CITY OF ST. PETERSBURG, FLORIDA DEVELOPMENT SERVICES DEPARTMENT DEVELOPMENT REVIEW SERVICES DIVISION COMMUNITY PRESERVATION COMMISSION ACTION TAKEN / MINUTES Council Chambers City Hall November 17, 2008 175 5th Street North 1 p.m. St. Petersburg, Florida 33701 I. OPENING REMARKS OF CHAIR AND SWEARING IN OF WITNSSES: Introduction comments given by CPC Chair David Bacon and swearing in of witnesses was given by the clerk for the Commission. II. ROLL CALL: Commission Members: Alternates: 1. David Bacon, Chair - P 1. Arnett Smith, Jr. - P 2. Robert Carter - P 2. Jeffery Wolf - P 3. Robert Fisher - P 4. Suzanne LaBerge - P 5. Christine Page - P 6. Robin Reed - P A = Absent 7. Marie Stirling - A P = Present III. EXECUTIVE ACTION: None. IV. PUBLIC HEARING: AGENDA ITEM #1 CASE NUMBER: HPC 08-02 R-1 Old Pasadena TABLED FROM 10/17/08 404 Sunset Drive South LANDMARK: Merhige Residence A. Matthew and Joanna Rosen City of St. Petersburg Local Designation of the Merhige Residence Approve local designation of the Merhige Residence. ACTION TAKEN: Yes - Bacon; Carter; Fisher; Page; Reed; Smith; and Wolf. No N/A Conflicts - LaBerge. Approved. Page 1 of 8
Page 2 of 8 AGENDA ITEM #2 CASE NUMBER: TDR 08-02 F-2 Downtown TABLED FROM 10/17/08 405 Central Avenue LANDMARK: Snell Arcade (HPC 86-08) Snell Arcade Condominium Association, Inc. Mark Keiser, President Establish Transfer of Development Rights credits for 609,420 square feet. Approve establishing Transfer of Development Rights credits for 609,420 square feet. Yes - Bacon; Fisher; LaBerge; Reed; Smith; and Wolf. No N/A Conflicts - Carter; Page; and Stirling. AGENDA ITEM #3 CASE NUMBER: TDR 08-05 Historic Park Street 7401 Central Avenue LANDMARK: Sunset Hotel (HPC 07-03) Central Avenue Hotel, LLC Robert Kapusta Establish Transfer of Development Rights credits for 358,180 square feet. Approve establishing Transfer of Development Rights credits for 358,180 square feet. Yes - Bacon; Carter; Fisher; LaBerge; Page; Reed; and Smith No N/A Conflicts - None.
Page 3 of 8 AGENDA ITEM #4 CASE NUMBER: COA 08-35 Historic Roser Park APPEAL OF ADMINISTRATIVE APPROVAL 815 Prospect Court South LANDMARK: Roser Park Historic District (HPC 87-10) Catherine Lazarus APPELLANT: Bruce Brouillette APPEAL: Staff approval of a COA requesting the construction of a one-room, screened addition measuring approximately 11 x12 and located on the rear (west) elevation. Approval of a COA requesting the construction of a one-room, screened addition measuring approximately 11 x12 and located on the rear (west) elevation. Yes - Bacon; Carter; Fisher; LaBerge; Page; Reed; and Smith. No N/A Conflicts - None. AGENDA ITEM #5 CASE NUMBER: 08-54000031 D-10 Historic Old Northeast TABLED FROM 10/17/08 1317 Beach Drive Northeast Richard And Barbara Joule P.O. Box 76324, St. Petersburg, FL 33734 George K. Rahdert, Esquire 535 Central Avenue, St. Petersburg, FL 33701 After-the-fact variance to retain an illegally installed driveway along Beach Drive Northeast. PARCEL ID NO.: 17/31/17/83220/076/0060 NT-3 Approve after-the-fact variance to retain an illegally installed driveway along Beach Drive Northeast. Yes - Bacon; Carter; Fisher; and Smith. No LaBerge and Page. Conflicts - Reed and Wolf.
Page 4 of 8 AGENDA ITEM #6 CASE NUMBER: 08-54000032 J-16 Ponce De Leon DEFERRED UNTIL 01/16/09 3039-27th Avenue North Ngoc Anh Le Thomas J. Burns P.O. Box 7953, St. Petersburg, FL 33734 Variance to allow a circular driveway in the front yard in the NT zoning district. PARCEL ID NO.: 11/31/16/53046/000/0130/ NT-1 AGENDA ITEM #7 CASE NUMBER: 08-54000034 E-14 Granada Terrace TABLED FROM 10/17/08 106-23rd Avenue Northeast Richard and Stephanie Brooks N/A Variances to rear and side yards for a second story addition to an existing garage. PARCEL ID NO.: 17/31/17/32562/009/0050 NT-3 REQUIRED SETBACK: 10' Rear Yard 7.5 Side Yard PROPOSED SETBACK: 2.4 Rear Yard 4.9 Side Yard Approve variances to rear and side yards for a second story addition to an existing garage. Yes - N/A No Bacon; Fisher; LaBerge, Page; Reed; Smith; and Wolf. Conflicts - Carter. ACTION TAKEN: Denied.
Page 5 of 8 AGENDA ITEM #8 CASE NUMBER: 08-54000036 R-4 Historic Park Street 424-75th Street North John A. and Kristine Spickler N/A Variance to front yard setback for a pool and an over-height fence. PARCEL ID NO.: 19/31/16/20484/011/0010/ NT-3 POOL: REQUIRED SETBACK 30' PROPOSED SETBACK 20' REQUESTED 10' VARIANCE FENCE: MAXIMUM HEIGHT 5 PROPOSED HEIGHT 6 VARIANCE 2 Approve variance to front yard setback for a pool and an over-height fence. Yes - N/A No Bacon; Carter; Fisher; LaBerge; Page; Reed; and Smith. Conflicts None. ACTION TAKEN: Denied. AGENDA ITEM #9 CASE NUMBER: 08-52000006 F-18 Five Points 800 32 nd Avenue North Roy K. Haugseth, Trustee 1621 Gulf Boulevard, # 1508, Clearwater, FL 33767 Laura Bamond, Esquire 3510-1st Avenue North, #128, St. Petersburg, FL 33713 AND Randy Wedding, Architect Wedding & Stephenson Architects 300-1st Avenue South, St. Petersburg, FL 33701 Reinstatement of 8 dwelling units for a total of 23 dwelling units and a variance for parking. PARCEL ID NO.: 07/31/17/79596/000/0210/ NT-2 Approve reinstatement of 8 dwelling units for a total of 23 dwelling units and a variance for parking. Yes - Carter; LaBerge; Page; Reed; Smith; and Wolf. No Fisher Conflicts Bacon
Page 6 of 8 AGENDA ITEM #10 CASE NUMBER: COA 08-42 Downtown DEFERRED 146-4 th Avenue Northeast LANDMARK: Henry-Bryan House (HPC 93-06) DMH Ventures Punit R. Shah Relocation of building to 115-16 th Avenue Northeast and a change in Condition 12 in the staff report to state that within 60 days of COA application approval, the applicant shall provide City Staff with a maintenance plan. Such plan shall include maintenance provisions for before and after relocation. AGENDA ITEM #11 CASE NUMBER: COA 08-41 Downtown DEFERRED 136-4 th Avenue Northeast LANDMARK: Bay Gables (HPC 93-07) DMH Ventures Punit R. Shah Demolition of structure and clearing of site. V. ADMINISTRATIVE APPROVALS: A. The following Historic Preservation items were administratively approved ( Streamlined ) between September 23 and October 20, 2008. CASE NUMBER:1 COA 08-36mm 559 Mirror Lake Drive LANDMARK: St. Petersburg Lawn Bowling Club (HPC 93-01) CONDITIONS: City of St. Petersburg Resurface one court with grass. Repair and replace hex block sidewalks. Replace a 12 ft section of fencing and concrete block wall on southern boundary with a gate. Remove wooden bench along eastern wall. Remove wooden gutter framing. Remove chain link fence on west boundary. Add lighting. Hex block will be retained and reused. The historic delineation and masonry curbing of the court will be retained. The outline of the gutters will be retained. Proposed lighting will be approved by historic preservation staff prior to installation. Any additional work will require an additional COA.
Page 7 of 8 CASE NUMBER:2 COA 08-37 682 Roser Park Drive South LANDMARK: Roser Park Historic District (HPC 87-10) CONDITIONS: Gary Guthrie Construct a one-story addition on the west elevation. Any changes to the plan will require modification of the COA. Any work not included in the scope of this COA will require additional approval. CASE NUMBER:3 COA 08-38 1825 4 th Street North LANDMARK: Turner s Sunken Gardens (HPC 98-03) CONDITIONS: City of St. Petersburg Install a donor antenna on the roof to feed into building repeater system. It will be ballast mounted on a weighted metal sled. No rooftop penetration will occur, and antenna will not be visible from the street. New antenna will not be visible from the street. CASE NUMBER:4 COA 08-43mm 815 Prospect Court South LANDMARK: Roser Park Historic District (HPC 87-10) CONDITIONS: Catherine Lazzarus Install new 6 ft, vinyl privacy fence on rear and side (south) yard to replace existing fence. Fence will be installed as identified in COA application and meet all zoning requirements. Any work outside the scope listed above will require an additional COA.
Page 8 of 8 B. The following cases will be administratively approved on Friday,. AGENDA ITEM #5 CASE NUMBER: 08-54000037 G-14 Greater Woodlawn DEFERRED UNTIL 01/16/09 2336-12th Street North John D. and Loretta A. Rieman N/A Variance request to rear yard setback for new detached accessory living space. PARCEL ID NO.: 12/31/16/98838/000/0610/ NT-2 REQUIRED SETBACK 10' PROPOSED SETBACK 4.5' REQUESTED 5.5' VARIANCE VI. ADJOURNMENT: