Getting Back to Net Zero Energy Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace NSAA FRAIC LEED AP BD+C
Overview 1. Energy is mysterious, ubiquitous, and mind boggling 2. Defining Net Zero Energy 3. Examples Local and Global 4. Protocols and Regulatory Frameworks Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C 2
Fire 3 Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C
Potential 4 Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C
Kinetic 5 Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C
Sound 6 Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C
Light 7 Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C
Atomic 8 Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C
Weird 9 Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C
Energy Touches Everything Everything in the universe can be described in terms of energy. Galaxies, stars, molecules, and atoms may be regarded as organizations of energy. Living organisms may be looked upon as engines which operate by means of energy derived directly or indirectly from the sun. The civilizations, or cultures of mankind, also, may be regarded as a form of organizational energy Leslie White, American anthropologist, 1900-1975 10 Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C
The Law of Conservation of Energy The First Law of Thermodynamics Energy can neither be created or destroyed Energy can change forms and flow from one form to another The total energy of a closed system does not change The total amount of energy in the universe, a closed system, has always been the same, however the forms that energy takes are always changing. Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C 11
Dark Energy But if the universe is a closed system with a finite amount of energy how can it spawn more empty space which must contain more energy? aiieeeeeeeeehhh 12 Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C
Back here on earth most of us just tend to take energy for granted 13 Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C
Back to Buildings Net Zero Energy Buildings. 4 Types NZEB A. Building integrated renewables provide all necessary energy NZEB B. On site renewables provide all necessary energy NZEB C. Off site imported renewables NZEB D. Off site purchased renewables National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C 14
NZEB Definition: US Department of Energy After leading an extensive stakeholder engagement process over the past year and a half, the Energy Department released its findings in the recently published A Common Definition for Zero Energy Buildings, which states that a Zero Energy Building is an energy-efficient building where, on a source energy basis, the actual annual delivered energy is less than or equal to the on-site renewable exported energy. This definition also applies to campuses, portfolios, and communities. In addition to providing clarity across the industry, this new DOE publication provides important guidelines for measurement and implementation, specifically explaining how to utilize this definition for building projects. DOE Sept. 2015 See also link above to 22 page document describing definition 15 Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C
European Commission Energy Nearly Zero-Energy Buildings https://ec.europa.eu/energy/en/topics/energy-efficiency/buildings/nearly-zero-energy-buildings Nearly zero-energy buildings have very high energy performance. The low amount of energy that these buildings require comes mostly from renewable sources. The Energy Performance of Buildings Directive requires all new buildings to be nearly zero-energy by the end of 2020. All new public buildings must be nearly zeroenergy by 2018. 16 Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C
WHW/Architecture 49 Moving Towards Net Zero 4 Projects Joggins interpretive Centre Bluenose Academy P-9, Lunenburg Bridgetown School P-12 Agricola Street Passive House Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C 17
Joggins Fossil Cliffs Nova Scotia s first LEED Gold Building Opened Spring 2007 50kW Wind Turbine Solar PV Solar Thermal Green Champion Client Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C 18
Bluenose Academy P-9 Lunenburg, Nova Scotia Completed 2014 LEED Gold Solar PV Solar Air Solar Thermal Solar Air Pellet Boiler 19 Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C
Bridgetown School P-12 20 Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C
Getting to Net Zero via Passive House Proposed Passive House Mixed Use Project -Architecture 49, Halifax Owner Client: Persimmon Properties Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C 21
22 Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C
6 Factors for achieving net zero energy buildings #1. Acknowledging the existential threat of climate change as real. 23 Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C
6 Factors for achieving net zero energy buildings #2. An aspirational green champion 24 Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C
6 Factors for achieving net zero energy buildings #3. A committed and knowledgeable team fluent in the arts of facilitating an integrated design process Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H- 19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C 25
6 Factors for achieving net zero energy buildings #4 Educated Occupants Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C 26
6 Factors for achieving net zero energy buildings #5 A supportive regulatory framework, stringent energy codes, knowledgeable authorities. Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C 27
6 Factors for achieving net zero energy buildings #6 Realistic Budget 28 Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C
CaGBC s Net Zero Initiative http://www.cagbc.org/ Context Dec1 2015: In support of first ever Buildings Day at COP 21, CaGBC commits (amongst other things) to working towards bringing a net zero rating verification to Canada Dec12 2015: COP 21 international commitments to keep global average temperature increase well below 2 0 C above pre-industrial levels and to pursue efforts to limit the temperature increase to 1.5 0 C
Context March 2016: Vancouver Declaration First Ministers agree to Federal target of reducing GHG emissions to 30% below 2005 levels by 2030 Four working groups established to develop a pan-canadian framework on clean growth and climate change April 2016: WGBC launches Advancing Net Zero initiative with CaGBC participation
CaGBC s Net Zero Initiative Overarching goal: Catalyze action towards reducing GHG emissions associated with buildings Market sector: Commercial / institutional buildings Design and operations
CaGBC s Net Zero Initiative How? (sub-goals) Create consistency in our understanding and approach to Net Zero in Canada Develop a framework and associated definition(s) of Net Zero buildings that achieves broad applicability and buy-in across the country Explore the need and potential for some recognition of Net Zero efforts Identify a possible role for the CaGBC in Net Zero buildings
Progress June 1, 2016: First meeting of CaGBC s Path to Net Zero Working Group June-August: consultations with Working Group, CaGBC Energy and Engineering Technical Advisory Committee, LEED Canada Steering Committee, and small number of other key stakeholders First report to be completed end of September Definition and preliminary framework
Progress Considerations include: Energy and/or carbon Site or source (if source ) Regional or national electric grid emissions factors Onsite/offsite renewables, RECs, carbon offsets Embodied energy/carbon of materials Etc
Next steps Feedback on framework Development of pathways / strategies to net zero Development of framework for third party verification of Net Zero buildings
Nova Scotia s Environmental Goals and Sustainable Prosperity Act Enacted unanimously 2007 25% renewables by 2015 40% renewables by 2020 State of the Art Green Building (NSCC Waterfront Campus LEED Gold) Low profile Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C 36
European Union 20/20/20 Adopted by European Union parliament December 2008 To reduce emissions of greenhouse gases by 20% by 2020 taking 1990 emissions as the reference. To increase energy efficiency to save 20% of EU energy consumption by 2020. To reach 20% of renewable energy in the total energy consumption in the EU by 2020. Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C 37
Germany 38 Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C
USA California Timeline of California's Renewables Portfolio Standard 2002: Senate Bill 1078 establishes the RPS program, requiring 20% of retail sales from renewable energy by 2017. 2003: Energy Action Plan I accelerated the 20% deadline to 2010. 2005: Energy Action Plan II recommends a further goal of 33% by 2020. 2006: Senate Bill 107 codified the accelerated 20% by 2010 deadline into law. 2008: Governor Schwarzenegger issues Executive Order S-14-08 requiring 33% renewables by 2020. 2009: Governor Schwarzenegger issues Executive Order S-21-09 directing the California Air Resources Board, under its AB 32 authority, to adopt regulations by July 31, 2010, consistent with the 33% renewable energy target established in Executive Order S-14-08. 2011: Senate Bill X1-2, signed by Gov. Edmund G. Brown, Jr., codifies 33% by 2020 RPS. 2015: Senate Bill 350, signed by Gov. Edmund G. Brown, Jr. codifies 50% by 2030 RPS Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H- 19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C 39
2030 Challenge All new buildings, developments, and major renovations shall be carbon-neutral by 2030 http://architecture2030.org/2030_challenges/2030-challenge/ 40 Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C
Living Building Challenge https://livingfuture.org/sites/default/files/photo s/15-0105%20nzeb%20docreq- FINAL.pdf NZEB Certification Required Imperatives 1-01 Limits to Growth 1-06 Net Positive Energy 1-19 Beauty and Spirit 1-20 Inspiration and Education Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H- 19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C 41
Nature s Way How tough is it to achieve Net Zero Energy, Zero Water, Zero Waste? Simple! Just add earth, air, water, and sunshine! Just 42 Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C
NZEB A Bullitt Centre, Seattle, Washington Interactive Dashboard. http://buildingdashboard.com/clients/bullittcenter/ NZEB A/ Net Energy Positive. Net Zero Water Living Building 2013 Greenest Commercial office Building 50,000SF Produces more energy than it consumes 43 Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C
Net Zero Energy NZEB A. Bullitt Centre, Seattle, Washington 44 Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C
Rocky Mountain Institute Innovation Centre http://www.rmi.org/innovationcenter LEED Platinum (NC v2009) Anticipating ILFI Net Zero Energy Certification Anticipating Living Building Challenge Petal Recognition PassiveHouse Certified PHIUS+ Source Net Zero project Exceeds Architecture 2030 Challenge goals Anticipating Energy Star target score of 100 45 Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C
Bigging it Up 46 Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C
Thank you Questions/Discussion.and net zero energy, water, and waste. Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H- 19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C 47
2016 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2050 2055 2060 2065 2070 2075 2080 2085 2090 2095 2100 48 Ecology Action Centre Speaker Series - Built Environment 21 September 2016 H-19 Dalhousie School of Architecture John Crace FRAIC MNSAA LEED AP BD+C