FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Regular Meeting Agenda Thursday, June 7, :30 PM

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Regular Meeting Agenda Thursday, June 7, 218 12:3 PM Call to Order 18-67-1 Approval of Agenda Invocation 18-67-12 Approval of May 24, 218 Minutes Citizen Time Fulton County Development Authority 18-67-13 SCP Oakley Owner LLC First Amendment Sandstone Creek ACLP LLC 18-67-14 Parkway West CC Inc Atlanta Development Authority 18-67-15 TSquare Owner LLC First Amendment Hart Square Fifth LLC Section Reports 18-67-2 Field Book Changes Page 4 18-67-21 Homestead Exemption Changes Page 6 18-67-22 Exemption Approvals Page 8 18-67-23 Exemption Denials Page 12 18-67-24 Conservation Use Approvals Page 15 18-67-25 Special Properties Page 26 18-67-26 Personal Property Administrative Changes Page 28 18-67-27 Residential Administrative Changes Page 29 18-67-28 217 Appeals To Superior Court Page 31 18-67-29 218 Appeal Value Changes (Personal Property) Page 34 18-67-21 218 Appeal Withdrawals (Personal Property) Page 35 Chief Appraiser s Report 18-67-3 Adoption of 218 Fulton-DeKalb City of Atlanta Resolution Discussion Items 18-67-D1 299C Properties (Morris) (Fitzgerald) 18-67-D2 Deactivated/Child Parcels 18-67-D3 Appeals Update 18-67-D4 Exemptions Update 18-67-D5 SmartFile and Remedy Force Update 18-67-D6 Email Addresses Executive Session

Fulton County Board of Assessors Regular Meeting Minutes May 24, 218 Member Attendance: Brandi Hunter-Lewis, Chair; Salma Ahmed, Vice-Chair; Michael Fitzgerald; Edward London; and Royce Morris. Staff Attendance: DeWayne Pinkney, Secretary/Deputy Chief Appraiser; Dwight Robinson, Chief Appraiser; Curtis Broden and Tara Parker, Deputy Chief Appraisers; Vincent Clark, Gaetjens Coreus, and Corey McDaniel, Appraisal Managers; Henry Brigham, Information Systems Manager; Jacqueline Davis, Administrative Coordinator, Reginald Elder, Database Specialist. Other Attendees: Cheryl Ringer and Kimberly Alexander, Fulton County Attorney s Office Chair Brandi Hunter-Lewis called the meeting to order at 12:35 p.m. Approval of Agenda 18-524-1 Motion to approve: Ahmed, Second: London. The motion passed unanimously. Invocation Brandi Hunter-Lewis gave the invocation. Approval of May 3, 218 Minutes 18-524-12 Motion to approve: Fitzgerald, Second: London. The motion passed unanimously. Citizen Time Edward McCormack 17-15-1-23-8 Mr. McCormack addressed the Board regarding his 217 appeal which was resolved. However, the data issues that were discovered on the property were never corrected in the system. Dwight Robinson stated that he has spoken with Mr. McCormack and will have staff get with him to ensure the data characteristics are corrected. Section Reports Motion Second Vote 18-524-2 Field Book Changes London Ahmed Unanimous 18-524-21 Homestead Exemption Changes Fitzgerald Ahmed Unanimous 18-524-22 Exemption Approvals Fitzgerald London Unanimous 18-524-23 Exemption Denials Ahmed London Unanimous 18-524-24 Conservation Use Approvals London Fitzgerald Unanimous 18-524-25 Conservation Use Breach Fitzgerald London Unanimous 18-524-25 Personal Property Administrative Changes London Ahmed Unanimous 18-524-26 Personal Property Releases Ahmed London Unanimous 18-524-27 Residential Administrative Changes Fitzgerald London Unanimous Discussion Items 18-524-D1 Homestead Tax Deferral 48-5-72 (Morris) Cheryl Ringer and Stephen Pruitt gave an overview of how this tax deferral works and explained that it was a function of the Tax Commissioner s office. 18-524-D2 Update: SmartFile and Remedy Force (Fitzgerald) DeWayne Pinkney gave an update on SmartFile and reported that the Appeal, Data Gathering and Address Change modules are working fine. Dwight Robinson stated that there were some technical issues with Remedy Force, and the Information Technology department is working to get it back online. Fulton BOA Meeting - 6-7-18 - Page 2

Chief Appraiser Report A copy of the report outline and attachments are included with the minutes of this meeting. 1. 218 Assessment Notices Mailed May 22, 218 as planned and posted to the website. 2. Town Hall/Media Outreach There are a few community meetings scheduled in the next couple of weeks. Staff will be present to answer appraisal related questions. 3. Department Newsletter A department newsletter has been implemented to keep staff informed of important issues and events. The newsletter will be published quarterly. 4. Service Legend Michelle Smith who is a supervisor in the Field Book division was recently selected as a Service Legend for providing excellent customer service. 5. Market Modeling Preliminary meetings have been held to begin review of adding a market modeling module to IAS. More information will be provided as this project moves forward. 6. News Articles Recent news articles regarding tax assessments are included in this report. 7. Performance Review Report An analysis and response to the PRB report will be completed over the next few weeks. 8. Analysis of Values of Properties Sold in 215 This analysis has begun but is not yet completed. 9. Dwight Robinson provided the Board with a list of the commercial parcels where the 299C value freeze was removed. Executive Session (1:39 p.m. 2:1 p.m.) Motion for executive session to discuss litigation: Fitzgerald, Second: Ahmed. The motion passed unanimously. Motion to return to regular session: Ahmed, Second: London. The motion passed unanimously. Adjournment Motion to adjourn: Fitzgerald, Second: London. The meeting was adjourned at 2:5 p.m. Submitted By: S. DeWayne Pinkney, Secretary Board of Assessors Minutes May 24, 218 Page 2 of 2 Fulton BOA Meeting - 6-7-18 - Page 3

6/5/218 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 7 June, 218 HT536GAFUL FBC Field Book Changes COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES PARCEL ID YEAR APPRAISER OWNER NAME REASON NOTES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE 1 14-8-7-7-2 217 MS TECHNOLOGY SQUARE LLC Land consolidation CONSOLIDATED PER PLAT BOOK 394-36 643, -643, 2 22-546-1261-81-8 218 MS RCH CAPITAL LLC Ownership correction 2,741,5 2,741,5 1 Fulton BOA Meeting - 6-7-18 - Page 4

6/5/218 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 7 June, 218 HT536GAFUL FBC Field Book Changes RESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES PARCEL ID YEAR APPRAISER OWNER NAME REASON NOTES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE 3 7-6-141-5-4 218 MS LITTLE JOHN H & CASSES KATHLEEN L Ownership correction 34, 34, 4 14-19-2-74-3 218 MS PETERSON GARY Ownership correction 288,4 288,4 2 Fulton BOA Meeting - 6-7-18 - Page 5

6/5/218 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 7 June, 218 HT536GAFUL HEC Homestead Exemption Changes HOMESTEAD DIVISION PARCEL ID YEAR APPRAISER OWNER NAME REASON NOTES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE 1 14-48-9-59-2 215 FB LENNARD PAUL R & ARZEWSKI CECYLIA Homestead removal PER T/P REQUEST DUPLICATE H/E 142,7 142,7 2 14-48-9-59-2 216 FB LENNARD PAUL R & ARZEWSKI CECYLIA Homestead removal PER T/P REQUEST DUPLICATE H/E 142,7 142,7 3 14-48-9-59-2 217 FB LENNARD PAUL R & ARZEWSKI CECYLIA Homestead removal PER T/P REQUEST DUPLICATE H/E 142,7 142,7 4 14-177-15-11-8 217 FB ROBINSON CARLISS L Continuing occupancy OWNERSHIP CHANGED IN ERROR 3,6 3,6 5 14-18-9-49-1 215 FB CANTRELL LULA ET AL Homestead removal VACANT LOT 4,5 4,5 6 14-18-9-49-1 216 FB CANTRELL LULA ET AL Homestead removal VACANT LOT 4,5 4,5 7 14-18-9-49-1 217 FB CANTRELL LULA ET AL Homestead removal VACANT LOT 4,5 4,5 1 Fulton BOA Meeting - 6-7-18 - Page 6

6/5/218 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 7 June, 218 HT536GAFUL HEC Homestead Exemption Changes HOMESTEAD DIVISION PARCEL ID YEAR OWNER NAME REASON NOTES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE 8 17-62-3-96-4 215 FB HALDAR LISA M & ANKUR Continuing occupancy REINSTATE 386,2 386,2 9 17-62-3-96-4 216 FB HALDAR LISA M & ANKUR Continuing occupancy REINSTATE 386,2 386,2 1 17-62-3-96-4 217 FB HALDAR LISA M & ANKUR Continuing occupancy REINSTATE 386,2 386,2 11 17-2- LL-18-3 216 FB TILLEM JERRY & YVONNE Homestead removal PER CLOSING ATTY. 2,3, 2,3, 12 17-2- LL-18-3 217 FB TILLEM JERRY & YVONNE Homestead removal PER CLOSING ATTY. 2,3, 2,3, 2 Fulton BOA Meeting - 6-7-18 - Page 7

5/31/218 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 7 June, 18 HT536GAFUL ME Exemption Approvals EXEMPT PROPERTIES PARCEL ID YEAR APPRAISER OWNER NAME REASON NOTES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE 1 17-183- LL-2 3-4 CHRIST CHURCH OF ATLANTA INC 218 Make Exempt PART OF THE CHURCH CAMPUS 73 2,438,8 2,438,8 2 22-448-113-81-9 CITY OF ALPHARETTA GEORGIA & THE CITY OF 218 Make Exempt PUBLIC PROPERTY 73 599,3 599,3 3 22-448 -113-82-7 CITY OF ALPHARETTA GEORGIA & THE CITY OF 218 Make Exempt PUBLIC PROPERTY 73 319,7 319,7 1 Fulton BOA Meeting - 6-7-18 - Page 8

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form Appeal Correction Exempt ME Tax Year(s): 218 Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Christ Church of Atlanta Inc 17-183- LL-23-4 Property Location: Howell Mill Rd Tax District: 5 Property Class: E2 Neighborhood: 1732 Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: Dwelling Characteristic Changes Year Built: Effective Age: Story Height: Square Feet Living Area: Basement (Finished Area): Basement (Unfin. Area): Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Garage: Attic: Condition & Desirability: Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: Percent Complete: Land Information Square Feet: Acres: 6.696 6.696 Exemptions & Special Assessments Public Prop. Conservation Use X Religious Preferential Asmt. Charitable Historic Rehabilitated X Non-Profit Transitional Educational Notes & Recommendations Env. Sensitive The taxpayer submitted an exempt questionnaire for tax year 218 in which the property owner is described as a religious group, a 51(c)3, and a non profit organization. The property was previously four parcels which were acquired in December of 217. The property has since consolidated into a single parcel for tax year 218 which contains two residential structures, a pool house, an outdoor swimming pool, a basketball and playground area, walking trails and additional parking space. Although the two residential structures are vacant, the owner states that they use the pool house club for meetings and bible study. They also utilize the over flow parking, the play ground and the trails. The owner already had special permit granted by the city of Atlanta for a church with accessory childcare and columbarium uses that was adopted for the property prior to the purchase on October 16th, 217. The subject is contiguous to the church campus and the main sanctuary. The property is now integrated into the church campus, and it should be exempt as a place of religious worship. Recommendation : Grant Exempt Status for tax year 218 Property Valuation Summary Special Sat. Recommended Current Value Value Value Land 791,9 791,9 Building 1,646,9 1,646,9 Field Review Date: 5/9/18 Date Submitted: 5/17/18 Appraisal Staff: Gaetjens Coreus G: Appraisal Manager: Gaetjens Coreus G:, Accessories Total 2,438,8 2,438,8 Form SRF-RE (Rev. 9/6) Dep. Chief Appraiser: Fulton BOA Meeting - 6-7-18 - Page 9 Chief Appraiser: Dwight Robinson ~ v '

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form Appeal Correction Exempt ME Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: 218 City of Alpharetta Georgia 22-448-11 3-81-9 149 Mayfield Rd 1 E1 24 Dwelling Characteristic Changes Year Built: Effective Age: Story Height: Square Feet Living Area: Basement (Finished Area): Basement (Unfin. Area): Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Garage: Attic: Condition & Desirability: Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: Percent Complete: II Exemptions & Special Assessments X Public Prop. Conservation Use Religious Charitable Non-Profit Educational Preferential Asmt. Historic Rehabilitated Transitional Env. Sensitive New Parcel from a Land Split Notes & Recommendations This parcel was transfered to the city of Alpharetta in October of 217. The City of Alpharetta owns and used this property for public use as of January 1, 218; therefore, it should have been exempt as public property for the 218 tax year. Recommendation : Grant exempt status for tax year 218 Land Information Square Feet: Acres: 1.9653 1.9653 Property Valuation Summary Special Sat. Recommended Current Value Value Value Land 47,8 47,8 Building 191,5 191,5 Field Review Date: N/A Date Submitted: 5/31/18 Appraisal Staff: Gaetjens Cereus ~ Appraisal Manager: Gaetjens Cereus ~ Accessories Dep. Chief Appraiser: Total 599,3 599,3 Chief Appraiser: Form SRF RE (Rev. 9/6) Fulton BOA Meeting - 6-7-18 - Page 1 Dwight Robinson fi..h ~

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form Appeal Correction Exempt ME ----- Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: 218 City of Alpharetta Georgia 22-448-113-82-7 148 Mayfield Rd 1 E1 22 Dwelling Characteristic Changes Exemptions & Special Assessments Year Built: Effective Age: Story Height: Square Feet Living Area: Basement (Finished Area): Basement (Unfin. Area): Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Garage: Attic: Condition & Desirability: Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: Percent Complete: X Public Prop. Conservation Use Religious Charitable Non-Profit Educational Preferential Asmt. Historic Rehabilitated Transitional Env. Sensitive New Parcel from a Land Split Notes & Recommendations This parcel was transfered to the city of Alpharetta in October of 217. The City of Alpharetta owns and used this property for public use as of January 1, 218; therefore, it should have been exempt as public property for the 218 tax year. Recommendation : Grant exempt status for tax year 218 Land Information Square Feet: Acres: 2.3 2.3 Property Valuation Summary Special Sat. Recommended Current Value Value Value Land 213,8 213,8 Building 15,9 15,9 Field Review Date: N/A Date Submitted: 5/31/18 Appraisal Staff: Gaetjens Cereus ~ Appraisal Manager: Gaetjens Cereus (ft.._ Accessories Total 319,7 319,7 Dep. Chief Appraiser: Chief Appraiser: Dwight Robinso~,$ A ~ Form SRF-RE (Rev. 9/6) Fulton BOA Meeting - 6-7-18 - Page 11

5/31/218 PARCEL ID YEAR APPRAISER BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 7 June, 18 OWNER NAME REASON NOTES EXM Exemption Denials EXEMPT PROPERTIES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE HT536GAFUL Exemption Denial 1 12-216 - 518-46-5 NORTH FULTON COMMUNITY CHARITIES INC 218 PROPERTY IS NOT IN USE 73 869,1 869,1 2 14-119-2-22- 1 MONROE MARVA M 217 PROPERTY OWNED BY INDIVIDUAL 73 14, 14, 1 Fulton BOA Meeting - 6-7-18 - Page 12

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form Appeal Correction Exempt EXM Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: 218 North Fulton Community Charities Inc. 12-216-518-46-5 11275 Elkin Rd 45 C3 C19 Dwelling Characteristic Changes Exemptions & Special Assessments Public Prop. Conservation Use Year Built: X Religious Preferential Asmt. Effective Age: Charitable Historic Rehabilitated Story Height: Non-Profit Transitional Square Feet Living Area: Educational Env. Sensitive Basement (Finished Area): Basement (Unfin. Area): Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Garage: Attic: Condition & Desirability: Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: Percent Complete: Notes & Recommendations The property owner submitted an exempt questionnaire for tax year 218 requesting the exemption based on the owner being a non-profit 51 ( c)3 entity. The subject is an old daycare recently acquire by the owner on December 27, 217. Although the owner is intended to use the property to further the mission of their non-profit which is to educate, to provide development and assistance programs in order to enhance and expand their ability to serve residents needs including emergency financial assistance, food, clothing and life skills classes, but the property was not being used for purely public charity as of January 1 of 218. The owner also confirmed that the facility is undergoing renovation to accommodate their need and they plan to open the facility in summer of 218. Land Information Square Feet: Acres: 1.53 1.53 Recommendation: Deny exemption for tax year 218. Property Valuation Summary Special Asmt. Current Value Value Recommended Value Land 413,2 413,2 Building 455,9 455,9 Accessories Total 869,1 869,1 Field Review Date: Date Submitted: Appraisal Staff: Appraisal Manager: Dep. Chief Appraiser: Chief Appraiser: n/a 5/16/18 Gaetjens Coreus (k Gaetjens Coreus Dwight Robinson Gt_ f\ fit,;lv I '(/}f1 Form SRF-RE (Rev. 9/6) Fulton BOA Meeting - 6-7-18 - Page 13

-... ~.. - _ --..,_ lit...:....ll ~... -- --- Tax Year(s): 217 Appeal FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form Correction Exempt EXM Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: Monroe, Marva M 14-119-2-22-1 989 Peeples St NW 5 R1 145.2 Dwelling Characteristic Changes Exemptions & Special Assessments Public Prop. Conservation Use Year Built: Religious Preferential Asmt. Effective Age: Charitable Historic Rehabilitated Story Height: X Non-Profit Transitional Square Feet Living Area: Educational Env. Sensitive Basement (Finished Area): Basement (Unfin. Area): Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Garage: Attic: Condition & Desirability: Cost & Design Factor: Notes & Recommendations Taxpayer submitted an Exempt Property Questionnaire for tax year 217 requesting an exemption based on the property owner being a non-profit organization. The current owner on record isn't in the name of the organization, but in the name of an individual (Marva Monroe). Also, per the questionnaire, the property is not open to the public. Al so, based on what has been provided, the property does not appear to be used for charitable pursuit. Based upon this information the property does not qualify for exempt status under Georgia law. Quality Grade: Percent Complete: Recommendation: Deny exemption for tax year 217. Land Information Square Feet: Acres:.1655.1655 Property Valuation Summary Special Asmt. Recommended Current Value Value Value Field Review Date: N/A Date Submitted: 5/17/18 Land 22,6 22,6 Building 117,4 117,4 Accessories Total 14, 14, Form SRF-RE (Rev. 9/6} Appraisal Staff: Fulton BOA Meeting - 6-7-18 - Page 14 Kathryn Byrer ' Appraisal Manager: Gaetjens Cereus a Dep. Chief Appraiser: A9~ Chief Appraiser: Dwight Robinson {J(!If. v

5/31/218 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 7 June, 18 HTS36GAFUL CVA CUVA Approvals EXEMPT PROPERTIES PARCEL ID YEAR APPRAISER OWNER NAME REASON NOTES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE 1 7-182-15-27- HOBGOOD INVESTMENTS TRUST THE 218 CUVA Approved 218 CUVA RENEWAL 73 18,8 18,8 2 7-182-15-74-2 HOBGOOD INVESTMENTS TRUST THE 218 CUVA Approved 218 CUVA RENEWAL 73 38,9 38,9 3 7-25-14-15-9 HOBGOOD INVESTMENTS TRUST THE 218 CUVA Approved 218 CUVA RENEWAL 73 339,6 339,6 4 7-41 - 159-31- GOSDIN NEAL MICHAEL 218 CUVA Approved 218 CUVA RENEWAL 73 249,9 249,9 5 8-5-5-44-1 WEINSTEIN MARK 218 CUVA Approved 218 ADDITION TO EXISITNG CUVA 73 17,4 17,4 6 8-31-132-8 - KENNETH K BRYANT & ELAINE S BRYANT 218 CUVA Approved 218 CUVA RENEWAL 9 174,3 2, -172,3 7 9F-232-11-28-5 BROWN RALPH N 218 CUVA Approved 218 CUVA RENEWAL 73 75,5 1,9-73,6 1 Fulton BOA Meeting - 6-7-18 - Page 15

5/31/218 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 7 June, 18 HT536GAFUL CVA CUVA Approvals EXEMPT PROPERTIES PARCEL ID YEAR OWNER NAME REASON NOTES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE 8 9F-27-124-29-4 218 73 ALDREDGE SARA H CUVA Approved NEW CUVA FOR 218 6,7 6,7 9 22-42-268-18-2 THACKER RANDALL J & DEBORAH H 218 CUVA Approved 218 NEW CUVA 73 21, 517,9 37,9 2 Fulton BOA Meeting - 6-7-18 - Page 16

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form Appeal Correction Exempt CVA ---- Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: 218 HOBGOOD INVESTMENTS TRUST THE 7-182-15-27- Hobgood Rd 55 V3 76 Dwelling Characteristic Changes Exemptions & Special Assessments Year Built: Effective Age: Story Height: Square Feet Living Area: Basement (Finished Area): Basement (Unfin. Area) : Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Garage: Attic: Condition & Desirability: Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: Percent Complete: Land Information Public Prop. X Conservation Use Religious Charitable Non-Profit Educational Notes & Recommendations Preferential Asmt. Historic Rehabilitated Transitional Env. Sensitive Taxpayer submitted an Application for Current Use Assessment of Bona Fide Agricultural Property. This property was previously under a covenant which expired on 12-31-217. This is a single covenant which includes 3 parcels totaling for about 65 acres. This parcel consists of 1.67 acres of pasture and.6548 acres of timber. This property is used for pasture. The requirement for the CUVA Program based on the rules and regulations of the Department of Revenue of the State of Georgia are as follows: The primary use of the property shall include, but not be limited to: a) raising, harvesting or storing crops. b) production of aquaculture, horticulture, floriculture, forestry, dairy, livestock, poultry and apiarian products. The property meets CUVA land requirements (b) above. Square Feet: Acres: 1.7218 - - Recommendation: The Board of Assessors grant CUVA. This is a Renewal covenant beginning January 1, 218 ending December 31, 227. Property Valuation Summary Current F Recommended Special Asmt. Recommended Value FValue Value Sp Asmt Value Land 18, 18, 1,651 Building Accessories Total 18, 18, 1,651 Field Review Date: 5/18/18 Date Submitted: 5/21/18 Appraisal Staff: Gaetjens Cereus Gc Appraisal Manager: Gaetjens Cereus Ct.- Dep. Chief Appraiser: Tara Parker w/1~ Chief Appraiser: Dwight Robinson ~' Form SRF-RE (Rev. 9/6) Fulton BOA Meeting - 6-7-18 - Page 17

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form Appeal Correction Exempt CVA Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: 218 HOBGOOD INVESTMENTS TRUST THE 7-182-15-74-2 Hobgood Rd 55 V5 76 Dwelling Characteristic Changes Year Built: Effective Age: Story Height: Square Feet Living Area: Basement (Finished Area): Basement (Unfin. Area): Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Garage: Attic: Condition & Desirability: Exemptions & Special Assessments t-----public Prop. X Conservation Use ---- t-----religious Preferential Asmt. t-----charitable Historic Rehabilitated 1-----Non-Profit Transitional t-----educational Env. Sensitive Notes & Recommendations Taxpayer submitted an Application for Current Use Assessment of Bona Fide Agricultural Property. This property was previously under a covenant which expired on 12-31 -217. This is a single covenant which includes 3 contiguous parcels totaling for about 69 acres. The subject parcel consists of a pond of 5 acres and 27 acres of timber. This property is used for timber. Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: Percent Complete: Land Information The requirement for the CUVA Program based on the rules and regulations of the Department of Revenue of the State of Georgia are as follows: The primary use of the property shall include, but not be limited to: a) raising, harvesting or storing crops. b) production of aquaculture, horticulture, floriculture, forestry, dairy, livestock, poultry and apiarian products. The property meets CUVA land requirements (b) above. Square Feet: Acres: 32.18 Recommendation: The Board of Assessors grant CUVA. This is a Renewal covenant beginning January 1, 218 ending December 31, 227. Property Valuation Summary Current F Recommended Special Asmt. Value FValue Value Land 38,9 38,9 Recommended Sp Asmt Value 22,186 Field Review Date: 5/18/18 Date Submitted: 5/21/18 Appraisal Staff: Gaetjens Coreus G_ Building Appraisal Manager:...:G::.:a::.:e:.:llc.e:::n:=s...:C:.:o:.:r.=e.::.us=--...lo.li...------ Accessories Total 38,9 38,9 22,186 Dep. Chief Appraiser: Chief Appraiser: Tara Parker ~~~~~ln~~----- Form SRF -RE (Rev. 9/6) Fulton BOA Meeting - 6-7-18 - Page 18

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form Appeal Correction Exempt CVA ----- Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: 218 HOBGOOD INVESTMENTS TRUST THE 7-25-14-15-9 Hobgood Rd 55 V5 77 Dwelling Characteristic Changes Year Built: Effective Age: Story Height: Square Feet Living Area: Basement (Finished Area): Basement (Unfin. Area): Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Garage: Attic: Condition & Desirability: 1------Public Prop. 1-----Religious I-----Charitable 1-----Non-Profit 1-----Educational Exemptions & Special Assessments X ---- Conservation Use Preferential Asmt. Historic Rehabilitated Transitional Notes & Recommendations Env. Sensitive Taxpayer submitted an Application for Current Use Assessment of Bona Fide Agricultural Property. This property was previously under a covenant which expired on 12-31-217. This is a single covenant which includes 3 parcels totaling for about 65 acres. This parcel consists of 1.5892 acres of pasture and 33.78 acres of timber. This property is used for timber. Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: Percent Complete: Land Information The requirement for the CUVA Program based on the rules and regulations of the Department of Revenue of the State of Georgia are as follows: The primary use of the property shall include, but not be limited to: a) raising, harvesting or storing crops. b) production of aquaculture, horticulture, floriculture, forestry, dairy, livestock, poultry and apiarian products. The property meets CUVA land requirements (b) above. Square Feet: Acres: 35.37 Recommendation: The Board of Assessors grant CUVA. This Is a Renewal covenant beginning January 1, 218 ending December 31, 227. Property Valuation Summary Current F Recommended Special Asmt. Recommended Value FValue Value Sp Asmt Value Land 339,6 339,6 33,399 Field Review Date: 5/18/18 Date Submitted: 5/21/18 Appraisal Staff: Gaetjens Coreus Gc Building Accessories Total 339,6 339,6 33,399 Appraisal Manager: Dep. Chief Appraiser: Chief Appraiser: Gaetjens Coreus Tara Parker Dwight Robinson Form SRF-RE (Rev. 9/6) Fulton BOA Meeting - 6-7-18 - Page 19

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form Appeal Correction Exempt CVA ---- Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: 218 GOSDIN NEAL MICHAEL 7-41 -159-31- Gullatt Rd 25 vs 78 Dwelling Characteristic Changes Exemptions & Special Assessments Year Built: Effective Age: Story Height: Square Feet Living Area: Basement (Finished Area): Basement (Unfin. Area): Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Garage: Attic: Condition & Desirability: Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: Percent Complete: Public Prop. X Conservation Use Religious Charitable Non-Profit Educational Notes & Recommendations Preferential Asmt. Historic Rehabilitated Transitional Env. Sensitive Taxpayer submitted an Application for Current Use Assessment of Bona Fide Agricultural Property. This property was previously under a covenant which expired on 12-31-217. This parcel consists of 19.5 acres of pasture and 14.58 acres of timber. This property is used for managing livestock and storing crops. The requirement for the CUVA Program based on the rules and regulations of the Department of Revenue of the State of Georgia are as follows: The primary use of the property shall include, but not be limited to: a) raising, harvesting or storing crops. b) production of aquaculture, horticulture, floriculture, forestry, dairy, livestock, poultry and apiarian products. The property meets CUVA land requirements (b) above. Land Information Square Feet: Acres: 35.26 35.26 Recommendation: The Board of Assessors grant CUVA. This is a Renewal covenant beginning January 1, 218 ending December 31, 227. Property Valuation Summary Current F Recommended Special Asmt. Value FValue Value Land 198, 198, Building 51,9 51,9 Accessories Total 249,9 249,9 Field Review Date: 4/27/18 Recommended Value Date Submitted: 5/18/18 28,391 Appraisal Staff: Gaetjens Coreus a 51,9 Appraisal Manager: Gaetjens Coreus Q Dep. Chief Appraiser: Tara Parker :tt? A/J 8,291 Chief Appraiser: v..(\)f/( Dwight Robinson, J v Form SRF-RE (Rev. 9/6) Fulton BOA Meeting - 6-7-18 - Page 2

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form Appeal Correction Exempt CVA ---- Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: 218 WEINSTEIN MARK 8-5-5-44-1 1245 Henry Mill Rd 65 V4 82 Dwelling Characteristic Changes Public Prop. X Conservation Use Year Built: Religious Preferential Asmt. Effective Age: Charitable Historic Rehabilitated Story Height: Non-Profit Transitional Square Feet Living Area: Educational Env. Sensitive Basement (Finished Area): Basement (Unfin. Area): Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Garage: Attic: Condition & Desirability: Notes & Recommendations Taxpayer submitted an Application for Current Use Assessment of Bona Fide Agricultural Property. This property was purchased by Mr. Weinstein in May of 217. It is contiguous to an existing 4 parcels 1 covenant owns by Mr. Weinstein's totaling for 196.7 acres that began in 214. This newly acquired parcel will be added to the existing covenant which makes it 5 parcel 1 covenant. Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: Percent Complete: Land Information The requirement for the CUVA Program based on the rules and regulations of the Department of Revenue of the State of Georgia are as follows: The primary use of the property shall include, but not be limited to: a) raising, harvesting or storing crops. b) production of aquaculture, horticulture, floriculture, forestry, dairy, livestock, poultry and apiarian products. The property meets CUVA land requirements (b) above. Square Feet: Acres: 3.3 3.3 Recommendation: The Board of Assessors grant CUVA. This is an addition to existing covenant beginning January 1, 214 ending December 31, 223. Property Valuation Summary Current F Recommended Special Asmt. Value FValue Value Recommended Sp Asmt Value Field Review Date: 5/25/18 Date Submitted: 5/31/18 Land 17,4 17,4 2,71 Appraisal Staff: Gaetjens Coreus Building Appraisal Manager: Accessories Total 17,4 17,4 2,71 Dep. Chief Appraiser: Chief Appraiser: Tara Parker -----~~~~7----- Form SRF RE (Rev. 9/6) Fulton BOA Meeting - 6-7-18 - Page 21

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form Appeal Correction Exempt CVA ---- Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: 218 Bryant, Kenneth K & Elaine S 8-31-132-8- Campbellton Redwine Rd 65 VS 83 Dwelling Characteristic Changes Year Built: Effective Age: Story Height: Square Feet Living Area: Basement (Finished Area): Basement (Unfin. Area): Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Garage: Attic: Condition & Desirability: Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: Percent Complete: Land Information Square Feet: Acres: 15.782 15.782 Public Prop. X Conservation Use Religious Charitable Non-Profit Educational Notes & Recommendations Preferential Asmt. Historic Rehabilitated Transitional Env. Sensitive Taxpayer submitted an Application for Current Use Assessment of Bona Fide Agricultural Property. This property was previously under a covenant which expired on 12-31-217. This parcel consists of 9.8366 acres of pasture and 5.9454 acres of timber. This property is used for managing livestock and producing plants and trees. The requirement for the CUVA Program based on the rules and regulations of the Department of Revenue of the State of Georgia are as follows: The primary use of the property shall include, but not be limited to: a) raising, harvesting or storing crops. b) production of aquaculture, horticulture, floriculture, forestry, dairy, livestock, poultry and apiarian products. The property meets CUVA land requirements (b) above. Recommendation: The Board of Assessors grant CUVA. This is a Renewal covenant beginning January 1, 218 ending December 31, 227. Property Valuation Summary Current F Recommended Special Asmt. Value FValue Value Land 172,3 172,3 Building 2, 2, Recommended Sp Asmt Value 16,426 2, Field Review Date: 5/24/18 Date Submitted: 5/3/18 Appraisal Staff: Appraisal Manager: Kathryn Byrd rj!'2 Accessories Total 174,3 174,3 18,426 Dep. Chief Appraiser: Chief Appraiser: Tara Parker -----~~~~~~---- Form SRF RE (Rev. 9/6) Fulton BOA Meeting - 6-7-18 - Page 22

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form Appeal Correction ---- Exempt CVA Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: 218 BROWN RALPH N 9F-232-1 1-28-5 Evans Dr 5 vs 9611 Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: Dwelling Characteristic Changes 1------Public Prop. ;.X.;: Conservation Use Year Built: 1------Religious Preferential Asmt. Effective Age: I-----Charitable Historic Rehabilitated Story Height: 1------Non-Profit Transitional Square Feet Living Area: 1------Educational Env. Sensitive Basement (Finished Area): Basement (Unfin. Area): Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Garage: Attic: Notes & Recommendations Taxpayer submitted an Application for Current Use Assessment of Bona Fide Agricultural Property. This property was previously under a covenant which expired on 12-31 -217. This parcel consists of 7.6147 acres of pasture and 22.149 acres of timber. This property is used for wildlife habitat and the production of aquaculture. Condition & Desirability: Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: Percent Complete: The requirement for the CUVA Program based on the rules and regulations of the Department of Revenue of the State of Georgia are as follows: The primary use of the property shall include, but not be limited to: a) raising, harvesting or storing crops. b) production of aquaculture, horticulture, floriculture, forestry, dairy, livestock, poultry and apiarian products. The property meets CUVA land requirements (b) above. Square Feet: Land Information Recommendation: The Board of Assessors grant CUVA. This is a Renewal covenant beginning January 1, 218 ending December 31, 227. Acres: 29.63 Property Valuation Summary Current F Recommended Special Asmt. Value FValue Value Land 73,6 73,6 Building 1,9 1,9 Accessories Total 75,5 75,5 Recommended Value 27,421 1,9 29,321 Field Review Date: 4/27/18 Date Submitted: 5/21/18 Appraisal Staff: Kathryn Byrd Y Appraisal Manager: Dep. Chief Appraiser: Tara Parker - --------~~~~~------- Chief Appraiser: Form SRF-RE (Rev. 9/6) Fulton BOA Meeting - 6-7-18 - Page 23

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form Appeal Correction Exempt CVA Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: 218 ALDREDGE SARA H 9F-27-124-29-4 Stonewall T eli Rd 55 V5 966 r Dwelling Characteristic Changes Exemptions & Special Assessments f-----public Prop. :X_; Conservation Use Year Built: Effective Age: Story Height: Square Feet Living Area: Basement (Finished Area): Basement (Unfin. Area): 1------Religious f-----charitable 1------Non-Profit 1------Educational Preferential Asmt. Historic Rehabilitated Transitional Env. Sensitive Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Garage: Attic: Condition & Desirability: Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: Percent Complete: Notes & Recommendations Taxpayer submitted an Application for Current Use Assessment of Bona Fide Agricultural Property. This is a new covenant. This parcel consists of 11 acres of timber. This property is used for timberxxxx. The requirement for the CUVA Program based on the rules and regulations of the Department of Revenue of the State of Georgia are as follows: The primary use of the property shall include, but not be limited to: a) raising, harvesting or storing crops. b) production of aquaculture, horticulture, floriculture, forestry, dairy, livestock, poultry and apiarian products. The property meets CUVA land requirements (b) above. Land Information Recommendation: The Board of Assessors grant CUVA. This is a New covenant beginning January 1, 218 ending December 31, 227. Square Feet: Acres: 11 Property Valuation Summary Current F Recommended Special Asmt. Value FValue Value Land 6,7 6,7 Recommended Sp Asmt Value 1,367 Field Review Date: 5/23/18 Date Submitted: 5/24/18 Appraisal Staff: Gaetjens Coreus <k. Building Appraisal Manager: Gaetjens Cereus Accessories Dep. Chief Appraiser: Tara Parker Total 6,7 6,7 1,367 Chief Appraiser: Dwight Robinson Form SRF-RE {Rev. 9/6) Fulton BOA Meeting - 6-7-18 - Page 24

FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form Appeal Correction Exempt CVA Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property Location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: 218 Thacker, Randall J & Deborah H 22-42-268-18-2 Birmingham Hwy 56 V4 227 Dwelling Characteristic Changes Year Built: Effective Age: Story Height: Square Feet Living Area: Basement (Finished Area): Basement (Unfin. Area): Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Garage: Attic: Condition & Desirability: Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: Percent Complete: Land Information t-----public Prop.!-----Religious!-----Charitable 1-----Non-Profit!-----Educational Exemptions & Special Assessments X Conservation Use --- Preferential Asmt. Historic Rehabilitated Transitional Env. Sensitive Notes & Recommendations Taxpayer submitted an Application for Current Use Assessment of Bona Fide Agricultural Property. This parcel is newty created from a split to remove the residence. The remaining 7.55 acres is used as a farm where the owner has over 33 goats, a flock of 6 chickens and other livestock on the property. This parcel consists of 5.66 acres of pasture and 1.893 acres of timber. This property is used for feeding, breeding, and managing livestock. The requirement for the CUVA Program based on the rules and regulations of the Department of Revenue of the State of Georgia are as follows: The primary use of the property shall include, but not be limited to: a) raising, harvesting or storing crops. b) production of aquaculture, horticulture, floriculture, forestry, dairy, livestock, poultry and apiarian products. The property meets CUVA land requirements (b) above. Square Feet: Acres: 7.553 Recommendation: The Board of Assessors grant CUVA. This is a New covenant beginning January 1, 218 ending December 31, 227. Property Valuation Summary Current F Recommended Special Asmt. Value FValue Value Recommended Sp Asmt Value Field Review Date: 5/25/18 Date Submitted: 5/29/18 Land 517,9 517,9 8,16 Appraisal Staff: Kathryn Byr/l!J Building Appraisal Manager: Gaetjens Coreus Accessories Dep. Chief Appraiser: Tara Parker Total 517,9 517,9 8,16 Chief Appraiser: Dwight Robinson Form SRF RE (Rev. 9/6) Fulton BOA Meeting - 6-7-18 - Page 25

5/31/218 PARCEL I D YEAR APPRAISER BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 7 June, 18 OWNER NAME REASON NOTES SP Special Properties Agenda EXEMPT PROPERTIES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE HT536GAFUL 1 14-12-2-64-1 LEMMOND LEANNE M 218 Historic approved MARK HISTORIC 73 32,5 32,5 1 Fulton BOA Meeting - 6-7-18 - Page 26

- ~.- ~ ---- -- IL: -... ~ ~~ -- -- Appeal FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff Review Form Correction Exempt SP Tax Year(s): Property Owner: Parcel Identification: Property location: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Subdivision Name: Agent I Tax Rep: 218 Lemmond Leanne M 14-12-2-64-1 881 Memorial Dr # 315 5 H3 14268 Dwelling Characteristic Changes Exemptions & Special Assessments Public Prop. Conservation Use Year Built: Religious Preferrential Asmt. Effective Age: Charitable Historic Rehabilitated Story Height: Square Feet Living Area: Basement (Finished Area): Basement (Unfin. Area): Basement (Rec. Room): Heating & Air: Garage: Attic: Condition & Desirability: Cost & Design Factor: Quality Grade: Percent Complete: land Information Square Feet: Acres:.352.352 Non-Profit Educational Landmark Historic Notes & Recommendations Transitional Env. Sensitive Property owner submitted an approved Application for Landmark Historic from the Atlanta Urban Design Commission. The subject property has been verified as meeting the requirements needed to be designated as landmark historic property. The property has been listed on the National Register of Historic Places. The property has been certified by the Atlanta Urban Commission as having exceptional architectural, cultural or historical significance. The City of Atlanta has adopted an ordinance authorizing such preferential assessment for Landmark Historic property. The subject property includes less than 2 acres of surrounding land. The property was purchased in September of 214 for $23,. The frozen value shall be the greater of the two, previous year fair market value or the purchase price. the previous year value was 146,. Recommendation: Subject property be granted Landmark Historic Property designation as of January 1, 218. Property Valuation Summary Special Asmt. Recommended Current Value Value Sp Asmt Value land 4,5 36,34 Building 28, 193,66 Accessories Total 32,5 23, Form SRF RE (Rev. 9/6) Field Review Date: 5/25/18 Fulton BOA Meeting - 6-7-18 - Page 27 Date Submitted: 5/29/18 Appraisal Staff: Gaetjens Coreus Ct. Appraisal Manager: Gaetjens Coreus (k, Dep. Chief Appraiser: Tara Parker ~/1 Chief Appraiser: Dwight Robinson (< ~ - ~ '

5/31/218 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 7 June, 218 HT536GAFUL AD2 Administrative Agenda-Personal Property PERSONAL PROPERTY PARCEL ID YEAR PROPERTY TYPE APPRAISER Tax District Correction 1 P2172128 217 BUSNES P56 Ownership Correction 2 P26641 217 BUSNES P48 OWNER NAME REASON NOTES CANSLER RESEARCH INC Tax district correction CHANGE TAX DISTRICT FROM 1 TO 57 UNITED GEORGIA LOANS L L C Ownership correction PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE 36,915 36,915 18,587 18,587 3 P21366 216 BUSNES P5 HAMILTON ONE L L C Ownership correction 6,487 6,487 4 P21366 217 BUSNES P5 HAMILTON ONE L L C Ownership correction 6,487 6,487 1 Fulton BOA Meeting - 6-7-18 - Page 28

6/6/218 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 7 June, 218 HT536GAFUL CAD Administrative Agenda - Commercial COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES PARCEL ID YEAR APPRAISER OWNER NAME REASON NOTES PREVIOUS CURRENT CHANGE 1 14-148-2-135-6 217 996 SIASIM ABERNATHY LLC Land consolidation SEND 217 NOTICE 635,6 635,6 1 Fulton BOA Meeting - 6-7-18 - Page 29

-...... _ -- -.,. ~ ~ L.,..."" 2 ~-~ FUlJDN COUNTY Tax Year(s): FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Real Property Staff R eview Form 2 17 Reason for Property Review Lead Parent Parcel: Lead Property Owner: Lead Situs Address: Tax District: Property Class: Neighborhood: Action: Bldg./Subdivision Name: Field Review Date: 14-148-2-66-3 Siasim Abernathy LLC 1685 Ralph D Abernathy 5-Atlanta C-4 C6 1 Land Consolidation 11 /15117 This is an after-digest land consolidation for 217. Appraisers Notes and Recommendations Parent parcels were consolidated to create parcel 14-148-2-1 35-6. Recommend that the new parcel be sent an assessment notice to reflect the new valuation. ParcciiO Parent Parccl(s): 14-148-2-66-3 14-148-2-128-1 F $136,8 $163,2 SJOO,OOO New Parcel(s): 1~-148-2-135-6 S635.6 $635,6 Land Size Land Value Building Size SF or acres Per SF or acre Gross or Net Leaseable.73 Acres 586,575 Acre 1,368 SF Submitted by: David A. Robinson, Sr. ~ Appraisal Manager: Vincent Clark p Date: 3/27/ 18 Deputy Chief Appraiser: Curtis Broden Chief Appraiser: Dwi(!ht Robinson Form REISRF l Rev. OW l Fulton BOA Meeting - 6-7-18 - Page 3

6/6/218 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 7 June, 218 AS2 Appeal Hearing Officer to Superior Court COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES HT531GAFOR 1 217 17-1-5-66-9 VIRGINIA HIGH ASSOCIATES 124 NORTH HIGH AVE ATL LUC CODE: 371 NBHD CA1 IMP APPRS: 998 District 5 Total APPL REASON: Value and Uniformity STAFF RECOM: No change in value NOTICE VALUE 614,2 CURRENT 2,767,1 CHANGE 3,381,3 3,381,3 3,381,3 2 217 17-1-8-11-2 GOLDBERG SARAH S ET AL 133 NORTH HIGH AVE ATL LUC CODE: 371 NBHD CA1 APPRS: 998 District 5 APPL REASON: Value and Uniformity STAFF RECOM: No change in value IMP Total NOTICE VALUE 369, CURRENT 1,78,7 CHANGE 1,447,7 1,447,7 1,447,7 3 217 17-16-4-91-2 SELIG TWELFTH STEET LLC 6 TWELFTH ST NE ATL LUC CODE: 2C1 NBHD CB3 APPRS: 69 District 5 APPL REASON: Value and Uniformity STAFF RECOM: No change in value IMP Total NOTICE VALUE 2,4, CURRENT 1,777,1 CHANGE 4,177,1 4,177,1 4,177,1 4 217 17-18-7-62-8 FOURTEENTH STREET VENTURE 151 FOURTEENTH ST NW ATL LUC CODE: 344 NBHD CB1 APPRS: 69 District 5 APPL REASON: Value and Uniformity STAFF RECOM: No change in value IMP Total NOTICE VALUE 1,824,3 CURRENT 1,438,9 CHANGE 3,263,2 3,263,2 3,263,2 5 217 17-18-8-55-1 SELIG ENTERPRISES INC 121 SPRING ST NW ATL LUC CODE: 3C3 NBHD CB2 APPRS: 69 District 5C APPL REASON: Value and Uniformity STAFF RECOM: No change in value IMP Total NOTICE VALUE 2,15,1 CURRENT 153, CHANGE 2,168,1 2,168,1 2,168,1 6 217 17-11- LL-61-4 SELIG ENTERPRISES INC 299 PEACHTREE RD NE ATL LUC CODE: 347 NBHD C36 APPRS: 613 District 5T APPL REASON: Value and Uniformity STAFF RECOM: No change in value IMP Total NOTICE VALUE 2,841,4 CURRENT 3,28,1 CHANGE 6,121,5 6,121,5 6,121,5 7 217 17-15- LL-1-1 TWELVE HUNDRED FOSTER STREET LLC 12 FOSTER ST NW ATL LUC CODE: 398 NBHD C45 IMP APPRS: 69 District 5L Total APPL REASON: Value and Uniformity STAFF RECOM: No change in value NOTICE VALUE 8,593,5 CURRENT 21,6 CHANGE 8,615,1 8,615,1 8,615,1 Fulton BOA Meeting 1-6-7-18 - Page 31

6/6/218 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 7 June, 218 AS2 Appeal Hearing Officer to Superior Court COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES HT531GAFOR 8 217 17-15- LL-258-7 WESTSIDE ATLANTA RETAIL LLC 121 HOWELL MILL RD NW ATL LUC CODE: 3 NBHD C45 IMP APPRS: 69 District 5L Total APPL REASON: Value and Uniformity STAFF RECOM: No change in value NOTICE VALUE 2,389,5 CURRENT CHANGE 2,389,5 2,389,5 2,389,5 9 217 17-193- LL-62-2 SELIG SEABORD LLC 1375 SEABOARD INDUSTRIAL BLVD NW ATL LUC CODE: 452 NBHD C44 APPRS: 69 District 5 APPL REASON: Value and Uniformity STAFF RECOM: No change in value IMP Total NOTICE VALUE 1,642,7 CURRENT 2,431,3 CHANGE 4,74, 4,74, 4,74, 1 217 17-193- LL-74-7 SELIG ENTERPRISES INC 1116 LOGAN CIR NW ATL LUC CODE: 393 NBHD C44 APPRS: 69 District 5 APPL REASON: Value and Uniformity STAFF RECOM: No change in value IMP Total NOTICE VALUE 676,4 CURRENT 686,4 CHANGE 1,362,8 1,362,8 1,362,8 11 217 17-193- LL-9-3 SELIG ENTERPRISES INC 1166 LOGAN CIR NW ATL LUC CODE: 398 NBHD C44 APPRS: 69 District 5 APPL REASON: Value and Uniformity STAFF RECOM: No change in value IMP Total NOTICE VALUE 51,4 CURRENT 699,3 CHANGE 1,2,7 1,2,7 1,2,7 12 217 17-193- LL-11-8 SELIG ENTERPRISES INC 1855 PLYMOUTH RD NW ATL LUC CODE: 41 NBHD C44 APPRS: 69 District 5 APPL REASON: Value and Uniformity STAFF RECOM: No change in value IMP Total NOTICE VALUE 2,292,3 CURRENT 551,9 CHANGE 2,844,2 2,844,2 2,844,2 13 217 17-193- LL-14-2 SELIG LOGAN LLC 125 LOGAN CIR NW ATL LUC CODE: 398 NBHD C44 APPRS: 69 District 5 APPL REASON: Value and Uniformity STAFF RECOM: No change in value IMP Total NOTICE VALUE 599,6 CURRENT 776,8 CHANGE 1,376,4 1,376,4 1,376,4 14 217 17-193- LL-111-7 SELIG ENTERPRISES 1379 LOGAN CIR NW ATL LUC CODE: 398 NBHD C44 APPRS: 69 District 5 APPL REASON: Value and Uniformity STAFF RECOM: No change in value IMP Total NOTICE VALUE 639,9 CURRENT 739, CHANGE 1,378,9 1,378,9 1,378,9 Fulton BOA Meeting 2-6-7-18 - Page 32

6/6/218 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 7 June, 218 AS2 Appeal Hearing Officer to Superior Court COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES HT531GAFOR 15 217 17-193- LL-119- SELIG ENTERPRISES INC 1184 LOGAN CIR NW ATL LUC CODE: 398 NBHD C44 APPRS: 69 District 5 APPL REASON: Value and Uniformity STAFF RECOM: No change in value IMP Total NOTICE VALUE 1,68,8 CURRENT 2,743,1 CHANGE 4,423,9 4,423,9 4,423,9 16 217 17-193- LL-13-7 SELIG ENTERPRISES INC 1465 CHATTAHOOCHEE AVE NW ATL LUC CODE: 374 NBHD C44 APPRS: 69 District 5 APPL REASON: Value and Uniformity STAFF RECOM: No change in value IMP Total NOTICE VALUE 1,655,1 CURRENT 2,613,4 CHANGE 4,268,5 4,268,5 4,268,5 17 217 17-229- LL-42-2 SELIG ENTERPRISES INC 28 GENERAL TRUMAN ST NW ATL LUC CODE: 398 NBHD C43 APPRS: 344 District 5V APPL REASON: Value and Uniformity STAFF RECOM: No change in value IMP Total NOTICE VALUE 1,356,8 CURRENT 287,1 CHANGE 1,643,9 1,643,9 1,643,9 18 217 17-266-2-17-5 345 AIP LLC 345 ATLANTA IND PKY NW ATL LUC CODE: 398 NBHD C42 APPRS: 344 District 5 APPL REASON: Value and Uniformity STAFF RECOM: No change in value IMP Total NOTICE VALUE 561,6 CURRENT 2,599,3 CHANGE 3,16,9 3,16,9 3,16,9 19 217 22-528-112-23-9 DEERFIELD VILLAGE LLC 536 WINDWARD PKY FUL LUC CODE: 374 NBHD C14 APPRS: 666 District 56 APPL REASON: STAFF RECOM: No change in value IMP Total NOTICE VALUE 2,655, CURRENT 826, CHANGE 3,481, 3,481, 3,481, Fulton BOA Meeting 3-6-7-18 - Page 33

5/31/218 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 7 June, 218 P4 Appeal Value Changes - Personal Property PERSONAL PROPERTY HT531GAFOR TAXYR LEGAL PROPERTY TYPE APPR DISTRICT NAME DESC REASON FOR CHANGE STAFF RECOMMENDATION NOTICE VALUE CURRENT CHANGE 1 218 V21836 ELAM ROGER 3 LAKEVIEW RIDGE W MARIETTA 36 15,675 13,688-1,987 P5 45 1 Fulton BOA Meeting - 6-7-18 - Page 34

5/31/218 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF 7 June, 218 WD Appeal Withdrawn PERSONAL PROPERTY HT531GAFOR TAXYR LEGAL PROPERTY TYPE APPR DISTRICT NAME DESC REASON FOR CHANGE STAFF RECOMMENDATION NOTICE VALUE CURRENT CHANGE 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 218 1 218 1 218 56 218 5 218 5 218 5 218 5 V21834 V218592 V218714 V218449 V2185 V218476 V218447 ALOTHMAN SAMEH RAFE 15,125 1,3 515 MORNING MIST CT ALPHARETTA 322 4721 BATLEY JOHNATHAN BLAKE 119 SEALE DR ALPHARETTA 322 3598 29,625 21,932 BIDWELL MATTHEW S 166 SEGWICK DR 11,675 6,5 BOLLRATH CHRISTIAN 499 DANUBE RD NE ATLANTA 3342 388 66,25 52,79 BRAND DONNA 698 ROSWELL RD UNIT F1 2,85 17,588 BROWN THEODORE JUNIOR 2,575 2,75 4 SEVENTEENTH ST NW UNIT 2111 ATLANTA 3363 154 CHECKER CAB CO INC 563 TRABERT AVE NW ATLANTA 339 468 15, 1, -4,825-7,693-5,625-13,541-3,262-5 -5, 1 Fulton BOA Meeting - 6-7-18 - Page 35