OCTOBER 2015 ORAL ARGUMENT CALENDAR

Transcription

1 UPDATED: 9/16/2015 OCTOBER 2015 ORAL ARGUMENT CALENDAR Page 0 of 7

2 Updated: 09/16/2015 OCTOBER, 2015 OCTOBER 6, :00 PM (EASTERN TIME) MOTION PANEL: JUDGE STUMBO, PRESIDING JUDGE, JUDGE JAMES LAMBERT AND JUDGE VANMETER. OCTOBER 13, :15 10:45 AM (EASTERN TIME) ORAL ARGUMENT, #2014-CA MR, JAMES HARRIS v RYAN LIBKE CHIEF JUDGE ACREE, PRESIDING JUDGE, JUDGE NICKELL AND JUDGE TAYLOR, ASSOC. 11:00 AM (EASTERN TIME) - COURT MEETING 1:00 PM 1:30 PM (EASTERN TIME) ORAL ARGUMENT, #2014-CA MR, MELISSA CZAJA v DANNY FACKLER- JUDGE COMBS, PRESIDING JUDGE, JUDGE JAMES LAMBERT AND JUDGE VANMETER, ASSOC. PHONE NUMBERS WHERE PANEL MEMBERS CAN BE REACHED WHEN ORAL ARGUMENTS SCHEDULED: BARDSTOWN Contact Diane Thompson (502) FAYETTE Contact Dana Carter (859) FRANKFORT Contact Patricia Brauer - (502)

3 LOCATION: COURT OF APPEALS COURTROOM, 360 DEMOCRAT DRIVE, FRANKFORT, KENTUCKY DATE: Tuesday, October 13, :15 AM PJ: ACREE, HON. GLENN E. NICKELL, HON. C. SHEA TAYLOR, HON. JEFF S. 2014CA JAMES HARRIS v RYAN LIBKE Civil; Immunity: Whether the circuit court erred when it dismissed appellants' negligence claims finding the appellees were cloaked with qualified official immunity. SHELBY COUNTY HON CHARLES R. HICKMAN DEAN, MARK HARRIS, JAMES FULLER, ADAM PETITT, CAROL BRIZENDINE, VICTOR III ULFERTS, STUART LIBKE, RYAN TRIPLE S BOARD OF ADJUSTMENTS & APPEALS TRIPLE S. PLANNING COMMISSION PREVIOUSLY ON AUGUST 19, 2015 AT 3:45 PM IN LOUISVILLE, KENTUCKY 01:00 PM PJ: COMBS, HON. SARA W. LAMBERT, HON. JAMES H. VANMETER, HON. LAURANCE B. 2014CA MELISSA CZAJA v DANNY FACKLER Suit on behalf of the estate of decedent for wrongful death as a result of injuries suffered while confined in the Bullitt County Detention Center.Appeal from entry of partial summary judgment. BULLITT COUNTY HON RODNEY BURRESS MCCOY, DUSTAN CZAJA, MELISSA BRANNON, MARGARET MANDO, JEFFREY BULLOCK, DONNA FACKLER, DANNY Page 1 of 7

4 LOCATION: FAYETTE COUNTY CIRCUIT COURTROOM, COURTROOM I, 4TH FLOOR, 120 NORTH LIMESTONE STREET, LEXINGTON, KENTUCKY DATE: Tuesday, October 27, :30 PM PJ: STUMBO, HON. JANET L. MAZE, HON. IRV TAYLOR, HON. JEFF S. 2014CA CA ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMAPNY v YAMILE PENDONES REYES MOR appeal from jury verdict in favor of Appellee in auto accident case. Issues are whether trial court erred in refusing to set aside verdict and for new trial on grounds of improper closing argument by appellee's counsel, excessive verdict and admission of a portion of deposition testimony. On cross-appeal Appellee argues that trial court improperly modified judgment. FAYETTE COUNTY HON THOMAS L CLARK DITTERT, JAMIE JONES, ERNEST II KELLER, J. ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMAPNY ELLIS, JASON JOHNSON, VINCENT SCOTT, DAVID REYES, YAMILE 02:15 PM PJ: STUMBO, HON. JANET L. MAZE, HON. IRV TAYLOR, HON. JEFF S. 2014CA STEPHON QUILTON CARTER v UNIVERSITY OF KENTUCKY MOR appeal from jury verdict in favor of Appellees. Issues are whether trial court erred in not directing a verdict in favor of Appellant in employment discrimination and wrongful termination case and in rejecting certain expert testimony. FAYETTE COUNTY HON PAMELA R GOODWINE WILLIAMS, AUBREY CARTER, STEPHON KRIZ, BARBARA UNIVERSITY OF KENTUCKY Page 2 of 7

5 LOCATION: FAYETTE COUNTY CIRCUIT COURTROOM, COURTROOM I, 4TH FLOOR, 120 NORTH LIMESTONE STREET, LEXINGTON, KENTUCKY DATE: Tuesday, October 27, :00 PM PJ: MAZE, HON. IRV STUMBO, HON. JANET L. TAYLOR, HON. JEFF S. 2014CA CHARLIE COLEMAN v SANITATION DISTRICT NO. 1 OF NORTHERN KENTUCKY Summary judgment and declaratory judgment action regarding rate increases by sanitation district. Coleman, et al. challenged the legality of the increases in light of new legislation resulting in KRS and.035 which altered the process for approving such rate increases. Whether the new legislation applied to the contested rate increases; whether a rational relationship existed between the service charges and the benefit realized; whether the doctrine of laches precluded appellants' claims. Both parties request oral argument. CAMPBELL COUNTY HON FRED A STINE GATLIN, JACK VOELKER, BRANDON COLEMAN, CHARLIE MANDO, JEFFREY SANITATION DISTRICT NO. 1 OF NORTHERN KENTUCKY Page 3 of 7

6 LOCATION: FAYETTE COUNTY CIRCUIT COURTROOM, COURTROOM I, 4TH FLOOR, 120 NORTH LIMESTONE STREET, LEXINGTON, KENTUCKY DATE: Wednesday, October 28, :00 AM PJ: TAYLOR, HON. JEFF S. MAZE, HON. IRV STUMBO, HON. JANET L. 2014CA JESSICA M. BURDETTE v COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY Whether circuit court properly denied appellant's motion to suppress evidence. CRIMINAL MADISON COUNTY HON JEAN CHENAULT LOGUE HART, JASON SCHMIDT, KATHLEEN BURDETTE, JESSICA CONWAY, JACK PRATHER, JEFFREY COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY 10:45 AM PJ: TAYLOR, HON. JEFF S. MAZE, HON. IRV STUMBO, HON. JANET L. 2012CA CA CA CABINET FOR HEALTH AND FAMILY SERVICES v COURIER-JOURNAL, INC CA and 2014-CA Whether the Cabinet violated the Open Records Act; whether circuit court properly awarded attorney's fees and statutory penalties; 2012-CA Whether Appeal Nos CA and 2014-CA should be dismissed as moot or alternatively affirmed upon grounds of res judicata. FRANKLIN COUNTY HON PHILLIP J. SHEPHERD HEAVRIN, CHRISTINA IRVIN, D SNYDER, SHERYL CABINET FOR HEALTH AND FAMILY SERVICES ABATE, MICHAEL FLEISCHAKER, JON ROGERS, JEREMY HOULIHAN, ROBERT JR SKIDMORE, KIF ADAMS, AMELIA WEST, B. COURIER-JOURNAL, INC. LEXINGTON H-L SERVICES, INC. THE NATIONAL COUNCIL OF JEWISH WOMEN WATKINS, PATRICK Page 4 of 7

7 LOCATION: FAYETTE COUNTY CIRCUIT COURTROOM, COURTROOM I, 4TH FLOOR, 120 NORTH LIMESTONE STREET, LEXINGTON, KENTUCKY DATE: Wednesday, October 28, :30 AM PJ: TAYLOR, HON. JEFF S. MAZE, HON. IRV STUMBO, HON. JANET L. 2012CA CABINET FOR HEALTH AND FAMILY SERVICES v THE TODD COUNTY STANDARD, INC. Whether circuit court properly ordered the Cabinet to produce certain records; whether the circuit court erred by awarding attorney's fees and statutory penalties. FRANKLIN COUNTY HON PHILLIP J. SHEPHERD HEAVRIN, CHRISTINA IRVIN, D WOMACK, MONA CABINET FOR HEALTH AND FAMILY SERVICES ADAMS, AMELIA ABATE, MICHAEL FLEISCHAKER, JON ROGERS, JEREMY NATIONAL COUNCIL OF JEWISH WOMEN THE TODD COUNTY STANDARD, INC. Page 5 of 7

8 LOCATION: NELSON COUNTY JUSTICE CENTER, DISTRICT COURTROOM, 200 NELSON COUNTY PLAZA, BARDSTOWN, KENTUCKY DATE: Thursday, October 29, :00 AM PJ: JONES, HON. ALLISON E. LAMBERT, HON. DEBRA HEMBREE THOMPSON, HON. KELLY 2014CA PUTNAM & SONS, LLC v PADUCAH INDEPENDENT SCHOOL DISTRICT Civil; Appeal of Court's determination of just compensation in a condemnation action. Issues involving eminent domain and constitutional standard of just compensation market value. MCCRACKEN COUNTY BIERSDORF, DANIEL WRIGHT, SAMUEL HON CRAIG Z CLYMER PUTNAM & SONS, LLC WHITLOW, MARK PADUCAH INDEPENDENT SCHOOL DISTRICT 10:45 AM PJ: JONES, HON. ALLISON E. LAMBERT, HON. DEBRA HEMBREE THOMPSON, HON. KELLY 2015CA DONNA THOMAS v EDDIE'S SERVICE CENTER WC; Whether the order of the Workers' Compensation Board affirming the dismissal of Appellant's claim was proper. WORKERS COMP WOODFORD COUNTY RICHARDSON, PAULA THOMAS, DONNA BOLTON, STEVEN HUTSON, RICHARD LOVAN, DWIGHT BOLTON, STEVEN EDDIE'S SERVICE CENTER WORKERS' COMPENSATION BOARD Page 6 of 7

9 LOCATION: NELSON COUNTY JUSTICE CENTER, DISTRICT COURTROOM, 200 NELSON COUNTY PLAZA, BARDSTOWN, KENTUCKY DATE: Thursday, October 29, :30 PM PJ: LAMBERT, HON. DEBRA HEMBREE JONES, HON. ALLISON E. THOMPSON, HON. KELLY 2014CA SAMUEL PATTON v COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY Whether the trial court properly overruled the motion to withdraw Appellants guilty plea which was taken after a jury returned a guilty verdict. CRIMINAL EDMONSON COUNTY HON RONNIE C DORTCH MASCAGNI, FRANK III PATTON, SAMUEL VAN DE ROSTYNE, THOMAS COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY 01:15 PM PJ: LAMBERT, HON. DEBRA HEMBREE JONES, HON. ALLISON E. THOMPSON, HON. KELLY 2014CA ROBERT HUXOL v DAVIESS COUNTY FISCAL COURT Whether the Daviess County Fiscal Court properly rezoned acreage from urban and rural agricultural to coal mining uses. DAVIESS COUNTY HON JOSEPH W CASTLEN FITZGERALD, THOMAS OVERSTREET, KENT HUXOL, ROBERT PORTER, CLAUD KNIGHT, TERRA HAYNES, BRIAN DAVIESS COUNTY FISCAL COURT OWENSBORO METROPOLITAN PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION RUBY JEAN HITCHCOCK REVOCABLE LIVING TRUST Page 7 of 7