious services and house homeless members of the congregation. Upon further investigation, it was discovered that the property was not granted a certification of occupancy by the city until April 6,. Since the property was not in use as of the 1st of January, the recommendation to the Board is to deny exemption for tax year. Recommendation: Deny exemption for tax year 2018. Land Information Square Feet: Acres: 0.2152 0.2152 Property Valuation Summary Special Asmt. Recommended Current Value Value Value Land 11,700 0 11,700 Field Review Date: 03/22/18 Date Submitted: 03/26/18 Appraisal Staff: Kathryn Byrd Building 54,000 0 54,000 Accessories 0 0 0 Total 65,700 0 65,700 Appraisal Manager: Dep. Chief Appraiser: Chief Appraiser: Gaetjens Coreus Dwight Robinson Form SRF-RE (Rev. 09/06) Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 23

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form Appeal Correction Exempt EXM Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: Veterans Empowerment Organization of Georgia Inc. 14-0146-00 12-044-0 370 Lanier St 05 C3 C409 Dwelling Characteristic Changes Year Built: Effective Age: Story Height: Square Feet Living Area: 1: Exemptions & Special Assessments Public Prop. Conservation Use Religious Preferential Asmt. Charitable Historic Rehabilitated X Non-Profit Transitional Educational Env. Sensitive Basement (Finished Area): Basement (Unfin. Area): Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Garage: Attic: Condition & Desirability: Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: Percent Complete: Land Information Square Feet: Acres: 0.3324 0.3324 Notes & Recommendations Taxpayer submitted an Exempt Property Questionnaire on the subject for tax year and 2018 requesting an exemption based on the property owner being a non-profit entity. The Veterans Empowerment Organization of Georgia Inc. acquired this apartment complex on December 28, 2016. In order for a property to be exempt as purely public charity, not only the property must be owned by the non-profit 501 ( c)3 entity, but the property must also be used exclusively for the charitable pursuit of the entity as of January 1 of the year the exemption is requested. Since the property was acquired on December 28, 2016, we requested information from the owner to prove and confirm the property was in use on January 1,. The owner did not provide the documentation to prove their use of the property. The exemption request for tax year was made to the assessors on March 3rd, 2018: Therefore; we do not have the ability to go back and confirm the use of the property as of January 1, : However, a field check on March 4th, 2018 did confirm the use of the property as of January 1, 2018, but not the use as of January 1, Recommendation: Deny exemption for tax year. Property Valuation Summary Special Asmt. Recommended Current Value Value Value Land 114,200 0 114,200 Building 35,800 0 35,800 Accessories 0 0 0 Field Review Date: 03/04/18 Date Submitted: 03/26/18 r;p Appraisal Staff: Kathryn Byrd Appraisal Manager: Gaetjens Cereus (k, Dep. Chief Appraiser: /) /J Total 150,000 0 150,000 Form SRF RE (Rev. 09/06) Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 24 Chief Appraiser: Dwight Robinson~ v \

03/28/2018 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF OS April, 18 HT536GAFUL CVA CUVA Approvals EXEMPT PROPERTIES PARCEL ID YEAR APPRAISER OWNER NAME REASON NOTES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE 1 08-2600-0107-094-8 DAVENPORT RICHARD & 2018 CUVA Approved 2011 CUVA CONTINUATION 009 14,269 14' 269 0 2 22-4770-0892-040-1 JACKSON PAMELA F A 2018 CUVA Approved ADDITION TO EXISTING CUVA 009 5,836 7,288 1,452 1 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 25

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form Appeal Correction Exempt CVA ---- Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: 2018 DAVENPORT RICHARD & DAVENPORT JAN C 08-2600-0107-094-8 0 Jones Ferry Rd 65 V5 08003 Dwelling Characteristic Changes Year Built: Effective Age: Story Height: Square Feet Living Area: Basement (Finished Area): Basement (Unfin. Area): Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Garage: Attic: Condition & Desirability: Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: Percent Complete: [I Exemptions & Special Assessments Public Prop. X Conservation Use Religious Charitable Non-Profit Educational Notes & Recommendations Preferential Asmt. Historic Rehabilitated Transitional Env. Sensitive Taxpayer submitted Application for Current Use Assessment of Bona Fide Agricultural Assessment. The owner purchased the property on September 22,. This is a continuation of a covenant that began on January 1, 2011. The property is used for feeding, breeding and managing livestock. The requirement for the CUVA Program based on the rules and regulations of the Department of Revenue of the State of Georgia are as follows: The primary use of the property shall include, but not be limited to: a) raising, harvesting or storing crops. b) production of aquaculture, horticulture, floriculture, forestry, dairy, livestock, poultry and apiarian products. The property meets CUVA land requirements (b) above. Land Information Square Feet: Acres: 11.306 11.306 Recommendation: The Board of Assessors grant CUVA. This Is a Continuation of a covenant beginning January 1, 2011 ending December 31, 2020. Property Valuation Summary Current FMV Recommended Special Asmt. Value FMVValue Value Land 105,500 105,500 14,269 Building 0 0 0 Accessories 0 0 0 Total 105,500 105,500 14,269 Field Review Date: 03/23/18 Recommended Value Date Submitted: 03/26/18 14,269 Appraisal Staff: Gaetjens Coreus ~ 0 Appraisal Manager: Gaetjens Coreus Gt- 0 Dep. Chief Appraiser: Tara Parker ~ /2 14,269 Chief Appraiser: Dwight Robinson ~ Form SRF-RE (Rev. 09106) Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 26

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form Appeal Correction Exempt CVA Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: 2018 JACKSON PAMELA FA 22-4770-0892-040-1 0 Hopewell Rd 56 V4 0 Dwelling Characteristic Changes Year Built: Effective Age: Story Height: Square Feet Living Area: Basement (Finished Area): Basement (Unfin. Area): Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Garage: Attic: Condition & Desirability: Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: Percent Complete: Land Information Square Feet: Acres: 2.05 2.05 ~----Public Prop. 1------Religious I-----Charitable 1------Non-Profit 1------ Educational X Conservation Use ---- Preferential Asmt. Historic Rehabilitated Transitional Notes & Recommendations Env. Sensitive Taxpayer submitted an Application for Current Use Assessment of Bona Fide Agricultural Property. This property was previously under a covenant which expired 12-31-. This parcel is contigeous to four other parcels owned by the same owner that is in a 4 parcels 1 covenant that began 1/01/. This parcel will be added to the existing covenant. It consists of 1.438 acres of pasture and 0.615 acres of timber. This property is used for feeding and breeding livestock. The requirement for the CUVA Program based on the rules and regulations of the Department of Revenue of the State of Georgia are as follows: The primary use of the property shall include, but not be limited to: a) raising, harvesting or storing crops. b) production of aquaculture, horticulture, floriculture, forestry, dairy, livestock, poultry and apiarian products. The property meets CUVA land requirements (b) above. Recommendation: The Board of Assessors grant CUVA. This is an addition to an existing covenant beginning January 1, ending December 31, 2023. Property Valuation Summary Current FMV Recommended Special Asmt. Value FMVValue Value Recommended Value Field Review Date: 03/23/18 Date Submitted:..:0:..::3.:..:/2:..:6::.../1.:..:8; _ Land 133,100 133,100 0 2,113 Appraisal Staff:...;G=.a=.e::.;tL:je:..:.n:..::s...:C:..o::.;r..::e..::u.::.s--=:..:::..------ Building 5,500 5,500 0 5,500 Appraisal Manager:...;G=.a=.e::.;tL:je:..:.n:..::s...:C:..o::.;r..::e..::u.::.s.,...A------- Accessories 0 0 0 Total 138,600 138,600 0 0 7,613 Dep. Chief Appraiser: Chief Appraiser: Tara Parker ------~~~~---- Dwight Robinson Form SRF-RE (Rev. 09/06} Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 27

03/29/2018 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 05 April, 2018 HT536GAFUL RAD Administrative Agenda - Residential RESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES PARCEL ID YEAR APPRAISER OWNER NAME REASON NOTES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE 1 07-1602-0170-086-8 100 LYONS BRIDGET ANN Land consolidation LAND COMBINED FOR 0 126,000 126,000 2 13-0124- LL-198-7 17,300 2,791-14,509 3 13-0124- LL-199-5 13,600 1,396-12,204 4 13-0124- LL-200-1 13,600 1,396-12,204 5 13-0124- LL-201-9 19,400 19,400 0 6 13-0124- LL-202-7 20,200 3,629-16,571 7 13-0124- LL-203-5 14,400 1,675-12,725 1 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 28

03/29/2018 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 05 April, 2018 HT536GAFUL RAD Administrative Agenda - Residential RESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES PARCEL ID YEAR OWNER NAME REASON NOTES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE 8 13-0124- LL-204-3 14,400 1,675-12,725 9 13-0124- LL-205-0 18,700 3,350-15,350 10 13-0124- LL-206-8 18,000 3,071-14,929 11 13-0124- LL-207-6 14,400 1,675-12,725 12 13-0124- LL-208-4 14,400 1,675-12,725 13 13-0124- LL-209-2 18,700 3,350-15,350 14 13-0124- LL-210-0 18,700 3,350-15,350 2 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 29

03/29/2018 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 05 April, 2018 HT536GAFUL RAD Administrative Agenda - Residential RESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES PARCEL ID YEAR OWNER NAME REASON NOTES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE 15 13-0124- LL-211-8 13,600 1,396-12,204 16 13-0124- LL-212-6 13,600 1,396-12,204 17 13-0124- LL-213-4 18,000 3,071-14,929 18 13-0124- LL-214-2 18,000 3,071-14,929 19 13-0124- LL-215-9 13,600 1,396-12,204 20 13-0124- LL-216-7 13,600 13,600 0 21 13-0124- LL-217-5 18,000 3,071-14,929 3 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 30

03/29/2018 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 05 April, 2018 HT536GAFUL RAD Administrative Agenda - Residential RESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES PARCEL ID YEAR OWNER NAME REASON NOTES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE 22 13-0124- LL-218-3 18,000 3,071-14,929 23 13-0124- LL-219-1 13,600 1,396-12,204 24 13-0124- LL--9 13,600 1,396-12,204 25 13-0124- LL-221-7 15,800 15,800 0 26 13-0124- LL-222-5 19,400 3,629-15,771 27 13-0124- LL-223-3 13,600 1,396-12,204 28 13-0124- LL-224-1 13,600 1,396-12,204 4 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 31

03/29/2018 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 05 April, 2018 HT536GAFUL RAD Administrative Agenda - Residential RESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES PARCEL ID YEAR OWNER NAME REASON NOTES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE 29 13-0124- LL-225-8 18,000 3,071-14,929 30 13-0124- LL-226-6 16,500 2,512-13,988 31 13-0124- LL-227-4 14,400 1,675-12,725 32 13-0124- LL-228-2 15,100 1,954-13,146 33 13-0124- LL-229-0 17,300 2,791-14,509 34 13-0124- LL-230-8 25,200 5,862-19,338 35 13-0124- LL-231-6 14,400 1,675-12,725 5 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 32

03/29/2018 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 05 April, 2018 HT536GAFUL RAD Administrative Agenda - Residential RESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES PARCEL ID YEAR OWNER NAME REASON NOTES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE 36 13-0124- LL-232-4 15,100 1,954-13,146 37 13-0124- LL-233-2 30,300 7,816-22,484 38 13-0124- LL-234-0 21,600 4,466-17,134 39 13-0124- LL-235-7 14,400 1,675-12,725 40 13-0124- LL-236-5 14,400 1,675-12,725 41 13-0124- LL-237-3 20,200 3,908-16,292 42 13-0124- LL-238-1 25,200 5,862-19,338 6 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 33

03/29/2018 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 05 April, 2018 HT536GAFUL RAD Administrative Agenda - Residential RESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES PARCEL ID YEAR OWNER NAME REASON NOTES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE 43 13-0124- LL-239-9 14,400 1,675-12,725 44 13-0124- LL-240-7 14,400 1,675-12,725 45 13-0124- LL-241-5 16,500 2,512-13,988 46 13-0124- LL-250-6 18,700 3,350-15,350 47 13-0124- LL-251-4 13,600 1,396-12,204 48 13-0124- LL-252-2 13,600 1,396-12,204 49 13-0124- LL-253-0 15,100 1,954-13,146 7 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 34

03/29/2018 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 05 April, 2018 HT536GAFUL RAD Administrative Agenda - Residential RESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES PARCEL ID YEAR OWNER NAME REASON NOTES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE 50 13-0124- LL-254-8 47,000 14,236-32,764 51 13-0124- LL-255-5 14,400 1,675-12,725 52 13-0124- LL-256-3 15,100 1,954-13,146 53 13-0124- LL-257-1 31,100 8,095-23,005 54 13-0124- LL-258-9 20,200 3,908-16,292 55 13-0124- LL-259-7 14,400 1,675-12,725 56 13-0124- LL-260-5 14,400 1,675-12,725 8 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 35

03/29/2018 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 05 April, 2018 HT536GAFUL RAD Administrative Agenda - Residential RESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES PARCEL ID YEAR OWNER NAME REASON NOTES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE 57 13-0124- LL-261-3 18,700 3,350-15,350 58 13-0124- LL-262-1 18,700 3,350-15,350 59 13-0124- LL-263-9 14,400 1,675-12,725 60 13-0124- LL-264-7 53,600 16,748-36,852 61 13-0124- LL-265-4 18,700 3,350-15,350 62 13-0124- LL-266-2 18,700 3,350-15,350 63 13-0124- LL-267-0 14,400 1,675-12,725 9 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 36

03/29/2018 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 05 April, 2018 HT536GAFUL RAD Administrative Agenda - Residential RESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES PARCEL ID YEAR OWNER NAME REASON NOTES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE 64 13-0124- LL-268-8 14,400 1,675-12,725 65 13-0124- LL-269-6 18,700 3,350-15,350 66 13-0124- LL-270-4 18,700 3,350-15,350 67 13-0124- LL-271-2 14,400 1,675-12,725 68 13-0124- LL-272-0 14,400 1,675-12,725 69 13-0124- LL-273-8 18,700 3,350-15,350 70 13-0124- LL-274-6 18,700 3,350-15,350 10 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 37

03/29/2018 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 05 April, 2018 HT536GAFUL RAD Administrative Agenda - Residential RESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES PARCEL ID YEAR OWNER NAME REASON NOTES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE 71 13-0124- LL-275-3 14,400 1,675-12,725 72 13-0124- LL-276-1 14,400 1,675-12,725 73 13-0124- LL-277-9 18,700 3,350-15,350 74 13-0124- LL-278-7 18,700 3,350-15,350 75 13-0124- LL-279-5 14,400 1,675-12,725 76 13-0124- LL-280-3 14,400 1,675-12,725 77 13-0124- LL-281-1 18,700 3,350-15,350 11 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 38

03/29/2018 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 05 April, 2018 HT536GAFUL RAD Administrative Agenda - Residential RESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES PARCEL ID YEAR OWNER NAME REASON NOTES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE 78 13-0124- LL-282-9 18,700 3,350-15,350 79 13-0124- LL-283-7 14,400 1,675-12,725 80 13-0124- LL-284-5 14,400 1,675-12,725 81 13-0124- LL-285-2 10,800 3,350-7,450 82 13-0124- LL-286-0 18,700 3,350-15,350 83 13-0124- LL-287-8 14,400 1,675-12,725 84 13-0124- LL-288-6 14,400 1,675-12,725 12 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 39

03/29/2018 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 05 April, 2018 HT536GAFUL RAD Administrative Agenda - Residential RESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES PARCEL ID YEAR OWNER NAME REASON NOTES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE 85 13-0124- LL-289-4 18,700 3,350-15,350 86 13-0124- LL-290-2 18,700 3,350-15,350 87 13-0124- LL-291-0 14,400 1,675-12,725 88 13-0124- LL-292-8 14,400 1,675-12,725 89 13-0124- LL-293-6 18,700 3,350-15,350 90 13-0124- LL-294-4 18,700 3,350-15,350 91 13-0124- LL-295-1 14,400 1,675-12,725 13 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 40

03/29/2018 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 05 April, 2018 HT536GAFUL RAD Administrative Agenda - Residential RESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES PARCEL ID YEAR OWNER NAME REASON NOTES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE 92 13-0124- LL-296-9 20,900 4,187-16,713 93 13-0124- LL-297-7 20,900 4,187-16,713 94 13-0124- LL-298-5 25,200 5,862-19,338 95 13-0124- LL-299-3 15,800 2,233-13,567 96 13-0124- LL-300-9 16,500 2,512-13,988 97 13-0124- LL-301-7 25,200 5,862-19,338 98 14-0162-0002-017-7 007 DERDA CHRISTINE M & SEAN P SUBJECT ROLLED BACK TO 2016 VALUE 403,800 177,100-226,700 14 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 41

03/29/2018 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 05 April, 2018 HT536GAFUL RAD Administrative Agenda - Residential RESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES PARCEL ID YEAR OWNER NAME REASON NOTES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE 99 14-0202-0006-043-1 2015 266 PAYTON T C Improvement removed HOUSE REMOVED. VACANT LAND 164,300 19,500-144,800 100 14-0202-0006-043-1 2016 266 PAYTON T C Improvement removed HOUSE REMOVED. VACANT LAND 164,300 16,100-148,200 101 14-0202-0006-043-1 266 PAYTON T C Improvement removed HOUSE REMOVED. VACANT LAND 164,300 16,100-148,200 15 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 42

- ~... - --..::::= -- L: -. 2 ~... FUITONCDTY Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhooc Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: Appeal FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS LYONS, BRIDGET ANN 07 16000868 6743 RIVERTOWN RD 25 R1 # 96163 Real Property Staff Review Form Correction X Exempt ----- Dwelling Characteristic Changes Exemptions & Special Assessments Year Built: Effective Age: Story Height: Square Feet Living Area: Basement (Finished Area): 1955 1980 1,662 FULL f-----public Prop. I-----Religious f---- - Charitable f----- Non-Profit I-----Educational Conservation Use Preferrential Asmt. Historic Rehabilitated Transitional Env. Sensitive Basement (Unfin. Area): Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Garage: Attic: Condition & Desirability: CH/AC GD Notes & Recommendations Three lots were consolidated into one newly created parcel for tax year. Therefore, the following parcels have been deleted: 0716000314 (1.84 acs), 07 16000322 (2.1 acs) & 07 16000850 (.55 acs); creating this new parcel with a total acreage of 4.524 acres. Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: Percent Complete: c The fair market value recommended to the Board is $126.000. All changes are current & up-dated in the 2018 digest file. Square Feet: Acres: Land Information 0 0 197,065 4.524 Property Valuation Summary Special Asmt. Current Value Value Recommended Value Field Review Date: 03/12/18 Date Submitted: 03/12/18 Land 0 0 65,700 Appraisal Staff: Tamara M.lv Building 0 0 60,300 Appraisal Manager: Zach Mitchell Accessories Total 0 0 0 0 126,000 Deputy Chief Appraiser:.. T:..:a:.:.ra=-.:..P..:a::..:rk.:..:e:.:.r_...,c,!+ ------ Form SRF RE (Rev. 09/06) Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 43

=- _--.. -= -- -......... _ -- L.: - - :JI ~... RILIDN COUNTY Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form Appeal Correction X Exempt Oaks At Flat Shoals 1 LLC See Att See Att 55 R Photograph Not Available 1396 Dwelling Characteristic Changes Exemptions & Special Assessments Public Prop. Conservation Use Year Built: N?A Religious Preferrential Asmt. Effective Age: Charitable Historic Rehabilitated Story Height: Non-Profit Transitional Square Feet Living Area: Educational Env. Sensitive Basement (Finished Area): Basement (Unfin. Area): Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Garage: Attic: NfA NfA Notes & Recommendations Taxpayer purchased 96 parcels in a 2013 multi-parcel sale for $250,000. Taxpayer did not receive sale price for tax year. Appraiser adjusted land values to reflect sale price allocation. Per SB346, values should reflect purchase price for year after sale only. Condition & Desirability: Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: NfA Percent Complete: I Land Information Square Feet: 0 Acres: 0 0 0 Property Valuation Summary Special Asmt. Recommended Current Value Value Value Land See Att See Att SeeAtt Building See All See Att See Att Accessories See All See Att See Att Field Review Date: Date Submitted: 3/16/2018 Staff Appraiser: Wendy Kennedy rlj L Appraiser Manager: Zachary Mitchell ~ Dep. Chief Appraiser: Tara Parker =6t)2 Total See All See All See Att Form SRF-RE (Rov. 09/06) Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 44

PARID TAXYR Prior YR Value Adiusted Value 13 0124 LL1987 17,300 $2,791 13 0124 LL1995 13,600 $1,396 13 0124 ll2001 13,600 $1,396 13 0124 LL2019 19,400 $3,629 13 0124 Ll2027 20,200 $3,908 13 0124 ll2035 14,400 $1,675 13 0124 LL2043 14,400 $1,675 13 0124 Ll2050 18,700 $3,350 13 0124 ll2068 18,000 $3,()71 13 0124 ll2076 14,400 - - -- _$~. ~75 13 0124 ll2084 14,400 $1,675 13 0124 ll2092 18,700 -- _$3,350 13 0124 ll2100 18,700 $3,350 13 0124 ll2118 13,600 - - - _$].,39~ 13 0124 ll2126 13,600 $1,396 13 0124 ll2134 18,000 -- $_3,071 13 0124 ll2142 18,000 $3,071 13 0124 ll2159 13,600 -- $~.:39~ - -- 13 0124 ll2167 13,600 $1,396 13 0124 ll2175 18,000 $3,071 13 0124 ll2183 18,000 $~,07~ 13 0124 ll2191 13,600 $1,396 13 0124 ll9 13,600 $1,396 13 0124 ll2217 15,800 $~.?33 13 0124 ll2225 19,400 $~._629 13 0124 Ll2233 13,600 - $].,396 13 0124 Ll2241 13,600 $1,396 13 0124 ll2258 18,000 $3.971 13 0124 ll2266 16,500 ----- $?,512 13 0124 ll2274 14,400 $_!,67? 13 0124 ll2282 15,100 $1,954 13 0124 ll2290 17,300 _$2,791 13 0124 Ll2308 25,200 $5,862 13 0124 ll2316 14,400 $1,675 13 0124 Ll2324 15,100 $1,954 13 0124 ll2332 30,300 $7,816 13 0124 ll2340 21,600 $4,466 13 0124 LL2357 14,400 $1,675 13 0124 ll2365 14,400 $1,675 13 0124 LL2373 20,200 $3,908 13 0124 LL2381 25,200 $5,862 13 0124 LL2399 14,400 $1,675 13 0124 ll2407 14,400 $1,675 13 0124 ll2415 16,500 $2,512 13 0124 LL2506 18,700 $3,350 13 0124 LL2514 13,600 $1,396 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 45

13 0124 LU522 13,600 $1,396 13 0124 LL2530 15,100 $1,954 13 0124 LL2548 47,000 $14,236 13 0124 LL2555 14,400 $1,675 13 0124 LL2563 15,100 $1,954 13 0124 LL2571 31,100 $8,~5 13 0124 LL2589 20,200. $3,~Q8 13 0124 LL2597 14,400 $1,675 13 0124 ll2605 14,400 $1,()?~.. 13 0124 LL2613 18,700 $3,350 13 0124 LL2621 18,700.. $~.~50 13 0124 LL2639 14,400 $1,675 13 0124 LL2647 53,600 $!6,]48 13 0124 LL2654 18,700 $3,_~!)Q.. 13 0124 LL2662 18,700 $3,~50 13 0124 LL2670 14,400 ----~!,675 13 0124 LL2688 14,400 $1,675 13 0124 LL2696 18,700 $~,350 13 0124 LL2704 18,700 S!~~Q - 13 0124 ll2712 14,400. $!,(i?5 13 0124 LL2720 14,400 $1,675 13 0124 LL2738 18,700 --- $~!~?9 13 0124 LL2746 18,700 $3,~~9 13 0124 LL2753 14,400 - $_~!(i7!). 13 0124 LL2761 14,400 $1,675 13 0124 LL2n9 18,700 $3.~~Q_ 13 0124 LL2787 18,700 $3,350 13 0124 LL2795 14,400 - $_!.~?:5. - -- - 13 0124 LL2803 14,400 $1,~?5 13 0124 LL2811 18,700 _$3,~?Q --- - - 13 0124 LL2829 18,700 $3,350 13 0124 LL2837 14,400 $1,f5?5 13 0124 LL2845 14,400 $1,675 13 0124 LL2852 10,800 - _$3.~?Q - 13 0124 LL2860 18,700 $3,350 13 0124 LL2878 14,400 $1,675 13 0124 LL2886 14,400 $1,675 13 0124 LL2894 18,700 $~.~~() 13 0124 LL2902 18,700 $3,350 13 0124 LL2910 14,400 $1,_()??. 13 0124 LL2928 14,400 $1,675 13 0124 LL2936 18,700 $3,350 13 0124 LL2944 18,700 $3,350 13 0124 LL2951 14,400 $1,675 13 0124 LL2969 20,900 $4,187 13 0124 LL29n 20,900 $4,187 13 0124 LL2985 25,200 $5,862 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 46

13 0124 LL2993 13 0124 LL3009 13 0124 LL3017 15,800 16,500 25,200.. 2?... ~~~--- -- -- - $~,51~-- $5,862 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 47

---.- _.,. - - -- -- &;.; -. :II -- -...-- FUlTON COUNTY Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: Appeal FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form DERDA CHRISTINE M & SEAN P 14-0162-0002-017-7 1962 WALKER AVE 15 R1 1455 Correction X ----"-'--- Exempt Dwelling Characteristic Changes Exemptions & Special Assessments Year Built: 1930 Effective Age: 1995 Story Height: 1 Square Feet Living Area: 2547 Basement (Finished Area): 1000 Basement (Unfin. Area): Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Central With NC Garage: 662 Attic: Condition & Desirability: VG Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: A- Percent Complete: 100 Residential 1930 1995 1 2547 1000 Central With NC 662 VG A- 100 Residential 1-----Public Prop. I------Religious I-----Charitable I-----N on-profit I-- ---Educational Conservation Use - ---Preferential Asmt. Historic Rehabilitated Transitional Env. Sensitive Notes & Recommendations The subject's value was increased in 201 7 due to CPI while other homes in the nbhd where rolled back to 2016 values. There were no data changes to the subject during this time. In order to have subject be in line with the nbhd, I recommend its value be rolled back to the 2016 value as well. Land Information Square Feet: Acres: 7,500 0.1722 7,500 0.1722 Property Valuation Summary Current Value Land $30,000 Building $373,800 Accessories $0 Total $403,800 I Special Asmt. Value Recommended Value $25,300 $151,800 $0 $177,100 Field Review Date: 02/08/18 Date Submitted: 03/26/18 Appraisal Staff: Jafari Farmer (~ Appraisal Manager: Zachary Mitchell ~// Dep. Chief Appraiser: Tara Parker ~ Form SRF RE (Rev. 09/06) Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 48

~ -......::= _.,. ~ - L..: -.,..lll -...-... -- AJIJDN COUNTY -- -- Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: 2015 Appeal PAYTON T C 14 020200060431 FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS 0 WILLIS M ILL RD SW 5 R 14595 Real Property Staff Review Form Correction X Exempt Dwelling Ch aracteristic Changes Year Built: 1992 Effective Age: Story Height: 1 Square Feet Living Area: 2,812 Basement (Finished Area): 1200 0 Basement (Unfin. Area): Basement (Rec. Room): 0 Heating & Air: 4 0 Garage: Attic: 0 0 Condition & Desirability: AVERAGE Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: B- Percent Complete: Land Information Square Feet: 57,517 57,517 Acres: 1.3204 1.3204 I Public Prop. Religious Charitable Non-Profit Educational Exemptions & Special Assessments Conservation Use ----Preferrential Asmt. Historic Rehabilitated Transitional Env. Sensitive Notes & Recommendations AFTER FIELD INSPECTION APPRAISER FOUND THE PARCEL TO BE VACANT AS OF 1/1/2015. NEW VALUE IS FAIR AND EQUITABLE. Property Valuation Summary Recommended Current Value Value Land 19,500 0 19,500 Building 153,900 0 0 Accessories 0 0 0 Total 173,400 0 19,500 Date Submitted: 03/26/18 Appraiser: Robert Comer 11/1(? Appraisal Manager: Zachary Mitchell 2dl0 Dep. Chief Appraiser: Tara Parker - r\j,.-, J, ; Form SRF-RE (Rev. 09/06) Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 49

-... -- -- :-:.. -- '~ --![.; :.. -._,.-... AJlJ1JN QlllfTY Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax Distric t: Property Class: Neighborhood: Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: Appeal 2016- PAYTON T C 14 020200060431 FULTO N CO UNTY BOARD OF ASSESSO RS 0 W ILLIS MILL RD SW 5 R 14595 Real Property Staff Review Form Correction X Exempt ---- Dwelling Characteristic Changes Year Built: 1992 Effective Age: NIA Story Height: 1 NJA Square Feet Living Area: 2,812 Basement (Finished Area): 1200 0 Basement (Unfin. Area): NIA Basement (Rec. Room): 0 Heating & Air: 4 0 Garage: Attic: 0 0 Condition & Desirability: AVERAGE NIA Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: B- Percent Complete: Land Information Square Feet: 57,517 57,517 Acres: 1.3204 1.3204 J Public Prop. Religious Charitable Non-Profit ----Educational Exemptions & Special Assessments Conservation Use Preferrentlal Asmt. Historic Rehabilitated Transitional Env. Sensitive Notes & Recommendations AFTER FIELD INSPECTION APPRAISER FOUND THE PARCEL TO BE VACANT AS OF 1/1/2015. NEW VALUE IS FAIR AND EQUITABLE. Property Valuation Su mmary Recommended Current Value Value Land 16,100 0 16,100 Building 153,900 0 0 Accessories 0 0 0 Total 170,000 0 16,100 Date Submitted : 03126/18 Appraiser: Robert Comer t:fk_ Appraisal Manager: Zachary Mitchell '"lin\ Dep. Chief Appraiser: Tara Parker Form SRF RE (Rev. 09/06) Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 50

03/28/2018 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 05 April, 2018 HT536GAFUL CAD Administrative Agenda - Commercial COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES PARCEL ID YEAR APPRAISER OWNER NAME REASON NOTES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE 1 09F-0703-0027-023-6 344 CMSGS INVESTMENTS LLC Land package SEND NOTICE 341,800 343,600 1,800 2 09F-0703-0027-034-3 344 SKYE RISE LLC Land package SEND NOTICE 1,054,500 1,030,900-23,600 3 09F-3500-0132-138-3 071 SOUTH FULTON PARKWAY L L C Right Of Way 21,000,000 21,000,000 0 4 09F-3500-0132-139-1 071 DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY OF Right Of Way 12,508,600 12,508,600 0 5 09F-3500-0151-140-5 071 DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY OF FULTON COUNTY Right Of Way 19,500,000 24,573,600 5,073,600 6 12-1992-0427-089-1 613 GEORGIAS OWN CREDIT UNION Right Of Way 2,443,700 2,443,600-100 7 14-0017-0011-068-6 998 FORD FACTORY SQAURE L P Land Split LAND SPLIT 14 0017 00011 041 3 4,977,900 4,977,900 0 1 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 51

03/28/2018 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 05 April, 2018 HT536GAFUL CAD Administrative Agenda - Commercial COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES PARCEL ID YEAR OWNER NAME REASON NOTES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE 8 14-0017-0011-122-1 998 FORD FACTORY RESIDENTIAL LLC Land Split LAND DIMENSION CHANGE 11,342,100 12,832,700 1,490,600 9 14-0161-0007-008-2 071 TOLES LATONYA Correct improvement value ADJUST LAND AND BUILDING VALUE FOR 269,100 183,000-86,100 10 17-0016- LL-091-6 626 JOHNSON FERRY JOINT VENTURE LLC Right Of Way SEND NOTICE 750,100 682,700-67,400 11 17-0016- LL-168-2 626 JOHNSON FERRY JOINT VENTURE LLC Right Of Way SEND NOTICE 1,052,100 1,002,000-50,100 12 17-0016- LL-313-4 626 JOHNSON FERRY JOINT VENTURE LLC Right Of Way SEND NOTICE 146,200 139,100-7,100 13 17-0035- LL-613-4 626 SLV GEORGIA 4 LLC Right Of Way 7,620,500 7,433,900-186,600 14 17-0107-0002-056-6 069 KOGAN MAX & ASYA Land Split 591,100 68,600-522,500 2 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 52

03/28/2018 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 05 April, 2018 HT536GAFUL CAD Administrative Agenda - Commercial COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES PARCEL ID YEAR OWNER NAME REASON NOTES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE 15 17-0107-0002-057-4 069 KOGAN MAX & ASYA Land Split 0 715,200 715,200 3 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 53

-.... -- --- -- -- ~...,..,..ll ~-... -- IDLTDN COUNTY Tax Year(s): Lead Pat ent Parcel: Lead Property Owner: Lead Situs Address: Tax District: Property C lass: Neighborhood: Action: BldgJSubdivision Name: Field Review Date: FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form 09F 0703 0027 023 6 CMSGS INVESTMENT 0 Senoia Road 25-Fairburn C-3 C810 Land Dimension 03/ 14/17 LAND Reason for Property Review This is an after-digest land eli mens ion change for. Appraisers Notes and Recommendations Property is cu ttently owned by CMSGS Tnvesunents llc. This parcel is the result of a land dimension change resulting in an acreage adjusment fi om 0.9 to 0.9 1. It is currently vacant land. Parent Pa rccl(s): Parcel LD 09F-0703-0027-023-6 09F-0703-0027 -034-3 FMV 34 1,800 1,054.500 1,396,300 New Parccl(s): 09F-0703-0027-023-6 343,600 343,600 Land Size Land Value Building Size SF or acres Per SF or acre Gross or Net Leaseable 39640.00 $8.67 0 v- c Submitted by: Lakeyshia Minniefield ~ Appraisal Manager: _V:...;i~ n.:.:ce:.:n:.:. t...:: C::..::Ia::: r..:..: k'------ Date: Deputy Chief Appraiser: 03/ 19/ 17 Curtis Broden Chief Appraiser: Owi ht Robinson Form R EISRF ~ Rev. 02104 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 54

-. - ~.... -..._ -- ~... :JI ~... ffilidncoukty Tax Year(s): FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form LAND Reason for f>ropet ty Review Lead Parent Parcel: Lead Property Owner: Lead Situs Addt ess : Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Action: Bldg./Subdivision Name: Field Review Date: 09F 0703 0027 023 6 SKYE RISE LLC 7920 Senoia Road 25-Fairburn C-3 C8IO Land Dimension 03/ 14/17 This b an afit:r-digest land dimen ion change tor. Appraisers Notes and Recommendations Property is currently owned by Skye Rise LLC. This parcel is the result of a land dimension change resulting in an acreage adjusunent from 0.87 to 0.7651. It is improved land with Retail-Multiple Occupancy. Parent Parcel(s): ParceiiO 09F-0703-0027-023-6 09F-0703-0027-034-3 FMV 341.800 1.054.500 1,396,300 New Parcel(s): 09F-0703-0027-034-3 1,080,000 1,080,000 Land Size Land Value Building Size SF or acres Per SF or acre Gross or Net Leaseable 33327.00 $11.91 3,206 Submitted by: Lake shia Minniefield \[C Appraisal Manager: _V:...:i~n.=.:ce:.:. n.:.:t...:: C:..::Ia:::r.:..:k _ Date: 031!9/ 17 Deputy Chief Appraber: Curti:. Broden Cltief Appraiser: Dwight Robinson Form REISRF-L Rev. 02/04 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 55

-..., ---.-- ~ _.,. 1:..:...-..,. 31 ~-... FULJON COUHTY Tax Year(s): FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property StaiTReview Form LAND Reason for Property Review Lead Parent Parcel: Lead Property Owner: Lead Situs Address: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Action: BldgJSubdivision Name: Field Review Date: 09F-3500-0132-138-3 South Fulton Parkway 4950 Mason Rd 50 C5 C801 Right of Way 01/23/ 18 Right of Way Appraisers Notes and Recommendations Right of Way per document attached. Subject parcel has been reduced!tom 41.57acres to 39.1332 acres. ll1e land package was worked after the notice was sent. Although the 299c was removed and the property characteristics changed. there was no change in the overall value of property. TI1e value remained at $2 1,000,000. Parcci i D Parent Parcel(s): 09F-3500-0132-138-3 FMV $21,000,000 S21,000,000 New Parccl(s): U9F -35110-0 132-1 31!-3 $21,000,000 Land Si:.e Land Value Building Size I Gross SqFt/AC Per- SqFt/AC Gross I Net Leasable 39.1332 $52,858 669, 152 S2 1,000,000 Submined by: Date: Osbourne Harrison ~ 02/01/ 18 Appraisal Manager: Deputy Chief Appraiser: Curtis Broden Chief Appraiser: Dwight Robinson, Form REtSRF L Rev 02104 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 56

-... ~- -- -... <# ~ -... - -- -- -- L: _.,. Jl ~-... AIUUNCOUHTY Ta.~ Year(s): FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form LAND Reason for Property Review Lead Parent Puree!: Lead Property Owner: Lead Situs Address: Tax District: Property Class: 1' eighborhood: Action: Bldg./Subdivision Name: field Review Date: 09F-3500-0 132-139-1 Development Authority 4950 Mason Rd 50 15 C801 Right of Way 01/23/18 Right of Way Appraisers Notes and Recommendations Right of Way per document attached. Subject parcel has been reduced from 31.97 acres to 31.5375 acres. 'The overall characteristics of the property derived a value of$12.508,600. Parent Purcc1(s): 09F-3500-0132-138-3 s 12,508,600 s 12.508,600 New Pnrcel(s): 09F -3500-0 132-138-3 s 12,508,600 Laud Si:.e Laud Value Buildiug Size I Gross SqFt I AC Per- St1Ft!AC Gross I Net Leasable 31.5375 S56.568 546.520 s 12,508,600 Submitted by: Osbourne Harrison t.jpc- Appraisal Manager: Vincent Clark VV Date: 02/01118 Deputy Chief Appraiser: Curtis Broden Chief Appraiser: Dwioht Robinson Form REISRF l Rc. 02104 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 57

-- -- -- -~,.-- -..... - -.. L.,. :. ~...- FUUUNCDUHTY Tax Year(s): 20 17 FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form LAND Reason for Property Review Lead Parent Parcel: Lead Property Owner: Lend Situs Address: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Action: Bldg./Subdivision Name: Field Review Date: 09F-3500-0151-140-5 Development Authority 4475 South Fulton Pkwy 50 [5 C801 Right of Way 01 /23/18 Right of Way Appraisers Notes and Recommendations Right ofway per document attached. Subject parcel has been increased from 63.3 1 acres to 68.14 acres. Due to overall changes in characteristics of property. the value increased trom $19,500,000 to $24.573,600. Parent Parcel(s): 09F-3500-0151-1.10-5 s 19,500,000 s 19,500,000 New P:trcel(s): 09F -3500-01 51-1.10-5 $24,573,600 Lam/ S i::e Land Value Building Si:.e I Gross S f1ft I AC Per-SqFt/AC Gross INet Leasable 68.14 $46,68 1 773.776 $24,573.600 Submitted by: Osbourne Harrison pt!:- Appraisal Manager: Vincent Clark L(L/ Date: 0210 Il ls Deputy Chief Appraiser: Curtis Broden Chief Appraiser: Form REISRF-t Ro~. 02104 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 58

- - _... - ~ ----.._ -- -- L: -~.ll ~... -- FULJDNCOUID Tax Year(s): Lead Par ent Parcel: Lead Property Owner: Lead Situs Address: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Action: BldgJSubdivision Name: Field Review Date: FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property StaiJRcvicw Form LAND Reason for Property Re~ iew 12-1992-0427-089-1 'll1is is an after-digest land Right of Way for. GEORGL'-\S OWN CREDIT UNlOf' I 184 Alpharella Street 45 C-3 Cl l5 Land Right of Way 11121117 Appraisers Notes and Recommendations TI1is is a piece of land that decreased!tom.6979ac to.6431 ac due to a right of way located at 1184 Alpharetta. Street in Roswell. The value decreased slightly. Parent Parccl(s): Parcci!D 12-1992.0-127-089-1 FMV s 2,-143.700 Total s 2.-1-13,700 New Parccl(s): 12-1992.Q-127.089-I s 2.-1-13,600 fora I s 2,443,600 1 Land Size Land Value Building Size SF or acres Per SF or acre Gross or Net Leaseable 0.6431 512.56/sf 7,036 Submitted by: 03/1 9118 Deputy Chief Appraiser: Curtis Broden Chief Appraiser: Dwinht Robinson Form REISRF L Rov. 02/04 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 59

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form ffiudh COUHTY Tax Year(s): LAND Reason for Property Review Lead Parent Parcel: 14 0017 0011 068 6 LAND PACKAGE REQUEST- SPLIT Lead Property Owner: Lead Situs Address: Tnx District: Property C lass: Neighborhood: Action: Bldg./Subdivision Name: Field Review Date: FORD FACfORY RESlDENTlAL LLC 699 PONCE DELEON AVE cos C4 CA02 Appraisers Notes nnd Recommendations Land package consist of a multi occupany retail building which has 14 1,088 square feet and an apartment which consist of 122 units. Map change request consisted of spliting 2.2488 acres of land over two parcels. The parcels listed are 14 0017 0011 122 at 1.8256 and 14 0017 0011 068 6 at.83754. ParcciiD Parent Parcel(s): 14 0017 00 11 068 6 14 00 17 00 II 122 I Fl\IV 4,977,900 11,342, 100 - t New Parcel(s): 14 00 17 00 I I 068 6 1400 170011 0122 1 16,320,000 4,977,900 12,832,700 Lmtd Si:e Land Value Building Size I Gross SoFt / AC Per- SoFt/AC Gross!Net Leasable 1 7,810,6~ Submitted by: Sharon Y Williams Appraisal Manager: Vincent Clark Date: 11/27/ 17 Appraisal Manager: Deputy Chief Appraiser: Cunis Broden Form REISRF l. Rev 0210' Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 60

-- -..: '= 1:,; - --.:JI =---=-= FUITOX COUNTY Twc Yca~s) : Parcel ID Property Owner Situs Address Tax District Property Class Neighborhood Action Code Bldg./Subdivision Name Formal Appeal I 4-0 I 6 I -0007-008-2 Toles Latonya 3710 Main St 15Z C3 C913 Value Adjustment Kids Salon FULTON COUNTY BOARI> OF ASSESSORS REAL PROPERTY STAFF REVlEW FORM Error Correction Assessment exceeds market value. xxxxx Reason fo r Property Rc,icw Appraisers.-;otcs :111d Recommendations The subject property is in need of deferred maintenance such as roof, porch and siding. Adjustments were made to the overnll condition of the property, which reduce.."<.! the building value. Recommend the BOA accept the value of$ 183,000. Contact Date: I /22120 18 Contact Number: 470-808-7508 Agent I Owner: Toles Latonya Field Review Date: 218120 18 Land Building Current $123,900 $ 145,200 Rccomntcntlrd $ 108,000 $75,000 Lam/ Si:e Land Value Buildinu Si:e I Gross or Net per square foot 9,000 $ 12.00 2,4 13 TOTAL 269,100 183,000 Submitted by: Osbourne Harrison f'k Appraisal ~lanager Vincent Clark Date: 2/14/2018 Deputy Chief Appraiser: Curtis Broden Chief Appraiser: Dwight Robinson( Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 61 G

-- --...---..,_ '-..: -- ""' :Jill ~-... RlllDN COUNTY Tax Year(s): -. -- -- lend Parent Parcel: Lead Property Owner: Lend Situs Address: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Action: Bldg./Subdivision Name: Field Review Date: FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form 17-0016-LL-091-6.Johnson Ferry,Joint Ventu re LLC 1430 South.Johnson Ferry Rd. 59 Sandy Springs c C203 Right-of-Way 01/02/18 LAND Right-of-Wny Reason for Property Review Appraisers Notes and Recommendations Dimension change from.482ac to.3488ac per deed for a Right-of-Way on South Johnson Ferry Rd.. ParcciiD Parent Parcel(s): 17-0016-LL-091-6 FMV 750,100 750.100 New Parcel(s): 17-00 16-Ll-091-6 682,700 Lam/ Si:.e Land Value Building Si:.e I Gross SqFtl AC Per- SaFt!AC Gross!Net Leasable 15 194 s.r. $44.93/s.f. 682,700 Submitted by: Leslie R. Askelv Appraisal Manager: Core:v McDnnieltvt_ Date: 03/19/18 Deputy Chief Appraiser: C urtis Broden Chief Appraiser: Form REtSil F-l. Rev 02104 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 62

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form LAND lead Parent Parcel: lead Property Owner: Lead Situs Address: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Action: Bldg./Subdivision Name: Field Review Date: 17-0016-LL-168-2 Nap Pill HiU LLC 1160 Johnson Ferry Rd. 598 Sandy Springs c C203 Right-of-Way 01/02/18 Right-of-Way Reason for Property Review Appraisers Notes and Recommendations Dimension change from 2.924AC to 2.7834AC per deed fot a Right-of-Way on Johnson Ferry Rd. ParcciiD Parent Parcel(s): 17-0016-LL-168-2 FM V 1,052,1 (}() 1,052,100 :-.lew Parcel(s): 17-00 16-LL-168-2 1,002,000 Land Si:,e Land Value Building Si:.e I Gross S Ft I AC Per- St. Ft/AC Gross Net Leasable 121,245/s.f. 8.26/s.f 1,002,000 Submitted by: Leslie R. Askew Appraisal Manager: Corey.\lcDaniel r:ji'v Date: 03/ 19/ 18 Deputy C hief Appraiser : Curtis Broden Form REJSRF L Rev. 02104 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 63

-... ~ - ---... --... -- L-..,..=- ~... fuodn COUNTY Tax Year(s) : FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form LAND Reason for Property Review Lead Parent Parcel: Lead Property Owner: Lead Situs Address: Tax District: Property Class: l'ieigbborhood: Action: Bldg./Subdivision Name: Field Review Date: 17-0016-LL-313--t Johnson Ferry.Joint Venture LLC Old.Johnson Ferry Rd. 59 Sa ndy S prin~ c C203 Right-of-Way Ol/02/18 Right-of-Way Appraisers Notes and Recommendations Dilnension change from.62-tac to.5478ac per deed for a Right-of-Way on Old Johnson Fen: Rd. Parcel 10 Parent Parcel(s): J 7-00 16-LL-3 13-4 FMV 146,200 146,200 New Parcel(s): 17-00 16-LL-313-4 139,100 Lund Size Land Value Building Size I Gross St1Ft I AC Per- SoFt/AC Gross I Net Leasable 23862 s.f. 5.83/s.f 139,100 Submitted by: Appraisal Manager: Corev McDaniel f)f"" Date: 03/19/18 Deputy C hief Appraiser: Curtis Broden Chief Appraiser: Form REISRF L Rav. 02/04 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 64

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form LAND Tax Year(s): Lead Parent Parcel: Lead Prope1 ty Owner: Lead Situs Address: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Action: Bldg./Subdivision Name: Field Review Date: 201 7 17-0035-LL-613-4 SLY GEORGIA 4 LLC 6500 Glcnridge Dr 59-Sandy Springs C-5 C205 Right-of-Way ll/30/ 17 Reason for Property Review This is an after-digest right of way change for 20 17. Appraisers Notes and Recommendations Parce11and size was adjusted on a vacant piece ofland to account for the.65 acres split to right-of-way. Recommend that an assessment notice be sent tor to reflect the new value. Pa rcel LD FMV Parent Parccl(s): 17-0035-LL-613-4 7,620,500 7,620,500 New Parcel(s): 17-0035-LL-613-4 7,433,900 7,433.900 Land Size Land Value Building Size SF or acres Per S F or acre Gross or Net Leaseable 25.812AC 288,002/AC Submined by: Date: Leslie R. Askew 03/ 19/18 Appraisal Manager: Corey McDaniel cat;(_ Deputy Chief Appraiser: Curtis Broden Chief Appraiser: Fonn REJSRF-l Rev. 0210<1 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 65

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form FULJDN COUNTY Tax Year(s): Lead Parent Parcel: Lead Property Owner: Lead Situs Address: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Action: BldgJSubdivision Name: Field Review Date: 17 0 I 07-0002-056-6 KOGAN MAX & ASYA 0 Westshire 05-Atlanta C-3 CBOI LS 03/ 19/ 18 LAND Reason for Property Review This i:; an atler-digest land split for 20 17. Appraisers Notes and Recommendations Subject parent parcel was split to create two parcels 056-6 and 057-4, which is a 6 unit multi-family property. The Land split has created 2 parcels with the acreage of.l4 AC and.15 AC one of which has the improvement and the 01her with just vacant land. Parcel ID FMV Parent Parccl(s): I 7 0 I 07-0002-056-6 $ 591, 100.00 17 0107-0002-057-4 $ 591,100 New Parcel(s): Submitted by: 17 0 I 07-0002-056-6 17 0107-0002-057-4 68.6011 7 15.200 783,800 Jer maine Tomlinson Land Size Land Value SF or acres Per SF or acre 48,838 65.52 psf Building Size Gross or Net Leasable 48,838 sf vo Appraisal Manager:...:\...:'i;.:.nc=..:e:..:.. n:..:..t-=c:..:.: Ia::.r;.:.k Date: 03/ 19/ 18 Deputy Chief Appraiser:.9:!_nis - :..:..:.::...~--0~~ Broden ~ v Chief Appraiser: Form RE/SRF l Rev. 02/04 Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 66

-- -... 4> ~-......... _ L..:-..- 2 ~... RILJDN COUNTY Tax Year(s): FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form LAND Reason for Property Review Lead Parent Parcel: Lead Property Owner: Lead Situs Address: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Action: Bldg./Subdivision Name: Field Review Date: 17 0 I 07-0002-057-4 KOGAN MA.-'< & ASY A 0 Westshire 05-Atlanta C-3 CB01 LS 03/1 9/18 This is an after-digest land split fo r. Appraisers Notes and Recommendations Subject parent parcel was split to create two parcels 056-6 and 057-4, which is a 6 unit multi- fiuni ly property. The Land split has created 2 parcels with the acreage of.14 AC and.15 AC one of which has the improvement and the other with just vacant land. ParcciiD FMV Parent Parccl{s): 17 0 I 07-0002-056-6 s 591.100.00 17 0107-0002-057-4 $ 591.100 New Parccl(s): 17 0 I 07-0002-056-6 17 0 I 07-0002-05 7-~ 68,600 715,200 Land Size Land Value SF or acres Per SF or acre 48,838 65.52 psf Building Size Gross or Net Leasable 48,838 sf 783,800 Submitted by: Date: Jermaine Tomlinson 03/ 19118 Appraisal Manager:...:V...:i::..:.nc::..:e::..n::. t..::c:.:.:la::..:.r::..:.k _ Deputy Chief Appraiser: Curtis Broden Chief Appraiser: DwioJn Robinson Form REISRF l Rev. 02J'Od Fulton BOA Meeting - 04-05-18 - Page 67