RE: Comments on the draft Report by CRA International June 20, 2005 Pertaining to Proposed Vernal Pool Critical Habitat Designation
|
|
- Nelson Gibson
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 1 July 20, 2005 TO: FROM: Mr. Wayne White, Field Supervisor Sacramento Fish and Wildlife Service Office U. S. Fish and Wildlife Service 2800 Cottage Way, Room W Sacramento, CA Dr. Barney F. Hope Professor of Economics California State University Chico, CA RE: Comments on the draft Report by CRA International June 20, 2005 Pertaining to Proposed Vernal Pool Critical Habitat Designation A. Please accept my attached comments pertaining to the proposal for critical habitat designation (CHD) for 15 vernal pool species in California and southern Oregon. B. The general problems with the report by CRA International (CRA) can be categorized as follows: 1. The report contains numerous omissions, errors, deceptions, and flaws. 2. The economic concepts and theories used in the report are misapplied, applied incorrectly, or selectively applied. 3. The report includes no cost benefit analysis and virtually no economic analysis of the benefits from environmental protection afforded by CHD for vernal pools. 4. No authors are listed on the report title page. Since the report presents the proposed CHD almost completely from the perspective of real estate development, one can conclude that this report was prepared by real estate developers or those with strong ties to the real estate industry. 5. CRA took months and months to produce this late report and it was submitted to USFWS such that the public does not have a 60 day period to comment. C. My attached comments provide details and specifics to the general problems listed above. D. Because of the poor quality of the CRA report, I urge the USFWS to seek a full refund for monetary compensation paid to the anonymous CRA authors for their report.
2 2 Comments on a Report Prepared for the U. S. Fish and Wildlife Service Economic Impacts of Critical Habitat Designation for Vernal Pool Species Report by CRA International, June 20, ) The CRA Report only tabulates costs. Of the $992 million in costs, $965 million or 97% of the putative costs are projected to be impacts on real estate which the authors of the study label lost development opportunities. 1 A valid study would include benefits. This would allow for a cost-benefit analysis. Therefore this report is only a very narrow and extremely flawed (see below) tabulation of costs: it is not economic analysis. 2) The CRA Report fails to note that the costs of $992 million are expressed in mythical consumer/producer surplus dollars. Furthermore, they are grossly inflated because of incorrectly applying supply and demand curve concepts and inappropriately using an elasticity of demand estimate generated in an economic study 43 years ago. See my comments below. 3) The CRA Report fails to present the $992 million in costs in relative context. For example, what are the $992 million in costs relative to the total economic activity for CHD in the designated areas? What are the costs relative to the total economic activity for CHD in each county? a) The percent of county area proposed for Butte County CHD is 5.5% of the county. So the total real estate development impact will be small relative to the size of Butte County. i) Post CHD adaptive practices, in-fill housing development, densification, and the benefits of environmental protection can mitigate or eliminate the magnitude of CHD impacts. ii) CHD will result in a win win situation for home buyers and builders when environmental and quality-of-life benefits are included in a comprehensive costbenefit study. (1) This is especially true of Butte County as retirees and tourists increasingly come to live and visit Butte County. These benefits are not included in the CRA Report. There is no discussion in the CRA Report of the connections between environmental amenities and population segments: retirees; tourists; families; those engaged in recreation. iii) While the area proposed for Butte County is 5.5%, the map generated for Butte Country in the CRA Report 2 shows an area greater than 5.5%. While this area is label deadweight loss (again expressing mythical consumer/producer surplus dollars ), the public receives the impression that well over 5.5% of Butte County will be impacted. (1) The Butte map constructed by CRA on page 77 expresses deadweight losses based on Census Tract information. But the data for Butte County on page 59 is derived from FIPS sources. In no place in the report do the authors explain the different or the significance of selectively using different sources. 4) The authors only include the aggregate costs in their executive summary and do not include annualized or relative costs in their executive summary. This type of presentation gives a deceptive and extreme overstatement of the costs impacts. While the authors can point to a few numbers referring to annual costs buried in the report, the media has reported only the 1 CRA Report, p. 2 2 Ibid, p. 77
3 larger, non-qualified, number. This communicates a dramatically deceptive tabulation of incorrectly calculated costs to the public and gives the public the impression that there will be draconian economic difficulties with CHD. 5) To illustrate how the CRA report overstates consider the housing impacts in Butte County. The report notes that the change in housing units over a 20 year period because of CHD will be 353 fewer housing units or fewer housing units per year over a 20 year period. 3 Yet the authors fail to compare that figure to the total number of housing units constructed. a) For Butte County, if Federal Information Processing Standards (FIPS) code one of 12 FIPS areas in Butte County is excluded, the total change in housing units is not minus 353, but minus 132. Over a 20 year period, this averages a minus 6.6 housing units per year. The authors report structure again presents data to exaggerate and overstate impacts and costs and the report is seriously deficient in presenting data with relative measures. b) The CRA authors assume that all vernal pool lands are suitable for housing development. But some Butte County land is unsuitable for housing because of soil conditions, agriculture use, infrastructure expenses, or nitrate problems associated with septic systems in rural Butte County. 6) The author s methodology of economic efficiency is deficient in terms of examining producer costs. 4 Since the authors have chosen to examine real estate impacts, then the appropriate methodology would be one that includes balance sheets and income statements as those are the tools used by real estate developers. Real estate developers do not use the neoclassical economist s concept of producer surplus in the course of doing business. Rather they are motivated by profits as manifested on balance sheets and income statements. a) Even if one accepts the use of consumer and producer surplus, the elasticity of demand and supply/demand parts of the report is so flawed that both consumer and producer surplus estimates are incorrect and meaningless. See below. 7) The price elasticities of demand estimates of -1 determined by Reid in 1962 and Rosen in 1979 are not valid for the housing market in the last decade in California, in 2005, or the 20 year time period specified by the USFWS for the study. 5 The price elasticity of demand for housing in the last 5 years especially in Yolo and Butte countries has been extremely inelastic. Demographics, rising per-capita income, and migration to Butte county suggested that the price elasticity of demand will be very inelastic in the next 20 years not the unitary elasticity determined by Reid 43 years ago in a very different housing market and a very different demographic, economic, and land-use planning context. a) The price elasticities numbers and framework used in the CRA Report are only used by economists to examine extremely short term changes of quantity demanded to price. The CRA approach is deficient for the following reasons: i) As noted above, the elasticities numbers used from a 43 year old study are not valid for today s housing market. (1) Even if we accept the authors flawed consumer surplus/producer surplus methodology, note that as the price elasticities of demand becomes more inelastic as they have in over the last decade this will dramatically increase consumer 3 Derived from data on p. 59. Dividing this number by 20 (years) results in a yearly reduction of housing units. The authors present a yearly reduction of 18 units on p The authors assert that Economists generally characterize opportunity costs in terms of changes in producers and consumer surplus in affected markets. [Ibid, p. 8] But there are serious flaws with not including balance sheets and income statements in studies involving business like real estate developers. And as noted in subsequent comments the authors used of consumer and producer surplus in their report is seriously flawed. 5 See footnote #85, p. 52 of the CRA Report. 3
4 surplus in a housing market. Since the authors do not use appropriate number for the price inelasticity of demand, they dramatically understate consumer surplus and dramatically overstate the cost ($965 million) in mythical consumer surplus/ producer surplus dollars. ii) The price elasticity number and framework used by the CRA authors are inappropriate for any 20 year time. Over a 20 year period the demand curve and supply curves will shift. The authors fail to distinguish between a change in quantity demanded (one demand curve for a particular point in time) with a change in demand (demand curve shift over time) in their study. If real estate developers in the last decade used the elasticities numbers used by the CRA authors, they would have missed out on tremendous profits. iii) Given the small increase in relative costs associated with CHD and a very price inelasticity of demand, market conditions will allow CHD costs to be shifted from real estate developers to home buyers with little or no impact on profits. 6 While the CRA authors present flawed producer surplus numbers, the producers will continue to earn profits. iv) Housing studies have shown that home buyers are willing to pay a higher price for environmental amenities. Since the authors only rely on the neoclassical concept of consumer surplus and refused to include any environmental benefits in their report, they fail to see the benefits accruing to home buyers because of environmental protection. Home buyers recognized these benefits and are willing to pay for them. (1) Even if one accepts the authors methodology, note that consumer surplus will increase over time even with higher housing prices. This can be demonstrated with calculating consumer surplus with the demand curve to the left and the demand curve to the right that has shifted out over time and there has been a reduction in the price elasticity of demand as we move from P 1 to P 2. (See diagrams next page) Note that the price of housing, P h, is higher in the right panel but consumer surplus is also higher. This is demonstrated by applying the definition of consumer surplus. The increase in consumer surplus is even more dramatic if the price elasticity of demand in the left panel is the number used in the out-dated and unsuitable Reid and Rose studies (ε = -1) while the elasticity of demand in the right panel at P 2 is less than -1. (2) Now consider what happens if we use the same framework but have the price of land on the vertical axis and the quantity of land on the horizontal axis. If the supply curve (for land) intersects the demand curve at P 2 and the supply curve shifts to the left because of environmental regulation and we remain less than unitary elasticity, producer revenue will increase while costs will stay the same or decrease: profits will increase. (3) When the mistakes are corrected for elasticity and supply/demand frameworks in the CRA Report, it leads to the conclusion that land restrictions imposed by CHD will actually increase consumer surplus and increase producer profits. Therefore, since the CRA authors represent real estate developers, their own framework leads to the conclusion that CHD for vernal pools should be adopted in order to increase consumer surplus and producer profits. 4 6 The CRA Report indicates housing prices in Butte County will increase by 0% to 3.1%. If the FIPS code area is excluded, then the change will be from 0% to 2.2%. [Calculated from data on p. 59] One can see that the estimated increase in housing prices is relatively small.
5 5 P h Ph P 2 P 1 Q h Q h While the slope of the demand curve remains the same, the demand curve shift in the right panel results in a lower elasticity of demand at P 2 compared to P 1. This is consistent with the current housing market in California, especially Butte County. While numbers have not been used in the panels to calculate elasticities, the panel framework is theoretically correct: at P 2 the elasticity of demand is lower that at P 1. 8) The CRA authors note that Executive Order notes that it may not be feasible to monetize, or even quantity, the benefits of environmental regulations. 7 There is no discussion, arguments, or analysis by the CRA authors as to why section of EO applies in the case of CHD for vernal pools. The existence of EO does not mean that it is automatically or uncritically applied. The CRA authors assert Given the limitations associated with estimating the benefits of proposed CHD for the vernal pool species, the Service believes that the benefits of proposed CHD are best expressed in biological terms that can be weighed against the expected cost impacts of the rulemaking. 8 a) There is no discussion as to what are the limitations. b) There is no reference to the environmental literature as to how economists estimate the benefits of environmental protection and how those benefits have been integrated into a cost-benefit analysis. c) The CRA authors assert the Service believes.... Yet there is no reference or footnote as to where the Service believes that Executive Order applies. d) Please note that Executive Order requires a 60 day public comment period. 9 To allow the CRA authors to have months and months to put together a flawed report and then to deny the public a comment period of not less than 60 day is an agency failure. e) The CRA authors assert that the benefits of proposed CHD are best expressed in biological terms that can be weighed against the expected cost impacts of the rulemaking. This discussion will be included in the preamble to the final rulemaking. 10 Since that discussion will be included in the final rulemaking, when will the public have time to comment on this part of the CHD process? The CRA authors delayed the dissemination of a ponderous and flawed report by months and therefore deny the public a 60 day comment period and then notify the public that they will not be able to comment on an important part of the CHD because it will be in a future preamble. 7 Ibid, p Loc cit 9 See EO 12866:... addition, each agency should afford the public a meaningful opportunity to comment on any proposed regulation, which in most cases should include a comment period of not less than 60 days. 10 CRA Report, p. 12.
6 9) The CRA authors presents impacts when the biological and /or non-economic exclusions are included into the propose rule 11 in Section X. This includes a five country model for Butte, Madera, Solano, and Sacramento counties. Section 10 presents a hedonic regression model with no environmental hedonic variables! The model variables include lot size, dwelling unit square footage, bedrooms, baths, stories, and tract, a vector of indicator variables capturing fixed effects for each census tract. 12 While the econometric literature includes hedonic models that include environmental variables, the CRA model excludes environmental variables. Furthermore, the CRA authors tortuously estimate the regional intensive margin value of land, yet the authors note that CHD of vernal pool species has little effect on the regional economy. 13 Their precise estimate is that the reductions equals.0003 of the region s output. 14 No press report included such a tiny and meaningless impact in their articles. a) The CRA authors recognize that in Southern Oregon growth can take place because new migrants are attracted to the quality of life It is well recognized that the quality of life is Southern Oregon is based on environmental protection and amenities. Yet the CRA authors fail to include any benefits quantitatively or qualitatively in their report for CHD for vernal pools. 10) The CRA authors note that CHD has the potential to affect development potential and associated speculative land value at a very early stage in the development process. 16 But the authors fail to indicate whether CHD will be positive or negative in terms of development. Then they use the Alonso-Muth-Mills model to discuss how CHD will negatively impact consumer and producer welfare. 17 This is not surprising since the model does not include any variables for individual or social benefits from environmental protection. The author s conclusion is that there is nothing economically flawed or environmentally unsound by making all land available for development and no land or vernal pools. The logical conclusion from their study is to allow CHD for vernal pools land areas to be reduced to zero and vernal pool species and habitat to become extinct. Their conclusion is that CHD results in higher housing prices and lost rents to developers and landowners, the subtraction of rents earned through the production of scarce housing, and surplus losses to consumers and producers. 18 Even if one accepted those conclusions, then one would also accept the CRA authors claim that the reduction in houses will be 18 a year in Butte County and the price of housing will increase by 0% to 3.1% hardly the frightening conclusion of higher housing prices, lost rents, and lost surplus. But are these price increases in units of mythical consumer/producer surplus? Or are they reflective of real dollars? And if they are real dollars, where is the balance sheet and income statement presentations and economic/environmental analysis that leads to that conclusion? 6 11 See footnote 23, CRA Report, p Ibid, p If the CRA authors really intended the USFWS to understand their model, they would have described the variables included in tract. They do not. They would also provide a more detailed explanation of the result of their model. 13 Ibid, p Loc cit. 15 Ibid, p Ibid, p See p Ibid, p See footnotes #2 & #5 by this commentator.
7 7 The CRA Report is deficient for a dozen reasons: 1. The report attempts to only tabulate costs. 2. The report makes no attempt to include environmental benefits. 3. Executive Order is mentioned in the CRA Report, but there is no discussion of why the incorporation of environmental benefits was not included in the CRA Report. 4. There is no cost-benefit analysis. 5. There is virtually no economic analysis. 6. There is no environmental analysis. 7. There are virtually no relative cost measures. 8. The core methodology is constructed on a flawed and inappropriate economic model with foundations in consumer and producer surplus. If one correct all the mistakes then the logical conclusion of the CRA authors is for USFWS to adopt CHD for vernal pools to increase consumer surplus and producer profits. 9. There is no discussion of economic, financial, or business analysis based on the tools used by businesses: balance sheets and income statements. These tools must be employed if one desires to investigate the impact of land-use policy on business operations. These tools must be supplemented by considering the public interest, economic analysis, and cost benefit analysis including environmental benefits from changing land-use regulations. 10. The elasticity of price demand numbers do not fit today s housing market. Nor do they fit the housing market for 2005 to The hedonic econometric model contains no hedonic environmental variables. 12. While the authors have some data, scant narrative, and consumer/producer surplus measures for Butte County, nothing in their report applies or makes any sense for Butte County. I highly recommend that the USFWS reject the CRA Report and develop an analysis that includes benefits as well as costs and correct the omissions, errors, deceptions, and flaws of the CRA Report before reaching a decision about the CHD for vernal pools. Sincerely, Barney F. Hope Dr. Barney F. Hope, Professor of Economics Department of Economics California State University, Chico Chico, CA The assessments, analysis, and conclusions in this document do not necessarily represent the views of California State University, Chico. The commentator has not been paid by any real estate interests, environmental organizations, the USFWS, or California State University, Chico for producing these comments.
Rent economic rent contract rent Ricardian Theory of Rent:
Rent Rent refers to that part of payment by a tenant which is made only for the use of land, i.e., free gift of nature. The payment made by an agriculturist tenant to the landlord is not necessarily equals
More informationProcedures Used to Calculate Property Taxes for Agricultural Land in Mississippi
No. 1350 Information Sheet June 2018 Procedures Used to Calculate Property Taxes for Agricultural Land in Mississippi Stan R. Spurlock, Ian A. Munn, and James E. Henderson INTRODUCTION Agricultural land
More informationThe Impact of Internal Displacement Inflows in Colombian Host Communities: Housing
The Impact of Internal Displacement Inflows in Colombian Host Communities: Housing Emilio Depetris-Chauvin * Rafael J. Santos World Bank, June 2017 * Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile. Universidad
More informationSee also Deadweight Loss; Government failure; Pricing, Ethical Issues in; Rents, Economic; Unintended Consequences, law of
Rent Control Rent control measures legally mandate price ceilings for private sector housing units. The laws either limit the price that property owners may charge renters or the amount that property owners
More informationSouth Sacramento Habitat Conservation Plan Nexus Study
South Sacramento Habitat Conservation Plan Nexus Study Prepared for: SSHCP Plan Partners Prepared by: Economic & Planning Systems, Inc. April 5, 2018 EPS #161005 Table of Contents 1. INTRODUCTION AND MITIGATION
More informationEach copy of any part of a JSTOR transmission must contain the same copyright notice that appears on the screen or printed page of such transmission.
Durability and Monopoly Author(s): R. H. Coase Source: Journal of Law and Economics, Vol. 15, No. 1 (Apr., 1972), pp. 143-149 Published by: The University of Chicago Press Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/725018
More informationNorthgate Mall s Effect on Surrounding Property Values
James Seago Economics 345 Urban Economics Durham Paper Monday, March 24 th 2013 Northgate Mall s Effect on Surrounding Property Values I. Introduction & Motivation Over the course of the last few decades
More informationWhat Factors Determine the Volume of Home Sales in Texas?
What Factors Determine the Volume of Home Sales in Texas? Ali Anari Research Economist and Mark G. Dotzour Chief Economist Texas A&M University June 2000 2000, Real Estate Center. All rights reserved.
More informationMHC 2012 Housing Tax Credit Cycle MARKET STUDY GUIDE
MHC 2012 Housing Tax Credit Cycle MARKET STUDY GUIDE I. DATA SOURCES 1. Acceptable data sources include: a. The 2000 Census b. Data from state or local planning bodies c. Data purchased commercially from
More informationEXPLANATION OF MARKET MODELING IN THE CURRENT KANSAS CAMA SYSTEM
EXPLANATION OF MARKET MODELING IN THE CURRENT KANSAS CAMA SYSTEM I have been asked on numerous occasions to provide a lay man s explanation of the market modeling system of CAMA. I do not claim to be an
More informationFile Reference No : Leases (Topic 842): a Revision of the 2010 Proposed Accounting Standards Update, Leases (Topic 840)
September 13, 2013 Technical Director Financial Accounting Standards Board 401 Merritt 7 P.O. Box 5116 Norwalk, CT 06856-5116 Via email: director@fasb.org File Reference No. 2013-270: Leases (Topic 842):
More informationHow Did Foreclosures Affect Property Values in Georgia School Districts?
Tulane Economics Working Paper Series How Did Foreclosures Affect Property Values in Georgia School Districts? James Alm Department of Economics Tulane University New Orleans, LA jalm@tulane.edu Robert
More informationNational Rental Affordability Scheme. Economic and Taxation Impact Study
National Rental Affordability Scheme Economic and Taxation Impact Study December 2013 This study was commissioned by NRAS Providers Ltd, a not-for-profit organisation representing NRAS Approved Participants
More information5. PROPERTY VALUES. In this section, we focus on the economic impact that AMDimpaired
5. PROPERTY VALUES In this section, we focus on the economic impact that AMDimpaired streams have on residential property prices. AMD lends itself particularly well to property value analysis because its
More informationNew York Agricultural Land Trust
New York Agricultural Land Trust P.O. Box 121 Preble, NY 13141 www.nyalt.org New York Agricultural Land Trust Agricultural Conservation Easements and Appraisals Introduction An agricultural conservation
More informationEvaluating Measure 37 Claims
Three Methods for EM 89-E March 007 Evaluating Measure 7 Claims W.K. Jaeger Executive summary Measure 7 imposes an enormous burden on government. It asks government to know the unknowable: what would the
More informationUsing Hedonics to Create Land and Structure Price Indexes for the Ottawa Condominium Market
Using Hedonics to Create Land and Structure Price Indexes for the Ottawa Condominium Market Kate Burnett Isaacs Statistics Canada May 21, 2015 Abstract: Statistics Canada is developing a New Condominium
More informationThe Impact of Urban Growth on Affordable Housing:
The Impact of Urban Growth on Affordable Housing: An Economic Analysis Chris Bruce, Ph.D. and Marni Plunkett October 2000 Project funding provided by: P.O. Box 6572, Station D Calgary, Alberta, CANADA
More informationTrends in Affordable Home Ownership in Calgary
Trends in Affordable Home Ownership in Calgary 2006 July www.calgary.ca Call 3-1-1 PUBLISHING INFORMATION TITLE: AUTHOR: STATUS: TRENDS IN AFFORDABLE HOME OWNERSHIP CORPORATE ECONOMICS FINAL PRINTING DATE:
More informationDepartment of Agricultural and Resource Economics, Fort Collins, CO
May 2006 EDR 06-03 Department of Agricultural and Resource Economics, Fort Collins, CO 80523-1172 http://dare.colostate.edu/pubs ASSESSING THE TOTAL ECONOMIC VALUE OF RANCHING IN MOUNTAIN COMMUNITIES:
More informationHousing Supply Restrictions Across the United States
Housing Supply Restrictions Across the United States Relaxed building regulations can help labor flow and local economic growth. RAVEN E. SAKS LABOR MOBILITY IS the dominant mechanism through which local
More informationAN ECONOMIC ANALYSIS OF DROUGHT CONDITIONS ON LAKE HARTWELL AND THE SURROUNDING REGION
AN ECONOMIC ANALYSIS OF DROUGHT CONDITIONS ON LAKE HARTWELL AND THE SURROUNDING REGION Jeffery S. Allen, Robert T. Carey, Lori A. Dickes, Ellen W. Saltzman, Corey N. Allen, G. Michael Mikota AUTHORS :
More informationCalifornia Office 2001 N Street Suite 110 Sacramento, CA VIA
California Office 2001 N Street Suite 110 Sacramento, CA 95811 VIA EMAIL June 20, 2016 Mary Piepho, Chair, Contra Costa County LAFCO 651 Pine Street, 6th Floor Martinez, California 94553 Re: Comments to
More informationProving Depreciation
Institute for Professionals in Taxation 40 th Annual Property Tax Symposium Tucson, Arizona Proving Depreciation Presentation Concepts and Content: Kathy G. Spletter, ASA Stancil & Co. Irving, Texas kathy.spletter@stancilco.com
More informationThe New Housing Market and its Effect on Infrastructure Financing Capacity
The New Housing Market and its Effect on Infrastructure Financing Capacity Economic & Planning Systems, Inc. NIFR 2009 November 6, 2009 1 Presentation Overview Housing Market Trends New Home Pricing Trends
More informationDRAFT REPORT. Boudreau Developments Ltd. Hole s Site - The Botanica: Fiscal Impact Analysis. December 18, 2012
Boudreau Developments Ltd. Hole s Site - The Botanica: Fiscal Impact Analysis DRAFT REPORT December 18, 2012 2220 Sun Life Place 10123-99 St. Edmonton, Alberta T5J 3H1 T 780.425.6741 F 780.426.3737 www.think-applications.com
More informationThe Corner House and Relative Property Values
23 March 2014 The Corner House and Relative Property Values An Empirical Study in Durham s Hope Valley Nathaniel Keating Econ 345: Urban Economics Professor Becker 2 ABSTRACT This paper analyzes the effect
More informationAn overview of the real estate market the Fisher-DiPasquale-Wheaton model
An overview of the real estate market the Fisher-DiPasquale-Wheaton model 13 January 2011 1 Real Estate Market What is real estate? How big is the real estate sector? How does the market for the use of
More informationSchool Quality and Property Values. In Greenville, South Carolina
Department of Agricultural and Applied Economics Working Paper WP 423 April 23 School Quality and Property Values In Greenville, South Carolina Kwame Owusu-Edusei and Molly Espey Clemson University Public
More informationCan the coinsurance effect explain the diversification discount?
Can the coinsurance effect explain the diversification discount? ABSTRACT Rong Guo Columbus State University Mansi and Reeb (2002) document that the coinsurance effect can fully explain the diversification
More informationEconomics 5800 Urban Economics Second Mid-term Exam. Instructions
Economics 5800 Urban Economics Second Mid-term Exam Instructions Name Page 1 This examination has five questions and you are to do all five. Please number your answers clearly. Each question will be worth
More informationHousing market and finance
Housing market and finance Q: What is a market? A: Let s play a game Motivation THE APPLE MARKET The class is divided at random into two groups: buyers and sellers Rules: Buyers: Each buyer receives a
More informationTaxes and Land Preservation Computing the Capital Gains Tax
Fact Sheet 780 Taxes and Land Preservation Computing the Capital Gains Tax Many farmers have their wealth tied up in their land and would like to convert some of this land value into cash. Others want
More informationSorting based on amenities and income
Sorting based on amenities and income Mark van Duijn Jan Rouwendal m.van.duijn@vu.nl Department of Spatial Economics (Work in progress) Seminar Utrecht School of Economics 25 September 2013 Projects o
More informationChapter 35. The Appraiser's Sales Comparison Approach INTRODUCTION
Chapter 35 The Appraiser's Sales Comparison Approach INTRODUCTION The most commonly used appraisal technique is the sales comparison approach. The fundamental concept underlying this approach is that market
More informationAPPRAISAL REVIEW REPORT
APPRAISAL REVIEW REPORT REVIEW OF APPRAISALS BY BECCARIA & WEBER, INC. RE: BUENA VISTA MOBILE HOME PARK PALO AL TO, CALIFORNIA REVIEWED BY JAMES BRABANT, MAI PREPARED FOR Law Foundation of Silicon Valley,
More informationReview of the Prices of Rents and Owner-occupied Houses in Japan
Review of the Prices of Rents and Owner-occupied Houses in Japan Makoto Shimizu mshimizu@stat.go.jp Director, Price Statistics Office Statistical Survey Department Statistics Bureau, Japan Abstract The
More informationAbout Conservation Easements
Section Three: Farm Transfer Tools About Conservation Easements Editor s note: One question that our education collaborative has fielded consistently throughout the years is about conservation easements.
More informationEstimating National Levels of Home Improvement and Repair Spending by Rental Property Owners
Joint Center for Housing Studies Harvard University Estimating National Levels of Home Improvement and Repair Spending by Rental Property Owners Abbe Will October 2010 N10-2 2010 by Abbe Will. All rights
More informationJames Alm, Robert D. Buschman, and David L. Sjoquist In the wake of the housing market collapse
istockphoto.com How Do Foreclosures Affect Property Values and Property Taxes? James Alm, Robert D. Buschman, and David L. Sjoquist In the wake of the housing market collapse and the Great Recession which
More informationIV. REVIEW PROCEDURES FOR MINOR SUBDIVISIONS
IV. REVIEW PROCEDURES FOR MINOR SUBDIVISIONS IV-A. General Minor subdivisions create five or fewer lots from a tract of record, each lot of which has legal and physical access. If the tract of record proposed
More informationOntario Rental Market Study:
Ontario Rental Market Study: Renovation Investment and the Role of Vacancy Decontrol October 2017 Prepared for the Federation of Rental-housing Providers of Ontario by URBANATION Inc. Page 1 of 11 TABLE
More informationThe Local Government Fiscal Impacts of Land Uses in Union County:
The Local Government Fiscal Impacts of Land Uses in Union County: Revenue and Expenditure Streams by Land Use Category Jeffrey H. Dorfman and Bethany Lavigno Department of Agricultural & Applied Economics
More informationRural Demography, Public Services and Land Rights in Africa: A Village-Level Analysis in Burkina Faso
Rural Demography, Public Services and Land Rights in Africa: A Village-Level Analysis in Burkina Faso Margaret S. McMillan, William A. Masters and Harounan Kazianga World Bank April 26, 2012 Can local
More informationChapter SWAINSON S HAWK IMPACT MITIGATION FEES
The Swainson s Hawk ordinance can also be viewed online at: http://qcode.us/codes/sacramentocounty/ Once at the website, click on Title 16 BUILDINGS AND CONSTRUCTION, then Chapter 16.130 SWAINSON S HAWK
More informationCHICO/CARD AREA PARK FEE NEXUS STUDY
REVISED FINAL REPORT CHICO/CARD AREA PARK FEE NEXUS STUDY Prepared for: City of Chico and Chico Area Recreation District (CARD) Prepared by: Economic & Planning Systems, Inc. December 2, 2003 EPS #12607
More informationComparative Study on Affordable Housing Policies of Six Major Chinese Cities. Xiang Cai
Comparative Study on Affordable Housing Policies of Six Major Chinese Cities Xiang Cai 1 Affordable Housing Policies of China's Six Major Chinese Cities Abstract: Affordable housing aims at providing low
More informationSales Ratio: Alternative Calculation Methods
For Discussion: Summary of proposals to amend State Board of Equalization sales ratio calculations June 3, 2010 One of the primary purposes of the sales ratio study is to measure how well assessors track
More informationInitial sales ratio to determine the current overall level of value. Number of sales vacant and improved, by neighborhood.
Introduction The International Association of Assessing Officers (IAAO) defines the market approach: In its broadest use, it might denote any valuation procedure intended to produce an estimate of market
More informationVolume Title: Well Worth Saving: How the New Deal Safeguarded Home Ownership
This PDF is a selection from a published volume from the National Bureau of Economic Research Volume Title: Well Worth Saving: How the New Deal Safeguarded Home Ownership Volume Author/Editor: Price V.
More informationCity and County of San Francisco
City and County of San Francisco Office of the Controller - Office of Economic Analysis Residential Rent Ordinances: Economic Report File Nos. 090278 and 090279 May 18, 2009 City and County of San Francisco
More informationReviewing Growth Management Planning for Housing
Washington Research Council BRIEFLY Policy makers should avoid overly proscriptive regulation of the housing market, maximizing opportunities for residential and commercial development that is consistent
More informationAllyn D. Rifkin, PE RTPG the Rifkin Transportation Planning Group
Allyn D. Rifkin, PE RTPG the Rifkin Transportation Planning Group Los Feliz Towers E-mail allynrifkin@gmail.com 4455 Los Feliz Boulevard Suite 1403 Telephone and fax -- (323) 664-2805 Los Angeles, CA 90027
More informationAn Accounting Tradeoff Between WRP and Government Payments. Authors Gregory Ibendahl Mississippi State University
An Accounting Tradeoff Between WRP and Government Payments Authors Gregory Ibendahl Mississippi State University ibendahl@agecon.msstate.edu Selected Paper prepared for presentation at the Southern Agricultural
More informationThe FSZ: Preserving California's Prime Agricultural Farmland
The FSZ: Preserving California's Prime Agricultural Farmland I. Introduction Everybody would like a 35 percent discount on their property tax bill. Under recently enacted legislation, by agreeing to restrict
More informationCurrent Situation and Issues
Handout 13: Impervious and Gross Area Charges The purpose of this handout is to frame the issues around the gross and impervious parcel area based charges. Current Situation and Issues Current Structure
More informationUse of Comparables. Claims Prevention Bulletin [CP-17-E] March 1996
March 1996 The use of comparables arises almost daily for all appraisers. especially those engaged in residential practice, where appraisals are being prepared for mortgage underwriting purposes. That
More informationSTRONG FOUNDATIONS AFFORDABLE HOMES IN THE COUNTRYSIDE THE ROLE OF ENTRY LEVEL EXCEPTION SITES EXECUTIVE SUMMARY CLA MEMBER S VIEW
STRONG FOUNDATIONS MEETING RURAL HOUSING NEEDS CLA POLICY BRIEFING: ENGLAND 2 AFFORDABLE HOMES IN THE COUNTRYSIDE THE ROLE OF ENTRY LEVEL EXCEPTION SITES EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The revised draft of the National
More informationGeographic Variations in Resale Housing Values Within a Metropolitan Area: An Example from Suburban Phoenix, Arizona
INTRODUCTION Geographic Variations in Resale Housing Values Within a Metropolitan Area: An Example from Suburban Phoenix, Arizona Diane Whalley and William J. Lowell-Britt The average cost of single family
More information(Res. No R003, ) NON-REGIONAL ROAD CAPITAL EXPANSION FEE [2] Footnotes: --- (2) Findings.
9.5. - NON-REGIONAL ROAD CAPITAL EXPANSION FEE [2] Footnotes: --- (2) --- Editor's note Res. No. 12262006R003, adopted Dec. 26, 2006, deleted former 9.5, and enacted a new 9.5 as set out herein. The former
More informationKathy Coon, SRA Appraisal Review: CSI Style ( )
Appraisal Review: CSI Style Southern California Chapter Appraisal Institute July 16, 2009 Kathy Coon, SRA Chief Appraiser/Director-Appraisal Appraisal Quality Control FNC, Inc. www.fncinc.com com When
More informationAffordable Housing Policy. Economics 312 Martin Farnham
Affordable Housing Policy Economics 312 Martin Farnham Introduction Housing affordability is a significant problem in Canada (especially in Victoria) There are tens of thousands of homeless in Canada Many
More informationATTACHMENT A: FINDINGS
ATTACHMENT A: FINDINGS 1.0 CEQA FINDINGS 1.1 ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORTS Findings pursuant to public resources code Section 21081 and the California Environmental Quality Act Guidelines Sections 15090
More informationHousing as an Investment Greater Toronto Area
Housing as an Investment Greater Toronto Area Completed by: Will Dunning Inc. For: Trinity Diversified North America Limited February 2009 Housing as an Investment Greater Toronto Area Overview We are
More informationCHAPTER 10 FIXED ASSETS AND INTANGIBLE ASSETS
1. a. Property, plant, and equipment or Fixed assets b. Current assets (merchandise inventory) 2. Real estate acquired as speculation should be listed in the balance sheet under the caption Investments,
More information6. Review of Property Value Impacts at Rapid Transit Stations and Lines
6. Review of Property Value Impacts at Rapid Transit Stations and Lines 6.0 Review of Property Value Impacts at Rapid Transit Station April 3, 2001 RICHMOND/AIRPORT VANCOUVER RAPID TRANSIT PROJECT Technical
More information7829 Glenwood Avenue Canal Winchester, Ohio November 19,2013
7829 Glenwood Avenue Canal Winchester, Ohio 43110 614-920-1425 November 19,2013 Technical Director File Reference Number 2013-270 Financial Standards Accounting Board 401 Merritt 7 Norwalk, Connecticut
More informationOAKLAND CITY COUNCIL
REVISED 7/23/2002 APPROVED AS TO FORM AND LEGALITY: DEPUTY CITY ATTORNEY OAKLAND CITY COUNCIL ORDINANCE NO. 12442 C.M.S. AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE OAKLAND MUNICIPAL CODE TO ESTABLISH A JOBS/HOUSING IMPACT
More informationCabarrus County, NC Adequate Public Facilities Ordinance. Contents
Contents Section 15. Adequate Public Facilities Standards.... 2 Section 15-1. Introduction.... 2 Section 15-2. How to Use this Chapter.... 3 Section 15-3. Basic Terms and Definitions... 4 Section 15-4.
More informationA Quantitative Approach to Gentrification: Determinants of Gentrification in U.S. Cities,
A Quantitative Approach to Gentrification: Determinants of Gentrification in U.S. Cities, 1970-2010 Richard W. Martin, Department of Insurance, Legal, Studies, and Real Estate, Terry College of Business,
More informationAssessment Quality: Sales Ratio Analysis Update for Residential Properties in Indiana
Center for Business and Economic Research About the Authors Dagney Faulk, PhD, is director of research and a research professor at Ball State CBER. Her research focuses on state and local tax policy and
More informationThe Effects of Housing Price Changes on the Distribution of Housing Wealth in Singapore
The Effects of Housing Price Changes on the Distribution of Housing Wealth in Singapore Joy Chan Yuen Yee & Liu Yunhua Nanyang Business School, Nanyang Technological University, Nanyang Avenue, Singapore
More informationASSESSORS ANSWER FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS ABOUT REAL PROPERTY Assessors Office, 37 Main Street
A. THE ASSESSMENT PROCESS: ASSESSORS ANSWER FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS ABOUT REAL PROPERTY Assessors Office, 37 Main Street What is mass appraisal? Assessors must value all real and personal property in
More informationA STUDY OF TRANSFER OF DEVELOPMENT RIGHTS (TDR) IN THURSTON COUNTY, WASHINGTON
A STUDY OF TRANSFER OF DEVELOPMENT RIGHTS (TDR) IN THURSTON COUNTY, WASHINGTON Prepared June 2010 by Evergreen College students Jenna Fissenden and Steven Michener with guidance from staff members within
More informationEfficiency in the California Real Estate Labor Market
American Journal of Economics and Business Administration 3 (4): 589-595, 2011 ISSN 1945-5488 2011 Science Publications Efficiency in the California Real Estate Labor Market Dirk Yandell School of Business
More informationMULTIPLE CHALLENGES REAL ESTATE APPRAISAL INDUSTRY FACES QUALITY CONTROL. Issues. Solution. By, James Molloy MAI, FRICS, CRE
REAL ESTATE APPRAISAL INDUSTRY FACES MULTIPLE CHALLENGES By, James Molloy MAI, FRICS, CRE QUALITY CONTROL Third-party real estate appraisal firms are production-driven businesses designed to complete assignments
More informationKESWICK CLUB, L.P. OPINION BY v. Record No JUSTICE LAWRENCE L. KOONTZ, JR. January 12, 2007 COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE
Present: All the Justices KESWICK CLUB, L.P. OPINION BY v. Record No. 060672 JUSTICE LAWRENCE L. KOONTZ, JR. January 12, 2007 COUNTY OF ALBEMARLE FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF ALBEMARLE COUNTY James A. Luke,
More informationLIMITED-SCOPE PERFORMANCE AUDIT REPORT
LIMITED-SCOPE PERFORMANCE AUDIT REPORT Agricultural Land Valuation: Evaluating the Potential Impact of Changing How Agricultural Land is Valued in the State AUDIT ABSTRACT State law requires the value
More informationFOR OFFICE USE ONLY Date Submitted Received By Fees Paid $ Receipt No. Received By Application No. Application Complete Final Action Date
COMMERCIAL, INDUSTRIAL, & MANUFACTURING SITE PLAN (CIM) APPLICATION Mariposa County Planning Department 5100 Bullion Street, P.O. Box 2039 Mariposa, CA 95338 Telephone (209) 966-5151 FAX (209) 742-5024
More informationEstimating User Accessibility Benefits with a Housing Sales Hedonic Model
Estimating User Accessibility Benefits with a Housing Sales Hedonic Model Michael Reilly Metropolitan Transportation Commission mreilly@mtc.ca.gov March 31, 2016 Words: 1500 Tables: 2 @ 250 words each
More informationHedonic Pricing Model Open Space and Residential Property Values
Hedonic Pricing Model Open Space and Residential Property Values Open Space vs. Urban Sprawl Zhe Zhao As the American urban population decentralizes, economic growth has resulted in loss of open space.
More informationGENERAL ASSESSMENT DEFINITIONS
21st Century Appraisals, Inc. GENERAL ASSESSMENT DEFINITIONS Ad Valorem tax. A tax levied in proportion to the value of the thing(s) being taxed. Exclusive of exemptions, use-value assessment laws, and
More informationHow Severe is the Housing Shortage in Hong Kong?
(Reprinted from HKCER Letters, Vol. 42, January, 1997) How Severe is the Housing Shortage in Hong Kong? Y.C. Richard Wong Introduction Rising property prices in Hong Kong have been of great public concern
More informationThe Impact of Market Rate Vacancy Increases Eleven-Year Report
The Impact of Market Rate Vacancy Increases Eleven-Year Report January 1, 1999 - December 31, 2009 Santa Monica Rent Control Board April 2010 TABLE OF CONTENTS Summary 1 Vacancy Decontrol s Effects on
More informationATTACHMENT B DRAFT NON-RESIDENTIAL NEXUS ANALYSIS. Prepared for City of Sonoma. Prepared by: Keyser Marston Associates, Inc.
ATTACHMENT B DRAFT NON-RESIDENTIAL NEXUS ANALYSIS Prepared for City of Sonoma Prepared by: Keyser Marston Associates, Inc. February 2018 TABLE OF CONTENTS I. INTRODUCTION... 1 Purpose... 1 Analysis Scope...
More informationDecember 15, Financial Accounting Standards Board 401 Merritt 7 PO Box 5116 Norwalk, CT
December 15, 2010 Financial Accounting Standards Board 401 Merritt 7 PO Box 5116 Norwalk, CT 06856-5116 International Accounting Standards Board 30 Cannon Street London EC4M 6XH United Kingdom Request
More informationHousing Affordability Research and Resources
Housing Affordability Research and Resources An Analysis of Inclusionary Zoning and Alternatives University of Maryland National Center for Smart Growth Research and Education Abt Associates Shipman &
More informationMONETARY POLICY AND HOUSING MARKET: COINTEGRATION APPROACH
MONETARY POLICY AND HOUSING MARKET: COINTEGRATION APPROACH Doh-Khul Kim, Mississippi State University - Meridian Kenneth A. Goodman, Mississippi State University - Meridian Lauren M. Kozar, Mississippi
More informationResidential May Karl L. Guntermann Fred E. Taylor Professor of Real Estate. Adam Nowak Research Associate
Residential May 2008 Karl L. Guntermann Fred E. Taylor Professor of Real Estate Adam Nowak Research Associate The use of repeat sales is the most reliable way to estimate price changes in the housing market
More informationOffer-back under the Public Works Act - a re-appraisal?
Property, real estate & construction 05 August 2008 Offer-back under the Public Works Act - a re-appraisal? The owners of land held under the Public Works Act 1981 (PWA) may have greater security of investment
More informationValuation of Special Purpose Transportation Properties Dr. Mike Tretheway Chief Economist InterVISTAS Consulting Inc.
Valuation of Special Purpose Transportation Properties Dr. Mike Tretheway Chief Economist InterVISTAS Consulting Inc. Presented to Canadian Property Tax Association 29 September 2014 Background InterVISTAS
More informationAppraisers and Assessors of Real Estate
http://www.bls.gov/oco/ocos300.htm Appraisers and Assessors of Real Estate * Nature of the Work * Training, Other Qualifications, and Advancement * Employment * Job Outlook * Projections Data * Earnings
More informationAd-valorem and Royalty Licensing under Decreasing Returns to Scale
Ad-valorem and Royalty Licensing under Decreasing Returns to Scale Athanasia Karakitsiou 2, Athanasia Mavrommati 1,3 2 Department of Business Administration, Educational Techological Institute of Serres,
More informationREDSTONE. Regression Fundamentals.
REDSTONE from Bradford Advanced Analytics Technologies for Appraisers Regression Fundamentals www.bradfordsoftware.com/redstone Bradford Technologies, Inc. 302 Piercy Road San Jose, CA 95138 800-622-8727
More informationNational Association for several important reasons: GOING BY THE BOOK
GOING BY THE BOOK OR WHAT EVERY REALTOR SHOULD KNOW ABOUT THE REALTOR DUES FORMULA EDITORS NOTE: This article has been prepared at the request of the NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS by its General Counsel,
More informationRATE STUDY IMPACT FEES PARKS
RATE STUDY FOR IMPACT FEES FOR PARKS CITY OF KENMORE, WASHINGTON May 15, 2001 TABLE OF CONTENTS Executive Summary................................................... 1 1. Statutory Basis and Methodology
More informationCALIFORNIA ADVOCATES FOR NURSING HOME REFORM
CALIFORNIA ADVOCATES FOR NURSING HOME REFORM 650 Harrison Street 2nd Floor.San Francisco, CA 94107 415-974-5171 800-474-1116 Fax 415-777- 2904 March 15, 2006 Office of Regulations Department of Health
More informationRESOLUTION NO ( R)
RESOLUTION NO. 2013-06- 088 ( R) A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF McKINNEY, TEXAS, APPROVING THE LAND USE ASSUMPTIONS FOR THE 2012-2013 ROADWAY IMPACT FEE UPDATE WHEREAS, per Texas Local
More informationAPPENDIX A. Market Study Standards and Requirements
APPENDIX A Market Study Standards and Requirements Section 42(m)(1)(A)(iii) of the IRS Code and Section IV(A)(2) of the 2018 Qualified Allocation Plan (QAP) require market studies for all low-income housing
More informationImlTRUST LANDS. August 15, 2014
1707 North 9th Street PO Box 5523 Bismarck, ND 58506-5523 Phone: (701) 328-2800 Fax: (701 ) 328-3650 www.fand.nd.gov Letter of Comment No. 38 D E PARTMENT OF ImlTRUST LANDS INVE STING FOA EDUCATION Lance
More information