IN THE COURT OF APPEAL IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA AT MELBOURNE No. S APCI
|
|
- Regina Hill
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 1 IN THE COURT OF APPEAL IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA AT MELBOURNE No. S APCI IN THE MATTER OF WILLMOTT FORESTS LIMITED (RECEIVERS AND MANAGERS APPOINTED) (IN LIQUIDATION) (ACN ) WILLMOTT FORESTS LIMITED (RECEIVERS AND MANAGERS APPOINTED) (IN LIQUIDATION) (ACN ) IN ITS CAPACITY AS MANAGER OF THE UNREGISTERED SCHEMES LISTED IN SCHEDULE 2 AND ORS ACCORDING TO SCHEDULE 1 Appellants OUTLINE OF SUBMISSIONS OF THE WILMOTT GROWERS GROUP INC Date of document: 18 May 2012 Filed on behalf of: Willmott Growers Group Inc A L Prepared by: Mills Oakley Lawyers Level Collins Street MELBOURNE VIC 3000 Solicitor's Code: DX: 558 Tel: Fax: Ref: DJMM: Attention: Dan Mackay dmackay@millsoakley.com.au 1. The Appellants have large land holdings in New South Wales and Victoria, on which tenants, represented by WGG, are midway through 25 year leases in respect of which all rent has been paid in advance at the beginning of the term. Unsurprisingly, the Appellants wish to rid the land of these leases, so they can realize the unencumbered freehold rather than the (far less valuable) reversion. 2. This appeal raises the question of whether a lessor, with no other basis for doing so, Hindcastle may destroy the proprietary interest of its commercially inconvenient tenant by embracing liquidation and (through its liquidator) deploying the disclaimer power conferred by s 568 of the Corporations Act 2001 ( the Act ). 3. The Appellants omit the first sentence of the passage from Hindcastle v Barbara Attenborough Associates Ltd 1 ( Hindcastle ) quoted at paragraph 4 of their submissions. The missing sentence identifies the very circumstance that Lord Nicholls of Birkenhead is addressing in the passage: The simplest case is of a landlord and an insolvent tenant. No third parties are involved. Disclaimer operates to determine all the tenant s obligations under the tenant s covenants, and all his rights under the landlord s covenants. (emphasis added) 1 [1997] AC 70, 87.
2 2 4. The learned primary judge cannot have failed to apply the passage, as the passage does not apply to the present circumstances. The passage applies to the inverse, and common, situation of disclaimer by an insolvent tenant of its leasehold. 5. An insolvent tenant (through its liquidator) can disclaim the tenant s leasehold under s 568(1)(c) - (f). Leave is not required; see s 568(1A). The disclaimer would consequently determine the tenant s estate in land; see s 568D(1). There is nothing surprising about this, as the leasehold is the tenant s own property, which the tenant is entitled to surrender. The landlord s reversion becomes freehold. It is a completely different proposition for an insolvent landlord to effect the determination of a tenant s estate in land by a disclaimer, as the leasehold is not the landlord s property. An insolvent landlord can disclaim the landlord s own property or in rem rights under s 568(1)(a), but it cannot disclaim a tenant s in rem rights. 6. In Hindcastle, Lord Nicholls of Birkenhead does not mention disclaimer by an insolvent landlord in his consideration of the application of disclaimer provisions to the principal types of landlord and tenant situations 2. It is not an oversight. Other than a decision of a Master of the Supreme Court of Queensland in Re Jandowae Estates Pty Ltd 3, no case nor commentary can be found where an insolvent landlord is said to be entitled to disclaim a tenant s lease. WGG submits that the decision in Re Jandowae Estates Pty Ltd is incorrect Her Honour rightly rejected the submission that Hindcastle is equally applicable to an insolvent landlord, as such a submission failed to acknowledge that a lease creates both contractual and proprietary rights 5. Her Honour s reliance on this principle is not inconsistent with Progressive Mailing House Pty Ltd v Tabali Pty Ltd 6 ( Tabali ). Rather, the discussion in Tabali is premised upon a lease being both a contract and an estate in land, owned by the tenant. As Mason J notes: 7 Repudiation or fundamental breach of a lease involves considerations which are not present in the case of an ordinary contract. First, the lease vests an estate or interest in land in the lessee and a complex relationship between the parties centres upon that interest in property. Secondly, this relationship has been shaped historically in very large measure by the law of property, though in recent times the relationship has been refined and developed by means of contractual arrangements. 8. Deane J also recognised the dual nature of leases: 8 2 [1997] AC 70, (1989) 7 ACLC There was no contradictor and Bastable (see paragraph 11 below) was not cited. 5 Reasons for Decision at [9], Appeal Book section F. 6 (1985) 157 CLR (1985) 157 CLR 17 at (1985) 157 CLR 17 at 51.
3 3 A lease for a term of years ordinarily possesses a duality of character which can give rise to conceptual difficulties. It is both an executory contract and an executed demise. Its origins lie in contract rather than real property in that the lessee s remedies were originally restricted to a personal action against the lessor on his covenant to give enjoyment of the land 9. Hill J in Kennedy Holdings & property Management Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation 9, referring to this very passage from Deane J, said at 499: This is, of course, true, although it is hardly an adequate description of a lease today to suggest that the benefits of a lessee depend solely upon contract and not upon the underlying estate in land which is demised. Nothing in Tabali suggests to the contrary. Indeed, immediately after the passage quoted by counsel for the applicant, Deane J points out that in time it had become accepted that a lessee had a right to possession which was an interest in the land that the lessee was entitled to protect against third parties. 10. Tabali concerned the application of contractual principles where there is repudiation and termination of a lease. The Appellants submissions require a leap of logic as there has been no repudiation or termination to which contractual principles might apply in the present case. There is simply a question as to whether the Appellants can disclaim leases. Tabali has no relevance to the passage from Hindcastle. Re Bastable 11. The Appellants claim that Re Bastable, Ex Parte the Trustee 10 ( Bastable ) and Dekala Pty Ltd (in liq) v Perth Land & Leisure Ltd 11 ( Dekala ) do not apply to a leasehold interest. In support of this submission, the Appellants refer to an article by Associate Professor David Brown, Disclaimer of land: seeing the wood through the trees 12. The article does not enhance the submissions of the Appellants and insofar as it relies upon Hindcastle, the author misunderstands that the example given by Lord Nicholls related only to an insolvent tenant. 12. In Bastable, the statutory regime (footnoted in the report) was relevantly indistinguishable from ss 568 and 568D of the Act. Romer LJ says: 13 It is in substance contended on behalf of the trustee that if a vendor of real estate, by contract entered into with a purchaser, becomes bankrupt, the trustee in the bankruptcy of the vendor, without disclaiming the land or the interest in the land which was the subject of the contract, can, by disclaiming the contract alone, put himself in the position of owner of the estate freed altogether from the purchaser s interest in the estate, leaving the purchaser only the remedy of proving in the bankruptcy for any loss he may have suffered by having his contract destroyed. That would indeed be a serious contention if it could be maintained (1992) 39 FCR 495 at [1901] 2 KB (1987) 17 NSWLR Insolvency Law Bulletin, April 2012 at pp [1901] 2 KB 518 at
4 4 It cannot, I think, be that such a result was ever intended by the Act. And indeed, when s. 55 is examined, it has, in my view, no such operation or effect. The fallacy of the argument for the appellant lies, I think, in ignoring the nature of the interest of the purchaser of real estate after a contract for its sale has been made between him and the owner of the estate. The purchaser has, then, something more than a pecuniary interest under his contract. He has an equitable interest in the land itself. 13. In both Bastable and Dekala, it was recognised that, insofar as the contract conferred an equitable interest in land, the interest cannot be disclaimed. A lease is both a contract and an estate in land. The finding in Bastable is just as applicable to an interest in land conferred by a lease. 14. If the Appellants are correct in claiming a liquidator can disclaim a contract and in the process extinguish the proprietary and equitable rights of others, then a liquidator can disclaim a contract creating a charge, with the effect of freeing land subject to that charge. Fortunately for banks and commercial stability, the Appellants are not correct. Bennett J said in National Australia Bank v Victoria 14 : As a matter of logic, a trustee in bankruptcy can only disclaim a bankrupt s interest in mortgaged properties. Such a disclaimer would not extend to the interests of a mortgagee. As applied to the present case, the vesting of the Properties occurred subject to the Bank s mortgages. 15. If the liquidator of an insolvent landlord does not want to be burdened with onerous covenants attached to land then it can disclaim the landlord s estate, that is, its freehold. Title escheats to the Crown subject to mortgages and charges 15. There can be no relevant distinction between a purchaser s lien, a charge or a lease. 16. The uncertainty the Appellants claim would occur in the event that a leasehold survives after a contract is disclaimed need not arise, as there is no utility in disclaiming the contract, because the leasehold survives. Section 568D of the Act 17. If the liquidator of an insolvent lessor disclaims under s 568(1)(a) or (c)-(e) or even (f) 16, the company s rights, interests and property affected by s 568D(1) can only be the reversion. There is a textual anomaly in the inclusion of the word liabilities in the expression company s rights, interests, liabilities and property. The Appellants wish to exploit this anomaly. They contend that the word, in that context, denotes every conceivable obligation of the company including a covenant of quiet enjoyment. They further contend that the word liability, when used at the 14 [2010] FCA 1230 at [13]. 15 National Australia Bank v New South Wales(2009) 182 FCR 52; Re Middle Harbour Investments Ltd (No 2) [1977] 2 NSWLR 652 at 660; National Australia Bank v Victoria [2010] FCA 1230 at [15]. 16 Here, the contract is not shown to be unprofitable so s 568(1)(f) may operate subject to s 568(1A).
5 5 end of s 568D(1), is wide enough to include another s proprietary rights (such as a leasehold) or an obligation not to interfere with the proprietary (or other accrued) rights of third parties. 18. In Sims and Anor (as liqs of Enron Australia Pty Ltd) v TXU Electricity Ltd 17, Spigelman CJ said he generally agreed with the following reasoning of Austin J: [23] Austin J accepted the force of s 568D(1) in the following passage (at Simms (as liq of Enron Australia Finance Pty Ltd (in liq)) v TXU Electricity Ltd (2003) 204 ALR 658 ; 48 ACSR 266 at [57] [60]): [57] There is, however, a provision which provides a context for s 568(1B) and an indication that the section was not intended to authorise the variation of contractual rights and obligations in the manner contended for by the plaintiffs. Under s 568D(1) a disclaimer terminates the company s rights and liabilities in respect of the disclaimed contract, while not affecting the counterparty s rights and liabilities except so far as necessary to release the company from liability. I agree with the defendants that under s 568D(1), in its application to an unperformed contract: disclaimer deprives the company of its right to future performance of the contract by the counterparty: see Hindcastle Ltd v Barbara Attenborough Ltd [1997] AC 70 at 87 per Lord Nicholls; Sandtara Pty Ltd v Abigroup Ltd (1996) 42 NSWLR 491 at per Cole JA; and the counterparty s existing, vested contractual rights and benefits are, generally speaking, unaffected by the disclaimer: Capital Prime Properties Plc v Worthgate Ltd (in liq) [2000] 1 BCLC 647 at 654 per Neuberger J; Re Tulloch Ltd (in liq) (1977) 3 ACLR 808 at 813 per Needham J; Rothwells Ltd (in liq) v Spedley Securities Ltd (in liq) (1990) 20 NSWLR 417 at 422 per Hodgson J. (emphasis added) 19. The tenant s right to quiet enjoyment for the remainder of the term is an existing, vested contractual right and benefit. Further, it is a vested property right. The right to quiet enjoyment has already accrued, particularly given the tenants have paid the total rent for the 25 year term in advance. 20. The tenant s entitlement to exclusive possession and quiet enjoyment for the term of the lease is not dependent on the contract, but also arises from the interest in the land, running with the land, and is a property right arising from privity of estate. It is a different right from the landlord s reversionary interest. Lord Nicholls in Hindcastle noted: 18 The rights of the tenant under these covenants will be enforceable by him against the landlord, either by virtue of privity of contract, or privity of estate, or both. (emphasis added) 17 (2005) 53 ACSR 295 at [23]. 18 [1997] AC 70, at 85.
6 6 21. Accordingly, not only is the right to quiet enjoyment an accrued and vested right, it cannot be considered necessary to extinguish the lessee s in rem rights in order to release the insolvent landlord from covenants under the contract. Statutory interpretation 22. The reference to lease of land in s 568(1A) is a reference to the leasehold of a tenant 19. It should not be misconstrued as including the obligations of a lessor under a lease. The lessor does not hold a lease of land, but holds the reversion. 23. Section 568(1A) can be better understood by looking at the commentary introducing the precursor provision in the Bankruptcy Act, carried through to the Act. The Explanatory Memorandum for the Bankruptcy Amendment Bill 1979, in respect of clause 64 disclaimer of onerous property, states: 20 Amendments: The provisions relating to the disclaimer of onerous property will be amended (b) A notice to a lessor (and any sub-lessee or mortgagee) of intention to disclaim a lease must be given by prescribed form (emphasis added) 24. Further, Harmer s General Insolvency Inquiry Report No , Chapter 13 Insolvency administration, deals with disclaimer of leases 21 : Special provision is made in both individual and corporate insolvency for disclaimer of a lease Although it is essential that persons affected by the disclaimer of a lease, such as a lessor, a sub-lessee or a mortgagee of a lease be entitled to notice that the lease is being disclaimed, it does not appear justifiable to permit such persons alone to be able to require the insolvency administrator to seek leave of the court before disclaiming. (emphasis added) 25. The Explanatory Memorandum of the Corporate Law Reform Bill 1992, indicates s 568(1A) was introduced following the Harmer Report s consideration of the individual and corporate insolvency provisions, referred to in the preceding paragraph. 26. It is plain from the above extracts that there is no contemplation of disclaimer of a lease by a lessor. Dated: 18 May 2012 GARRY BIGMORE QC MATTHEW KENNEDY 19 Discussion of s 454(6) of the Companies (Queensland) Code in Re Jandowae Estates Pty Ltd (1989) 7 ACLC 179 at Explanatory Memorandum, Bankruptcy Amendment Bill 1979, paragraph Harmer s General Insolvency Inquiry Report No , Chap. 13 Insolvency administration, page 261 paragraph 619.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA AT MELBOURNE COMMERCIAL AND EQUITY DIVISION COMMERCIAL COURT CORPORATIONS LIST S CI
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA AT MELBOURNE COMMERCIAL AND EQUITY DIVISION COMMERCIAL COURT CORPORATIONS LIST S CI 2011 6816 IN THE MATTER OF WILLMOTT FORESTS LIMITED (RECEIVERS AND MANAGERS APPOINTED)
More informationRe Willmott Forests Ltd [2012] VSC 29
SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA COURT OF APPEAL S APCI 2012 0026 In the Matter of Willmott Forests Limited (Receivers and Managers appointed) (in liquidation) (ACN 063 263 650) BETWEEN WILLMOTT FORESTS LTD (Receivers
More informationIN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY CIV JUDGMENT OF ASHER J
IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY CIV-2008-404-8214 IN THE MATTER OF Section 143 of the Land Transfer Act 1952 BETWEEN AND CAPITAL + MERCHANT INVESTMENTS LIMITED (IN RECEIVERSHIP) AND
More informationSUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND CITATION: Rannadia P/L & Ors v The Sheik Holdings P/L [2006] QCA 366 PARTIES: RANNADIA PTY LTD ACN 086 680 551 (first appellant/first applicant) RAAD MOHAMMED SALIM AL-BAHRANI
More informationDID ANYONE NOTICE? CHALLENGES TO THE VALIDITY OF PROPERTY NOTICES
DID ANYONE NOTICE? CHALLENGES TO THE VALIDITY OF PROPERTY NOTICES Introduction Those involved in mixed-use developments will come across just about every type of property notice: o contractual break notices;
More informationDetermination of Leases
Determination of Leases John Murphy Examiner of Titles Property Registration Authority e-mail john.murphy@prai.ie Solicitors CPD Study Group 26 th March 2015 Copyright Property Registration Authority 2015
More informationTo be vested or not to be vested that is the declaration by Denis Barlin, FTIA, Barrister, 13 Wentworth Selborne Chambers
FEATURE To be vested or not to be vested that is the declaration by Denis Barlin, FTIA, Barrister, 13 Wentworth Selborne Chambers Abstract: A recent stamp duty decision by the New South Wales Court of
More informationTransfer of Land Formalities
Transfer of Land Formalities may hold have a proprietary or equitable interest in the land if the request formalities are satisfied or a specifically enforceable contract exists. Formalities For GLL a
More informationOff-the-plan contracts for residential property. Submission of the Law Society of New South Wales
Off-the-plan contracts for residential property Submission of the Law Society of New South Wales 1. Is there a separate mandatory disclosure regime needed for off-the-plan contracts? Yes, there is a need
More informationLAWS2383 Land Law Notes
LAWS2383 Land Law Notes Native title and Crown grants... 4 Determinable and conditional interests... 4 Legal future interests... 4 Fundamental concepts... 5 Recognised property rights... 5 Contracts and
More informationLAND APPEAL COURT OF QUEENSLAND
LAND APPEAL COURT OF QUEENSLAND CITATION: Moreton Bay Regional Council v White & Anor [2018] QLAC 4 PARTIES: Moreton Bay Regional Council (appellant) v Michael and Lainie White (respondents) FILE NO: LAC010-17
More informationReal Property Law Notes
Real Property Law Notes PART I: THE CREATION AND ACQUISITION OF PROPERTY INTERESTS IN LAND... 3 1 An Introduction to Real Property Law... 3 2 An Introduction to the Torrens System of Land Title... 3 2.1
More informationIN THE COURT OF APPEAL BETWEEN. COLONIAL HOMES AND COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES LIMITED Formerly called BALMAIN PARK LIMITED AND
THE REPUBLIC OF TRINIDAD AND TOBAGO IN THE COURT OF APPEAL CIVIL APPEAL No. 47 OF 2007 BETWEEN COLONIAL HOMES AND COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES LIMITED Formerly called BALMAIN PARK LIMITED AND APPELLANT KASSINATH
More informationPREVENTING THE ACQUISITION OF A RIGHT OF LIGHT BY A CONSENT WITHIN SECTION 3 PRESCRIPTION ACT 1832 HOW CAN IT BE DONE AND WHAT PITFALLS ARE THERE?
PREVENTING THE ACQUISITION OF A RIGHT OF LIGHT BY A CONSENT WITHIN SECTION 3 PRESCRIPTION ACT 1832 HOW CAN IT BE DONE AND WHAT PITFALLS ARE THERE? By Andrew Francis, Barrister Serle Court, 6 New Square,
More informationHirers and lessors beware
Hirers and lessors beware Keep up or risk your goods and securities slipping through your hands By Karl Hill* Karl Hill While your contracts may be watertight in today s legal environment, unless you make
More informationCITATION: Sertari Pty Ltd v Nirimba Developments Pty Ltd [2007] NSWCA 324
NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL CITATION: Sertari Pty Ltd v Nirimba Developments Pty Ltd [2007] NSWCA 324 FILE NUMBER(S): 40202 of 2007 HEARING DATE(S): 30 July 2007 JUDGMENT DATE: 15 November 2007 PARTIES:
More informationLa w of forfeiture faced with radical reform An overview of the Landlord and Tenant (Termination of Tenancies) Bill
La w of forfeiture faced with radical reform An overview of the Landlord and Tenant (Termination of Tenancies) Bill Received (in revised form): 5 December 2006 Guy Walton works as an In-House Real Estate
More informationBefore: THE PRESIDENT OF THE QUEEN'S BENCH {SIR ANTHONY MAY) LORD JUSTICE JACOB MR JUSTICE LEWISON. Between: VANDAL FOOTWEAR LTD.
Case No: Al/2009/0846 Neutral Citation Number:!20091 EWCA Civ 1478 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF JUDICATURE COURT OF APPEAL (CIVIL DIVISION) ON APPEAL FROM THE TECHNOLOGY AND CONSTRUCTION COURT QBD (HIS HONOUR
More informationRECOVERING COSTS IN THE FIRST-TIER TRIBUNAL. CIH Home Ownership & Leasehold Management Conference & Exhibition 5 and 6 February 2014
RECOVERING COSTS IN THE FIRST-TIER TRIBUNAL INTRODUCTIONS MARK OAKLEY Why is it important? How else would the costs be paid? Do you really want to? Funding litigation Typical Scenarios Lessee Application
More informationSUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND CITATION: Dwyer v Derek & Anor [2003] QSC 274 PARTIES: JEFFERY SEAN DWYER (applicant) v RITA MARIA-ANGELA DEREK (first respondent) JOHN ALEXANDER DEREK (second respondent) JEFFERY
More informationIntroduction to Leases:
Introduction to Leases: Essential Fundamentals for Searching and Examining Leasehold Estates Presented by Mel Platt Vice-President & Sr. Commercial Underwriter Commonwealth Land Title Insurance Company
More informationENSURING CREDITOR PROTECTION IN ASIA PACIFIC CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS
Asia Pacific Projects Update ENSURING CREDITOR PROTECTION IN ASIA PACIFIC CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS PART I: THE NEW AUSTRALIAN PERSONAL PROPERTY SECURITIES LAW KEY CONTACTS Jane Hider Partner T +61 3 9274
More informationA Landlord's Lien for Rent on Bankruptcy of His Tenant
Washington University Law Review Volume 1 Issue 4 January 1916 A Landlord's Lien for Rent on Bankruptcy of His Tenant Follow this and additional works at: http://openscholarship.wustl.edu/law_lawreview
More informationDealing with fixtures on a lease renewal A trap for the unwary? Tom Roscoe, Wilberforce Chambers. April 2014
Dealing with fixtures on a lease renewal A trap for the unwary? Tom Roscoe, Wilberforce Chambers April 2014 Introduction 1. In negotiations or proceedings for the renewal of a lease, parties often focus
More informationIN THE UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE ) ) ) ) ) ) ) OPINION 1. Before the Court is the Objection of the FLYi and
IN THE UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE IN RE: FLYi, INC., et al. Debtors. ) ) ) ) ) ) ) Chapter 11 Case Nos. 05-20011 (MFW) (Jointly Administered) Re: Docket Nos. 2130, 2176,
More informationROYAL BANK REALTY INC. ASSESSOR OF AREA BURNABY-NEW WESTMINSTER. Supreme Court of British Columbia (A902670) Vancouver Registry
The following version is for informational purposes only, for the official version see: http://www.courts.gov.bc.ca/ for Stated Cases see also: http://www.assessmentappeal.bc.ca/ for PAAB Decisions SC
More informationLandlord and tenant in an insolvency context. David Nicholls Landmark Chambers
Landlord and tenant in an insolvency context David Nicholls Landmark Chambers Insolvency trends - corporate Insolvency trends - personal Key statistics Total annual company insolvencies at lowest level
More informationPROPERTY LAW SUMMARY 2011
SUMMARY 2011 LAWSKOOL PTY LTD CONTENTS HOW DOES THE LAW DEFINE PROPERTY 5 What can be considered property 5 The rights of property 6 The Distinction between PERSONAL and REAL property 7 Real property 7
More informationWHEN IS A LANEWAY A PUBLIC HIGHWAY?
WHEN IS A LANEWAY A PUBLIC HIGHWAY? Author: Julie Davis Date: 1 September, 2016 Copyright 2016 This work is copyright. Apart from any permitted use under the Copyright Act 1968, no part may be reproduced
More informationPeter Levaggi, Joint Head of Property Litigation Group, Charles Russell LLP
Peter Levaggi, Joint Head of Property Litigation Group, Charles Russell LLP Roger Elford, Joint Head of Group, Charles Russell LLP II JORDANS CONTENTS Foreword Preface Table of Cases Table of Statutes
More informationProperty. A Carelessly Written Cheque Could Render a Property Purchase to Fall Through
Newsletter December 2014 Property A Carelessly Written Cheque Could Render a Property Purchase to Fall Through Introduction Advantages of drawing a cheque for payment are plenty: for example, one does
More informationDUBLIN SOLICITORS CPD 26 TH March 2015 THE LAND AND CONVEYANCING LAW REFROM ACT 2009 IMPACT FOR CONVEYANCING PRACTITIONERS
DUBLIN SOLICITORS CPD 26 TH March 2015 THE LAND AND CONVEYANCING LAW REFROM ACT 2009 IMPACT FOR CONVEYANCING PRACTITIONERS Codification and Simplification were the key aims behind the Act. The Act removed
More informationRECOVERING COSTS IN THE LVT. CIH Home Ownership & Leasehold Management Conference & Exhibition 5 and 6 February 2013
RECOVERING COSTS IN THE LVT INTRODUCTIONS MARK OAKLEY Why is it important? How else would the costs be paid? Do you really want to? Funding litigation Typical Scenarios Lessee Application regarding service
More informationOccupation certificates and PCA closure of files
Occupation certificates and PCA closure of files AAC Conference, WatersEdge, Walsh Bay 30 October 2009 Paper presented by Michael Mantei, town planner and solicitor, Planning Law Solutions Liability limited
More informationThe Shotgun Tenancy: The Fate of the Prime Landlord and Subtenant When a Bankrupt Tenant Rejects Its Lease in Bankruptcy
From ALI CLE's The Practical Real Estate Lawyer The Shotgun Tenancy: The Fate of the Prime Landlord and Subtenant When a Bankrupt Tenant Rejects Its Lease in Bankruptcy Michael Pollack, Of Counsel at Ballard
More informationAvoiding Commercial Lease Pitfalls
Avoiding Commercial Lease Pitfalls LSNT CPD 7 August 2013 Prof Les McCrimmon & Mr David Baldry Barristers William Forster Chambers Focus of Discussion Essential elements of a lease Notice to Quit Notice
More informationINSTRUCTIONS TO SOLICITORS
INSTRUCTIONS TO SOLICITORS (NORTHERN IRELAND) PLATFORM Platform P.O. Box 3462 Cheadle Road Leek ST13 9BG Telephone: 0345 070 1999 DX 16351 (Leek) We should like you to act on our behalf in relation to
More informationLEASEHOLD ISSUES MASTERCLASS POWERS OF LEASING AND THE EFFECT OF A SURRENDER. Gary Cowen, Falcon Chambers
LEASEHOLD ISSUES MASTERCLASS POWERS OF LEASING AND THE EFFECT OF A SURRENDER Gary Cowen, Falcon Chambers 1. In this presentation, I shall consider the powers of leasing and of accepting a surrender where
More informationEXPOSURE DRAFT - FOR COMMENT AND DISCUSSION ONLY. Deadline for comment: 10 August Please quote reference: PUB00220.
Deadline for comment: 10 August 2016. Please quote reference: PUB00220. QUESTION WE VE BEEN ASKED QB XX/XX INCOME TAX DATE OF ACQUISITION OF LAND All legislative references are to the Income Tax Act 2007
More informationINTERPRETATION OF RESTRICTIVE COVENANTS
INTERPRETATION OF RESTRICTIVE COVENANTS Author: Philip Barton Date: 1 October, 2013 Copyright 2013 This work is copyright. Apart from any permitted use under the Copyright Act 1968, no part may be reproduced
More informationState Reporting Bureau
fares'] Qsc. 343 State Reporting Bureau Queensland Government Department of Justice and Attorney-General Transcript of Proceedings Copyright in this transcript is vested in the Crown. Copies thereof must
More informationINTERNATIONAL COUNCIL OF SHOPPING CENTERS 2018 Canadian Law Conference
Camelino GalessiereLLP LAWYERS 6 Adelaide St. E. Suite 220 Toronto, ON M5C 1H6 416.306.3827 lgalessiere@cglegal.ca INTERNATIONAL COUNCIL OF SHOPPING CENTERS 2018 Canadian Law Conference Bankruptcy & Insolvency
More informationNEW ZEALAND PARLIAMENTARY LIBRARY
BILLS DIGEST PROPERTY LAW BILL 2006 Date of Introduction: 30 October 2006 Bills Digest No. 1444 NEW ZEALAND PARLIAMENTARY LIBRARY Bills Digest No. 1444 Published by the Parliamentary Library Parliament
More informationSUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND CITATION: Simpson & Ors v Jackson [2014] QSC 191 PARTIES: FILE NO: 5346 of 2014 DIVISION: PROCEEDING: ORIGINATING COURT: CHERYL DIANN SIMPSON (plaintiff) TERRY STEPHEN SIMPSON
More informationTHE IMPLICATIONS OF THE ARROW ASSET MANAGEMENT CASE. Presented by: Francesco Andreone
Strata and Community Title in Australia for the 21 st Century III Conference THE IMPLICATIONS OF THE ARROW ASSET MANAGEMENT CASE Presented by: Francesco Andreone francesco.andreone@andreones.com The Implications
More informationThe Right to Manage A short guide
The Right to Manage A short guide Real Estate Private Client Corporate Law CONTENTS Introduction 2 Commonhold & Leasehold Reform Act 2002 4 Qualifying conditions 4 Setting up a right to manage company
More informationAssignments Pro Tanto, And Why To Avoid Them
Assignments Pro Tanto, And Why To Avoid Them Thomas C. Barbuti Sublease? Assignment? Assignment pro tanto? Maybe a sublease or an assignment, but an assignment pro tanto is an invitation to fracture occupancy
More informationSTATE OF MICHIGAN COURT OF APPEALS
STATE OF MICHIGAN COURT OF APPEALS FRANK J. NOA, Plaintiff-Appellee, UNPUBLISHED October 13, 2005 v No. 255310 Otsego Circuit Court AGATHA C. NOA, ESTATE OF MICHAEL J. LC No. 03-010202-CH NOA and M&M ENTERPRIZES,
More information2010 No. 11 LAND REGISTRATION. Land Registry (Fees) Order (Northern Ireland) 2010
STATUTORY RULES OF NORTHERN IRELAND 2010 No. 11 LAND REGISTRATION Land Registry (Fees) Order (Northern Ireland) 2010 Made - - - - 21st January 2010 Affirmed by resolution of the Assembly on 1st March 2010
More informationLeases (S.566) Manual Part
Leases (S.566) Manual Part 19-2-21 Document last reviewed May 2017 1 Leases (S.566) 21.1 A lease is a particular form of wasting asset which is subject to special rules. For Capital Gains Tax purposes,
More informationPLEASE NOTE. For more information concerning the history of this Act, please see the Table of Public Acts.
PLEASE NOTE This document, prepared by the Legislative Counsel Office, is an office consolidation of this Act, current to May 30, 2009. It is intended for information and reference purposes only. This
More informationa short guide to The Right to Manage
a short guide to The Right to Manage CONTENTS Page 1 INTRODUCTION 2 commonhold & leasehold reform act 2002 Qualifying Conditions SETTING UP A RIGHT TO MANAGE COMPANY INVITATION NOTICE CLAIM NOTICE LANDLORD
More informationAdverse Possession and Applications to the Land Registry. Jonathan Klein and Duncan Heath
Adverse Possession and Applications to the Land Registry Jonathan Klein and Duncan Heath A is the registered proprietor of Blackacre. Blackacre has an area of 100 square hectares. B is the registered proprietor
More informationWHERE ARE WE NOW ON SERVICE CHARGES?
WHERE ARE WE NOW ON SERVICE CHARGES? by John Furber QC John specialises in all aspects of the law of real property, with an emphasis on property developments and commercial leases. He also has many years
More informationImpact of Australia Post s changes to the delivery of letters on the service of notices under commercial leases
Impact of Australia Post s changes to the delivery of letters on the service of notices under commercial leases Background In January 2016, Australia Post implemented a number of changes to the delivery
More informationSUZUKI AUSTRALIA PTY. LIMITED ACN ABN TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF SALE
SUZUKI AUSTRALIA PTY. LIMITED ACN 001 828 164 ABN 57 001 828 164 TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF SALE Your transaction is subject to these legally binding terms and conditions. Please read them carefully before
More information(a) who the persons, or each group of persons, holding the common or group rights comprising the native title are; and
Native Title History! Despite the international recognition of Indigenous or native people in other sovereign countries! Australia s common law system did not formally recognise native right like it does
More informationIIN THE COURT OF APPEAL BETWEEN. HEATHER BLACKMAN and. And
REPUBLIC OF TRINIDAD AND TOBAGO IIN THE COURT OF APPEAL Civ.A No 66 of 1999 BETWEEN HEATHER BLACKMAN and WINSTON MILLER Appellants And TAURUS SERVICES LIMITED Respondent Panel: R. Nelson, J.A. W. Kangaloo,
More informationEasements, Covenants and Profits à Prendre Executive Summary
Easements, Covenants and Profits à Prendre Executive Summary Consultation Paper No 186 (Summary) 28 March 2008 EASEMENTS, COVENANTS AND PROFITS À PRENDRE: A CONSULTATION PAPER EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 1.1 This
More informationThe Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth)
The Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth) The Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth) ( Act ) creates a single national law governing security interests and similar transactions with respect
More informationK/S Victoria v House of Fraser: Where are we now?
K/S Victoria v House of Fraser: Where are we now? John Randall QC The question of whether the liability of a tenant s guarantor can survive an assignment has been debated since 1996 Sandi Murdoch, Estates
More informationPrinciples of Property Law: Exam Notes Trimester 2, 2016
Principles of Property Law: Exam Notes Trimester 2, 2016 Concepts of Property 4 Property rights v Contractual rights 4 Recognition of New Property Types 5 Classification of Property 6 Doctrine of Fixtures
More informationPriorities of Interests in Registered Land. Kester Lees Falcon Chambers
Priorities of Interests in Registered Land Kester Lees Falcon Chambers OVERVIEW This seminar will cover: 1. How to protect an interest on the Register of Title. 2. The rules under Land Registration Act
More informationLand Titling Law and Practice in NSW
Table of Contents Land Titling Law and Practice in NSW Stilianou Preliminary Preface, Tables, Index 1. Legal Aspects of Land Titling 2. The Registrar-General and the Registrar-General s Directions 3. The
More informationIN THE DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA FIFTH DISTRICT JULY TERM v. CASE NO. 5D
IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA FIFTH DISTRICT JULY TERM 2007 LEESBURG COMMUNITY CANCER CENTER, ETC., Appellant, v. CASE NO. 5D06-2457 LEESBURG REGIONAL MEDICAL CENTER, INC., ETC.,
More informationCivil and Administrative Tribunal New South Wales
Civil and Administrative Tribunal New South Wales Medium Neutral Citation: Hearing dates: Date of orders: Decision date: Jurisdiction: Before: Decision: Catchwords: Legislation Cited: Cases Cited: Category:
More informationPERPETUITY ACT. Published by Quickscribe Services Ltd.
PDF Version [Printer-friendly - ideal for printing entire document] PERPETUITY ACT Published by Quickscribe Services Ltd. Updated To: [includes 2016 Bill 18, c. 5 amendments (effective March 10, 2016)]
More informationMemorandum of Provisions
Memorandum of Provisions 252608_BOM35400_1111.indd 1 Registered Number AF751541 AA1546 State or Territory New South Wales Victoria 713456017 Queensland 1708558 Australian Capital Territory M421 Tasmania
More informationASSETS OF COMMUNITY VALUE. John Male QC and Thomas Jefferies. Community right to bid (assets of community value)
ASSETS OF COMMUNITY VALUE John Male QC and Thomas Jefferies Introduction 1. In November 2011 the Department for Communities and Local Government published A plain English guide to the Localism Act. That
More information3 Selected Cases On Ground Leases
3 Selected Cases On Ground Leases 3.1 INTRODUCTION Certain problems arise again and again in the world of ground leases. Most of this book seeks to prevent those problems by recognizing that they can occur
More informationIN THE HIGH COURT OF JUSTICE KEITH BAHADOORSINGH. And. And
THE REPUBLIC OF TRINIDAD AND TOBAGO IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUSTICE Claim No.CV2010-00292 Between KEITH BAHADOORSINGH And Claimant CHANDROWTIE MANGRA And First Named Defendant SHUBHASH GOSINE Second Named
More informationRev. Rul CLICK HERE to return to the home page. 1. Purpose.
CLICK HERE to return to the home page Rev. Rul. 55-540 1. Purpose. The purpose of this Revenue Ruling is to state the position of the Internal Revenue Service regarding the income tax aspects of the purported
More informationBERMUDA 1974 : 52 LANDLORD AND TENANT ACT
Title 26 Laws of Bermuda Item 41 BERMUDA 1974 : 52 LANDLORD AND TENANT ACT 1974 ARRANGEMENT OF SECTIONS PART I PRELIMINARY 1 Interpretation PART II PAYMENT OF RENT 2 Rental period where no agreement in
More informationTERMINATION OF TENANCIES FOR TENANT DEFAULT EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
TERMINATION OF TENANCIES FOR TENANT DEFAULT (LAW COM NO 303) EXECUTIVE SUMMARY INTRODUCTION 1.1 The law of forfeiture currently regulates how and when a landlord may terminate a tenancy as a result of
More informationValuer-General and Another v Addington Raceway Limited - [1969] NZLR 327
Valuer-General and Another v Addington Raceway Limited - [1969] NZLR 327 Land Valuation Court, Christchurch 21 October; 11 November 1968 Tompkins J. Valuers and valuations -- Particular kinds of valuation
More informationLETTER TO COMPANY - DRAFT CITY OF LONDON LAW SOCIETY LAND LAW COMMITTEE CERTIFICATE OF TITLE (7 TH EDITION 2016 UPDATE)
LETTER TO COMPANY - DRAFT CITY OF LONDON LAW SOCIETY LAND LAW COMMITTEE CERTIFICATE OF TITLE (7 TH EDITION 2016 UPDATE) This is the first of two letters which may be sent by the solicitors giving the Certificate
More informationrbk Doc#236 Filed 03/22/18 Entered 03/22/18 15:00:22 Main Document Pg 1 of 9
18-5004-rbk Doc#236 Filed 03/22/18 Entered 03/22/18 15:00:22 Main Document Pg 1 of IN THE UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS SAN ANTONIO DIVISION In re: A GACI, L.L.C., Debtor.
More informationCalifornia Bar Examination
California Bar Examination Essay Question: Real Property And Selected Answers The Orahte Group is NOT affiliated with The State Bar of California PRACTICE PACKET p.1 Question Larry leased in writing to
More informationCONTRACT OF SALE OF REAL ESTATE 1
CONTRACT OF SALE OF REAL ESTATE * Part 1 of the form of contract published by the Law Institute of Victoria Limited and The Real Estate Institute of Victoria Ltd 1980. Property address:... The vendor agrees
More informationTenure confusion: are shared ownership lessees assured tenants, long lessees or both? TRISTAN SALTER Five Paper October 2018
Tenure confusion: are shared ownership lessees assured tenants, long lessees or both? TRISTAN SALTER Five Paper October 2018 This article seeks to re-examine the case of Richardson v Midland Heart [2008]
More informationTHE KIAMBU COUNTY VALUATION AND RATING BILL, 2015 ARRANGEMENT OF CLAUSES PART I PRELIMINARY PART II ADMINISTRATION PART III- VALUATION
THE KIAMBU COUNTY VALUATION AND RATING BILL, 2015 ARRANGEMENT OF CLAUSES Clause PART I PRELIMINARY 1- Short title. 2- Interpretation. 3- Purpose of the Act. PART II ADMINISTRATION 4- Functions of the Department.
More informationPPSA retention of title property
PPSA retention of title property Introduction Retention of title property, in general terms, describes any property which is in the possession of one party (pursuant to the terms of some agreement) but
More informationPassing of property. Retention of title. Buyer pays seller (tracing/registering payment)
0 Bonus Question Natureally plc sells leather to various garment makers on terms that require payment days after delivery. About 0% of its sales are to regular customers and the rest are to one-off customers.
More informationPolicy and Procedures for Lawyers and Surveyors March 2006
PDCAs Policy and Procedures for Lawyers and Surveyors March 2006 MGA Compliance Statement: Exception for parcels created in land registration as result of an approved plan of survey/subdivision Clause
More information4.01 PROPERTY OF THE ESTATE
4 The Estate 4.01 PROPERTY OF THE ESTATE 4.01(a) The Estate In General The concept of the estate defines in some fashion the reach of the bankruptcy law in a bankruptcy case. The filing of a voluntary,
More informationLAING: On land law. 1. Licences:
LAING: On land law. Topics: 1. Licences 2. Leasehold Interests 3. Strata Title 4. Native Title 5. Boundaries 6. Easements 7. Mortgages 8. Co-ownership 9. Covenants 1. Licences: Licence: 1. A permission,
More informationCompany Officers: (Names, Title, Phone & Fax Numbers, addresses please) Business Operations Manager:
APPLICATION FOR CREDIT Date: Branch: ABN: Company Name: ACN: Trading Name: Registered Office: Trading Address: Postal Address: Phone No: E-mail Addresses: Fax No: Full Names, addresses & phone numbers
More informationYour lease (Retail Lease)
Your lease (Retail Lease) Whether you are a landlord or tenant, the terms of your lease can influence the flexibility, profitability and reputation of your business. There are a number of important factors
More informationBuying a residential property in. England and Wales
Buying a residential property in CONTENTS Buying a residential property in ----------------------------------------Page 3 Freehold, Leasehold and Commonhold properties------------------------------page
More informationPART I OF THE LANDLORD AND TENANT ACT 1987 TWENTY YEARS ON BUT STILL NOT WORKING
PART I OF THE LANDLORD AND TENANT ACT 1987 TWENTY YEARS ON BUT STILL NOT WORKING A paper presented to The Property Litigation Association Autumn Training Day at the Royal Society of Medicine on 2 October
More informationRevision Workshop Agency Practice
Revision Workshop Agency Practice The starting point is the instruction from the clients. It is then for the professional agent to define the scope of work and confirm the instructions (including the payment
More informationCONDOMINIUM MORTGAGE FINANCING
CONDOMINIUM MORTGAGE FINANCING INTRODUCTION: Condominium mortgage financing is generally in one of two forms. During development of the project, the owner/declarant will have blanket mortgage financing
More informationEquipment Lease Agreement Template
Equipment Lease Agreement Template LESSOR; LESSEE; (insert name and address) (insert name and address) DATE: 1. LEASE: The lessor hereby agrees to lease to Lessee and the Lessee hereby agrees to take on
More informationDilapidations. Topics of the moment. A Paper for The White Paper Conference Company Commercial Property Leases Conference 10 October 2017
Dilapidations Topics of the moment A Paper for The White Paper Conference Company Commercial Property Leases Conference 10 October 2017 Guy Fetherstonhaugh QC FALCON CHAMBERS Introduction 1. Leases that
More informationPLANNING & BUILDING INSPECTION. Dale Ellis, AICP Assistant Director of Planning and Building Inspection
MEMORANDUM PLANNING & BUILDING INSPECTION County of Monterey Date: June 17, 2003 To: From: Members of the Planning Commission Dale Ellis, AICP Assistant Director of Planning and Building Inspection Subject:
More informationINCOME TAX DATE OF ACQUISITION OF LAND, AND START DATE FOR 2-YEAR BRIGHT-LINE TEST
QUESTION WE VE BEEN ASKED QB 17/02 INCOME TAX DATE OF ACQUISITION OF LAND, AND START DATE FOR 2-YEAR BRIGHT-LINE TEST All legislative references are to the Income Tax Act 2007 (the Act) unless otherwise
More informationMemorandum of Provisions
Memorandum of Provisions Registered Number AF751541 AA1546 State or Territory New South Wales Victoria 713456017 Queensland 1708558 Australian Capital Territory M421 Tasmania 11457421 South Australia 372121
More informationPersonal Property Securities Act 2008 (Cth) Background and Key Concepts 15 JUNE Important
Personal Property Securities Act 2008 (Cth) Background and Key Concepts 15 JUNE 2011 Important Why is it important? In October 2011, the Personal Property Securities Reform (the PPS Reform) will commence
More informationHomes (Fitness for Human Habitation and Liability for Housing Standards) Bill
Homes (Fitness for Human Habitation and Liability for Housing Standards) Bill EXPLANATORY NOTES Explanatory notes to the Bill, prepared by the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government with
More informationPossessory Title in the Context of Aboriginal Claimants
Possessory Title in the Context of Aboriginal Claimants Brady Pohle* To the present day, no court in Australia has decided a case of possessory title being claimed by Aboriginal claimants. In the landmark
More information