Reyjew Adovted. The Review (Attachment A) is adopted as the required

CITY OF BLUFFDALE, UT AH A MUNICIPAL CORPORATION RESOLUTION NO. 2018-49 A RESOLUTION ADOPTING THE BIENNIAL REVIEW OF THE MODERATE INCOME HOUSING ELEMENT OF THE GENERAL PLAN FOR THE CITY OF BLUFFDALE FOR THE YEAR 2018 PURSUANT TO UTAH CODE 10-9a-408 WHEREAS the City Council is req uired biennially to review and report the C ity 's moderate income housing plan e lement of its general plan and its implementation; and WHEREAS the C ity has prepared a report of the moderate income housing e lement for the year 2018 utilizing the form and in structions prescribed by the Department of Workforce Services; and WHEREAS the report sets forth the fi ndings of th e Council's review; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF BLUFFDALE, AS FOLLOWS: Reyjew Adovted. The Review (Attachment A) is adopted as the required Section 1. biennial review of the moderate income housing e lement for the C ity of for the year 2018. Section 2. Covies Delivered. A copy of the Review shall be de livered to the Department of Workforce Services and posted on the C ity's Official Website pursuant to Utah Code I 0-9a-408. Effective Date. This Resolution shall become effective immediately Section 3. upon its passage and authorizes and directs the Mayor to execute and cause to be de! ivered the same. PASSED, APPROVED, AND ADOPTED: October 24, 2018. CITY OF BLUFFDALE

Voting by the City Council: Aye Nay Council Member Aston Council Member Higby Council Member Kallas Counci I Member Nielsen Council Member Preece _ x_ X X X X

MODERATE-INCOME HOUSING REPORTING FORM A form for reporting the findings of a biennial moderate-income housing element review. Revised: March 2018 ~ WORKFORCE SERVICES HOUSING & COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT,,-,,. A proud partner of the AmencanJobCenter network

MODERATE-INCOME HOUSING REPORTING FORM General purpose municipal governments, other than towns, are required to include a 5-year moderateincome housing element in their comprehensive general plan. The following are obligated municipal governments: All cities of the first, second, third, and fourth class. Cities of the fifth class: o Having an estimated population greater than or equal to 5,000 residents; AND o That are located in a county with a population greater than or equal to 31,000 residents. Metro Townships: o o Having an estimated population greater than or equal to 5,000 residents; Having an estimated population less than 5,000 BUT is located in a county with a population greater than or equal to 31,000 residents. In addition, every two years the legislative body ofobligated municipal governments are to: Conduct a thorough review of the moderate-income housing element and its implementation; and Revise its 5-year moderate-income housing needs estimates; and Report the findings of the biennial review to the Housing and Community Development Division (HCDD) of the Utah Department of Workforce Servicesno later than December 3 l5 1 ;and Post the findings report on their municipality's website. NOTE: Completion of this form on ly partially satisfies each municipality's obligations t o ensure an adequate supply of moderate-i ncome housing within their geographic jurisdiction. It is also incumbent upon each municipality t o stay apprised of pertinent state and federal housing-related legislation, administrative rules, regu latory procedures, and reporting deadlines. When did the municipality last adopt a new moderate-income housing element?... Municipal Government: City ofbluffdale Reporting Date: General Plan's Web Address: MUNICIPAL GOVERNMENT INFORMATION: I 0_3_12_5_12_0_1_4_--1 ----------------------------- ;..._ http://bluffdale.com/2681planning MUNICIPAL GOVERNMENT CONTACT INFORMATION: Mailing Address: 2222 West 14400 South p.0. Box : City: Bluffdale, UT Zip Code: 84065 Mayor's First and Last Name: _o_e_rk_t_i_m_ot_h_y Mayor's Email Address: <ltimothy@ bluffdale.com --------------------- ------- Preparer's First and Last Name : Caitlyn Miller Preparer' s Title: Associate Planner ---------------------------- PREPARER INFORMATION: ------------------------- Preparer' s Email Address: ------------------------------- cmiller@bluffdale.com ---------------------------- Preparer' s Telephone: (801 ) 254-2200 Extension: 422 ----------------- Utah Oep.Jrtment of Workforce Servil>s Pagel of 21 Housilg and Community Development Divilkin

5 tate of Utah INSTRUCTIONS (2 OF 3): The following pages contain two (2) parts that pertain to UCA 10-9a-103(b) and UCA 10-9a-408. Part I consists of eight (8) sections that require the report's preparer to revise 5-year estimates of the municipality's housing needs. The report's preparer will need to download data from the U.S. Census Bureau's FactFinder website to complete this part of the form. Part II consists of seven (7) sections that will require the preparer to review city ordinances, existing plans, and compile records from multiple sources, including: The municipality's various departments, affiliated development agencies, interlocal cooperatives, associations of government, public housing authorities, and/or county assessors. NOTE: Reporting the findings of a biennial moderate-income housing review is a time intensive process. Municipalities should set-aside sufficient time to prepare an adequate report. The Utah Housing and Community Development Division has developed this form to assist municipal governments with their biennial reporting obligations. Nonetheless, a preparer of the biennial report is expected to have a basic knowledge of planning principles, a familiarity with demographic methods, and an understanding of state laws governing moderate-income housing as well as applicable municipal ordinances. PART I: REVISED ESTIMATES OF 5-YEAR MODERATE-INCOME HOUSING NEEDS In accordance with UCA 10-9a-103(b ), please complete the tables in the following sections to revise estimates of the municipality's 5-year moderate-income housing needs. The report's preparer should use the advanced search functions of the U.S. Census Bureau's American FactFinder website to look up tabulated values from the American Community Survey (ACS). Specific ACS tables are listed in each table to aid searches. FactFinder tutorials are widely available on the internet, including HCDD's website: https://jobs.utah.gov/housing/affordable/ moderate/index.html. Municipalities should use 5-year ACS estimates, but they may determine for themselves whether to use 3-year or 1-year estimates if available and appropriate. Alternatively, municipalities may use the most recent estimates and projections generated by the Utah Population Estimates Committee. Municipalities may use compound annual growth rate, average annual growth rate, trend analysis, or a more sophisticated estimating technique of their choice to estimate their 5-year moderate-income housing needs. www.factfinder.census.gov SECTION 1: Population by tenure in the municipality Most Table 801003 2010 Recent American Table 825008 American Community Community Growth 5-Year Survev Survey Rate Proiection Total Population: (ACS Table 801003) 7,043 9,809 5.53% 12,126 Total Population in occupied housing units 7,043 9,809 5.48% 12,077 (ACS Table 825008) Total Population in owneroccupied housing units 6,008 8,449 5.38% 10,342 (ACS Table B25008) Utah Department of Workforce Services Page4of21 Housing and Community Development Division

Total Population in renteroccupied housing units 1,035 1,360 6.20% 1,735 (ACS Table B25008) Subtract the total population living in occupied housing units from the total population to estimate the total population with limited housing. 0 0 0.00% 50 Source!: U.S. Census Bureau. Table 801003: Total population. American Community Survey. Source 2: U.S. Census Bureau. Table B2S008: Total population in occupied housing units by tenure. American Community Survey. SECTION 2: Supply of housing units by structure type in the municipality Most Table 825001 2010 Recent Table 825032 American American Community Community Growth 5-Year Survey Survey Rate Proiection TOTAL HOUSING UNITS (ACS Table B25001) 1,965 2,680-3,247 Total occupied units (ACS Table B25032) 1,899 2,577-3,132 Owner-occupied structures (ACS Table B25032) 1,567 2, 158-2,607 1 unit, detached 1,271 1,980-2,597 1 unit, attached 196 151-79 2 units 0 0 0 0 3 or 4 units 28 0-0 5 to 9 units 45 10-0 10 to 19 units 27 17-0 20 to 49 units 0 0 0 0 50 or more units 0 0 0 0 Mobile homes 0 0 0 0 Boat, RV, van, etc. 0 0 0 0 Renter-occupied structures (ACS Table B25032) 332 419-525 1 unit, detached 85 152-264 1 unit, attached 32 10-0 2 units 0 0 0 0 3 or 4 units 29 33-33 5 to 9 units 21 9-0 10 to 19 units 165 190-199 20 to 49 units 0 0 0 0 50 or more units 0 25-53 Mobile homes 0 0 0 0 Boat, RV, van, etc. 0 0 0 0 Source 1: U.S. Census Bureau. Table 825001: Total housing units. American Community Survey. Source 2: U.S. Census Bureau. Table B25032: Tenure by units in structure. American Community Survey. Utah Department of Workforce Services Page S of 21 Housing and Community Development Division

St ate of Uta h Moderate-I ncome Housing Reporting Form SECTION 3: Housing occupancy in the municipality Most Table 825003 2010 Recent American Table 825081 American Community Community Growth 5-Year Survev Survev Rate Proiection Total households in occupied housing units 1,899 2,577-3,132 (ACS Table B25003) Total households in owneroccupied housing 2, 158 2,158-2,607 (ACS Table B25003) With a Mortgage 1,292 1,655-1,910 (ACS Table B25081) Without a Mortgage (ACS Table B25081) 275 503-697 Total households in renteroccupied housing 332 4 19-525 (ACS Table B25003) Source 1: U. S. Census Bureau. Table 825003: Tenure. Amm,rn Community Survey. Source 2: U.S. Census Bureau. Table B25081: Mortgage status. American Community Survey. SECTION 4: Housing vacancy in the municipality Most Table 825004 2010 Recent American American Community Community Growth 5-Year Survey Survey Rate Projection Total vacant units ( ACS Table B25004) 66 103 - l 16 For rent (ACS Table B25004) 0 27-7 1 Rented, not occupied (ACS Table B25004) 0 0 0 0 For sale only (ACS Table B25004) 0 42-47 Sold, not occupied (ACS Table B25004) 35 0-0 For seasonal, recreat ional, or occasional use 0 0 0 0 ( ACS Table B25004) For migrant worke rs (ACS Table B25004) 0 0 0 0 Other vacant (ACS Table B25004) 31 34-46 Source 1: U.S. Census Bureau. Table 825003: Tenure. Am er1can Community Survey. Utah Department of Workforce Services Page 6 of 21 Hou~ng and Community Development Division

Moderate-I ncome Housing Re porting Form SECTION 5: Average household size of the municipality Most 2010 Recent Table 825010 American American Community Community Survey Survev Average Household Size (ACS Table B25010) 3.71 3.8 1 Average Owner Household Size 3.83 3.92 (ACS Table B25010) Average Renter Household Size 3. 12 3.25 (ACS Table B25010) Source 1: U.S. Census Bureau. Table 625010: Average household size ofoccupied housing units by tenure. American Community Survey. SECTION 6: Monthly median housing costs in the municipality Most Table 825088 2010 Recent American American Table 825064 Community Community Growth Survey Survev Rate Total median owneroccupied housing costs $1,878 $1,868 - (ACS Table B25088) Units with a mortgage (ACS Table B25088) $2, 192 $2,188 - Units without a mortgage (ACS Table B25088) $485 $537 - Median gross rent (ACS Table B25064) $1,034 $964 - Source 1: U.S. Census Bureau. Table 625088: Median selected monthly owner costs (Dollars) by mortgage status. American Community Survey. Source 2: U.S. Census Bureau. Table 625064: Median gross rent (Dollars). American Community Survey. 5-Year Proiection $1,924 $2,1 93 $626 $867 SECTION 7: Median household income in the municipality Most Table 825119 2010 Recent American American Community Community Growth Survey Survev Rate Median household income (ACS Table B25119) $87,536 $9 1,573 - Owner-occupied income (ACS Table B25119) $95,733 $105,903 - Renter-occupied income (ACS Table B25119) $46,429 $41,750 - Source 1: U.S. Census Bureau. Table 625119: Median household income that past 12 months by tenure. American Community Survey. 5-Year Proiection $91,243 $ 11 4,541 $35,933 Utah Department of Workforce Services Page 7 of21 Housing and Community Development Division

Stat e of Utah Moderate-Income Housing Rep orting Form SECTION 8: "COUNTY-LEVEL" Area Median Income (AMI)* Most Table 819019 2010 Recent American Table 819119 American Community Community Growth 5-Year Survey Survey Rate Projection Median HOUSEHOLD income (ACS Table 619019) $58,004 $64,601 - $69,630 1-person household $30,361 $34,113 - $37,360 2-person household $60,637 $67,123 - $72,382 3-person household $68,167 $76,109 - $82,219 4-person household $74,445 $84,644 - $93,41 5 5-person household $74,099 $80,801 - $84,797 6-person household $80,529 $86,423 - $84,802 ~ 7-person household $84,994 $88,98 1 - $86,223 Median FAMILY income (ACS Table 619119) $67,451 $75,066 - $80,592 2-person fanily $60,473 $65,8 17 - $69,559 3-person fanily $66,267 $75,152 - $81,950 4-person fa nily $73,544 $84,384 - $93,504 5-person fanily $74,046 $80,167 - $83,369 6-person fanily $80,593 $86,810 - $85,679 ~ 7-person family $83,674 $86,184 - $83,3 18 Source 1: U.S. Census Bureau. Table B19019: Median household income that past 12 months by household size. AmeriGm Communrty Survey. Source 2: U.S.Census Bureau. Table B19119: Median family income in the past 12 months byfamiysize. American Communny Survey. * NOTE: AMI is always calculated at the COUNTY-LEVEL. Usina the calculations above, exolain the municioalitv's current and oroiected housina needs. Currently the ACS estimates a need for 856 units for moderate income households. Of these units, 417 would need to be affordable to low-income households and 164 would need to be affordable to extremely low-income households. By the year 2023 the ACS estimates the City of Bluffdale will have an estimated demand for 932 moderate-income housing units, 455 of which would be needed for low-income households and 179 of which would be needed for extremely low-income households. The City of Bluffdale currently has 1,505 units affordable to moderate-income households. Of these, 70 non-restricted units and 336 income-restricted units are affordable to low-income households. The 336 income-restricted units receive incentives from three of the city's EDA and RDA bodies pursuant to state statute. The Moderate Income Housing Element (pg. 3 1) of Bluffdale' s General Plan (adopted March 25, 2014) sets a target for 20% of new units to be affordable to moderate-income households. If this target is met, an estimated additional 4 13 affordable units will be available by 2023 which would bring the city's supply to 1,9 18 units. Since the previous biennium, 1,202 multi-family units have received approval and are currently (or soon to be) under constrnction. Utah Department of Workforce Services Pag e8 of 21 Hou~ng and Communny Development Division

PART II: FINDINGS OF THE MODERATE-INCOME HOUSING ELEMENT REVIEW In accordance with UCA 10-9a-408, please complete the following sections to report the findings of the municipal legislative body's review of the moderate-income housing element of the general plan. SECTION 1: Efforts made by the municipality to reduce, mitigate, or eliminate barriers to moderate income housing The following questions were adapted from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development's "Questionnaire for HUD's Initiative on Removal of Regulatory Barriers" (0MB approval no. 2535-0120). 1) {!)Yes QNo 2) QYes {!)No 3) {!>Yes QNo 4) QYes {!)No 5) {!)Yes QNo 6) {!)Yes QNo 7) QYes {!)No 8) QYes {!)No Does the municipality's general plan include a moderate-income housing element that utilizes maps, illustrations, tables, and a detailed analysis of means and techniques to set forth goals, policies, and guidelines intended to direct the jurisdiction's present and future residential development? Does the moderate-income housing element of the municipality's general plan take into account the anticipated growth of the region, for existing and future residents, including low-income, very low-income, and extremely low-income households for at least the next five years? Does the municipality's zoning ordinance and map, development and subdivision regulations or other land use controls conform to the jurisdiction's comprehensive plan regarding moderate-income housing needs by providing: a) Sufficient land use and density categories for multifamily housing, duplexes, small lot homes and other similar elements; and b) Sufficient land zoned or mapped "as-of-right" in these categories, that can permit the building of moderate-income housing addressing the needs identified in the plan? Does the municipality's zoning ordinance set minimum building size requirements that exceed the local housing or health code or is otherwise not based upon explicit health standards? If the municipality has development impact fees, are the fees specified and calculated under local and/or state statutory criteria? Do the municipality's development impact fee statutes provide criteria that set standards for the allowable types of capital investments that have a direct relationship between the fee and the development, and a method for fee calculation? If the municipality has impact fees or other significant fees, does it provide waivers of these fees for moderate-income housing? Has the municipality adopted specific building code language regarding housing rehabilitation that encourages such rehabilitation through gradated regulatory requirements applicable as different levels of work are performed in existing buildings? Utah Department of Workforce Services Page9of21 Housing and Community Development Division

9) {!)Yes QNo 10) {!)Yes QNo 11) {!)Yes QNo 12) (!) Yes Q No 13) QYes {!)No 14) QYes {!)No 15) QYes {!)No 16) QYes {!)No 17) QYes {!)No 18) {!)Yes QNo 19) QYes {!)No 20) QYes {!)No Does the municipality use a recent version of a nationally recognized model building code, published within the last 5 years, without significant technical amendment or modification? Does the municipality's zoning ordinance or land use regulations permit manufactured housing "as-of-right" in all residential districts and zoning classifications in which similar site-built housing is permitted, subject to design, density, building size, foundation requirements, and other similar requirements applicable to other housing that will be deemed realty, irrespective of the method of production? Within the past five years, has a the municipality's legislative body conducted a comprehensive study of, public hearings for, or established a formal ongoing process to review residential development regulations and processes to assess their impact on its supply of moderate-income housing? Has the municipality implemented regulatory reforms consistent with the findings of a comprehensive housing study, public hearings, or periodic reviews in the last five years? Within the past five years, has the municipality modified infrastructure standards and/or authorized the use of new infrastructure technologies ( e.g. water, sewer, street width) to significantly reduce the cost of housing? Does the municipality grant sufficient density bonuses to offset the cost of building below market units as an incentive for any market rate residential development that includes a portion of moderate-income housing? Has the municipality established a single, consolidated permit application process for housing development that includes building, zoning, engineering, environmental, and related permits? Alternatively, does your jurisdiction conduct concurrent, not sequential, reviews for all required permits and approval~? Does the municipality provide for expedited permitting and approvals for all moderate-income housing projects? Has the municipality established time limits for government review and approval or disapproval of development permits in which failure to act, after the application is deemed complete, by the government within the designated time period, results in automatic approval? Does the municipality allow "accessory apartments" either as: a) a special exception or conditional use in all single-family residential zones or, b) "as-ofright" in a majority of residential districts otherwise zoned for single-family housing? Does the municipality have an explicit policy that adjusts or waives existing parking requirements for all moderate-income housing developments? Does the municipality require moderate-income housing projects to undergo public review or special hearings when the project is otherwise in full compliance with the zoning ordinance and other development regulations? Utah Department of Workforce Services Page 10of21 Housing and Community Developm ent Division

21) What other efforts has the municipality made to reduce, mitigate, or eliminate barriers to moderate-income housing? Incentives from EDA/RDA to subsidize affordable housing units, allowed accessory dwelling units in all detached single family zones as a conditional use to develop additional housing on the west side of Bluffdale, etc. SECTION 2: Report the municipality's actions to encourage the preservation of existing moderate-income housing and development of new moderate-income housing during the preceding biennium? During the previous biennium (2016-present) the city approved 1,202 new multi-family units in higher density developments, several of which are currently (or soon to be) under construction. Additionally, three property owners applied, and received approval, for an accessory dwelling unit in their home. The City of Bluffdale also utilized affordable housing funds set aside from local EDA and RD As pursuant to statute. Utah Department of Workforce Services Page 11 of 21 Housing and Community Development Division

SECTION 3: Analyze the municipality's progress in providing moderate-income housing. SUBSECTION 3. 1: Enter data from TABLE 1 and TABLE 2 at the end of this form into the tables below to calculate the municipality's progress in providing affordable and available moderate-income rental housing for the current and previous biennium. Subtract data in TABLE 2 from TABLE 1 to estimate the municipality's progress in providing moderate-income housing. Finally, in each table below subtract the number of affordable units from the number of renter households and then subtract the number of available units from the number of renter households to estimate the municipality's moderate-income housing gap. Calculate the municipality's housing gap for the current biennium by entering the number of moderate-income renter households, affordable rental units, and available rental units in the municipality from TABLE 1 below: Renter Affordable Available Affordable Units Available Units Households Rental Units Rental Units - Renter Households - Renter Households :S: 80% HAMFI 55 25 0-30 -55 < 50% HAMFI 120 140 70 20-50 :S: 30% HAMFI 260 340 245 80-15 Calculate the municipality's housing gap for the previous biennium by entering the number of moderate-income renter households, affordable rental units, and available rental units in the municipality from TABLE 2 below: Renter Affordable Available Affordable Units Available Units Households Rental Units Rental Units - Renter Households - Renter Households :s: 80% HAMFI 50 35 15-15 -20 < 50% HAMFI 130 120 60-10 -70 :S: 30% HAMFI 235 325 240 90 5 Subtract data from TABLE 2 from TABLE 1 to estimate progress in providing moderate-income housing Renter Affordable Available Affordable Units Available Units Households Rental Units Rental Units - Renter Households - Renter Households :s: 80% HAMFI 5-10 -1 5-15 -20 < 50% HAMFI -10 20 10 30 20 < 30% HAMFI 25 15 5-10 -20 SUBSECTION 3.2: Report the number of all housing units in the municipality that are currently subsidized by each level of government below: Municipal Government o State Government ------ o ------ Federal Government 336 ------ SUBSECTION 3.3: Report the number of all housing units in the municipality that are currently deed-restricted for moderate-income households in the box below: ~, 33-6----~ Utah Department of Workforce Services Page 12of21 Housing and Community Development Division

SECTION 4: Report all efforts made by the city to coordinate moderate income housing plans and actions with neighboring municipalities or associations of governments established by an interlocal agreement under Title 11, Chapter 13, lnterlocal Cooperation Act during the preceding biennium. The City of Bluffdale will provide a copy of this year's report to its neighboring municipalities as well as any other interested bodies and is open to discussing the findings with them. Additionally, members of the City Council, Planning Commission, residents, and staff participated in the Wasatch Choice 2050 discussion with regional planning agencies and other local municipalities and discussed items such as transit options, job centers, and other development opportunities in the region. Utah Department of Workforce Services Page 13 of21 Housing and Community Development Division

SECTION 5: Report the municipality's efforts to utilize the moderate income housing setasides from redevelopment agencies, community development agencies, or economic development agencies by completing the following tables. Project Area Name: Eastern Bluffdale EDA Agency type: Start date: Expiration date: Initial value: Future value: % Rate per yr.: Amount collected: Amount expended: EDA 01/01/2008 12/31/2023 0.012412 Description of moderate-income housing set-aside utilization: 20% of funds allocated to affordable housing incentives, rent offsets. Project Area Name: Agency type: Start date: Expiration date: Initial value: Future value: % Rate per yr.: Amount collected: Amount expended: Gateway RDA RDA 01 /01/2010 12/31 /2024 0.012412 Description of moderate-income housinq set-aside utilization: 20% of funds allocated to affordable housing incentives, rent offsets. Project Area Name: Agency type: Start date: Expiration date: Initial value: Future value: % Rate per yr.: Amount collected: Amount expended: Jordan Narrows EDA EDA Description of moderate-income housing set-aside utilization: 01 /01 /20 11 20% of funds allocated to affordable housing incentives, rent offsets. 12/31/2025 0.012412 Project Area Name: Agency type: Start date: Expiration date: Initial value: Future value: % Rate per yr.: Amount collected: Amount expended: Description of moderate-income housinq set-aside utilization: Utah Department of Workforce Services Page 14 of21 Housing and Community Development Division

SECTION 6: Report the money expended by the municipality to pay or waive constructionrelated fees required by the municipality during the preceding biennium. None at this time. SECTION 7: Provide a description of the programs of the Utah Housing Corporation that were utilized by the municipality during the preceding biennium. None at this time. Utah Department of Workforce Services Page 16 of21 Housing and Community Development Division

INSTRUCTIONS (3 OF 3): SUBMISSION GUIDELINES: 1. Biennial moderate-income housing review reports are due on December 31st of each year. 2. Emails must include the following items as separate attachments: (a) A findings report of the biennial moderate-income housing element review (b) The most current version of the moderate-income housing element of the municipality's general plan ( c) A copy of the resolution formally adopting the current moderate income housing element as part of the municipality's general plan ( d) A link to the biennial report on the municipality's website 3. Acceptable electronic document formats include: (a) DOC, DOCX, RTF, OTD, and PDF 4. Emails MUST be addressed to: biennialreporting@utah.gov For additional moderate-income housing planning resources, please visit: https: //jobs. uta h. gov/housing/affordable/ moderate/ind ex. htm I Utah Department of Workforce Services Page 17 of21 Housing and Community Development Division