A Comparative Study on the Effectiveness of Housing Allowance on Tenant Households in the UK, the Netherlands and Sweden
|
|
- Alicia Nash
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 A Comparative Study on the Effectiveness of Housing Allowance on Tenant Households in the UK, the Netherlands and Sweden Min Ah Jung PhD Student, Department of Urban Studies University of Glasgow (0) The purpose of this study is to examine the effectiveness of housing allowance system as a policy instrument of social policy and housing policy. With the consideration of the design of the national housing allowance system in the UK, the Netherlands and Sweden, the changes in household s Residual Income after rents and Rent to Income Ratio before and after housing allowance are studied in terms of tenant groups with different incomes, family types, tenant tenure and employment status. Overall, it seems that housing allowances are likely to be effective to maintain household income after housing costs and reduce financial burden for housing costs. However, the clear relationship between the housing allowance impact and its design has not been found. Introduction In most welfare states, different ways of national support for housing have been implemented for decades for low-income households. As a part of housing support, the housing allowance could reduce the low-income household s burden on housing costs payment and therefore it helps the low-income household maintain their living above a certain level. Also it is noted that where housing allowances are carried out, varied national policy aims are crossed: one is to secure income maintenance as a social policy objective and another is to enhance housing affordability as a housing policy objective. Therefore, when it comes to the housing allowance evaluation, the main research question would be to what extent the housing benefit system is effective to achieve income maintenance and housing affordability for its beneficiaries. Moreover, the structure of housing allowances varies according to countries and even within one county s housing allowance system, the design of housing allowance could make a difference in the achievement of policy goals for varied household groups. To account for this, the study will adopt a comparative approach using three case countries, i.e. the UK, the Netherlands and Sweden and explore the effectiveness of housing allowances on its recipients with regard to these two policy objectives and different housing allowance systems in three countries. 1
2 Housing Allowances in Welfare States It is widely accepted that housing expenditure has a significant impact on household finance, in particular for low-income households economy, because it is the largest component of their budget (Freeman et al, 1999; Kemp, 2000; Alcock, 2006). Therefore housing has been considered as a subject the consumption in market, most welfare states have intervened in the housing system by employing various policy instruments. The national intervention is categorised into two strands: one is so called bricks and mortar subsidies, i.e. supply-side or producer subsidies; another is known as demand-side or consumer subsidies (see Howenstine, 1975; Quigley, 1979; Davison, 1999; Olsen, 2000; Priemus and Kemp, 2004). In housing studies, it is suggested that the major housing subsidy until the 1970s was bricks and mortar subsidies, i.e. the provision of new dwellings by the state or lowered housing price in market through financial assistances to housing builders and landlords. However demand-side housing subsidies have been increased or introduced in most European countries since the 1970s (Kemp, 2000; Priemus and Kemp, 2004). For the reasons of this policy shift, Kemp (2000) suggested that the emerging of income-related housing allowances in the 1970s is associated with the shifts in other policy areas and explained four main factors as follows: the changing notion of housing policy from public sector provision to market or quasi-market housing; the increased interest on consumer choice for the low-income households; the reduction in severe housing shortages and the growing concern over income problems to be tackled; the better targeting of assistances with housing expenditure for those who are in need, from the point of the selective view to welfare provision (Kemp, 2000, p.46). In practice, welfare states have taken into account the effect of housing costs on household s financial burden and provided financial supports for housing through parts of existing social assistance benefits or the introduction of separate income related housing allowances (see Eardley et al, 1996). And through this process, housing policy in welfare states became more tightly woven with other policy areas, in particular, social security system aiming at poverty protection and income maintenance. The Evaluation of Housing Allowances In any policies related to housing allowances, it is said that the aim of housing allowance is related to the household s living condition after housing costs payments. In practice, housing allowances have functioned as maintaining recipients circumstances and affecting the level of living after housing consumption (Freeman et al, 1999). And this function is related to different policy object, i.e. securing income maintenance for social policy and housing affordability for housing policy. In order to evaluate the effectiveness of housing allowances, two different measures are mainly used, one is residual income after housing costs and another is housing expenditure to income ratio. The concept of residual income, i.e. the amount of income left after housing costs payment takes into account three (or four) components as follows: income, housing costs, housing allowance (and minimum costs of living). Although these elements are not expressed in the same way as seen in table 1, the common issue of residual income measures is concerned with the amount of remaining income after paying housing cost that would be used for living consumption and whether the minimum standard of living would be secured or not. When it comes to housing allowance, the 2
3 presence and absence of housing allowance affect considerably the burden for housing costs payment and therefore it links to the problem of the income maintenance of households in the lower end of income distribution. From this point of view, the residual income measurement could be used in the evaluation of the income maintenance effect of housing allowance schemes in terms of social policy although it has been employed in the housing affordability measurement in housing literatures. Table 1. The Measurement of Residual Income in Literature Research Randolph (ed) (1992) Chaplin et al (1994) Freeman and Whitehead (1995) Freeman et al (1999) Marshall et al (2000) The Calculation of Residual Income Net weekly household income + estimated Housing Benefit (estimated household applicable amount + Housing Benefit earned income disregard) *1.2 weekly basic rent weekly eligible service charge Net income + Housing Benefit earned income disregard + Housing Allowance Rent Income Support applicable amount Net income + Housing Benefit earned income disregards Rent Income Support applicable amount Net income + Housing Benefit Minimum housing expenditure Minimum nonhousing expenditure Income Rent Income Support + Housing Benefit Source: Randolph (ed), 1992; Chaplin et al, 1994; Freeman and Whitehead, 1995; Freeman et al, 1999; Marshall et al, In the current housing literature, housing affordability is measured as the proportion of housing expenditure to household s income and it is said that the housing affordability problem occurs when a household pays more than a certain percentage of its income to obtain adequate and appropriate housing (Maclennan and Williams, 1990; Bramley, 1990; Kearns, 1992; Hancock, 1993; Chaplin et al, 1994; Marsh and Riseborough, 1995; Freeman, et al, 1999). While the concept of housing affordability is based on the ratio of housing expenditure to household income, the calculation varies depending on the inclusion or exclusion of housing allowance and the definition of income (net income or gross income) and the scope of housing expenditure (only rent or mortgage payments and housing service charges). For example, the housing affordability for tenant is defined variously as follows (Freeman et al, 1999, p.12): 1) Housing affordability ratio = dwelling rent / net income 2) Housing affordability ratio = (dwelling rent housing allowance) / net income 3) Housing affordability ratio = dwelling rent / (net income + housing allowance) 4) Housing affordability ratio = dwelling rent / gross income 5) Housing affordability ratio = (dwelling rent housing allowance) / gross income However there are practical problems when we measure housing affordability with this ratio standard. Firstly, it is difficult to decide the proportion of housing costs to income as a standard. Secondly, the measurement of housing affordability by using one single ratio is not sensitive to address the variation in households incomes (Kearn, 1992). Moreover the ratio of housing costs to income should be set out at the point where the socially acceptable standard of housing and non-housing goods are consumed (Hancock, 1993). However this ratio measurement does not provide any information about whether the household consumes housing with an acceptable standard. Nevertheless, this ratio measurement is the most widely used measure of affordability due to its simplicity and data availability (Freeman et al, 1999, p.12). In 3
4 practice, different ratios are employed according to countries and they vary from 15 to 30 per cent of household s income (Joseph Rowntree Memorial Trust International Housing Finance Colloquium, 1989, cited in Kearns, 1992, p ). The research In this study, the impact of housing allowance on income maintenance and housing affordability will be analysed in the UK, the Netherlands and Sweden. Although tenants and homeowners are eligible for housing allowance in the UK and Sweden, the scope of this research is restricted to tenant households because they are likely to be worse off than owner-occupier households and the proportion of housing costs to household s budget and the effectiveness of the housing allowance receipt might be sizable than those for owner-occupier households. Family Resources Survey 2006 of the UK, the Netherlands Housing Research (WoON) 2006 and Household Finances (HEK) 2006 of Sweden are used. For the analysis, two main indicators, i.e. Residual Income after rents and Rent to Income Ratio are employed. Firstly, two residual incomes (after rents) before and after housing allowances are adjusted by OECD modified equivalence scale and the change in households' residual income by housing allowances is analysed. With the result of residual income changes, we will evaluate the impact of housing allowances on income maintenance, i.e. the extent to how the housing allowance contributes to sustain tenant households income after housing costs payment. Secondly, two Rent to Income Ratios (RIR) are compared, one is the ratio of gross rent to household income (i.e. RIR without housing allowance) and another is the ratio of net rent to household income (i.e. RIR with housing allowance). By comparing these two ratios, we could examine how much the housing allowance receipt has an effect on the improvement of housing affordability. Before the use of RIR, we need to decide the standard RIR to judge if a household has a housing affordability problem. In this research, housing affordability problem is defined as follows: if RIR is below 20, there is no housing affordability problem; if RIR is between 20 and 30, there is a housing affordability problem; if RIR is over 30, there is a sever housing affordability problem. That is to say, the higher RIR means the less housing affordability, i.e. the more problems. Adding to indicators, the ratio of housing allowance to gross rent is useful because this shows to what extent the housing allowance could contribute to reduce rent payment after housing allowances. Therefore this ratio is considered with regard to the research result. Finally, the results are compared by using four variables, i.e. income quintiles, household composition, tenant tenure and employment status. While the same categories are used for income quintiles, household composition in three countries, there are variances in categories of tenant tenure and employment status depending on the original national data. The National Housing Allowance System Although housing allowances are means-tested benefits for housing cost payment for low-income households in the UK, the Netherlands and Sweden, there are variances in the structure of housing allowances according to countries. Firstly, while both tenants and homeowners are eligible for housing allowance receipt in the UK and 4
5 Sweden, only tenant households are eligible for it in the Netherlands. Secondly, as for tenants households, housing allowances are paid for rent plus heating costs in Sweden, it is not paid for heating in the UK and Netherlands. Thirdly, housing allowances are computed differently in three countries. It is more straightforward in the Netherlands than other countries. For example, if the rents are higher than around 200 1, the housing allowances are paid for above it by applying 100%, 75% and 50% subsidy rates. In the UK, if a household receives social security benefit, i.e. Income Support, Jobseeker s Allowance and Pension Credit, housing allowance is paid for 100% of their eligible housing expenditure. However, a household does not receive social security benefit, 65% of the difference between household income and applicable amount are deducted from their housing expenditure and the remains are their housing allowances 2. The calculation of the Swedish housing allowance is more complex than former two countries because there are varied housing allowance schemes according to family types, i.e. family with children, young people (aged 18-28) without children and pensioner. When it comes to non-pensioner households, housing allowances consist of 50-75% of housing expenditure (a) and children grant (b). And if their household incomes are over income threshold, 20% (family with children) or 33% (young people without children) of the difference between household income and income threshold are deducted from (a+b). However there are some common features in three countries housing allowance system. Firstly, the current housing allowance system is advantageous to lower income households than others. For example, this aspect is related to the benefit rule that households receiving social security benefit are entitled to the maximum amount of housing allowance in the UK. Also in the Netherlands, the less personal contribution is applied to lower income households than others. Secondly, the certain types of families are preferred by the housing allowance receipt. For instance, in the UK system, the applicable amount used for the reduction in housing allowance is advantageous to large family rather than single or household without children. In the Netherlands, there are different standards of personal contribution and the subsidy rates according to household composition and these standards are more generous to large family, the elderly and the disabled than others. In Sweden, households with children are advantaged in the benefit rates because the benefit amount are related to the number of children and the standard of eligible rent ceiling, the subsidy rates, taper and income limits are more generous to them than households without children. Also there is another housing costs support for the Swedish pensioner, called special housing supplement, which is additionally paid if disposable income (including housing allowances) of pensioners is smaller than the standard of living. Considering these variances and similarities, there could be hypothesised expectations with regard to the actual function of housing allowances based on the structural characteristics of the housing allowance system between and within countries. Therefore, the design of housing allowance system should be minded when we understand the research result. 1 This price is called norm rent ( ), regarded as personal contribution in the Dutch housing allowance system. 2 Since the introduction of Local Housing Allowance in 2008, Local Reference Rent is applied instead of the eligible rent for private tenants. 5
6 Table 2. Housing Allowance System in the UK, the Netherlands and Sweden UK Country Benefit Scheme Eligible Housing Expenditure Eligible Tenure Benefit Calculation Housing Benefit Rents and some service charges recipients of IS, JAS(IB), PC non-recipients Local authority Tenants Registered Social Landlord Tenants HB=100% of eligible rent HB=eligible rent 0.65*(assessed income applicable amount) Local Housing Allowance Private Tenants LHA= full standard allowance Income Support for Mortgage Cost -Mortgage interest payment -Interest payments of loans for repairs and improvements -Other housing cost Owner-occupiers The standard rate of interest is applied. LHA= eligible rent ceilings (Local Reference Rent) 0.65*(assessed income applicable amount) Netherlands Rent Allowance Rents Tenant 1) Rents below the norm rent ( per month): no housing allowance 2) Rents between the norm rent and the quality discount limit ( per month): 100% covered by housing allowance 3) Rents between the quality discount limit and the deduction cut limit: 75% covered by housing allowance - the deduction cut limit: for three or multi-person households: per month and for smaller households: per month 4) Rents between the deduction cut limit and the liberalisation limit ( ): 50% covered by housing allowance for single-person households, three or multi-person households, elderly people and the disabled. Sweden Housing Allowance for families with children Housing Allowance for young people (18-28) without children Housing Supplement for Pensioners -Rents including heating costs -Annual fees to the cooperative, a part of interest expense on loan -Property tax, 70% of the site leasehold fee, heating and other running expenses 70% of interest expense on housing loan - Tenants - Co-operative/Tenantowned housing residents -Homeowners HA=assessed housing expenditure(a)(75% or 50% of housing expenditure) + child grant (b) If the claimant s estimated income is below an income threshold, (a+b) is provided, or not, 0.2*(estimated income-income threshold) would be reduced from (a+b). HA=assessed housing expenditure (a)(75% or 50% of housing expenditure) If the claimant s estimated income is below an income threshold, (a) is provided, or not, 0.33*(estimated income-income threshold) would be reduced from (a). The difference between the maximum housing supplement and income deduction is paid 6
7 The Effectiveness of Housing Allowances on Tenant Households Income Maintenance: Changes in Residual Income after Rents by Housing Allowance The result has shown that the housing allowance receipt could make a difference in residual income of housing allowance recipients in three countries: their residual incomes after rents payment have been improved relatively 70% in Sweden, 61% in the UK and 21% in the Netherlands by the housing allowance receipt. With regard to household income, it is generally anticipated that the housing allowance system would be more advantageous to lower income households for benefit receipt. However, it is not always the lowest income group that the support from housing allowance is most helpful. When we look at the housing allowance to rent ratio showing to what extent the housing allowance contribute to the reduction of housing costs, while housing allowances are more helpful for lowest and lower income groups in the UK, it is more helpful for middle lower income groups in the Netherlands and Sweden. Furthermore, rather lowest income group, these groups mentioned above have shown the better improvement in residual income in three countries. It might be because not only income level, other factors such as household types and rents are interrelated to the total housing allowance calculation. In terms of family types, household composition is presumably associated with the more generous housing allowance rates in three countries. As stated previously, there is the less reduction of housing allowance by the advantageous applicable amount for some family types in the UK; varied eligible rent ceilings, personal rent contributions and subsidy rates are applied in the Netherlands; there are different child grants, subsidy rates and tapers according to family types and additional support for pensioners in Sweden. In particular the benefit might be more generous to households with children in terms of higher benefit rates, lower taper (in Sweden), higher ceiling of eligible rent (in Sweden and the Netherland) and other rules than households without children. Therefore, we might expect that certain family types would be more favoured by the housing allowance system than others. However while households with children are likely to receive more housing allowances in three countries and pensioner households are also likely to have more housing allowances in the Netherlands and Sweden, the housing allowance is not always more helpful for households with children and pensioners than others. Considering the housing allowance to rent ratio, the housing allowance receipt is more helpful to reduce financial burden for housing costs for households without children and single pensioners in the UK, single households without children and all pensioners in Sweden but households with children and single pensioner in the Netherlands. That is to say, although the housing allowance is likely to be helpful for some pensioner households as expected, there are differences in the result of non-pensioner households between countries. Moreover, it seems that the effectiveness of housing allowance is likely to be effective for single households than couple households: the improvement in residual income is better for single households excluding pensioners in the UK, all single households in the Netherlands, single pensioner, single without children in Sweden, although the result of couple with children is also good in Sweden. Therefore it is noted that all households with higher ratio of housing allowance to rent have not experienced the more improvement in residual income and it seems that the generosity of housing allowance design for family types is not directly related to the result of housing allowance on income maintenance. 7
8 In the three countries studied here, the same rule has been applied to tenants within country. Although there are varied rules in the current UK system according to tenure types, i.e. private or non-private, the UK data used here has been collected before Local Housing Allowances rolling-out across country. Therefore it is expected that the housing allowance system might deal with varied tenant types equally. However, with regard to housing allowance to rent ratio between tenants tenure, while the housing allowance receipt is more helpful for non-private housing tenants in the UK, the extent of housing allowance support are at similar level regardless of tenant tenure in Sweden and the Netherlands. Also the UK housing allowance is likely to be more effective for non-private households in terms of income maintenance than private housing tenants. Moreover there are differences in residual income improvement between tenant tenure in the Netherlands and Sweden, the result is better for private housing and housing association housing tenants in Sweden and the Netherlands. From this, we could say that although there are no varied rules according to tenant tenure, non-private tenants are likely to be more favoured by the UK system and also there are differences in income maintenance between tenant types in three countries. Relating to the effectiveness of housing allowance on households with different working status, it is generally expected that the housing allowance system might be more generous to workless households than working households. This is because their working status is related to their income condition (and social security benefit receipt) and family features and it would result in the different benefit receipt. And this anticipation has been linked to the result. As well as the ratio of housing allowances to rent, the improvement of residual income by housing allowance take-up are better for workless households in three countries (although it is not observed a statistically significant difference in the UK households) and part-time working than other fulltime working households in the Netherlands and Sweden. 8
9 Table 3. Improvement in Residual Income by Housing Allowance (%, relative term) UK Netherlands Sweden Tenant with HA (N=3,376) (N=7,124) (N=1,022) Average (%) Income Quintiles high 1st Q (110.7) 3rd Q (24.1) 3rd Q (108.3) 2nd Q (92.1) 2nd Q (23.0) 2nd Q (93.7) 3rd Q (53.9) 4th Q (21.7) 1st Q (75.5) 4th Q (36.1) 1st Q (18.8) 4th Q (60.0) low 5th Q (12.2) 5th Q (18.7) 5th Q (12.7) (F=48.111***) (F=52.506***) (F=8.325***) Household Composition high Si without children (85.9) Pensioner Si (26.4) Pensioner Si (111.0) Lone-parent (71.4) Si without children (23.8) Co without children (83.5) Pensioner Si (50.7) Lone-parent (20.0) Si without children (60.7) Co with children (48.3) Co without children (15.9) Pensioner Co (43.5) Co without children (32.1) Pensioner Co (15.6) Lone-parent (28.4) low Pensioner Co (28.2) Co with children (14.5) Co with children (16.8) (F=9.461***) (F= ***) (F=8.923***) Tenant Tenure high HA (74.2) Private (22.6) Private or HA (77.9) Public (61.9) HA or Coop (21.2) Coop (34.5) low Private (30.1) Public (16.3) - (F=14.507***) (F=4.770**) (t= ***) Employment Status high Si/Co-all out of work (63.1) Si/Co-all out of work (22.7) Si out of work (96.4) Si/Co-1 or more in PT (46.9) Si/Co-1 or more in PT (18.5) Co-2 out of work (54.0) Co-1 in FT/ 1 out of work (31.0) Si/Co-all in FT (14.6) Si in work (13.9) Si/Co-all in FT (25.9) Co-1 in FT/ 1 out of work (12.3) Co-only 1 in work (13.9) Low Co-1 in FT/ 1 in PT (14.3) Co-1 in FT/ 1 in PT (11.0) Co-2 in work(8.0) (F=1.556) (F=97.273***) (F=9.974***) Source: Family Resources Survey 2006 (UK), Netherlands Housing Research (WoON) 2006, Household Finances (HEK) 2006 (Sweden), the author calculations. Note: * p<.05 ** p<.01 *** p<.001 Housing Affordability: Changes in the Rent to Income Ratio by Housing Allowance If low-income tenants do not receive their housing allowances, they would face very serious housing affordability problems 3, i.e. high financial burden for housing costs. As table 4 indicates, their Rent to Income Ratio (RIR) before housing allowance takeup are over 40% in the UK and the Netherlands and over 50% in Sweden. It means that these low-income households should spend around half of their income on housing costs and it would decrease non-housing consumption and their level of living. However, these problems have been considerably eased when housing allowances are paid: tenants with housing receipt would not have housing affordability problems in the UK; while they still have housing affordability problems, households financial burden for housing costs are improved by more than 30% (relative term) in the Netherlands and Sweden. 3 The author defines housing affordability problem as follows: if RIR is below 20, there is no housing affordability problem; if RIR is between 20 and 30, there is a housing affordability problem; if RIR is over 30, there is a sever housing affordability problem. 9
10 Among tenants with housing allowance receipt, housing costs burden is more serious for lowest-income tenants than other tenants in all three countries and they are still placed in the highest rank of housing affordability problem even after housing allowance receipt. In terms of household income groups, the higher housing allowance to rents ratio, i.e. getting more help from housing allowance for rents payment is closely related to the better improvement in RIR by housing allowances: they are lower income groups in the UK and Sweden and the middle three lower income groups in the Netherlands. Also the UK result presents that the housing allowance is likely to be more effective for tackling housing affordability problems than others. As the result presented, while there are no housing affordability problems after housing allowances in the UK across all income quintile groups, the lowest income groups in both countries (and the 4th income quintile in Sweden) still have a severe housing affordability problem. Moreover, the improvement in housing affordability by housing allowances is less for the Dutch and Swedish tenants with housing allowances than the UK tenants. It is noted that households with children have more housing affordability problems than others in three countries. In particular, couple with children have more housing affordability problems than other families, even after they received housing allowance. In the UK and Sweden, this might be related to the result that housing allowance to rent ratio is lower for these households than others. The results of housing affordability improvement between family types are complicated. The RIR changes are larger for household without children and single pensioner in the UK; lone-parent and single pensioner in the Netherlands; all pensioners in Sweden. However, the result is similar to that of household income, these households have faced better housing allowance to rent ratio than others, i.e. the higher housing allowance to rent ratio, the better result. Adding to this, we could look at the difference in the result between countries: while there are no housing affordability problems in the UK households except for couple with children, all family types still have housing affordability problems in the Netherlands and Sweden. As mentioned before, housing allowance receipt is likely to be less helpful for private housing tenants because their housing allowance to rents ratio is smaller than other tenants in the UK. In practice, here are much more differences in RIR between tenant tenure in the UK and the housing allowance is likely to be less effective to deal with housing affordability problems for them than non-private housing tenants in the UK. However, compared to the UK, there are not significant differences in RIR as well as RIR improvement between tenant tenure in the Netherlands and Sweden. Here again, we could find that these two countries system are prone to treat varied tenant groups equally with the reflection of their design. The presence or absence of worker in a family is related to the housing allowance rule such as the eligibility for the best allowance rate or lower deduction rate of housing allowances relating to their income. In practice, the housing allowance is likely to be helpful for workless households than working households in terms of housing allowance to rent ratio. Therefore it is expected that the current benefit system might be more beneficial for workless households than working households. Of course, RIR of workless households are not always lower than all working households even when they received housing allowances, except for Sweden. However in terms of RIR improvement by housing allowances, the anticipated result has been founded in three 10
11 countries. The RIR improvement is better for workless than working households than working households in all three countries. This might be related to the result that unemployed households have shown higher housing allowances to rent ratio than others with regard to the design of housing allowance. Table 4. Rent to Income Ratios of Tenants Receiving Housing Allowance (%) UK Netherlands Sweden Tenant with HA (N=3,376) (N=7,124) (N=1,022) RIR Gross R IR Net R IR Gross R IR Net R IR Gross R IR Net R IR Average (%) Income Quintiles high 1st Q (74.3) 1st Q (12.9) 1st Q (53.2) 1st Q (33.9) 1st Q (61.2) 1st Q (36.7) 2nd Q (53.4) 3rd Q (11.4) 2nd Q (45.2) 2nd Q (28.1) 3rd Q (59.6) 4th Q (33.7) 3rd Q (45.3) 4th Q (10.0) 3rd Q (43.4) 3rd Q (26.7) 2nd Q (56.7) 5th Q (29.5) 4th Q (36.9) 2nd Q (9.8) 4th Q (40.5) 4th Q (25.5) 4th Q (55.7) 3rd Q (28.9) how 5th Q (16.2) 5th Q (4.3) 5th Q (37.5) 5th Q (24.5) 5th Q (40.3) 2nd Q (26.4) (F) ( ***) (16.945***) ( ***) ( ***) (41.133***) (11.499***) Household Composition High Co with children Co with children Co with children Co with children Co with children Co with children (62.5) (20.6) (57.5) (36.0) (66.1) (44.2) Lone-parent (56.1) Lone-parent (13.1) Lone-parent (47.5) Co without children (30.0) Pensioner Co (61.2) Lone-parent (36.0) Co without children (53.3) Si without children (8.6) Co without children (45.6) Pensioner Co (28.4) Pensioner Si (54.8) Co without children (33.0) Si without children (47.7) Pensioner Co (7.8) Pensioner Co (44.3) Lone-parent (27.9) Lone-parent (53.2) Si without children (28.0) Pensioner Si Co without Pensioner Si Si without Si without Pensioner Co Low (32.2) Pensioner Co (31.3) children (6.5) Pensioner Si (5.6) (40.0) Si without children (39.4) children (26.2) Pensioner Si (25.0) children (48.6) Co without children (44.7) (27.9) Pensioner Si (26.3) (F) (61.238***) (31.399***) ( ***) ( ***) (16.202***) (28.827***) Tenant Tenure high Private (65.3) Private (30.5) HA or Coop (44.0) Public (28.8) Private or HA (56.8) Private or HA (31.8) HA (44.9) HA (8.1) Private (43.5) HA or Coop (27.7) Coop (45.2) Coop (27.8) low Public (39.4) Public (4.5) Public (42.7) Private (27.5) - - (F) or (t) (91.978***) ( ***) (0.509) (0.374) (-7.313***) (-2.786***) Employment Status high Co-1 in FT/ 1 out of work (70.7) low Si/Co-1 or more in PT (56.6) Si/Co - all in FT (55.9) Si/Co-all out of work (43.8) Co-1 in FT/ 1 in PT (38.4) Co-1 in FT/ 1 out of work (25.5) Co-1 in FT/ 1 in PT (24.8) Co-1 in FT/ 1 out of work (49.9) Co-1 in FT/ 1 out of work (32.9) Co-1 in FT/ 1 in PT (30.7) Si/Co-1 or more in PT (27.9) Si/Co-all out of Co-1 in FT/ 1 in PT (45.1) Si/Co- 1 or more Si/Co-1 or more in PT (23.8) in PT (44.1) Si/Co-all in FT Si/Co-all out of (18.0) work (44.0) work (27.5) Si/Co-all out of Si/Co-all in FT Si/Co-all in FT work (8.1) (36.8) (25.0) Co-2 out of work (64.2) Co-only 1 in work (44.5) Co-only 1 in Co-2 in work work (60.7) (41.8) Si out of work Si in work (35.7) (54.6) Co-2 in work Co-2 out of (49.0) work (34.2) Si in work (46.6) Si out of work (27.3) (F) (11.531***) (46.864***) (34.078***) (32.063***) (16.537***) (26.223***) Source: Family Resources Survey 2006 (UK), Netherlands Housing Research (WoON) 2006, Household Finances (HEK) 2006 (Sweden), the author calculations. Note: Gross R refers to gross rents before housing allowances and Net R refers to net rents after housing allowances (i.e. gross rents minus housing allowances). In Sweden, the sum of rent and heating costs is used as rents in order to reflect the benefit rule. * p<.05 ** p<.01 *** p<
12 Table 5. Improvement in RIR by Housing Allowance (%, relative term) UK Netherlands Sweden Tenant with HA (N=3,376) (N=7,124) (N=1,022) Improvement Average (%) Income quintiles high 1st Q (81.8) 3rd Q (37.9) 2nd Q (50.5) 2nd Q (80.6) 2nd Q (36.9) 3rd Q (48.8) 3rd Q (76.4) 4th Q (36.3) 1st Q (40.2) 4th Q (75.6) 1st Q (34.3) 4th Q (36.2) low 5th Q (73.1) 5th Q (34.3) 5th Q (26.6) (F=7.692***) (F=21.811***) (F=22.366***) Household Composition high Co without children (82.9) Lone-parent (40.1) Pensioner Co (57.2) Pensioner Si (80.2) Pensioner Si (36.8) Pensioner Si (48.5) Si without children (79.9) Co with children (36.6) Si without children (40.4) Lone-parent (74.6) Pensioner Co (34.9) Co with children (31.2) Pensioner Co (73.2) Co without children (33.5) Lone-parent (28.9) low Co with children (71.2) Si without children (32.6) Co without children (21.7) (F=6.979***) (F=57.191***) (F=21.595***) Tenant Tenure high Public (86.6) HA or Coop (36.0) Private or HA (41.0) HA (77.0) Private (35.5) Coop (38.0) low Private (48.2) Public (32.3) - (F= ***) (F=1.554) (t=-1.219) Employment Status high Si/Co-all out of work (79.8) Si/Co-all out of work (36.5) Co-2 out of work (47.1) Co-1 in FT/ 1 out of work (63.6) Si/Co-1 or more in PT (35.3) Si out of work (46.8) Si/Co-all in FT (62.5) Co-1 in FT/ 1 out of work (33.1) Co-only 1 in work (23.7) Si/Co-1 or more in PT (56.3) Co-1 in FT/ 1 in PT (31.2) Si in work (22.8) low Co-1 in FT/ 1 in PT (36.5) Si/Co-all in FT(31.1) Co-2 in work (14.7) (F=37.295***) (F=18.976***) (F=36.560***) Source: Family Resources Survey 2006 (UK), Netherlands Housing Research (WoON) 2006, Household Finances (HEK) 2006 (Sweden), the author calculations. Note: * p<.05 ** p<.01 *** p<.001 Conclusions This study has focused on the effectiveness of housing allowances on income maintenance and housing affordability of low-income tenants. The result has presented that the housing allowance plays a role in the improvement of income maintenance and housing affordability by reducing housing costs burden actually. Also it seems that the result is related to some features of housing allowance in each country. Social security benefit recipients in the UK are eligible for maximum housing allowance receipt and this could result in the better improvement in lowest income households. In terms of family type, the housing allowances are likely to be more effective for pensioner households as expected, in particular in the Netherlands and Sweden where the benefit system is more generous for them. Moreover, while the housing allowance system does not treat tenant tenure differently, the UK private housing tenants are less advantaged in housing allowance receipt and housing allowances is less effective for them than non private housing tenants. Commonly, it is said that housing allowance is more effective for workless household than working households. This might be because the employment status and the absence of earnings 12
13 are related to the social security benefit entitlement and it might make their benefit receipt better for them in three countries. However, while the result has indicated the effectiveness of housing allowances on income maintenance and housing affordability and some disadvantaged households might have more help through housing allowance receipt as expected, it is hard to say that there is the clear relationship between the result and the feature of national housing allowance system between countries. There are differences between the expectation based on the housing allowance design and the actual support from housing allowance take-up. Also while some household types would be favoured by the current system in one country, the interaction of household's living condition and the rule of housing allowances within country could cause different result. Clearly, the housing allowances own the positive function for income security and housing affordability for low-income tenant households in three countries. However, it is arguable which aspect of the national housing allowances are more closely related to these functions and the further study should be required in order to understand the relationship or interaction more clearly. Acknowledgment This paper is based on the author s PhD thesis. I would like to thank my supervisors, Mark Stephens and Kenneth Gibb. References Alcock, P. (2006) Understanding Poverty, 3 rd Macmillan. Edition, Hampshire: Palgrave Bramley, G. (1990) Access, Affordability and Housing Need, Paper presented at ESRC Housing Studies Conference, University of Surrey, September Chaplin, R., Martin, S., Yang, J. H. and Whitehead, C. M. E. (1994) Affordability: Definitions, Measures and Implications for Lenders, Discussion Paper No. 45, Department of Land Economy, University of Cambridge. Davison, A. (1999) Alternative Model of Social Housing: Tenure patterns and Costrenting in New Zealand and Sweden, Housing Studies, Vol. 14(4), pp Department for Work and Pensions (2002) Building Choice and Responsibility: A Radical Agenda for Housing Benefit, London: HMSO. Department for Work and Pensions (2005) Receiving the LHA: claimants early experiences of the LHA in the nine Pathfinder areas. ha/evaluation/2005/lha6-receiving.pdf, accessed on 14 June Department for Work and Pensions Housing Benefit Site. accessed on 14 June
14 Department for Work and Pensions (2007) Housing Benefit Local Housing Allowance Guidance Manual. ha/lha-guidance-manual-amd1.pdf, accessed on 14 June Department for Work and Pensions (2008) Family Resources Survey , accessed via the UK Data Archive. accessed on 14 June Doling, J. (1997) Comparative Housing Policy: Government and Housing in Advanced Capitalist Countries, London: Macmillan. Eardley, T., Bradshaw, J., Ditch, J., Gough, I. and Whiteford, P. (1996) Social Assistance in OECD Countries: Synthesis Report, Department of Social Security Research No. 46, London: HMSO. Freeman, A. and Whitehead, C. M. E. (1995) Affordability Revisited in English Housing Association New Let Accommodation , Discussion Paper No. 88, Department of Land Economy, University of Cambridge. Freeman, A., Holmans, A. and Whitehead, C. M. E. (1999) Evaluating Housing Affordability: Main Research Report for the CIH, LGA and NHF, Property Research Unit, Department of Land Economy, University of Cambridge and London School of Political Economics. Hancock, K. E. (1993) Can t Pay? Won t Pay? or Economic Principles of Affordability, Urban Studies, Vol. 30(1), pp Howenstine, E. J. (1975) The Changing Role of Housing Production Subsidies and Consumer Housing Subsidies in European National Housing Policy, Land Economics, Vol. 51(1), pp Kearns, A. (1992) Affordability of Housing Association Tenants: A Key Issue for British Social Housing Policy, Journal of Social Policy, Vol. 21(Part1), pp Kemp, P. A. (2000) The Role and Design of Income-related Housing Allowances, International Social Security Review, Vol. 53(3), pp Maclennan, D. and Williams, R. (1990) Housing Concerns and Affordability in Britain and the United States, in Maclennan, D. and Williams, R. (eds) (1990) Affordable Housing in Britain and America, York: Joseph Rowntree Foundation. Marsh, A. and Riseborough, M. (1995) Making Ends Meet: Older People, Housing Association Costs and the Affordability of Rented Housing, London: National Federation of Housing Associations. Marshall, D., Lyall Grant, F. and Freeman, A. (2000) Getting Rents Right? : The Place of Affordability in the Rent Setting Process: A Summary Report, Dataspring 14
15 Discussion Paper No. 2, Cambridge Housing and Planning Research, University of Cambridge. OECD Benefits and Wages: Statistics, OECD Tax-Ben country specific files, the Netherlands (2005). accessed on 14 June OECD Benefits and Wages: Statistics, OECD Tax-Ben country specific files (2006) the UK and Sweden. accessed on 14 June accessed on 14 June Olsen, E. O. (2000) The Cost-Effectiveness of Alternative Methods of Delivering Housing Subsidies, University of Virginia. accessed on 14 June Priemus, H. and Kemp, P. A. (2004) The Present and Future of Income-related Housing Support: Debates in Britain and the Netherlands, Housing Studies, Vol. 19(4), pp Quigley, J. M. (1979) Housing Allowances and Demand Oriented Housing Subsidies, Policy Studies Journal, Vol. 8(2) Special No. 1, pp Randolph, B. (1992) Housing Associations After the Act, Associations Research Report No. 18, London: National Federation of Housing Associations. Statistics Sweden, Household Finances (HEK) 2006, The Ministry of Housing, Spatial Planning and Environment (VROM) international homepage, accessed on 14 June The Ministry of Housing, Spatial Planning and the Environment (VROM), Netherlands Housing Research (WoON) 2006, accessed via the Netherlands Data Archiving and Networked Services, accessed on 14 June The Swedish Social Insurance Agency (2005) Social Insurance. accessed on 14 June The Swedish Social Insurance Agency (2007) Social Insurance in Sweden accessed on 14 June The Swedish Social Insurance Agency homepage, Help with the cost of housing. accessed on 14 June
Defining and measuring. standard [Powerpoint Presentation]
Loughborough University Institutional Repository Defining and measuring housing affordability in the private rented sector using the minimum income standard [Powerpoint Presentation] This item was submitted
More informationPOLICY BRIEFING. ! Housing and Poverty - the role of landlords JRF research report
Housing and Poverty - the role of landlords JRF research report Sheila Camp, LGIU Associate 27 October 2015 Summary The Joseph Rowntree Foundation (JRF) published a report in June 2015 "Housing and Poverty",
More informationSpring Budget Submission to HM Treasury From the Association of Residential Letting Agents (ARLA) January 2017
Spring Budget Submission to HM Treasury From the Association of Residential Letting Agents (ARLA) January 2017 Background 1. ARLA is the UK s foremost professional and regulatory body for letting agents;
More informationNew policy for social housing rents
New policy for social housing rents 1. Introduction The Essex Review of affordable housing policy carried out in 2008 pointed to the unfairness of the current system of rent setting for both social landlords
More informationHousing Needs Survey Report. Arlesey
Housing Needs Survey Report Arlesey August 2015 Completed by Bedfordshire Rural Communities Charity This report is the joint property of Central Bedfordshire Council and Arlesey Parish Council. For further
More informationScottish Parliament Social Security Committee Social Security Support for Housing Written Submission from ARLA Propertymark March 2019
Scottish Parliament Social Security Committee Social Security Support for Housing Written Submission from ARLA Propertymark March 2019 Background 1. ARLA Propertymark is the UK s foremost professional
More informationDefining and measuring. housing affordability using the Minimum Income Standard, and the possibility
Loughborough University Institutional Repository Defining and measuring housing affordability using the Minimum Income Standard, and the possibility of a living rent This item was submitted to Loughborough
More informationEconomic and monetary developments
Box 4 House prices and the rent component of the HICP in the euro area According to the residential property price indicator, euro area house prices decreased by.% year on year in the first quarter of
More informationMETREX Expert Group Affordable Housing
METREX Expert Group Affordable Housing METREX 125 West Regent Street GLASGOW G2 2SA Scotland UK T. +44 (0) 1292 317074 F. +44 (0) 1292 317074 secretariat@eurometrex.org http://www.eurometrex.org 1 METREX
More informationUnderstanding the rentrestructuring. housing association target rents
Understanding the rentrestructuring formula for housing association target rents Rent Briefing paper 4 Wendy Solomou, Peter Wright and Christine Whitehead Date: July 2005 Understanding the rentrestructuring
More informationResponse to the Scottish Parliament s Finance Committee call for evidence on the proposed LBTT supplement on additional residential homes
Response to the Scottish Parliament s Finance Committee call for evidence on the proposed LBTT supplement on additional residential homes Background From National Association of Estate Agents (NAEA) January
More informationAPPENDIX A DRAFT. Under-occupation Policy
APPENDIX A DRAFT Under-occupation Policy Published: August 2013 1 1 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 1.1 The introduction of the Welfare Reform Act 2012 has led to cuts in the amount of housing benefit people receive
More informationTHE CASE FOR SUBSIDISED HOUSING FOR LOU-INCOME FAMILIES. This report has been prepared and published to direct attention to the need
THE CASE FOR SUBSIDISED HOUSING FOR LOU-INCOME FAMILIES This report has been prepared and published to direct attention to the need for providing adequate housing for low-income and large families at rents
More informationHousing Market Affordability in Northern Ireland
Housing Market Affordability in Northern Ireland A report commissioned by the Northern Ireland Housing Executive and Chartered Institute of Housing from Professor Steve Wilcox, University of York The Regional
More informationA Model to Calculate the Supply of Affordable Housing in Polk County
Resilient Neighborhoods Technical Reports and White Papers Resilient Neighborhoods Initiative 5-2014 A Model to Calculate the Supply of Affordable Housing in Polk County Jiangping Zhou Iowa State University,
More informationHousing Costs and Policies
Housing Costs and Policies Presentation to Economic Society of Australia NSW Branch 19 May 2016 Peter Abelson Applied Economics Context and Acknowledgements Applied Economics P/L was commissioned by NSW
More informationComparative Study on Affordable Housing Policies of Six Major Chinese Cities. Xiang Cai
Comparative Study on Affordable Housing Policies of Six Major Chinese Cities Xiang Cai 1 Affordable Housing Policies of China's Six Major Chinese Cities Abstract: Affordable housing aims at providing low
More informationIs renting unaffordable in the Netherlands? 1
ENHR 2013 Conference Overcoming the crisis. Integrating the Urban Environment Is renting unaffordable in the Netherlands? 1 Authors: Marietta Haffner 1,2 and Harry Boumeester 1 1 OTB Research Institute
More informationSector Scorecard. Proposed indicators for measuring efficiency within the sector have been developed for the following areas:
Registered Providers Working Group on Efficiency Sector Scorecard Proposed indicators for measuring efficiency within the sector have been developed for the following areas: A. Business Health B. Development
More informationCountry Policy Framework Netherlands
Promoting Investment in Private Rented Housing Supply: International Policy Comparisons Project for Communities and Local Government by: Centre for Comparative Housing Research De Montfort University,
More informationHOUSING AFFORDABILITY
HOUSING AFFORDABILITY (RENTAL) 2016 A study for the Perth metropolitan area Research and analysis conducted by: In association with industry experts: And supported by: Contents 1. Introduction...3 2. Executive
More informationAffordability of housing Flanders and the Netherlands compared in the short-term and long-term
Affordability of housing Flanders and the Netherlands compared in the short-term and long-term Marietta Haffner 1 Kristof Heylen 2 1) OTB Research Institute for Housing, Urban and Mobility Studies, Delft
More informationEUROPEAN COMMISSION EUROSTAT
Ref. Ares(2018)1187552-02/03/2018 EUROPEAN COMMISSION EUROSTAT Directorate D Government Finance Statistics (GFS) and quality Luxembourg ESTAT/D-1/LA/GD/gh D(2018) Ms Jennifer Banim Assistant Director General
More informationPolicy Briefing Banish the Bedroom Tax Monster Campaign- Action Plan for Scotland
Policy Briefing Banish the Bedroom Tax Monster Campaign- Action Plan for Scotland From the Shelter Scotland policy library August 2013. All rights reserved. This document is only for your personal, non-commercial
More informationPOLICY BRIEFING.
High Income Social Tenants - Pay to Stay Author: Sheila Camp, LGiU Associate Date: 2 August 2012 Summary This briefing covers two housing consultations; the most recent, the Pay to Stay consultation concerns
More informationA matter of choice? RSL rents and home ownership: a comparison of costs
sector study 2 A matter of choice? RSL rents and home ownership: a comparison of costs Key findings and implications Registered social landlords (RSLs) across the country should monitor their rents in
More informationa mismatch in the supply of and need for low rent dwellings in the private rental market Housing affordability and private renting Outline
Sydney Research Centre Sydney Research Centre Housing affordability and private renting Judy Yates University of Sydney a mismatch in the supply of and need for low rent dwellings in the private rental
More informationCONTENTS. List of tables 9 List of figures 11 Glossary of abbreviations 13 Preface and acknowledgements 15 1 INTRODUCTION...19
CONTENTS List of tables 9 List of figures 11 Glossary of abbreviations 13 Preface and acknowledgements 15 1 INTRODUCTION...19 1.1 Research scope and purpose...19 1.1.1 The cases...20 1.1.2 The period of
More informationExposure Draft ED/2013/6, issued by the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB)
Leases Exposure Draft ED/2013/6, issued by the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) Comments from ACCA 13 September 2013 ACCA (the Association of Chartered Certified Accountants) is the global
More informationShaping Housing and Community Agendas
CIH Response to: DCLG Rents for Social Housing from 2015-16 consultation December 2013 Submitted by email to: rentpolicy@communities.gsi.gov.uk This consultation response is one of a series published by
More informationExtending the Right to Buy
Memorandum for the House of Commons Committee of Public Accounts Department for Communities and Local Government Extending the Right to Buy MARCH 2016 4 Key facts Extending the Right to Buy Key facts 1.8m
More information[03.01] User Cost Method. International Comparison Program. Global Office. 2 nd Regional Coordinators Meeting. April 14-16, 2010.
Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized International Comparison Program [03.01] User Cost Method Global Office 2 nd Regional
More informationIntroduction: Proposals:
Election Manifesto 2011 Introduction: Perhaps one of the most regrettable aspects of the Celtic Tiger was the absolute failure by the State to increase the level of social housing for the most vulnerable
More informationHousing Benefit and Council Tax Benefit Circular. All HB and CTB managers and staff. Officers preparing subsidy claims and estimates
Housing Benefit and Council Tax Benefit Circular Department for Work and Pensions 1 st Floor, Caxton House, Tothill Street, London SW1H 9NA HB/CTB S1/2011 SUBSIDY CIRCUR WHO SHOULD READ All HB and CTB
More informationCOMPARISON OF THE LONG-TERM COST OF SHELTER ALLOWANCES AND NON-PROFIT HOUSING
COMPARISON OF THE LONG-TERM COST OF SHELTER ALLOWANCES AND NON-PROFIT HOUSING Prepared for The Fair Rental Policy Organization of Ontario By Clayton Research Associates Limited October, 1993 EXECUTIVE
More informationSocial rents policy: choices and trade-offs
Social rents policy: choices and trade-offs 5 November 2015 Social rent policy: choices and trade-offs Stuart Adam, Daniel Chandler, Andrew Hood and Robert Joyce Policy background and trade-offs Robert
More informationHOW CAN WE ENSURE SOCIAL HOUSING REMAINS AFFORDABLE? AN INTRODUCTION TO LIVING RENT
HOW CAN WE ENSURE SOCIAL HOUSING REMAINS AFFORDABLE? AN INTRODUCTION TO LIVING RENT IS AFFORDABILITY IMPORTANT? YES!!! KEY ISSUES IN OUR AREA Poverty levels 0 hour contracts Low paid jobs market Austerity
More informationCity Futures Research Centre
Built Environment City Futures Research Centre Estimating need and costs of social and affordable housing delivery Dr Laurence Troy, Dr Ryan van den Nouwelant & Prof Bill Randolph March 2019 Estimating
More informationDocument under Separate Cover Refer to LPS State of Housing
Document under Separate Cover Refer to LPS5-17 216 State of Housing Contents Housing in Halton 1 Overview The Housing Continuum Halton s Housing Model 3 216 Income & Housing Costs 216 Indicator of Housing
More informationCIH Scotland l. Keeping our Rents Affordable. 2 nd October 2013 Donna Milton, Managing Director, Arneil Johnston
CIH Scotland l Keeping our Rents Affordable 2 nd October 2013 Donna Milton, Managing Director, Arneil Johnston Why is Affordability Analysis on the Agenda? Housing system analysis Development funding model
More informationEarls Barton. Rural Housing Survey. Authors: A Miles & S Butterworth Date: October 2012
Earls Barton Rural Housing Survey Authors: A Miles & S Butterworth Date: October 2012 Swanspool House, Doddington Road, Wellingborough, Northamptonshire, NN8 1BP Tel: 01933 229777 DX 12865 www.wellingborough.gov.uk
More informationThe role of policy in influencing differences between countries in the size of the private rented housing sector Professor Michael Oxley 26/2/14
The role of policy in influencing differences between countries in the size of the private rented housing sector Professor Michael Oxley 26/2/14. 1 Introduction Comparative studies of rented housing
More informationThe private rented housing sector: The UK and ideas from other countries
The private rented housing sector: The UK and ideas from other countries Social Market Foundation Seminar Thursday 23 rd March 2017 Professor Michael Oxley Director, Cambridge Centre for Housing Planning
More informationFact sheet Housing Benefit Reform: the Local Housing Allowance Q&A
Fact sheet Housing Benefit Reform: the Local Housing Allowance Q&A From the Shelter policy library February 2004 www.shelter.org.uk 2004 Shelter. All rights reserved. This document is only for your personal,
More informationBriefing: Service charges and Universal Credit
April 2014 Briefing: Service charges and Universal Credit Key issues Service charges are governed by legislations and regulation Eligibility for benefit will change under Universal Credit (UC) There is
More informationDomestic Private Rented Sector Minimum Level of Energy Efficiency
Domestic Private Rented Sector Minimum Level of Energy Efficiency Consultation to amend The Energy Efficiency (Private Rented Property) (England and Wales) Regulations 2015 in relation to domestic properties
More informationHOUSING REVENUE ACCOUNT BUDGET 2018/19 The Impact of Decreasing Dwelling Rents for the Council s Housing Stock.
HRA Budget Report 1 Name of the policy and briefly describe the activity being considered including aims and expected outcomes. This will help to determine how relevant the policy is to equality. HOUSING
More informationStatus of HUD-Insured (or Held) Multifamily Rental Housing in Final Report. Executive Summary. Contract: HC-5964 Task Order #7
Status of HUD-Insured (or Held) Multifamily Rental Housing in 1995 Final Report Executive Summary Cambridge, MA Lexington, MA Hadley, MA Bethesda, MD Washington, DC Chicago, IL Cairo, Egypt Johannesburg,
More informationSOUTH CAMBRIDGESHIRE DISTRICT COUNCIL SELF-COMMISSIONED HOUSING AT ORCHARD PARK
SOUTH CAMBRIDGESHIRE DISTRICT COUNCIL REPORT TO: New Communities Portfolio Holder Meeting 20 May 2010 AUTHOR/S: Executive Director Operational Services/ Corporate Manager Planning and New Communities Purpose
More informationDecember Arbon House, 6 Tournament Court, Edgehill Drive, Warwick CV34 6LG T F
Response to Department for Communities and Local Government s consultation paper Houses in Multiple Occupation and residential property licensing reforms from Association of Residential Letting Agents
More informationHousing Need and aspiration: the role of mid market rent A summary of research findings and points for consideration by the housing sector
Housing Need and aspiration: the role of mid market rent A summary of research findings and points for consideration by the housing sector Housing Need and aspiration: the role of mid market rent A summary
More informationSubject. Date: 2016/10/25. Originator s file: CD.06.AFF. Chair and Members of Planning and Development Committee
Date: 2016/10/25 Originator s file: To: Chair and Members of Planning and Development Committee CD.06.AFF From: Edward R. Sajecki, Commissioner of Planning and Building Meeting date: 2016/11/14 Subject
More informationKristof Heylen a b & Marietta Haffner b c d a Higher Institute for Labour (Hiva), Catholic University of Leuven,
This article was downloaded by: [KU Leuven University Library] On: 28 January 2015, At: 01:41 Publisher: Routledge Informa Ltd Registered in England and Wales Registered Number: 1072954 Registered office:
More informationPOLICIES FOR LOW AND MODERATE INCOME HOUSING
POLICIES FOR LOW AND MODERATE INCOME HOUSING HOUSING ALLOWANCES AND DEMAND ORIENTED HOUSING SUBSIDIES John M. Quigley, University of California-Berkeley and Yale University ABSTRACT It is estimated that
More informationReview of the Prices of Rents and Owner-occupied Houses in Japan
Review of the Prices of Rents and Owner-occupied Houses in Japan Makoto Shimizu mshimizu@stat.go.jp Director, Price Statistics Office Statistical Survey Department Statistics Bureau, Japan Abstract The
More informationHOUSING AFFORDABILITY
HOUSING AFFORDABILITY 2016 A study for the Perth metropolitan area Research and analysis conducted by: In association with industry experts: And supported by: Contents 1. Introduction...3 2. Executive
More information2006 Census Housing Series: Issue 9 Inuit Households in Canada
December 2010 Socio-economic Series 10-019 2006 Census Series: Issue 9 Inuit in Canada introduction This Research Highlight examines the housing conditions of Inuit 1 in Canada using data from the 2006
More informationState of the Housing Market in Bristol 2013
State of the Housing Market in Bristol 2013 Housing Stock Bristol has 190,000 homes, and plans to increase this by around 13,000 by 2026. Currently 15% of stock is owned by the city council, 6% by housing
More informationStarting points. Starting points Personal interests in the subject Research interests/opportunities International links : eg ENHR, Nova, KRIHS, CCHPR
Starting points Starting points Personal interests in the subject Research interests/opportunities International links : eg ENHR, Nova, KRIHS, CCHPR The changing emphasis of policy in the UK Housing renewal
More informationCity of Salinas Nexus Studies Overview and Summary February 2016
City of Salinas Nexus Studies Overview and Summary February 2016 1) Introduction The City of Salinas is looking at ways to increase the supply of affordable housing in Salinas. The City already has a successful
More informationNote on housing supply policies in draft London Plan Dec 2017 note by Duncan Bowie who agrees to it being published by Just Space
Note on housing supply policies in draft London Plan Dec 2017 note by Duncan Bowie who agrees to it being published by Just Space 1 Housing density and sustainable residential quality. The draft has amended
More informationNo place to live. A UNISON survey report into the impact of housing costs on London s public service workers
No place to live A UNISON survey report into the impact of housing costs on London s public service workers 1 FOREWORD Public services are critical to the London economy. Good transport and housing, quality
More informationPolicy briefing: Avoiding unnecessary evictions among social tenants in Wales
Policy briefing: Avoiding unnecessary evictions among social tenants in Wales September 2018 Introduction This paper sets out the case for raising minimum standards in the way in which social landlords
More informationChoice-Based Letting Guidance for Local Authorities
Choice-Based Letting Guidance for Local Authorities December 2016 Contents Page 1. What is Choice Based Lettings (CBL) 1 2. The Department s approach to CBL 1 3. Statutory Basis for Choice Based Letting
More informationSocial Care Co-operatives. Alex Bird. 1
Social Care Co-operatives Alex Bird www.consultancy.coop 1 European experience More than 140 million people are members of co-ops of all kinds in Europe. Some 10 per cent of France's employees work in
More informationTrends in Affordable Home Ownership in Calgary
Trends in Affordable Home Ownership in Calgary 2006 July www.calgary.ca Call 3-1-1 PUBLISHING INFORMATION TITLE: AUTHOR: STATUS: TRENDS IN AFFORDABLE HOME OWNERSHIP CORPORATE ECONOMICS FINAL PRINTING DATE:
More informationAffordable Housing Policy. Economics 312 Martin Farnham
Affordable Housing Policy Economics 312 Martin Farnham Introduction Housing affordability is a significant problem in Canada (especially in Victoria) There are tens of thousands of homeless in Canada Many
More informationReclassification of properties the pros and cons
Reclassification of properties the pros and cons Simon Smith Assistant Director CIH consultancy July 2013 Overview Why do it? The Legal Position Financial Implications Other Strategic Implications What
More informationGetting Started With Your Local Housing Market Assessment. A Step by Step Guide
Getting Started With Your Local Housing Market Assessment A Step by Step Guide November 2014 2 Getting Started With Your Local Housing Market Assessment Contents Background and Introduction 4 Stage 1a:
More informationHousing affordability in Australia
Housing affordability in Australia Evidence, implications, approaches University of Auckland Dr Ian Winter, Executive Director Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute July 2013 Key message Analysis
More informationTHE ROLE OF SOCIAL HOUSING IN HOUSING POLICIES
Ing. Martin Polák 1 THE ROLE OF SOCIAL HOUSING IN HOUSING POLICIES MIESTO SOCIÁLNEHO BÝVANIA V BYTOVEJ POLITIKE Abstract The role of social housing should not be seen to be limited to the provision of
More informationCENTRAL GOVERNMENT ACCOUNTING STANDARDS
CENTRAL GOVERNMENT ACCOUNTING STANDARDS NOVEMBER 2016 STANDARD 4 Requirements STANDARD 5 INTANGIBLE ASSETS INTRODUCTION... 75 I. CENTRAL GOVERNMENT S SPECIALISED ASSETS... 75 I.1. The collection of sovereign
More informationManaging a Section 8, Section 236, PRAC/LIHTC Project
Managing a Section 8, Section 236, PRAC/LIHTC Project www.lizbramletconsulting.com www.lbctrainingcenter.com www.lizbramlet.wordpress.com HUD-Assisted Projects and LIHTC Across the country, owners are
More informationDEMAND FR HOUSING IN PROVINCE OF SINDH (PAKISTAN)
19 Pakistan Economic and Social Review Volume XL, No. 1 (Summer 2002), pp. 19-34 DEMAND FR HOUSING IN PROVINCE OF SINDH (PAKISTAN) NUZHAT AHMAD, SHAFI AHMAD and SHAUKAT ALI* Abstract. The paper is an analysis
More informationAttachment 3. Guelph s Housing Statistical Profile
Attachment 3 Guelph s Housing Statistical Profile Table of Contents 1. Population...1 1.1 Current Population (26)...1 1.2 Comparative Growth, Guelph and Ontario (21-26)...1 1.3 Total Household Growth (21
More informationSales of intermediate housing
Sales of intermediate housing - 2009 Summary of issues...1 20.1 Introduction... 2 20.2 Intermediate Housing who has been housed... 2 Table 1: Shared ownership and OMHomeBuy sales, 2007/08...3 Fig 1: Total
More informationSERVICE POLICY MUTUAL EXCHANGES AND SUCCESSIONS OF TENANCY
SERVICE POLICY MUTUAL EXCHANGES AND SUCCESSIONS OF TENANCY INTRODUCTION This policy was reviewed following the introduction of Choice Based Lettings for the North Yorkshire Sub-Regional area. In light
More informationData Note 1/2018 Private sector rents in UK cities: analysis of Zoopla rental listings data
Data Note 1/2018 Private sector rents in UK cities: analysis of Zoopla rental listings data Mark Livingston, Nick Bailey and Christina Boididou UBDC April 2018 Introduction The private rental sector (PRS)
More informationCurrent affordability and income
Current affordability and income 21.1 Introduction...1 21.2 The relationship between intermediate and private rented markets...2 21.3 Renting privately...3 Table 1: Lower quartile rent, required household
More informationThe cost of increasing social and affordable housing supply in New South Wales
The cost of increasing social and affordable housing supply in New South Wales Prepared for Shelter NSW Date December 2014 Prepared by Emilio Ferrer 0412 2512 701 eferrer@sphere.com.au 1 Contents 1 Background
More information6 Central Government as Initiator: Housing Action Trusts
6 Central Government as Initiator: Housing Action Trusts The Housing Act 1988 sets up a framework within which the Secretary of State will be able to appoint Housing Action Trusts to take over council
More informationThinking about renting and claiming Housing Benefit?
Are you or a member of your family disabled? Thinking about renting and claiming Housing Benefit? A guide for disabled people on claiming Housing Benefit, and for families of disabled people who would
More informationA Guide to Developing an Inclusionary Housing Program
Richard Drdla Associates affordable housing consultants inc A Guide to Developing an Inclusionary Housing Program Developed for: Acorn Institute Canada Sept 2010 Acknowledgment This guide was prepared
More informationEnding Security of Tenure for Social Renters: Opening the Door to Ambulance Service Social Housing?
City Futures Research Centre Ending Security of Tenure for Social Renters: Opening the Door to Ambulance Service Social Housing? Suzanne Fitzpatrick, Heriot Watt University, Edinburgh Hal Pawson, Heriot
More informationThe introduction of the LHA cap to the social rented sector: impact on young people in Scotland
The introduction of the LHA cap to the social rented sector: impact on young people in Scotland Brought to you by the Chartered Institute of Housing Executive Summary About the research This research was
More informationRent setting Policy. Contents. Summary:
Rent setting Policy Summary: This policy sets out Genesis Housing Association s approach to rent setting and rent increases and decreases for all properties. The policy sets out how we will calculate and
More informationREAL ESTATE REFORMS: THE UK S MOST POPULAR PROPERTY POLICY IDEAS MFS
REAL ESTATE REFORMS: THE UK S MOST POPULAR PROPERTY POLICY IDEAS MFS Real Estate Reforms: The UK S Most Popular Property Policy Ideas On 24 June 2016, the UK awoke to the news that it would be leaving
More informationThe impacts of changes to social rents policy
The impacts of changes to social rents policy Robert Joyce Introduction Draws on IFS report published on 5 th November Social Rent Policy: Choices and Trade-Offs www.ifs.org.uk/uploads/publications/comms/r108.pdf
More informationReforming the land market
Reforming the land market How land reform can help deliver the government target of 300,000 new homes per year CPP Working Paper 01/2018 April 2018 Thomas Aubrey Centre for Progressive Policy About the
More informationThe newsletter of Govanhill Housing Association for tenants and factored owners in Merrylee. Cuts to benefits know your rights
MERRYLEE NEWSLETTER The newsletter of Govanhill Housing Association for tenants and factored owners in Merrylee Summer 2017 Cuts to benefits know your rights Further changes are being made to the benefits
More informationHow to define, achieve and measure affordability in rental housing
How to define, achieve and measure affordability in rental housing Housing is a fundamental right as citizens cannot enjoy other rights without it. However, a roof over people s head is not enough to promote
More informationMixed Tenure Communities and Neighbourhood Quality
Mixed Tenure Communities and Neighbourhood Quality A study using Survey of English Housing and Census data ESDS Conference, London, 31 October 2011 Where We Live And Why It Matters Phil Mason & Ade Kearns
More informationNSW Affordable Housing Guidelines. August 2012
August 2012 NSW AFFORDABLE HOUSING GUIDELINES TABLE OF CONTENTS 1.0 INTRODUCTION... 1 2.0 DEFINITION OF KEY TERMS... 1 3.0 APPLICATION OF GUIDELINES... 2 4.0 PRINCIPLES... 2 4.1 Relationships and partnerships...
More informationCJC response to the DCLG consultation on: TACKLING UNFAIR PRACTICES IN THE LEASEHOLD MARKET
September 2017 CJC response to the DCLG consultation on: TACKLING UNFAIR PRACTICES IN THE LEASEHOLD MARKET General remarks: There has been widespread support for the Government s move to reform leasehold
More informationOperating council-run Private Sector Leasing schemes to meet housing need and make a profit
Operating council-run Private Sector Leasing schemes to meet housing need and make a profit Martin Pereira Martin.pereira@havering.gov.uk What do you know about Social Lettings Agencies and what do you
More informationHOUSING ALLOCATIONS SCHEME (Scheme of Letting Priorities)
HOUSING ALLOCATIONS SCHEME (Scheme of Letting Priorities) Housing Allocations Scheme (Scheme of Letting Priorities) Section 1. Introduction 1.1 Introduction 1.2 Housing Areas 1.3 Transfer Applications
More informationBoone County, Kentucky Cost of Community Services Study Executive Summary
Boone County, Kentucky Executive Summary Suburban sprawl is an issue that many urban/rural fringe communities are faced with today. Pressures on building out instead of up result in controversies about
More informationBriefing: Rent reductions
First issued 22 December 2015 Revised and reissued 5 February 2016 Further revised 29 March 2016 Briefing: Rent reductions Supporting implementation Summary of key points: This briefing sets out how Housing
More informationTOWN TABLE OF. April 19, 2011 POLICY TITLE: DEFINITIONS Guideliness Hector PAH. PAH Build APPENDIX B. social fabric.
TOWN OF CANMO ORE POLIC CY EFFECTIVEE DATE: ADOPTED BY RESOLUTION: POLICY TITLE: AMENDED BY RESOLUTIONS: April 19, 2011 145-2011, Aprill 19, 2011 Council Meeting Perpetually Affordable Housing (PAH) Policy
More informationDirect Payment of Housing Benefit: Are Social Landlords Ready?
Direct Payment of Housing Benefit: Are Social Landlords Ready? Author(s): Steve Green Kesia Reeve David Robinson Elizabeth Sanderson Centre for Regional Economic and Social Research, Sheffield Hallam University
More information