Grand Traverse County Equalization Report

Similar documents
NOTICE GRAND TRAVERSE COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS EQUALIZATION MEETING. Tuesday, April 15, 2:00 p.m.

Tuscola County Equalization Report 2017 (Preliminary Taxable Values Included)

Allegan County Equalization Department

MECOSTA COUNTY EQUALIZATION JANUARY 1 - DECEMBER 31, 2014 APRIL 16, 2015

Equalization Report 2017 St. Clair County, Michigan

Personal and Real Property - TOTALS

Equalization. Equalization. Statutory Duties. Statutory Authority

Ottawa CountyEqualization Department

Ottawa County Equalization Department

2017 EQUALIZATION REPORT

Assessing Reform Proposal Summary

Equalization Department

Property Appraisal Division Finance Department Anchorage: Performance Value Results

Property Appraisal Division Finance Department Anchorage: Performance. Value. Results.

2018 Mackinac County Equalization Report

RESOLUTION # RESOLUTION REGARDING WASHTENAW COUNTY ROAD COMMISSION IMPROVEMENTS (HAYES SUBDIVISION)

POSITION DESCRIPTION

Property Appraisal Division Finance Department Anchorage: Performance. Value. Results.

NEIGHBORHOOD ENTERPRISE ZONE ACT Act 147 of The People of the State of Michigan enact:

ASSESSMENT AND TAXATION

COMMERCIAL REHABILITATION ACT Act 210 of The People of the State of Michigan enact:

Property Assessment Seminar

Michigan Assessors Association

Request for Proposals For Assessor. Charter Township of Augusta Washtenaw County

INDUSTRIAL FACILITY EXEMPTION CERTIFICATE POLICY

A. Inflation Rate Used in the 2017 Capped Value Formula.

Design Group, Ltd. Acmee Michigan March 3, 20:09 for a proposed project to the north ofthe existing park (commonly

Cover Photo by William Broekhuizen

Property Tax Oversight Program

KALAMAZOO METROPOLITAN COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION (KMCPC)

41 st Annual Conference Appraising Property

CITY OF DUNWOODY, GA CITY COUNCIL. Ken Wright, Mayor

State Tax Commission. Guide to Basic Assessing

To: Property Appraisers, Taxing Authorities and Interested Parties From: James McAdams Date: June 5, 2012 Bulletin: PTO 12-04

Bulletin No. 4, January 24, 1997, Qualified Agricultural Property

Assembly Bill No. 489 Committee on Growth and Infrastructure CHAPTER...

Michigan s Use of Ad Valorem Special Assessments

AGENDA CHARTER TOWNSHIP OF MERIDIAN Downtown Development Authority November 6, :30 am Municipal Building-Town Hall Room 5151 Marsh Rd.

H.B. 75 As Introduced

L. BROOKS PATTERSON OAKLAND COUNTY EXECUTIVE

The Department s Role

Q. How is Agricultural property valued? A. GENERAL INFORMATION Many states have laws regarding the preferential assessment of agricultural land.

INTERDEPARTMENTAL M E M O R A N D U M. Preliminary Water Control District Rate Resolution

The meeting was called to order by the (Vice) Chairman of the Agency and, upon roll being called, the following members of the Agency were:

Be It Enacted by the Legislature of the State of Florida:

CHAPTER House Bill No. 963

3 Resolution approving, for purposes of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended,

Swisher County Appraisal District Annual Report

In Boone County, accurate assessments generate fair property taxes Alan Zielinski, Boone County Chief Assessment Officer

INFORMATION ON 2017 PROPERTY TAX ASSESSMENTS AND APPEALS IN ORLEANS PARISH Property Tax Assessment & Appeal Information

2018 Budget Presentation Assessor s Office. Steve Schleiker, El Paso County Assessor Presentation Date: November 9, 2017

CITY OF OWATONNA ASSESSMENT REPORT. Steele County Assessor s Department. William G. Effertz, SAMA Steele County Assessor

CITY OF MILTON, GEORGIA

STATE OF MICHIGAN COUNTY OF BERRIEN ORONOKO CHARTER TOWNSHIP LAND DIVISION ORDINANCE NO. 90

Charter Township of Fort Gratiot

(c) County board of commissioners means 1 of the following, as applicable: (ii) In all other counties, 1 of the following:

CITY OF. DATE: August 23, Mayor and City Council TO: Leif J. Ahnell, C.P.A., C.G.F.O. City Manager FROM:

Assessment Overview. Gallagher Amendment Interim Committee. July 13, 2018

CHARTER TOWNSHIP OF FENTON BOARD OF TRUSTEES MINUTES FOR REGULAR MEETING OF DECEMBER 17, 2012

July 25, 2012 Minutes Washington County Board of Equalization Supervisor s Room Courthouse Blair, Nebraska 68008

Amendment U Exempt Certain Possessory Interests From Property Taxes. Amendment U proposes amending the Colorado Constitution to:

H.329. It is hereby enacted by the General Assembly of the State of Vermont: (a) Land which has been classified as agricultural land or managed forest

FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT POSTING

Charter Township of Lyon P.A. 198 Industrial Facilities Tax Exemption Tax Abatement Guidelines

UNDERSTANDING PROPERTY TAXES IN COLORADO

PENINSULA TOWNSHIP LAND DIVISION ORDINANCE TOWNSHIP OF PENINSULA COUNTY OF GRAND TRAVERSE, STATE OF MICHIGAN ORDINANCE NO OF 2012

IT IS RECOMMENDED THAT YOUR BOARD, ACTING AS THE GOVERNING BODY OF THE COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES:

THE VILLAGE AT LITCHFIELD PARK COMMUNITY FACILITIES DISTRICT

The Texas Constitution sets out five basic rules for property taxes in our state:

ALACHUA COUNTY VALUE ADJUSTMENT BOARD. Process and Procedures 2007

THE OFFICE OF COUNTY ASSESSOR

CITY OF NOVI LAND DIVISION INSTRUCTIONS

RESOLUTION NO. PRESENT: ABSENT: WHEREAS, pursuant to the Plant Rehabilitation and Industrial Development

York County 2015 Reassessment Program. York County Assessor s Office 18 W. Liberty St York SC fax

VICTOR TOWNSHIP BOARD OF TRUSTEES RESOLUTION NO ROUND LAKE AQUATIC MANAGEMENT SPECIAL ASSESSMENT DISTRICT

Principal Residence Exemption Review

CITY OF MENOMINEE, MICHIGAN SPECIAL COUNCIL PROCEEDINGS OCTOBER 21, 2015

Map Franklin County ASSESSMENTS FOR 2017 TAX COLLECTION STEVE MARKS ASSESSOR

PIATT COUNTY BOARD OF REVIEW RULES & PROCEDURES 2013

RESOLUTION NUMBER 3970

GRATTAN TOWNSHIP KENT COUNTY, MICHIGAN RESOLUTION NO COWAN LAKE SANITARY SEWER SPECIAL ASSESSMENT DISTRICT

UNDERSTANDING YOUR ASSESSMENT

COMAL APPRAISAL DISTRICT ANNUAL APPRAISAL REPORT

APPEAL PROCESS GUIDE FOR THE PROPERTY OWNER

1. Governmental powers over private property rights include a. power of taxation. b. power of escheat. c. police power. d.

COMAL APPRAISAL DISTRICT ANNUAL APPRAISAL REPORT

We look forward to working with you to build on our collaboration and enhance our partnership on behalf of all Minnesotans.

DUPAGE COUNTY COMPLIANCE TO PA THE HOMESTEAD ASSESSMENT TRANSPARENCY ACT REPORT COMPILED PURSUANT TO PA

Bonds at their respective maturities, to the extent such principal and interest is not satisfied from the proceeds of the sales and use tax; and

ACT 425 AGREEMENTS: CAN THEY WORK FOR YOU? LAW, WEATHERS & RICHARDSON, P.C. 333 Bridge Street, NW, Suite 800 Grand Rapids, MI (616)

Property Tax Fairness and the Future of Further Reform

A motion was made by Mr. Yanos and seconded by Mr. Cronk to approve the payroll as presented. Motion carried 3-0.

We hope the trends provide additional perspective on your county s work. We know it provided valuable insight on the work we do here at Revenue.

Board of Review Present: Dennis Uecker, Bob Knueppel, Bruce Nekich, Mary Jensen, Mike Grant, Kim Hopfinger and Ted Engelbart

ORDINANCE NO NOW THEREFORE the Council of the City of Flowery Branch hereby ordains as follows:

Cranes in the air! Amari & Locallo

Past & Present Adjustments & Parcel Count Section... 13

Office of Legislative Services Background Report The Assessment of Real Property: Answers to Frequently Asked Questions

EUREKA CHARTER TOWNSHIP BOARD MINUTES MONDAY, APRIL 14, 2014 Approved

IN THE SUPREME COURT STATE OF FLORIDA. vs. DCA CASE NO. 1D08-515

Transcription:

Grand Traverse County Equalization Report 1

GRAND TRAVERSE COUNTY EQUALIZATION DEPARTMENT 4 BOARDMAN AVENUE STE 13 TRAVERSE CITY, MI 49684-2577 Phone: 231.922.4772 Fax: 231.922.4447 www.co.grand-traverse.mi.us April 1th, 218 Honorable Board of Commissioners Grand Traverse County Governmental Center 4 Boardman Ave Traverse City, MI 49684 Ladies and Gentlemen: The Grand Traverse County Equalization Department has prepared this equalization report as authorized by the County Board of Commissioners. I recommend that the Grand Traverse County Board of Commissioners adopt the proposed County equalized values in this report. This report is a result of an equalization study in every class of real property and of the total personal property in all fourteen (14) assessing units of Grand Traverse County. This report does not embrace any property taxed under P.A. 77 of 1951; P.A. 68 of 1963; P.A. 199 of 1974; P.A. 385 of 1994; P.A. 224 of 1995; P.A. 147 of 1992 or Section 5 of Article IX of the Constitution of the State of Michigan. All County equalized values are subject to review and change by the Michigan State Tax Commission until the fourth Monday in May, when the final order is issued. The resolution adopting the 218 Grand Traverse County Equalization Report is located on the pages following. Respectfully submitted, James D. Baker, MMAO Director Grand Traverse County Equalization Department 2

Acknowledgements In facilitating the completion of a project of this nature and magnitude, the support of a number of organizations and individuals was absolutely necessary and I am grateful to all the participants. The burden of maintaining a county-wide property information network while meeting impending statutory deadlines was carried out extraordinarily well by the staff of the Grand Traverse County Equalization Department. I would like to thank the Grand Traverse County Board of Commissioners for providing the Department with the resources to accomplish these duties. I would also like to express my gratitude to the Assessors of the city, townships and villages of Grand Traverse County for their prompt assistance in the assembling and reporting of data for this analysis. Foreword The State Constitution commands the legislature to establish a system of property taxation and of equalization of assessments. The rationale underlying this approach is that the cost of municipal services, such as police, fire protection and education should be borne through taxation imposed upon the general public. That taxation is required to be uniform and fair to all taxpayers; County Equalization is required to ensure that. 3

GRAND TRAVERSE COUNTY EQUALIZATION DEPARTMENT REPORTS TO BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS Carol Crawford Chair Ron Clous Vice-Chair Addison Sonny Wheelock Dr. Bob Johnson Dr. Dan Lathrop Cheryl Gore Follette Tom Mair INTERIM MANAGEMENT TEAM Undersheriff Nate Alger Finance Director Dean Bott Deputy Prosecutor Christopher Forsyth DEPARTMENT OF EQUALIZATION James D. Baker Director, MMAO (4) Chris Fieldhouse Deputy Director, MCAO Joel Bremer - Appraiser II, MCAO Michael Barres - Appraiser I, MCAT Susan Karakos Senior Appraiser, MAAO (3) Russ Casselman Appraiser II, MCAO Mike Steffes - GIS Analyst Joshua Green - GIS Technician 4

SUPERVISORS, ASSESSORS, PRESIDENTS, & MANAGERS GRAND TRAVERSE COUNTY 218 LOCAL UNIT SUPERVISOR ASSESSOR Acme Township (1) Jay B. Zollinger Dawn Kuhns Blair Township (2) Nicole Blonshine Wendy Witkop East Bay Township (3) Beth Friend James D. Baker Fife Lake Township (4) Linda Forwerck Dawn Kuhns Garfield Charter Township (5) Chuck Korn Amy DeHaan Grant Township (6) Douglas E. Moyer Michelle Englebrecht Green Lake Township (7) Marvin D. Radtke William Muha Long Lake Township (8) Karen J. Rosa Angela Friske Mayfield Township (9) John E. Ockert David Brown Paradise Township (1) Rob Lajko Dawn Kuhns Peninsula Township (11) Rob Manigold Sally Akerley Union Township (12) Doug Mansfield Debra Johnson Whitewater Township (13) Ron Popp Dawn Kuhns PRESIDENT Fife Lake Village (41) David C. McGough Dawn Kuhns Kingsley Village (42) Rodney Bogart Dawn Kuhns MANAGER City of Traverse City (51) Marty Colburn Polly Cairns 5

TOWNSHIPS & CITY 218 GRAND TRAVERSE COUNTY - ALL AD VALOREM PROPERTY Parcel Count 217 Parcel Count 218 Parcel Count % Change CEV 217 CEV 218 County Equalized % Change TAXABLE 217 TAXABLE 218 Taxable % Change Acme 3,483 3,483.% $45,47,6 $41,212,8 1.28% $331,32,712 $344,194,667 3.89% Blair 4,598 4,634.78% $323,377,95 $339,784,3 5.7% $265,875,29 $282,86,283 6.39% East Bay 8,226 8,158 -.83% $661,622,4 $693,918,4 4.88% $541,699,42 $567,969,31 4.85% Fife Lake 1,31 1,297 -.31% $7,688,2 $71,37,.49% $52,291,829 $54,223,538 3.69% Garfield 8,95 8,13.43% $1,22,599,1 $1,61,119,4 3.77% $866,712,296 $93,5,416 4.24% Grant 1,99 1,95 -.36% $73,774,251 $76,112,4 3.17% $53,58,162 $55,488,817 4.58% Green Lake 4,15 4,32.42% $332,663,1 $343,142,7 3.15% $275,352,377 $286,961,218 4.22% Long Lake 5,14 5,48.68% $596,824,5 $627,336,2 5.11% $479,931,652 $55,964,89 5.42% Mayfield 1,94 1,111 1.55% $75,151,1 $77,28,772 2.5% $57,13,647 $59,481,457 4.16% Paradise 2,58 2,582.8% $15,857,5 $157,475,5 4.39% $123,919,343 $129,856,563 4.79% Peninsula 4,216 4,23.33% $894,743,8 $923,545,6 3.22% $674,55,682 $72,28,945 4.15% Union 436 448 2.75% $28,547,1 $29,288,4 2.6% $24,332,755 $25,449,481 4.59% Whitewater 2,11 2,3 -.4% $255,2,3 $264,785,1 3.83% $194,59,181 $22,853,18 4.29% Traverse City 8,781 8,881 1.14% $1,186,26,675 $1,249,892,256 5.36% $928,294,158 $985,966,549 6.21% TOTALS 54,949 55,132.33% $6,77,177,576 $6,324,678,828 4.7% $4,868,438,486 $5,16,798,342 4.896% 6

TOWNSHIPS & CITY Parcel Count 217 Parcel Count 218 Parcel Count % Change CEV 217 CEV 218 County Equalized % Change TAXABLE 217 TAXABLE 218 Taxable % Change Acme 3,319 3,32.3% $381,185,5 $388,555,7 1.93% $37,44,612 $322,537,567 4.91% Blair 4,26 4,266.14% $37,526,75 $321,423,7 4.52% $25,65,778 $265,21,875 6.6% East Bay 7,615 7,595 -.26% $638,911, $671,229,3 5.6% $518,988,2 $545,28,21 5.7% Fife Lake 1,248 1,248.% $68,459,3 $68,95,3.65% $5,62,929 $52,91,838 4.5% Garfield 6,69 6,662.8% $944,31,1 $978,464,7 3.65% $788,144,296 $82,845,716 4.15% Grant 1,38 1,39.1% $67,649,31 $7,43, 3.54% $46,933,221 $49,42,117 5.3% Green Lake 3,816 3,833.45% $323,6,3 $333,789,4 3.15% $266,289,577 $277,67,918 4.25% Long Lake 4,86 4,884.49% $588,866,3 $619,187,9 5.15% $471,973,452 $497,815,789 5.48% Mayfield 1,34 1,45 1.6% $71,386,2 $73,137,72 2.45% $53,338,747 $55,599,657 4.24% Paradise 2,487 2,493.24% $144,689,7 $15,767,7 4.2% $117,757,443 $123,153,963 4.58% Peninsula 4,11 4,18.17% $885,797,5 $914,736,7 3.27% $665,19,382 $693,22,45 4.23% Union 393 48 3.82% $26,562,3 $27,39,1 3.12% $22,347,955 $23,561,36 5.43% Whitewater 1,914 1,99 -.26% $247,571,3 $256,226,1 3.5% $187,6,358 $194,294,18 3.87% Traverse City 7,18 7,81.9% $1,134,83,675 $1,194,374,8 5.32% $876,117,158 $93,449,93 6.2% TOTALS 49,712 49,891.36% $5,83,32,235 $6,68,231,472 4.8% $4,621,628,91 $4,851,87,833 4.96% TOWNSHIPS & CITY Parcel Count 217 218 GRAND TRAVERSE COUNTY - REAL PROPERTY 218 GRAND TRAVERSE COUNTY - PERSONAL PROPERTY Parcel Count 218 Parcel Count % Change CEV 217 CEV 218 County Equalized % Change TAXABLE 217 TAXABLE 218 Taxable % Change Acme 164 163 -.61% $23,862,1 $21,657,1-9.24% $23,862,1 $21,657,1-9.24% Blair 338 368 8.88% $15,851,2 $18,36,6 15.83% $15,89,512 $17,649,48 11.64% East Bay 611 563-7.86% $22,711,4 $22,689,1 -.1% $22,711,4 $22,689,1 -.1% Fife Lake 53 49-7.55% $2,228,9 $2,131,7-4.36% $2,228,9 $2,131,7-4.36% Garfield 1,486 1,468-1.21% $78,568, $82,654,7 5.2% $78,568, $82,654,7 5.2% Grant 61 56-8.2% $6,124,941 $6,69,4 -.91% $6,124,941 $6,68,7 -.92% Green Lake 199 199.% $9,62,8 $9,353,3 3.21% $9,62,8 $9,353,3 3.21% Long Lake 154 164 6.49% $7,958,2 $8,148,3 2.39% $7,958,2 $8,148,3 2.39% Mayfield 6 66 1.% $3,764,9 $3,891,7 3.37% $3,764,9 $3,881,8 3.1% Paradise 93 89-4.3% $6,167,8 $6,77,8 8.76% $6,161,9 $6,72,6 8.77% Peninsula 115 122 6.9% $8,946,3 $8,88,9-1.54% $8,946,3 $8,88,9-1.54% Union 43 4-6.98% $1,984,8 $1,898,3-4.36% $1,984,8 $1,888,445-4.85% Whitewater 97 94-3.9% $7,449, $8,559, 14.9% $7,448,823 $8,559, 14.9% Traverse City 1,763 1,8 2.1% $52,177, $55,517,456 6.4% $52,177, $55,517,456 6.4% TOTALS 5,237 5,241.8% $246,857,341 $256,447,356 3.88% $246,89,576 $255,71,59 3.61% 7

$41,212,8 $344,194,667 $339,784,3 $282,86,283 $693,918,4 $567,969,31 $71,37, $54,223,538 $1,61,119,4 $93,5,416 $76,112,4 $55,488,817 $343,142,7 $286,961,218 $627,336,2 $55,964,89 $77,28,772 $59,481,457 $157,475,5 $129,856,563 $923,545,6 $72,28,945 $29,288,4 $25,449,481 $264,785,1 $22,853,18 $1,249,892,256 $985,966,549 $1,3,, $1,2,, $1,1,, $1,,, $9,, $8,, $7,, $6,, $5,, $4,, $3,, $2,, $1,, $ 218 COUNTY EQUALIZED & TAXABLE VALUES BY UNIT 218 County Equalized Value 218 Taxable Value 8

1.28% 3.89% 5.7% 6.39% 4.88% 4.85%.49% 3.69% 3.77% 4.24% 3.17% 4.58% 3.15% 4.22% 5.11% 5.42% 2.5% 4.16% 4.39% 4.79% 3.22% 4.15% 2.6% 4.59% 3.83% 4.29% 5.36% 6.21% 8.% 7.% 6.% 5.% 4.% 3.% 2.% 1.%.% 218 COUNTY EQUALIZED & TAXABLE VALUE ONE YEAR CHANGE PERCENTAGES BY UNIT County Equalized % Change Taxable % Change 9

$5,92,332,312 $4,478,431,81 $5,59,516,828 $4,392,56,777 $5,244,751,933 $4,298,414,642 $5,128,714,773 $4,286,13,69 $5,213,555,36 $4,396,631,123 $5,324,497,292 $4,474,83,286 $5,528,183,66 $4,62,528,695 $5,761,372,513 $4,698,287,253 $6,77,177,576 $4,868,438,486 $6,324,678,828 $5,127,59,14 $6,,, $5,,, $4,,, $3,,, $2,,, $1,,, $ 1 YEAR GRAND TRAVERSE COUNTY COUNTY EQUALIZED & TAXABLE VALUES 29 21 211 212 213 214 215 216 217 218 County Equalized Value Taxable Value 1

FRACTIONAL UNIT 218 COUNTY EQUALIZED VALUES TOTAL CEV: $6,324,678,828 11

FRACTIONAL UNIT 218 COUNTY TAXABLE VALUES TOTAL VALUE: $5,16,798,342 12

GRAND TRAVERSE COUNTY 218 COUNTY EQUALIZED VALUES BY CLASSIFICATION TOTAL VALUE: $6,324,678,828 13

GRAND TRAVERSE COUNTY 218 TAXABLE VALUES BY CLASSIFICATION TOTAL VALUE: $5,16,798,342 14

3/27/218 1:54 AM Parcel Count Report Page: DB: 1/1 Gt18 County: 28- GRAND TRAVERSE ---------------------- Real ---------------------- ----------------- Personal --------------- Grand Governmental Unit Ag Comm Ind Res T-C Dev Total Ag Comm Ind Res Util Total Exempt Total ACME TWP (1) 78 21 11 321 332 147 8 8 163 66 3549 BLAIR TWP (2) 41 341 16 3868 4266 332 6 32 37 41 4677 EAST BAY CHTR TWP (3) 28 185 48 7334 7595 55 22 36 563 146 834 FIFE LAKE TWP (4) 27 46 2 1173 1248 39 3 7 49 72 1369 GARFIELD CHTR TWP (5) 119 76 5567 6662 1423 51 5 1479 175 8316 GRANT TWP (6) 146 9 19 865 139 23 1 32 56 23 1118 GREEN LAKE TWP (7) 161 12 366 3833 182 8 9 199 93 4125 LONG LAKE TWP (8) 45 15 3 4731 4884 148 1 1 6 165 46 595 MAYFIELD TWP (9) 147 28 4 865 144 42 24 66 12 1122 PARADISE TWP (1) 77 9 7 2319 2493 68 1 2 89 87 2669 PENINSULA TWP (11) 227 78 3 38 418 118 2 2 122 127 4357 UNION TWP (12) 4 5 399 48 9 31 4 43 491 WHITEWATER TWP (13) 77 41 8 1783 199 56 6 32 94 93 296 TRAVERSE CITY (51) 138 47 5996 781 1752 44 4 18 325 926 Totals 893 3355 261 45381 4989 4844 16 3 248 5255 1349 56494 15

3/27/218 11:47 AM Equalization Report GRAND TRAVERSE Page: DB: 1/5 Gt18 Assessment Assessed Equalized Assessed Equalized Assessed Equalized % County Unit Real Ratio Real Factor Personal Ratio Personal Total Total Total -- 1 ACME TWP (1) -- Agricultural 14,165,3 49.25 14,165,3 1. Commercial 52,977,7 49.29 52,977,7 1. Industrial 3,81, 49.28 3,81, 1. Residential 318,331,7 49.72 318,331,7 1. Timber-Cutover 5. 1. Developmental 5. 1. Totals 388,555,7 388,555,7 21,657,1 5. 21,657,1 41,212,8 41,212,8 6.49 -- 2 BLAIR TWP (2) -- Agricultural 5,28,5 49.77 5,28,5 1. Commercial 6,79,7 49.69 6,79,7 1. Industrial 3,119,8 49.89 3,119,8 1. Residential 252,232,7 49.96 252,232,7 1. Timber-Cutover 5. 1. Developmental 5. 1. Totals 321,423,7 321,423,7 18,36,6 5. 18,36,6 339,784,3 339,784,3 5.37 -- 3 EAST BAY CHTR TWP (3) -- Agricultural 4,444,1 49.71 4,444,1 1. Commercial 72,288,5 49.82 72,288,5 1. Industrial 12,126,6 49.69 12,126,6 1. Residential 582,37,1 49.57 582,37,1 1. Timber-Cutover 5. 1. Developmental 5. 1. Totals 671,229,3 671,229,3 22,689,1 5. 22,689,1 693,918,4 693,918,4 1.97 -- 4 FIFE LAKE TWP (4) -- Agricultural 2,982,8 49.8 2,982,8 1. Commercial 4,314,1 49.47 4,314,1 1. Industrial 597,7 49.87 597,7 1. Residential 61,1,7 49.36 61,1,7 1. Timber-Cutover 5. 1. Developmental 5. 1. Totals 68,95,3 68,95,3 2,131,7 5. 2,131,7 71,37, 71,37, 1.12 16

3/27/218 11:47 AM Equalization Report GRAND TRAVERSE Page: DB: 2/5 Gt18 Assessment Assessed Equalized Assessed Equalized Assessed Equalized % County Unit Real Ratio Real Factor Personal Ratio Personal Total Total Total -- 5 GARFIELD CHTR TWP (5) -- Agricultural 5. 1. Commercial 384,593,9 49.87 384,593,9 1. Industrial 28,561,1 49.99 28,561,1 1. Residential 565,39,7 49.14 565,39,7 1. Timber-Cutover 5. 1. Developmental 5. 1. Totals 978,464,7 978,464,7 82,654,7 5. 82,654,71,61,119,41,61,119,4 16.78 -- 6 GRANT TWP (6) -- Agricultural 14,679, 49.38 14,679, 1. Commercial 723,5 49.69 723,5 1. Industrial 559, 49.51 559, 1. Residential 54,81,5 49.37 54,81,5 1. Timber-Cutover 5. 1. Developmental 5. 1. Totals 7,43, 7,43, 6,69,4 5. 6,69,4 76,112,4 76,112,4 1.2 -- 7 GREEN LAKE TWP (7) -- Agricultural 5. 1. Commercial 15,535,1 49.97 15,535,1 1. Industrial 4,382,4 49.91 4,382,4 1. Residential 313,871,9 49.91 313,871,9 1. Timber-Cutover 5. 1. Developmental 5. 1. Totals 333,789,4 333,789,4 9,353,3 5. 9,353,3 343,142,7 343,142,7 5.43 -- 8 LONG LAKE TWP (8) -- Agricultural 7,2,9 49.95 7,2,9 1. Commercial 13,275,9 49.9 13,275,9 1. Industrial 979,1 49.94 979,1 1. Residential 597,732, 49.77 597,732, 1. Timber-Cutover 5. 1. Developmental 5. 1. Totals 619,187,9 619,187,9 8,148,3 5. 8,148,3 627,336,2 627,336,2 9.92 17

3/27/218 11:47 AM Equalization Report GRAND TRAVERSE Page: DB: 3/5 Gt18 Assessment Assessed Equalized Assessed Equalized Assessed Equalized % County Unit Real Ratio Real Factor Personal Ratio Personal Total Total Total -- 9 MAYFIELD TWP (9) -- Agricultural 16,536,774 49.83 16,536,774 1. Commercial 4,55,8 49.52 4,55,8 1. Industrial 1,6 49.88 1,6 1. Residential 52,443,898 49.92 52,443,898 1. Timber-Cutover 5. 1. Developmental 5. 1. Totals 73,137,72 73,137,72 3,891,7 5. 3,891,7 77,28,772 77,28,772 1.22 -- 1 PARADISE TWP (1) -- Agricultural 7,958,9 49.37 7,958,9 1. Commercial 8,516,5 49.48 8,516,5 1. Industrial 126,5 49.21 126,5 1. Residential 134,165,8 49.71 134,165,8 1. Timber-Cutover 5. 1. Developmental 5. 1. Totals 15,767,7 15,767,7 6,77,8 5. 6,77,8 157,475,5 157,475,5 2.49 -- 11 PENINSULA TWP (11) -- Agricultural 6,225,6 49.98 6,225,6 1. Commercial 19,21,9 5. 19,21,9 1. Industrial 521,5 49.62 521,5 1. Residential 834,967,7 49.86 834,967,7 1. Timber-Cutover 5. 1. Developmental 5. 1. Totals 914,736,7 914,736,7 8,88,9 5. 8,88,9 923,545,6 923,545,6 14.6 -- 12 UNION TWP (12) -- Agricultural 5. 1. Commercial 636,5 49.28 636,5 1. Industrial 51,1 49.62 51,1 1. Residential 26,72,5 49.63 26,72,5 1. Timber-Cutover 5. 1. Developmental 5. 1. Totals 27,39,1 27,39,1 1,898,3 5. 1,898,3 29,288,4 29,288,4.46 18

4/3/218 4:9 PM Equalization Report GRAND TRAVERSE Page: DB: 4/5 Gt18 Assessment Assessed Equalized Assessed Equalized Assessed Equalized % County Unit Real Ratio Real Factor Personal Ratio Personal Total Total Total -- 13 WHITEWATER TWP (13) -- Agricultural 14,313,9 49.55 14,313,9 1. Commercial 4,353,2 49.98 4,353,2 1. Industrial 2,492,5 49.36 2,492,5 1. Residential 235,66,5 49.15 235,66,5 1. Timber-Cutover 5. 1. Developmental 5. 1. Totals 256,226,1 256,226,1 8,559, 5. 8,559, 264,785,1 264,785,1 4.19 -- 51 TRAVERSE CITY (51) -- Agricultural 5. 1. Commercial 41,859,2 49.53 41,859,2 1. Industrial 3,391,7 49.83 3,391,7 1. Residential 762,123,9 49.89 762,123,9 1. Timber-Cutover 5. 1. Developmental 5. 1. Totals 1,194,374,8 1,194,374,8 55,517,456 5. 55,517,4561,249,892,2561,249,892,256 19.76 19

3/27/218 11:47 AM Equalization Report GRAND TRAVERSE Page: DB: 5/5 Gt18 Grand Totals Assessed Equalized % Real Assessed Equalized Assessed Equalized Assessed Equalized Real Real Total Personal Personal % County % County Total Total Agricultural 147,787,774 147,787,774 2.44 2.34 2.34 Commercial 1,42,942,5 1,42,942,5 17.19 16.49 16.49 Industrial 87,9,6 87,9,6 1.44 1.38 1.38 Residential 4,79,41,598 4,79,41,598 78.94 75.74 75.74 Timber-Cutover... Developmental... Personal 256,447,356 256,447,356 4.5 4.5 6,68,231,472 6,68,231,472 1. 256,447,356 256,447,356 1. 1. 6,324,678,828 6,324,678,828 2

Michigan Department of Treasury STC 68 (Rev. 3-2) Grand Traverse County Personal and Real Property - TOTALS L-424 Statement of acreage and valuation in the year 218 made in accordance with Sections 29.1-29.8 of the Michigan Compiled Laws. Number of Acres Assessed Total Real Property Valuations Personal Property Valuations Total Real Plus Personal Property Township or City Acme (Col. 1) Acres Hundredths 13,261.37 (Col. 2) Assessed Valuations 388,555,7 (Col. 3) Equalized Valuations 388,555,7 (Col. 4) Assessed Valuations 21,657,1 (Col. 5) Equalized Valuations 21,657,1 (Col. 6) Assessed Valuations 41,212,8 (Col. 7) Equalized Valuations 41,212,8 Blair 22,746.58 321,423,7 321,423,7 18,36,6 18,36,6 339,784,3 339,784,3 East Bay 28,192.41 671,229,3 671,229,3 22,689,1 22,689,1 693,918,4 693,918,4 Fife Lake 22,539.35 68,95,3 68,95,3 2,131,7 2,131,7 71,37, 71,37, Garfield 13,769.73 978,464,7 978,464,7 82,654,7 82,654,7 1,61,119,4 1,61,119,4 Grant 22,795.37 7,43, 7,43, 6,69,4 6,69,4 76,112,4 76,112,4 Green Lake 18,943.23 333,789,4 333,789,4 9,353,3 9,353,3 343,142,7 343,142,7 Long Lake 19,419.7 619,187,9 619,187,9 8,148,3 8,148,3 627,336,2 627,336,2 Mayfield 23,11.94 73,137,72 73,137,72 3,891,7 3,891,7 77,28,772 77,28,772 Paradise 3,965.18 15,767,7 15,767,7 6,77,8 6,77,8 157,475,5 157,475,5 Peninsula 17,157.17 914,736,7 914,736,7 8,88,9 8,88,9 923,545,6 923,545,6 Union 23,34.16 27,39,1 27,39,1 1,898,3 1,898,3 29,288,4 29,288,4 Whitewater 3,37.36 256,226,1 256,226,1 8,559, 8,559, 264,785,1 264,785,1 Traverse City 8,789.8 1,194,374,8 1,194,374,8 55,517,456 55,517,456 1,249,892,256 1,249,892,256 Totals for County 295,32.35 6,68,231,472 6,68,231,472 256,447,356 256,447,356 6,324,678,828 6,324,678,828 OFFICE OF THE COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS OF GRAND TRAVERSE COUNTY WE HEREBY CERTIFY that the foregoing is a true statement of the number of acres of land, the value of the real property and of the personal property, the aggregate valuation of the real property and personal property, the equalized and assessed valuations of real property classifications in each township and city in said county as equalized by the Board of Commissioners in April of the reporting year, at a meeting of said board held in pursuant to the provisions of sections 29.1 29.8, MCL. I further certify that said statement does not embrace any property taxed under P.A. 77 of 1951; P.A. 68 of 1963; P.A. 198 of 1974; P.A. 225 of 1978; P.A. 385 of 1984; P A. 224 of 1985; P.A. 147 of 1992 or Section 5 of Article IX of the Constitution of the State. Dated, 2 Equalization Director Clerk of the Board of Commissioners Chairperson of Board of Commissioners 21

Michigan Department of Treasury STC 68 (Rev. 3-2) Grand Traverse County Equalized Valuations - REAL Statement of acreage and valuation in the year 218 made in accordance with Sections 29.1-29.8 of the Michigan Compiled Laws. Township or City Acme Blair East Bay Fife Lake Garfield Grant Green Lake Long Lake Mayfield Paradise Peninsula Union Whitewater Traverse City Total for County (Col. 1) Agricultural 14,165,3 5,28,5 4,444,1 2,982,8 14,679, 7,2,9 16,536,774 7,958,9 6,225,6 14,313,9 147,787,774 (Col. 2) Commercial Real Property Equalized by County Board of Commissioners (Col. 3) (Col. 4) Industrial Residential 52,977,7 6,79,7 72,288,5 4,314,1 384,593,9 723,5 15,535,1 13,275,9 4,55,8 8,516,5 19,21,9 636,5 4,353,2 41,859,2 1,42,942,5 3,81, 3,119,8 12,126,6 597,7 28,561,1 559, 4,382,4 979,1 1,6 126,5 521,5 51,1 2,492,5 3,391,7 87,9,6 318,331,7 252,232,7 582,37,1 61,1,7 565,39,7 54,81,5 313,871,9 597,732, 52,443,898 134,165,8 834,967,7 26,72,5 235,66,5 762,123,9 4,79,41,598 (Col. 5) Timber-Cutover (Col. 6) Developmental L-424 (Col. 7) Total Real Property 388,555,7 321,423,7 671,229,3 68,95,3 978,464,7 7,43, 333,789,4 619,187,9 73,137,72 15,767,7 914,736,7 27,39,1 256,226,1 1,194,374,8 6,68,231,472 Dated, 2 OFFICE OF THE COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS OF GRAND TRAVERSE COUNTY WE HEREBY CERTIFY that the foregoing is a true statement of the number of acres of land, the value of the real property and of the personal property, the aggregate valuation of the real property and personal property, the equalized and assessed valuations of real property classifications in each township and city in said county as equalized by the Board of Commissioners in April of the reporting year, at a meeting of said board held in pursuant to the provisions of sections 29.1 29.8, MCL. I further certify that said statement does not embrace any property taxed under P.A. 77 of 1951; P.A. 68 of 1963; P.A. 198 of 1974; P.A. 225 of 1978; P.A. 385 of 1984; P A. 224 of 1985; P.A. 147 of 1992 or Section 5 of Article IX of the Constitution of the State. Equalization Director Clerk of the Board of Commissioners Chairperson of Board of Commissioners 22

Michigan Department of Treasury STC 68 (Rev. 3-2) Grand Traverse County Assessed Valuations - REAL Statement of acreage and valuation in the year 218 made in accordance with Sections 29.1-29.8 of the Michigan Compiled Laws. L-424 Township or City (Col. 1) Agricultural Real Property Assessed Valuations Approved by Boards of Review (Col. 3) (Col. 4) Industrial Residential (Col. 2) Commercial (Col. 5) Timber-Cutover (Col. 6) Developmental (Col. 7) Total Real Property Acme 14,165,3 52,977,7 3,81, 318,331,7 388,555,7 Blair 5,28,5 6,79,7 3,119,8 252,232,7 321,423,7 East Bay 4,444,1 72,288,5 12,126,6 582,37,1 671,229,3 Fife Lake 2,982,8 4,314,1 597,7 61,1,7 68,95,3 Garfield 384,593,9 28,561,1 565,39,7 978,464,7 Grant 14,679, 723,5 559, 54,81,5 7,43, Green Lake 15,535,1 4,382,4 313,871,9 333,789,4 Long Lake 7,2,9 13,275,9 979,1 597,732, 619,187,9 Mayfield 16,536,774 4,55,8 1,6 52,443,898 73,137,72 Paradise 7,958,9 8,516,5 126,5 134,165,8 15,767,7 Peninsula 6,225,6 19,21,9 521,5 834,967,7 914,736,7 Union 636,5 51,1 26,72,5 27,39,1 Whitewater 14,313,9 4,353,2 2,492,5 235,66,5 256,226,1 Traverse City 41,859,2 3,391,7 762,123,9 1,194,374,8 Total for County 147,787,774 1,42,942,5 87,9,6 4,79,41,598 6,68,231,472 OFFICE OF THE COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS OF GRAND TRAVERSE COUNTY WE HEREBY CERTIFY that the foregoing is a true statement of the number of acres of land, the value of the real property and of the personal property, the aggregate valuation of the real property and personal property, the equalized and assessed valuations of real property classifications in each township and city in said county as equalized by the Board of Commissioners in April of the reporting year, at a meeting of said board held in pursuant to the provisions of sections 29.1 29.8, MCL. I further certify that said statement does not embrace any property taxed under P.A. 77 of 1951; P.A. 68 of 1963; P.A. 198 of 1974; P.A. 225 of 1978; P.A. 385 of 1984; P A. 224 of 1985; P.A. 147 of 1992 or Section 5 of Article IX of the Constitution of the State. Dated, 2 Equalization Director Clerk of the Board of Commissioners Chairperson of Board of Commissioners 23

R E S O L U T I O N XXX-218 Equalization Report 218 WHEREAS, The Grand Traverse County Equalization Department has established the various valuations of each of the units of government of Grand Traverse County, and WHEREAS, each of the thirteen (13) townships, two (2) villages and one (1) city have had the opportunity to review the equalization factors with the Equalization Department, and WHEREAS, this Board of Commissioners feels that these valuations are in order, NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Grand Traverse County Board of Commissioners has adopted the 218 equalized valuations for each city, village, and township recommended by the Grand Traverse County Equalization Director, as contained in this report, pursuant to Sec. 211.34 MCL 1948, as amended. Dated: 24