III. Approval of Agenda {Action: Approved Motion: Howard Second: Brooks Vote: 5-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Yes; Heard-Yes}

Transcription

1 Official Public Hearing Minutes (Present: Charlotte J. Nash, Jace Brooks, Lynette Howard, Tommy Hunter, John Heard) I. Call To Order, Invocation, Pledge to Flag II. Opening Remarks by Chairman III. Approval of Agenda {Action: Approved Motion: Howard Second: Brooks Vote: 5-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Yes; IV. Announcements V. Public Hearing - Old Business SUP , Applicant: Robert and Kim Lawrence, Owners: Robert and Kim Lawrence, Tax Parcel No. R , Application for a Special Use Permit in a R-140 Zoning District for an Accessory Building Greater than 1,000 Square Feet, 4400 Block of Alpine Court and 4400 Block of Hapsburg Way, 1.31 Acres. District 3/Hunter [Planning Department Recommendation: Approve with Conditions] [Planning Commission Recommendation: Deny] {Action: Denied Motion: Hunter Second: Nash Vote: 5-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Yes; RZC , Applicant: Fuqua Acquisitions II, LLC c/o Mahaffey Pickens Tucker, LLP, Owner: WB Holdings-Gwinnett, LLC, Rezoning of Tax Parcel Nos. R and 004B, C-2, O-I and RA-200 to MU-R; Regional Mixed-Use Development, 2900 Block of Buford Drive, Acres. District 4/Heard [Planning Department Recommendation: Approve with Conditions][Planning Commission Recommendation: Approve with Conditions] {Action: Approved with Change Motion: Heard Second: Howard Vote: 5-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Yes;

2 Page 2 V. Public Hearing - Old Business SUP , Applicant: Fuqua Acquisitions II, LLC c/o Mahaffey Pickens Tucker, LLP, Owner: WB Holdings-Gwinnett, LLC, Tax Parcel Nos. R and 004B, Application for a Special Use Permit in a MU-R (Proposed) Zoning District for a Recreation and Entertainment Facility (Outdoor), 2900 Block of Buford Drive, Acres. District 4/Heard [Planning Department Recommendation: Approve with Conditions][Planning Commission Recommendation: Approve with Conditions] {Action: Approved with Change Motion: Heard Second: Howard Vote: 5-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Yes; RZC , Applicant: Tim Landers, Owner: Billy Landers, Rezoning of Tax Parcel No. R , R-100 to C-2; Self- Storage (Climate Controlled), 3900 Block of Five Forks Trickum Road, 0.72 Acre. District 2/Howard (Tabled on 11/27/2018)(Tabled to 12/18/2018 Public Hearing)(Public hearing was not held)[planning Department Recommendation: Approve with Conditions][Planning Commission Recommendation: Tabled - Date: 12/4/2018] {Action: Tabled Motion: Howard Second: Brooks Vote: 5-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks- Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Yes; SUP , Applicant: Tim Landers, Owner: Billy Landers, Tax Parcel No. R , Application for a Special Use Permit in a C-2 (Proposed) Zoning District for Self-Storage (Climate Controlled), 3900 Block of Five Forks Trickum Road, 0.72 Acre. District 2/Howard (Tabled on 11/27/2018)(Tabled to 12/18/2018 Public Hearing) (Public hearing was not held)[planning Department Recommendation: Approve with Conditions][Planning Commission Recommendation: Tabled - Date: 12/4/2018] {Action: Tabled Motion: Howard Second: Brooks Vote: 5-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Yes;

3 Page 3 V. Public Hearing - Old Business RZM , Formerly Applicant: Edge City Properties, Inc. c/o Mahaffey Pickens Tucker, LLP, Owner: Richard Craig, Rezoning of Tax Parcel Nos. R & 524, R-75 to R-TH; Townhouses (Buffer Reduction), 1400 Block of Five Forks Trickum Road, Acres. District 4/Heard [Planning Department Recommendation: Deny][Planning Commission Recommendation: Approve with Conditions] {Action: Approved with Change Motion: Heard Second: Brooks Vote: 5-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Yes; RZM , Formerly , Applicant: Casgwyn Construction, LLC, Owner: Realestate Remarketing, LLC, Rezoning of Tax Parcel No. R , R-100 to R-TH; Townhouses (Buffer Reduction), 1900 Block of Pucketts Drive, 4.47 Acres. District 2/Howard (Tabled on 11/27/2018)(Tabled to 12/18/2018 Public Hearing)(Public hearing was not held)[planning Department Recommendation: Deny] [Planning Commission Recommendation: Approve with Conditions] {Action: Tabled Motion: Howard Second: Brooks Vote: 5-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Yes; RZM , Applicant: Brand Properties, LLC c/o Mahaffey Pickens Tucker, LLP, Owners: Sugarloaf Land Investments, LLC, Sugarloaf Marketplace Phase I, LLC & Sugarloaf Marketplace, LLC, Rezoning of Tax Parcel Nos. R , R and R , R- 100 and C-2 to RM-24; Apartments (Buffer Reduction), 1800 Block of Duluth Highway and 5600 Block of Sugarloaf Parkway, 8.55 Acres. District 1/Brooks [Planning Department Recommendation: Approve with Conditions][Planning Commission Recommendation: Approve with Conditions] {Action: Approved with Change Motion: Brooks Second: Howard Vote: 5-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Yes;

4 Page 4 V. Public Hearing - Old Business RZR , Formerly & Applicant: Home South Communities, LLC c/o Mahaffey Pickens Tucker, LLP, Owner: John T. Lamb, Rezoning of Tax Parcel No. R , RA- 200 to OSC; Single-Family Subdivision, 2400 Block of Sunny Hill Road and 2500 Block of Morgan Road, Acres. District 4/Heard (Tabled on 11/27/2018)(Tabled to 12/18/2018 Public Hearing)(Public hearing was not held)[planning Department Recommendation: Approve with Conditions] [Planning Commission Recommendation: Tabled - Date: 12/4/2018] {Action: Tabled Motion: Heard Second: Brooks Vote: 5-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Yes; RZR , Applicant: Pulte Group, Inc. c/o Alliance Engineering and Planning, Owners: Janice F. Lee, Whitney Corbin Lee, and Brenda Corbin Lee c/o Alliance Engineering and Planning, Rezoning of Tax Parcel Nos. R , 201, 272 and 273, R-100 and RA-200 to OSC; Single-Family Subdivision, 3500 Block of River Drive, 21.8 Acres. District 2/Howard [Planning Department Recommendation: Deny] [Planning Commission Recommendation: Approve with Conditions] {Action: Approved with Stipulations Motion: Howard Second: Brooks Vote: 5-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Yes; RZR , Applicant: GCIP SIX, LLC, c/o Mahaffey Pickens Tucker, LLP, Owner: GCIP SIX, LLC, Rezoning of Tax Parcel Nos. R and R , R-100 to OSC; Single-Family Subdivision, 3900 Block of Lake Carlton Road, Acres. District 3/Hunter (Tabled on 11/27/2018) (Tabled to 12/18/2018 Public Hearing)(Public hearing was not held)[planning Department Recommendation: Deny][Planning Commission Recommendation: Tabled - Date: 12/4/2018] {Action: Tabled Motion: Hunter Second: Brooks Vote: 5-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Yes;

5 Page 5 V. Public Hearing - Old Business RZR , Applicant: Stone Manor Holdings c/o Mahaffey Pickens Tucker, LLP, Owners: Stone Manor Holdings, LLC, Mary Imogene Fowler, JML Rev. Trust U/T/A and Timothy J. Boyle, Rezoning of Tax Parcel Nos. R B, 033, 044, and 045, RA-200, R- 75 MOD and C-2 to TND; Traditional Neighborhood Development (Buffer Reduction), 3100 Block of South Puckett Road and 3400 Block of Hamilton Mill Road, Acres. District 4/Heard [Planning Department Recommendation: Approve with Conditions][Planning Commission Recommendation: Approve with Conditions] {Action: Approved with Change Motion: Heard Second: Brooks Vote: 5-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Yes; RZR , Formerly , Applicant: The Providence Group of Georgia, LLC, Owners: Myron and Linda Baynes, Baynes Family, LLC and Yuling Hayter, Rezoning of Tax Parcel Nos. R , 043, 045 and 047, R-100 to TND; Traditional Neighborhood Development (Buffer Reduction), 3200 Block of Suwanee Creek Road, Acres. District 1/Brooks [Planning Commission Recommendation: Approve with Conditions] {Action: Approved with Stipulations Motion: Brooks Second: Heard Vote: 5-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Yes; RZR , Applicant: CKK Development, Owner: Charlotte Chaffin, Rezoning of Tax Parcel No. R , R-100 to R- TH; Townhouses (Buffer Reduction), 2800 Block of Rosebud Road, 8.06 Acres. District 3/Hunter (Tabled on 11/27/2018) (Tabled to 12/18/2018 Public Hearing)(Public hearing was not held)[planning Department Recommendation: Approve with Conditions][Planning Commission Recommendation: Deny] {Action: Tabled Motion: Hunter Second: Brooks Vote: 5-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Yes;

6 Page 6 V. Public Hearing - Old Business RZR , Applicant: Michael J. Caswell, Owner: DWE Investments LLLP, Rezoning of Tax Parcel Nos. R , R and R , RA-200 to R-75; Single-Family Subdivision, 2500 Block of Bold Springs Road, Acres. District 3/Hunter (Tabled on 11/27/2018)(Tabled to 12/18/2018 Business Session)(Public hearing was held)[planning Department Recommendation: Approve with Conditions As R-100][Planning Commission Recommendation: Approve with Conditions As - OSC] {Action: Tabled Motion: Hunter Second: Howard Vote: 4-0-1; Nash-Abstained; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Yes; RZR (Amended), Applicant: Mahaffey Pickens Tucker, LLP, Owners: Charles William Nix, James E. Nix, Jr. and Kenneth Redmond, Rezoning of Tax Parcel Nos. R , 011 and 030, RA-200 and R-100 to R-SR; Senior Oriented Residences, 300 Block of Cooper Road and 500 Block of Hope Hollow Road, Acres. District 3/Hunter [Planning Department Recommendation: Approve with Conditions][Planning Commission Recommendation: Approve with Conditions] {Action: Approved with Change Motion: Hunter Second: Brooks Vote: 2-3; Nash-No; Brooks-Yes; Howard-No; Hunter-Yes; Heard-No; Motion Failed} {Action: Approved with Change Motion: Heard Second: Howard Vote: 3-2; Nash-Yes; Brooks-No; Howard-Yes; Hunter-No; VI. Public Hearing - New Business 1. Support Services/Angelia Parham Approval/authorization for the Chairman to execute any and all documents necessary to abandon, declare as surplus, and to authorize disposition of 5,144 square feet (0.118 acres) of right-of-way formerly used as a public road known as Old Pucketts Mill Road and to quitclaim and release 3,495 square feet (0.080 acres) of associated slope easement located in Land Lot 1 of the 1st Land District in accordance with O.C.G.A and O.C.G.A Subject to approval as to form by the Law Department. District 4/Heard (Staff Recommendation: Approval) {Action: Approved Motion: Heard Second: Howard Vote: 5-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Yes;

7 Page 7 VI. Public Hearing - New Business 1. Support Services/Angelia Parham Approval/authorization for the Chairman to execute any and all documents necessary to abandon, declare as surplus, and to authorize disposition of 6,223 square feet (0.143 acres) of right-of-way formerly used as a public road known as Hamilton Creek Parkway located in Land Lot 2 of the 3rd Land District in accordance with O.C.G.A and O.C.G.A Subject to approval as to form by the Law Department. District 3/Hunter (Staff Recommendation: Approval) {Action: Approved Motion: Hunter Second: Brooks Vote: 5-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Yes; Approval/authorization for the Chairman to execute any and all documents necessary to abandon, declare as surplus, and to authorize disposition of 685 square feet (0.016 acres) of Hamilton Creek Parkway right-of-way located in Land Lot 2 of the 3rd Land District in accordance with O.C.G.A and O.C.G.A Subject to approval as to form by the Law Department. District 3/Hunter (Staff Recommendation: Approval) {Action: Approved Motion: Hunter Second: Brooks Vote: 5-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Yes; 2. Change in Conditions CIC , Applicant: pb2 architecture + engineering, Owner: Walmart Real Estate Business Trust, Tax Parcel No. R , Change in Conditions of Zoning for Property Zoned C-2, 4900 Block of Jimmy Carter Boulevard and 1100 Block of Rockbridge Road, Acres. District 2/Howard (Tabled on 11/27/2018)(Tabled to 12/04/2018 Business Session)(Public hearing was held)[planning Department Recommendation: Approve with Conditions][Planning Commission Recommendation: Approve with Conditions] {Action: Tabled Motion: Howard Second: Brooks Vote: 5-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Yes;

8 Page 8 VI Public Hearing - New Business 2. Change in Conditions SUP , Applicant: pb2 architecture + engineering, Owner: Walmart Real Estate Business Trust, Tax Parcel No. R , Application for a Special Use Permit in a C-2 Zoning District for Outdoor Sales, Storage or Display (Retail), 4900 Block of Jimmy Carter Boulevard and 1100 Block of Rockbridge Road, Acres. District 2/Howard (Tabled on 11/27/2018)(Tabled to 12/04/2018 Business Session)(Public hearing was held)[planning Department Recommendation: Approve with Conditions][Planning Commission Recommendation: Approve with Conditions] {Action: Tabled Motion: Howard Second: Brooks Vote: 5-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Yes; CIC , Applicant: Yuridia Barcenas Hernandez, Owner: Souter Holding, LLC, Tax Parcel No. R , Change in Conditions of Zoning for Property Zoned M-2, 4100 Block of Arcadia Industrial Circle, 1.0 Acre. District 2/Howard [Planning Department Recommendation: Approve with Conditions][Planning Commission Recommendation: Approve with Conditions] {Action: Approved with Stipulations Motion: Howard Second: Brooks Vote: 5-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Yes; CIC , Applicant: Mahaffey Pickens Tucker, LLP, Owner: Wayne H. Mason, Tax Parcel No. R , Change in Conditions of Zoning for Property Zoned R-TH (Buffer Reduction), 2500 Block of Highpoint Road, 6.17 Acres. District 3/Hunter [Planning Department Recommendation: Deny][Planning Commission Recommendation: Approve with Conditions] {Action: Approved with Change Motion: Hunter Second: Brooks Vote: 5-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks- Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Yes;

9 Page 9 VI. Public Hearing - New Business 3. Special Use Permit SUP , Applicant: Sky King of Lawrenceville, LLC, Owner: JR Lawrenceville, LLC, Tax Parcel No. R , Application for a Special Use Permit in a C-2 Zoning District for Firework Sales (Renewal), 1900 Block of Duluth Highway and 2100 Block of Breckinridge Boulevard, 3.2 Acres. District 1/Brooks [Planning Department Recommendation: Approve with Conditions][Planning Commission Recommendation: Approve with Conditions] {Action: Approved with Stipulations Motion: Brooks Second: Howard Vote: 5-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Yes; SUP , Applicant: Chetsada Ronpirin, Owner: Chetsada Ronpirin, Tax Parcel No. R , Application for a Special Use Permit in a M-1 Zoning District for Automobile Body and Repair Shop, 4100 Block of Arcadia Industrial Circle, 1.53 Acres. District 2/Howard[Planning Department Recommendation: Approve with Conditions][Planning Commission Recommendation: Approve with Conditions] {Action: Approved with Stipulations Motion: Howard Second: Nash Vote: 4-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Out of Room; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Yes; SUP , Applicant: Akram Abdelmasih, Owner: William and Patricia Quick, Tax Parcel No. R , Application for a Special Use Permit in a C-2 Zoning District for Automobile Body and Repair Shop, 3600 Block of Hewatt Court, 0.48 Acre. District 3/Hunter [Planning Department Recommendation: Approve with Conditions] [Planning Commission Recommendation: Approve with Conditions] {Action: Approved with Change Motion: Hunter Second: Brooks Vote: 5-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Yes;

10 Page 10 VI. Public Hearing - New Business 4. Rezonings RZC , Applicant: Mahaffey Pickens Tucker, LLP, Owner: Freeport Title & Guaranty, Inc., Rezoning of Tax Parcel Nos. R7005, 003, 021 and 022, O-I to C-2; Commercial Retail (Buffer Reduction), Blocks of Sugarloaf Parkway, 2.32 Acres. District 4/Heard [Planning Department Recommendation: Deny][Planning Commission Recommendation: Approve with Conditions] {Action: Approved with Stipulations Motion: Nash Second: Howard Vote: 3-0-1; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Out of Room; Heard- Abstained} RZR , Applicant: Jeffery O Mara, Owner: Jeffery O Mara, Rezoning of Tax Parcel No. R , RA-200 to R-100; Single- Family Subdivision, 1000 Block of Bailey Woods Road, 3.09 Acres. District 3/Hunter [Planning Department Recommendation: Approve with Conditions][Planning Commission Recommendation: Approve with Conditions] {Action: Approved with Stipulations Motion: Nash Second: Brooks Vote: 4-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Out of Room; RZR , Applicant: Prime Consulting, Inc., Owner: Billy J. Sharpton, Rezoning of Tax Parcel Nos. R and R , R-100 to OSC; Single-Family Subdivision, 1600 Block of Chandler Road and Blocks of Sharpton Trail, Acres. District 3/Hunter (Tabled on 11/27/2018) (Tabled to 12/18/2018 Public Hearing)(Public hearing was not held)[planning Department Recommendation: Approve with Conditions][Planning Commission Recommendation: Tabled - Date: 12/4/2018] {Action: Tabled Motion: Hunter Second: Brooks Vote: 5-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Yes;

11 Page 11 VI. Public Hearing - New Business 4. Rezonings RZR , Applicant: Hodges Family Properties, Owners: David A. and Connie Davis, Lillian F. Davis, and Joseph K. and Michelle Davis, Rezoning of Tax Parcel Nos. R , 005, 019 and 024, RA-200 to R-75; Single-Family Subdivision, 1400 Block of Prospect Road and 1500 Block of Prospect Church Road, Acres. District 4/Heard (Tabled on 11/27/2018)(Tabled to 12/18/2018 Public Hearing) (Public hearing was not held)[planning Department Recommendation: Approve with Conditions][Planning Commission Recommendation: Tabled - Date: 12/4/2018] {Action: Tabled Motion: Heard Second: Brooks Vote: 5-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Yes; RZR , Applicant: Hodges Family Properties, Owners: Kathy D. Puckett and Lillian F. Davis, Rezoning of Tax Parcel Nos. R and 022, RA-200 to R-75; Single-Family Subdivision, Blocks of Prospect Road, 5.34 Acres. District 4/Heard (Tabled on 11/27/2018)(Tabled to 12/18/2018 Public Hearing)(Public hearing was not held)[planning Department Recommendation: Approve with Conditions][Planning Commission Recommendation: Tabled - Date: 12/4/2018] {Action: Tabled Motion: Heard Second: Howard Vote: 5-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Yes; RZR , Applicant: Tina Chafin, Owner: Tina Chafin, Rezoning of Tax Parcel No. R , R-100 MOD to OSC; Single-Family Subdivision, 1700 Block of Holman Road and 4400 Block of Hog Mountain Road, Acres. District 3/Hunter (Tabled on 11/27/2018)(Tabled to 12/18/2018 Public Hearing)(Public hearing was not held)[planning Department Recommendation: Approve with Conditions] [Planning Commission Recommendation: Tabled - Date: 12/4/2018] {Action: Tabled Motion: Hunter Second: Brooks Vote: 5-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Yes;

12 Page 12 VI. Public Hearing - New Business 4. Rezonings RZR , Applicant: Mahaffey Pickens Tucker, LLP, Owner: Seven B s Family LP, Olwen Pearl Bagley, Gary M. Bagley and Terry Lee Bagley, Rezoning of Tax Parcel Nos. R , R , R , 381 and 382, R-75 MOD and R-100 MOD to TND; Traditional Neighborhood Development (Buffer Reduction), 2600 Block of Ivy Creek Road, Acres. District 4/Heard [Planning Department Recommendation: Approve with Conditions][Planning Commission Recommendation: Approve with Conditions] {Action: Approved with Change Motion: Heard Second: Brooks Vote: 4-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Out of Room; RZR , Applicant: Alphonsa Homes, Inc., Owner: Alphonsa Homes Inc., Rezoning of Tax Parcel Nos. R and 033, R-100 and C-2 to OSC; Single-Family Subdivision, 4500 Block of Rosebud Road, Acres. District 3/Hunter (Tabled on 11/27/2018)(Tabled to 12/18/2018 Public Hearing)(Public hearing was not held)[planning Department Recommendation: Deny][Planning Commission Recommendation: Tabled - Date: 12/4/2018] {Action: Tabled Motion: Hunter Second: Brooks Vote: 5-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Yes; 5. Planning & Development/Kathy S. Holland SNC Street Name Change from Nelson Pointe Drive to Strivers Row. Applicant: Derrick Gross. District 6, Land Lot 095. District 2/Howard {Action: Denied Motion: Howard Second: Brooks Vote: 4-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Out of Room;

13 Page 13 VII. New Business Ratification of Plat approvals for October 01, 2018 thru October 31, {Action: Approved Motion: Howard Second: Brooks Vote: 4-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks-Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Out of Room; VIII. Comments from Audience IX. Adjournment {Action: Adjourn Motion: Heard Second: Brooks Vote: 4-0; Nash-Yes; Brooks- Yes; Howard-Yes; Hunter-Out of Room;