Developing Worlds: Planning and Design in Latin America and the Middle East after WWII Hashim Sarkis Graduate School of Design, Harvard University hashim@hashimsarkis.com Course Description The course examines the relationship between socio-economic development, planning and design. It focuses on Latin America and the Middle East after WWII and on the impact of international development policies on regional architecture and urbanism. Even before the 1947 Marshall Plan for European Reconstruction, the United States had already been involved in aid and in development projects in the Middle East and in Latin America. However, it was the Truman Inaugural Speech of 1949 that ratified the process of assistance for the developing world and set the stage for international agencies like the World Bank, the United Nations Development Program, and nongovernmental organizations like the Ford Foundation to formulate strategies and aid packages that would help in the social and economic advancement of allied nation states. Invariably, these strategies tied the promises of accelerated development to the application of specific democratic political processes and free market economic models. They also came with particular requirements for planning at the national and regional scale. Invariably, these planning strategies were guided by models authored by modernist planners and architects of how cities, houses, and institutions should be designed and built. Invariably, the modernist aesthetic provided the visual guarantee that development was being achieved, quickly and effectively. The course will look at these design and planning models and their evolution over the past fifty years in parallel with developmental undertakings: from technical assistance and national planning focusing on economic issues, to social issues, to sustainability issues. from post-war reconstruction programs and technical assistance immediately after the Second World War, to national planning and state building in the 50s and 60s, to sites and services in the 60s and 70s, to sustainability and micro credit in the present. Even if these models were hardly ever realized, they had a significant impact on design throughout the developing world. And even when the development projects were sometimes locally self-generated, they were often influenced by international development models guided by a few experts (Sert and Wiener, Doxiadis, and Turner) who came to dominate the development culture of the period. The course aims to highlight this important but hardly-examined link between design and planning on the one hand and the procedures of development in the recent history of developing countries on the other. It uses the comparative approach (between Latin America and the Middle East) in order to understand at once the particularities of different settings but also the similar ways in which development strategies were applied worldwide.
Cases The cases will follow a somewhat chronological order focusing on different types of projects that typify a particular era of development as we move from the immediate post-war period to the present. Forerunners These include two projects that were influential in setting the stage for international development practices: Puerto Rico under Rexford Tugwell and the role of architects like Richard Neutra, Klumb, and Casals in formulating the idea of national planning and design; and Greece and Turkey after WWII and the impact that this model had on the shaping of the agricultural landscape in both countries. National Planning We will then go to look at the first World Bank related experiments after the war particularly in Colombia and the projects of Jose Lluis Sert, Paul Wiener and Le Corbusier. In the Middle East we will look at the Eisenhower policies, the Point Four Development Program in Iraq and Lebanon around 1958 and the new settlements by Constantinos Doxiadis. Capital Cities The creation of nation states after the war did not only propel the idea of national planning but also the idea of re-centering the territory and creating new capital cities. As such we will look at the phenomenon of new capital cities. In Latin America, we will focus on Brasilia, and the capital cities on the two sides of the Punjab: Islamabad and Chandigarh. Housing The planning initiatives would soon be challenged by the realities of urban poverty and unplanned growth. As such new models related to the provision of sites and services and grass roots approaches to planning begin to emerge in the sixties. In this respect we will look at the housing theories of John Habraken, John Turner, Hassan Fathy, and Christopher Alexander and their applications in Peru, Mexico, and Egypt. Independent Initiatives We will also look at contexts where national wealth and local initiative would generate other approaches to development. The case study here will be Ciudad Guyana in Venezuela designed by the Joint Center of Harvard and MIT. We will also study the impact of oil transportation on the reorganization of the Saudi desert. NGO s We will examine the role of NGO s in advancing development from The Ford Foundation and its schools building programs to the micro-credit approach in the work of Arif Hasan in Pakistan.
Heritage and Development We will also examine the world heritage sites program of the United Nations and the role of cultural heritage in enhancing development. Contemporary Themes Lastly, we will look at several contemporary themes in development, or redevelopment as it has been often referred to in present debates, namely sustainability, participation, and post-war reconstruction, focusing in the last theme on the current reconstruction of Beirut. Class 1: Introduction: Development and Design Amartya Sen, The Ends and Means of Development, in Development as Freedom, (New York: Anchor Books, 1999), 35-53 Arturo Escobar, Economics and the Space of Development, in Encountering Development, (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1995), 55-101 Hashim Sarkis, On the Line Between Procedures and Aesthetics, in The Pragmatist Imagination, Thinking About Things in the Making, edited by Joan Ockman and John Rachjman, (New York: Princeton Architectural Press, 2000) Class 2: Forerunners: Puerto Rico Rexford Tugwell, The Stricken Land: The Story of Puerto Rico, (New York: Greenwood Press, 1968) excerpts Thomas S. Marvel and Lucilla F. Marvel, The American Presence in Puerto Rico: Architecture, Planning, Construction, Working Paper #78, (San Juan: The Carribean Institute and Study Center for Latin America, Inter American University of Puerto Rico, April 1998) Class 3: Forerunners: The Reconstruction of Turkey and Greece Sibel Bozdogan and Resat Kasaba, editors, Rethinking Modernity and National Identity in Turkey, (Seattle: The University of Washington Press, 2002) excerpts Constantinos Doxiadis, Destruction of Towns and Villages in Greece, (Athens: Hypourgeion Anoikodomeseos, 1947) Class 4: National Planning and Design: Colombia Maria Rubert de Ventos, Cities in Latin America: The Work of Town Planning Associates 1943-1956 in Sert: Architect in New York, edited by X. Costa and G. Hartray, (Barcelona: ACTAR and The Museum of Contemporary Art)
Paul Lester Weiner and Jose Luis Sert, Town Planning in South America, from L Architecture d Aujourd hui, N.33, 1951, 32-56 Class 5: National Planning: Iraq and Lebanon (with Guest Speaker: Panaiyota Pyla) Hashim Sarkis, Circa 1958: Lebanon in the Pictures and Plans of Constantinos Doxiadis, (Beirut: Dar An-Nahar, 2003) excerpts. Class 6: New Capital Cities: Brasilia James Holston, The Modernist City: An Anthropological Critique of Brasilia, (Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1990), excerpts David G. Epstein, Brasilia, Plan and Reality, A Study of Planned and Spontaneous Urban Development, (Berkeley, University of California Press, 1971), excerpts Class 7: New Capital Cities: Chandigarh Vikramditya Prakash, Chandigarh s Le Corbusier, The Struggle for Modernity in Post-Colonial India, (Seattle: The University of Washington Press, 2002), excerpts Class 8: New Capital Cities: Islamabad (and Riyadh, Kuwait, and Abuja)Constantinos Doxiadis, Islamabad: the Creation of a New Capital City, in Ekistics, Nov. 1965, vol. 20:120, 301-305 Constantinos Doxiadis, Ekistics, An Introduction to the Science of Human Development, (New York: Oxford Univeristy Press, 1968), excerpts Housing: Fathy in Egypt Hassan Fathy, Architecture for the Poor, An Experiment in Rural Egypt, (Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 2000) excerptsthursday, October 23 Housing: Sites and Services John F.C. Turner, Housing as Verb, in Freedom to Build, Dweller Control of the Housing Process, edited by John F.C. Turner and Robert Fichter (New York: The Macmillan Company) 148-175 Class 9: Housing: SAR and Alexander Dorine van Hoogstraten, Between Structure and Form: Habraken and the Alternative to Mass Housing, in Housing for the Millions, John Habraken and the SAR, (1960-2000), edited by Koos Bosma, Dorine van Hoogstraten and Martjin Vos, (Rotterdam: Nai Publishers, 2000) exceprts
John Habraken, The Structure of the Ordinary: Form and Control in the Built Environment, (Cambridge: MIT Press, 1998) Christopher Alexander et al., The Production of Houses, (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1985) excerpts Class 9: Development at Midway E.F. Schumacher, Small is Beautiful, (London: Bond and Briggs, 1973), excerpts Class 10: Resourceful Development: Ciudad Guayana Lisa Peattie, The View from the Barrio, (Ann Arbor: The University of Michigan Press, 1968) excerpts Lloyd Rodwin, Planning Guayana, A General Perspective, in Planning Urban Growth: The Guayana Program, edited by Lloyd Rodwin, (Cambridge, Mass: The MIT Press, 1969) 9-38 Class 11: Resourceful Development: Oil and Arabia NGOs: The Ford Foundation Schools Dwight Mcdonald, The Ford Foundation: The Men and the Millions, with a new introduction by Francis X. Sutton (New Brunswick: Transaction Publishers, 1989, excerpt Class 12: NGOs: Recent Activities Francoise Choay, The Invention of the Historic Monument, (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 2001), 138-163Thursday, November 20 Redevelopment: Reconstruction Hashim Sarkis, A Vital Void: Reconstructions of Downtown Beirut, in The Resilient City, edited by Thomas Campanella and Lawrence Vale, MS Class 13: Redevelopment: Sustainability The World Commission on Environment and Development, Our Common Future, 43-66 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1987)Thursday, December 4 Redevelopment: Micro-Credit Arif Hassan, Housing Crisis in Central Asia (Karachi: City Press, 1999) Readings History, Theory, and Politics of Development: Development, Planning and Design: