HOUSING AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT FOUNDATION RECENT DEVELOPMENTS IN HOUSING FINANCE IN LITHUANIA Eduardas Kazakevičius 1
SUMMARY! Macro environment conducive of housing finance development: GDP, prices, interest rates, source of funds! Growing demand for mortgage loans! Legal / institutional barriers to improvement of the existing stock! Historically, lack of policy coordination of housing programs! Development of the National Housing Strategy 2
MACROECONOMIC FRAMEWORK Lithuanian macroeconomic indicators, 1996-2002* (*forecast)! Local banks sold to foreign investors 30 25 20 GDP growth! Pension funds not active yet % 15 10 5 Inflation! Insurance sector is picking up 0-5 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 Nominal interest rates of loans in Lt -10 3
MACROECONOMIC FRAMEWORK EURO / MONTH 2400 2000 1600 1200 800 400 0 Households income and expenditure in income deciles 116 174 232 261 290 434 507 579 869 2317 I II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X Deciles Total expenditure Total income! 35,000 real estate sales yearly! 5,161 mortgage loans in 2001! 9,000 mortgage loans expected in 2002 for 180 mln. EUR! Average loan of 19,000 EURO (2002)! Banks have funds to meet mortgage demand 4
BASIC FACTS ABOUT HOUSING SECTOR! 1.3 million dwellings: - 37% private houses, - 60% private apartments, - 3% municipal housing.! Age structure: - 26% built before 1960, - 65%: 1960-1990, - 9%: after 1990. Major imbalances:! Tenure: 97% private, only 3% municipal rental stock! Standards: poor condition, lack of proper management! Location: surplus in rural areas, lack in developing areas 5
BASIC FACTS ABOUT HOUSING SECTOR New housing construction, 1995-2002* (* - forecast)! 1.04 household per Number of dwellings completed 6000 5000 4000 3000 2000 1000 0 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002* 3+ dwelling buildings 1-2 dwelling buildings dwelling (difference of 48,000);! 2.5 rooms and 2.7 persons per dwelling;! Construction = 0.3% of housing stock (1-1.5 in mature markets)! Around 90% of multifamily buildings need renovation and improvement of energy efficiency. 6
SOURCE OF FUNDS FOR HOUSING FINANCE Housing acquisition:! Government budget no longer used! Domestic bank deposits! Foreign bank deposits! Mortgage bonds: draft law submitted to the Parliament! Homeowners equity: savings and privatized apartments Multifamily building renovation and upgrade:! The World Bank loan forming a revolving fund! Credit enhancements aimed at involvement of commercial financial institutions (since 2003) 7
LENDING INSTRUMENTS! Typical terms of market mortgages (for 2002): 5-7% interest rate, 10-25 year maturity, 20-30 % downpayment! State support to homebuyers: - State mortgage insurance: downpayment down to 5%, (maximum insurance charge is 4,34% in 2002) - Soft loan interest subsidies (till 2003) - Mortgage interest deductibility (since 2003) - Capital grants for special social groups 8
MORTGAGE DEMAND! 80% of households intend to improve their housing: - 67% repair or remodel existing housing - 23% buy new dwelling (house or apartment)! Preferred financing of housing improvements: - personal savings: 66% YES / 27% NO - assistance from relatives: 35% YES / 56% NO - bank loan: 19% YES / 69% NO; - lease: 9% YES / 73% NO 9
MORTGAGE DEMAND Number of dwellings completed 9000 8000 7000 6000 5000 4000 3000 2000 1000 0 Forecast of housing completions for different scenarios, 2002-2007* (* - CMHC forecast) Only 6% of Lithuanian households used bank loans for housing:! Income gap! Equity gap! Effort ratio! Preferences 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002* 2003* 2004* 2005* 2006* 2007* Status Quo Positive Growth Slowdown 10
REGULATORY AND INSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK Challenges:! Constitutional problem with homeowners associations HOA! Mortgage liens on apartments to protect lenders! Eviction rights and children s rights! Credit underwriting of housing borrowers! Collateral value uncertainty! Shifting housing policy interventions! Mortgage bonds acceptable to the investment market 11
GOVERNMENT HOUSING RELATED PROGRAMS! State support law: instrument changes in 2002! Utility compensation: amended in 2002! Mortgage insurance: amended in 2002! Mortgage bonds: submitted to Parliament in 2002! Energy Efficiency Housing Pilot Project: re-lending! Interest deduction: replace interest subsidies in 2003! Subsidized contract savings: rejected as too expensive 12
NATIONAL HOUSING STRATEGY Basic Framework Goals: Broad housing choice Efficient use of existing housing Efficient provision of new housing Basic social / economic principles and preferences Objectives: Improved tenure choice Enhanced ability to pay Improved housing mobility Responsible homeownership Improved existing housing stock Non-profit housing Programs: Tools: Legal, technical, financial constrains Cost benefit criteria 13
NATIONAL HOUSING STRATEGY Emerging recommendations on housing finance programs:! Interest rate subsidy: NO, but previous commitments honored! Interest deduction: YES(?), but with targeting and cost control! Up front grants: YES, to selected buyers (young families)! Unsubsidized mortgage bonds: YES, issued by anyone! Subsidized contract savings: NO, too expensive intermediary! Mortgage insurance: YES, with more targeting! Credit bureaus: YES, for better credit underwriting! Lending to HOAs: YES, but credit enhance. needed by banks! HOA grants / loans on energy efficiency: YES, but small scale! Mortgage lien on apartments: YES, but need Civil Code change! Alternative to mortgage liens: YES, if effectively protect lenders 14