Descendants of John Porter and Elizabeth Donald

Descendants of John Porter and Elizabeth Donald Generation 1 1. JOHN 1 PORTER was born on 05 Feb 1795 in Paisley, Renfrew, Scotland (See "photo" of birth and baptism record, and accompanying explanation.). He died on 29 Apr 1858 in Ottawa, Carleton, Ontario, Canada (Ottawa City Council Minutes of 1911, page 631. 23. Porter John.. Died April 29, 1858, age 65 years, Elizabeth Donell, wife of John Porter, died July 13, 1847, age 52. John Porter Jr, died Aug 22nd, 1841, age 24, Thos Porter died Oct 10, 1843, age 14). He married (1) ELIZABETH DONALD, daughter of John? Donald and Joan? Shields? on 18 Feb 1814 in Paisley, Renfrew, Scotland (See "photo's" from both High and Low church. Both state irregular marriage. Low church says marriage 18 Feb, recorded 18 Oct. High church says marriage 16 Oct. See also "photo" of birth of daughter Mary in 1814. IGI M119623, & IGI M115735.). She was born on 30 Oct 1793 in Paisley, Renfrew, Scotland (Gravestone gives her maiden surname as Donell. Presumably this name was given by her husband John. Her son David gave her maiden name as Donald, in his second marriage record. Donell, Donald and McDonald are sometimes interchangeable. See "photo"). She died on 13 Jul 1847 in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada (Ottawa City Council Minutes of 1911, page 631. 23. Porter John.. Died April 29, 1858, age 65 years, Elizabeth Donell, wife of John Porter, died July 13, 1847, age 52. John Porter Jr, died Aug 22nd, 1841, age 24, Thos Porter died Oct 10, 1843, age 14). He married (2) JANET SARAH? GLEN on 13 Sep 1848 in Paisley Middle Church, Scotland (Bytown Packet Oct 26, 1848: "At Dalry, Scotland on 13 Sept 1848, John Porter of Bytown to Sarah, dau of late Captain Glen, Royal Navy." In his will of 1858, John Porter mentions his wife Janet. IGI M119615 See "photo" of marriage record.). She was born in 1797 in Scotland (age 51 at marriage in 1848). John Porter and Elizabeth Donald had the following children: 2. i. ALEXANDER 2 PORTER was born on 04 Oct 1831 in Bathurst, Lanark, Ontario, Canada (Birth and Death Dates from Landis Cemetery Index.). He died on 21 Sep 1914 in Landis, Saskatchewan, Canada (Birth and death dates from Landis cemetery index.). He married Catherine Wilson, daughter of John Wilson and Jane Hunt in 1859. She was born on 10 Jan 1839 in Fitzroy, Carleton, Ontario, Canada (Jan 10, 1839 from Landis Record. Jan 1839 from 1901 and 1911 census.). She died on 05 Sep 1929 in Landis, Saskatchewan, Canada (Landis cemetery index Saskatchewan Cemeteries Project lists: "Porter, Catherine (nee Wilson) Jan 10, 1839 - Sept 5, 1929 dau of John and Jane (nee Hunt)"). i MARY PORTER was born on 18 Jun 1814 in Paisley, Renfrew, Scotland. She died before 1821 (Possible death. Did not accompany family to Canada.). JOHN PORTER was born in Jun 1816 in Paisley, Renfrew, Scotland (Date calculated from age 25 years 2 mo at death on 17 Aug, 1841.). He died on 07 Aug 1841 in Bytown, Canada West (Bathurst Courier of Aug 17: Death in Bytown, 7th Inst, John Porter, Eldest son of J. Porter, Esq, Merchant of that place, aged 25 years, 2 months.). 3. WILLIAM PORTER was born in Aug 1817 in Paisley, Renfrew, Scotland (Age 53 at death in 1870.). He died on 12 Oct 1870 in Bathurst, Lanark, Ontario, Canada (See "photograph" of obituary from the Perth Courier.). He married Janet Morton Watt, daughter of Thomas Watt and Mary Brymmer on 30 Jan 1844 in Perth, Bathurst, Ontario, Canada (Bathurst Courier, Feb 6, 1844: Marriage, On the 30th ult, by Rev.Wm Bell, Mr. William Porter to Miss Janet Watt, both of the township of Bathurst.). She was born on 09 May 1825 in Stirling, Scotland (Birth date from death record. Birth Location and middle name from back of photograph given as Sterling. Probably Stirling.). She died on 17 Aug 1909 in Mill St., Deseronto Hastings, Ontario, Canada (Ontario death record confirmed from photograph). v. THIRD_SON PORTER was born in 1818. He died in 1821. 4. ELIZABETH PORTER was born on 25 Feb 1820 in Paisley, Renfrew, Scotland (Birth date given in Baptism Record.). She died on 18 Sep 1877 in Westmeath?, Renfrew,

date given in Baptism Generation Record.). She 1 (con't) died on 18 Sep 1877 in Westmeath?, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (Gravestone in Beachburg, Ontario died Sept 18, 1877, age 58 years, Native of Paisley, Scotland). She married Hugh Carmichael on 02 Feb 1847 in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada (Bathurst Courier, 16 Feb 1847. Marriage On 2nd Inst, at the residence of the Brides father, Bytown, by Rev. Mr. Durie, Mr. Hugh Carmichael, Westmeath to Elizabeth, eldest daughter of John Porter, Esq. (Also reported in Globe and Mail, Toronto.)). He was born in 1813 in Argylshire, Scotland (birth year from gravestone age at death.). He died on 17 Jul 1864 in Westmeath, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (Ottawa Citizen Death Announcement July 22, 1864: Hugh Carmichael. Died at his residence, Edgewood Farm, Westmeath, CW on July 17, 1864. Gravestone: Sacred to the memory of Hugh Carmichael, a native of Argylshire, Scotland...age 51). v vi ix. JAMES PORTER was born in 1827 in Bathurst, Lanark, Ontario. He married LYDIA. THOMAS MCGUFFOG PORTER was born in 1829 in Bathurst, Lanark, Ontario. He died on 03 Oct 1843 in Bytown, Ontario (Death reported in Bytown Gazette on Oct 5.). MARY PORTER was born on 24 Mar 1830 in Bathurst, Lanark, Ontario (Birth date given in Baptism Record.). 5. x. DAVID PORTER was born in 1834 in Bathurst, Lanark, Ontario, Canada. He died before 1891 (Wife listed as widowed in 1891 census.). He married (1) MARY ELLEN COMRIE, daughter of Peter Comrie and Catherine Burns on 15 Nov 1866 in Westmeath, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (Ottawa Citizen Marriage printed Nov 24, 1866, On Nov 15, by the Rev Hugh Cameron, David Porter to Mary Helen Comrie, eldest daughter of Peter Comrie, all of Westmeath, CW. County marriage record says David Porter age 20 married Mary Helen Connell, Nov 5). She was born in 1841 in Carleton Place. She died on 11 Dec 1881 in Pembroke, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (Gravestone: Mary E Comrie, wife of David Porter died Dec 11, 1881, aged 40 yrs. Mary Ellen dau of D. & M. Porter died Mar 29, 1882, aged 8 yrs.). He married (2) MARY JANE RAMSAY on 22 Oct 1882 in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada (Marriage record states David's parents were John Porter and Elizabeth Donald). She was born on 08 May 1843 in Amprior (Birth date from death record. Second given name Jane from her death record, and from her son William Ramsay Porter's death record.). She died on 20 Feb 1921 in Point Grey, British Columbia (Age: 77). 6. xi. JANE PORTER was born on 15 Dec 1836 in Bathurst, Lanark, Ontario (Birth date given in Baptism Record.). She died on 04 Jan 1905 in Middlesex, Ontario, Canada. She married James A. Dyke on 04 Aug 1853 in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada (Bytown Packet or Ottawa Citizen marriage notice printed Aug 6, 1853: At Bytown on Aug 4, James Dyke to Jane Porter). He was born in 1823 in Quebec, Canada. x GEORGE? PORTER was born in 1838 in Ottawa (No proof that this George is a member of the same family.). He married Mary A. Wilson, daughter of William Wilson and Jane on 25 Sep 1859 in Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (Both spouses living in Renfrew.). She was born in 1838 (From age at marriage). Generation 2 2. ALEXANDER 2 PORTER (John 1 ) was born on 04 Oct 1831 in Bathurst, Lanark, Ontario, Canada (Birth and Death Dates from Landis Cemetery Index.). He died on 21 Sep 1914 in Landis, Saskatchewan, Canada (Birth and death dates from Landis cemetery index.). He married Catherine Wilson, daughter of John Wilson and Jane Hunt in 1859. She was born on 10 Jan 1839 in Fitzroy, Carleton, Ontario, Canada (Jan 10, 1839 from Landis Record. Jan 1839 from 1901 and 1911 census.). She died on 05 Sep 1929 in Landis, Saskatchewan, Canada (Landis cemetery index Saskatchewan Cemeteries Project lists: "Porter, Catherine (nee Wilson) Jan 10, 1839 - Sept 5, 1929 dau of John and Jane (nee Hunt)").

Generation 2 (con't) Alexander Porter and Catherine Wilson had the following children: i. JOHN JAMES 3 PORTER was born on 29 Mar 1862 in Beachburg, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (from 1901 census). He died on 06 Aug 1924 in Landis, Saskatchewan, Canada (Landis Cemetery Index). i WILLIAM PORTER was born on 26 Dec 1863 in Beachburg, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. He died on 22 Mar 1941 in Biggar, Saskatchewan, Canada (Landis cemetery index.). ALEXANDER PORTER was born on 06 Oct 1866 in Beachburg, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (date from 1901 census). He died on 21 Nov 1930 in Saskatoon, Saskatchewan (Birth year and death date from Landis cemetery index.). 7. ALICE PORTER was born on 09 Feb 1867 in Beachburg, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (Elm Creek Cemetery records). She died on 27 Mar 1962 in Elm Creek, Manitoba (Elm Creek Cemetery records.). She married Walter Armstrong on 02 Dec 1885 in Beaulieu, Dakota. He was born on 31 Aug 1857 in Ontario, Canada (Elm Creek Cemetery records. Confirmed by Joyce Allen). He died on 26 Nov 1941 in Elm Creek, Manitoba (Elm Creek Cemetery records). 8. v. ALBERT EDWARD PORTER was born on 01 Jan 1869 in Beachburg, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (1869 based on ages in census reports and birth dates of siblings.). He died on 12 May 1951 in Flint, Genesee, Michigan (About 1950 in Whitmore family tree.). He married Essie Carr Buckley on 29 Jun 1907 in Palmer, Washington, Missouri (Albert E. Porter listed as being from Lancaster, Kittson, Minnesota). She was born on 19 Mar 1881 in Missouri. She died on 06 May 1958 in Michigan, USA. HENRY ALEXANDER ARTHUR? PORTER was born on 13 Mar 1870 in Beachburg, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. He died on 15 Jul 1960 in Paynton, Saskatchewan, Canada (Paynton cemetery index. Landis reocrd page 257.). He married CHARLOTTE JANE "JENNIE". She was born in 1888. She died in 1982. 9. v ROBERT ANDREW PORTER was born on 20 Oct 1871 in Beachburg, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (Birth date Oct 20, 1871 according to his daughter Hattie Elinor. Calculated birth date from death date and age at death also is Oct 20, 1871.). He died on 25 Sep 1945 in Elm Creek, Manitoba, Canada. He married Gertrude Agnes Hannaford Larter, daughter of George Herbert Larter and Mary Dammarell on 21 Nov 1900 in Granville or Hampden Township, Kittson, Minnesota (Larter family bible Presumed marriage location near home of bride or groom.). She was born on 22 Jan 1879 in Charlottetown, PEI, Canada (Larter family bible). She died on 10 Jan 1966 in Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada. 10. vi HERBERT THOMAS PORTER was born on 24 Mar 1874 in Beachburg, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. He died on 20 Mar 1955 in Vernon, BC (Reg. Number: 1955-09-003715). He married Rhoda Lidster, daughter of Elias Holmes Lidster and Mathilda Jane Reid on 30 Sep 1902 in Dufferin, Lisgar, Manitoba, Canada (REGISTRATION NUMBER: 1902,001113). She was born on 05 Feb 1882 in Ontario. She died on 04 Jul 1959 in Vernon, BC (Reg. Number: 1959-09-008135). ix. STILL BORN PORTER was born on 23 Nov 1874 in Westmeath, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (Parents listed Alexander Porter and Catharine Wilson). He died on 23 Nov 1874 in Westmeath, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. 11. x. WALTER PORTER was born on 04 Dec 1875 in Beachburg, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. He died on 08 Jan 1944 in Orange (Not proven that this is the same Walter Porter. Likely because: - exact birth date a in Canada, in Orange county in 1930 & 40 census. Buried in Fairhaven cemetery in Orange, same as Harold E

Generation 2 (con't) 1930 & 40 census. Buried in Fairhaven cemetery in Orange, same as Harold E and Minnie C. But Carmichael was aunt, not mother.). He married Minnie Brown on 30 Sep 1903 in Dufferin, Lisgar, Manitoba, Canada (REGISTRATION NUMBER: 1903,001633). She was born on 27 Jul 1878 in Ontario. She died on 15 Feb 1968 in Long Beach, Los Angeles, California, USA (Not proven this is the record for the same Minnie Porter, but likely because birth year within 1 year in Canada, buried in Fairhaven cemetery, same as probable husband and son.). xi. STILL BORN 2 PORTER was born on 30 Nov 1877 in Westmeath, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (Parents Alexander Porter and Catherine Wilson). She died on 30 Nov 1877 in Westmeath, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. 12. x CLARA PORTER was born on 10 Feb 1879 in Beachburg, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. She died on 14 Aug 1968 in Spokane City (Birth date in death record matches birth date of Clara Porter.). She married (1) ERNEST OMAR LARTER, son of George Herbert Larter and Mary Dammarell on 27 Dec 1898 in Northcote, Kittson, Minnesota (Larter family bible). He was born on 02 Jun 1875 in PEI, Canada (Larter family bible has date 2 June, 1876. WWI draft registration has date 2 June 1875, signed by Ernest. 1875 is more consistent with census records. Apparently the family bible list was prepared for all children at once, years after Ernest's birth.). He died on 13 Mar 1922 in Hillyard, Spokane, Washington. She married (2) EDWARD H TOUHEY on 12 Jan 1931 in Spokane, Washington, United States. 13. xi GEORGE PORTER was born in Feb 1881 in Morden, Manitoba, Canada. He died in 1967. He married Janetta Ardella Gee on 31 Oct 1906 in R.M. Grey, Manitoba (REGISTRATION NUMBER: 1906,002929). She was born on 27 Jul 1888 in Ontario. She died on 30 Aug 1982 in Vernon, BC (Reg. Number: 1982-09-014524). x ADDIE PORTER was born on 08 Nov 1883 in Walhalla, Pembina, North Dakota, USA (1883 from Landis Record, Nov 1883 from 1900 census, 8 Nov from 1901 census.). She died about Jun 1904 in Elm Creek, Manitoba (Calculated from birth date and age at death.). 3. WILLIAM 2 PORTER (John 1 ) was born in Aug 1817 in Paisley, Renfrew, Scotland (Age 53 at death in 1870.). He died on 12 Oct 1870 in Bathurst, Lanark, Ontario, Canada (See "photograph" of obituary from the Perth Courier.). He married Janet Morton Watt, daughter of Thomas Watt and Mary Brymmer on 30 Jan 1844 in Perth, Bathurst, Ontario, Canada (Bathurst Courier, Feb 6, 1844: Marriage, On the 30th ult, by Rev.Wm Bell, Mr. William Porter to Miss Janet Watt, both of the township of Bathurst.). She was born on 09 May 1825 in Stirling, Scotland (Birth date from death record. Birth Location and middle name from back of photograph given as Sterling. Probably Stirling.). She died on 17 Aug 1909 in Mill St., Deseronto Hastings, Ontario, Canada (Ontario death record confirmed from photograph). William Porter and Janet Morton Watt had the following children: 14. i. JOHN ROBERT? 3 PORTER was born on 10 Nov 1844 in Bathurst, Lanark, Ontario (Mentioned as primary heir in father's will. Given name Robert in 1900 census is probably an error.). He married Mary Ann Moulton, daughter of Robert Moulton and Anne Agnes? on 27 Mar 1879 in Drummond, Lanark, Ontario, Canada (Bathurst Courier, 4? April 1879. Marriage on Thurs 27th inst, at the residence of the bride's parents by Rev Jacob Freshman, Mr. John Porter Bathurst, to Miss Mary Ann Moulton, eldest daugther of Mr. Robert Moulton, Drummond.). She was born on 29 Apr 1852 in Ontario, Canada (From). She died on 23 Apr 1912 in N. Dakota (From "The Moultons With Irish Heritage" Confirmed by Gravestone inscription.). 15. ISABELLA MARIA PORTER was born on 02 Mar 1847 in Bathurst, Lanark, Ontario, Canada (Isabella Maria listed in father's will.). She died on 21 Aug 1885 in Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (Died a few months after Allan born. Death registerred with maiden name.). She married John McLellan on 26 Jun 1867 in Lanark, Ontario,

Generation 2 (con't) maiden name.). She married John McLellan on 26 Jun 1867 in Lanark, Ontario, Canada (Listed as Isabella Maria McLellan, wife of John McLellan, of Ross, Renfrew county, in her father's will. Marriage record from the Perth Courier, 28 June, 1867... on 26th Inst... John McLellan, Ross, to Isabella, daughter of Mr. William Porter, Bathurst.). He was born on 12 Jun 1838 in Greenoch, Scotland (From McLellan family tree by Cathy Walker). He died on 25 Feb 1899 in Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. 16. i THOMAS MCGUFFOCK PORTER was born on 23 Sep 1849 in Bathurst, Lanark, Ontario, Canada (Wiilliam McGuffock listed as one of William Porter's children in William's will.). He married Ellen Kinsella on 16 Jan 1878 in Lanark, Lanark, Ontario, Canada (Bathurst Courier 18 Jan, 1878. Marriage on the 16th? inst by Rev. Jacob Freshman, at the parsonage, Mr. Thomas Porter Westmeath to Miss Ellen Kinsella, Beckwith). She was born in Dec 1850 in Ontario. MARGARET A. PORTER was born on 20 Nov 1851 in Bathurst, Lanark, Ontario, Canada (Listed as a child of William Porter in William's will.). She married John Taylor after 1881 (Margaret A. (Porter) Taylor and John Taylor signed documents in 1887 to release their claim on William Porters farm.). 17. v. ELIZABETH PORTER was born on 14 Nov 1854 in Bathurst, Lanark, Ontario, Canada (Listed as a child of William Porter in William's will. 1854 not certain.). She died on 24 Sep 1931 in Minto Manitoba (REGISTRATION NUMBER: 1931,040342. Not proven same Elizabeth.). She married James Comrie on 09 Aug 1881 in Ross, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. He was born on 30 Oct 1845 in Ontario (1845 given in death record). He died on 10 Jul 1931 in Winnipeg, Manitoba (REGISTRATION NUMBER: 1931,032146). WILLIAM PORTER was born on 01 Dec 1857 in Bathurst, Lanark, Ontario, Canada. He died on 31 Jan 1860 in Bathurst, Lanark, Ontario, Canada. 18. v WILLIAM PORTER was born on 31 May 1860 in Bathurst, Lanark, Ontario, Canada (Listed as a child of William Porter in William's will.). He married EMMA HINZ. She was born in Feb 1868 in Minnesota. vi ix. MARY JANE BYERS PORTER was born on 26 Jan 1863 in Bathurst, Lanark, Ontario, Canada (Listed as a child of William Porter in William's will.). She married George Edward Clement on 10 Apr 1889 in Lanark, Lanark, Ontario, Canada. He was born about 1857 in Ontario. GEORGE ALEXANDER PORTER was born in 1866 in Bathurst, Lanark, Ontario, Canada (Listed as a child of William Porter in William's will.). 19. x. JESSIE MARTINA PORTER was born on 05 May 1868 in Bathurst, Lanark, Ontario, Canada (Listed as a child of William Porter in William's will. Martina from marriage record. Birth date from 1901 census.). She died in 1959. She married Albert Edward Augustus Manning on 20 Apr 1892 in Perth, Ontario, Canada. He was born on 12 Apr 1862 in Whitby, Ontario (From gravestone). He died on 07 Nov 1927 in Ontario, Ontario, Canada (Gravestone). 4. ELIZABETH 2 PORTER (John 1 ) was born on 25 Feb 1820 in Paisley, Renfrew, Scotland (Birth date given in Baptism Record.). She died on 18 Sep 1877 in Westmeath?, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (Gravestone in Beachburg, Ontario died Sept 18, 1877, age 58 years, Native of Paisley, Scotland). She married Hugh Carmichael on 02 Feb 1847 in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada (Bathurst Courier, 16 Feb 1847. Marriage On 2nd Inst, at the residence of the Brides father, Bytown, by Rev. Mr. Durie, Mr. Hugh Carmichael, Westmeath to Elizabeth, eldest daughter of John Porter, Esq. (Also reported in Globe and Mail, Toronto.)). He was born in 1813 in Argylshire, Scotland (birth year from gravestone age at death.). He died on 17 Jul 1864 in Westmeath, Renfrew,

(birth year from gravestone age at death.). Generation He died 2 (con't) 17 Jul 1864 in Westmeath, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (Ottawa Citizen Death Announcement July 22, 1864: Hugh Carmichael. Died at his residence, Edgewood Farm, Westmeath, CW on July 17, 1864. Gravestone: Sacred to the memory of Hugh Carmichael, a native of Argylshire, Scotland...age 51). Hugh Carmichael and Elizabeth Porter had the following children: i. MARY ELIZABETH 3 CARMICHAEL was born in Jan 1847. She died on 22 Jul 1848 in Gatineau Mills, Chelsea (Ottawa City Council Minutes of 1911, cemetery records, 21. Carmichael, Mary E., Sacred to the memory of Mary Elizabeth, daughter of Hugh Carmichael, Gatineau Mills, Chelsea who departed this life 22nd July 1848, age 1 year 7 mo.). i ELIZABETH CARMICHAEL was born on 21 Jul 1849 in Gatineau Mills, Quebec, Canada (Ottawa Citizen Birth Notice, July 28, 1849. At Gatineau Mills, July 21st, Elizabeth, infand dauhter of Hugh Carmichael, Esq). JOHN ALEXANDER CARMICHAEL was born in 1850 in Quebec, Canada. DUNCAN A. CARMICHAEL was born in 1852 in Quebec, Canada. He married Mary Skead on 10 Nov 1874 in St. Andrews Church, Ottawa (Ottawa Citizen, Nov 10, 1874: On the 10th inst at St. Andrews CHurch by Rev D.M. Gordon, D.A. Carmichael, M.D. to Miss Mary Skead, eldest daughter of Mr. Robert Skead, Ottawa.). v. JANE E. CARMICHAEL was born on 16 Aug 1853 in Gatineau Mills, Quebec, Canada (Ottawa Citizen Birth Announcement, Aug 20, 1853: At Gatineau Mills, Aug 16th, Mrs. H. Carmichael of a daughter.). She died on 24 Jul 1856 (Ottawa City Council Minutes of 1911, cemetery records, 22. Carmichael, Jane E, Daughter of Hugh Carmichael, Gatineau Mills, Westmeath who departed this life on July 24, 1856, 2 years 11 mos.). 20. HUGH ANDREW CARMICHAEL was born in 1856 in Gatineau Mills, Quebec, Canada. He married Lillian Harriet Eggleston, daughter of Newton Eggleston and Charity on 05 Feb 1878 in Beachburg, Westmeath, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (Bathurst Courier, 22 Feb, 1878. Marriage on Tues 9 Feb at the residence of the Bride's father, Beachburg,... Hugh A. Carmichael to Harriet Eggleston of the same place.). She was born in Oct 1858 in Beachburg, Ontario, Canada (Birth month calculated from age 21 years 8 months at death in June 1880.). She died on 13 Jun 1880 in Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. v ALLAN G. CARMICHAEL was born on 04 Apr 1856. He died on 31 Jul 1856 (Ottawa City Council Minutes of 1911, cemetery records, 22. Carmichael, Jane E, Daughter of Hugh Carmichael, Gatineau Mills, Westmeath who departed this life on July 24, 1856, 2 years 11 mos. Also, Allan G., his son, July 31, 1856, aged 3 mos., 27 dys.). 21. vi JAMES WILLIAM CARMICHAEL was born on 15 Oct 1859 in Ontario, Canada (Age at death 41 & 10/12 years. Calculated birth date between Oct 2 & Nov 2, 1859.). He died on 02 Sep 1901 in Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. He married (1) SARAH BIGGS on 03 Jan 1888 in Stafford, Renfrew, Ontario (Marriage record confirms James' parents were Hugh Carmichael and Elizabeth Porter). She was born on 01 Jan 1867 in Alice (Date from 1901 census matches age in marriage record.). He married (2) ELIZABETH KEYES on 26 May 1880 in Renfrew, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. She was born about 1858 in Westmeath. She died on 26 Sep 1886 in Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (Beachburg Cemetery Reocrd: Elizabeth Keyes, wife of J.W. Carmichael died Sept 26, 1886, age 28. Death record says she was a Farmer's wife.). 22. ix. THOMAS DAVID CARMICHAEL was born in 1862 in Westmeath, Ontario, Canada. He

Generation 2 (con't) 22. ix. T D C was born in 1862 in Westmeath, Ontario, Canada. He married Margaret Catherine Menzie on 10 Nov 1886 in Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. She was born about 1866 in Ontario. 5. DAVID 2 PORTER (John 1 ) was born in 1834 in Bathurst, Lanark, Ontario, Canada. He died before 1891 (Wife listed as widowed in 1891 census.). He married (1) MARY ELLEN COMRIE, daughter of Peter Comrie and Catherine Burns on 15 Nov 1866 in Westmeath, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (Ottawa Citizen Marriage printed Nov 24, 1866, On Nov 15, by the Rev Hugh Cameron, David Porter to Mary Helen Comrie, eldest daughter of Peter Comrie, all of Westmeath, CW. County marriage record says David Porter age 20 married Mary Helen Connell, Nov 5). She was born in 1841 in Carleton Place. She died on 11 Dec 1881 in Pembroke, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (Gravestone: Mary E Comrie, wife of David Porter died Dec 11, 1881, aged 40 yrs. Mary Ellen dau of D. & M. Porter died Mar 29, 1882, aged 8 yrs.). He married (2) MARY JANE RAMSAY on 22 Oct 1882 in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada (Marriage record states David's parents were John Porter and Elizabeth Donald). She was born on 08 May 1843 in Amprior (Birth date from death record. Second given name Jane from her death record, and from her son William Ramsay Porter's death record.). She died on 20 Feb 1921 in Point Grey, British Columbia (Age: 77). David Porter and Mary Ellen Comrie had the following children: 23. i. CATHERINE ELIZA "KATE" 3 PORTER was born on 18 Oct 1867 in Ontario. She married Findlay Watt before 1901 (Findlay with parents in 1891. Information about Kate's husband and children from Mrs. Harold McBride, Beachburg.). He was born in Dec 1865 in Ontario. i MARY ELLEN PORTER was born on 18 Jun 1873 in Bradford, Simcoe, Ontario, Canada. She died on 20 Mar 1882 in Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (Gravestone: Mary E Comrie, wife of David Porter died Dec 11, 1881, aged 40 yrs. Mary Ellen dau of D. & M. Porter died Mar 29, 1882, aged 8 yrs.). WILMETTA JANE PORTER was born on 02 Aug 1875 in Simcoe, Ontario, Canada. David Porter and Mary Jane Ramsay had the following child: 24. WILLIAM RAMSAY PORTER was born on 31 Oct 1883 in Ottawa, Ontario (location and date from death record.). He died on 22 Feb 1968 in Vancouver, BC (Age: 84). He married Sarah Ethel Willis on 02 Dec 1912 in Vancouver BC. She was born on 24 Oct 1885 in Bathurst, New Brunswick. She died on 27 Jun 1942 in Vancouver, BC (Age: 56). 6. JANE 2 PORTER (John 1 ) was born on 15 Dec 1836 in Bathurst, Lanark, Ontario (Birth date given in Baptism Record.). She died on 04 Jan 1905 in Middlesex, Ontario, Canada. She married James A. Dyke on 04 Aug 1853 in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada (Bytown Packet or Ottawa Citizen marriage notice printed Aug 6, 1853: At Bytown on Aug 4, James Dyke to Jane Porter). He was born in 1823 in Quebec, Canada. James A. Dyke and Jane Porter had the following children: i. JAMES ANDREW 3 DYKE was born in 1855 in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada. i ELIZABETH M. DYKE was born in 1857 in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada. BEATRICE M. DYKE was born on 04 Nov 1860 in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada. She died on 12 Jul 1913 in Middlesex, Ontario, Canada (Death record lists parents as James Dyke and Jane Porter.). HERBERT E. DYKE was born in 1863 in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada. v. GERTRUDE LOUISA DYKE was born in 1865 in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada. She died on 16 Apr 1892 in York, Ontario, Canada. She married Edward James Whyte on 25 Dec 1889 in Middlesex. He was born in 1864.

Generation 2 (con't) v ARTHUR LAWRENCE DYKE was born in 1867 in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada. He married Elizabeth Hamilton on 22 May 1920 in York. HILDA JANE DYKE was born on 16 Dec 1870 in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada. She died on 25 May 1908 in Lambton, Ontario, Canada. She married Robert B. Bell on 13 Oct 1897 in Middlesex (Middlesex, Ontario). He was born in 1870 in Ontario. Generation 3 7. ALICE 3 PORTER (Alexander 2, John 1 ) was born on 09 Feb 1867 in Beachburg, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (Elm Creek Cemetery records). She died on 27 Mar 1962 in Elm Creek, Manitoba (Elm Creek Cemetery records.). She married Walter Armstrong on 02 Dec 1885 in Beaulieu, Dakota. He was born on 31 Aug 1857 in Ontario, Canada (Elm Creek Cemetery records. Confirmed by Joyce Allen). He died on 26 Nov 1941 in Elm Creek, Manitoba (Elm Creek Cemetery records). Walter Armstrong and Alice Porter had the following children: i. LILLIAN CLARA 4 ARMSTRONG was born on 01 Dec 1897 in Northcote, Minnesota, USA (Confirmed by Joyce Allen). She died on 11 Aug 1992 in Biggar, Saskatchewan, Canada (Date from Joyce Allen). She married Percy Servage on 22 Jan 1925 in Grey Municipality, Manitoba (REGISTRATION NUMBER: 1925-003216). He died on 08 May 1984 (Date from Joyce Allen). 25. ALICE IDA ARMSTRONG was born in Oct 1886 in North Dakota, USA. She died on 07 Jun 1967 in Elm Creek, Manitoba ("Ripples from the Creek", p195). She married Robert George Love on 24 Dec 1907 in Grey Municipality, Manitoba (REGISTRATION NUMBER: 1907,002202). He was born in Mar 1885 in Ontario. He died in 1969 in Carman, Manitoba (Information from Joyce Allen). i VIOLET MABEL ARMSTRONG was born on 10 Dec 1893 in Minnesota, USA (Exact date from Joyce Allen.). She died on 27 Oct 1989 in Carman, Manitoba (Date from Joyce Allen). She married Ira William Hargest on 22 Dec 1915 in Grey Municipality, Manitoba (REGISTRATION NUMBER: 1915,212135). He was born on 15 Jan 1887 in Brant, Ontario, Canada. 8. ALBERT EDWARD 3 PORTER (Alexander 2, John 1 ) was born on 01 Jan 1869 in Beachburg, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (1869 based on ages in census reports and birth dates of siblings.). He died on 12 May 1951 in Flint, Genesee, Michigan (About 1950 in Whitmore family tree.). He married Essie Carr Buckley on 29 Jun 1907 in Palmer, Washington, Missouri (Albert E. Porter listed as being from Lancaster, Kittson, Minnesota). She was born on 19 Mar 1881 in Missouri. She died on 06 May 1958 in Michigan, USA. Albert Edward Porter and Essie Carr Buckley had the following child: i. EDNA ELLIS ALICE? 4 PORTER was born about 1908 in Oregon. She died on 12 Feb 1927 in Cedar Key, Levy, Florida (Information from Whitmore Family Tree). She married L. H. Kennedy on 07 May 1926 in Levy, Florida. 9. ROBERT ANDREW 3 PORTER (Alexander 2, John 1 ) was born on 20 Oct 1871 in Beachburg, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (Birth date Oct 20, 1871 according to his daughter Hattie Elinor. Calculated birth date from death date and age at death also is Oct 20, 1871.). He died on 25 Sep 1945 in Elm Creek, Manitoba, Canada. He married Gertrude Agnes Hannaford Larter, daughter of George Herbert Larter and Mary Dammarell on 21 Nov 1900 in Granville or Hampden Township, Kittson, Minnesota (Larter family bible Presumed marriage location near home of bride or groom.). She was born on 22 Jan 1879 in Charlottetown, PEI, Canada (Larter family bible). She died on 10 Jan 1966 in Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada. Robert Andrew Porter and Gertrude Agnes Hannaford Larter had the following children: 26. i. VIVIAN RUTH 4 PORTER was born on 05 Jan 1903 in Elm Creek, Manitoba (R.M.

Generation 3 (con't) 26. i. V R P was born on 05 Jan 1903 in Elm Creek, Manitoba (R.M. Dufferin. REGISTRATION NUMBER: 1903-006022). She died on 28 Feb 1979 in Borden, Saskatchewan. She married Peter George Garrett on 17 Nov 1926 in Elm Creek, Manitoba, Canada (R.M. Grey REGISTRATION NUMBER: 1926,051418). He died in 1976 (Date from wife Ruth's obit.). 27. IVA MARION PORTER was born on 16 Aug 1907 in Elm Creek, Manitoba, Canada (Manitoba Birth REGISTRATION NUMBER: 1907-001923 Mother listed as Gertrude Larter.). She died on 20 Mar 1991 in Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada. She married Lloyd John Johnson on 18 Mar 1932 in Winnipeg, Manitoba (Family records from H.E. (Porter) Butler). He was born on 20 Apr 1903 in Clear Springs, Manitoba. He died on 14 Jan 1975 in Winnipeg, Manitoba (See obituary). 28. i HATTIE ELINOR PORTER was born on 20 Dec 1915 in Elm Creek, Manitoba, Canada. She died on 19 Oct 2010 in White Rock, BC (Notified by daughter S.A. (Butler) Weaver). She married LEONARD EWART BUTLER. He was born on 14 Mar 1915 in Elm Creek, Manitoba, Canada. He died on 01 Oct 1977 in British Columbia, Canada. 29. ROBERT GORDON PORTER was born on 29 Nov 1918 in Elm Creek, Manitoba, Canada. He died on 09 Jun 2000 in Carmen, Manitoba, Canada. He married Pearl Grace Thompson on 11 Oct 1943 in Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada. She was born on 27 Apr 1923 in Elm Creek District (from Obit). She died on 11 Sep 2002. 10. HERBERT THOMAS 3 PORTER (Alexander 2, John 1 ) was born on 24 Mar 1874 in Beachburg, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. He died on 20 Mar 1955 in Vernon, BC (Reg. Number: 1955-09-003715). He married Rhoda Lidster, daughter of Elias Holmes Lidster and Mathilda Jane Reid on 30 Sep 1902 in Dufferin, Lisgar, Manitoba, Canada (REGISTRATION NUMBER: 1902,001113). She was born on 05 Feb 1882 in Ontario. She died on 04 Jul 1959 in Vernon, BC (Reg. Number: 1959-09-008135). Herbert Thomas Porter and Rhoda Lidster had the following children: i. JAMES FRANKLIN 4 PORTER was born on 09 Jan 1904 in R.M. Dufferin, Manitoba (REGISTRATION NUMBER: 1904,003259). i CECIL HERBERT PORTER was born on 29 May 1906 in R.M. Grey, Manitoba (REGISTRATION NUMBER: 1906,011421). He died on 09 Jun 1970 in Vernon, BC (Reg. Number: 1970-09-008160). He married MARGARET "PEGGY" SPENCE. She was born on 06 Apr 1917 in Vernon, British Columbia, Canada. She died on 28 Jan 2010 in Lumby, British Columbia, Canada. FLORENCE BEATRICE PORTER was born on 16 Jul 1907 in R.M. Grey, Manitoba (REGISTRATION NUMBER: 1907,001920). CATHERINE ELAINE PORTER was born on 01 Dec 1912 in Elm Creek, Manitoba (Manitoba birth REGISTRATION NUMBER: 1912-001987.). v. BESSIE LILLIAN PORTER was born on 11 Jul 1916 in Elm Creek, Manitoba (from daughter Virginia.). She died on 18 Aug 1989 in Salt Spring Island, BC, Canada (from daughter Virginai.). ALLAN DOUGLAS PORTER was born about 09 Jun 1918 in Elm Creek, Manitoba, Canada. He died on 09 Dec 1979 in British Columbia, Canada (Not certain same Allan Douglas Porter). 11. WALTER 3 PORTER (Alexander 2, John 1 ) was born on 04 Dec 1875 in Beachburg, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. He died on 08 Jan 1944 in Orange (Not proven that this is the same Walter Porter.

Canada. He died on 08 Jan 1944 in Generation Orange (Not 3 proven (con't) that this is the same Walter Porter. Likely because: - exact birth date a in Canada, in Orange county in 1930 & 40 census. Buried in Fairhaven cemetery in Orange, same as Harold E and Minnie C. But Carmichael was aunt, not mother.). He married Minnie Brown on 30 Sep 1903 in Dufferin, Lisgar, Manitoba, Canada (REGISTRATION NUMBER: 1903,001633). She was born on 27 Jul 1878 in Ontario. She died on 15 Feb 1968 in Long Beach, Los Angeles, California, USA (Not proven this is the record for the same Minnie Porter, but likely because birth year within 1 year in Canada, buried in Fairhaven cemetery, same as probable husband and son.). Walter Porter and Minnie Brown had the following child: i. HAROLD E 4 PORTER was born about 1904 in Manitoba. He died in 1925 in Orange, California (Not proven this is the record for the same Harold E. Porter, but likely because birth correct within 1 year in Canada, buried in Fairhaven cemetery, same as his probable parents.). 12. CLARA 3 PORTER (Alexander 2, John 1 ) was born on 10 Feb 1879 in Beachburg, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. She died on 14 Aug 1968 in Spokane City (Birth date in death record matches birth date of Clara Porter.). She married (1) ERNEST OMAR LARTER, son of George Herbert Larter and Mary Dammarell on 27 Dec 1898 in Northcote, Kittson, Minnesota (Larter family bible). He was born on 02 Jun 1875 in PEI, Canada (Larter family bible has date 2 June, 1876. WWI draft registration has date 2 June 1875, signed by Ernest. 1875 is more consistent with census records. Apparently the family bible list was prepared for all children at once, years after Ernest's birth.). He died on 13 Mar 1922 in Hillyard, Spokane, Washington. She married (2) EDWARD H TOUHEY on 12 Jan 1931 in Spokane, Washington, United States. Ernest Omar Larter and Clara Porter had the following children: i. IRENE CLARA 4 LARTER was born in 1901 in Whitefish, Montana. She died on 28 Apr 1904 in Whitefish, Montana (Conrad Memorial Cemetery, Kalispell, Montana). 30. LEIGH ERNEST LARTER was born on 24 Jan 1906 in Whitefish, Montana. He died on 19 Feb 1987 in Spokane, Washington, United States of America. He married (1) CHRISTINA MONTANA COOK on 05 Jan 1934 in Newport, Washington. He married (2) ELVIRA A before 1940 in Washington, USA. She was born about 1907 in Idaho. She died on 10 Mar 1985 in Spokane City (Age: 78). 13. GEORGE 3 PORTER (Alexander 2, John 1 ) was born in Feb 1881 in Morden, Manitoba, Canada. He died in 1967. He married Janetta Ardella Gee on 31 Oct 1906 in R.M. Grey, Manitoba (REGISTRATION NUMBER: 1906,002929). She was born on 27 Jul 1888 in Ontario. She died on 30 Aug 1982 in Vernon, BC (Reg. Number: 1982-09-014524). George Porter and Janetta Ardella Gee had the following children: i. OMAR 4 PORTER was born in Nov 1908 in Saskatchewan. i MABEL PORTER was born in Jan 1911 in Saskatchewan. KATHLEEN PORTER was born in 1912 in Saskatchewan, Canada. ROBERT PORTER was born in 1914 in Saskatchewan, Canada. v. WILLIAM PORTER was born on 30 May 1919 in Landis, Saskatchewan, Canada (Born on parents homestead.). He died on 06 Jan 1984 in Landis, Saskatchewan, Canada (Birth and death dates from Obituary.). He married KATHERINE MCDONALD. 14. JOHN ROBERT? 3 PORTER (William 2, John 1 ) was born on 10 Nov 1844 in Bathurst, Lanark, Ontario (Mentioned as primary heir in father's will. Given name Robert in 1900 census is probably an error.). He married Mary Ann Moulton, daughter of Robert Moulton and Anne Agnes? on 27 Mar 1879 in Drummond, Lanark, Ontario, Canada (Bathurst Courier, 4? April 1879. Marriage on Thurs 27th inst, at the residence of the bride's parents by Rev Jacob Freshman, Mr. John Porter Bathurst,

27th inst, at the residence of the bride's Generation parents 3 by (con't) Rev Jacob Freshman, Mr. John Porter Bathurst, to Miss Mary Ann Moulton, eldest daugther of Mr. Robert Moulton, Drummond.). She was born on 29 Apr 1852 in Ontario, Canada (From). She died on 23 Apr 1912 in N. Dakota (From "The Moultons With Irish Heritage" Confirmed by Gravestone inscription.). John Robert? Porter and Mary Ann Moulton had the following children: i. ANNIE EDNA 4 PORTER was born on 15 Feb 1882 in North Dakota. She died on 07 Jul 1943 in Los Angeles, California (death record confirms birth date of 15 Feb, 1882 in North Dakota, and also that her father's name was Porter and mother's maiden name was Moulton.). 31. IRA JOHN PORTER was born on 11 Nov 1885 in North Dakota. He died in 1952 in North Dakota. He married JENNIE RUTH DELONG. She was born on 09 Jan 1880 in Brooklin, Ontario. She died in 1964 in North Dakota. i OLIVE M PORTER was born in Sep 1888 in North Dakota. LOTTIE H PORTER was born in Jul 1892 in North Dakota (Lottie may have been a nickname for Charlotte, according to Rita Fox.). v. WILLIAM R PORTER was born in Aug 1880 in N Dak. 15. ISABELLA MARIA 3 PORTER (William 2, John 1 ) was born on 02 Mar 1847 in Bathurst, Lanark, Ontario, Canada (Isabella Maria listed in father's will.). She died on 21 Aug 1885 in Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (Died a few months after Allan born. Death registerred with maiden name.). She married John McLellan on 26 Jun 1867 in Lanark, Ontario, Canada (Listed as Isabella Maria McLellan, wife of John McLellan, of Ross, Renfrew county, in her father's will. Marriage record from the Perth Courier, 28 June, 1867... on 26th Inst... John McLellan, Ross, to Isabella, daughter of Mr. William Porter, Bathurst.). He was born on 12 Jun 1838 in Greenoch, Scotland (From McLellan family tree by Cathy Walker). He died on 25 Feb 1899 in Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. John McLellan and Isabella Maria Porter had the following children: 32. i. JOHN 4 MCLELLAN was born on 10 May 1868 in Ross, Renfrew North, Ontario, Canada. He died on 13 Jun 1946 in Kirkland Lake, Ontario (From McLellan Family tree, Catherine Walker). He married Maggie Little on 14 Jun 1893 in Beachburg, Renfrew, Ontario (Marriage record confirmed father John, mother Isabella M. Porter.). She was born in 1872 in Ontario. i JANET MARIA MCLELLAN was born on 13 Jan 1870 in Ross, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. ANN "MINNIE?" MCLELLAN was born on 25 Sep 1871 in Ross, Renfrew North, Ontario, Canada (date not certain). She married Peter McLaren on 20 Nov 1899 in Renfrew, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (marriage record confirms father John, mother Isabella Porter.). He was born in 1864 in Ontario. 33. WILLIAM MCLELLAN was born on 14 Jul 1873 in Ross Renfrew North, Ontario, Canada. He married Martha Jane Little on 07 Feb 1900 in Renfrew, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. She was born in Jan 1875 in Ontario. v. THOMAS ARCHIBALD MCLELLAN was born on 23 Apr 1875 in Ross, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. He died on 07 Jan 1934 in Perth, Lanark, Ontario, Canada (Death record lists parents as John McLellan and Issabella Porter). He married Lizzie Little on 20 Dec 1905 in Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. JANE "JENNIE" MCLELLAN was born on 25 Dec 1876 in Ross, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. She married John James Campbell McLean on 24 Jun 1907 in Renfrew, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada.

Generation 3 (con't) v vi ix. ISABELLA MARIA MCLELLAN was born on 07 Dec 1878 in Ross, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (birth record confirms father John, mother Isabella Maria Porter.). She married Daniel Burton Stewart on 11 Feb 1909 in Ross, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. He was born in 1875. DANIEL DAVID? MCLELLAN was born on 10 Nov 1880 in Ross, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (David in Birth record. Daniel in other records. Same birth date.). MARGARET E. MCLELLAN was born on 19 Aug 1882 in Ross, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (birth record confirms father John, mother Issabella Porter.). x. ALLAN MCLELLAN was born on 07 May 1885 in Ross, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. He died on 21 Jan 1910 in Spanish River, Ontario, Canada (Train wreck. Not proven this is the same Allan McLellan.). He married Evelyn Norma Wright on 20 Jan 1907 in Renfrew, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (marriage record confirms father John, mother Isabella Maria Porter.). She was born in 1886. 16. THOMAS MCGUFFOCK 3 PORTER (William 2, John 1 ) was born on 23 Sep 1849 in Bathurst, Lanark, Ontario, Canada (Wiilliam McGuffock listed as one of William Porter's children in William's will.). He married Ellen Kinsella on 16 Jan 1878 in Lanark, Lanark, Ontario, Canada (Bathurst Courier 18 Jan, 1878. Marriage on the 16th? inst by Rev. Jacob Freshman, at the parsonage, Mr. Thomas Porter Westmeath to Miss Ellen Kinsella, Beckwith). She was born in Dec 1850 in Ontario. Thomas McGuffock Porter and Ellen Kinsella had the following children: i. WILLIAM JAMES 4 PORTER was born on 07 Mar 1880 in Beachburg, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. i CHARLES A PORTER was born in May 1882 in North Dakota. JESSIE PORTER was born in Mar 1884 in North Dakota. ROY PORTER was born in Jul 1885 in North Dakota. v. JOHN WILBUR PORTER was born on 03 Nov 1887 in Inkster, North Dakota. 17. ELIZABETH 3 PORTER (William 2, John 1 ) was born on 14 Nov 1854 in Bathurst, Lanark, Ontario, Canada (Listed as a child of William Porter in William's will. 1854 not certain.). She died on 24 Sep 1931 in Minto Manitoba (REGISTRATION NUMBER: 1931,040342. Not proven same Elizabeth.). She married James Comrie on 09 Aug 1881 in Ross, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. He was born on 30 Oct 1845 in Ontario (1845 given in death record). He died on 10 Jul 1931 in Winnipeg, Manitoba (REGISTRATION NUMBER: 1931,032146). James Comrie and Elizabeth Porter had the following children: i. LORA MABEL 4 COMRIE was born on 27 May 1882 in Westmeath, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (birth record confirms father James, mother E. Porter). She married Charles Henry Roche on 15 Jul 1903 in Rosser, Manitoba (Manitoba Registration 1903,002010.). i ROBERT COMRIE was born on 26 Jun 1884 in Westmeath. JESSIE MARGARET COMRIE was born on 14 Dec 1886 in Westmeath, Renfrew, Ontario Canada (birth record confirms father James, mother Elizabeth Porter.). She married John Edward Stewart on 15 Jul 1915 in Rosser, Manitoba (Manitoba Vital Stats REGISTRATION NUMBER: 1915,182126).

Generation 3 (con't) GEORGE P. COMRIE was born on 02 Apr 1888 in Westmeath, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (birth record confirms father James, mother Elizabeth Porter.). v. WILLIAM JAMES COMRIE was born on 10 Mar 1891 in Westmeath, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. HATTIE HARRIETT? COMRIE was born on 14 Nov 1893 in Manitoba (Date not proven). 18. WILLIAM 3 PORTER (William 2, John 1 ) was born on 31 May 1860 in Bathurst, Lanark, Ontario, Canada (Listed as a child of William Porter in William's will.). He married EMMA HINZ. She was born in Feb 1868 in Minnesota. William Porter and Emma Hinz had the following children: i. ROSE ANNE 4 PORTER was born in Nov 1888 in North Dakota. i LILLIE J PORTER was born in Mar 1893 in North Dakota. WILLIAM ROBERT PORTER was born on 14 Apr 1896 in North Dakota. EMILY M PORTER was born in Apr 1896 in North Dakota. v. HAROLD HENRY PORTER was born on 30 Jun 1899 in North Dakota. HENRY L PORTER was born in 1907 in North Dakota. 19. JESSIE MARTINA 3 PORTER (William 2, John 1 ) was born on 05 May 1868 in Bathurst, Lanark, Ontario, Canada (Listed as a child of William Porter in William's will. Martina from marriage record. Birth date from 1901 census.). She died in 1959. She married Albert Edward Augustus Manning on 20 Apr 1892 in Perth, Ontario, Canada. He was born on 12 Apr 1862 in Whitby, Ontario (From gravestone). He died on 07 Nov 1927 in Ontario, Ontario, Canada (Gravestone). Albert Edward Augustus Manning and Jessie Martina Porter had the following children: i. MURIEL VICTORIA 4 MANNING was born on 25 Dec 1894 in York, Ontario, Canada. She married Charles Vincent Scott on 29 Mar 1918 in York, York, Ontario, Canada. i LAURA HELENA MANNING was born on 24 May 1899 in York, Ontario, Canada. DOUGLAS MANNING was born on 24 May 1897 in York, Ontario, Canada. He died on 22 Aug 1897 in York, Ontario, Canada. ALBERT GORDON MANNING was born on 25 Mar 1904 in York, Ontario, Canada. He died on 20 Aug 1904 in York, Ontario, Canada. v. DOROTHY ELOISE BERNICE MANNING was born on 02 Jan 1912 in Toronto (Information from Hand Family Tree by Stacey Mitchell). 20. HUGH ANDREW 3 CARMICHAEL (Elizabeth 2 Porter, John 1 Porter) was born in 1856 in Gatineau Mills, Quebec, Canada. He married Lillian Harriet Eggleston, daughter of Newton Eggleston and Charity on 05 Feb 1878 in Beachburg, Westmeath, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (Bathurst Courier, 22 Feb, 1878. Marriage on Tues 9 Feb at the residence of the Bride's father, Beachburg,... Hugh A. Carmichael to Harriet Eggleston of the same place.). She was born in Oct 1858 in Beachburg, Ontario, Canada (Birth month calculated from age 21 years 8 months at death in June 1880.). She died on 13 Jun 1880 in Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. Hugh Andrew Carmichael and Lillian Harriet Eggleston had the following child:

Generation 3 (con't) i. ALLEN 4 CARMICHAEL was born on 13 Feb 1880 in Westmeath, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (Allen in birth record.). 21. JAMES WILLIAM 3 CARMICHAEL (Elizabeth 2 Porter, John 1 Porter) was born on 15 Oct 1859 in Ontario, Canada (Age at death 41 & 10/12 years. Calculated birth date between Oct 2 & Nov 2, 1859.). He died on 02 Sep 1901 in Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. He married (1) SARAH BIGGS on 03 Jan 1888 in Stafford, Renfrew, Ontario (Marriage record confirms James' parents were Hugh Carmichael and Elizabeth Porter). She was born on 01 Jan 1867 in Alice (Date from 1901 census matches age in marriage record.). He married (2) ELIZABETH KEYES on 26 May 1880 in Renfrew, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. She was born about 1858 in Westmeath. She died on 26 Sep 1886 in Renfrew, Ontario, Canada (Beachburg Cemetery Reocrd: Elizabeth Keyes, wife of J.W. Carmichael died Sept 26, 1886, age 28. Death record says she was a Farmer's wife.). James William Carmichael and Sarah Biggs had the following children: i. ELYMAS ARCHIBALD 4 CARMICHAEL was born on 30 Mar 1900 in Ontario. PERCY EARL CARMICHAEL was born on 08 Jul 1889 in Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. James William Carmichael and Elizabeth Keyes had the following children: i ELIZABETH ROSALIA "LILLY" CARMICHAEL was born on 08 Nov 1882 in Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. HUGH HAROLD CARMICHAEL was born on 17 Mar 1881 in Beachburg, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. v. JAMES W CARMICHAEL was born in 1884 in Ontario. 22. THOMAS DAVID 3 CARMICHAEL (Elizabeth 2 Porter, John 1 Porter) was born in 1862 in Westmeath, Ontario, Canada. He married Margaret Catherine Menzie on 10 Nov 1886 in Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. She was born about 1866 in Ontario. Thomas David Carmichael and Margaret Catherine Menzie had the following children: i. MARY E 4 CARMICHAEL was born about 1889 in Ontario. HUGH ARCHIBALD CARMICHAEL was born on 11 May 1890 in Beachburg, Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. 23. CATHERINE ELIZA "KATE" 3 PORTER (David 2, John 1 ) was born on 18 Oct 1867 in Ontario. She married Findlay Watt before 1901 (Findlay with parents in 1891. Information about Kate's husband and children from Mrs. Harold McBride, Beachburg.). He was born in Dec 1865 in Ontario. Findlay Watt and Catherine Eliza "Kate" Porter had the following children: i. GORDON W. 4 WATT was born in Jan 1906 in Ontario. EDWARD PORTER WATT was born on 24 May 1908 in Renfrew, Ontario, Canada. 24. WILLIAM RAMSAY 3 PORTER (David 2, John 1 ) was born on 31 Oct 1883 in Ottawa, Ontario (location and date from death record.). He died on 22 Feb 1968 in Vancouver, BC (Age: 84). He married Sarah Ethel Willis on 02 Dec 1912 in Vancouver BC. She was born on 24 Oct 1885 in Bathurst, New Brunswick. She died on 27 Jun 1942 in Vancouver, BC (Age: 56). William Ramsay Porter and Sarah Ethel Willis had the following children: i. MILDRED 4 PORTER was born about 1913 in British Columbia. MARGARETTE PORTER was born about 1917 in British Columbia.

i Generation 3 (con't) CATHERINE PORTER was born about 1920 in British Columbia. Generation 4 25. ALICE IDA 4 ARMSTRONG (Alice 3 Porter, Alexander 2 Porter, John 1 Porter) was born in Oct 1886 in North Dakota, USA. She died on 07 Jun 1967 in Elm Creek, Manitoba ("Ripples from the Creek", p195). She married Robert George Love on 24 Dec 1907 in Grey Municipality, Manitoba (REGISTRATION NUMBER: 1907,002202). He was born in Mar 1885 in Ontario. He died in 1969 in Carman, Manitoba (Information from Joyce Allen). Robert George Love and Alice Ida Armstrong had the following children: i. ROBERT WESLEY 5 LOVE was born in Nov 1908 in Manitoba. ALICE ELVA LOVE was born in 1915 in Manitoba. 26. VIVIAN RUTH 4 PORTER (Robert Andrew 3, Alexander 2, John 1 ) was born on 05 Jan 1903 in Elm Creek, Manitoba (R.M. Dufferin. REGISTRATION NUMBER: 1903-006022). She died on 28 Feb 1979 in Borden, Saskatchewan. She married Peter George Garrett on 17 Nov 1926 in Elm Creek, Manitoba, Canada (R.M. Grey REGISTRATION NUMBER: 1926,051418). He died in 1976 (Date from wife Ruth's obit.). Peter George Garrett and Vivian Ruth Porter had the following children: i. MURIEL GRACE 5 GARRETT was born on 26 Sep 1928 in Carman, Manitoba, Canada. She married JOHN ROSNER. i ROBERT WARREN GARRETT was born on 03 Jan 1930 in Elm Creek, Manitoba. He married Myrtle Evelyn Bidewell on 12 Jul 1952 in Moose Jaw, Saskatchewan, Canada. She was born on 13 Nov 1932. GEORGE RENO GARRETT was born on 16 Nov 1934 in Parkbeg, Saskatchewan, Canada. He married Joan Elizabeth McIntyre on 25 Oct 1956. She was born on 06 Aug 1937. DONALD EDGAR GARRETT was born on 06 Jan 1936 in Secretan, Saskatchewan, Canada. He died in 1937 (Date from mother Ruth's obit.). v. ELINOR MARIE GARRETT was born on 23 Nov 1937 in Chaplin, Saskatchewan, Canada. She married JACK HORACE LEVERTON. JAMES KENNETH GARRETT was born on 21 Oct 1939. He married SANDRA BOSAK. 27. IVA MARION 4 PORTER (Robert Andrew 3, Alexander 2, John 1 ) was born on 16 Aug 1907 in Elm Creek, Manitoba, Canada (Manitoba Birth REGISTRATION NUMBER: 1907-001923 Mother listed as Gertrude Larter.). She died on 20 Mar 1991 in Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada. She married Lloyd John Johnson on 18 Mar 1932 in Winnipeg, Manitoba (Family records from H.E. (Porter) Butler). He was born on 20 Apr 1903 in Clear Springs, Manitoba. He died on 14 Jan 1975 in Winnipeg, Manitoba (See obituary). Lloyd John Johnson and Iva Marion Porter had the following child: i. LLOYD RONALD 5 JOHNSON was born on 26 Jan 1933 in Winnipeg, Manitoba. He died on 19 Jan 1996 in Winnipeg, Manitoba. He married Mary Eleanor Nash on 11 Jul 1959. She was born in Port Arthur, Ontario. 28. HATTIE ELINOR 4 PORTER (Robert Andrew 3, Alexander 2, John 1 ) was born on 20 Dec 1915 in Elm Creek, Manitoba, Canada. She died on 19 Oct 2010 in White Rock, BC (Notified by daughter S.A. (Butler) Weaver). She married LEONARD EWART BUTLER. He was born on 14 Mar 1915 in Elm Creek, Manitoba, Canada. He died on 01 Oct 1977 in British Columbia, Canada.