DHAKA: THE DRAW (& Nearby Nayaranganj)

Similar documents
FUSHUN: RUST BELT BUT HOPEFUL. November 24, 2008

CHANGSHA: CONSTRUCTION CENTRAL

HO CHI MINH (SAIGON): MOBILE URBAN AREA. 21 November 2008

TAIYUAN: RUST BELT RECOVERY

Housing and emergence of slums in Asian Cities

Key Issue Two: Where are people distributed within urban areas? CHAPTER 13

World Development Report Reshaping Economic Geography

CfE Higher Geography HUMAN ENVIRONMENTS: URBAN CHANGE IN MUMBAI

Urbanization. Urbanization in Chindia -- India Struggles with the Next 500 Million. Asian Experience with Compact Growth

Geography. October 29, Monday.

Research Report to the Architectural Institute of Japan (AIJ), Okinawa Chapter for the Young Researcher Award, 2007

Market Implications of Foreign Buyers

Linkages Between Chinese and Indian Economies and American Real Estate Markets

What are Urban Landuse Zones?

Higher Densities No Sprawl: Master Plan for the City of Ramat-Gan, Israel

410 Land Use Trends Comprehensive Plan Section 410

Challenging Trends Facing Housing in La Crosse

Public Transportation

Profile of International Home Buyers in Florida

Housing for the Region s Future

Centre and the Hong Kong Sectio

3 RENTAL HOUSING STOCK

Ch. 14 CAPITOL HILL. Historic Districts - Apartment and Multi-family Development

8Land Use. The Land Use Plan consists of the following elements:

The cost of increasing social and affordable housing supply in New South Wales

Americas Office Trends Report

Urban Land Use. Unit 4 GEO22F PB

Thailand: Focus on Pattaya

2014 Plan of Conservation and Development

Table of Contents. Appendix...22

Findings: City of Johannesburg

2014 Charleston Tri-County Region

Provide a diversity of housing types, responsive to household size, income and age needs.

Chapter 13. Urban Patterns

Existing Land Use. Typical densities for single-family detached residential development in Cumberland County: 1

Re: Proposed Safeway renovation and expansion on Henry/Shattuck Avenue

DEVELOPMENT OF FLEXIBLE OPEN SPACES IN HOUSING CONCEPTS FOR YANGON REGARDING SOCIAL AND CULTURAL CONDITIONS IN MYANMAR

HOUSING ELEMENT Inventory Analysis

Affordable Housing Policy. Economics 312 Martin Farnham

Chapter 5: Inside the City II: A Closer Look

Land Use Survey Summer 2014

Suburban Sprawl: Exposing Hidden Costs, Identifying Innovations. Summary

IDENTIFICATION OF MEGACITIES AND THEIR VERTICAL AND HORIZONTAL CLASSIFICATION IN THE PERIOD FROM 1950 TO 2050

Housing conditions in the slum 3. Problem with ergonomics 5. Concept 7. Ergonomic modification, materials. 8. Logical reasoning.. 9. Site plan...

POPULATION FORECASTS

Context Briefing 2 Progress with housing and regeneration interventions

Staff Report PLANNING DIVISION COMMUNITY & ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT. Alley Closure

APPENDIX C CHARACTERISTICS OF THE ENERGIZE PHOENIX CORRIDOR

INLAND EMPIRE REGIONAL INTELLIGENCE REPORT. School of Business. April 2018

SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA REGIONAL PROGRESS REPORT

COMPARISON BUILDINGS. Circulation, Clients, and Guest Spaces vs. Family Spaces

ZIMMERMAN/VOLK ASSOCIATES, INC.

Housing Characteristics

4.2.8 Westwood/VA Hospital Station Area

Bylaw No , being "Official Community Plan Bylaw, 2016" Schedule "A" DRAFT

CAIRO: URBAN PLANNING MODEL. 13 May 2006

Place Type Descriptions Vision 2037 Comprehensive Plan

Focus article: Metropolitan and rural housing market developments

Orange County Housing Report

LAKE MERRITT STATION AREA PLAN

Burlington Unincorporated Community Plan

Appendix A. Factors Affecting City Current Expenditures

How Severe is the Housing Shortage in Hong Kong?

Housing in African Cities: why it matters and what is going wrong

2013 Arizona Housing Market Mid-Year Report

Queens Drive regeneration: Swindon Council's unaffordable housing strategy

Chapter 12. Key Issue Four: Why do services cluster downtown?

A Short Review of Multifamily, Rental Housing on Long Island

Flatbush Rezoning and Text Amendments LR Item 3: Description of Proposal

The Park at High Crossing. vitality proximity value

L. LAND USE. Page L-1

Economic density (proxied by light emission), Population and economic density of urban agglomerations, 2006

The Seattle MD Apartment Market Report

Housing Prices Under Supply Constraints. Markets behave in certain reliable ways. When the supply of a

An Assessment of Sydney s Industrial Land Supply. A shortage of developable land has the potential to impact occupier location strategies

Radian RATE Programme STAR Survey Results April 2017 to December 2017 All Residents Report February 2018

Affording Coralville: A Conversation about Our Housing Needs Coralville Public Library

Damascus

HONG KONG: LIKE NO OTHER

2018 Housing Issues Briefing Shane Davies, Seattle King County REALTORS President Remarks

Urbanisation. The Growth of Towns & Cities

The tower has helped manage urban density, but it often fails to honor qualities of life on the street. Now we have the opportunity to change that.

Settlement Pattern & Form with service costs analysis Preliminary Report

Keppel Land in China. May 2006

THE REDEVELOPMENT PLAN

Housing Markets: Balancing Risks and Rewards

Tree-lined streets, multilevel

The Impact of Market Rate Vacancy Increases Eleven-Year Report

Trinity Guardrail End Cap Survey - Part III

APARTMENT MARKET SUPPLY AND DEMAND DATA. Prepared March 2012 PAGE 1

Case Study: Tokyu Corporation

Comparative Housing Market Analysis: Minnetonka and Surrounding Communities

APPENDIX A FACTORS INFLUENCING COUNTY FINANCES

How Does the City Grow?

$7,700,000. Airport Business Center FOR SALE PROPERTY NE 80th Ave, 7820 NE Holman Ave, 6130 NE 78th Ct Portland, OR 97218

CTBUH Copyright. The Remaking of Mumbai in the Sustainable Age. Mr. Ratnakar Gaikwad

EXISTING CORRIDOR CONDITIONS CHAPTER 3

Radian RATE Programme STAR Survey Results April 2017 to March 2018 All Residents Report April 2018

Addressing the Impact of Housing for Virginia s Economy

Hamilton s Housing Market and Economy

Transcription:

DHAKA: THE DRAW (& Nearby Nayaranganj) DHAKA: BASIC INFORMATION World Similar Rank to Urban Area Population (2009) 10,685,000 22 Paris, Dongguan Projection (2025) 18,900,000 17 Shenzhen, Seoul- Incheon, Los Angeles Urban Land Area: Square Miles (2009) 110 Hannover, Victoria Urban Land Area: Square Kilometers 285 271 (BC), Bakersfield, Hiroshima, Xiamen Density: Per Square Mile (Latest) 97,100 Well above Hong 1 Density: Per Square Kilometer (Latest) 37,500 Kong and all others *Continuously built up area (Urban agglomeration) Land area & density rankings among the approximately 850 urban areas with 500,000+ population. Data from Demographia World Urban Areas (http://www.demographia.com/db-worldua.pdf) General Description 22 May 2009 Dhaka is the capital of Bangladesh and one of the world s newest megacities (A megacity is urban area or agglomeration over 10,000,000 population). Dhaka is also the world s poorest megacity, though two of the next three entrants to the megacity class will be poorer (Lagos and Kinshasa, with Karachi being somewhat more affluent than Dhaka. 1 Traveling to Dhaka Dhaka is served by international airline flights to Zia International Airport. 1 See also The Draw of Dhaka, http://www.newgeography.com/content/00778-the-draw-dhaka, Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 1

Traveling in Dhaka This rental car tour was principally based upon walks, taxicab rides and the special experience being shown around the Dhaka area by two college students. Rajib and Shojib. They drove the author around Dhaka in air conditioned comfort for a day and provided far better commentary and descriptions than one could ever expect from a taxicab driver. They made arrangements for me to enter three slums, which is a very special experience. Previously, I had been able to tour the inside of shantytowns only in Soweto (Johannesburg area) and Rochina (Rio de Janeiro) and these were on organized tours. Only late in the day, after visiting all three, was I to find out that neither of them had ever entered a slum before. The Location: River City Dhaka may be the most inconveniently placed urban area in the world, even worse than New Orleans. The urban area sits on the world s largest river delta, the Ganges Brahmaputra Delta (The Ganges is called the Padma River in Bangladesh). The rivers themselves are among the mightiest in the world. The Ganges rises in southwestern Tibet, on the southern slopes of the Himalaya Mountains and has the greatest average discharge at its mouth of any river in the world (following the Amazon, which has a discharge five times as great). The Brahmaputra is a tributary of the Ganges meeting that river s main channel approximately 100 miles from the Bay of Bengal (Indian Ocean). The Brahmaputra has an unusual course, also beginning in southwestern Tibet, however on the northern slopes of the Himalayas, not far from the source of the Ganges. From that point, the river flows east, turning south briefly near the eastern extent of India, then turning west toward Bangladesh. At its mouth, the Brahmaputra s average discharge rate is greater than that of the Mississippi River and among the ten largest in the world. 2 Dhaka is surrounded by the rivers and distributaries of the Ganges-Brahmaputra system. The low elevation of the surrounding land is illustrated in Slides 216 and 218. The urban area is protected from the routine and disastrous floods by flood channels and floodwalls. The main channel of the Ganges is approximately 20 miles away (30 kilometers). Somewhat north of this point is the confluence of the Ganges and Brahmaputra 3 Rivers, no more than 50 miles (80 kilometers) from Dhaka. Approximately 40 miles (60 kilometers) to the north is the Old Brahmaputra River, which was the main course of the Brahmaputra River until it changed course more than 200 years ago (Slide 3 4 ). The Old Brahmaputra flows into another large river, the Meghna, which merges with the Ganges (Padma) approximately 30 miles (50 kilometers) south of Dhaka. The Meghna flows within 15 miles of Old Dhaka (25 kilometers), approximately 2 Based upon information in http://books.google.com/books?id=huxrvyuk0rac&pg=pa99&lpg=pa99&dq=%2bbrahmaputra+%2bbraiding &source=bl&ots=xdgcydvr48&sig=xmf0z1au6ogse1qdplbuwsriefw&hl=en&ei=cwcpsq3bl9ofmqe5k5ifc A&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=3#PPA101,M1 3 Also called the Jamuna south of the point where the river was diverted from its previous course (now called the Old Brahmaputra). 4 From http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/0/01/bd_map_central_bangladesh.jpg Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 2

three miles south of Naraganganj (5 kilometers). For the final 50 miles (80 kilometers) to the Bay of Bengal, the main course of the Ganges/Padma carries the Meghna name. Somewhat closer are other distributor rivers of the Ganges-Brahmaputra system, such as the Buriganga River (Slides 161, 162, 165,166 212-214 & 216-218)), which separates a small western section of the Dhaka urban area from the larger section on the eastern bank. Somewhat north of Zia International Airport and the Uttara Model Town, an east-west distributor channel, the Tairag River, splits the main portion of the urban area from its northern extension into Tongi (Gazipur District). A few miles to the east of the urban area, another is another distributaries, the Balu River, which is met by the rapidly developing Demra section of the urban area (which extends from Old Dhaka to the river). A new bridge is under construction at the eastern end of Demra and development has started to spill over the Balu River. The Balu meets the Sitalankya River, which encloses most of the Naraganganj urban area (below) and completes the inner loop of distributor rivers around Dhaka. If there ever was a river city, Dhaka is it. The Ganges-Brahmaputra River is also home to another of the world s megacities, Kolkata (Calcutta3). However Kolkata s geographical challenges are far less, with less of the surrounding land taken up by wetlands and without the relatively dense mesh of distributor channels. At least partially as a result, Kolkata, despite its reputation for density, is at least 50 percent less dense than Dhaka Most of the Dhaka urban area is located in the Dhaka District of Bangladesh. The urban area also extends into Gazipur District to the north and is in the process of expanding into Naraganganj District to the east. The urban area also extends into Naraganganj District, to the south. Eventually, it is likely that the Dhaka urban area will extend further south and engulf the satellite urban area of Naraganganj (below) Dhaka: On the Way to 40 Million? Dhaka is one of the world s newest megacities, with an urban agglomeration over 10.7 million population (based upon United Nations population growth rate projections). There are few urban areas in the world that are growing faster than Dhaka. Historically, nearly one-third of the urban population increase in Bangladesh has been in Dhaka. This seems likely to continue, since the nation has few other urban centers. The second largest, Chittagong, is just one-third the size of Dhaka. At projected urban population growth rates, Dhaka could have 40 million people by 2050, which is 5 million more than live in Tokyo-Yokohama today. Dhaka: World s Most Dense Urban Area With its strong population growth (based upon the 2008 government estimate and the projected growth to 2009), Dhaka appears to have emerged as the world s most dense major urban area, displacing Hong Kong. Dhaka has a very small urban footprint, covering only 110 square miles (285 square kilometers), which with its population of nearly 10,700,000 represents a density of 97,000 per square mile (37,000 per square kilometer). Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 3

A few examples illustrate the hyper-density of Dhaka. The world s largest urban area, Tokyo-Yokohama, covers nearly 30 times as much land area and has a population of approximately 35 million. At Dhaka densities, Tokyo- Yokohama s urban footprint would accommodate nearly 300 million people --- almost as many people as live in the United States. The world s largest expanse of urbanization, New York, covers more than 40 times as much land area as Dhaka. If New York were as densely developed as Dhaka it would have 430 million people, a population nearly equal to that of the United States and Japan combined. Many urbanologists express admiration for Portland, Oregon s densification policies. Yet, Portland covers nearly more than 4.5 times as much land as Dhaka, while having less than 1/7 th the population. If Portland were as dense as Dhaka, it would be home to 46 million people, almost as many people as live in California, Washington and Oregon. However, due to its large average household size (4.7), Dhaka does not have the most dense housing patterns in the world. That title continues to reside with Hong Kong, which has only 2.9 persons per household. Dhaka s has a density of approximately 20,600 residences per square mile (8,000 per square kilometer), compared to Hong Kong s 24,400 per square mile (9,400 per square kilometer). Further, Dhaka s residential buildings are far less imposing than those in Hong Kong. Part of the reason is that so many of Dhaka s residents live in slums (shantytowns) that are generally hidden from the view of major streets (below). However, Dhaka feels every bit as dense as the data shows. People are everywhere, whether crowding on sidewalks, crowding in buses or milling around bus stops and stations waiting to be picked up. Further, the large green areas, government facilities military installations and two international airports (one now converted into the National Parade Grounds) consume a large share of Dhaka s land area, making the high density even more imposing. Poverty Bangladesh is a poor country. Most recent estimates place the gross domestic product per capita of Bangladesh at under $1,500 annually (purchasing power parity). Progress is being made, principally from the fruits of globalization. There has been strong growth in garment production and huge numbers of jobs have been created. However, even this progress is threatened by inward-looking anti-trade movements in developed countries whose proponents ignore the likelihood that their policies would drive the poor of Dhaka (and elsewhere) into even more intense poverty. Even if these selfish intentions fail, it will take decades for Bangladesh to join the ranks of middle income nations, much less high income nations. That, nonetheless, should be the objective. Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 4

Dhaka s Urban Form Dhaka has a very small urban footprint, covering only 110 square miles (285 square kilometers), ranking it approximately 270 th among the more than 850 urban areas in the world with more than 500,000 population (Slide 2). The urban area is from 5 to 7 miles wide (8 to 11 kilometers), east to west and 15 to 20 miles (25 to 30 kilometers ) long, from north to south. Dhaka is a decentralized urban area. There are at least three cores, the apparent strongest of which is the area around Old Dhaka, to the south of the urban area (Slides 124-199). This area includes considerable green space, most government offices and universities. There is a second core in the middle of the urban area, in the vicinity of the National Assembly Hall Slide 17) or parliament building (Slides 9-123). Finally, there is a newer, more affluent the Gulshan-Banini area, which houses many diplomatic missions (Slides 307-343). However, large commercial buildings are located all over the Dhaka area. There are significant office and commercial concentrations in the Uttara Model Town (Slides 263-270), north of Zia International Airport as well as in Dhanmondi, also in the central area. The garment industry is Dhaka s largest employer. Garment factories are located throughout the urban area (Slides 203, 238, 252, 256, 273 & 284) and there are billboard reminders of the urban area s reliance on the industry (Slide 306). Despite its high density, Dhaka s density is visibly different than that of Hong Kong, which was until recently the world s most dense urban area. There are many mid-rise buildings, at five to 10 floors. There are also a number of taller buildings, but there are none of the more than 50 story residential and office towers that are so common in Hong Kong. Currently, Dhaka s tallest building is less than 40 stories and relatively few buildings exceed 20 floors. The central sector also includes Bashundhara City, which the owners claim is the largest shopping center in South Asia (Slides 24 & 25). There are approximately 1,500 stores on 8 levels. This center, however, is markedly different than most enclosed shopping malls. Generally, the stores are very small and the usual international stores are few in number. Most stores appear to sell music CDs or apparel. In March of 2009, a fire gutted the upper stories of the office building on top of the shopping center. Green Dhaka: Despite its unequaled density, Dhaka has considerable amounts of green space, befitting a national capital. The National Assembly Hall is located in a large green area near the center of the urban area. National government offices and ministries and universities are also located in large green areas, in the older center, near Old Dhaka. Housing Nearly all housing in Dhaka is multi-unit. Many of the buildings are low-rise, however the area is densifying as property owners develop higher rise buildings (For example, Slides 47-53). Developers often propose building higher rise buildings and sharing the equity (often on a 60:40 basis, with 60% to the developers). This has made it possible for Dhaka to densify significantly, both in the more affluent areas and in areas that house much of the rest of Dhaka s population. Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 5

The most affluent areas are Gulshan & Banini (Slides 307-343), the Uttara New Town (Slides 266-269) and Dhanmondi, (Slides 91-103) which have upper middle income and luxury condominium and apartment buildings. Japan Garden City: Perhaps the most significant new development is the Japan Garden City, located in Mohammedpur, in the central sector of the urban area. This high rise development will have at least 14 high rise residential towers of 16 floors as well as a shopping area. There will be an underground garage as well as a multi-storied auxiliary garage along the main road serving the project. Overall, the site is 9.78 acres and will include 1,803 residential units. Developers claim that only 43 percent of the site is built upon, with the balance being in greenway, in which they include walkways, garden and vacant area. The project is being sold as pollution free, though the developer s website provides no details on the latter claim. Critics claim that much of the greenway is really dedicated to traffic circulation and that little of the property is usable recreation area (a school playground). Further, they note that the highrise buildings are being built from 8 to 10 feet apart (up to 10 meters apart). The development will be very crowded indeed. The eventual population is estimated at 9,000, which would give it a population density of nearly 590,000 per square mile (more than 225,000 per square mile), which is more than the average Dhaka slum (570,000, see below). Further, the developers estimate that the project will be supported by approximately 2,500 cars, which will provide a substantial burden to the narrow and already congested roadway (Ring Road) on which the project is located (Slides 77-83). 5 The Slums (Shantytowns): It is estimated that nearly 40 percent of Dhaka residents live in informal housing or slums (shantytowns). 6 These settlements tend to be marbled throughout the urban area, along the streams, railroads, lakes and ponds and in the drainage canals. They are generally hidden from the view of major streets. However, none of the shantytowns are so expansive as can found in Mumbai. Perhaps that is because commerce is decentralized in Dhaka, with garment factories spread throughout the urban area. People in the shantytowns have to work and many walk to their jobs, both factory and domestic. Their lives are precarious. Population densities in the slums have been reported as high as 4,200 per acre, which converts to more than 2,500,000 per square mile or more than 1,000,000 per square kilometer. 7. At that density, the population of the world could be accommodated in the Tokyo-Yokohama urban area, leaving 10 percent of the land for open space. The average density of slums is approximately 570,000 per square mile (220,000 per square mile). Assuming the nearly 40 percent estimate of slum population, it appears that nearly 4,000,000 people live in the slums. They live on little more than 6 percent of the urban land area. However, even with the large share of the population living at these densities, the balance of Dhaka is nearly as dense as Hong Kong (see table). 5 Developer s website: http://www.jgclbd.com/index1.html. Report critical of the project: http://www.tibangladesh.org/research/es_rajuk_eng.pdf, page 10. 6 http://pdf.usaid.gov/pdf_docs/pnadi537.pdf. 7 http://www.rrcap.unep.org/reports/soe/dhaka-soe-05/3-8dhaka-slum.pdf Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 6

More than 95 percent of slum residents have access to electricity and nearly 60 percent have access to natural gas for cooking. More than 90 percent have access to municipal tap water, though nearly 99 percent of these households must share with neighbors (sometimes more than 30 households share the same tap). 8 Often, this access to municipal utilities is pirated (illegal). Table Dhaka: Estimated Population Density: Overall and Slums: 2009 Population Square Miles Density Square Kilometers Density Other than Slums 6,690,000 103.0 65,000 267 25,100 Slums 3,995,000 7.0 570,000 18 220,100 Urban Area 10,685,000 110.0 97,100 285 37,500 Most of the slum dwellings are single story. The Begunbari slum (Slum #1, Slide 6), which we visited, is an exception. Many of the buildings in this slum are two floors, with individual residences confined to a single floor. The buildings are raised by bamboo pilings above the flood channel in which they are located. The government is in the process of condemning this slum (Slide 345-378). Two other slums were visited. Slum #2 (Slide 6) was along the Buriganga River on the northwest side of the urban area. This small slum has developed on the riverside slopes of the floodwall (Slides 379-385). Slum #3 (Slide 6) was also located in the northwestern sector, adjacent to a pond. This slum was smaller than Begunbari (Slides 379-400). Here, we were able to make a brief visit to an NGO elementary school (Slide 401). Dhaka: The Ultimate in Rural to Urban Exodus In recent centuries, the principal migration of the world s population has been from rural areas to urban areas. As late as 1900, less than 20 percent of the world s population lived in urban areas. That figure has now risen to more than 50 percent. Urbanization occurred earliest in the first world, as the increased wealth produced by the industrial revolution attracted people from the countryside. In 1900, 40 percent of the US population was urban, a figure that had risen to 80 percent by 2005. Trends in Europe, Japan and other first world nations are similar. A similar migration was slower to start in the less developed world. Only in 2005 did China achieve a 40 percent urbanization rate. Urbanization is expected to continue virtually everywhere, with the world rate increasing to 70 percent by 2050. Despite its later start, the rate of urbanization in the developing world far exceeds that achieved decades ago in the developed world. Nowhere, however, are the trends more stark than in Bangladesh and its capital, Bangladesh is approaching 160 million people, despite having a land area less than that of Wisconsin. Its population density, rural and urban combined, is approximately 3,200 per square mile (1,250 per square kilometer) and is nearly equal to that of the Portland urban (urbanized) area, which had 3,300 per square mile. The nation s population density is more than three times the threshold 8 http://pdf.usaid.gov/pdf_docs/pnadi537.pdf. Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 7

used by census authorities in the United States, France, the United Kingdom and Canada for delineation of urban areas. However, most of Bangladesh is not urban. The United Nations puts the urban share of the Bangladesh population at 28 percent, barely two-thirds of the less developed world average. Even this is a stunning increase from the less than 5 percent of 1950. By 2050, the United Nations says that Bangladesh will add 87 million people, 97 million of whom will be added to urban areas. The rural population is expected to decline as the urban population rises to near 60 percent. 9 Passenger Transport Dhaka s transportation system is poorly developed. The urban area, as noted above, is elongated, north to south. The centers are generally on a north to south axis, which creates considerable travel demand. Yet, there are only two or three major roads that traverse most of the urban area. The principal road is generally four to six lanes, though expands to eight lanes near Zia International Airport. An unusual feature of Dhaka s roads is the large number of overhead electrical wires that are typical. Many of these wires fall to street level and one must be careful, as a result, to avoid them walking on sidewalks (Slides 21 & 67). The Inspector General of Police estimates that the main road is blocked for 6 hours per day at railroad crossings. Needless to say, with its density inducing traffic congestion and insufficient road infrastructure, Dhaka s traffic is horrific (Slides 42 & 46). 10 There are no freeways in the Dhaka area, which is the only one of the world s megacities without a freeway. At present, there are plans to build an elevated freeway ring road around the urban area. Dhaka is the only one of the world s megacities that does not have English or French language road signs along with those in the native language. In the case of Bangladesh, this means that the road signs are in Bangla, which has its own script and is unfamiliar to westerners. As a result, travel by rental car travel by westerners most difficult. 11 Public Transport: Public transport is principally by three modes --- the buses, which are hideously crowded (Slide 59 & 65), the auto-rickshaws (Slide 153 & 155) and the human powered rickshaws (Slide 36, 171, 187 & 286). There are also vehicles that carry six to eight passengers sitting laterally in the back, somewhat similar (though smaller) than the jeepneys of Manila. There is a large and crowded bus station at Farmgate, in the central area (Slides 8 and the logo for this rental car tour (above and on section dividers in slides). Local officials have variously talked about improving the limited suburban rail service that operates from Naraganganj through Dhaka to Tongi. There has also been discussion of building 9 http://esa.un.org/unup/index.asp?panel=1 10 http://www.amchambd.org/amcham2/all_files/speech%20on%20traffic%20jam%20by%20igp..doc, 11 In the case of most Rental Car Tours, the author rents a car. However, there are two exceptions. Generally, in lower income countries where driving is on the left, taxis are hired, while in China it is nearly impossible to rent a car without a local drivers license, which also necessitates taxis. Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 8

urban rail lines or rapid busways, in the expectation that this would reduce traffic congestion. There is the potential for such rapid transit systems to reduce traffic congestion, but only by attracting passengers from buses and reducing bus traffic. It is unrealistic to expect automobile users to switch to any such rapid transit system and, indeed, the demand for personal transport is rising rapidly. Dhaka s transport problems seem likely to only become worse. The principal problem is that Dhaka s density is far too high for an urban area to perform productivity. There is some land to the east of the urban area that can be developed, but it seems likely that this land (and more) will be required for the huge projected population increase. In short, Dhaka s transport challenge seems overwhelming in dimensions that are unimaginable even in the world s other most congested urban areas, such as Mumbai, Manila and Jakarta. Air Pollution: Despite the traffic congestion, the air pollution could be far worse. All of the autorickshaws and a large share of Dhaka s cars operate on natural gas. The Draw of Dhaka Why do they come to Dhaka? What is the draw of a place that to western eyes could be dismissed as one of the least attractive urban environments in the world? It is the same incentives that drew people to Chicago from the countryside and to Sao Paulo from the sugar plantations. People routinely seek better lives. As with Jakarta and Manila, rural populations did not migrate to Dhaka because they were better off where they came from. Moreover, virtually all of the migrants from rural areas could return home tomorrow. Not surprisingly, few do. Dhaka: City of Hope Of course, it is all a matter of perspective. Dhaka may not look pleasing to affluent foreigners. Few residents of Portland, Paris or Perth would willingly make permanent moves to the poverty of Dhaka. But despite the intensity of its challenges, for the rural poor of Bangladesh, Dhaka is a city of hope. but for the rural population of Bangladesh, Dhaka is a city of hope. APPENDIX: NAYARANGANJ URBAN AREA NAYARANGANJ : BASIC INFORMATION World Rank Urban Area Population (2009) 655,000 563 Likely to be Projection (2025) absorbed by Dhaka Urban Land Area: Square Miles (2009) 12 Urban Land Area: Square Kilometers 31 Density: Per Square Mile (Latest) 54,600 Density: Per Square Kilometer (Latest) 21,100 Similar To Quebec, Concepcion, Bremen, Okayama --- Not Applicable 763 Magadan, Oxford, Davis (Calif.), Warnambool (Victoria) 8 Mumbai, Macao Nayaranganj is an urban area with 650,000 population, approximately 10 miles (16 kilometers) south of Old Dhaka s historic core (Slides 401-420). Today, Nayaranganj is nearly connected to Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 9

Dhaka by a thin strip of urbanization with a gap of between one and two miles (two to three kilometers) and is thus not considered a part of the Dhaka urban agglomeration. Like Dhaka, Narayanganj is very dense, with nearly 55,000 per square mile (21,000 per square kilometer), ranking 8 th in the world out of the more than 850 urban areas with populations exceeding 500,000. However, it seems likely that the continued growth of both Dhaka and Nayaranganj will result in an eventual consolidation into the larger Dhaka urban area. Bangali Hospitality I spent one of the nights in Dhaka in the Gulshan Club in Gulshan, which was very nice accommodations. I was able to stay there due to the intervention of a friend of an academic colleague in Paris. Moreover, I was invited to have dinner in the house of the friend, which was a very rich experience. Overall, the hospitality in Bangladesh was marvelous. http://www.rentalcartours.net http://www.demographia.com http://www.publicpurpose.com Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 10

MAPOF THEAREA Rental Car Tour: Dhaka 2 Dhaka Naranganganj Dhaka 3 4 NORTHEAST 2 3 1 GEOGRAPHIC CENTER OLD DHAKA & SOUTH Slums Visited 5 6 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 11

Geographical Center 8 9 10 11 12 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 12

13 14 15 16 17 18 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 13

19 20 21 22 23 24 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 14

25 26 27 28 29 30 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 15

31 32 33 34 34 3535 3636 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 16

3737 3838 39 40 41 42 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 17

43 44 45 46 47 48 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 18

49 50 51 52 53 53 54 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 19

55 56 57 58 59 60 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 20

61 62 63 64 65 66 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 21

67 68 69 70 71 72 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 22

73 74 75 76 Japan Garden City 77 77 Japan Garden City 78 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 23

Japan Garden City Japan Garden City 79 80 Japan Garden City 81 Japan Garden City 82 Japan Garden City 83 83 84 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 24

85 86 87 88 89 90 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 25

Dhanmondi Dhanmondi 9191 92 Dhanmondi Dhanmondi 93 94 Dhanmondi Dhanmondi 95 96 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 26

Dhanmondi Dhanmondi 97 98 99 100 101 102 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 27

103 104 105 106 107 108 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 28

109 110 111 112 113 114 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 29

115 116 117 118 119 120 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 30

121 122 Old Dhaka & South 123 125 126 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 31

127 128 129 130 131 132 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 32

133 134 135 136 137 138 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 33

139 140 141 142 143 144 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 34

145 146 147 148 149 150 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 35

151 152 153 154 155 156 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 36

157 158 159 160 161 162 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 37

163 164 165 166 167 168 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 38

Dhaka-Chittagong Highway 169 170 171 172 173 174 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 39

175 176 177 178 179 180 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 40

181 182 183 184 185 186 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 41

187 188 189 190 191 192 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 42

193 194 195 196 197 198 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 43

Northwest 199 201 202 203 204 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 44

205 206 207 208 209 210 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 45

211 212 213 214 215 216 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 46

217 218 219 220 221 222 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 47

223 224 225 226 227 228 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 48

229 230 5926 231 232 233 234 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 49

235 236 237 238 239 240 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 50

241 242 243 244 245 246 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 51

247 248 249 250 251 252 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 52

Northeast 254 254 255 255 256 256 257 257 258 258 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 53

259 259 260 260 261 261 262 262 263 263 264 264 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 54

265 265 266 266 267 267 268 268 269 269 270 270 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 55

271 271 272 272 273 273 274 274 275 275 276 276 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 56

277 277 278 278 279 279 280 280 281 281 282 282 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 57

283 283 284 284 285 285 286 286 287 287 288 288 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 58

289 289 290 290 291 291 292 292 293 293 294 294 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 59

295 295 296 296 297 297 298 298 299 299 300 300 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 60

301 301 302 302 303 303 304 304 305 305 306 306 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 61

Gulshan & Banini i 308 308 309 309 310 310 311 311 312 312 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 62

313 313 314 314 315 315 316 316 317 317 318 318 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 63

319 319 320 320 321 321 322 322 323 323 324 324 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 64

325 325 326 326 327 327 328 328 329 329 330 330 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 65

331 331 332 332 333 333 334 334 335 335 336 336 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 66

337 337 338 338 339 339 340 340 341 341 342 342 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 67

Slums 343 343 Slum #1 345 346 346 347 347 348 348 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 68

349 349 350 350 351 351 352 352 353 353 354 354 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 69

355 355 356 356 357 357 358 358 359 359 360 360 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 70

361 361 362 362 363 363 364 364 365 365 366 366 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 71

367 367 368 368 369 369 370 370 371 371 372 372 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 72

373 373 374 374 375 375 376 376 377 377 378 378 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 73

Slum #2 379 380 380 381 381 382 382 383 383 384 384 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 74

385 385 Slum #3 386 387 387 388 388 389 389 390 390 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 75

391 391 392 392 393 393 394 394 395 395 396 396 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 76

397 397 398 398 399 399 400 400 Narayanganj 402 402 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 77

403 403 404 404 405 405 406 406 407 407 408 408 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 78

409 409 410 410 411 411 412 412 413 413 414 414 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 79

415 415 416 416 417 417 418 418 419 419 420 420 Urban Tours by Rental Car: Dhaka 80