City of Kingston Information Report to Heritage Kingston Report Number HK

To: From: Resource Staff: Date of Meeting: April 4, 2016 Subject: Executive Summary: City of Kingston Information Report to Heritage Kingston Report Number HK-16-003 Chair and Members of Heritage Kingston Lanie Hurdle, Commissioner, Community Services Paige Agnew, Director, Planning, Building & Licensing Services Information Report - Cultural Heritage Property Evaluation and Conservation Project and Review of Proposed Listings This report provides an update on the Cultural Heritage Property Evaluation (CHPE) and Conservation Project and the proposed next steps. Staff will be recommending the inclusion of 127 new properties to the City s Heritage Properties Register as non-designated properties of cultural heritage value or interest (known as listed properties). This report is provided to the Committee for consultative purposes as per Section 27(1.3) of the Ontario Heritage Act. The City retained Archaeological Research Associates (ARA) in January of 2015 to complete a review of 144 properties and to provide a statement of significance report on each. The reports were subsequently reviewed by the City s Historic Properties Research Working Group (now the Heritage Properties Working Group) with revisions being made as appropriate. Through the work of ARA and the working group, 95 properties are being recommended for designation ; seven (7) updates are recommended to existing designation by-laws (i.e. the addition of heritage attributes); 31 new listings are recommended; and 11 properties have been identified as having little cultural heritage value and therefore no further action is recommended. Section 27(1.2) of the Ontario Heritage Act, R.S.O. 1990, Chapter 0.18 allows the Council of a Municipality to include in their Heritage Register, properties that are not designated but are of cultural heritage value or interest. In accordance with Section 27(1) of the Ontario Heritage Act, the City Clerk keeps the Register; however, Planning, Building & Licensing Services administers additions to the Register. Staff propose to initially list 127 properties on the City s Heritage Properties Register (), including 119 from the CHPE project and eight (8) from the 2013 Williamsville Designation project thus providing for a baseline level of conservation. 64

Information Report to Heritage Kingston Report Number HK-16-003 April 4, 2016 Page 2 of 7 Once listed in the Register, those properties earmarked for further protection will be considered for designation. The designation of properties under Section 29 of the Ontario Heritage Act will be preceded by a process of land owner consultation and opportunity to review the reports and working group findings. Where owners are not in agreement with the City s findings, staff will arrange to meet with property owners to discuss the rationale for any proposed designation. In some instances, owners may be required to provide information to substantiate a position of disagreement with the findings of the City. In some cases, staff may still recommend to designate the property and will prepare all related documentation (i.e. notice and implementing by-law). This approach will be evaluated on a case by case basis. Recommendation: This report is for information purposes only. 65

Information Report to Heritage Kingston Report Number HK-16-003 April 4, 2016 Page 3 of 7 Authorizing Signatures: Lanie Hurdle, Commissioner, Community Services Gerard Hunt, Chief Administrative Officer Consultation with the following Members of the Corporate Management Team: Cynthia Beach, Corporate & Strategic Initiatives Denis Leger, Transportation, Facilities & Emergency Services Jim Keech, President and CEO, Utilities Kingston Desiree Kennedy, Chief Financial Officer & City Treasurer Not required Not required Not required Not required 66

Information Report to Heritage Kingston Report Number HK-16-003 April 4, 2016 Page 4 of 7 Options/Discussion: City s Vision The City s Strategic Plan 2015-2018 has an overall vision for the City to become Canada s most sustainable City, and includes Protect heritage as a component of Planning a Livable City ; one of the six priorities of the Plan to achieve its overall vision. The Goal of the City s Official Plan (Section 2.1) is To protect, conserve and strategically deploy the natural, cultural and built resources of the City in a manner that promotes compatibility between different functions that encourages sustainable forms of energy production and the use of cultural heritage resources to benefit the public good;. The Principles of Growth policies of the Official Plan notes, under Section 2.3.7, Cultural heritage resources will continue to be valued and conserved as part of the City s defining character, quality of life, and as an economic resource that contributes to tourism in both the urban and rural portions of the City. The City of Kingston is well known for its cultural heritage resources and its part in Canadian history. Cultural heritage plays a key role in the City's identity and overall quality of life, and contributes to its economic prosperity. The City s Heritage Properties Register includes approximately 1,200 properties of cultural heritage value and interest. However, this does not represent the breath of cultural heritage resources within the City of Kingston. Given the important role that cultural heritage resources play in Kingston, the City continues to place a high level of priority on conserving this non-renewable resource. Background on CHPE Project The Cultural Heritage Property Evaluation (CHPE) and Conservation Project was initiated in 2014 as part of the City s on-going efforts to support the conservation of its cultural heritage resources. The purpose of the project was to research and evaluate properties of possible cultural heritage value or interest and to prepare the statement of significance for those properties that warrant conservation and inclusion on the City s Heritage Properties Register. Two information reports have been provided to the Municipal Heritage Committee over the past year to introduce this project and to provide a status update (Report Numbers MHC-14-062 and MHC-15-061). A staff briefing on this project was given to the Committee at its March 7, 2016 meeting. Section 27 of the Ontario Heritage Act (OHA) requires municipalities to keep a Register of properties within its jurisdiction that are of cultural heritage value and/or interest. In accordance with Section 27(1) of the OHA, the City Clerk keeps the Register; however, Planning, Building & Licensing Services administers additions to the Register. Under the authority of Section 27(1.2) of the Act, the Register can include properties that are not designated but that Council believes to be of cultural heritage value or interest. These are commonly referred to as listed properties. Archaeological Research Associates Ltd. (ARA) was retained in January 2015 to begin their research and review of 144 properties of possible heritage value throughout the City. The list of properties was compiled from various sources and divided into five (5) phases based on geographic location, origin and priority. 67

Information Report to Heritage Kingston Report Number HK-16-003 April 4, 2016 Page 5 of 7 The evaluation process undertaken by the consultants (ARA), involves individual background research of each property, including a site visit and title/ownership research, and an evaluation of the cultural heritage value of the property based on Ontario Regulation 9/06 criteria. This criteria includes an evaluation of the property s physical/design value, its historical or associative value and its contextual value, including their respective sub-criteria (Exhibit B - Property Evaluation and Recommendation Chart). A report outlining the information on each property was prepared by ARA and provided to staff and the Historical Properties Research Working Group for review and comment. Based on the determined level of cultural heritage value a recommendation of the appropriate level of heritage conservation was made i.e. designation; listing; or no further action. Of the 144 properties reviewed, 95 were recommended for designation under Section 29 of the Ontario Heritage Act (OHA), seven (7) updates to existing designation by-laws were recommended, thirty-one (31) properties were recommended for inclusion on the Register as listed properties under Section 27 of the OHA, while eleven (11) properties were determined to have little cultural heritage value and did not meet the necessary criteria for inclusion on the Register. Background on Williamsville Designation Project In 2013, Laurie Smith Heritage Consulting was retained to review a selection of 28 buildings along Princess Street between Bath Road and Division Street. Their assessment recommended the designation of nine (9) of those buildings and an update to the designating by-law for 826 Princess Street ( Ashton, also known as the CNIB building). These individual reports were evaluated and reviewed by the Historic Properties Research Working Group in a similar manner as noted above. One of the buildings, the Vaughn Terrace at 426-436 Princess Street, was designated through By-Law Number 2015-20 on March 27, 2015. The remaining eight (8) properties await further action. Notification Process For those properties which are recommended for designation as opposed to just listing, the individual property reports (prepared by ARA or Smith Heritage and reviewed by the Working Group) are used as the basis for drafting the designating by-law (should the property warrant designation). The report and draft by-law are provided, by registered mail, to the property owner(s), preceded and followed by a phone call. Where requested, staff will arrange to meet with property owners to discuss the rationale for any proposed designation. Following consultation with the property owner, staff will prepare a notice of intention to designate and provide a draft designating by-law to Heritage Kingston for review. Once approved by Council, the notice of intention to designate will be served on the property owner(s), the Ontario Heritage Trust and published in the newspaper/website and the thirty (30) day appeal period will commence, as required by the Ontario Heritage Act (OHA). A notice of passing is required following the completion of the appeal period. It is staff s intent to work collaboratively with the various property owners to educate them on the implications of a heritage designation and to provide a simple and efficient approval system for all necessary alterations. However, it is reasonable to assume that not all property owners will 68

Information Report to Heritage Kingston Report Number HK-16-003 April 4, 2016 Page 6 of 7 be supportive of the designation of their property. If consensus cannot be reached with the property owner, staff may in some cases recommend that the City proceeds with designation regardless, particularly if the designation of the property is considered to be of high priority. This will be assessed on a case by case basis. The designating by-law will be processed according to the requirement of the OHA and prepared using sound, well researched information by creditable and experienced heritage professionals. Should a by-law be appealed to the Conservation Review Board, staff will ensure that all necessary steps will have been taken and the necessary heritage criteria met, to ensure a defendable City position. Next Steps Given the number of properties recommended for designation, the legislative notices and by-law requirements and the required appeal period, it is possible that the designation of all 103 properties could take up to 24 months to complete. As an intermediary step, staff propose the listing of 127 properties, being those recommended for inclusion on the Register through the CHPE and Williamsville projects, thus affording these properties with a minimal level of heritage protection. The implementation of designating by-laws will be pursued through a process of prioritization, consultation and notification pursuant to the Act. As required by Section 27(1.3) of the Ontario Heritage Act, Council shall consult with its municipal heritage committee prior to adding listed properties to its register. to this report provides the addresses of all the properties to be included on the Register. Further, offers a brief description of the cultural heritage value associated with each property. The full evaluation reports for each property are available by request from the Planning Division. Prior to inclusion on the Register as listed/non-designated properties, property owners received a courtesy letter with the evaluation report, provided by registered mail. There are no appeal rights to Council s decision to be included as a listed property on the Register. Staff also intends to formulate a ranking system to prioritize the 103 properties recommended for new designation in order to focus staff s efforts towards the most significant heritage properties first. The ranking system will be based on the following four criteria: 1. Level of heritage value, based on the number of OHA criteria (O. Reg. 9/06) being met; 2. Level of public visibility and recognisability of the heritage attributes; 3. Age of building; and 4. Level of perceived threat of demolition/substantial alteration. Once ranked, the property owner notification and consultation will follow the program noted above. It is staff s hope that through education and discussion with property owners the majority of the properties recommended for designation will be processed with the owners support. Existing Policy/By-Law: Ontario Heritage Act, R.S.O. 1990, C. O.18. (Province of Ontario) City of Kingston Official Plan 69

Information Report to Heritage Kingston Report Number HK-16-003 April 4, 2016 Page 7 of 7 Notice Provisions: Public notice will be provided pursuant to the Ontario Heritage Act. Accessibility Considerations: Not applicable Financial Considerations: The funds to research and review all properties are allocated in the existing capital budget. Contacts: Paige Agnew, Director, Planning, Building & Licensing Services 613-546-4291 extension 3252 Greg Newman, Manager, Policy Planning 613-546-4291 extension 3289 Ryan Leary, Senior Planner, Heritage 613-546-4291 extension 3233 Other City of Kingston Staff Consulted: This report has been circulated to a number of internal departments for review and comment. Exhibits Attached: Exhibit B Table of Properties to be Listed Property Evaluation and Recommendation Chart (prepared by ARA) 70

1 Albert Street 484 Princess Street United Church Red brick church with stone foundation, built in 1931, in the Collegiate Gothic style, by architect Colin Drever. 2 Aragon Road 13 John Hogan House vernacular limestone farmhouse built c.1863. John Hogan Sr. and his son John Hogan Jr. were cheesemakers and dairymen. 3 Aragon Road 204 Michael Burke Farm A two storey L -shaped red brick Ontario vernacular farmhouse built after 1861. Michael Burke was an Irish-born Roman Catholic farmer. 4 Aragon Road 384 Corrigan House vernacular limestone farmhouse built before 1860. Daniel and Patrick Corrigan built the house. 5 Aragon Road 464 Draper Farm An Ontario vernacular brick farmhouse, built prior to 1860. Richard Draper Sr., an Irish-born Wesleyan Methodist farmer, built the house and sold it to his son Richard Jr. 6 Bath Road 4085 Bayview Farm A two-and-a-half storey stone farmhouse, built before 1860. Associated with the McGuin and Rankin families who worked at and owned the nearby McGuin Mill. 7 Bath Road 4097 Hugh Rankin Jr. House A two-storey L -shaped stone farmhouse, built c. 1860. Associated with the McGuin and Rankin families who worked at and owned the nearby McGuin Mill. 8 Bath Road 4111 McGuin House A one-and-a-half storey stone farmhouse and a two-storey stone farmhouse with classical additions. Built in 1851. Anthony McGuin was the son of United Empire Loyalist Captain Daniel McGuin. Page 71 1

9 Bath Road 4255 Aiken House A one-and-a-half storey classically balanced stone farmhouse, built before 1860. Robert Aiken was an Americanborn Wesleyan Methodist yeoman who lived and farmed the property. 10 Battersea Road 2285 James Hickey House A one-and-a-half storey rectangular limestone house built prior to 1860. James Hickey Sr. was the Road Master and used the house to collect tolls. Property includes a barn. 11 Belmont Avenue 160 Miller House A one-and-a-half-storey limestone house with classical proportions, built after 1878. John and Mary Miller were the first owners. 12 Brock Street 149 McKay Fur House Brick commericial building, built c. 1907. Associated with furrier John McKay who began a successful business from this building. 13 Brock Street 161 Benjamin Norris House A wood frame building, built c. 1842. Benjamin Norris, a carpenter, built and lived in this house with his wife Elizabeth. 14 Brock Street 163 Dr. Thomas Dupuis House An Italianate building, built c. 1883. Associated with Dr. Thomas R. Dupuis who used the building as a residence and medical office. 15 Bur Brook Road 2643 Jackson Mills Schoolhouse A one-storey limestone schoolhouse and a rare example of bank house construction, built in 1855. 16 Clergy Street 151 Maple Cottage/ Sexton House A Classical style house, built between 1842 and 1848. Owned and built for City Councillor, Major James Meagher. Sold to Queen Street Church and used as the sexton's residence. Page 72 2

17 Clergy Street 153 A small stone cottage (now covered in stucco), built c. 1843. 18 Cloggs Road 2904 Clogg A two storey L -shaped brick farmhouse, built c. 1895. Philip Clogg was a British-born farmer. House was likely built by his son Jacob. 19 Colborne Street 11 A semi-detached brick dwelling with classical proportions, built between 1875 and 1892. 20 Colborne Street 13 Lower Colborne Street Victorian Terrace A two-and-a-half storey red brick Victorian-era structure, built c. 1886. 21 Colborne Street 15 Lower Colborne Street Victorian Terrace A two-and-a-half storey red brick Victorian-era structure, built c. 1886. 22 Colborne Street 17 Lower Colborne Street Victorian Terrace A two-and-a-half storey red brick Victorian-era structure, built c. 1886. 23 Colborne Street 8 A one-and-a-half storey wood frame house, built c. 1850. Page 73 3

24 Colborne Street 9 A semi-detached brick dwelling with classical proportions, built between 1875 and 1892. 25 Cole Hill Road 2364 Spooner A one-and-a-half-storey L -shaped Ontario vernacular stone bankhouse, built before 1860. Reuben Spooner was a Canadian-born Wesleyan Methodist farmer who owned the farmhouse. 26 Creekford Road 3012 Zachariah David vernacular limestone farmhouse, built between 1851 and 1861. Zachariah David was a Canadian-born Episcopalian Methodist farmer and road master. 27 Creekford Road 3160 Morley Farmstead A farmstead containing a one-and-ahalf-storey L -shaped Ontario vernacular frame farmhouse (built prior to 1851), a barn and wood outbuilding. William Morley was a British-born Episcopalian Methodist farmer. 28 Creekford Road 3448 Robert Rose Farmstead vernacular stone farmhouse, built between 1852 and 1860. Robert Rose was a farmer and yeoman. 29 Days Road 321 Crystal Springs School House (S.S. Number 2) This simple two-storey rubblestone limestone building was built by Hayes Construction Company of Kingston in 1869. Crystal Springs School House was the centre of education in the community from its construction in 1869 until its closing in 1950. 30 Division Street 488 Bryant Stone House A classically balanced two-storey stone house, built between 1860 and 1878. John Bryant Jr. was a teamster (drove a team of horses), a stone dealer, a farmer and a quarryman. Page 74 4

31 Florida Road 4226 Hiram Walker Farmstead A mid-19 th century farmstead with a oneand-a-half-storey Ontario vernacular frame farmhouse (c.1855), barn and outbuildings. Hiram Walker (a farmer) and his wife Mercy raised fourteen children here. 32 Florida Road 4604 Miles Redden A one-and-a-half-storey Ontario vernacular frame farmhouse c. 1870. Miles Redden was an Ontario-born farmer and Primitive Methodist. 33 Front Road 1193 Charles Grass House A two-storey L -shaped Italianate stone house, built c. 1870. Charles Grass was the grandson of Captain Michael Grass who is considered one of the first settlers in the former Township of Kingston. 34 Front Road 790 John Murton House An Italianate style two-storey structure (c.1875), constructed from red brick with a limestone foundation. Farmers John and Sarah Murton built this house. 35 Front Road 890 John Herchmer Wartman House The house is in a style known as an Ontario adaptation of the Italianate style. Red brick laid in Flemish Bonds, built c. 1865. John Wartman family farmed this land for over 100 years. 36 Highway 15 1292 Patterson A one-and-a-half storey L -shaped Ontario vernacular structure, constructed from red brick after 1861. Richard S. Patterson was a local councillor and farmer. 37 Highway 15 1624 The property contains a one-and-a-halfstorey L -shaped Ontario vernacular farmhouse constructed c. 1873, a barn, two silos, and three outbuildings. 38 Highway 38 2518 Robert Gibson Jr. Farm Complex The property contains a two-storey limestone house constructed between 1844 and 1852 as well as several farm buildings. Robert Gibson was appointed Postmaster of Glenvale in 1858. Page 75 5

39 Highway 38 2555 Davidson vernacular brick farmhouse constructed in 1860. Joseph Davidson and wife, Mary Ann, who was a member of the Ellerbeck family, a prominent UEL family. 40 Highway 38 3578 Vanluven Farmstead The property contains a one-and-a-half storey Ontario vernacular stone farmhouse, built prior to 1851, with a stone farm building and several barns. Leonard Vanluven was a Wesleyan Methodist yeoman and farmer. 41 Highway 38 3702 Murvale Wesleyan Methodist Church Gothic Revival one-storey limestone church constructed c. 1871. 42 Hillview Road 692 A two-storey L -shaped brick farmhouse built after 1861. 43 Hillview Road 704 Collins Bay Wesleyan Methodist Church A Gothic Revival brick church, built in 1872. It was a religious gathering place for the Collins Bay and the surrounding farming community for over 75 years. 44 Hillview Road 730 Grass/Ellerbeck House A two-storey brick house constructed after 1878. Associated with prominent Grass and Ellerbeck UEL families. 45 Hillview Road 780 Smith House A one-and-a-half-storey L -shaped limestone farmhouse, built between 1860 and 1878. 46 Howes Road 3994 Thomas Stevens vernacular stone farmhouse, built after 1861. Thomas Stevens was a Britishborn farmer. Page 76 6

47 Jackson Mills Road 1901Jackson Mill A three-and-a-half storey frame mill, built prior to 1851. Edward Jackson leased the property and ran a grist mill with William Jackson in the mid-19th century. 48 Kepler Road 2583 The Kepler School (S.S. Number 20) A one-and-a-half storey brick school house constructed in 1888. 49 Kepler Road 2586 Kepler Methodist Episcopal Church A one-storey Gothic Revival red brick church constructed in 1878. 50 Kepler Road 2638 Jacob Powley vernacular limestone farmhouse constructed circa 1860. The Powleys were a notable local family who had a school and a Methodist Episcopal Church built on their land. 51 Kepler Road 2745 Francis Guess A one-and-a-half storey limestone farmhouse built before 1852. 52 Kingston Mills Road 473 Charles Harrison House The property contains a two-storey limestone farmhouse constructed prior to 1860, as well as several outbuildings. Harrison was an Irish Catholic stone mason and operated the Blessing's tavern. 53 Lee Road 2785 A two-storey limestone house constructed after 1878. 54 Lee Road 2880 Knapp Farmstead The property contains a one-storey stone house constructed prior to 1851 with a large two-storey addition added after 1851 (but prior to 1876) and several farm buildings. Page 77 7

55 Lee Road 2966 Daniel Wartman Farmstead The property contains a one-and-a-halfstorey brick house constructed between 1851 and 1861 as well as several farm buildings. Associated with UEL Wartman family. 56 Maple Ridge Drive 375 Carolan A one-and-a-half storey L -shaped Ontario vernacular stone house constructed between 1852 and 1861. Cornelius Carolan was an Irish Catholic farmer and road master. 57 McAdoos Lane 1067 vernacular brick house, built after 1878. 58 Montreal Street 1081 A one-and-a-half storey limestone house constructed between 1860 and 1878. 59 Montreal Street 831 A one-and-a-half storey red brick house with a mansard roof, constructed between 1860 and 1865. 60 Montreal Street 888 vernacular frame farmhouse constructed between 1860 and 1878. 61 Old Kingston Mills Road 950 Holy of Jesus Roman Catholic Church A Gothic Revival church built in 1888 of sandstone and limestone. 62 Orser Road 2973 Emanuel Orser Farmstead The property contains a one-and-a-half storey Ontario vernacular limestone farmhouse, built before 1878 and several farm buildings. Associated with UEL Orser family. Page 78 8

63 Orser Road 3570 Davis Farmstead vernacular house constructed prior to 1851. Isaac V. Davis was a Roman Catholic farmer. 64 Princess Street 239-241 Oddfellows Block A two-storey red-brick commercial building constructed in 1891. Designed by Power & Son and associated with the Oddfellows Relief Assoc. 65 Princess Street 249-253 Henry Brame Shop A two-storey red-brick commercial building (1850) and a two-storey addition (c. 1910). Henry Brame was a cabinetmaker and undertaker. 66 Princess Street 255-265 Abramsky's Clothing Shop A three-storey commercial building which may date to 1865. Associated with the Abramsky family and the Jewish-Canadian settlement in this area. 67 Princess Street 3516-35 John B. Powley House A two-storey limestone house built prior to 1861. John B. Powley sold portions of this land to facilitate the settlement of Westbrook. 68 Princess Street 3526 Westbrook United Church A one-storey limestone Gothic Revival church built in 1867. 69 Princess Street 3536 The Leonard Carriage Shop A two-storey stone shop built between 1855 and 1861. Nathaniel Leonard was a carriage/wagon maker, agricultural implements maker, Returning Officer and contractor. 70 Princess Street 3562 A two-storey red brick house built before 1878. 71 Princess Street 3578 Sproul's Farmers' and Drovers' Inn A two-storey stone Inn built between 1838 and 1848. Associated with the Metzlers, the Sprouls, the Benjamins and the Ashley families. Page 79 9

72 Princess Street 3581 Westbrook Wesleyan Methodist Church A one-storey limestone church built in 1860. 73 Princess Street 3606 Marshall Farmstead A one-and-a-half storey stone house constructed between 1840 and 1860 and a wooden shed. William Marshall was an English-born farmer. 74 Princess Street 3728 Gardiner A one-and-a-half storey frame house constructed between 1860 and 1871. William Gardiner was an Irish-born Episcopalian Methodist farmer. 75 Princess Street 3737 The Red Rock School A limestone schoolhouse built circa 1850. 76 Princess Street 3761 C. W. Benjamin A one-and-a-half storey stone farmhouse constructed after 1871. Charles Wesley Benjamin was a Methodist and farmer. 77 Princess Street 3791 Ebenezer Benjamin Jr. Farmstead The property contains a one-and-a-half storey limestone farmhouse constructed after 1871 and a number of stone and wood outbuildings. 78 Princess Street 450 Bell Telephone Building A two-storey, commercial building with limestone cladding and a flat roof. Associated with Colonel John Duff and Dr. George Bell as well as architects Fredrick Macnab and Hugh Allan Inglis Valentine. 79 Princess Street 506 George Newlands House A two-and-a-half-storey Italianate-style brick house with a limestone foundation. It was designed by Kingston architect John Power and built for local contractor George Newlands in 1874. Page 80 10

80 Princess Street 520 Bermingham-Hardy House A two-and-a-half-storey, Queen-Annestyle house built in c. 1892. Associated with the Honourable William Hardy and Cornelius Bermingham. 81 Princess Street 620 Princess Street United Church Rectory A two-and-a-half-storey Edwardian style structure of brick construction with a stone foundation. It was built in 1907-08 to serve as the residence for the minister. 82 Princess Street 635 Carter's Grocery A two-storey, gable-roofed, stone building with rooftop dormers, built c. 1875. Thomas Carter, a former penitentiary guard who, with his wife Margaret Carter, operated a grocery store here. 83 Princess Street 647 Thomas McCrea's Carriage & Blacksmith Shop A two-storey, gable-roofed, stone building with prominent brick chimneys, built in the mid-to-late 1840s. 84 Princess Street 662-670 Carnovsky Bakery A two-storey, gable-roofed stone building, built of stone in the mid-to-late- 1840s. 85 Purdy s Mill Road 999 Riley Stone House A one-and-a-half storey stone house was built circa 1871. Edward Riley, an English immigrant, constructed the house. 86 Quabbin Road 2800 Wilson A one-and-a-half storey classically balanced brick farmhouse constructed between 1852 and 1861. Thomas Wilson family were early settlers along Quabbin Road. 87 Quabbin Road 3076 Mohan Farmstead vernacular brick farmhouse constructed between 1851 and 1861. Michael Mohan is an early settler of Quabbin Road. Page 81 11

88 Quabbin Road 3250 Guess Farmstead The property contains a one-and-a-half storey Ontario vernacular limestone farmhouse constructed between 1851 and 1860, a barn and several outbuildings. 89 Queen Street 209 Isaac Cohen House A two-and-a-half storey Queen Annestyle red-brick residential building constructed between 1893 and 1904. Is associated with the Jewish-Canadian settlement area. 90 Queen Street 211 A two-and-a-half storey red-brick residential building with limestone foundation constructed between 1893 and 1904. 91 Queen Street 216 Benjamin Bailey House A two-and-a-half storey front gable residence constructed circa 1875. Benjamin Bailey House was one of the founders of the Bailey Broom Company, a prominent and influential local business. 92 Radage Road 1715 James Smith A one-and-a-half storey L -shaped Ontario vernacular brick farmhouse, built before 1878. The Smith and Shannon families were early farmers in the area. 93 Smith Road 3751 Alexander Bell Farmstead A one-and-a-half storey rectangular limestone building, built after 1861. The Bell family were long-time residents and farmers on Smith Road. 94 Smith Road 3867 Hiram Smith Farmstead A one-and-a-half storey rectangular limestone building, built between 1851 and 1861. Hiram Smith lived and farmed the property between 1849 and 1889. 95 Sunnyside Road 1517 Johnson vernacular brick farmhouse constructed between 1860 and 1878. Page 82 12

96 Sunnyside Road 1553 Fairbanks vernacular stone farmhouse constructed prior to 1851. Caleb Fairbanks was a veteran of the War of 1812. 97 Sunnyside Road 1572 Powley Farmstead The property contains a one-and-a-half storey Ontario vernacular limestone farmhouse, a limestone woodshed, and a limestone barn, all built circa 1815-1820. 98 Sydenham Road 1360 John Harpell Farmstead The property contains a one-and-a-halfstorey classically balanced limestone farmhouse constructed prior to 1851, a second one-and-a-half storey limestone building and a barn. 99 Sydenham Road 1397 Isaac D. Powley A one-and-a-half storey limestone house, built between 1851 and 1860. The Powleys were one of the first United Empire Loyalist families. 100 Sydenham Road 2043 M.P. Guess A one-and-a-half storey limestone house, built prior to 1851. Associated with the William Guess family and the John Irvine family. 101 Sydenham Road 2268 Jesse Purdy House vernacular frame house built prior to 1851. Jesse Purdy was an Americanborn Wesleyan Methodist UEL and farmer. 102 Sydenham Street 181 Charles Gildersleeve Building A two-storey red-brick commercial building constructed in 1891. Associated with the prominent Gildersleeve family. 103 Sydenham Street 184-188 Sydenham Street Stone Commercial Block A two-and-a-half storey stone building constructed in the 1840s. Page 83 13

104 Sydenham Street 187 A two-and-a-half storey Italianate style red-brick former residential building constructed in 1898. 105 Sydenham Street 203 Robert Matthews House A two-and-a-half storey limestone semidetached residential building constructed circa 1840. Robert Matthews was a local mason and active member of the community. 106 Sydenham Street 205 Robert Matthews House A two-and-a-half storey limestone semidetached residential building constructed circa 1840. Robert Matthews was a local mason and active member of the community. 107 Sydenham Street 216 A one-and-a-half storey red-brick Craftsman-style house, constructed between 1923 and 1924. 108 Unity Road 1136 Glenburnie Public School (S.S. Number 14) The property contains a one-room schoolhouse built circa 1888. 109 Unity Road 1216 Glenburnie Methodist Church The property contains a rectangular church structure built in 1857 with a 1956-1957 modern addition designed by local architect Wilfred Sorensen. 110 Unity Road 1228 William Shurtleff A one-and-a-half storey limestone farmhouse built before 1860. Shurtleff was an Ontario-born Methodist farmer, who was the Post Master of Glenburnie from 1887-1890. 111 Unity Road 1274 Rankin Farmstead The property contains a late-19 th century two-and-a-half storey red brick farmhouse and several farm buildings. Hugh Rankin was an Irish-born Presbyterian farmer. Page 84 14

112 Unity Road 1359 George Hunter vernacular brick farmhouse constructed between 1862 and 1878. George Hunter, a farmer and Post Master, with wife Sarah and son Frederick, lived and worked the property until 1908. 113 Unity Road 3254 Matthew McRory Farmstead The property contains a one-and-a-half storey Ontario vernacular farmhouse built prior to 1851 and several farm buildings. Matthew McRory was a farmer. 114 Unity Road 3578 William Raycroft A one-and-a-half storey limestone Ontario vernacular farmhouse built after 1861. William Raycroft and family of 9 were living and farming the property. 115 Unity Road 3693 John Walpole vernacular brick farmhouse, built before 1861. John Walpole, a Methodist farmer, and his wife Catherine, lived on the property until 1918. 116 Unity Road 3836 Abraham Cramer A one-and-a-half-storey farmhouse, built prior to 1851. Abraham Cramer was an American-born yeoman who fought as a corporal in the War of 1812. 117 Unity Road 4017 The property contains a two-storey classically balanced farmhouse constructed prior to 1860 and several outbuildings and barns. 118 Unity Road 788 Clark Schoolhouse A one-storey schoolhouse constructed prior to 1860. Associated with John D. Clark schoolmaster. 119 Unity Road 896 Thomas Draper Farmstead The property contains a one-and-a-half storey red brick farmhouse, as well as a barn and other farm buildings. Page 85 15

120 Wartman Avenue 815 Edward Horsey Cottage A one-and-a-half storey L -shaped Italianate Villa constructed between 1860 and 1864, by and for well-known local architect Edward Horsey. 121 Wellington Street 167 Anglin Building A narrow four-storey brick commercial building constructed circa 1876. Samuel Anglin owned a sucessful sawmill in Battersea with his brother William. 122 Wellington Street 347 Davis Dry Dock A dry dock constructed in 1884 and a one-and-a-half storey machine shop. A ship building business established by Robert Davis and his three sons. 123 Westbrook Road 1146 Knight The property contains a one-and-a-half storey stone house constructed in the 1850s, and a two-storey red brick house constructed between 1880 and 1890. 124 Wilton Road 3108 Damon Babcock vernacular brick farmhouse, built prior to 1878, and a wooden barn. Babcock, a Methodist farmer, with wife Anne, lived on the property until the 1920s. 125 Woodbine Road 1212 Kingston Christian School A one-and-a-half storey limestone farmhouse constructed in the early to late 19 th century, prior to 1860. 126 Woodbine Road 1332 Daniel E. Grass Frame vernacular frame farmhouse constructed in the early to mid-19 th century, prior to 1851. Daniel E. Grass is the grandson of Captain Michael Grass, an early UEL setter. Page 86 16

127 Yonge Street 22 Portsmouth Brewery Kiln & Office A three-storey stone former kiln, constructed between 1892 and 1904, and a one-storey former office c. 1924. Portsmouth Brewery was one of the key industries in Portsmouth Village. Page 87 17

Exhibit B Statement of Significance Report 123 Fake Street 5.0 EVALUATION OF SIGNIFICANCE Table 1: Evaluation of the Cultural Heritage or Interest of the Property According to Ontario Regulation 9/06 EVALUATION OF PROPERTY Criteria Description Is a rare, unique, representative or early example of a style, type, expression, material or Design or Physical Historical or Associative Contextual construction method Displays a high degree of craftsmanship or artistic value Displays a high degree of technical or scientific achievement Has direct associations with a theme, event, belief, person, activity, organization or institution that is significant to a community Yields or has the potential to yield information that contributes to the understanding of a community or culture Demonstrates or reflects the work or ideas of an architect, builder, artist, designer or theorist who is significant to a community Is important in defining, maintaining or supporting the character of an area Is physically, functionally, visually or historically linked to its surroundings Is a landmark 6.0 RECOMMENDATION RECOMMENDATION FOR PROPERTY Recommendation The property has no cultural heritage value or interest, therefore it requires no further work. The property should be considered for addition to the Municipal Heritage Register. The property should be considered for designation under Part IV of the Ontario Heritage Act. January 2015 HR-065-2015 88 Archaeological Research Associates Ltd.