the great house price divide A briefing paper by the Smith Institute

Similar documents
Land Registry Practice Guide 13 May Official searches of the index of relating franchises and manors

ACADATA PRICES AND TRANSACTIONS (APAT LGA) METHODOLOGY

Landbay Rental Index. Powered by MIAC. UK Nationwide

Rental Index Report. March Powered by MIAC. Statistics: March Key Feature: The Regional Cost of Renting

Rental Index Report. April Powered by MIAC. Statistics: April Key Feature: Rental Change Across the UK

HomeLet Rental Index

HomeLet Rental Index

HomeLet Rental Index

HomeLet Rental Index

HomeLet Rental Index

HomeLet Rental Index

HomeLet Rental Index

HomeLet Rental Index

HomeLet Rental Index

Providers are asked to note the following in respect of the information requested:

Rightmove House Price Index

Rental Index Report. October Powered by MIAC. Statistics: UK. Key Feature: Growth in East Midlands, as Interest Rates Rise

Rightmove House Price Index

Inner London drives asking prices in the capital down 1.5% year-on-year

Rightmove House Price Index

Contents SEPTEMBER 2009

Rightmove House Price Index

Under embargo for 00:01 hours, Monday 20 th June 2016 Prices fall this month in London but no other region

Rightmove House Price Index

Average Property Asking Price 239, ,500 % Change in Month -1.2% 1.2% % Change in Past Year 0.1% 2.2% Monthly Index (Jan 2002=100)

House prices see biggest monthly boost for a year

Brexit! What next? CHC One Big Conference. Helen Collins, Director, Savills Housing Consultancy. 6 th October savills.com

Rightmove House Price Index

Rental Index Report. December Powered by MIAC. Statistics: December Key Feature: Rental increase and rail fare rise

2011 Census Snapshot: Housing

Rightmove House Price Index

Student accommodation rent report Student accommodation rent report

London & South East hold back house price growth

Rightmove House Price Index

Rightmove House Price Index

Rental Index Report. August Powered by MIAC. Key Feature: London Student City, Graduate Magnet. Statistics: UK. Area Spotlight: West Midlands

Rightmove House Price Index

London loses its boom-town crown to the South East

Rightmove House Price Index

Principality Building Society House Price Index Wales, Q1 2019

Private Hall Rent Data

Rightmove House Price Index

Rightmove House Price Index

Average number of days to find a buyer

January monthly change in asking prices

Low-Cost Home Ownership for People with Long-Term Disabilities - HOLD (ref 25)

H me Reach. The key to home ownership

House prices break new record, even as monthly growth falters

National Heritage List for England Online Application Form Guidance

Monthly asking price trend

IFHP World Congress Tallinn 12 September 2011 Planning as an Economic Tool. Duncan Bowie University of Westminster, UK

Rightmove House Price Index

Rightmove House Price Index

WHERE DO LAND DEVELOPERS GET THE BEST RETURN ON INVESTMENT IN ENGLAND? DEVELOPER REPORT

Monthly asking price trend

Rightmove House Price Index

Planning for affordable housing Michael Newey

Future Housing Requirements for the North

The Rightmove House Price Index

Rightmove House Price Index

Rightmove House Price Index

Rightmove House Price Index

The National Rent Review. December 2017

June 2013 Rental Index

2018: A tale of different markets leads to Rightmove forecast of +1%

Chargeable Green Garden Waste Research

MORE TH>N REVEALS THE FINANCIAL REALITIES OF RUNNING A HOME

Housing Led Recovery? Investing in the future. Implications for housing providers.

FARES NATIONAL AVERAGES AND BY AREA JANUARY 2012 THE NATIONAL AVERAGE FARE

December monthly change in asking prices

Reimagining London s Retail Parks

PLANNING FOR LONDON S BUILD TO RENT FUTURE

Acquisition Grants to Local Authorities to Underwrite Repairs Notices

FARES NATIONAL AVERAGES AND BY AREA FEBRUARY 2012

Research Programme. Residual Land Values: Measuring Performance and Investigating Viability

% monthly change in average asking prices

TwentyCi Property & Homemover Report Q Information embargoed until Wednesday 10th January 2017 at 00:01

Rural property values outperforming urban areas since the financial crisis *But affordability concerns grow*

Affordable Housing: Building through cycles

Housing affordability in England and Wales: 2018

Shared Ownership and Affordable Homes Programme 2016 to 2021 Addendum to the Prospectus. June 2018

Can t Supply: Can t Buy. The affordability of private housing in Great Britain summary report

BOARD PAPER - NHS ENGLAND

flexible right to buy

ROGUE LANDLORDS IN LONDON

Rental Index. Key Findings. Analysis. UK Rental Index by Number of Beds. Powered by MIAC Results for April 2017

HOUSING IN LONDON: The evidence base for the Mayor s Housing Strategy

2016 Q3 PROPERTY MARKET REPORT

Buy-to-Let Index Quarterly Report

Rent setting Policy. Contents. Summary:

Investigation report. Know your place

House prices in the latest three months (March 2014 May 2014) were 2.0% higher than in the preceding three months (December February2014).

Rental Index. Key Findings. Analysis. Index by Bedroom. Powered by MIAC Results for November 2016

Shared Ownership, Homebuy and HOLD (ref 07)

Has Brexit burst the British housing bubble?

Housing as an Investment Greater Toronto Area

Country life costs Brits over 44,000

landlord services

D S P Housing & Development Consultants

The rent trap and the fading dream of owning a home

Transcription:

the great house price divide A briefing paper by the Smith Institute

the great house price divide A briefing paper by the Smith Institute Published by The Smith Institute This report represents the views of the authors and not those of the Smith Institute. The Smith Institute December 2013

Contents Content Foreword Executive summary House prices in England and Wales House price boom and bust Price changes in pounds Who benefits and by how much? The total value of the housing stock: the growing regional divide A divided Britain: London and the North East Falling house prices since 2010 A tale of one (inner) city Ranking of average house prices by local area 2007-13 3 6 10 10 13 16 17 18 19 20 21 23 2

Foreword This briefing paper, written by the Smith Institute s in-house research team, forms part of our on-going work programme on the housing crisis. It follows recent reports we have published on council housing, the London housing market, the future of housing associations, housing and philanthropy, and home ownership. The research is intended to inform the debate about the state of the residential property market and house price movements in England and Wales. Our aim is to document what has happened across the country to house prices since the financial crisis, and to place the spotlight on some of the policy implications. The purpose of the report is not however to argue that high prices are good thing but to draw attention to the growing spatial disparities. We felt there was a need to provide a fuller picture of local housing markets and price movements since 2007, not least so policy makers are better informed about future house price growth and how price changes impact on demand and supply. There is also a need to look much wider at the socio-economic effects of changes in house prices by local areas. The discussion about house price movements has recently been dominated by rising house prices in London and its hinterland. Our research clearly documents the London effect, with values above what they were before the financial crisis. But, what stands out from the data is that there are many places in England and Wales where values are low and house prices remain well below their 2007 peak. As the research shows, what we have witnessed over the past six years is the growth of two distinct and divergent housing markets: a London centric property market where house prices have recovered and in some cases soared; and the rest of England and Wales where prices are flat and transactions are low. Beyond the headlines of double digit price rises in inner London, the report is a salutary reminder that average house prices for the country (which discount inflation) remain below their 2007 peak. It is also important to recognise that the divergence in house prices is symptomatic of deep-rooted and persistent uneven economic development, with jobs and growth concentrated in London and the South East. Increasing numbers of those looking to buy in these high demand areas will be excluded from homeownership. In those regions where prices are highest homeownership levels have been falling fastest. Moreover, it can lead to house price bubbles (especially given the historically high ratio of earnings to house prices). Perhaps just as worryingly if investment in new homes follows demand for housing (i.e. in London and the South East) it will result in more 3

economic activity and growth in these places thus further unbalancing the economy. Nevertheless, millions of home owners have seen the value of their homes collapse. This not only reduces some people s personal wealth (and that of regions), but also undermines their ambition to move on. In many parts of the country homeowners (particularly those who bought homes at the peak of the market) will now be in negative equity. The problem could become very serious in low value areas if interest rates rise. House-builders, developers and lenders are also wary of the higher risks in places where values remain low. This further distorts an already imperfect housing market and has a negative knock-on effect for investment in affordable and sub-market housing. For these reasons any government should take careful note of what has occurred since 2007 and calibrate its housing policy in the future to avoid another damaging cycle of housing boom and bust. Paul Hackett, Director, Smith Institute 4

Executive summary 5

Executive summary The research is primarily based on data from HM Land Registry and covers the period from the house price peak in November 2007 to October 2013. Of the 179 local areas examined in England and Wales, the place where house prices have fallen the most is Blaenau Gwent prices there have fallen by almost half (47.7%), and the average cost of a home is now 46,356. Other places have also seen major price falls: Hartlepool down 41.9%, Knowsley down 36.2%, Blackpool down 34.5%, Liverpool down 33%. The place where house prices have risen the most over the period is the City of Westminster, which saw price rises of 43.2% and the average price of a home is now 863,257. Other places in London also saw huge rises: Kensington & Chelsea up 42.8%, Hackney up 35.6%, Islington up 27.6%, Camden up 26.9% Across the country average prices are down by 15,000. In London the average home homeowner is 40,000 wealthier, whilst in the North East they are 30,000 poorer. An average homeowner in Hartlepool will have lost 44,000 on the value of their home since 2007; meanwhile an average homeowner in Kensington and Chelsea would have seen the value of their home rise by 351,000. Average house prices in England and Wales are 9% down on their peak in 2007. In London they are up by 12%. As a consequence, the average house price in England and Wales is 166,000. In London it is almost 400,000. The gap in average house prices between London and England and Wales has widened from 1.9 times in October 2007 to 2.4 times in October 2013. In all regions outside London house prices are still below the peak of 2007. Areas in the Midlands are 15% lower and in the North East down almost 25%. These changes also mask differences within and between London and other areas. The differential between the lowest and highest value areas was 10 times in 2007. 6

Now it stands at almost 25 times. All areas with average prices above 278,000 have experienced price rises, whereas just 5% of areas with prices below 278,000 have. Overall, those in high value housing areas have experienced rises whilst those in low cost areas have witnessed falls. Not only does this impact negatively on individuals but also on areas. For example, whilst the value of London s housing stock has increased by 140 billion since 2007 it has fallen by 203 billion in England and Wales (and by 343 billion excluding London). London s share of England and Wales property wealth has increased from 20% to 24% in five years. In total, London s 3.4 million homes are worth 1.3 times the value of the 6.9 million homes in the North East, Wales, East Midlands, Yorkshire and the Humber. House prices have fallen in value since the general election in all but London, the South East and Eastern Region. London has experienced a rise of 17%. Even within London there are differences: 6 of the 32 boroughs have experienced price falls since 2007, all of which have the lowest house prices and all of which are in outer London. If current trends continue the gap in house prices between London and the rest of the country will continue to widen. 7

Areas with the biggest fall in house prices, November 2007 - October 2013 Area Region Price change (%) Price change ( ) House price (2013) 1 Blaenau Gwent Wales -47.70% - 44,076 48,356.26 2 Hartlepool North East -41.90% - 44,191 61,174.65 3 Knowsley North West -36.20% - 47,313 83,241.13 4 Blackpool North West -34.50% - 39,079 74,229.03 5 Liverpool North West -33.00% - 41,159 83,392.59 6 Durham North East -32.00% - 37,252 79,073.33 7 Wolverhampton West Midlands -31.20% - 40,124 88,245.27 8 St Helens North West -31.10% - 39,829 88,275.52 9 Blackburn with North West -29.90% - 30,035 70,315.32 Darwen 10 Merseyside North West -27.70% - 37,638 97,843.44 Source: Smith Institute analysis of HM Land Registry data Areas with the biggest increases in house prices, November 2007 - October 2013 Area Region Price change (%) Price change ( ) House price (2013) 1 City of Westminster London 43.20% 260,230 863,256.78 2 Kensington and Chelsea London 42.80% 350,904 1,171,320.59 3 Hackney London 35.60% 129,403 493,350.11 4 Islington London 27.60% 121,499 562,721.12 5 Camden London 26.90% 143,249 676,278.49 6 Hammersmith and London 25.80% 130,215 637,072.85 Fulham 7 Wandsworth London 24.60% 97,248 493,029.32 8 Lambeth London 22.20% 79,682 440,183.87 9 Southwark London 19.80% 72,762 441,377.10 10 Haringey London 16.80% 59,004 410,784.13 Source: Smith Institute analysis of HM Land Registry data 8

The great house price divide 9

The great house price divide House prices in England and Wales When it comes to house prices, Britain is a divided nation. The average house price in England and Wales is 166,000. In the North East it is below 100,000 and in London it is four times higher (just under 400,000). This divide has worsened since the recession. Average house price, October 2013 Source: Smith Institute analysis of HM Land Registry data 10

House prices in England and Wales, October 2013 Source: Smith Institute analysis of HM Land Registry data 11

Over the longer term London s house prices have risen even more dramatically, leaving the rest of the country adrift. Importantly it is not just the proportional gap in prices between London and England and Wales which has risen from 1.5 times to 2.4 times, but also the absolute amount. For example, the gap was around 31,000 in 1995 today it now stands at 225,000. Average house prices in England and Wales and London, 1995 and 2012 Source: Smith Institute analysis of HM Land Registry data If current trends continue the gap in house prices between London and the rest of the country will continue to widen. By 2020 London house prices could conceivably be 3 times the average prices in England and Wales. 12

House price boom and bust The narrative of another house price boom is a tale of one city. In all areas of the country apart from London values are down on their peak of 2007. 1 And in all regions outside the greater South East of England price falls have been greater than the national average. In the Midlands (East and West) prices are down by around 15% and in the North East by almost 25%. Worryingly for some areas prices are continuing to fall. It also worth noting that inflation between November 2007 and May 2013 stood at 20.5% meaning that the real terms falls have been more extreme than are presented in this paper. 2 An unbalanced housing market undermines national productivity and competiveness by making it extremely difficult (and expensive) for people to move for work from low costs housing areas to high cost housing areas. A widening housing price divide also exacerbates income and wealth inequalities between places and constrains local and national efforts to rebalance the economy. Investors are wary of investing in places where house values are flat or falling. Overseas investment in particular is attracted to high value markets in London, raising the risk of a speculative housing bubble which would be damaging to the economy. Change in house prices (%) November 2007 October 2013 Source: Smith Institute analysis of HM Land Registry data 1 Peak values are set at November 2007 when they were highest in England and Wales rather than for each area. 2 ONS, Consumer Price Index 13

Change in house prices (%) November 2007 October 2013 Source: Smith Institute analysis of HM Land Registry data 14

A further illustration of the widening gap is presented below, with the price differential in the lowest area versus the highest area jumping from around 10 times more expensive to almost 25 times more expensive. This widening gap is not just between areas with low property values, the differential between the median area and highest also rose during the period from 5 times to 8 times more expensive approaching the multiple observed for the lowest to highest average price in 2007. Gap between areas with highest, median and lowest average prices November 2007 and October 2013 Source: Smith Institute analysis of HM Land Registry data 15

Price changes in pounds Changes in prices affect the value of the asset a homeowner holds, and in a falling market will push some into negative equity. The average homeowner who bought at the peak in London will today be 40,000 richer even after a global recession. For someone in the North East they are 30,000 poorer. Across the country, the value of the average home is down by 15,000. Moreover, the picture is starker still when comparing places within these regions. In Hartlepool the average homeowner will have lost 44,000 since 2007 (or 41% of the value) whereas someone in Kensington and Chelsea would have seen prices rise 351,000 (a 43% rise). The profit alone would enable someone to buy almost six average priced properties in Hartlepool. The relative fall in the value of homes has long term implications in regional differences in regard to personal finance, not least inheritance, less capital to release for housing repairs and retirement, and a constraint on people s ability to move. Change in house prices ( ) November 2007 October 2013 Source: Smith Institute analysis of HM Land Registry data 16

Who benefits and by how much? As the graph makes clear, in general, areas with high house values in 2007 have seen rises over above their peak. The few areas (12%) which had prices above 300,000 in 2007 have seen average house prices rise since the recession. Those with relatively low average prices have seen falls. This is particularly noticeable at the extreme left of the graph, with prices down by as much as half of peak values. For those in poorer areas values have declined reducing the value of their asset; for homeowners in high demand areas values rose (and for non-homeowners in those areas housing has become even more expensive). In total, all of the areas with average prices above 278,000 in 2007 (15% of all areas) have experienced price rises, whereas in places with average prices below 278,000 just 5% experienced rises. As a consequence the gap between those with high value homes and those with average and low value homes has widened. House price changes ( ) November 2007 October 2013 2013 Source: Smith Institute analysis of HM Land Registry data 2007 17

The total value of the housing stock: the growing regional divide Since 2008, the value of England and Wales housing stock has declined. However, once again the picture varies greatly between regions. The value of housing stock in London has increased by 140 billion. In England and Wales it has fallen by 203 billion (and by 343 billion excluding London). In 2007 London s share of England and Wales property wealth was 20%. Within five years it had increased to 24%. London and the South East combined account for 44% of the total. In total London s 3.4 million homes are worth 1.3 times the value of the 6.9 million homes in the North East, Wales, East Midlands, and Yorkshire and the Humber. Total value of housing stock ( bn) 2008 Value 2013 Value Change Percent of England and Wales total (2007) Percent of England and Wales total (2013) London 983 1,123 140 20.4% 24.3% South East 936 910-26 19.4% 19.7% East 537 510-27 11.1% 11.0% South West 510 471-39 10.6% 10.2% North West 483 403-80 10.0% 8.7% West Midlands 354 336-18 7.3% 7.3% Yorkshire and the 348 294-54 7.2% 6.4% Humber East Midlands 310 270-40 6.4% 5.8% Wales 205 176-29 4.2% 3.8% North East 160 129-31 3.3% 2.8% Total 4,825 4,622-203 100% 100% Total (excluding 3,842 3,499-343 London) Source: Smith Institute analysis based on research by Savills 18

A divided Britain: London and the North East The picture of house price changes is starkly illustrated in the figure below. Both the North East and London were equally affected by the downturn. However since then house prices in the two regions have diverged. Prices in the North East from early 2009 stabilised (and grew a little) until around the time of the general election and have since fallen further. In London prices rose returning to their peak in 2012, and since then have risen by 12%. House price change, 2007-2013 (Novemver 2007=100) Source: Smith Institute analysis of HM Land Registry data 19

Falling house prices since 2010 Since the general election in most regions average homeowners have experienced further falls in the value of their home. In the North East, North West, Yorkshire and the Humber, the East Midlands, West Midlands, Wales and the South West prices have fallen. Whilst prices have risen slightly in England and Wales (by 1.1%), as a whole this is a largely a result of 17% growth in London. House prices since May 2010 Source: Smith Institute analysis of HM Land Registry data 20

A tale of one (inner) city Average house prices in London have historically been higher than the rest of the UK. In 2007 average house prices in London were 1.9 times prices in England and Wales as a whole. In 2010 it was 2 times. And by 2013 the gap had risen to 2.4 times. The average house price in London is 390,000 and in Kensington and Chelsea it is 1.2 million. Over the period average prices rose by 350,000 in Kensington and Chelsea, over double the average cost of a house in the UK. This is in part due to high levels of overseas investment in London s prime property market. 1 Moreover, sales in England and Wales have dropped by 25% over the period but by just 3% in the nine inner London boroughs with the highest house price growth. But within London there have also been differences the average house price in Barking and Dagenham is now 228,000. Moreover six of the 32 boroughs saw decreases all of which have the lowest average values in London, and all in outer London. House prices in London, October 2013 Source: Smith Institute analysis of HM Land Registry data 1 Heywood, A London for sale? (Smith Institute, 2012) 21

House price change in London November 2007 October 2013 Source: Smith Institute analysis of HM Land Registry data 22

Ranking of average house prices by local area November 2007 October 2013 Price change (%) Price change ( ) House price (2013) Blaenau Gwent -47.70% - 44,076 48,356.26 Hartlepool -41.90% - 44,191 61,174.65 Knowsley -36.20% - 47,313 83,241.13 Blackpool -34.50% - 39,079 74,229.03 Liverpool -33.00% - 41,159 83,392.59 Durham -32.00% - 37,252 79,073.33 Wolverhampton -31.20% - 40,124 88,245.27 St Helens -31.10% - 39,829 88,275.52 Blackburn with -29.90% - 30,035 70,315.32 Darwen Merseyside -27.70% - 37,638 97,843.44 Middlesbrough -27.10% - 28,111 75,559.59 Stoke-on-Trent -26.60% - 24,112 66,443.03 Sunderland -26.60% - 29,861 82,047.83 Stockton-on-Tees -26.20% - 35,101 98,903.72 Halton -26.00% - 33,051 94,098.42 Bradford -25.80% - 32,536 93,460.49 Wigan -25.80% - 30,778 88,191.30 Sefton -25.40% - 38,497 113,124.07 Lancashire -25.20% - 34,730 102,950.71 Sandwell -24.40% - 29,737 91,770.41 Barnsley -24.00% - 27,675 87,421.45 North -23.90% - 29,604 93,809.60 Lincolnshire Torfaen -23.70% - 29,665 95,485.51 Northumberland -23.70% - 36,840 118,092.84 Wakefield -23.10% - 32,362 107,317.19 Rochdale -23.00% - 26,690 89,109.74 23

Neath Port Talbot -22.60% - 25,167 85,776.85 Darlington -22.00% - 28,671 101,444.94 Torbay -21.70% - 37,884 136,031.27 Oldham -21.60% - 23,569 85,424.83 Rotherham -21.50% - 26,955 98,265.23 Wirral -21.50% - 30,101 109,684.08 City of -21.30% - 29,104 107,016.49 Peterborough West Yorkshire -21.20% - 29,294 108,454.45 City of -20.90% - 21,568 81,603.66 Nottingham Flintshire -20.90% - 30,965 116,807.59 Swansea -20.80% - 27,238 103,505.00 Gateshead -20.70% - 24,196 92,655.14 Rhondda Cynon -20.70% - 19,346 73,865.18 Taff Gwynedd -20.60% - 32,307 124,316.15 Newcastle upon -20.50% - 28,897 112,088.39 Tyne Tameside -20.50% - 24,917 96,605.78 Kirklees -20.30% - 28,149 110,555.90 Bolton -20.20% - 23,511 92,406.52 Leeds -20.00% - 30,309 120,541.32 South Yorkshire -19.90% - 25,532 102,385.82 Tyne and Wear -19.70% - 25,264 102,744.59 South Tyneside -19.20% - 24,370 102,405.44 Doncaster -19.20% - 22,707 95,371.60 Wrekin -18.90% - 28,419 121,686.18 Walsall -18.70% - 24,899 107,836.74 Sheffield -18.40% - 25,734 114,148.20 Conwy -18.40% - 28,775 127,250.32 24

Cheshire West and -18.30% - 33,180 147,553.80 Chester Lincolnshire -18.30% - 27,125 120,579.67 City of Derby -18.30% - 23,385 103,854.61 Isle of Anglesey -18.20% - 29,029 130,220.77 Wrexham -18.10% - 25,309 114,447.84 Bury -17.40% - 23,560 111,604.51 Leicester -17.10% - 21,996 106,025.22 Greater Manchester -16.80% - 21,617 106,940.65 Newport -16.70% - 23,130 115,406.04 Salford -16.50% - 18,672 94,210.23 North East -16.50% - 17,193 86,712.53 Lincolnshire East Riding of -16.30% - 25,342 130,181.85 Yorkshire Bridgend -15.90% - 22,020 115,662.81 Denbighshire -15.70% - 21,561 115,004.43 Medway -15.50% - 25,084 136,272.03 Carmarthenshire -15.40% - 20,664 113,369.78 West Midlands -15.10% - 20,879 117,333.88 Staffordshire -14.90% - 22,739 129,327.77 Luton -14.90% - 22,148 125,589.58 Caerphilly -14.80% - 17,654 101,308.26 City of Kingston -14.80% - 13,190 75,530.11 Upon Hull Swindon -14.50% - 22,019 129,176.92 Birmingham -14.40% - 19,681 116,587.95 Calderdale -14.30% - 16,735 99,838.27 Redcar and -14.30% - 18,018 107,173.61 Cleveland Cheshire East -14.10% - 24,166 146,947.90 Nottinghamshire -13.90% - 19,762 121,817.54 25

Dudley -13.80% - 19,691 122,484.82 City of Plymouth -13.80% - 20,337 126,500.81 North Yorkshire -13.80% - 26,868 166,664.87 Cardiff -13.50% - 22,345 143,193.31 South -13.50% - 28,125 179,391.17 Gloucestershire Somerset -13.40% - 25,461 164,552.06 Powys -13.40% - 22,435 144,242.22 Northamptonshire -13.30% - 21,544 139,308.75 Warrington -13.20% - 21,218 138,862.05 North Tyneside -13.20% - 18,687 122,100.05 Portsmouth -13.10% - 21,884 144,280.02 Warwickshire -13.10% - 23,927 157,682.05 Leicestershire -13.00% - 22,250 148,348.98 Cumbria -12.80% - 18,019 122,041.72 Pembrokeshire -12.70% - 22,014 151,220.21 Cornwall -12.70% - 26,155 179,059.46 Stockport -12.50% - 20,710 144,555.54 Merthyr Tydfil -12.40% - 10,591 74,478.56 Shropshire -12.40% - 22,752 159,494.84 Worcestershire -12.00% - 22,858 166,963.03 Southend-on-Sea -11.90% - 20,967 154,481.90 Thurrock -11.90% - 19,958 146,557.62 Norfolk -11.70% - 19,311 144,709.23 Suffolk -11.60% - 20,230 153,977.04 Southampton -11.50% - 18,326 140,594.48 Isle Of Wight -11.40% - 20,136 156,467.01 Derbyshire -11.10% - 15,534 124,387.72 Rutland -11.10% - 26,930 213,695.81 Slough -10.80% - 20,792 170,473.81 Herefordshire -10.70% - 21,372 176,798.63 Trafford -10.30% - 20,597 179,406.40 26

Bournemouth -10.30% - 19,765 170,826.11 Milton Keynes -10.10% - 17,490 154,879.70 Wiltshire -10.00% - 20,661 185,978.44 Manchester -9.90% - 11,406 103,150.61 North Somerset -9.80% - 19,332 176,789.16 Barking and -9.10% - 22,949 228,561.31 Dagenham Central Bedfordshire -8.90% - 17,288 175,259.55 Kent -8.80% - 17,960 185,235.35 Dorset -8.80% - 20,919 215,588.13 Ceredigion -8.70% - 15,434 160,929.25 Coventry -8.60% - 10,857 115,287.22 Devon -8.40% - 17,804 192,158.18 Newham -8.30% - 21,523 235,726.61 East Sussex -8.20% - 16,399 183,325.71 Gloucestershire -8.20% - 16,008 177,876.88 Poole -7.30% - 16,836 211,408.05 The Vale of -7.10% - 13,066 169,578.63 Glamorgan Essex -6.60% - 13,827 193,667.05 Bedford -6.40% - 11,441 165,205.44 City of Bristol -6.20% - 11,882 178,054.07 Havering -6.10% - 16,997 259,778.90 West Sussex -5.60% - 12,911 215,888.47 Bexley -5.20% - 13,023 235,488.83 Cambridgeshire -5.10% - 10,223 187,473.64 Reading -4.30% - 9,490 209,900.05 Hampshire -4.30% - 9,747 214,998.19 Croydon -3.80% - 10,526 265,366.73 West Berkshire -3.20% - 8,151 238,925.16 Enfield -2.30% - 6,590 269,676.56 27

Bath and North East -1.70% - 4,231 236,798.25 Somerset York -1.40% - 2,795 186,875.52 Buckinghamshire -0.80% - 2,280 271,638.27 Solihull -0.50% - 1,083 206,219.06 Oxfordshire 0.30% 510 249,531.38 Sutton 1.10% 2,869 271,567.69 Bracknell Forest 1.40% 3,126 227,795.70 Monmouthshire 1.60% 3,050 195,882.29 Brighton and Hove 2.40% 5,503 237,228.65 Wokingham 2.80% 7,919 294,335.03 Hillingdon 2.90% 8,064 286,684.72 Surrey 3.20% 9,708 317,613.42 Windsor and 3.50% 11,704 350,417.93 Maidenhead Greenwich 4.00% 11,066 294,477.88 Harrow 4.30% 12,765 312,641.21 Kingston upon 4.70% 15,137 339,014.83 Thames Waltham Forest 4.70% 12,476 282,450.93 Hertfordshire 4.80% 11,804 261,706.89 Hounslow 5.70% 16,960 315,844.54 Redbridge 5.80% 17,621 326,094.33 Bromley 6.60% 20,285 330,084.91 Brent 7.50% 23,270 334,213.81 Tower Hamlets 8.10% 30,022 403,168.63 Barnet 10.10% 35,487 389,073.16 Greater London 11.80% 41,116 390,720.40 Lewisham 12.00% 33,993 318,239.86 Merton 13.20% 45,364 389,432.89 Ealing 14.00% 46,318 378,147.41 28

Richmond upon 15.90% 70,348 514,734.94 Thames Haringey 16.80% 59,004 410,784.13 Southwark 19.80% 72,762 441,377.10 Lambeth 22.20% 79,682 440,183.87 Wandsworth 24.60% 97,248 493,029.32 Hammersmith and 25.80% 130,215 637,072.85 Fulham Camden 26.90% 143,249 676,278.49 Islington 27.60% 121,499 562,721.12 Hackney 35.60% 129,403 493,350.11 Kensington and 42.80% 350,904 1,171,320.59 Chelsea City of Westminster 43.20% 260,230 863,256.78 Source: Smith Institute analysis of HM Land Registry data 29

The Smith Institute The Smith Institute is an independent think tank which provides a high-level forum for thought leadership and debate on public policy and politics. It seeks to engage politicians, senior decision makers, practitioners, academia, opinion formers and commentators on promoting policies for a fairer society. If you would like to know more about the Smith Institute please write to: The Smith Institute Somerset House South Wing Strand London WC2R 1LA Telephone +44 (0)20 7845 5845 Email info@smith-institute.org.uk Website www.smith-institute.org.uk The Smith Institute is a not-for-profit company (registered as SI Research Limited, 07098225)