Minutes 2014 Minnetonka Local Board of Appeal and Equalization Monday, April 21, 2014 1. Call to Order. Mayor Schneider called the meeting to order at 6:15 p.m. 2. Roll Call: Council members Dick Allendorf Patty Acomb, Brad Wiersum, Tim Bergstedt, Tony Wagner, Bob Ellingson, Terry Schneider were present. 3. Introductory Report. City Assessor Rebecca Malmquist gave the staff report. 4. Appeals to the board of review: A. Valuation changes being brought by the City Assessor to the Local Board of Appeal and Equalization for action: Petitioner 2013 Estimated Market Value 2014 Estimated Market Value 2014 Assessor s Recommendation 1) Gregory Kessler Amy Kessler 11811 Ridgemount Ave W PID: 02-117-22-12-0038 $441,000 $533,700 $448,300 2) Craig Sicard Kathryn Sicard 408 Parkers Lake Rd #305 PID: 04-117-22-21-0047 $333,800 $308,500 $265,000 3) William Hippee Jr 408 Parkers Lake Rd #313 PID: 04-117-22-21-0055 $238,300 $220,200 $161,500 4) Thomas Johnson Jill Johnson 15001 Tammer La PID: 04-117-22-43-0032 $422,700 $489,000 $457,900 5) John Hallberg Renee Hallberg
14791 Oakways Ct PID: 04-117-22-44-0030 $810,500 $983,800 $823,100 6) Javier Cascudo Colleen Cascudo 16101 Rosemary La PID: 08-117-22-11-0027 $324,400 $360,700 $334,900 7) Adam Drill Ashley Drill 2131 Portico Green PID: 09-117-22-22-0054 $350,000 $350,000 $210,000 8) David Grauze Sarah Coumoyer 14620 Woodruff Rd PID: 09-117-22-41-0010 $403,200 $421,300 $388,600 9) Leah McLean Benjamin Garbe 14821 Copperfield Pl PID: 09-117-22-43-0037 $550,100 $678,000 $493,800 10) Joseph Ford Jenifer Ford 12910 Woodbridge Tr PID: 10-117-22-41-0016 $269,600 $397,600 $375,000 11) Leigh Anne Snider Stanley Cunningham 12015 Cambridge Ct PID: 11-117-22-21-0040 $664,300 $690,300 $651,400 12) Christopher Wagner Anna Wagner 12105 Hilloway Rd W PID: 11-117-22-24-0047 $1,001,400 $1,001,400 $834,400 13) Mark Steingas M. Joan Steingas 3034 Gizmo La
PID: 13-117-22-11-0083 $188,500 $200,700 $188,900 14) Nathan Pottebaum Jessica Pottebaum 9601 Oak Ridge Tr PID: 13-117-22-41-0052 $440,500 $537,400 $387,400 15) James Schultz Margaret Schultz 3703 Plymouth Rd PID: 14-117-22-33-0024 $440,100 $423,900 $380,500 16) Scott L Hackett Judy Hackett 14610 Minnehaha Pl PID: 16-117-22-11-0045 $435,200 $518,800 $459,300 17) Kelley Oelhafen 15404 Robinwood Dr PID: 16-117-22-34-0009 $152,500 $183,700 $154,300 18) Michael Skadron Judy Skadron 11578 Cedar Pass PID: 11-117-22-42-0046 $1,167,500 $1,077,000 $910,000 19) Jeffrey Zoss Stefanie Zoss 4135 Heatherton Pl PID: 22-117-22-23-0055 $596,800 $686,000 $668,600 20) Jeri Massengill David Hodnefield 4272 Oak Drive La PID: 23-117-22-42-0033 $170,500 $309,900 $268,000 21) Linda Dundas 4657 Deerwood Dr PID: 27-117-22-12-0058 $184,800 $196,800 $189,500 22) Michael Arvidson
Mary Arvidson 4905 Baker Rd PID: 27-117-22-14-0061 $143,300 $170,200 $163,700 23) Kristin Stanley Lester Stanley 4815 Chantrey Pl PID: 28-117-22-21-0029 $681,500 $733,400 $634,300 24) Kerry Rosenhagen Erika Rosenhagen 4852 Woodhurst La PID: 28-117-22-24-0040 $650,400 $664,700 $580,000 25) Timothy Scott 15900 Nursery Dr PID: 28-117-22-33-0073 $616,800 $631,900 $543,000 26) Zhongqi Bai Zhenzhen Yan 5109 Vine Hill Rd PID: 30-117-22-32-0020 $222,400 $230,700 $155,000 27) Heidi Clement 18150 Covington Path PID: 31-117-22-43-0102 $166,500 $166,500 $132,000 28) Ann Sangpan 16670 Creekside La PID: 32-117-22-43-0026 $313,900 $378,200 $335,000 29) Catherine Krawczak Gunnar An 5627 Glen Ave PID: 33-117-22-13-0051 $152,000 $149,000 $139,000 30) Edward Wons Julaine Cole 6016 Pinewood La PID: 33-117-22-43-0007 $341,800 $359,900 $325,000 31) Rajesh Modi Trupti Modi
5681 Glen Moor Rd E PID: 34-117-22-13-0006 $276,500 $295,700 $278,400 32) Dustin Johnson 14721 Karyl Dr PID: 21-117-22-44-0017 $227,000 $252,600 $205,000 33) William Hippee Jr 408 Parkers Lake Rd #312 PID: 04-117-22-21-0054 $464,900 $429,600 $357,200 34) Daniel Yavner Mary Yavner 3143 Atwater St PID: 13-117-22-13-0009 $216,700 $230,400 $216,700 35) Gunard Nelson Carol Nelson 11689 Lone Lake Ridge PID: 35-117-22-12-0046 $766,600 $898,600 $766,600 36) Karen Cole 5032 Westmill Rd PID: 29-117-22-31-0044 $272,200 $272,200 $240,300 37) Henry Eydel 10315 Lakeview Dr W PID: 01-117-22-43-0022 $341,400 $400,700 $341,400 38) Sharei Chesed Congregation 1712 Hopkins Crossroad PID: 02-117-22-44-0012 $284,200 $236,600 $150,000 39) NFK Properties 6109 Blue Circle Dr PID: 36-117-22-43-0029 $850,000 $990,000 $850,000 40) GPH Wayzata LLC 15409 Wayzata Blvd PID: 04-117-22-31-0019 $3,500,000 $3,900,000 $3,400,000
41) GPH Wayzata LLC 15407 Wayzata Blvd PID: 04-117-22-31-0020 $5,500,000 $6,100,000 $5,200,000 42) Emeritus Corporation 14505 Minnetonka Dr PID: 16-117-22-41-0008 $6,396,000 $6,552,000 $6,552,000 43) CBC North-South, LLC 111 Cheshire La PID: 03-117-22-22-0003 $4,458,200 $4,458,200 $4,458,200 44) Robert Elconin Pamela Elconin 14521 Woodhill Cir PID: 28-117-22-14-0030 $325,400 $372,400 $343,700 45) William Doce-Heiam Suzanne Doce-Heiam 4803 Hamilton Rd PID: 28-117-22-23-0004 $495,500 $529,700 $514,900 46) Joyce Lyons Kevin Carpenter 2128 Windsong Cir PID: 09-117-22-12-0031 $684,500 $793,100 $679,400 47) The Oak Ridge Country Club 11 Loring Rd PID: 13-117-22-32-0006 $473,500 $517,000 $438,200 48) Summit Hospitality 17, LLC 10985 Red Circle Dr PID: 36-117-22-33-0020 $4,185,000 $4,650,000 $4,650,000 49) Country Village Shopping Center, LLC 11400 State Hwy No 7 PID: 23-117-22-11-00041 $12,500,000 $12,656,900 $12,656,900 50) W2005 New Century Hotel
Portfolio 10420 Wayzata Blvd PID: 01-117-22-24-0036 $5,334,000 $5,715,000 $5,715,000 51) Jancy Eddy Patrick Eddy 300 Sunnyvale La PID: 02-117-22-21-0037 $305,500 $379,500 $358,300 Schneider read each petition into the record. Each item was voted on separately with Wagner moving, and Wiersum seconding each motion to adopt the Assessor's recommended values. All voted "yes" on each individual motion. Motions carried. B. Petitions to the Local Board of Appeal and Equalization requiring advisor s recommendation: Petitioner 2013 Estimated Market Value 2014 Estimated Market Value 2014 Assessor s Recommendation 1) Edgar Mallison Diane Mallison 15808 Post Rd PID: 09-117-22-22-0010 $367,800 $439,100 2) IH2 Property Illinois LP 14513 Woodhill Ter PID: 21-117-22-41-0050 $344,500 $326,300 3) Jon Halverson Susan Halverson 4634 White Oak Rd PID: 27-117-22-22-0036 $325,700 $373,700 4) Thomas Elmer Beth Herrick 4709 Highland Rd PID: 28-117-22-21-0048 $147,000 $147,000 5) Carolyn Cook 14601 Atrium Way #322 PID: 28-117-22-44-0372 $133,000 $133,000 6) John Stockard Vanessa Stockard
4622 Lynwood Ter PID: 30-117-22-42-0015 $195,000 $261,900 7) Robert Shainess Michelle Shainess 5938 Lone Lake Loop PID: 35-117-22-42-0107 $460.000 $522,800 8) Gerrod Heise Jennifer Smith 4515 Greenwood Dr PID: 22-1174-22-44-0025 $321,000 $441,100 9) Sigvard Birkeland Holly Birkeland 5301 Rogers Dr PID: 27-117-22-44-0028 $373,200 $406,500 10) Adam Amato Anne Amato 4580 Greenwood Dr PID: 22-117-22-44-0021 $356,600 $394,200 11) Bradford Hayes 5723 High Park Dr PID: 32-117-22-24-0010 $274,300 $330,200 12) Neil Selden Angel Selden 11500 Oberlin Rd PID: 02-117-22-11-0055 $202,500 $220,900 13) David Yasmineh 2634 Crosby Rd PID: 08-117-22-41-0009 $782,900 $945,800 14) Bradley Wylie 12710 Cedar Lake Rd PID: 11-117-22-33-0023 $246,000 $296,600
Schneider read each petition into the record. Wagner moved, and Wiersum seconded a motion to refer the appeals requiring further review to the city's LBAE advisors. Wagner moved Wiersum seconded a motion to close the agenda to further petitions. All voted "yes." Motion carried. C. Petitioners wishing to go directly to the Hennepin County Board of Appeal and Equalization. Simple acceptance of the appeal by the Local Board of Appeal and Equalization preserves their right to go to the Hennepin County Board of Appeal and Equalization. None Wiersum moved, Bergstedtseconded a motion to continue the meeting to May 5, 2014. All voted "yes." Motion carried. Acomb moved, Wiersum seconded a motion to adjourn at 6:39 p.m. All voted yes. Motion carried. Respectfully submitted. David E. Maeda City Clerk