Minutes 2016 Minnetonka Local Board of Appeal and Equalization Monday, April 11, Mayor Terry Schneider called the meeting to order at 6:18 p.m.

Transcription

1 Minutes Minnetonka Local Board of Appeal and Equalization Monday, April 11, 1. Call to Order. Mayor Terry Schneider called the meeting to order at 6:18 p.m. 2. Roll Call: Council members Tony Wagner, Dick Allendorf, Patty Acomb, Brad Wiersum, and Tim Bergstedt, and Mayor Terry Schneider were present. Bob Ellingson was present at 6:25 p.m. 3. Introductory Report. City Assessor Colin Schmidt gave the report. 4. Appeals to the board of review: A. Valuation changes being brought by the City Assessor to the Local Board of Appeal and Equalization for action: Schneider read the following into the record: Petitioner 1) Keith Lunzer Kirsten Lunzer 4131 Dynasty Dr ) Thomas Campbell Johanna Campbell 3806 Williston Rd ) Andrew Finn Libby Finn 2327 Meeting Pl ) Eugene Dobkin Dahlgren Rd ) Brian Noah Dana Noah $453,100 $456,500 $413,700 $292,600 $244,600 $225,000 $758,300 $807,600 $777,400 $165,400 $178,100 $165,000 $270,500 $280,800 $245,000

2 5321 Michaele La ) Andrew Kremer Anh Kremer Post Rd ) Mark Kozikowski Tamara Kozikowski 2425 Grays Landing Rd ) Ann Herzog-Olson 4217 Christy La ) Paul Gunderson Camilla Gunderson Creek Rd W ) Stanislav Shafir Iryna Shafir 3502 Larchwood Dr ) Steven Sundberg Katharine Sundberg 2316 Sheridan Ter ) Douglas Nelson Marilyn Nelson Creek Rd W ) Paul Chevalier Sandra Chevalier Glenavon Ct ) Sylvia Erickson Skyview Dr ) Richard Saliterman 2105 Hopkins Crossroad $409,200 $465,200 $445,300 $1,612,000 $1,744,500 $1,675,000 $380,200 $415,300 $370,000 $381,400 $435,000 $381,400 $381,100 $378,700 $325,000 $483,400 $517,000 $483,200 $150,000 $175,000 $165,000 $500,900 $547,900 $532,500 $218,900 $230,800 $150,000 $161,800 $170,600 $125,100

3 ) Thomas Bohn Jr $514,600 $499,200 $430,000 Jenna Bohn 1908 Welland Ave ) Richard Ploetz $459,300 $487,100 $477,000 Karen Ploetz Sussex Dr ) Michael Tolliver $392,300 $420,800 $409,400 Luann Tolliver Wychewood Rd ) Damien Aguilar $365,800 $396,700 $385,000 Kim Aguilar North St ) Jo Soo $474,200 $484,300 $470,000 Kristin L H Soo 2391 Vernon Cir ) Richard DeLaCruz $611,800 $605,700 $526,900 Rebecca DeLaCruz 5405 Highland Rd ) Paul Gotlieb $632,900 $712,600 $670,000 Leslie Gotlieb Cedar Pass ) Thomas Lutz $405,200 $449,200 $392,000 Marcia Lutz 3677 Steele St ) Michael Speca $378,800 $425,400 $399,200 Jennifer Speca The Strand ) John Twele $250,000 $288,700 $250,000

4 Maressia Twele 5121 Baker Rd Minnetonka, MN ) John Grieme Dulce Grieme McGinty Rd W ) Hugh Ritchey Diane Ritchey Crestridge Dr ) Kelly Chermack 5949 Fairwood La ) Jeffry Roehl Natchana Roehl 4600 Lynwood Ter ) HP Minnesota I LLC Crestridge Dr ) Michael Mehle Jan Mehle 2009 Runnymeade Ct ) Diana Hoyt Jennifer La ) Katharine Smith 4820 Westminster Rd ) David Herbst Elcy Wang 4703 Asher Dr ) Dana Gurstel 9708 St Johns Rd $481,900 $477,300 $462,800 $291,200 $322,600 $295,000 $369,900 $377,300 $340,800 $309,400 $332,800 $309,200 $700,000 $690,500 $680,000 $333,500 $386,200 $330,000 $332,600 $339,000 $325,300 $594,400 $593,400 $562,400 $853,900 $853,700 $780,000 $421,300 $460,900 $433,300

5 ) Hyung Choi Kristin Choi Old Bren Rd Minnetonka, MN ) Mark Ravich Overlook Dr ) Elizabeth Wilson McGinty Rd W ) William Handsaker Minnetonka Blvd ) Deborah Lien Bierbaum 1934 Linner Rd ) Paul Specketer Raquel Specketer Huntingdon La ) Calm Bay LLC Grays Bay Blvd $639,200 $692,800 $645,000 $1,327,500 $1,348,600 $1,100,000 $1,309,000 $1,424,200 $1,325,000 $257,600 $299,200 $290,100 $673,600 $692,000 $599,000 $908,700 $728,800 $643,000 $2,506,500 $2,700,000 $2,250,000 Wiersum moved, Wagner seconded a motion to approve the assessors recommendations. All voted yes. Motion carried. B. Petitions to the Local Board of Appeal and Equalization requiring advisors recommendation: Petitioner 1) Xiwen Zhao Yuqing Chen Creek Ridge Tr $362,000 $369,500 Advisors

6 ) William Ogram Jr Mary Ogram 6102 Creek Ridge Ct ) Bakal Tziyon 5562 Bimini Dr Minnetonka, MN ) Sandra Cronin 6110 Concord Hill La ) Owen Moen Diane Moen Powderhorn Dr ) Calm Bay LLC Grays Bay Blvd ) Thomas Johnson Jill Johnson Tammer La ) WN Webster Inc Smith Dr ) Bruce Wollenberg Ruth Wollenberg 5100 Prescott Dr ) Leo Hendrickson Ann Hendrickson 9701 Cedar Lake Rd ) Robert Hovelson Marilyn Hovelson Minnehaha Pl $779,700 $823,500 $192,700 $216,900 $297,000 $324,400 $255,100 $269,300 $2,506,500 $2,700,000 $434,500 $468,600 $203,400 $164,700 $273,500 $318,900 $199,900 $162,700 $470,000 $500,000 Advisors

7 ) Calm Bay LLC Grays Bay Blvd ) Mary Nelson 5721 High Park Dr ) John Hinnenthal Joann Hinnenthal 2410 Bantas Point Rd ) Jerry Heine Patricia Heine Adeline La ) Benjamin Johnson Michelle Johnson 4736 Gaywood Dr ) Elaine Kaehler 4163 Hull Rd $1,475,000 $1,500,000 $260,400 $265,800 $200,000 $222,000 $156,700 $195,000 $368,400 $388,400 $250,700 $261,500 Advisors Bill Webster, Smith Drive, said he purchased the house last April for his son. The assessor assessed the value at $203,400 for. For 2017 the assessor said the value could only be lowered to $164,700. Webster said he bought the house from someone who was going to clean it up and flip it. The purchase price for that person was the regular MLS listing of $110,000. Webster purchased the home from that person for $125,000. He didn t think it was fair he was being taxed at the $164,700 value. Schneider said Webster would have to convince the advisors to agree with him. He said the assessment determination was more complicated than just the purchase price. Don Hendrickson speaking on the behalf of his parents property at 9701 Cedar Lake Road said the assessed value seemed much higher than the other houses in the area. Schneider said Hendrickson could look at the comparable data with the advisors. Allendorf moved, Acomb seconded a motion to refer the items to the advisors. All voted yes. Motion carried.

8 C. Petitions to the Local Board of Appeal and Equalization to be referred back to the Assessing staff for review: Petitioner 1) St Pauls Evan Luth Church (Mes Amis French School) Lake St Extension $N/A $106,000 Wiersum moved, Bergstedt seconded a motion to refer the item back to staff. All voted yes. 5. Recess and continue meeting Wiersum moved, Allendorf seconded a motion to close the agenda to any new applications, recess and continue the meeting to Monday, April 25,. All voted yes. Motion carried. Schneider called a recess at 6:54 p.m. Respectfully submitted, David E. Maeda City Clerk