HONG KONG MONTHLY RESEARCH FEBRUARY 2016 REVIEW AND COMMENTARY ON HONG KONG'S PROPERTY MARKET

Similar documents
HONG KONG MONTHLY RESEARCH JANUARY 2018 REVIEW AND COMMENTARY ON HONG KONG'S PROPERTY MARKET

HONG KONG MONTHLY RESEARCH NOVEMBER 2015 REVIEW AND COMMENTARY ON HONG KONG'S PROPERTY MARKET

HONG KONG MONTHLY RESEARCH APRIL 2018 REVIEW AND COMMENTARY ON HONG KONG'S PROPERTY MARKET. Office Decentralisation and relocation continue

HONG KONG MONTHLY REVIEW AND COMMENTARY ON HONG KONG'S PROPERTY MARKET

HONG KONG MONTHLY RESEARCH FEBRUARY 2018 REVIEW AND COMMENTARY ON HONG KONG'S PROPERTY MARKET

HONG KONG MONTHLY RESEARCH NOVEMBER 2017 REVIEW AND COMMENTARY ON HONG KONG'S PROPERTY MARKET

HONG KONG MONTHLY RESEARCH DECEMBER 2017 REVIEW AND COMMENTARY ON HONG KONG'S PROPERTY MARKET

HONG KONG MONTHLY RESEARCH MARCH 2018 REVIEW AND COMMENTARY ON HONG KONG'S PROPERTY MARKET. Office Prime site in West Kowloon under spotlight

HONG KONG MONTHLY RESEARCH NOVEMBER 2016 REVIEW AND COMMENTARY ON HONG KONG'S PROPERTY MARKET

HONG KONG MONTHLY RESEARCH DECEMBER 2016 REVIEW AND COMMENTARY ON HONG KONG'S PROPERTY MARKET

HONG KONG MONTHLY RESEARCH OCTOBER 2015 REVIEW AND COMMENTARY ON HONG KONG'S PROPERTY MARKET. Office Grade-A office vacancy rates even lower

HONG KONG MONTHLY RESEARCH MAY 2018 REVIEW AND COMMENTARY ON HONG KONG'S PROPERTY MARKET. Office More consolidation activity in Kowloon East

HONG KONG MONTHLY RESEARCH MAY 2016 REVIEW AND COMMENTARY ON HONG KONG'S PROPERTY MARKET

HONG KONG MONTHLY RESEARCH JUN 2017 REVIEW AND COMMENTARY ON HONG KONG'S PROPERTY MARKET

HONG KONG PRIME OFFICE Monthly Report

Hong Kong Prime Office Monthly Report. October 2011 RESEARCH NON-CORE DISTRICTS LEAD THE MARKET

Hong Kong Prime Office Monthly Report. September 2011 RESEARCH NON-CORE DISTRICTS LEAD THE MARKET

HONG KONG PRIME OFFICE Monthly Report

Hong Kong Prime Office Monthly Report. August 2011 RESEARCH LEASING ACTIVITY ROBUST DESPITE VOLITILITY

HONG KONG PRIME OFFICE Monthly Report

Hong Kong Monthly. January 2014 RESEARCH REVIEW AND COMMENTARY ON HONG KONG'S PROPERTY MARKET. OFFICE Activity subdued during the holiday season

April 2012 Hong Kong monthly

HONG KONG PRIME OFFICE Monthly Report

June 2012 Hong Kong Monthly

July 2012 Hong Kong Monthly

Hong Kong Monthly REVIEW AND COMMENTARY ON HONG KONG'S PROPERTY MARKET

Hong Kong Monthly REVIEW AND COMMENTARY ON HONG KONG'S PROPERTY MARKET

HONG KONG Luxury Residential Monthly Report

HONG KONG MONTHLY RESEARCH OCTOBER 2018 REVIEW AND COMMENTARY ON HONG KONG S PROPERTY MARKET

HONG KONG Luxury Residential Monthly Report

February 2013 Hong Kong Monthly

Hong Kong Monthly REVIEW AND COMMENTARY ON HONG KONG'S PROPERTY MARKET

HONG KONG Luxury Residential Monthly Report

HONG KONG Luxury Residential Monthly Report

HONG KONG Luxury Residential Monthly Report

HONG KONG Luxury Residential Monthly Report

HONG KONG Luxury Residential Monthly Report

HONG KONG. April 2011 RESEARCH. Japan disasters affect hk home sales. Monthly Report

Property Investment. 1. Two IFC, Central 2. International Commerce Centre, Kowloon Station 3. East Point City, Tseung Kwan O 4.

HONG KONG Luxury Residential Monthly Report

SUN HUNG KAI PROPERTIES LIMITED ANNUAL REPORT 2001/02

CHINA AND HONG KONG RESIDENTIAL MARKETS. by Knight Frank and Holdways 10 December 2014

Gross Rental Income* Gross Rental Income* by Sector

Property Investment. International Commerce Centre, Kowloon Station 38 SUN HUNG KAI PROPERTIES LIMITED

Road to regaining Balance? Hong Kong office market in 2020

Rents diverge in core and non-core areas. Figure 1. Retail rent performance diverged within the 2015F

FY2013 Annual Results. 26 September New World One Step Forward We Create New Living Experience

PROPERTY INSIGHTS. Market Overview. Retail rents in core markets plunged further. Citigold Private Client. Hong Kong Quarter 3, 2015

Hong Kong Office MarketView

PROPERTY INSIGHTS. Market Overview. Buoyant office take-up in CBD. Hong Kong Quarter 2, DTZ office rental index (Q =100)

Growing at a Slower Pace

BUILDING FOR THE BETTER CHINA. Hong Kong

Hong Kong Office MarketView

New World One Step Forward. We Create New Living Experience. FY2014 Annual Results 24 Sep 2014

Delia Memorial School (Hip Wo) Guidance notes on filling Student s Particulars Record

Hong Kong Office MarketView

FOR VIBRANT LIFESTYLES THE REACH, YUEN LONG, HONG KONG

market A Rebound in research & forecast report colliers international HONG KONG 3Q 2012 market overview

colliers international HONG KONG A Mild Correction

HK Island Central. Central / Admiralty / Sheung Wan Admiralty Centre ifc (International Finance Centre) (One & Two) Shanghai Commercial Bank Building

Briefing Residential sales June 2018

Appendix: List of CLP Power s EV charging stations (14 December 2018)

Project Summary Major Property Development Projects in Hong Kong. Project Summary Major Property Development Projects in Hong Kong.

market Strong Investment Demand research & forecast report colliers international HONG KONG 4Q 2012 market overview

Kowloon Region. Unit No. District Meeting Venue & Contact Tel. Meeting Time. The Salvation Army Chuk Yuen Children and Youth Centre

Monthly update of MTR facilities for passengers with disabilities December 2017

S.F. Service Points Update Notice

MTR Transformation of CBDs in Hong Kong

Selection Method for Shaw College Student Hostel Places 2014/2015 (Second draft)

The highly distinctive Manulife Financial Centre sets a precedent for the regeneration of the older districts of Hong Kong, providing over one

香港物業管理公司協會有限公司 The Hong Kong Association of Property Management Companies Limited

PROPERTY ANNUAL REPORT

Gross Floor Area of HOS Flat by Phase / Estate

18 D Shop D & Portion of Shop B, G/F, B. 16 B Shop B, G/F and Shop A2 & A3, Upper G/F, A2

Selection Method for Shaw College Student Hostel Places 2017/2018 (First Draft)

Selection Method for Shaw College Student Hostel Places 2016/2017 (Final Version)

Self Service Terminal Service Hour Hong Kong District Branch

Annual Results SEHK Stock Code: 127

Hong Kong Property Business

FY2015 Annual Results 24 Sep 2015 THE ARTISANAL MOVEMENT

Summaries. FY2015 Interim Results 27 Feb 2015

Collection Point Address

CLP Power Extends Electric Vehicle Charging Network as Popularity of Green Motoring Accelerates

Will The Downtrend End Sooner

S.F. Express Circle K Convenience Store Self-pickup Service Service Coverage: Kowloon

HONG KONG EXAMINATIONS AND ASSESSMENT AUTHORITY 2019 HONG KONG DIPLOMA OF SECONDARY EDUCATION EXAMINATION ENGLISH LANGUAGE

Selection Method for Shaw College Student Hostel Places 2017/2018 (Second Draft)

Merchants Offers Details and Merchant's Additional Terms and Conditions Contact Details. 10% off on eligible hotels booking at Expedia website

Industrial rents shrug off retail market slowdown to reach new high

Unopened Space: Mapping Equitable Availability of Open Space in Hong Kong Press Conference Report by Carine Lai

SHOP NAME ADDRESS Tel No. Fax No. SHOP G2, AON CHINA BUILDING, 29 QUEEN'S ROAD CENTRAL, CENTRAL, H.K.

BANK OF CHINA LIMITED (A joint stock company incorporated in the People s Republic of China with limited liability) Stock Code: 3988

From Western District to Airport

MTR to work closely and align with the Government on announcement mechanism in relation to Railway Protection Area

Shaw College Selection Method for Student Hostel Places 2018/2019 (1st Draft)

HONG KONG LAND ONLY. Travel Period : 01 Oct 2018 ~ 02 Jan fr. S$150

Property Development 26 SUN HUNG KAI PROPERTIES LIMITED. Manhattan Hill, West Kowloon

S.F. Service Points Update Notice

New Business Districts Why Success or Failure

GREATER CHINA Quarterly

Transcription:

RESEARCH FEBRUARY 2016 HONG KONG MONTHLY REVIEW AND COMMENTARY ON HONG KONG'S PROPERTY MARKET Office Economic uncertainties to affect demand sustainability Residential Home sales hit 25-year low following US interest-rate rise Retail Big-ticket retail property sales to remain active

MARKET HIGHLIGHTS The Grade-A office market continues to polarise, with Mainland Chinese firms remaining the pillar of leasing demand and some multinational corporations downsizing. Residential sales in the first month of 2016 hit a 25-year low, with the market anticipating an increase in supply and rising mortgage rates to cause a fall in prices. 2016 is set to be another difficult year for retail, with diminishing tourist numbers and spending. Retail leasing will be slow, but more non-prime shopping arcade space could change hands. TABLE 1 Economic indicators and forecasts Economic indicator Period Latest reading 2012 2013 2014 GDP growth Q3 2015 +2.3%# +1.7% +2.9% +2.3% Inflation rate Dec 2015 +2.5% +4.1% +4.3% +4.4% Unemployment Oct Dec 2015 3.3%# 3.1% 3.3% 3.2% Prime lending rate Current 5 5.25% 5%* 5%* 5%* FIGURE 1 Grade-A office prices and rents Jan 2007 = 100 250 230 210 190 170 150 130 110 90 70 PRICE INDEX RENTAL INDEX 50 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Source: EIU CountryData / Census & Statistics Department / Knight Frank Research # Provisional * HSBC prime lending rate Prime Office The polarisation in the Grade-A office leasing market has grown more apparent. On the one hand, demand continued to be driven by Mainland Chinese firms. For example last month, a Mainland firm reportedly leased a high-floor premise in a premium building in at a record high rental rate after the financial crisis. On the other hand, a number of multinational corporations have been downsizing or even retreating from Hong Kong amid uncertainties in the local and global economies. In the near future, we expect the Grade-A office market to become more polarised, especially in. While premium Grade-A office buildings will continue to attract Mainland firms, given their quality, reputation and sea views, traditional Grade-A buildings in the district will see weaker demand. Grade-A office market is likely to continue outperforming other property sectors, the increasing challenges facing the Hong Kong and Mainland economies could add uncertainty to the sustainability of office demand. We expect office rents in core business areas, which have already been at high levels, to remain largely stable in 2016. The extremely low vacancy rates may also reverse if there are more downsizing and surrender cases. Meanwhile, Grade-A office rents in Kowloon East are likely to decline this year, with abundant supply in the pipeline, while those in Tsim Sha Tsui and Mong Kok are expected to remain firm or slightly increase, with supply continuing to be limited. Looking ahead, although the 2

HONG KONG MONTHLY RESEARCH FIGURE 2 Luxury residential prices and rents Jan 2007 = 100 190 170 150 130 110 90 70 50 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 FIGURE 3 Retail property prices and rents Jan 2007 = 100 400 350 300 250 200 150 100 PRICE INDEX RENTAL INDEX 50 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Source: Rating and Valuation Department / Knight Frank Research Note: Provisional figures from Jul 2015 to Dec 2015 Residential According to the Land Registry, only 2,045 residential sales transactions were recorded in the first month of 2016, following the US interest-rate rise in December 2015. Volume plunged 68.1% year on year, hitting the lowest monthly level in 25 years. Residential sales value in January slumped to HK$15.8 billion, a 63.4% decline from January 2015. Buyers took a wait-and-see attitude amid various uncertainties in both local and external markets. After the US interest-rate hike in December, mortgage rates in Hong Kong are expected to rise in the next few months. Developers may have to offer more attractive prices and incentives, especially in the New Territories, where supply will be abundant. In December 2015, mass residential prices still increased 2.7% from December 2014, while luxury residential prices dropped only around 1%, compared with the 13.8% and 6.4% growth in 2014 for mass and luxury prices respectively, according to the Rating and Valuation Department. Home prices are expected to decrease further this year, with mass residential prices dropping 5-10% and luxury home prices falling up to 5%, amid the US interest-rate hike and the projected increase in residential supply. Retail Hong Kong s retail market saw further deterioration before the Lunar New Year, amid a double-digit decline in visitor arrivals and weaker growth prospects in the local and Mainland economies. Total retail sales value in December 2015 decreased 8.5% year on year, the deepest monthly drop since January 2015. Again, the jewellery, watches and clocks, and valuable gifts category suffered the biggest drop 17.0% year on year (Table 13). As sales declined, many luxury brands suspended the opening of new shops or downsized existing stores. Therefore, demand for small shops was relatively robust in core retail areas. Meanwhile, the retail property sales market saw a number of arcade transactions last month. Looking ahead, the retail market will remain challenging in 2016 as the appreciation of the Hong Kong dollar against the RMB and other major Asian currencies, such as the Japanese yen, could further reduce Hong Kong s attractiveness to visitors. The weak job and stock markets may also harm consumer sentiment in the near term. We expect to see more big-ticket retail property sales transactions in 2016 as some developers and corporations offload part of their retail properties to deleverage their balance sheets in anticipation of future interest-rate rises. 3

SNAPSHOT PRIME OFFICE There were only a few major office sales transactions in January 2016. AXA leased office space of around 50,000 sq ft in Vertical SQ in Wong Chuk Hang last month. TABLE 2 Selected office sales transactions District Building Zone Sheung Wan Kowloon Bay Shun Tak Centre China Merchants Tower Billion Centre Block A Gross floor area (sq ft) Price (HK$ million) Price (HK$ per sq ft) High N/A $77.1 N/A Low N/A $41.0 N/A Cheung Sha Wan Excel Centre High 5,961 $54.8 $9,193 Sheung Wan Nam Wo Hong Building Mid 4,928 $41.8 $8,480 Source: Economic Property Research Centre TABLE 3 Selected office leasing transactions District Building Zone Floor area (sq ft) Wong Chuk Hang Vertical SQ Mid 49,350 (G) Kowloon Bay One Kowloon Low & high 35,295 (G) Kwun Tong One Harbour Square High 17,153 (G) Bank of China Tower Mid 12,221 (L) 4

HONG KONG MONTHLY RESEARCH SNAPSHOT Grade-A office rents increased in most major business districts in January 2016. TABLE 4 Month-on-month movement of Grade-A office rents (Jan 2016) / Admiralty Wan Chai / Causeway Bay Quarry Bay Tsim Sha Tsui Kowloon East Grade-A office prices dropped slightly in most major commercial areas last month. TABLE 5 Prime office market indicators (Jan 2016) Net effective rent Change Price Change District Premium Traditional Overall HK$ psf / mth Dec 15 Oct 15 Jan 15 HK$ psf Dec 15 Oct 15 Jan 15 $170.8 0.4% 4.2% 11.5% n/a n/a n/a n/a $117.4 0.1% 2.9% 14.4% n/a n/a n/a n/a $135.9 0.2% 3.5% 13.1% $26,927-0.6% -0.6% 3.5% Admiralty $97.5 1.5% 4.3% 16.8% $22,202-0.5% -1.5% -0.1% Sheung Wan $79.9 1.1% 4.6% 22.3% $19,842-0.4% -1.8% -4.3% Wan Chai $71.4 0.1% 1.5% 9.9% $19,503-0.5% -1.3% 3.5% Causeway Bay $76.9 0.2% 2.5% 12.6% $20,050 0.0% -1.2% 4.6% North Point $53.9-0.5% 0.9% 12.5% n/a n/a n/a n/a Quarry Bay $57.1-0.1% 0.4% 8.4% n/a n/a n/a n/a Tsim Sha Tsui Cheung Sha Wan $63.6 1.3% 1.1% 15.8% $12,664 0.0% -1.5% -0.1% $29.1 1.7% 0.4% 0.3% n/a n/a n/a n/a Hung Hom $30.7-0.9% -3.9% -13.8% n/a n/a n/a n/a Kowloon East Mong Kok / Yau Ma Tei $34.1-0.2% -0.5% -0.1% $10,970 0.0% -1.6% -6.8% $52.8 0.0% 1.4% 4.0% n/a n/a n/a n/a Rents and prices are subject to revision. 5

SNAPSHOT RESIDENTIAL Last month, a number of major luxury residential sales were recorded in Mid-Levels West. A number of large units were leased in traditional luxury residential districts in January. TABLE 6 Selected residential sales transactions District Mid-Levels West Mid-Levels West Building Tower / floor / unit Saleable area (sq ft) Price (HK$ million) Price (HK$ psf) 39 Conduit Road High floor unit 5,732 $594.76 $103,762 55 Conduit Road Low floor unit 3,235 $149.03 $46,068 Mid-Levels West Kennedy Town 55 Conduit Road Mid floor unit 2,548 $105.18 $41,279 Imperial Kennedy High floor unit 1,179 $40.97 $34,750 Source: Economic Property Research Centre TABLE 7 Selected residential leasing transactions District Happy Valley The Peak Mid-Levels Pokfulam Island South Building Tower / floor / unit Saleable area (sq ft) Monthly rent (HK$) Monthly rent (HK$ psf) Leighton Hill Mid floor unit 924 $59,000 $63.9 7 Mount Kellett Road Low floor unit 2,382 $145,064 $60.9 The Mayfair High floor unit 2,169 $128,000 $59.0 Residence Bel-Air Hong Kong Parkview Mid floor unit 1,376 $68,000 $49.4 High floor unit 2,067 $92,000 $44.5 6

HONG KONG MONTHLY RESEARCH SNAPSHOT Rents continued to fall in all five major luxury residential districts in January. TABLE 8 Month-on-month movement of luxury residential rents (Jan 2016) The Peak Island South Mid-Levels Jardine s Lookout / Happy Valley Pokfulam Last month, residential prices fell in most major luxury areas. TABLE 9 Luxury residential market indicators (Jan 2016) Rent Change Price Change District HK$ psf / mth Dec 15 Oct 15 Jan 15 HK$ psf Dec 15 Oct 15 Jan 15 The Peak $62.0-3.0% -5.9% -6.6% $40,091 0.0% -1.6% -3.1% Island South Mid- Levels Jardine s Lookout / Happy Valley $49.7-2.0% -4.0% -2.1% $28,463 0.0% 0.0% -10.8% $53.5-5.0% -6.9% -3.0% $25,820-0.7% -2.5% -2.7% $49.1-2.0% -4.0% -2.3% $25,977-0.8% -1.4% 2.5% Pokfulam $36.3-5.0% -6.9% -5.4% $24,015-0.4% -1.5% -0.5% Rents and prices are subject to revision. 7

SNAPSHOT RETAIL A number of shopping arcade units were sold in non-core retail districts. A number of small shop units were leased in core retail districts in January. TABLE 10 Selected retail sales transactions District Building Floor / unit Saleable floor area (sq ft) Price (HK$ million) Price (HK$ psf) Tai Po Jade Plaza L1 / unit 23 1,566 $80.8 $51,596 Tsim Sha Tsui Empress Plaza Basement 4,321 $75.0 $17,357 Kwai Chung Sun Kwai Hing Shopping Arcade Ground to third floor units 50,246 $503.0 $10,011 Tseung Kwan O Parkside Shopping arcade N/A $510.0 N/A Source: Economic Property Research Centre TABLE 11 Selected retail leasing transactions District Building Floor / unit Saleable floor area (sq ft) Monthly rent (HK$) Monthly rent (HK$ psf) Causeway Bay Ying Kong Mansion Ground floor / unit 1 273 $665,000 $2435.9 Mong Kok Far East Bank Mongkok Building Ground floor / unit 2 229 (G) $400,000 $1,746.7 Mong Kok 66-68 Sai Yeung Choi Street South Ground floor / unit 66 N/A $638,000 N/A Lyndhurst Building Ground floor / unit E6 N/A $630,000 N/A Source: Economic Property Research Centre 8

HONG KONG MONTHLY RESEARCH SNAPSHOT Prime street shop rents decreased across all major retail districts in January 2016. TABLE 12 Month-on-month movement of prime street shop rents (Jan 2016) Causeway Bay Tsim Sha Tsui Mong Kok The total retail sales value in 2015 decreased 3.7% year on year to HK$475.2 billion. TABLE 13 Retail sales by outlet type (Dec 2015) Value Share of total Change Outlet (HK$ billion) % Nov 15 Sep 15 Dec 14 Jewellery, watches and clocks and valuable gifts Clothing, footwear and allied products $8.0 18.3% 20.8% 34.0% -17.0% $6.0 13.8% 32.4% 54.9% -11.6% Department stores $5.0 11.5% 0.8% 41.8% -12.3% Fuel $0.7 1.7% 0.5% -3.5% -3.5% Food, alcoholic drinks and tobacco (excluding supermarkets) $3.6 8.3% 8.4% -11.3% 1.1% Consumer durable goods $7.9 18.2% 9.5% 21.1% -8.3% Supermarkets $4.4 10.1% 6.0% 1.1% 3.6% Others $7.9 18.0% 23.0% 31.2% -4.5% All retail outlets $43.7 100.0% 14.7% 24.0% -8.5% Source: Census and Statistics Department / Knight Frank Research 9

RESEARCH & CONSULTANCY David Ji Director Head of Research & Consultancy Greater China +852 2846 9552 david.ji@hk.knightfrank.com Pamela Tsui Senior Manager Research & Consultancy Greater China +852 2846 4843 pamela.tsui@hk.knightfrank.com CONTACTS Alan Child Chairman +852 2846 9522 alan.child@hk.knightfrank.com Piers Brunner Chief Executive Officer Greater China +852 2846 4848 piers.brunner@hk.knightfrank.com Paul Hart Executive Director Greater China +852 2846 9537 paul.hart@hk.knightfrank.com Knight Frank Research provides strategic advice, consultancy services and forecasting to a wide range of clients worldwide, including developers, investors, funding organisations, corporate institutions and the public sector. All our clients recognise the need for expert independent advice customised to their specific needs. RECENT MARKET-LEADING RESEARCH PUBLICATIONS Alnwick Chan Executive Director +852 2846 9551 alnwick.chan@hk.knightfrank.com CHINA VALUATION Clement Leung Executive Director +852 2846 9593 clement.leung@hk.knightfrank.com COMMERCIAL AGENCY Ross Criddle Director +852 2846 9527 ross.criddle@hk.knightfrank.com Global House Price Index Q3 2015 Knight Frank 萊坊 2016 Knight Frank Petty Limited Knight Frank Hong Kong Limited Greater China Quarterly Report Prime Cities Forecast Report 2016 Knight Frank Research Reports are available at KnightFrank.com/Research Chinese Outbound report RESIDENTIAL AGENCY Renu Budhrani Executive Director +852 2846 9550 renu.budhrani@hk.knightfrank.com RETAIL SERVICES Mont Leung Director Retail Services and Asset Management +852 2846 9535 mont.leung@hk.knightfrank.com Disclaimer This document and the material contained in it is general information only and is subject to change without notice. All images are for illustration only. No representations or warranties of any nature whatsoever are given, intended or implied. Knight Frank will not be liable for negligence, or for any direct or indirect consequential losses or damages arising from the use of this information. You should satisfy yourself about the completeness or accuracy of any information or materials. Copyright This document and the material contained in it is the property of Knight Frank and is given to you on the understanding that such material and the ideas, concepts and proposals expressed in it are the intellectual property of Knight Frank and protected by copyright. It is understood that you may not use this material or any part of it for any reason other than the evaluation of the document unless we have entered into a further agreement for its use. This document is provided to you in confidence on the understanding it is not disclosed to anyone other than to your employees who need to evaluate it. 10