RAMSEY COUNTY ASSESSOR 2013 DOWNTOWN ST. PAUL OFFICE REPORT

Similar documents
2016 DOWNTOWN SAINT PAUL OFFICE REPORT Values for Real Estate Taxes Payable in 2017

SAINT PAUL BUILDING OWNERS AND MANAGERS ASSOCIATION

REAL ESTATE INFORMATION

Greater Saint Paul Building Owners & Managers Association

2017 BOMA Market Report

SALE OR LEASE Wells Fargo Place 30 7th Street East, St. Paul, MN

345 St. Peter Street St. Paul, Minnesota Landmark

Equalization. Overview. Multiplier Basics

AREIS Online Report TOLEDO CITY - TOLEDO CSD EVANS PAUL B & ELIZABETH A C / ,700 74, W SYLVANIA AVE TOLEDO, OH ,500

RETAIL / OFFICE INVESTMENT

City of Saint Paul Commercial/Industrial and Mixed Use Building Permits Page 1 of 6

Miramar Industrial Property 2220 SW 60 Ter Miramar, FL 33023

Sentinel TOWN SQUARE TOWER FOR LEASE 445 MINNESOTA STREET, ST. PAULT

Miramar Industrial Property 1901 SW 100th Ter Miramar, Fl 33025

2018 BOMA Market Report

The Colony FOR SALE. 614 S 18th Street. Omaha, NE $995,000 MultiFamily PROPERTY HIGHLIGHTS. 8 Multifamily Units and 2000sqft of Retail

ONE CAPITAL CENTER 999 MAIN STREET BOISE, ID ICONIC OFFICE & RETAIL SPACE FOR LEASE IN THE DOWNTOWN CORE

The Parking Problem: More Users in Smaller Spaces Means Many Building Owners are in Tight Spots

Monthly Market Data Report

Copyrighted report licensed to NAI Brannen Goddard /9/2018. Page 1

MANHATTAN NEW DEVELOPMENT REPORT 2011 FOURTH QUARTER 1 MNS 115 EAST 23 RD STREET, NEW YORK, NY MNS.

31-35 ST. JAMES PLACE MADISON STREET. 4 Buildings, 21 Residential & 3 Commercial Units MAJOR PRICE REDUCTION! MADISON STREET

Plaza Court E 63rd Street, Raytown, MO KW Commercial. Donna Lilley, Broker Plaza Court Apartments

Manhattan Residential Rental Market Report

1829 RIVERSIDE AVE, MINNEAPOLIS, MN URBAN INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITY RIVERSIDE

FOR SALE 686 E Mill Street, San Bernardino, CA Owner-User Opportunity with Rare Excess Parking. Property Video at economosdewolf.

Commercial Building For Sale 6.42 Acres

Hickory Tree Apartments

224 Fifth Ave. New York, NY

Calgary Assessment Review Board

2. The estimated value of the interest to be conveyed or leased, determined at the highest and best use permitted under the redevelopment plan;

Post Sale List Sherwood Lane, Johnstown, CO, West A Street, Greeley, CO, 80634

90 Alton Rd, Miami Beach, FL 33139

MANHATTAN NEW DEVELOPMENT REPORT 2012 FIRST QUARTER 1 MNS 115 EAST 23 RD STREET, NEW YORK, NY MNS.

MCCULLOCH BUILDING 114 NORTH GRAND AVE OKMULGEE, OK Casey Litsey Associate Advisor

Minneapolis Trends. Permitted residential conversions, remodels and additions. Permitted non-residential conversions, remodels and additions

A 22-Story, Class A Office Building Located In The Central Business District Of Downtown Tampa, Florida

1829 RIVERSIDE AVE, MINNEAPOLIS, MN % LEASED 3 TENANT INVESTMENT RIVERSIDE

Metro: New Haven. Copyright 2016 Reis, Inc.

Black Knight Home Price Index Report: December Transactions U.S. Home Prices Up 0.1 Percent for the Month; Up 8.4 Percent Year-Over-Year

PROSPER: MOMENTUM IS BUILDING. Vision SP20 20

Ramsey County. Assessor s Report

THE AGGREGATETM 4TH QUARTER 2015

Sample Space Report of Select Relocation Alternatives

/4 Willow Brook Avenue Los Angeles, CA 90029

My Open Door Policy. Fairly appraise all properties, so you pay only your required share of taxes. Treat everyone with courtesy, honesty and respect.

Past & Present Adjustments & Parcel Count Section... 13

400 W. NORTH ST. SUITE 110

Property Report. Apartment Wilshire Blvd Los Angeles, CA Contents. Rent Comparables 1. Powered by Reis, inc.

Hoffman Corners Retail Center II COUNTY ROAD E EAST, VADNAIS HEIGHTS MINNESOTA

Martin Luther King W. Martin Luther King Jr. Blvd Los PROPERTY HIGHLIGHTS

City Center Market-Rate Housing Study

Introduction. Bruce Munneke, S.A.M.A. Washington County Assessor. 3 P a g e

Mattress firm. freestanding mattress firm W Jacobs Drive, Bloomington, IN 47404

COMAL APPRAISAL DISTRICT ANNUAL APPRAISAL REPORT

DOWNTOWN OFFICE BLDG 630 CENTER STREET NE SALEM, OR Tom Hendrie Advisor

AGENDA Transportation Committee Regular Meeting 4:00 PM - Monday, November 21, 2016 Council Conference Room, 7th Floor, City Hall 1055 S.

Callaghan Tower Vantage Dr, Suite 1200 San Antonio TX reocsanantonio.com R E O C

MULTI-FAMILY OPPORTUNITY 2130 S. Camino St., Anaheim, CA 92802

BOMA OFFICE INCOME & EXPENSE QUESTIONNAIRE

Major tenant contractions and impending corporate development set the stage for 2014 and beyond

Minneapolis Trends. Permitted residential conversions, remodels and additions. Permitted non-residential conversions, remodels and additions

PRÆDIUM Advisors. Offered at Only $4,236,905. That s a 7.5 CAP on In-Place 2018 NOI!

The GREENWOOD APARTMENTS

Wendy s 1770 University Ave W, Saint Paul, MN R E T A I L A D V I S O R S

Manhattan New Dev. Market Report th Quarter mns.com

LEXINGTON PARKWAY LEXINGTON PARKWAY ST. PAUL, MN

Houston s Strong Job Growth Boosts Office Leasing Activity

GATEWAY OFFICE PLAZA. Welcome to Gateway Office Plaza. 350 Burnsville Parkway Burnsville, MN 55337

HONG KONG FERRY (HOLDINGS) COMPANY LIMITED (Incorporated in Hong Kong under the Companies Ordinance)

RATE AND METHOD OF APPORTIONMENT FOR CASITAS MUNICIPAL WATER DISTRICT COMMUNITY FACILITIES DISTRICT NO (OJAI)

Pikes Peak area housing Market Statistics (As of: 2/28/2018)

Vacancy Continues to Decrease; Tenants Flocking to Space that Dovetails Recent Office Trends

REAL ESTATE DEVELOPMENT

METROPOLITAN TRACT PERFORMANCE REPORT For the Quarter Ended September 30, 2005

LETTER OF INTENT. NOW, THEREFORE, the parties hereby mutually intend as follows:

June 6, Proposed FY Annual Automatic Adjustment for the Affordable Housing Unit Base Fee

Introduction: Downtown Orlando Market Report Summary for First Quarter 2018

>> 2016 Off to A Good Start for Tri-Cities

SPRING John E. Zuccotti, Chairperson. Steven Spinola, President. 570 Lexington Avenue / New York, NY /

Introduction: Downtown Orlando Market Report Summary for Third Quarter 2018

The Market Watch Monthly Housing Report. Coachella Valley Median Detached Home Price Dec Dec 2016

value added multi-tenant retail center for sale

CITY OF SARASOTA DOWNTOWN REAL ESTATE DEVELOPMENT IN PROGRESS May 19, 2016

January nd Annual Metro Des Moines Apartment Survey. Part of the CBRE affiliate network. Prepared by Commercial Appraisers of Iowa, Inc.

Twin Cedars Apartments

Second Quarter Industrial Market Report 2017

Exclusive Sale Offering Memorandum. 205 Bedford Avenue Williamsburg Brooklyn

City of Norwalk Revaluation Project

Explanation of the Analysis Format

Pikes Peak area housing Market Statistics (As of: 9/30/2018)

MG Architects Kimberley Lane Houston, TX For more information contact: Ryan Hartsell Partner

COMAL APPRAISAL DISTRICT ANNUAL APPRAISAL REPORT

665 Lenox Avenue MIXED USE WALK-UP BUILDING

Toledo Court Apartments

116 REDONDO AVE., LONG BEACH

Announcing the Availability for Purchase of 45 Central Avenue, Newark, NJ 07102

Harris County Appraisal District

RESA Reports. real estate Staging Pricing. Brought to you by the Real Estate Staging Association

984 Sharon Street, New Bedford MA. 984 Sharon Street New Bedford, MA 02050

Transcription:

RAMSEY COUNTY ASSESSOR 2013 DOWNTOWN ST. PAUL OFFICE REPORT Values for Real Estate Taxes Payable in 2014 August 31, 2013 Photo Courtesy of the City of St. Paul This report summarizes the assessment of downtown St Paul office properties, and has been prepared utilizing public data. It covers Class A, Class B and Class C buildings for the assessment years 2009 through 2013. All displayed net rentable areas have been obtained from public or published sources. Listed values for prior year assessment reflect any subsequent adjustments due to appeals.

Ramsey County 2013 Assessor's Report on the Downtown St Paul Office Assessment Aggregate Assessed Value of Taxable Downtown St. Paul Office Buildings 2009 thru 2013 Assessments Assessment Year Class A Class B Class C Total % change 2009 $451,494,000 $294,593,800 $40,781,100 $786,868,900 2010 $372,417,600 $289,168,500 $32,158,200 $693,744,300-11.8% 2011 $345,537,800 $260,297,100 $33,903,900 $639,738,800-7.8% 2012 $339,404,900 $255,659,100 $31,105,800 $626,169,800-2.1% 2013 $322,700,400 $253,839,600 $29,912,500 $606,452,500-3.1% Reports value of the whole universe of Class A, B and C properties. Property Records and Revenue Ramsey County Assessor's Office Values as of July 2013 3

Aggregate Assessed Value of Downtown St. Paul Office Property 2009 thru 2013 Assessment Year By Building Class $500,000,000 2007 $450,000,000 $400,000,000 Dollars $350,000,000 $300,000,000 $250,000,000 $200,000,000 $150,000,000 $100,000,000 $50,000,000 Class A Class B Class C $0 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Property Records and Revenue Ramsey County Assessor's Office Values as of July 2013 4 July 2008

Downtown St Paul Office Median Values 2009 Thru 2013 Assessments $50,000,000 $45,000,000 2007 $40,000,000 $35,000,000 Dollars $30,000,000 $25,000,000 $20,000,000 $15,000,000 $10,000,000 $5,000,000 $0 A B C Building Class 2009 2010 2011 2012 Note: Median Values displayed are for the entire universe of CBD office buildings and are not limited to those buildings with published NRA's Property Records and Revenue Ramsey County Assessor's Office Values as of July 2013 Downtown St Paul Median Office Values Class A Class B Class C Dollars $50,000,000 $45,000,000 $40,000,000 $35,000,000 $30,000,000 $25,000,000 $20,000,000 $15,000,000 $10,000,000 $5,000,000 $0 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Assessment Years 5 July 2009

Downtown St Paul Office 2009 thru 2013 - Assessments per Sqft Net Rentable Area $140.00 $120.00 2007 $100.00 Dollars Per NRA $80.00 $60.00 $40.00 $20.00 2009 2010 2011 2012 $0.00 A B C Building Class Note: Median Values displayed are for the entire universe of CBD office buildings and are not limited to those buildings with published NRA's Property Records and Revenue Ramsey County Assessor's Office Values as of July 2013 Downtown St Paul Office Median $/Sqft $140.00 $120.00 Dollars Per NRA $100.00 $80.00 $60.00 $40.00 $20.00 $0.00 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Assessment Years Class A Class B Class C 6 July 2009

Ramsey County Assessor Information for St Paul CBD Office Properties 2009 thru 2013 Assessments Class "A" Properties 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Published Net Rentable Area (NRA) 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 06-28-22-12-0116 444 Cedar St UBS Plaza(Piper) $68.36 $54.69 $54.69 $54.69 $54.69 229,653 $ 15,700,000 $ 12,560,000 $ 12,560,000 $ 12,560,000 $ 12,560,000 06-28-22-12-0112 445 Minnesota ST Bremer Tower & Townsquare Retail $74.49 $74.49 $74.49 $67.04 $57.94 468,545 $ 34,900,000 $ 34,900,000 $ 34,900,000 $ 31,410,000 $ 27,148,300 31-29-22-43-0515 400 Robert St 400 Building $109.19 $96.95 $83.89 $83.89 $75.94 375,500 $ 41,000,000 $ 36,403,000 $ 31,500,000 $ 31,500,000 $ 28,515,200 06-28-22-12-0128 380 St Peter St Lawson Commons $141.47 $123.62 $117.44 $111.56 $103.76 436,478 $ 61,750,000 $ 53,956,200 $ 51,258,400 $ 48,695,500 $ 45,289,200 06-28-22-12-0099 30 7th St E Wells Fargo Place $149.63 $134.74 $124.90 $119.70 $111.67 634,895 $ 95,000,000 $ 85,547,300 $ 79,300,000 $ 76,000,000 $ 70,900,000 06-28-22-12-0132 401 Robert St 401 Bldg $151.82 $139.67 $125.86 $125.86 $125.84 572,044 $ 86,847,500 $ 79,900,000 $ 72,000,000 $72,000,000 $ 71,984,300 Values as of July 2013 Median $125.33 $110.28 $100.66 $97.73 $89.85 $ 335,197,500 $ 303,266,500 $ 281,518,400 $ 272,165,500 $ 256,397,000 Mean $115.83 $104.03 $96.88 $93.79 $88.31 Percentage Change -9.53% -7.17% -3.32% -5.79% Net Rentable Area (NRA) Sourced from Published St Paul BOMA Reports Only properties with a published Net Rentable are eligible for inclusion in this list Property Records and Revenue Ramsey County Assessor's Office 7

2013 downtown Class A Office Estimated Market Values $140.00 $120.00 $100.00 Dollars Per NRA $80.00 $60.00 $40.00 $20.00 $0.00 UBS Plaza(Piper) Bremer Tower & Townsquare Retail 400 Building Lawson Commons Wells Fargo Place 401 Bldg Values as of July 2013 Prepared by Ramsey County Assessor * Net Rentable Area (NRA) from BOMA. Excludes exempt and property with non-published NRA

Downtown St Paul Class "A" 2009-2013 Assessed Office Values $160.00 $140.00 $120.00 Dollars per Net Rentalable Area $100.00 $80.00 $60.00 $40.00 $20.00 $0.00 UBS Plaza(Piper) Bremer Tower & Townsquare Retail 400 Building Lawson Commons Wells Fargo Place 401 Bldg 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Values as of July 2013 Net Rentable Area(NRA) from BOMA. Excludes exempt and property with non-published NRA Prepared by Ramsey County Assessor 8

Ramsey County Assessor Information for St Paul CBD Office Properties 2009 thru 2013 Assessments Class "B" Properties 2009 per NRA 2010 per NRA 2011 per NRA 2012 per NRA 2013 per NRA Published Net Rentable Area 2009 Assessed 2010 Assessed 2011 Assessed 2012 Assessed 2013 Assessed (NRA) Value Value Value Value Value 06-28-22-11-0015 360 Robert St Empire Building $31.16 $28.04 $21.03 $14.64 $15.38 57,165 $1,781,200 $1,603,100 $1,202,300 $837,100 $879,000 06-28-22-11-0017 332 Minnesota First Nat'l Bank Bldg $38.97 $35.59 $31.39 $28.25 $28.25 660,640 $25,745,000 $23,512,400 $20,738,700 $18,664,800 $18,664,800 31-29-22-43-0532 130 7th St(121 7th Place) Metro Square $17.90 $17.90 $17.90 $28.45 $28.45 390,971 $7,000,000 $7,000,000 $7,000,000 $11,123,500 $11,123,500 06-28-22-11-0005 375 Jackson Street 375 Jackson Street Bldg $57.63 $51.87 $46.68 $44.35 $30.00 212,395 $12,240,000 $11,016,000 $9,914,400 $9,418,700 $6,371,900 06-28-22-11-0050 180 5th St E & 175 6th St E 180 E Fifth St Bldg $45.32 $40.79 $37.03 $28.24 $30.89 675,130 $30,600,000 $27,540,000 $25,000,000 $19,066,900 $20,854,400 06-28-22-11-0008 333 Sibley (166 Sibley) Sibley Square at Mears Park $53.30 $53.30 $34.58 $34.58 $33.63 206,390 $11,000,000 $11,000,000 $7,136,100 $7,136,100 $6,941,600 06-28-22-11-0051 366 Jackson St N Brooks Building $32.99 $32.99 $34.64 $35.11 $35.80 25,000 $824,700 $824,700 $866,000 $877,700 $895,000 06-28-22-11-0047 166 E. 4th St ST Paul Radiology $59.66 $53.69 $48.32 $43.49 $39.14 52,800 $3,150,000 $2,835,000 $2,551,500 $2,296,400 $2,066,800 06-28-22-12-0069 325 Cedar St Degree of Honor bldg $36.75 $33.94 $33.93 $37.33 $39.26 81500 $2,994,800 $2,765,800 $2,765,000 $3,042,400 $3,200,000 06-28-22-21-0041 28 7th St(406-460 St. Peter St) Hamm Building $46.91 $42.22 $41.65 $39.98 $39.98 184,866 $8,672,800 $7,805,500 $7,700,000 $7,391,000 $7,391,000 06-28-22-12-0031 55 5th St Alliance Bank Building $49.12 $49.12 $49.12 $41.76 $41.76 284,995 $14,000,000 $14,000,000 $14,000,000 $11,900,000 $11,900,000 31-29-22-43-0512 95 7th St(85 E. 7th Place) Golden Rule Building $47.16 $47.16 $45.96 $43.66 $43.66 289,378 $13,647,300 $13,647,300 $13,300,000 $12,635,000 $12,635,000 31-29-22-44-0609 400 E. Sibley St Park Square Court/Woods Bldg $47.09 $47.56 $47.25 $44.88 $44.88 129,321 $6,089,600 $6,150,000 $6,110,000 $5,804,500 $5,804,500 06-28-22-12-0060 359 Wabasha St(6 W. 5th St) Saint Paul Building $49.70 $47.22 $47.22 $47.22 $46.28 40,239 $2,000,000 $1,900,000 $1,900,000 $1,900,000 $1,862,200 06-28-22-12-0119 101 E 5th ST US Bank Center $107.70 $54.03 $54.03 $51.60 $51.60 370,187 $39,870,000, $20,000,000, $20,000,000, $19,100,000, $19,100,000, 06-28-22-12-0033 386 Wabasha St Ecolab University Center $58.66 $58.66 $49.86 $47.37 $52.11 150,012 $8,800,000 $8,800,000 $7,480,000 $7,106,000 $7,816,600 31-29-22-44-0443 175 5th St E Cray Plaza & parking ramp $72.52 $63.52 $58.04 $58.04 $58.04 219,796 $15,938,700 $13,960,700 $12,757,000 $12,757,000 $12,757,000 31-29-22-34-0280 17 Exchange St W Gallery Professional Building $77.11 $60.63 $65.93 $56.37 $58.23 105,433 $8,130,000 $6,392,300 $6,951,200 $5,943,200.0 $6,139,600 31-29-22-44-0055 413 Wacouta St Gilbert Building $54.88 $52.26 $54.88 $54.88 $60.36 35,303 $1,937,300 $1,845,000 $1,937,300 $1,937,300 $2,131,000 All Values as of July 2013 Median $49.12 $47.56 $46.68 $43.49 $39.98 $252,298,700 $216,923,000 $196,456,100 $158,937,600 $158,533,900 Net Rentable Area (NRA) Sourced from Published St Paul BOMA Reports Only properties with a published Net Rentable are eligible for inclusion in this list Mean $51.82 $45.82 $43.13 $41.06 $40.93 Percentage Change -14.02% -9.44% -19.10% -0.25% Property Records and Revenue Ramsey County Assessor's Office 9

2013 Class B Downtown Office Estimated Market Values $70.00 $60.00 $50.00 Dollars Per NRA* $40.00 $30.00 $20.00 $10.00 00 $0.00 Values as of July 2013 * Net Rentable Area (NRA) from BOMA. Excludes exempt and property with non-published NRA Prepared by Ramsey County Assessor

Downtown St Paul Class "B" Assessed Office Values* 2009 thru 2013 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 $120.00 $100.00 $80.00 Dollars per Net Rental Area $60.00 $40.00 $20.00 $0.00 Values as of July 2013 * Net Rentable Area (NRA) from BOMA. Excludes exempt and property with non-published NRA Prepared by Ramsey County Assessor 10

Ramsey County Assessor Assessment Information for St Paul CBD Office Properties - 2009 Thru 2013 Assessments Class "C" Properties 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Published Net Rentable Area (NRA) 2009 Assessed Value 2010 Assessed Value 2011 Assessed Value 2012 Assessed Value 2013 Assessed Value 32-29-22-33-0054 247 4th St E JAX Building $31.24 $31.24 $17.44 $17.44 $18.52 60,000 $ 1,874,300 $ 1,874,300 $ 1,046,400 $ 1,046,400 $ 1,111,400 31-29-22-34-0203 26 Exchange St E Exchange Bldg $24.20 $21.94 $23.04 $25.34 $25.34 65,000 $ 1,573,000 $ 1,426,100 $ 1,497,400 $ 1,647,100 $ 1,647,100 31-29-22-43-0060 133 7th St E & 460 Robert St Liberty Square $23.10 $23.10 $24.26 $24.26 $25.47 50,000 $ 1,155,000 $ 1,155,000 $ 1,212,800 $ 1,212,800 $ 1,273,400 31-29-22-44-0040 266 7th St E O'Conner Building $30.00 $28.50 $27.08 $25.72 $25.72 20,000 $ 600,000 $ 570,000 $ 541,500 $ 514,400 $ 514,400 32-29-22-33-0053 275 4th St Northwestern Building $31.23 $28.11 $26.21 $26.21 $27.52 72,500 $ 2,264,400 $ 2,038,000 $ 1,900,000 $ 1,900,000 $ 1,995,000 06-28-22-12-0024 421 Wabasha St Grace Building $30.28 $27.25 $27.16 $27.16 $28.52 40,500 $ 1,226,300 $ 1,103,700 $ 1,100,000 $ 1,100,000 $ 1,155,000 06-28-22-11-0001 213 4TH St E Homestyles $35.72 $30.06 $30.06 $28.66 $28.66 32,271 $ 1,152,700 $ 970,000 $ 970,000 $ 925,000 $ 925,000 05-28-22-22-0013 255 East Kellogg Bldg Goff & Howard Bldg $34.00 $30.60 $29.07 $29.07 $29.07 26,000 $ 883,900 $ 795,500 $ 755,700 $ 755,700 $ 755,700 31-29-22-44-0081 287 6th ST E Allen Building $32.34 $29.79 $31.28 $27.94 $29.71 112,553 $ 3,640,400 $ 3,352,800 $ 3,520,400 $ 3,144,400 $ 3,344,400 06-28-22-12-0054 340 Cedar St University Club/Athletic club $35.10 $31.59 $39.48 $39.48 $32.83 168,465 $ 5,912,500 $ 5,321,300 $ 6,651,600 $ 6,651,600 $ 5,530,400 31-29-22-44-0056 229-237 6th St E Railroader/Stevens Building $31.83 $35.01 $38.51 $40.44 $42.57 36,000 $ 1,145,800 $ 1,260,400 $ 1,386,400 $ 1,455,800 $ 1,532,400 06-28-22-22-0086 411 Main St Labor Professional Center $91.92 $91.92 $91.92 $91.92 $91.92 28,000 $ 2,573,700 $ 2,573,700 $ 2,573,700 $ 2,573,700 $ 2,573,700 Values as of July 2013 Median $32.09 $30.33 $29.56 $26.68 $28.02 $ 28,605,500 $ 26,672,300 $ 25,871,900 $ 22,926,900 $ 22,357,900 Mean $37.08 $34.81 $34.30 $28.83 $28.99 Net Rentable Area (NRA) Sourced from Published St Paul BOMA Reports Only properties with a published Net Rentable are eligible for inclusion in this lis Historical Values may be adjusted to reflect adjustments due to Tax Curt petitions. Property Records and Revenue Ramsey County Assessor's s Office Percentage Change -6.76% -3.00% -11.38% -2.48% 11

2013 Class C Only Values* Per NRA $100.00 $90.00 $80.00 $70.00 Dollars Per Net Rentable Area* $60.00 $50.00 $40.00 $30.00 $20.00 $10.00 $0.00 Values as of July 2013 * Net Rentable Area (NRA) from BOMA. Excludes exempt and property with non-published NRA Prepared by Ramsey County Assessor

Downtown St Paul Class "C" Assessed Office Values* in $/sqft 2009 thru 2013 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 $100.00 $90.00 $80.00 $70.00 $60.00 Dollars per NRA* $50.00 $40.00 $30.00 $20.00 $10.00 $0.00 Values as of July 2013 Prepared by Ramsey County Assessor * Net Rentable Area (NRA) from BOMA. Excludes exempt and property with non-published NRA 10

RECENT DOWNTOWN OFFICE SALES Contents: Tabular Class "A" & Class "B" Office building sales data since 2009 Chart of unit sale price compared to unit assessed value Sale, Arms Length - A sale in the open market between two unrelated parties, each of whom is reasonably informed, knowledgeable of market conditions, and under no undue pressure to either buy or sell. Both parties must be operating in their own best interests. 13

Ramsey County Assessor Downtown St Paul Office Sales since 2009 Parcel Address Project Class Published Net Rentable Area (NRA) Sale Price per Sq Ft NRA Assmnt per Sq Ft NRA Assessed Value Sale Price Date of Sale Ratio 06-28-22-11-0017 332 Minnesota St First National Bank B 660,640 $30.03 $28.25 $18,664,800 $19,837,000 Jun-12 94.09% 31-29-22-44-0055 413 Wacouta Bldg Gilbert Building B 35,503 $101.40 $60.02 $2,131,000 $3,600,000 Jul-13 59.19% Net Rentable Area (NRA) Sourced from Published St Paul BOMA Reports Only properties with a published Net Rentable are eligible for inclusion in this list Property Records and Revenue Ramsey County Assessor's Office 14

Downtown St Paul Office Sales** $120.00 $100.00 Dollars Per NRA $80.00 $60.00 $40.00 $20.00 $0.00 B First National Bank B Gilbert Building NRA (Published Net Rentable Areas) Ramsey County Assessor **Marketed Sales from 2009 through 2013 excluding bank sales, foreclosures, sheriff sales, tax forfeited, etc. 15

Wells Fargo Place Building Building Photo Property Address Owners Name & Mailing Address 30 7th St E St Paul tower, LP/WF Tower Holdings, LP St Paul, MN 55101 3555 timmons Lane, Suite 110 Houston, TX 77027-6442 Building Management Zeller Realty Mike Wilhelm Parcel Number(s) 06-28-22-12-0099 Property Value Asmt Year Land $ 8,098,300 $ 70.00 per Sqft Property Use: Office Tower Building $ 62,801,700 $ 98.92 Per NRA Gross Building Area 820743 - excludes parking ramp Sqft Total $ 70,900,000 000 $ 111.67 Per NRA Net Rental Area (NRA) 634,895 Built 1986 Number of Floors 37 Eff Year 1986 Number of apartments 0 Land Size 115,690 L:B 0.1822 Parking Stalls 158 Ramp / Lot Influence Factors Very core of CBD Skyway Connections To TownSquare, Macy's, Ramp Sales Data Month Year Sale Price $/Sqft Cert Num July 2000 $ 47,258,672 $ 74.44 October 2006 $ 104,940,000 $ 165.29 $ - Lease Information Commercial Apartments Office Rate Type T-Net Type #Units Rent/month Low $ 12.00 High $ 20.00 Studios Storage 1Brs Parking See notes Monthly Rate 2Brs Billboard Revenue 3Brs Other Lofts Expenses $14.24/Sqft including taxes 2013 Sources BOMA 2012 report - $17/sqft in tower, $12 - $20 in atrium space Notes Tower rents are advertized @ $17.00/sqft. Atrium space ranges from $12 - $20/sqft. Parking is $209/month regular & $280/month reserved

400 Robert Street Building 400 Robert St N St Paul, MN 55101-2015 Property Address Owners Name & Mailing Address Building Management McGough Properties Ann Staley Minnesota Mutual Life Insurance Company 400 Robert St N St Paul, MN 55101-2015 Parcel Number(s) 31-29-22-43-0515 Property Value Asmt Year 2013 Land $ 5,235,500 $ 52.00 per sqft Property Use: Office Tower Building Class A Building $ 23,279,700 $ 62.08 Per NRA Gross Building Area 412,264- excluding parking ramp Total $ 28,515,200 $ 76.04 Per NRA Net Rental Area (NRA) 375,024 Built 1980 Number of Floors 21 Eff Year 1980 Number of apartments 0 Land Size 100,683 L:B 2.3114 Parking Stalls 425 Ramp / Lot Influence Factors Core of CBD - entire block Skyway Connections North,South, East & West directions Sales Data Month Year Sale Price $/Sqft Cert Num July 2000 $ 47,258,672 $ 74.44 October 2006 $ 104,940,000 $ 165.29 $ - Lease Information Commercial Apartments Office Rate Type T-Net Type #Units Rent/month Low $ 10.00 High $ 12.00 Studios Storage 1Brs Parking $ 152.36 Monthly Rate 2Brs Billboard Revenue 3Brs Other Lofts Expenses $12.63/Sqft including taxes Sources BOMA 2012 report - tower rental Notes

Lawson Commons Property Address Owners Name & Mailing Address Building Management 380 St Peter St St Paul, MN 55102-1302 Behringer Harvard L C LLC 15601 Dallas Pkwy Frauenshuh Companies Sherry Hastings Addison, TX 75001-6026 Parcel Number(s) 06-28-22-12-0128 Property Value Asmt Year Land $ 2,452,700 $ 65.59 Per Sqft Property Use: Office Tower Building Class A Building $ 42,836,500 $ 98.14 Per NRA Gross Building Area 439,994 Total $ 45,289,200 $ 103.76 Per NRA Net Rental Area (NRA) 436,478 Built 1998 Number of Floors 13 Eff Year 1998 Number of apartments 0 Land Size 37,392 L:B 0.0850 Parking Stalls None Ramp / Lot Influence Factors CBD Skyway Connections South to Lowry Prof Bldg Sales Data Month Year Sale Price $/Sqft Cert Num June 2005 $ 84,500,000 $ 193.60 2013 $ - Lease Information Commercial Apartments Office Rate Type T-Net Type #Units Rent/month Low $ 13.00 High $ 14.00 Studios Storage 1Brs Parking Monthly Rate 2Brs Billboard Revenue 3Brs Other Expenses Lofts $12.53/Sqft including taxes Sources BOMA 2012 report Notes Parking contract with the city of St Paul on adjacent Lawson Parking Ramp.

401 Securian Building Property Address Owners Name & Mailing Address Building Management 401 Roberts St N Capitol City Property Mgmt Inc McGough Properties St Paul, MN 55101-1804 400 Robert St N Ann Staley St Paul, MN 55101-2015 Parcel Number(s) 06-28-22-12-0132 Property Value Asmt Year 06-28-22-12-0016 Land $ 4,889,100 $58.00 Per Sqft Property Use: Office Tower Building Class A Building $ 67,110,900 $117.29 Per NRA Gross Building Area 614,236 Total $ 72,000,000 $125.84 Per NRA Net Rental Area (NRA) 572,172 Built 1999 Number of Floors 13 Eff Year 1999 Number of apartments 0 Land Size 84,294 L:B 0.1372 Parking Stalls 940 Ramp / Lot Influence Factors Core of CBD Skyway Connections North, South, East & West Sales Data Month Year Sale Price $/Sqft Cert Num 2013 Lease Information Commercial Apartments Office Rate Type T-Net Type #Units Rent/month Low High Studios Storage 1Brs Parking $ 155.36 Monthly Rate 2Brs Billboard Revenue 3Brs Other Lofts Expenses Sources BOMA 2012 report - sqft only listed Notes The upper floors beginning at the 3rd flr and up are essentially owner occupied space. The 2nd flr(skyway level) is multi-tenant retail and office space. 1st Floor(Street Level) is multitenant offices. There is no published rental data available on Low/High T-net rents, vacancy or expenses.

Landmark Office Tower Property Address Owners Name & Mailing Address Building Management 345 St Peter ST Cusenza Landmark Towers, LLC Thompson National Properties St Paul, MN 55102-1211 578 W. Potrero Road Jerry Hersman Thousand Oaks, CA 91361-5013 St Paul, MN 55102-1211 Parcel Number(s) 06-28-22-13-0150 thru 0159 Property Value Asmt Year 2013 06-28-22-13-0177 thru 0197 Land $ 1,164,000 Property Use: Office Tower Building Class A Building $ 21,713,000 $ 101.96 Per NRA Gross Building Area Not Determined Total $ 22,877,000 $ 107.42 Per NRA Net Rental Area (NRA) 212,959 Built 1983 Number of Floors 20 Eff Year 1983 Number of apartments 0 Land Size See Notes L:B 0.1372 Parking Stalls Adjacent parcel Ramp / Lot Influence Factors CBD Skyway Connections South, & East, & to St Paul Hotel Sales Data Month Year Sale Price $/Sqft Cert Num 12 2007 $ 26,363,153 $ 123.79 365220 Lease Information Commercial Apartments Office Rate Type T-Net Type #Units Rent/month Low $ 12.00 High $ 13.00 Studios Storage 1Brs Parking $ 187.00 Monthly Rate 2Brs Billboard Revenue 3Brs Other Lofts Expenses $12.98/Sqft including taxes Sources BOMA 2012 report Notes This property is an office condo building with commercial condos up thru the 20th floor. Floors above the 20th floor are residential condos and not part of the commercial value. Parking is available to residential & commercial tenants at the adjacent Landmark Towers Parking Ramp. Only the commercial stall value is part of the overall commercial value. The various commercial condo unit values and commercial stall values are summed to equal the total land and building value. The sale on 12/28/07 inlcudes the office tower and commercial parking ramp stalls.

UBS Plaza Property Address Owners Name & Mailing Address Building Management 444 Cedar St MOT consolidated Properties Jones Land LaSalle St Paul, MN 55101-2179 386 Wabasha St N Jon Dahl 800 Capital Centre St Paul, MN 55102-1308 Parcel Number(s) 06-28-22-12-0116, 0117, 0118, & 0130 Property Value Asmt Year 2013 Land $ 935,200 $/Sqft Property Use: Office Tower Building Class A Building $ 11,624,800 S/Sqft $ 50.62 per NRA Gross Building Area Not Determined Total $ 12,560,000 $/Sqft $ 54.69 Per NRA Net Rental Area (NRA) 229,653 Built 1979 Number of Floors 25 Eff Year 1979 Number of apartments 0 Land Size See Notes L:B Parking Stalls None Ramp / Lot Influence Factors Very Core of St Paul SBD Skyway Connections Townsquare Sales Data Month Year Sale Price $/Sqft Cert Num 4 2001 $ 16,325,000 $ 71.09 10 2006 $ 15,000,000 $ 65.32 Lease Information Commercial Apartments Office Rate Type T-Net Type #Units Rent/month Low $ 9.00 High $ 11.00 Studios Storage 1Brs Parking Monthly Rate 2Brs Billboard Revenue 3Brs Other Lofts Expenses $11.15 including RE taxes Sources BOMA 2012 report Notes This property is subject to a multi-layered RLS's and not totally and accurately depicted on the map. Shares the location with the Bremer Office Tower, Town Square Retail, Town Square Gardens, and the Town Square Parking Ramp.

Bremer Tower Property Address Owners Name & Mailing Address Building Management 445 Minnesota St Town Square Realty Cushman Wakefield/NorthMarq St Paul, MN 55101-2190 C/O Sentinel Real Estate Corp Eric King 1251 Ave of Americas Fl36 New York, NY 10020-1181 Parcel Number(s) 06-28-22-0112, 0120, 0129, & 0131 Property Value Asmt Year 2013 Land $ 2,264,700 $/Sqft Property Use: Office Tower Building Class A Building $ 24,883,600 S/Sqft $ 100.28 Per NRA Gross Building Area 691,573 Total $ 27,148,300 $/Sqft $ 109.41 Per NRA Office Tower Only-NRA 248,140 Built 1979 Number of Floors 27 Eff Year 1979 Number of apartments 0 Land Size See Notes L:B Parking Stalls None Ramp / Lot Influence Factors Very Core of St Paul SBD Skyway Connections North, South, East, & West Sales Data Month Year Sale Price $/Sqft Cert Num $ - $ - Lease Information Commercial Apartments Office Rate Type T-Net Type #Units Rent/month Low $ 8.00 High $ 9.00 Studios Storage 1Brs Parking Monthly Rate 2Brs Billboard Revenue 3Brs Other Expenses Lofts $10.50/Sqft including taxes Sources BOMA 2012 report Notes Bremer Tower (formerly NCL) and Townsquare Retail is a complicated property of office tower and retail space. It is all described on RLS's that are stacked and subject to air rights and easements. The map may not accurately depict exact land and building. Though the total value included the Townsquare retail portion, the net rental area lists only the office tower. The NRA included the office tower, lower level office space (dept of Public Safety).