How has Peter Zumthor responded to all of the Senses in his building The Therme Vals? Name: Helin Ozcan Student Number: 1423670 Blog Link: http://www.blogs.wecreatetogether.net/helinozcan/category/16-17tyaaart002-3- key-ideas-in-art-and-design-current-debates/
Contents Page Introduction 3 The Five Senses in Architecture 4, 5, 6 The Therme Vals: Design 6, 7, 8 The Therme Vals: Senses 8, 9 Conclusion 10 Illustrations 11 Bibliography 12, 13 2
Introduction Architecture is not about form, it is about many other things. The Light and the use, and the structure, and the shadow, the smell and so on. I think form is the easiest to control, it can be done at the end. (Peter Zumthor, Royal Gold Medal Lecture at the RIBA London, Amy Frearson, 6 February 2013) I agree with this because it should be more valuable, to get people s senses to spark while they travel in a space, like the material can make people s touch, sound, sight senses to awaken which then will enable them to express the space sensually, making it more meaningful than its form. This essay will analyse how Peter Zumthor has applied each of the senses which consist of Sound, Sight, Touch, Smell, Taste in his architecture The Therme Vals. It will discuss how Zumthor has brought all of these senses together, in this one space to create a full sensory experience for the people. He has also brought daylight into the building which It will also analyse what the importance of this was, the reason why, and the effect it creates in the building that links with the senses. Instead of mere vision, or the five classical senses, architecture involves several realms of sensory experience which interact and fuse into each other. (Pallasmaa, The Eyes of the Skin Architecture and the Senses, pg 45) From this quote I can see that all the senses are actually united together, they spark one another and it is possible for it to come together in one space. The senses are a part of our lives, we can not feel, make memories, hear sound, and many more things it can awaken, without them. In architecture, architects can control people s senses in their buildings. There are a few architects who actually give importance to the senses and actually design considering it as the centre of their designs and Peter Zumthor is one of them. I will look at him as an architect who has designed The Therme Vals where he has created a sensory building and has designed from the interior to the exterior which is portrayed in the building, showing that more is happening on the interior. This show s how he has given care to the use of the building, which could be how people are going to travel in this space, material, have an affect on awakening the senses. Peter Zumthor has not created the Therme Vals as a one off building but has many other projects which have focused on the human well-being, senses through the use of the buildings. Firstly, I will review each of the senses and how they are important in architecture and make spaces more meaningful, I will reference relevant parts of how Zumthor has applied these senses in the Therme Vals while talking about each one. 3
The Senses in Architecture Sound gives an impression of the space we are in, it can tell us more then we think like the spatial and material qualities, it is the only sense in architecture that will come back to you with anything you do in a building. In the Therme Vals the material that is used throughout the building is stone, which I will talk about why Zumthor chose to construct it all out of this material further later in the essay, but if you were to be brought into this space blind folded without knowing where you were coming, and you start talking your voice would create an echo. This is due to the emptiness of the space and material used but because you don t now this, the sense Sound would give you a hint of the spacial and material qualities, for you to guess what kind of space you are in. In your houses your voices would not create an echo because the environment is acoustically low key due to the furniture, carpets, that are there for it not too. Sight is the dominant sense in all the senses and this is because it allows you to get a first impression of the buildings and make your first judgments about its form, and spatial qualities through what you see. It can trigger the sense Touch because these two senses are somehow united. As humans we have the need to Touch things, to test how it feels. An ordinary example of this in our lives is that, when you go out to shop and you see something that you want, you approach it and you Touch it, feeling the texture, material and this is the same in architecture too. Sometimes we don t realise that we do these but when we go into a building, things that catch our Sight we approach and Touch it, testing to see how it feels any different from what it looks like, and so we use both these senses together one after the other. Sight can also exclude the other senses and become a dominant sense on its own, if the architecture only wants its audience to experience this. If the form is very powerful the Sight might not even be considered to trigger the other senses after it, and this depends on how the architects have approached to the senses with that building. Does it want Sight to trigger the other senses or not. Examples of this in modern architecture today are Skyscrapers. They are not buildings which consider sensory experiences very much, they are more about the form, and architecture has the ability to control how it wants people s senses to act as they can control this with material, form, and other spatial qualities. In the case of the Therme Vals the sense Sight triggers to awaken the other senses more than the form. We human s we have the need to Touch things to see how our bodies would react to them and this is because Touch can be triggered through the other senses, Sight, Sound, Smell, Taste. Touch is a sense which is like the tester after some of these senses, like the Sight which doesn t tell us more than what the eyes see, so the Touch sense takes over and tells us the feeling of the material and how our bodies react to it. The hands generally come to the mind when we say Touch but actually it isn t only this, the whole body is involved for 4
example when you go to a swimming pool the whole body Touches the water so all of it is involved. Touch is part of the sensory system consisting of all the five senses. The Somatosensory system is part of this system, linked to the Touch sense only. Within the Therme Vals the Touch sense is very dominant, because of the different temperature baths. Like I mentioned above Touch, is part of the somatosensory system which consists of touch receptors that are in every part of the body. When they feel change of temperature, pain, if a part of the body touches something or a place the whole body is involved in with, the free nerve endings which detect these changes that happen, show reaction to it. Everything has a Smell, even architecture. Smell has a link with the memory. You can recall memories that are made through Smell. The Sense Smell is more dominant in places like a groceries store, restaurants, café s and places which always involves a physical Smell created, but this doesn t mean that you can t recall Smell in other buildings or spaces differently if it doesn t have this. It doesn t always need to be in places like restaurants, or café s. The sense Smell can be abstract, so you can express a Smell of a space with its spatial qualities, for example, if you take several breaths in a spacious space, and packed space it can tell you the quality of the spaces. There is always a Smell even if it is not strong enough, there will be a scent that will help to make memories of it, and define that space with that Smell. At The Therme Vals, I think the sense Smell, has been used in an abstract way because of the spatial qualities, which are open and enclosed spaces, that plays with the different scents. The pools however have different temperatures which can have an effect on the scent and there are pools which have flower s in them to create a particular Smell. The open and enclosed space s, helps to keep the Smells separate within these different pools and you have to travel yourself to find out, and also in each of these spaces there are different amount s of people, and a mixture of there different scents which fuse together. I have been into a Turkish bath called a Hamam before and I remember the smell of the hot water, the steam created by the hot water in the enclosed room, which is to trap all the warmth and scent created from the bathing all in that space, within the packed atmosphere. The Smell of the scents created in that space helps me recall the memories from then today. The Smell sense wasn t the only sensory experience I was feeling in that space as my other senses were sparked but if I ever Smell a scent similar to this experience it recalls in my mind back to those memories, I can remember everything about it, where else with the other senses you can can recall certain memories too, but the memory and sense Smell has a strong bond. We use Smell to recall other places too such as homes, hospital s, different cities, and this is because everything has a Smell that is different in some way. For example, everyone has their own Smell that they create in their rooms, houses that is distinct to them, which they can create memories and recall later. You can recall memories with Smell from scents that you can create in a building or space of any kind. 5
The sense Taste is not like the other senses because you physically cannot Taste architecture, but you can Taste the architecture through the other senses, Sight, Sound, Touch, Smell. Taste is an abstract sense. Through the sense Smell, you can awaken the sense Taste, for example there are two different restaurants you can decide which suits your Taste and make a choice between the two place s, using the sense Smell to nurture the Taste. Another example of Taste with another one of the senses is Sight. There are several buildings around you but one has amazed you because that relates to your Taste, because the first impressions of it portrays a style you like. It can also put people in different categories, for example, in an ordinary family home two siblings share a room and they both have different Tastes of design, furniture, and way s of doing things which separates, and puts them into different categories. In The Therme Vals people can find their sense of Taste through the different temperature pools and different mysterious spaces created through the other senses. These different spaces enable people to chose which one suits there Taste and they feel better in which like I mentioned above, it puts people into different categories because if everyone had the same Taste and liked the same things, we would not have different buildings, cities, everything would be the same. That s why it is important how architects use the other senses to awaken the sense Taste in their buildings they create. The Therme Vals: Design Peter Zumthor is a Swiss Architect, born in Basel, Switzerland. He is the architect of the Therme Vals. Apart from this building, Zumthor has designed several other buildings which focus on sensory experiences, nature, and simplicity. In an interview (Architectural Journal editor Christine Murray, 02.06.2011, pg 10), Zumthor said Be yourself, love the profession, love building, I didn t set out to make a career, I set out to make good buildings. His buildings have portrayed what he has said here because in today s architecture there are many designs that make me think particularly as an Interior Architecture student that there aren t as many architects who consider what Zumthor has in his buildings. I am concluding this because of the architecture that is out there, Skyscrapers and tall-rise buildings. Steven Holl said in an interview, (Arch Daily editor Vanessa Quirk, 08.11.2016) ( ) I d say that Architecture doesn t have to be large to be meaningful. I think this quite touches on very well to Zumthor s buildings and todays architecture of skyscrapers and tall rise buildings. The way Zumthor works with the environment and builds considering the area he designs around, the use of the building, where else with skyscrapers and tall rise buildings they are larger buildings but don t get across a meaning much as the small ones because they don t consider as much of the nature, natural light, the use of the building which could be the senses, they could bring into the building for the well being of the human beings, and for them to express the building sensually rather than nothing. Through the research I did into some of Zumthor s other buildings I could see something common in the way he is 6
designing which is that he is creating spaces which trigger people s sense s through movement, so they have to discover themselves. Moving about in the spaces, there has to be something that triggers you to move about, and in the Therme Vals this is the daylight. In the Serpentine Pavilion in 2011 Zumthor s garden design was a garden which was in a black box as the exterior in a garden but you don t now what is inside it until you enter it. The interior is a garden of exotic plants from all different kinds, and as you start walking you discover these. The Therme Vals is similar to this design as well because until you walk through the corridor from the hotel which links the both and start travelling through it you don t now what is waiting for you when you look at it from the exterior. Zumthor creates small thing s that are not large in scale but they give people an experience to express the space sensually. The movement in his buildings add a unique style to him because especially at the Therme Vals which, is a spa where people go to relax, he has approached the term relax differently, by letting people find their own way to what relaxation is. The Therme Vals, was Zumthor s second architectural project after the Kunsthaus Bregenz. He started this project in 1993 while his first project was still under construction and was completed before that project, in 1996. The Therme Vals is a hotel and spa combined via a tunnel to the spa building in Graubunden Canton, Switzerland. The first inspiration of creating a spa underground came to Zumthor through viewing the place and looking at existing structures that could inspire him. They found between Ilanz and the Vals, Switzerland, galleries and tunnels constructed beneath the ground which inspired him further with the idea of creating an underground building. He came across quarries where they mine stone which, interested him that he did further research and discovered different types, layer s, colours of stone. The Main inspiration for the Thermal Bath s at Vals design today is the Turkish baths. ( ) But there was a colour photograph of the Rudas Baths in Budapest dating to the days of the Turks, which I had copied from a book and stuck on my wall (Peter Zumthor, Therme Vals, Scheidegger & Spies, pg 27). This quote shows how the Turkish Baths had inspired Zumthor and that when you look at the building today you can make relevance s with the Turkish Baths but the Therme Vals is more modern and the the use of the two is different. Zumthor has created a different interior that you don t have in Turkish Baths. In the Turkish Baths you bath, and that today different facilities have been added to it but it is actually a bath for the public, where else in the Therme Vals it is a spa, a place you can relax and discover different pools. Also when Zumthor visited the Turkish Bath s to get a clearer vision of the experience of being in one, he discovered that they change their cloths, relax after bathing in the same place and this influenced him in the designing of the Therme Vals to create spaces which give the same experience of feeling welcome, but in their own culture 7
of changing, so he put the changing rooms inside the building as soon as you enter through the long narrow corridor. They created block drawings which had started to depict what the interior was going to look like but also they were building from inside the mountain in front of the existing hotel and extending it out a bit which formed the exterior naturally in a way because they didn t think about it separately apart from that it will be coming out of the mountain as much as they did with the interior. The thing that Zumthor wanted to achieve with the building is that it looks natural and it fits in like it was always there and it actually come s out of the mountain naturally. Therme Vals: Senses Looking at the question I started the essay with how Zumthor has responded to all the senses at The Therme Vals. Through the analysis I did I have come to a conclusion that one of the aspects for Zumthor to create a sensory building for people was so that they experience different temperature baths through a discovery of there own, triggering the senses, with the support that the material stone gives. He has created a maze type of building which you have to travel through and explore it yourselves and throughout this process the atmosphere created with the support of the material stone, which is smooth on the floor but on the wall the stone is layered on top of each other and so at some parts it has this bumpy texture, and when there is light reflected on the walls this become more visible to the eye which can stimulate the Sight and Touch sense. The thing that triggers your senses to awaken one after another when you are travelling through this building is that the material stone is a bold and heavy material and you feel this when you see it, touch the material, and how it responds back to you. The way it sits there in the spaces the, big geometric cubes adds to this feeling, but the spaces in between give you a hint and lead you to the light and view of the outside. Like in Greek buildings the columns were the walls and from the space in between you would get the daylight coming through. The interior of the Therme Vals is like this there are these big block columns. Stone doesn t absorb the sound, it reflects it back so you can hear the sound of the water and the Sound of the people throughout the building. The daylight bought into the building through the long thin openings in the ceiling, where rays of daylight fall on the stone walls, and water help to stimulate the Touch sense. It automatically creates a feeling of wanting to Touch the light that falls on the walls feeling the warmth of it, and following the light. (see fig 1 and 2 to see how the light falls on the wall) 8
The second aspect is the design of the interior, which is partitioned with geometric cubes in the one big space from ceiling to floor blocking the view, and daylight coming in which you can glimpse as you enter. You have to make a choice of which route to follow, which stimulates the sense Taste. This also stimulates the sense Sight that you look around and express thoughts and judgments about the space from what you see for the first time. As you start discovering the building, making your way using your Sight sense, you see that they are not pure blocks from the ceiling to the floor, they are spaces which have showers, WC s, changing rooms, different temperature pools. You can enter one of the pools, which will stimulate your Sight, Touch, Smell, Sound senses. The Sound of the water and the Smell of the space if it is the flower pool where there are flowers put in the water to create a scent to fill that space, and if its the fire bath the smell of the steam arising, or the scents of the people who are there, fused together. This has already triggered some of the senses one after another, which you might not realise because it happening very quick and fusing into each other. As you come out of a pool, you take the water with you, leaving a trail of footsteps by walking out of the pool onto the floor, guiding someone else, to go and discover too. There are aspects of nature bought into the building. The material that is used for the building stone comes from nature, it is mined from quarries in fact the stone used in the Therme Vals comes from a local quarry near to the site in Vals. The way Zumthor has used the stone again in a cave like structure makes it feel natural which is what he wanted to achieve with the design and he even responded to it writing Building in stone, building with stone, building into the mountain, building out of the mountain, being inside the mountain ( ) (Peter Zumthor, Therme Vals, Scheidegger & Spiess). Throughout the interior Zumthor has designed it so that you get a glimpse of the landscape of the valley outside and the beams of daylight that come into the building by windows within the space looking out to the valley and daylight from the openings in the ceiling. Zumthor has used these big cubes sitting there in the interior to control the daylight, to get people to move around the building to get around the space. The building is built out of the mountain and at the point where it stops they have carried on as a flat roof covered with grass. There are rays of daylight that comes through these openings which adds an effect to the water in the indoor pools, enabling it to create a shimmering effect, and to stimulate people s senses to go into the pools, to feel the warmth of the light coming down from the ceiling reflecting into the water. It also guides people that there is more daylight as the building grows out of the mountain as they come through the dark. The daylight brought into the building has a major effect for the building because daylight has a different quality which gives people energy and well-being, it also has this quality of warmth and it is felt on the body. Zumthor has applied this very cleverly through out the design and it would not be as effective and sensual if the daylight was excluded. 9
Conclusion Peter Zumthor s aim was to create a sensory experience for the people of all genders, ages, to relax in this stone and water combined space. To create a building which you have to move and discover yourself which will stimulate the senses. Zumthor has achieved to create a full sensory building which targets to the culture of the Vals and bringing their own culture of bathing with the inspiration he took from the middle eastern culture of bathing, into this building and created a modern way of bathing through the material stone which sets out a bold statement through his simple and geometric design which doesn t contrast with the body, but oppositely makes it feel relaxing and welcome. In conclusion I would like to add my opinion about The Therme Vals and how Zumthor has responded to the senses in the Therme Vals through two aspects that I concluded which are the material Stone and the interior design. This building show s the body what it is capable of triggering and it gets a meaning when they meet with the body. Zumthor has responded to his other buildings in the way he has with the Therme Vals designing from the interior to the exterior. Most of the architecture buildings today don t design like Zumthor does, and that s why they don t stimulate the senses. Zumthor takes advantage of the natural sources we have and brings them into his designs to dominate and lead the space. We live in a world today where technology is very major and is rapidly growing and we can do most things that we couldn t a few years ago but I don t think that Architecture has taken advantage of this. We have tall skyscrapers and tall-rise building s; architects are racing with each other to create the tallest skyscraper. In my opinion skyscrapers all look the same even if the form is different from the exterior, this doesn t impact the interior space s, as they all look similar, they give the same feeling and that there is nothing that stimulates the other senses apart from the Sight. Expressing a space with a sensual experience helps to make the space more special and meaningful. It creates memories forever, which can be recalled. If you compare skyscrapers with the Therme Vals, where you don t see the form of the exterior because, you enter through an underground tunnel from the hotel. The Sight sense is dominant in the interior of The Therme Vals to guide to get around the spaces, and awakens the other senses as well with it, through the discovery they have to make. Zumthor has designed the Therme Vals coming out of the mountain, if he was to build a tall rise building there it would not fit in the landscape of the village Vals and be very distracting. I have tried to pass across in this essay how we need our senses to feel, make memories, and to experience things sensually in a building in accordance to buildings that don t design to stimulate the senses by looking at the building, The Therme Vals where Zumthor has responded to stimulate these senses. He has created a building where when people enter the space, and start discovering, that then they value the allure of it. 10
Illustrations Fig 1 The daylight falling on the walls and reflecting in the pool. You can also see the openings in the ceiling. Fig 2 The daylight falling on the walls from the openings in the ceiling also a beam of daylight entering from an entrance/exit from around the corner it reflecting on the floor. It also looks like there s reflection of the pool coming out from a hidden space from the left side in the image. 11
Bibliography Books Peter Zumthor Therme Vals, Scheidegger & Spiess Peter Zumthor Atmospheres, Birkhauser The Eyes Of The Skin Architecture And The Senses, Juhani Pallasmaa Journals Architectural Review, August 2015, Pages 30, 31, 35 Architectural journal, 12.02.2009 Pages 48, 49 Architectural Journal, 02.06.2011, Pages 8, 9, 10,18, 19 Architectural Journal, 16.04.2009, Pages, 5, 18, 41, 42, 43 Websites https://www.dezeen.com/2016/09/25/peter-zumthor-therme-vals-spa-baths-photographyfernando-guerra/ http://www.archdaily.com/798978/steven-holl-on-combining-heritage-and-modernhealthcare-design-at-his-maggies-centre-barts http://dressingtheair.com/sense/smell/architecture/vals-therme-600.htm https://atmospherics3.wordpress.com/4-therme-vals/ 12
http://www.bbc.co.uk/schools/gcsebitesize/science/aqa_pre_2011/human/thenervoussyste mrev1.shtml http://marialorenalehman.com/post/maximizing-the-sense-of-touch-in-adaptive-architecture http://health.howstuffworks.com/skin-care/information/anatomy/touching.htm http://www.archdaily.com/13358/the-therme-vals http://www.ehow.com/about_7222124_echoes-made_.html https://experiencingarchitecture.com/2010/05/18/architectural-means/ https://www.reference.com/science/reflection-sound- 1670d3cdd1d9726b?qo=contentSimilarQuestions https://lewisdimension.wordpress.com/2010/07/21/7-senses-in-architecture/ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jzmvfsvkdrk https://www.dezeen.com/2009/04/18/key-projects-by-peter-zumthor/ http://marialorenalehman.com/post/architectural-building-for-all-the-senses https://www.dezeen.com/2011/06/27/serpentine-gallery-pavilion-2011-by-peter-zumthor-2/ https://www.dezeen.com/2013/02/06/peter-zumthor-at-the-royal-gold-medal-lecture-2013/ 13