Canadian Wood Council G063 TIMBER FOR THE MASSES Liam Dewar, Director, EURBAN October 27, 2015
Credit(s) earned on completion of this course will be reported to AIA CES for AIA members. Certificates of Completion for both AIA members and non-aia members are available upon request. This course is registered with AIA CES for continuing professional education. As such, it does not include content that may be deemed or construed to be an approval or endorsement by the AIA of any material of construction or any method or manner of handling, using, distributing, or dealing in any material or product. Questions related to specific materials, methods, and services will be addressed at the conclusion of this presentation.
Course Description With so many compelling reason to build with mass timber the question is no longer why? but how?. As a construction method in its own right, mass timber construction has its own rules and regulations which need to be understood by all if mass timber is to achieve its potential of becoming the construction method of choice for most building types. This presentation will discuss focus on best practice in terms of design, procurement and construction through a number of case studies of recent projects that Eurban have been involved in.
Learning Objectives At the end of the this course, participants will be able to: Key learning points: KEY LEARNING OBJECTIVE 1 Understand what is being done in the UK in order to optimise the delivery of mass timber projects in terms of design and construction. KEY LEARNING OBJECTIVE 2 Understand the role of a CLT designer / specialist contractor on mass timber building projects and how knowledge and experience can inform design decisions and help deliver such projects effectively and safely. KEY LEARNING OBJECTIVE 3 Understand the risks associated with the design and delivery of large-scale mass timber buildings and how one might overcome such risks KEY LEARNING OBJECTIVE 4 Understand how mass timber construction differs from concrete construction and stick build construction, particularly in terms of the perceived risks of fire and moisture, and how to design for them.
Timber for the Masses Building a Timber Revolution LIAM DEWAR
Winery, Vauvert, France, 1998 Perraudin Architecture Gilles Perraudin, 1 installer IMAGE PERRAUDIN ARCHITECTURE
Architecture should be about satisfying a social need, not about addressing a financial condition. Using natural materials will escape the constraints of speculative industries, and return to a socially-alert, environmentally sustainable architecture. Gilles Perraudin, 2013
Can Lis & Can Feliz, Majorca, 1971 & 1994 Jørn Utzon IMAGE JAN UTZON
Can Lis, Porto Petro, Majorca, 1971 Jørn Utzon We have to understand the structure of wood, the weight and hardness of stone, the character of glass; we must become at one with our materials and be able to fashion and use them in accordance with their constitution. Jørn Utzon, The Innermost Being of Architecture, 1948
Brettstapel Dowelled or Nailed Laminated Timber (NLT)
Crosslam Cross Laminated Timber (CLT) IMAGEE STORA ENSO
Advantages of Crosslam
Structural Stability 7-Storey Test Building, Miki, Japan, 2007 IMAGE PROGETTOSOFIE
Dimensional Stability Unaffected by Moisture (within reason) IMAGE EURBAN
Dimensional Stability Unaffected by Temperature IMAGE EURBAN
Simplicity Airtightness IMAGE EURBAN
Simplicity Large Components (Less Joints) IMAGE DAVID GRANDORGE
Simplicity No Movement Joints IMAGE EURBAN
Simplicity Interface Detailing Support Structure IMAGE EURBAN
Simplicity Interface Details - Windows IMAGE EURBAN
Simplicity M&E Services IMAGE EURBAN
Thermal Stability Mass Timber - Five times better than Concrete MATERIAL THERMAL STABILITY λ / c.ρ (cm2/s) Mass Timber 12 Water 14 Brickwork 44 Concrete 68 SIP Panel (EPS) 167 Air 2,500 IMAGE EURBAN
Climate Stability Mass Timber Buildings - Eighty times better than Firewood TIMBER USE LIFE EXPECTANCY Timber Structure Woodfibre Insulation Furniture Books Wood Products Packaging Firewood 80 years 60 years 30 years 25 years 10 years 2 years 1 year IMAGEE EURBAN
Climate Stability The quickest and most cost-effective Carbon Store IMAGEE EURBAN
Health Benefits Reduced Heart Rate 600 heartbeats less per day IMAGE SOS
Health Benefits Reduced Heart Rate Medical evidence that timber as a construction material has a positive influence on human health. Evidence to support the argument that mass timber construction should be the favoured construction method for all buildings. IMAGE SOS
Arcadia Nursery, Edinburgh, Scotland, 2015 Malcolm Fraser Architects Eurban LIAM DEWAR IMAGE ANGUS BREMNER
Arcadia Nursery Designed around the concept of free play Children choose what activities they would like to participate in instead of being allocated to a playroom for the day. A place to learn, play and imagine LIAM DEWAR IMAGE M J RICHARDSON
Arcadia Nursery LIAM DEWAR IMAGE MFA
Arcadia Nursery LIAM DEWAR IMAGE EURBAN
Arcadia Nursery LIAM DEWAR IMAGE EURBAN
Arcadia Nursery LIAM DEWAR IMAGE EURBAN
Arcadia Nursery LIAM DEWAR IMAGE EURBAN
Arcadia Nursery LIAM DEWAR IMAGE EURBAN
Arcadia Nursery LIAM DEWAR IMAGE EURBAN
Arcadia Nursery LIAM DEWAR IMAGE EURBAN
Arcadia Nursery LIAM DEWAR IMAGE ANGUS BREMNER
Arcadia Nursery LIAM DEWAR IMAGE ANGUS BREMNER
Arcadia Nursery LIAM DEWAR IMAGE ANGUS BREMNER
Arcadia Nursery LIAM DEWAR IMAGE ANGUS BREMNER
Arcadia Nursery LIAM DEWAR IMAGE ANGUS BREMNER
Arcadia Nursery LIAM DEWAR IMAGE M J RICHARDSON
Arcadia Nursery LIAM DEWAR IMAGE ANGUS BREMNER
Crosslam Considerations IMAGE EURBAN
Logistics (maximum panel size) Road Transport IMAGE EURBAN
Logistics (maximum panel size) Site Access IMAGE BINDER HOLZBAUSYSTEME
Logistics Craneage IMAGE EURBAN
Logistics Craneage IMAGE EURBAN
Health & Safety Not Like This.. IMAGE MERK
LIAM DEWAR Mass Timber Construction in the UK
UK Service Providers Specialist Sub-Contractors & Market Share (Projects) We estimate that approximately 450 solid timber projects have been delivered in the UK to date, approx. 200 in the last 4 years. DESIGN-LED SUPPLY-LED CONTRACTOR-LED 45% 40% 15% LIAM DEWAR IMAGE EURBAN
UK Built Projects 2003-2011 LIAM DEWAR SCOURCE: TIMBER FIRST
Eurban What We Are Eurban is a consultancy and construction company specializing in the design, procurement and delivery of solid timber building structures LIAM DEWAR
What We Do Architect / Employer Perspective LIAM DEWAR IMAGE EURBAN
What We Do Supplier Perspective DESIGN ASSEMBLY LIAM DEWAR IMAGE EURBAN
Integrated Service Provider Design, Supply & Install TIMBER DESIGN MATERIAL SUPPLY SITE ASSEMBLY LIAM DEWAR IMAGE EURBAN
Timber Design Integrated Service Provider In-house Specialist Timber Engineers 3D CAD & BIM technology Level 2 TIMBER DESIGN LIAM DEWAR IMAGE EURBAN
Material Supply Integrated Service Provider CAD interface direct with manufacturers Project-specific solutions Work with leading European manufacturers MATERIAL SUPPLY LIAM DEWAR IMAGE EURBAN
Materials Supply Transportation LIAM DEWAR IMAGE EURBAN
Site Assembly Integrated Service Provider Directly-employed site installation teams Valuable feedback and lessons learnt from every project delivered. Retained knowledge / skill base SITE ASSEMBLY LIAM DEWAR IMAGE EURBAN
In-house Installers Quality on Site (Workmanship) LIAM DEWAR IMAGES DAVID GRANDORGE & ED REEVE
In-house Installers Safer Build Process Statistics 2012-2014 0 fatalities 0 major injuries 0 dangerous occurrences 0 reportable ill-health 3 non-reportable incidents LIAM DEWAR IMAGE EURBAN
LIAM DEWAR Eurban Services
Component Modelling For Costing Purposes LIAM DEWAR IMAGE EURBAN
Design Guidance For Architects / Client Reassurance LIAM DEWAR IMAGE EURBAN
Timber Engineering For Design Verification & Issue to Approval Bodies LIAM DEWAR IMAGE EURBAN
Fabrication & Delivery Information For Component Manufacture & Issue to Manufacturers LIAM DEWAR IMAGE EURBAN
Logistics For Programming & Issue to Main Contractor (Employer) LIAM DEWAR IMAGE EURBAN
Assembly Drawings For Site Teams LIAM DEWAR IMAGE EURBAN
Dune House, Suffolk, 2009 LIAM DEWAR IMAGE JVA
Timber Engineering LIAM DEWAR IMAGE EURBAN
Drawings Approval Manufacture LIAM DEWAR IMAGE EURBAN
Panelisation LIAM DEWAR IMAGE EURBAN
Materials Procurement LIAM DEWAR IMAGE EURBAN
Drawings Site Information LIAM DEWAR IMAGE EURBAN
Site Assembly LIAM DEWAR IMAGE EURBAN
Site Assembly LIAM DEWAR IMAGE EURBAN
Site Assembly LIAM DEWAR IMAGE EURBAN
Site Assembly LIAM DEWAR IMAGE EURBAN
Site Assembly LIAM DEWAR IMAGE EURBAN
European CLT Production IMAGE TU GRAZ
LIAM DEWAR IMAGE LIVING ARCHITECTURE
LIAM DEWAR IMAGE LIVING ARCHITECTURE
Eurban Projects Project Breakdown by Package Value Breakdown of Projects 2012/13 2014/15 35% Contracts up to $200k CAD 50% Contracts from $200k to $1m CAD 15% Contracts over $1m CAD LIAM DEWAR
Mass Timber Projects
Henry Yorke Mann Architect 14 Mass Timber Residences, North Vancouver, 1958-1969 Integral natural materials, as opposed to synthetic, or plastic materials, are utilized for their timeless qualities, inherent safety and predictability, and their non-toxicity to humans. www.henryyorkemann.com IMAGE BARRY DOWNS
Clark Residence, North Vancouver, 1969 Henry Yorke Mann Senec & Mann IMAGE RICHARD OLSEN
Clark Residence, 1969 Henry Yorke Mann Senec & Mann IMAGE RICHARD OLSEN
Clark Residence, 1969 Henry Yorke Mann Senec & Mann IMAGE RICHARD OLSEN
Clark Residence, 1969 Henry Yorke Mann Senec & Mann Constructed of 4" solid fir planks splined to each other - treated on the exterior with a preservative and on the interior with a wax sealer. IMAGE HENRY YORKE MANN
Studio in Bristol, Wisconsin, USA, 1970 Alfred Caldwell IMAGE ARCHITECTURE AND NATURE
Studio in Bristol, Wisconsin, USA, 1970 Alfred Caldwell The four inch depth of wood is its own insulation, so the building is intrinsically warm in winter and cool in Summer. Werner Blaser Architecture and Nature: The Work of Alfred Caldwell IMAGE ARCHITECTURE AND NATURE
Colosseum, Rome, 80 AD Flavian Dynasty Skilled Roman Builders & 100,000 Prisoners 0.39m 3 stone / ft 2 area SOURCE: BUILDING THE COLLOSEUM IMAGE DUDVA WIKIMEDIA
Colosseum, Rome, 80 AD The invention of concrete enabled this massive building to be built quickly, efficiently and to great effect. Early example of off-site manufacture (stairs and seats) SOURCE: BUILDING THE COLLOSEUM
Norwich Open Academy, Norfolk, 2010 Sheppard Robson Ramboll UK KLH UK, 12 installers 0.03m 3 timber / ft 2 area (7.7%) IMAGE HUFTON + CROW
Tower Houses, Ireland & Scotland, 1400s JD O Donaghue IMAGE JG O DONOGHUE
Stadthaus, London, 2008 Waugh Thistleton Techniker KLH UK, 6 Austrians 0.036m 3 timber / ft 2 area (20% more) LIAM DEWAR IMAGE WAUGH THISTLETON
Carbon Offset British Citizen, 1970s British Citizen: Carbon Footprint = 789 t CO 2 e Crosslam Equivalent = 1,000 m 3 Building Equivalent = 32,300 ft 2 Housing Equivalent = 20 houses IMAGE STEVE COLEMAN
Timber Resource British Columbia Mountain Pine Beetle British Columbia: Dead Pine = 1 billion m 3 Crosslam Equivalent = 333 million m 3 Building Equivalent = 1 billion ft 2 Housing Equivalent = 620,000 houses Carbon Offset = 31,000 people IMAGE PROVINCE OF BRITISH COLUMBIA
Two Options More timber houses: Build timber in lieu of concrete; Build more houses (more completions / annum) More timber per house: Mass timber rather than timber frame; Heavy mass timber increase m 3 timber / ft 2 area Use woodfibre insulation, timber cladding, etc. IMAGE PROVINCE OF BRITISH COLUMBIA
Heavy Mass Timber Mass Timber Structure + Insulation + Cladding IMAGE EURBAN
Sunken House, London, 2006 Adjaye Associates Eurban, 4 installers 0.045m 3 timber / ft 2 area (50% more) IMAGE ED REEVE
Sunken House IMAGE EURBAN
Sunken House IMAGE EURBAN
Sunken House IMAGE EURBAN
Sunken House IMAGE EURBAN
Sunken House IMAGE EURBAN
Sunken House IMAGE EURBAN
Sunken House IMAGE MERK TIMBER
Sunken House IMAGE MERK TIMBER
Sunken House IMAGE MERK TIMBER
Sunken House IMAGE EURBAN
Sunken House IMAGE EURBAN
Sunken House IMAGE EURBAN
Sunken House IMAGE EURBAN
Sunken House
Sunken House
Sunken House
Sunken House IMAGE EURBAN
Sunken House IMAGE EURBAN
Sunken House LIAM DEWAR IMAGE EURBAN
Sunken House IMAGE ED REEVE
Sunken House IMAGE EURBAN
Sunken House
Sunken House IMAGE EURBAN
Sunken House IMAGE EURBAN
Sunken House IMAGE EURBAN
Sunken House IMAGE EURBAN
Sunken House IMAGE EURBAN
Sunken House IMAGE EURBAN
Sunken House IMAGE EURBAN
Sunken House IMAGE EURBAN
Sunken House
Sunken House IMAGE EURBAN
Sunken House IMAGE EURBAN
Sunken House IMAGE EURBAN
Sunken House IMAGE ED REEVE
Sunken House IMAGE ED REEVE
Sunken House IMAGE ED REEVE
Sunken House IMAGE ED REEVE
Sunken House, London, 2006 Project Data CLIENT Private ARCHITECT Adjaye Associates CONCRETE ENGINEER Techniker TIMBER ENGINEER Eurban MAIN CONTRACTOR None (Construction Management) TIMBER CONTRACTOR Eurbanm2 FLOOR AREA 1,615 ft 2 INSTALLATION PERIOD 1 week MATERIALS USED Crosslam / LVL / Cassettes MANUFACTURER Merk Timber COMPONENT THICKNESSES 160mm (Walls); 300mm (Roof) STORED CARBON 58 t CO2e
Architecture Archive, Somerset, 2014 Hugh Strange Architects Eurban, 4 installers 0.075m 3 timber / ft 2 area (150% more) IMAGE DAVID GRANDORGE
Architecture Archive IMAGE HUGH STRANGE ARCHITECTS
Architecture Archive IMAGE HUGH STRANGE ARCHITECTS
Architecture Archive IMAGE HUGH STRANGE ARCHITECTS
Architecture Archive IMAGE EURBAN
Architecture Archive IMAGE EURBAN
Architecture Archive IMAGE EURBAN
Architecture Archive IMAGE DAVID GRANDORGE
Architecture Archive IMAGE DAVID GRANDORGE
Architecture Archive IMAGE DAVID GRANDORGE
Architecture Archive IMAGE DAVID GRANDORGE
Architecture Archive IMAGE DAVID GRANDORGE
Architecture Archive IMAGE EURBAN
Architecture Archive IMAGE DAVID GRANDORGE
Architecture Archive IMAGE DAVID GRANDORGE
Architecture Archive IMAGE DAVID GRANDORGE
Architecture Archive IMAGE DAVID GRANDORGE
Architecture Archive IMAGE DAVID GRANDORGE
Winery, Vauvert, France, 1998 Perraudin Architecture Gilles Perraudin, 1 installer IMAGE PERRAUDIN ARCHITECTURE
Architecture Archive IMAGE DAVID GRANDORGE
Architecture Archive IMAGE DAVID GRANDORGE
Architecture Archive, Somerset, 2014 Project Data CLIENT Private ARCHITECT Hugh Strange Architects CONCRETE ENGINEER Price & Myers TIMBER ENGINEER Eurban MAIN CONTRACTOR None (Construction Management) TIMBER CONTRACTOR Eurban/ m2 FLOOR AREA 1,290 ft 2 INSTALLATION PERIOD 2 weeks MATERIALS USED Crosslam / Glulam MANUFACTURER Stora Enso Wood Products COMPONENT THICKNESSES 300mm (Walls); 420mm (Roof) STORED CARBON t CO2e